Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

Circuit split · employee benefits law

Whether an ERISA plan fiduciary seeking reimbursement from a beneficiary's identifiable fund holding a third-party recovery is seeking 'equitable relief' under ERISA § 502(a)(3).

1 federal appellate case on this question, each acknowledging the disagreement in its own words.

  1. Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals · May 4, 2005

    “In assessing the fifth Johannssen factor, however, the court failed to consider that the Ninth Circuit’s decision in Westaff had created a circuit split on the question presented by the Reimbursement Award (a question that was not addressed by Knudson’s holding): whether a plan fiduciary asserting a subrogation right to reimbursement from a plan beneficiary who has received payments from a third party, and who possesses that recovery in an identifiable fund, is seeking “equitable relief’ under § 502(a)(3) of ERISA.” — Creates a split
    “In assessing the fifth Johannssen factor, however, the court failed to consider that the Ninth Circuit’s decision in Westaff had created a circuit split on the question presented by the Reimbursement Award (a question that was not addressed by Knudson’s holding): whether a plan fiduciary asserting a subrogation right to reimbursement from a plan beneficiary who has received payments from a third party, and who possesses that recovery in an identifiable fund, is seeking “equitable relief’ under § 502(a)(3) of ERISA.” — Acknowledges a circuit split
    Empirical analysis of this case →

The other side of the split

Decisions the acknowledging court(s) named as the opposing or joined side, quoted in the acknowledging opinion's own words.

  • On the other side · 9th Cir.Westaff
    “In assessing the fifth Johannssen factor, however, the court failed to consider that the Ninth Circuit’s decision in Westaff had created a circuit split on the question presented by the Reimbursement Award (a question that was not addressed by Knudson’s holding): whether a plan fiduciary asserting a subrogation right to reimbursement from a plan beneficiary who has received payments from a third party, and who possesses that recovery in an identifiable fund, is seeking “equitable relief’ under § 502(a)(3) of ERISA.” — Mid Atlantic Medical Services, LLC v. Sereboff, acknowledging the split
  • DiscussedBombardier
    “Although the court did not identify or explain the “heavy current” of precedent that the Sereboffs’ position contravened, it was apparently referring to the decisions on which its Reimbursement Award had relied: Knudson, Bombardier, Vareo, and our unpublished decision in Primax Recoveries, Inc.” — Mid Atlantic Medical Services, LLC v. Sereboff, acknowledging the split
  • DiscussedVareo
    “Although the court did not identify or explain the “heavy current” of precedent that the Sereboffs’ position contravened, it was apparently referring to the decisions on which its Reimbursement Award had relied: Knudson, Bombardier, Vareo, and our unpublished decision in Primax Recoveries, Inc.” — Mid Atlantic Medical Services, LLC v. Sereboff, acknowledging the split
  • Discussed · 4th Cir.Primax Recoveries, Inc. v. Young83 Fed.Appx. 523

What the split turns on

Anchor precedents:
Knudson
Statutes:
§ 502(a)(3) of ERISA

Cases are grouped by the legal question they announce a split on, classified from the court's own acknowledgment sentence. Verified acknowledgments only. Counter-side decisions are extracted from the acknowledging opinions' own text and linked only when the citation resolves in this corpus. See all circuit splits.