Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

96 Mass. 60

Gomersall v. Gomersall

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Decided January 15, 1867

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1867-01-15

Contract. The declaration was as follows: “ And the plaintiff says that the defendant entered into a contract and agreement with the plaintiff, whereby they were to become copartners in the business of making and selling shoddy, to which copartnership the plaintiff contributed his time, skill and knowledge of said business, and the defendant was to furnish machinery, stock and cash capital; said business and co-partnership to continue for the space of three years, and the…

Cited by 1 later decisions (1 by the Supreme Court) — most recently May 1926

Relies on Gibbes MacHinery Co. v. Johnson

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1867-01-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Bigelow, C. J.

¶1This demurrer must be sustained. The declaration includes a claim for profits by one copartner against another, alleged to be due to the plaintiff as a member of a co-partnership, and derived from the joint transactions of the firm. It is not averred that the business of the firm has been closed and its dealings and accounts adjusted and settled, so that there is now due to the plaintiff as the result of all the copartnership transactions an ascertained balance in money. Without such averment, no action at law can be maintained by the plaintiff for that portion of the claim set forth in the declaration which embraces an alleged share of the profits of the business of the firm as due to the plaintiff. Such averment and proof to sustain it are essential to the maintenance of an action at law by one copartner against another, to recover a balance resulting *62from the joint dealings. Williams v. Henshaw, 11 Pick. 81S. C. 12 Pick. 378. Capen v. Barrows, 1 Gray, 376. As the declaration is for an entire claim, and embraces a subject matter on which an action at law will not lie, we cannot be called on in the form in which the case is now before us to say whether some portion of the allegations in the declaration, when set forth as a distinct and substantial ground of claim, will support an action at law. As the case now stands, the order must be

¶2Demurrer sustained.

/96/mass/60 · .json · Public domain