Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

10 Watts 405

Heath v. Knapp

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania

Decided September 15, 1840

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · decided 1840-09-15

Elijah Heath against Joshua Knapp and others. Ejectment for 1634 acres of land. The plaintiff gave in evidence two warrants to Robert Morris, dated March 5, 1795, for 1000 acres of land each, and a survey on one of 1025 acres, 112 perches, to Alexander W. Foster, in right of Robert Morris, made August 26, 1820, returned and accepted January 30, 1822. A survey upon the other made August 26, 1820, to Hugh Brady, in right of Robert Morris, returned and accepted February 20,1821.

Decided 1840-09-15

Per Curiam.

¶1Before survey-made, such a warrant gives no interest in land: and if it did, the land could be sold only in the county. What then is the nature of such a warrant, or of the right conferred by it? It is a mere license-authority to do a particular thing for the warrantee’s benefit: it is an order to perform an act which may give him an estate in land, but in the mean time it is no more than a thing in action; and though equity might execute an agreement to transfer it, it is not assignable at law. Now at common law, a thing in action could not be seized in execution; and it will scarcely be pretended that a mere authority can. Could a marriage license, a lottery ticket, or a. tavern-keeper’s authority to retail, be levied and sold? These, though valuable, are so intimately *407associated with the person, as to be inseparable from it, without the assistance of a statute, even by the machinery of the law. The surveys made on these warrants,therefore, did notenure to the benefit of the person calling himself the sheriff’s vendee, because, as the sale was a nullity, there could be no sheriff’s vendee; and the direction given was improper.

¶2Judgment reversed, and a venire facias de novo awarded.

/10/watts/405 · .json · Public domain