Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

94 Ind. 208

Hansher v. Hanshew

Indiana Supreme Court

Decided November 24, 1883

Indiana Supreme Court · decided 1883-11-24

<p>Practice. — Motion in Arrest. — • When Made. — A motion in arrest must be made before the rendition of judgment; otherwise it comes too late to present any question.</p> <p>Same. — Motion by Plaintiff. — Sufficiency of Complaint. — A motion in arrest of judgment calls in question the sufficiency of the complaint, after verdict ; and where the only issue for trial was formed by a general denial of the complaint, and the finding- or verdict was for the defendant, the plaintiff’s motion in arrest of judgment will present no question for decision.</p> <p>Same. — Record.—Bill of Exceptions. — Supreme Court. — Under the civil code of 1852, where time was given beyond the term in which to file a bill of exceptions, unless the record affirmatively showed such filing within the time given, the bill could not be considered a part of the record by the Supreme Court.</p>

Relies on Smith v. Dodds · Brownlee v. Hare · Toledo, Wabash & Western Railway Co. v. Howes

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1883-11-24

How this case has been cited

Cited by 7 later decisions — most recently March 1910

7 state decisions

301883189019001910decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Howk, C. J.

¶1This was a suit by the appellant, Hansher, against the appellees Hanshew and-Daugherty, upon a complaint and supplemental complaint. The issues joined in the cause by the appellees5 joint answer by a general denial were tried by a jury, and a verdict was returned for the appellees, and judgment was rendered accordingly.

¶2In this court the first error assigned by the appellant is the overruling of his motion in arrest of judgment. The record shows that this motion was not made by the appellant until after the trial court had rendered its judgment. The motion, therefore, came too late, and no question is thereby presented for the decision of this court. Buskirk Pr., p. 264, et seq.; Smith v. Dodds, 35 Ind. 452; Brownlee v. Hare, 64 Ind. 311.

¶3The only other error assigned by the appellant is the overruling of his motion for a new trial.' In this motion the only causes assigned for a new trial were, that the verdict of the jury was contrary to law and was not sustained by sufficient evidence. Manifestly, these causes for a new trial can not be. considered, and will present no question for our decision, if it be true, as appellees5 counsel claim, that the bill of exceptions containing the evidence is not a part of the record. It is shown by the transcript that on May 20th, 1881, sixty days were given the plaintiff in which to file his bill of exceptions, and that such bill was not filed until the 24th day of July, 1881, or until five days after the expiration of the time given. These proceedings were had while the civil code of 1852 was still in full force. Under that code, it was settled by the decisions of this court, that where time was given extending beyond the term, in which to prepare and file a bill of exceptions, the record must affirmatively show that the bill was not only signed but filed within the time limited, or *210it will not constitute a part of the record. Buskirk Pr., p. 144; Toledo, etc., R. W. Co. v. Howes, 68 Ind. 458; Dunn v. Hubble, 81 Ind. 489.

Filed Nov. 24, 1883.Filed March 15,1884.

¶4In the case at bar, it must be held, therefore, that the bill of exceptions is not a part of the record.

¶5The judgment is affirmed, with costs.

/94/ind/208 · .json · Public domain