Currently serving (6)
Former judges (48)
- Jeffrey L. Hjelm2014–2020
- Susan W. Calkins1998–2007
- Howard H. Dana jr1993–2007
- Paul L. Rudman1992–2005
- Daniel E. Wathen1981–2001
- David Glendenning Roberts1980–1998
Kermit Victor Lipez1994–1998- Caroline Duby Glassman1983–1997
- Samuel W. Collins jr1988–1994
- Elmer H. Violette1981–1994
- Vincent L. McKusick1977–1992
Morton Aaron Brody1990–1991
David Brock Hornby1988–1990- Louis Scolnik1983–1988
- David A. Nichols1977–1988
- David A. Nicholas1977–1988
- Armand A. Dufresne jr1965–1985
- Edward S. Godfrey1976–1983
Gene Carter1980–1983- Suidney W. Wernick1970–1981
- Harry P. Glassman1979–1981
- Charles A. Pomeroy1969–1980
- James P. Archibald1971–1980
- Thomas E. Delahanty1973–1979
- Randolph A. Weatherbee1966–1976
- Donald W. Webber1953–1973
- Harold C. Marden1962–1970
- Robert B. Williamson1949–1970
- Walter M. Tapley jr1954–1969
- Abraham M. Rudman1965–1966
- Francis W. Sullivan1956–1965
- Cecil J. Siddall1958–1965
- Frederick Harold Dubord1956–1962
- Edward P. Murray1947–1962
- Sidney St. Felix Thaxter1930–1958
- Albert Beliveau1954–1958
- Raymond Fellows1946–1956
- Percy T. Clarke1955–1956
- Frank A. Tirrell jr1953–1955
- Edward F. Merrill1948–1954
- William B. Nulty1949–1953
- Harold H. Murchie1940–1953
- Arthur Chapman1942–1952
- Nathaniel Tompkins1945–1949
- Guy H. Sturgis1923–1949
- James H. Hudson1933–1947
- Harry Manser1935–1946
- George H. Worster1939–1942