Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

117 Me. 143

Lembo v. Donnell

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine

Decided March 11, 1918

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine · decided 1918-03-11

Action on the case to recover damages for alleged malpractice in performing an illegal operation upon plaintiff and for negligent treatment thereafter. Defendant filed general demurrer, in which plaintiff joined. Presiding Justice overruled demurrer; to which ruling defendant filed exceptions. Case stated in opinion.

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Exceptions overruled · Decided 1918-03-11

How this case has been cited

Cited by 4 later decisions — most recently July 1954

4 state decisions

2019181920193019401950decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Philbrook, J.

¶1This is an action on the case brought to recover damages against the defendant, a physician, for malpractice while performing an operation to procure an abortion on the plaintiff, and for unskilled treatment subsequent to the operation. The defendant filed a general demurrer which was overruled and the case comes to us upon exceptions to that ruling.

¶2*144The basis of defendant’s exceptions lies in his position that as the plaintiff consented to the operation she cannot recover because the operation is an illegal one.

¶3In a similar case, Miller v. Bayer, 94 Wis., 123; 68 N. W., 869, the court said: “It is further contended that plaintiff cannot recover, because she submitted to the operation performed upon her. Such is not the law. Consent by one person to allow another to perform an unlawful act upon such person does not constitute a defense to an action to recover the actual damages which such person thereby received;” citing 2 Greenleaf Ev., Sec. 85; Shay v. Thompson, 59 Wis., 540, 18 N. W., 473; Fitzgerald v. Calvin, 110 Mass., 153; Adams v. Waggoner, 33 Ind., 531; Com. v. Colberg, 119 Mass., 350; Grotton v. Glidden, 84 Maine, 589.

¶4We agree that this statement of the law is correct.

¶5Exceptions overruled.

/117/me/143 · .json · Public domain