Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

92 Cal. 590

People v. Mitchell

California Supreme Court

Decided December 30, 1891

California Supreme Court · decided 1891-12-30

<p>Criminal Law—Forgery — Uttering Forged Check—Information.— An information may properly unite the charges that the defendant feloniously forged a cheek with the intent to defraud, and that he uttered and passed the same with intent to defraud, knowing it to he false and forged, and evidence of both or either will sustain a verdict of guilty.</p> <p>Id. —Pleading of Forgery—Intent to Defraud. — Forgery is a statutory offense, and the intent to defraud is the essential element, and must be specifically alleged in the information, to sustain a judgment of conviction of that offense. It is not sufficient to charge that the defendant did “unlawfully, feloniously, and fraudulently make and forge ” the instrument specified.</p> <p>Id. — Uttering Forged Instrument—Allegation of Scienter. — To sustain a conviction of uttering and passing a forged check, the information must allege that at the time when the defendant uttered and passed the check he knew the same to he false, altered, forged, or counterfeited; and the allegation that he falsely and knowingly uttered and passed, as genuine, a false and forged check cannot be construed to mean that he knew the check was false and forged at the time he uttered and passed it.</p> <p>Id. — “Falsely ” Making and Forging. —It is not necessary to allege in the information, specifically, that the defendant “ falsely ” made and forged the instrument, though the statute uses the word “falsely.” The word “ forged ” implies false making to the full extent, as if it were expressed.</p> <p>Id. — Defective Information — Double Charge—Instruction—Yerdict of Guilty as Charged — Presumption. — Where an information contains the double charge of forgery of a check and of uttering and passing the forged check, and either of these two elements of the offense is defectively pleaded, if the court instructs the jury that they may find the defendant guilty under either branch of the charge, and the jury find the defendant guilty as charged in the information, it cannot he presumed, in support of the judgment, that the verdict was not based upon the void part of the information.</p> <p>Id.—Insufficiency of Evidence—Testimony of Expert—Comparison of 'Handwriting — Face of Check — Signature. — Where the only evidence to sustain a charge of forgery of a check is the testimony of an expert, upon comparison of the check with genuine handwriting of the defendant, that in his opinion the face of the check was written by the defendant, nothing being said specifically about the signature, and there being no evidence as to the existence of the purported drawer, or whether he did or did not authorize the signature, the evidence is insufficient to sustain a conviction.</p>

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1891-12-30

How this case has been cited

Cited by 27 later decisions — most recently October 1999 · most notably People v. Smith (1894), People v. Garnett (1900)

23 state decisions

5018911900191019201930194019501960197019801990decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

De Haven, J., concurring.

¶1In my opinion, the information in this case is sufficient, but I concur in the judgment, upon the ground that the evidence is insufficient to sustain ,the verdict. The only evidence that *594the check described in the information was a forgery, or that defendant knew its character when he transferred it, consisted of the testimony of one Gumpel, based upon a comparison of the check in question with certain writings proven to be in the handwriting of defendant. This witness'was asked whether, in his opinion, the face of the check and the writings referred to were in the same handwriting. In answer to which, “the witness testified that, in his opinion, the check and examples in evidence were all written by the same person.” This is not sufficient proof that the signature to the check was a forged one. Although as a matter of strict law it may be said that the face of a check includes the signature, it is not clear that the witness so understood it. Whether the signature to this check was genuine or false was a material fact in the case, and the attention of the witness should have been particularly directed to this. The record in this case leaves it in doubt whether the witness meant to say anything more than that the body of the check was in the handwriting of the defendant, but the jury should not have been compelled to guess as to his meaning, when a specific question would have made the matter clear.

/92/cal/590 · .json · Public domain