Currently serving (4)
Former judges (38)
- Helen E. Hoens2006–2013
- Virginia Long1999–2012
- Roberto A. Rivera-Soto2004–2011
- John E. Wallace jr2003–2010
- James Ronald Zazzali2000–2007
- Deborah Tobias Poritz1996–2006
- Peter Verniero1999–2004
- James H. Coleman1994–2003
- Gary S. Stein1985–2002
- Daniel Joseph O'Hern1981–2000
- Marie Louise Garibaldi1982–2000
- Alan B. Handler1977–1999
- Stewart Glasson Pollock1979–1999
- Robert Nathan Wilentz1979–1996
- Robert L. Clifford1973–1994
- Sydney Schreiber1975–1984
- Morris Pashman1973–1982
- Mark A. Sullivan1973–1981
- Worrall Fredrick Mountain1971–1979
- Richard Joseph Hughes1973–1979
- Nathan L. Jacobs1948–1975
- Frederick Wilson Hall1959–1975
- Joseph Weintraub1956–1973
- Haydn Proctor1957–1973
- Pierre P. Garven1973–1973
- John J. Francis1957–1972
- C. Thomas Schetting1959–1972
- C Thomas Schettino1959–1972
- Vincent S. Haneman1960–1971
- Albert E. Burling1947–1960
- Harry Heher1932–1959
- William A. Wachenfeld1946–1959
- A Dayton Oliphant1948–1957
- Arthur T. Vanderbilt1948–1957
William Joseph Brennan Jr.1951–1956- Clarence E. Case1929–1952
- Henry Elijah Ackerson jr1948–1952
Joseph Lamb Bodine1929–1948