Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

99 Ga. 44

Dyson v. State

Supreme Court of Georgia

Decided May 4, 1896

Supreme Court of Georgia · decided 1896-05-04

<p>1. The petition for certiorari in a criminal case alleging error in the verdict on the ground that it was contrary to law and the evidence, and there being in the evidence set forth in the petition, which purported to contain a statement of all the evidence introduced on the trial, nothing to show that the offense was' committed in the county where the trial was had, this court, following its previous adjudications on this subject, is constrained to hold that the judge of the superior court erred in refusing to sanction the petition.</p> <p>2. The error above indicated requires a reversal of the judgment, irrespective of the other questions presented by the petition for certiorari.</p>

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently December 1920

1 state decisions

Relies on Davis v. State

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1896-05-04

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Lumpkin, Justice.

¶11. The plaintiff in error was tried and convicted of a misdemeanor in tbe county court of Greene county. He presented his petition for certiorari to tbe judge of tbe superior court, whose refusal to sanction tbe same is complained of in the bill of exceptions. Tbe petition complains of quite a number of rulings and decisions wbicb it alleges were made by tbe county judge; avers that tbe verdict of guilty was contrary to tbe evidence, and sets forth what purports to be a statement of all tbe evidence introduced upon tbe trial. ' Prom this statement — which, for tbe present purpose, must be treated as a correct one— it nowhere appears that "the alleged offense was committed in Greene county; and for this reason, if for no other, tbe judge ought to have sanctioned tbe petition. There was no distinct assignment of error in tbe verdict on tbe ground that tbe venue was not proved, and it does not appear that tbe attention of tbe judge was called to this defect in tbe evidence, or that be distinctly passed upon this particular question. Hnder these circumstances, we would, if left free to do so, be very strongly inclined to bold that it was not incumbent upon bis honor to closely scrutinize tbe evidence with a view to ascertaining whether or not tbe venue was shown; but this question has been settled for us by several decisions of this court, among wbicb, and precisely in point, is that of Davis v. State, 82 Ga. 205, bolding that: “There can be no legal conviction without proof, *46direct or circumstantial, that the offense was committed in the county. And the lack of sufficient evidence of the venue is covered by exceptions taken by certiorari to the •finding of the county judge as contrary to law and without evidence to support it.”

¶22. The other questions presented by the petition for certiorari need not be passed upon. Indeed, many of them may be entirely eliminated, by the answer of the county judge, which will be forthcoming after the writ of certiorari has been issued and served upon him.

¶3Judgment reversed.

/99/ga/44 · .json · Public domain