Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

Presumptive evidence

Defined in 6 dictionaries — Case Law, Cyclopedic (1922), Ballentine's (1916), Bouvier (1914), Black's (1910), Kinney (1893)

Definitions from Case Law

From 11 U.S. 363 - The Schooner Jane v. The United States · 1813Most cited · 3 citing opinions

Although presumptive evidence is clearly admissible, and may of itself be sufficient to support, in many instances, even a criminal prosecution, yet the circumstances proved ought not only to harmonize with each other, but they ought in themselves to be so strong as fully to satisfy the mind of the fact they are intended to establish.

Show all 2 Supreme Court definitions and how they changed over time 1781–1813

The Cyclopedic Law Dictionary

Walter A. Shumaker and George Foster Longsdorf; ed. James C. Cahill · 1922

See "Circumstantial Evidence."

Ballentine's Law Dictionary

James A. Ballentine · 1916

Evidence which shows the existence of one fact by proof of the existence of others from which it may be inferred. See 62 Kan. 221, 61 Pac. 805.

Bouvier's Law Dictionary and Concise Encyclopedia

John Bouvier; revised by Francis Rawle · 1914

Black's Law Dictionary

Henry Campbell Black, M.A. · 1910

This term has several meanings in law. (i) Any evidence which is not direct and positive; the proof of minor or other facts incidental to or usually connected with the fact sought to be proved, which, when taken together, inferentially establish or prove the fact in question to a reasonable degree of certainty; evidence drawn by human experience from the connection of cause and effect and observation of human conduct; the proof of facts from which, with more or less certainty, according to the experience of mankind of their more or less universal connection, the existence of other facts can be deduced. In this sense the term is nearly equivalent to "circumstantial" evidence. See 1 Starkie, Bv. 558; 2 Saund. PI. & Ev. 673; Civ. Code Ga. 1895, § 5143; Davis v. Curry, 2 Bibb (Ky.) 239; Horbach v. Miller, 4 Neb. 44; State v. Miller, 9 Houst. (Del.) 564, 32 Atl. 137. (2) Evidence which must be received and treated as true and sufficient until rebutted by other testimony; as, where a statute provides that certain facts shall be presumptive evidence of guilt, of title, etc. State v. Mitchell, 119 N. C. 784, 25 S. Bl 783 ; State v. Intoxicating Liquors, 80 Me. 57, 12 Atl. 794. (3) Evidence which admits of explanation or contradiction by other evidence, as distinguished from conclusive evidence. Burrill, Circ. Ev. 89.

Defined under Evidence in Black's Law Dictionary.

A Law Dictionary and Glossary

George C. Kinney · 1893

Evidence presenting facts from which a presumption may be drawn as to the existence of other facts; evidence of facts admitting of explanation or contradiction. Presumptive heir: a person who, if his ancestor should die immediately, would be his heir.