Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

9 N.C. 576

Graves v. . Carter

Supreme Court of North Carolina

Decided December 5, 1823

Supreme Court of North Carolina · decided 1823-12-05

From Caswell. Assumpsit to recover the balance of the purchase money of a tract of land, which it was alleged Plaintiff had sold to Defendant.

Decided 1823-12-05

*580 Taylor, Chief-Justice,

¶1 delivered the opinion of the Court:

¶2 The case of Bracket v. Foscue, wherein this poin- occurred, was decided in conformity with the clear mil*' of law, that parol evidence shall not be received to contradict a deed ; and hovover reluctant the Court may he to apply a rule which produces injustice in the particular case, yet the community is benefited upon the whole, by an adherence to the law. In addition to the authorities cited in that case, may be added Rountree v. Jacob, 2 Taunt. 141 where it was held, that in an action for o«-' ncy had and received, if the Defendant shews a deed of assignment of the money to himself, and a receipt lor the consideration money endorsed,' it is a good discharge, though there is strong evidence of suspicion that the consideration is falsely recited, and that the money never was paid. Though in a Court of Equity, the ven-dee, who pays no part of the purchase money, will be considered as a trustee; yet, in law, the receipt cannot be got over, unless it is merely fraudulent Henderson v. Wild, 2 Campb. 561. There must be a new trial.

/9/nc/576 · .json · Public domain