Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

9 Johns. 127

Lansing v. Prendergast

New York Supreme Court

Decided May 15, 1812

New York Supreme Court · decided 1812-05-15

THIS was an action of covenant, for the recovery of seven years’ rent, brought upon a durable lease, executed by the plaintiff to the defendant, on the first day of March, 1793, for a f land in Lansingburgh, in which lease the yearly rent of four pounds was reserved to be paid yearly and every year, tor ever thereafter ; and which rent the defendant, his executors, administrators and assigns, expressly covenanted by the lease, to pay to the plaintiff, his heirs and assigns,…

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently July 1875

Relies on Frost v. Carter

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1812-05-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Per Curiam.

¶1There is no distinguishing this case, in principle, from that of Frost v. Carter. (1 Johns. Cas. 73.) The rent now sued for had not accrued at the time of the discharge. Rent afterwards to accrue and grow due, could not, in any sense, be considered as a present debt, at the time of the insolvent’s assignment, and for which the plaintiff might have become a petitioning creditor. It must be debitum in presentí, though it be solvendum in futuro. A discharge under the English acts of bankruptcy, or of insolvency, has never been considered as a bar to an action of covenant on an express covenant to pay rent. (1 H. Bl. 433. 4 Term Rep. 94. Auriol v. Mills, 8 East, 318. S. P. Cotterel v. Hooke, Doug. 97. Marks v. Upton, 7 Term Rep. 305.) The words of the bankrupt act of 7 Geo. I. c. 31. are nearly the same as those in our insolvent law. The recovery before the justice was no bar to rent not included in that suit. Each sum of annual rent was a distinct debt.

¶2Judgment for the plaintiff.

/9/johns/127 · .json · Public domain