¶1First. That the resolution or ordinance of the common council, authorizing Sharp and his associates to construct and operate the road, was valid as a license, revocable at pleasure, although in form a grant or contract; Second. That, conceding the resolution or ordinance was void, the original parties could not maintain the action, and that the amendment allowing the attorney-general to be made a party plaintiff was unauthorized and erroneous.
¶2All the judges, except MITCHELL, J., who took no part, were in favor of reversing the judgment and ordering a new trial.
¶3DENIO, C.J., JOHNSON, SELDEN, COMSTOCK and HUBBARD, Js., were of opinion that the resolution or ordinance was void.
¶4WRIGHT and T.A. JOHNSON, Js., dissented from this last proposition.