Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

12 Pa. 173

Hugus v. Walker

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania

Decided September 15, 1849

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · decided 1849-09-15

This was an action of ejectment by Isaac Hugus against Benjamin Walker, brought for the use of such of the creditors of William Gr. Walker, deceased, as were concerned in the purchase of the said William’s interest in the premises from A. H. Philson, his administrator. William Gr. W. and the defendant were sons of George Walker, deceased.

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently February 1907

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1849-09-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1The opinion of this Court was delivered by

Coulter, J.

¶2The three first errors assigned, which relate to the admission of evidence, cannot be sustained. The defendant was not estopped from giving the evidence objected to, merely because the evidence given by the plaintiff impugned, or might weaken it. If that were the case, the determination of causes would be drawn within the vortex of the Court, and when evidence was offered by one, the other party would produce stronger evidence, as he alleged, to show that it ought not to be admitted. All the reasons offered by the plaintiff against the reception of the evidence would go merely to the value of the evidence, when opposed by that *178of the plaintiff before the jury. The evidence was in itself competent, pertinent, and relative, and was all properly received. Its weight or value before the jury was another affair. Its effect might be weakened or impaired,by the testimony previously or subsequently given by the plaintiff. That was all a matter for the jury under the direction of the Court.

¶3As to the errors assigned in relation to the charge of the Court to the jury: There is nothing in them sufficient to disturb it. I will •let the charge speak for itself. It will carry itself through. The judgment is affirmed, for the reasons given by the Court below.

¶4Judgment affirmed.

/12/pa/173 · .json · Public domain