Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

9 Mo. 732

Switzer v. Carson

Supreme Court of Missouri

Decided January 15, 1846

Supreme Court of Missouri · decided 1846-01-15

The appellants rely upon the following points and authorities to reverse the judgment of the circuit court: 1. This being a suit by attachment, and the truth of the affidavit being the true issue submitted for trial, it was right and proper that the plaintiffs should have been allowed to give the jury any evidence tending to show an intent to remove their property for the purposes, and in the manner sworn to in the affidavit.

Decided 1846-01-15

Scott, J.,

¶1delivered the opinion of the court.

¶2The appellants sued the appellees by attachment in assumpsit. The ground of the attachment was, that the appellees were about to remove their property out of the State, so as to hinder and delay their creditors. The truth of the fact in the affidavit, on which the attachment was founded, was put in issue by the appellees, by a plea in the nature of a plea in abatement.

¶3On the trial it appeared that the appellees were tobacconists, engaged largely in buying, manufacturing and selling tobacco; and that at the time of levying the attachment, they were about to make a large shipment for sale. The appellants offered evidence to show that the appellees were largely indebted to others than themselves, which was objected to, and excluded by the court. There was evidence in the cause, of the indebtedness of the appellees to others than the appellants.

¶4A verdict was found for the appellees.

¶5The only question raised in the argument of the cause is the propriety of the action of the court in excluding the evidence of the indebtedness of the appellees, offered on the trial. The issue did not involve the question of the indebtedness of the appellees to the appellants; for the purpose of that trial their indebtedness to them was admitted; and evidence of indebtedness to others could not have been material. Indeed, if it was necessary, there appears from the record to have been enough of it before the jury.

¶6The other Judges concurring, the judgment will be affirmed.

/9/mo/732 · .json · Public domain