Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

9 S.C.L. 109

Morrow v. Morrow

Supreme Court of South Carolina

Decided May 15, 1818

Supreme Court of South Carolina · decided 1818-05-15

In this action there was a release pleaded by -i r -t i i • /■ • T defendants to the plaintiff s cause of action, in reciting the release, it was stated to have been ♦ i , 7 • 7 t • i i given on the 15th. under a videliat; and upon the production of the same, it bore date on the 14th of the month.

Decided 1818-05-15

¶1The opinion of the Court was delivered by

Mr. Justice Gantt.

¶2The record is not before the Court, and consequently the true state of the pleadings not apparent. It is probable, that the replication may have claimed the right of exception for a *110variance of this kind, if otherwise tenable. Nor can the Court say, but that the party defendant might not have proved the delivery of the release the day set forth in the plea.

¶3It is obvious that the cause has not been tried on its merits, and doubtful whether, if a new trial should be refused, the defendants would not be without a remedy.

¶4Thus viewing the case, and to ensure the ends of justice, I am of opinion that the verdict should be set aside, and a new trial granted, with leave to defendants to amend their plea.

Grimké, Colcock, Cheves, and JYott, J. concurred.
/9/scl/109 · .json · Public domain