Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

1 Dem. Sur. 299

Houghton v. Watson

New York Surrogate's Court

Decided June 15, 1882

New York Surrogate's Court · decided 1882-06-15

The petition presented in this matter showed that William Watson, late of Westchester county, died seized of a large estate, and leaving a widow, and several children, one of whom was the wife of Henry G. Houghton, of London, England; that he left a last will and testament, which was duly proved in 1877, of which his son William and others were executors; that his widow and all his children, with the exception of Mrs. Houghton, who had since died, were still living; that his…

Decided 1882-06-15

The Surrogate.

¶1As I think I have no power to make the order sought, were it to be granted it would afford no protection to the executors. The father of these minors, Dr. Houghton, is merely the natural guardian of them, and as such may control their persons only. He is not a guardian in socage, for the reason that such guardian can only exist where the minors have lands. Under this- will, everything is, by its provisions, converted into legal assets, in so far as these children’s interests are concerned. He is not their general guardian, nor have they any. If any money were paid to him, this court could exercise no supervisory power or control over him, as to his application of it, nor could he be called to account for its misapplication. There is no ground to suppose that the moneys would not be properly and judiciously used; at the same time the fact that they might not be, must be kept in view, as possible.

¶2Considering the style in which these children have thus far been reared, in consequence of the liberal in*302come of the mother, the large fortune to which, they are now entitled, their future expectations, and the straitened circumstances of their father, it would seem just that a generous allowance should be made, for their education and comfortable support, but it can be done only in a manner which the law recognizes as legitimate. By our laws, the wants of these minors can be properly cared for. through the medium of a general guardian, whose appointment may now be made by this court,- in a case like this. This application must, therefore, be denied.

¶3Ordered accordingly.

/1/demsur/299 · .json · Public domain