Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

97 Mass. 206

Knowles v. Hull

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Decided September 15, 1867

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1867-09-15

<p>Action under Gen. Sts. c. 137, for possession of a tenement in the basement of a meeting-house in Westfield.</p> <p>In the superior court, the facts were agreed and judgment was entered thereon for the defendant, and the plaintiff appealed to this court.</p> <p>The facts, as agreed, were substantially as follows: The building was owned by the Central Baptist Society in Westfield, and the defendant took possession of the demanded premises April 1, 1863, under a lease “ to hold for the term of three years from the first day of April 1863, with the privilege of two years in addition, unless the society shall sell said store, in which case the privilege of two years in addition shall be null and void.” This lease ran as from the Central Baptist Society to the defendant, and was signed by “J. S. Knowles, Jas. Ray Gladwin, L. B. Blood, Prudential Committee Gen. Bap. Society, lessors,” and was sealed with their individual seals. J. S. Knowles, who so signed and sealed it, was the plaintiff in this action. The defendant remained in occupation and paid rent for the first three years to the treasurer of the society, and tendered rent to him after that time and since the beginning of this action. On April 2, 1866, the society at a legal meeting voted “ to sell said church property to Deacon J. S. Knowles,” and “ to authorize L, B Blood to give a deed of the old church for the society to J. S. Knowles.” The next day Blood, for the society, conveyed to the plaintiff by deed of warranty the meeting-house and land, including the demanded premises. Due notice to quit was thereupon given by the plaintiff to the defendant, and this action was brought.</p>

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1867-09-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 3 later decisions — most recently April 1902

3 state decisions

1018671870188018901900decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Chapman, J.

¶1The defendant’s lease was “ to hold for the terra f three years from the first day of April 1863, with the privilege of two years in addition, unless the society shall sell said store, in. which case the privilege of two years in addition shall be null and void.” The court are of opinion that by the fair construction of this language, the privilege of the two years was to be void in case of a sale of the store at any time, either before the *208two years should commence, or while they were running. There is no limitation of the time within which the sale spoken of shall take place in order to terminate the privilege.

¶2This construction of the lease supersedes all the questions that have been presented respecting its validity.

¶3 Judgment for the plaintiff.

/97/mass/206 · .json · Public domain