Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

14 Me. 409

Kuhn v. Kaler

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine

Decided May 15, 1837

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine · decided 1837-05-15

Exceptions from the Court'of Common Pleas, Smith J. presiding. The only question raised in the case, was, whether the widow was entitled to dower in land situated as this was. The premises in which dower was claimed, containing about fifteen acres, and part of a larger tract, was wholly woodland, and on which no improvements have ever been made.

Decided 1837-05-15

¶1After a continuance for advisement, the opinion of the Court was prepared by

Shepley J.

¶2The general rule, that the widow is dowable of all lands of which her husband was seised during coverture, has ever been subject to certain exceptions. An additional exception was established in Massachusetts, while Maine was a part of that State, by the case of Conner v. Shepherd, where it was decided, that a widow was not dowable of unimproved lands. In the case of White et ux. v. Willis, it is said, drat this exception was not designed to extend to lands of this description used with the homestead, or cultivated land.

¶3The fifteen acres of unimproved land in which dower is now claimed were separated from the farm as early as 1805, leaving connected with it sufficient lands of the same description for the purpose of obtaining firewood, fencing, and building materials. And since that time', this^tract has not been connected with or appendant to, a cultivated farm.

¶4The argument of the plaintiff is, that it does not appear, that the widow could have assigned to her, in that part of the woodland remaining in connection with the farm, a convenient part for the purpose of obtaining firewood, fencing, Sic. But considering the large quantity of such land remaining with the small quantity of 'improved land, it cannot be presumed, that she cannot have her dower assigned conveniently for such purposes. And if such were the condition of the whole farm, the proof should come from the plaintiff, this being necessary to establish her right to dower in unimproved land so long disconnected with the farm.

¶5deceptions overruled.

/14/me/409 · .json · Public domain