Rev. Anne Scharon’s Empirical Analysis
1991
Citation profile
10 federal appellate · 10 district · 22 state decisions
How this case has been cited
Cited by 75 later decisions (4 by the Supreme Court) — most recently June 2023 · most notably Gibson v. Brewer (1997), Equal Employment Opportunity Commission v. Catholic University of America (1996)
10 federal appellate · 10 district · 22 state decisions — followed in 15 states
Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.
Relationships
Relies on Lemon v. Kurtzman · Serbian Eastern Orthodox Diocese for United States and Canada v. Milivojevich · Baskett v. United States · National Labor Relations Board v. Catholic Bishop · Kissinger v. Halperin
Most-quoted passages
The sentences later courts lift from this opinion, ranked by how many decisions quote each — the parts of the opinion doing the work. These counts are smaller than the citation total above because most of the 75 citing decisions cite the case generally; a passage count includes only decisions quoting that exact language verbatim.
“[A]s the Supreme Court said in Catholic Bishop, 440 U.S. at 502 , 99 S.Ct. at 1320 , “[t]he resolution of such charges ... will necessarily involve inquiry into the good faith of the position asserted by the clergy-administrators _ It is not only the conclusions that may be reached ... which may impinge on rights guaranteed by the Religion Clauses, but also the very process of inquiry.” See also Minker v. Baltimore Annual Conference of United Methodist Church, 894 F.2d 1354 , 1354, 1356-57 (D.C.Cir.1990) (In rejecting a minister’s ADEA claim, the court noted that the “determination of ‘whose voice speaks for the church’ is per se a religious matter.... We cannot imagine an inquiry less suited to a temporal court.”) _”
3 later decisions quote this exact passage · from the majority“Personnel decisions by church-affiliated institutions affecting clergy are per se religious matters and cannot be reviewed by civil courts for to review such decisions would require the courts to determine the meaning of religious doctrine and canonical law and to impose a secular court's view of whether in the context of the particular case religious doctrine and canonical law support the decision the church authorities have made. This is precisely the kind of judicial second-guessing of decision-making by religious organizations that the Free Exercise Clause forbids.”
3 later decisions quote this exact passage · from the majority“[T]he free exercise clause of the First Amendment protects the act of a decision rather than a motivation behind it.”
3 later decisions quote this exact passage · from the majority
How this case has been treated — in progress
Whether each later court followed, distinguished, criticized, or overruled this decision. The treatment classification (task #35) runs highest-cited cases first and lights up here as it reaches this one.