Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

9 Iowa 50

Beard v. Smith

Supreme Court of Iowa

Decided June 14, 1859

Supreme Court of Iowa · decided 1859-06-14

The writ was directed to the coroner. Defendant moved to dismiss the action, for the reason that “the papers do not show any authority for the coroner to act in the premises.” This motion was sustained and the suit dismissed. Plaintiff appeals.

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently November 1936

1 federal appellate ·

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1859-06-14

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Weight, C. J.

¶1The coroner performs the duties of the sheriff, when there is no sheriff; or where in a court of record, it happens that the sheriff is a party; or where an affidavit is filed stating a partiality, prejudice, consanguinity, or interest on the part of such officer. Code, sections 183 and 184.

¶2*51. The claim in this case is, that the sheriff is the party defendant. This does not sufficiently appear from the record. It is not alleged in the petition, and the only place in which it is referred to, is in the concluding part of the writ. But even there it is not stated that the defendant is the sheriff. The sheriff is the officer authorized by law to serve process in the first instance, and to make a service by the coroner as such, good, the disqualification of the sheriff, should be made reasonably manifest, and not be left to inference. If the sheriff is interested, or a party, or for any of the statutory reasons, an improper person to serve the process, it can be easily shown, and the writ thus receive an appropriate direction.

¶3In this case, however, there was error in dismissing the suit: first, because the direction of the writ to the coroner instead of the sheriff, could only operate to abate the writ, and not the action. And in the second place, the motion was made after the defendant had demurred to, and answered, the petition.

¶4It was manifestly made at too late a stage in the case to avail defendant.

¶5. Judgment reversed.

/9/iowa/50 · .json · Public domain