Bouchard’s Empirical Analysis

Citation profile

5 federal appellate · 2 district ·

Most-quoted passages

The sentences later courts lift from this opinion, ranked by how many decisions quote each — the parts of the opinion doing the work. These counts are smaller than the citation total above because most of the 17 citing decisions cite the case generally; a passage count includes only decisions quoting that exact language verbatim.

1. “cannot get at least 5 hours of sleep during the scheduled period.”

   4 later decisions quote this exact passage · from the dissent
   e.g. 82 F. Supp. 2d 426 - Shannon v. Pleasant Valley Community Living Arrangements, Inc. · John R. Roy Gary Waller David Rhoten Crystal Galloway Gary W. Holmes Eric T. Bushey M.T. Hammond John R. Lillard David H. Dixon Gary Semones Richard McManus Jason Hentz Patricia H. Dupuis Curtis Scott Ward Mike Tanner Gary A. Seibert Robert McKeever John L. Windhorn Bobby Daggerhart Melissa P. Harrison Jay F. Burton Teresa Hill Dwight C. Nolff Thad C. Miller David W. Shull David E. David Patricia H. Barnett Joseph J. Rooney Kevin G. Hicks Robbie Kubler Dalton E. Shull, Jr. John v. Ruff, Jr. Eric McFarland James Garcia Cynthia D. Plant Robert D. McClanahan George E. Hardy Fern Jenkins Mildred H. Miller Linda W. Semones Michael K. Kaczmarek Michael G. Jones Joey Keisler Rhett Loudenback Joseph A. Bastedo, Sr. David C. Hunter Loretta Hunter Betty Koerner J. Stuart Platt Evelyn J. Williams Jacqueline Fink Jonathon L. Humphrey Carroll W. Bledsoe, Jr. Jonathan M. Sebring Alice H. Bennett Tony L. Wingard Kenneth L. White, III Morris F. Anderson Stephen C. Sightler Jeff Barchus Anthony Bruce Taylor Tami Leigh Steinlage, and Daniel C. Force B.L. Burnes John W. Smith v. County of Lexington, South Carolina, John R. Roy Gary Waller David Rhoten Crystal Galloway Gary W. Holmes Eric T. Bushey M.T. Hammond John R. Lillard David H. Dixon Gary Semones Richard McManus Jason Hentz Patricia H. Dupuis Curtis Scott Ward Mike Tanner Gary A. Seibert Robert McKeever John L. Windhorn Bobby Daggerhart Melissa P. Harrison Jay F. Burton Teresa Hill Dwight C. Nolff Thad C. Miller David W. Shull David E. David Patricia H. Barnett Joseph J. Rooney Kevin G. Hicks Robbie Kubler Dalton E. Shull, Jr. John v. Ruff, Jr. Eric McFarland James Garcia Cynthia D. Plant Robert D. McClanahan George E. Hardy Fern Jenkins Mildred H. Miller Linda W. Semones Michael K. Kaczmarek Michael G. Jones Joey Keisler Rhett Loudenback Joseph A. Bastedo, Sr. David C. Hunter Loretta Hunter Betty Koerner J. Stuart Platt Evelyn J. Williams Jacqueline Fink Jonathon L. Humphrey Carroll W. Bledsoe, Jr. Jonathan M. Sebring Alice H. Bennett Tony L. Wingard Kenneth L. White, III Morris F. Anderson Stephen C. Sightler Jeff Barchus Anthony Bruce Taylor Tami Leigh Steinlage, and Daniel C. Force B.L. Burnes John W. Smith v. County of Lexington, South Carolina

2. “an employee who is on duty and is compensated from 6:00 a.m. to 9:00 a.m. and 5:00 p.m. to 10:00 p.m., Monday through Friday, and who sleeps Monday through Thursday nights on the premises, would be considered to reside on the premises for extended periods of time.”

   2 later decisions quote this exact passage · from the dissent
   e.g. Blackburn v. Kansas Elks Training Center for the Handicapped, Inc. · 194 F. Supp. 2d 1177 - Ormsby v. C.O.F. Training Services, Inc.

3. “usually enjoy an uninterrupted night's sleep”

   2 later decisions quote this exact passage · from the majority
   e.g. John R. Roy Gary Waller David Rhoten Crystal Galloway Gary W. Holmes Eric T. Bushey M.T. Hammond John R. Lillard David H. Dixon Gary Semones Richard McManus Jason Hentz Patricia H. Dupuis Curtis Scott Ward Mike Tanner Gary A. Seibert Robert McKeever John L. Windhorn Bobby Daggerhart Melissa P. Harrison Jay F. Burton Teresa Hill Dwight C. Nolff Thad C. Miller David W. Shull David E. David Patricia H. Barnett Joseph J. Rooney Kevin G. Hicks Robbie Kubler Dalton E. Shull, Jr. John v. Ruff, Jr. Eric McFarland James Garcia Cynthia D. Plant Robert D. McClanahan George E. Hardy Fern Jenkins Mildred H. Miller Linda W. Semones Michael K. Kaczmarek Michael G. Jones Joey Keisler Rhett Loudenback Joseph A. Bastedo, Sr. David C. Hunter Loretta Hunter Betty Koerner J. Stuart Platt Evelyn J. Williams Jacqueline Fink Jonathon L. Humphrey Carroll W. Bledsoe, Jr. Jonathan M. Sebring Alice H. Bennett Tony L. Wingard Kenneth L. White, III Morris F. Anderson Stephen C. Sightler Jeff Barchus Anthony Bruce Taylor Tami Leigh Steinlage, and Daniel C. Force B.L. Burnes John W. Smith v. County of Lexington, South Carolina, John R. Roy Gary Waller David Rhoten Crystal Galloway Gary W. Holmes Eric T. Bushey M.T. Hammond John R. Lillard David H. Dixon Gary Semones Richard McManus Jason Hentz Patricia H. Dupuis Curtis Scott Ward Mike Tanner Gary A. Seibert Robert McKeever John L. Windhorn Bobby Daggerhart Melissa P. Harrison Jay F. Burton Teresa Hill Dwight C. Nolff Thad C. Miller David W. Shull David E. David Patricia H. Barnett Joseph J. Rooney Kevin G. Hicks Robbie Kubler Dalton E. Shull, Jr. John v. Ruff, Jr. Eric McFarland James Garcia Cynthia D. Plant Robert D. McClanahan George E. Hardy Fern Jenkins Mildred H. Miller Linda W. Semones Michael K. Kaczmarek Michael G. Jones Joey Keisler Rhett Loudenback Joseph A. Bastedo, Sr. David C. Hunter Loretta Hunter Betty Koerner J. Stuart Platt Evelyn J. Williams Jacqueline Fink Jonathon L. Humphrey Carroll W. Bledsoe, Jr. Jonathan M. Sebring Alice H. Bennett Tony L. Wingard Kenneth L. White, III Morris F. Anderson Stephen C. Sightler Jeff Barchus Anthony Bruce Taylor Tami Leigh Steinlage, and Daniel C. Force B.L. Burnes John W. Smith v. County of Lexington, South Carolina · Roy