Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

Non Est Factum

Defined in 2 dictionaries — Black's (1910), Bouvier (1839)

Black's Law Dictionary

Henry Campbell Black, M.A. · 1910

Lat A plea by way of traverse, which occurs in debt on bond or other specialty, and also in covenant It denies that the deed mentioned in the declaration is the defendant's deed. Under this, the defendant may contend at the trial that the deed was never executed in point of fact; but he cannot deny its validity in point of law. Wharton; Haggart v. Morgan, 5 N. Y. 422, 55 Am. Dee. 350; Evans v. Southern Turnpike Co.., 18 Ind. 101. The plea of non est factum is a denial of the execution of the instrument sued upon, and applies to notes or other instruments, as well as deeds, and applies only when the execution of the instrument is alleged to be the act of the party filing the plea, or adopted by him. Code Ga. 1882, § 3472.

Special non est factum. A form of the plea of non est factum, in debt on a specialty, by which the defendant alleges that, although he executed the deed, yet it is in law "not his deed," because of certain special circumstances which he proceeds to set out; as, where he delivered the deed as an escrow, and it was turned over to the plaintiff prematurely or without performance of the condition.

A Law Dictionary, Adapted to the Constitution and Laws of the United States

John Bouvier · 1839

in pleading, is the general igsue in debt on bond or other specialty, and is, in form, as follows: “ And the said C D, by E F, his attorney, comes and defends the wrong and injury, when, &c. and says, that the said supposed writing obligatory, (or “indenture,” or “articles of agreement,” according to the subject of the action,) is not his deed. And of this he puts himself upon the country.” Though non est fucium is, in most cases, the general issue in debt on specialty, yet, when the deed is only inducement to the action, the general issue is nil debet. Steph. Pl. 174, n. In covenant the general issue is non est factum, and its form is similar to that indebt on a specialty. Ib. 174. It is, however, said that in covenant there is strictly speaking no general issue, as the plea of non est factum only puts the deed in issue, as in debt on a specialty, and not the breach of covenant or any other matter of defence. 1 Chit.