Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

96 Mass. 206

Straw v. Greene

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Decided January 15, 1867

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1867-01-15

Writ oe entry to foreclose a mortgage of various parcels of land, given originally by Adam Wiley to William L. Brown. Brown assigned the mortgage to the plaintiff in 1861, and died in the same year. Wiley was made one of the defendants, under Gen. Sts. c. 140, § 8, though he had conveyed the equity of redemption to the other defendants before the commencement of this action.

Decided 1867-01-15

Wells, J.

¶1The mortgagor, Adam Wiley, was properly joined in the suit, as a party defendant. The plaintiff was entitled to have judgment against him, as well as against the assignees of the mortgage, “ whether he then had any estate in the premises or not; ” and was not bound to accept the disclaimer offered, nor to take issue upon it. Gen. Sts. c. 140, § 8. The court rightly refused to order a nonsuit in favor of Wiley.

¶2One of the “ original parties to the contract or cause of action in issue and on trial ” was dead. Wiley was “ the other party,” and he was also a party to the suit. He could not be a witness at all, therefore, to testify in his own favor. The court rightly refused to permit him to disprove the validity of his debt to Brown. Permitting him to testify for the defendants as to a particular matter did not entitle them to make him a general witness, nor in any degree remove the restrictions of the statute. Any testimony which would tend to defeat Brown’s demands, for security of which the plaintiff sought to enforce the mortgage, must be regarded as testimony in favor of the principal debtor, as well as of the owner of the equity.

¶3Exceptions overruled.

/96/mass/206 · .json · Public domain