Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

94 Mass. 590

Hubbard v. Bliss

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Decided September 15, 1866

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1866-09-15

Replevin. Both parties claimed title under a sale from War-en Hubbard, Senior. The sale to the plaintiff was the earlier in date, and was upon the same conditions contained in the deed referred to in the preceding case. Under this sale the plaintiff took possession of the property until after the sale to the defendant, which was made in con sequence of the alleged breach of the condition of the sale to the plaintiff.

Decided 1866-09-15

Hoar, J.

¶1The exceptions in this case are sustained for the same reasons given in the opinion in the preceding case.

¶2The further point is taken by the plaintiff, that upon the breach of the condition no right of property could be transferred which would enable Bliss to defend this action. But the right of property and right of possession would both vest in the original owner, upon breach of the condition. No authority is found for the doctrine that the property must be taken into the actual manual control of its owner before he can sell it. It is not a mere right of action, even while the goods are in the hands of another. The defendant, having taken possession, was entitled to retain it. Exceptions sustained.

/94/mass/590 · .json · Public domain