Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

1 Sadler 355

Schur's Appeal

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania

Decided January 18, 1886

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · decided 1886-01-18

In 1870, Edwrard Kugel was appointed guardian of the minor heirs of John Muller, deceased. Held: “If the trastee purchase with an intention to hold for himself it is a legal fraud. Any confirmation of such sale must be upon a full knowledge of all the cireumstances, and a deliberate examination by the parties interested, i. A chancellor will not assist one to obtain anything arising out of a fraud.

Affirmed · Decided 1886-01-18

Per Ouriam:

¶1It may be conceded that the purchase for the benefit of the guardian, made at his own sale, was invalid. The sale, however, was confirmed by the orphans’ court with like effect as if permission had been given to him to bid thereat, and he had purchased in pursuance of a bid then made. Further conceding that the sale might have been avoided by the children interested in the property, yet they did not do so. On the contrary, with full knowledge, they ratified the same after they were of full age, and accepted and still retain the purchase money for which it was sold. Their right so to do cannot be successfully denied. A sale thus validitated has all the legal incidents against the guardian of a sale, valid when made. His obligation connected therewith was fixed. As there was no fraudulent combination between him and the children, his liability fixed and determined the liability of his surety.

¶2Decree affirmed and appeal dismissed, at the cost of the appellant.

/1/sadler/355 · .json · Public domain