Rehearing
Bouvier's Law Dictionary and Concise Encyclopedia · John Bouvier; revised by Francis Rawle · 1914
Bouvier's Law Dictionary and Concise Encyclopedia
A second consideration which the court gave to a cause on a second argument. In England a case heard by the Chancellor on appeal from the Master of the Rolls, etc., is a rehearing; Emerson v. Davies, 1 W. & M. 21, Fed. Cas. No. 4,437. A rehearing cannot be granted by the supreme court after the record has been remitted to the court below; Browder v. Mc- Arthur, 7 Wheat. (U. S.) 58, 5 L. Ed. 397. * Where any judge, who concurred in the decision, thinks proper to have a rehearing, the motion for one will be considered, otherwise it will be denied as of course; Brooks v. Baynolds, 59 Fed. 923, 8 C. C. A. 370, 16 U. S. App. 713. Where the grounds for a rehearing were not brought to the attention of the court at the argument or by brief, permission to reargue will be granted only in extreme cases; U. S. v. Ilall, 63 Fed. 472, 11 C. C. A. 294, 21 U. S. App. 426; and not where the questions have already been fully considered; Imperial Life Ins. Co. v..Newcomb, 63 Fed. 560, 11 C. C. A. 340, 27 U. S. App. 290; and not when the ground was not overlooked at the former trial; Clark v. Five Hundred and Five Thousand Feet of Lumber, 70 Fed. 1020, 17 C. C. A. 555, 34 U. S. App. 45. That a judgment of affirmance was by an equal decision of the judges merely, affords no ground for granting a rehearing; People v. New York, 25 Wend. (N. Y.) 256, 35 Am. Dec. 669. See Precedent. The practice in the federal courts is to file a petition for a rehearing which, with the argument in its support, is submitted, without oral argument, for the consideration of the court. When a motion for a new trial of an action at law and a petition for rehearing have been denied, equi ty will not entertain a bill to set the judgment aside on the same grounds alleged in the motion and petition; Hendrickson v. Bradley, 85 Fed. 508, 29 C. C. A. 303. The refusal of the circuit court to grant a rehearing is not the subject of review; Hardin v. Boyd, 113 U. S. 756, 5 Sup. Ct. 773, 28 L. Ed. 1141. Courts, esi>ecially in cases of general interest, order a reargument where they are in doubt or where the case was not argued before a full bench. In Taylor v. Young, 71 Pa. 81, eminent counsel not connected with the cause petitioned the court for a reargument on the ground that the judgment was not well considered and that it would unsettle titles to real estate. A reargument was When the merits have been decided on appeal, the circuit court cannot without leave of the supreme court grant a new trial, rehearing or review or hear new defences by amendment to the answer; In re Potts, 16G U. S. 2G3, 17 Sup. Ct. 520, 41 L. Ed. 994. After the mandate has gone down to the lower court, an application for a rehearing must be made in the appellate court..
See Bill of Review.