Currently serving (4)
Former judges (61)
- Ronald D. Castille1994–2014
- Seamus P. McCaffery2008–2014
- Joan Orie Melvin2010–2013
- Jane Cutler Greenspan2008–2009
- James J. Fitzgerald2007–2008
- Ralph J. Cappy1990–2008
- Cynthia A. Baldwin2006–2008
- Sandra Schultz Newman1996–2006
- Russell M. Nigro1996–2006
- William H. Lamb2003–2004
- Stephen A. Zappala1983–2002
- John P. Flaherty1979–2001
- Robert N.C. Nix jr1972–1996
- Nicholas P. Papadakos1984–1996
William D. Hutchinson1982–1995- Rolf Larsen1978–1994
Robert John Colville1992–1994- Frank J. Montemuro1992–1993
- James T. McDermott1982–1992
- Juanita Kidd Stout1988–1989
- Henry X. O'Brien1962–1983
- Samuel J. Roberts1963–1983
Bruce William Kauffman1980–1982- Roy Wilkinson jr1981–1982
- Michael J. Eagen1960–1980
- Thomas W. Pomeroy1968–1979
- Louis L. Manderino1972–1979
- Benjamin R. Jones1957–1978
- Israel Packel1977–1978
- John C. Bell jr1950–1972
- Alexander F. Barbieri1971–1972
- Herbert B. Cohen1957–1970
- Michael A. Musmanno1952–1968
Charles Alvin Jones1945–1966- Earl S. Keim1962–1963
- Curtis Bok1959–1962
- Anne X. Alpern1961–1961
- Thomas D. McBride1958–1959
- Thomas McKeen Chidsey1950–1958
- John C. Arnold1953–1958
- Allen M. Stearne1942–1956
- Horace Stern1936–1956
- James B. Drew1931–1952
- Grover C. Ladner1950–1951
- George W. Maxey1930–1950
- William B. Linn1932–1950
- Marion D. Patterson1940–1950
- Howard W. Hughes1943–1945
- William I. Schaffer1921–1943
- William M. Parker1941–1943
- H. Edgar Barnes1935–1940
- John W. Kephart1919–1940
- Robert S. Frazer1915–1936
- Alexander Simpson jr1919–1935
- Emory A. Walling1916–1931
- Sylvester B. Sadler1921–1931
- Robert von Moschzisker1910–1930
- Edward J. Fox1918–1918
- John P. Elkin1905–1912
- John Stewart1905–1906
- William P. Potter1902–1903