Circuit split · civil rights law
Whether a Bivens damages action for constitutional violations may be brought against employees of a privately operated federal prison
1 federal appellate case on this question, each acknowledging the disagreement in its own words.
- Holly v. Scott434 F3D 287
Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals · January 12, 2006
“In holding to the contrary, the majority disregards all of this authority and creates a circuit split.” — Acknowledges a circuit split
Empirical analysis of this case →
The other side of the split
Decisions the acknowledging court(s) named as the opposing or joined side, quoted in the acknowledging opinion's own words.
- On the other side · 6th Cir.Street v. Corr. Corp. of Am.102 F.3d 810
“& Training Corp., 350 F.3d 459 , 461 (5th Cir.2003) (holding that employees of a private correctional facility perform a “fundamentally government function” — “confinement of wrongdoers”— and so are government actors for § 1983 purposes); Street v.” — Holly v. Scott, acknowledging the split
- On the other side · 11th Cir.Ancata v. Prison Health Servs., Inc.769 F.2d 700
“Prison Health Servs., Inc., 769 F.2d 700 , 703 (11th Cir.1985) (explaining that employees of private health corporation are state actors when performing the public function of providing required medical services to inmates); Sarro v.” — Holly v. Scott, acknowledging the split
- On the other side · D.R.I.Sarro v. Cornell Corr., Inc.248 F.Supp.2d 52
“Cornell Corr., Inc., 248 F.Supp.2d 52 , 60-62 (D.R.I.2003) (holding that employees of a private operator of a prison facility perform a government function traditionally reserved to the government and are government actors for Bivens purposes); Palm v.” — Holly v. Scott, acknowledging the split
- On the other side · N.D.Tex.Palm v. Marr174 F.Supp.2d 484
“Marr, 174 F.Supp.2d 484 , 487-88 (N.D.Tex.2001) (holding that employees of a private prison facility exercise powers that are traditionally the exclusive prerogative of the state and so are governmental actors for § 1983 purposes); Giron v.” — Holly v. Scott, acknowledging the split
- On the other side · D.N.M.Giron v. Corr. Corp. of Am.14 F.Supp.2d 1245
“Marr, 174 F.Supp.2d 484 , 487-88 (N.D.Tex.2001) (holding that employees of a private prison facility exercise powers that are traditionally the exclusive prerogative of the state and so are governmental actors for § 1983 purposes); Giron v.” — Holly v. Scott, acknowledging the split
- On the other side · S.D.Tex.Kesler v. King29 F.Supp.2d 356
- On the other side · M.D.Fla.Nelson v. Prison Health Servs., Inc.991 F.Supp. 1452
“Prison Health Servs., Inc., 769 F.2d 700 , 703 (11th Cir.1985) (explaining that employees of private health corporation are state actors when performing the public function of providing required medical services to inmates); Sarro v.” — Holly v. Scott, acknowledging the split
- On the other sideRosborough350 F.3d 461
- Declined to followWest
“Indeed, like the en banc majority in West, the majority’s view stands alone among the federal circuits addressing this point.” — Holly v. Scott, acknowledging the split
- Discussed · 3rd Cir.Brown v. Philip Morris Inc.250 F.3d 789
“Philip Morris Inc., 250 F.3d 789 , 801 (3rd Cir.2001) (explaining that a Bivens action is “the federal equivalent of the § 1983 cause of action,” and holding in a Bivens case that “[i]n order to determine whether the conduct of a private party should be attributable to the federal government, courts apply the ‘state action’ analysis set forth by the Supreme Court” in § 1983 cases).” — Holly v. Scott, acknowledging the split
What the split turns on
- Anchor precedents:
- Bivens
- Statutes:
- § 1983
Cases are grouped by the legal question they announce a split on, classified from the court's own acknowledgment sentence. Verified acknowledgments only. Counter-side decisions are extracted from the acknowledging opinions' own text and linked only when the citation resolves in this corpus. See all circuit splits.