Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

90 Mass. 150

Russell v. Goodrich

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Decided January 15, 1864

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1864-01-15

Contract on a recognizance taken under Gen. Sts. c. 134, § 10, with condition that the defendant Goodrich, who had been arrested on an execution in favor of the plaintiff, should within thirty days from the time of his arrest deliver himself up for examination, giving notice as therein provided, and making no default, and abide the final order of the magistrate thereon.

Decided 1864-01-15

Bigelow, C. J.

¶1We do not see that there has been any breach of the recognizance declared on. The debtor attended at the time and place appointed for his examination, and until it was' finished, and the magistrate had made his final order and *151adjudication, by which he refused to administer to him the poor debtors’ oath. He was then liable to be taken on the execution, if the officer was present to serve it. But the debtor was not bound to go in search of the officer, or to take any steps to cause himself to be arrested and committed to jail; nor has he committed any breach of the condition of his recognizance, because the officer failed to be ready to take him on the execution after the magistrate had refused him the oath. His presence there after the examination was completed and the decision of the magistrate was pronounced was a full compliance with the condition of the'recognizance. Jacot v. Wyatt, 10 Gray, 236, 239. Doane v. Bartlett, 4 Allen, 75. Skinner v. Frost, 6 Allen, 285. All the subsequent proceedings of the magistrate, after he had adjudicated on the question of the right of the debtor to take the poor debtors’ oath, were coram non judice and void. The law gives no appeal to the debtor from the decision of the magistrate, except in cases where charges of fraud have been filed under Gen. Sts. c. 124, § 5, and a hearing is had thereon, according to §§ 32, 33. No such charges were filed in the present case. The magistrate had no authority or jurisdiction to adjourn the case after he had decided to refuse the oath to the debtor, nor was the latter bound to attend at the time and place of such adjournment. Judgment for the defendants.

/90/mass/150 · .json · Public domain