Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

12 N.C. 304

Davidson v. . Cowan

Supreme Court of North Carolina

Decided December 5, 1827

Supreme Court of North Carolina · decided 1827-12-05

From Mecklenburg. The Plaintiff, on (lie Spring Circuit of 1827, obtained a rule upon the Defendant to show cause why a former Sheriff of Mecklenburg should not amend his return toa writ of Fieri facias against one David Cowan, which issued on the. 21st of June,. 1810, and was returnable to the ensuing term of the Superior Court for that county.

Decided 1827-12-05

Hax.1i, Judge.

¶1 I think the proceeding in the Superior Court was irregular, because an alteration was suffered to be made in a record, at the instance of one who was not a party to it, and whose right might be affected by it. Besides, the alteration, at this distance of time, may injure the rights of third persons, held under thev record, as it originally stood. This seems to he the object now in view for as the negroes were not levied upon, as appears by the Sheriff’s return, under the execution which issued in 1810, but were sold under that which issued in 1811, after the death of David Cowan, *306 it is intended by the proposed alteration, to validate that sale, and of course, to affect the title of James Cowan,. to the same property, acquired in 1821, under Ann Cow-an. Be this as it may, I think the Court erred, in permitting the alteration to be made. This case, however, is similar to that of Carter v. Graves, (ante 74) and the appeal cannot be considered as taken from a regular proceeding in the Court below j it must therefore, be dismissed, but the Appellant is not bound to pay costs to the Appellee.

¶2 Pee Curiam. — Appeal dismissed, each party to pay his own costs.

/12/nc/304 · .json · Public domain