Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

91 Mass. 486

Commonwealth v. Cutler

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Decided November 15, 1864

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1864-11-15

<p>A previous conviction of the offence of keeping a tenement used for the unlawful sale of intoxicating liquors is no defence to an indictment for being a common seller of intoxicating liquors at the same time and place.</p> <p>If a not pros. has been entered in an indictment for being a com non seller of intoxicating liquors, upon an agreement by the defendant to discontinue the sale, the defendant ma> be convicted upon an indictment subsequent!)’- found, which includes the same time covered by the original indictment, although it does not appear at the trial that the defend ant had made sales of liquor after the entry of the not pros.</p>

Decided 1864-11-15

Dewey, J.

¶1The jury have found the defendant guilty of the offence of being a common seller of intoxicating liquors in violation of the provisions of Gen. Sts. c. 86, § 31. In support of the prosecution, the government offered the usual evidence of various sales of liquors made by the defendant. To the competency of a portion of this evidence the defendant interposes the objection that it applied to sales made during a period of time embraced in an indictment against him upon which he had been convicted under Gen. Sts. c. 87, of keeping and maintaining a common nuisance, by reason of his keeping a tenement used for the illegal keeping and sale of intoxicating liquors. In the opinion of the court this latter offence was a distinct and indo pendent one, created by a different statute, and a conviction thereof was no legal bar to an indictment for the offence of being a common seller under the provisions of c. 86. Commonwealth v. Bubser, 14 Gray, 83.

¶2No legal ground for exceptions arises from the arrangement alleged to have been made with the district attorney, as to forbearing to prosecute the defendant for this offence. It may be properly assumed that this prosecution was instituted upon sufficient evidence furnished to the public prosecutor that the defendant had violated the conditions of that arrangement.

¶3Exceptions overruled.

/91/mass/486 · .json · Public domain