Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

15 F. Cas. 1014

Lowber v. Shaw

U.S. District Court

Decided May 15, 1829

U.S. District Court · decided 1829-05-15

Assumpsit by the plaintiff [Edward Low-ber], as payee of a bill of exchange drawn at Philadelphia, by one Edmund Roberts, on the defendant, at Portsmouth, New Hampshire. The bill was dated 12th of May, 1827, for $500 payable to the plaintiff or order, at four months, for value received “being the amount of one share and interest in the cargo of the brig Mary Ann.” The declaration contained three counts: 1. On the bill as an accepted bill. 2. For money had and received. 3.

Decided 1829-05-15

STORY, Circuit Justice.

¶1My opinion is, that the witness is competent without a release. It is the common case of an agent called upon to prove his authority and agency; and that has always been deemed an excepted case. The witness has an equal interest either way. If he drew the bill without authority, and it is recovered from the defendant, then he is responsible over to the latter. If, on the other hand, no such re-*1015eovery is had, he is liable to the plaintiff. The witness must therefore be admitted.

¶2He proved the facts above stated. In the farther progress of the cause, the defence turned upon the ground, that the witness had deviated from his authority in the shipments for the voyage, and that the facts were known to the plaintiff. It was admitted, that upon the authorities there was a constructive acceptance of the bill, if taken as the plaintiff contended, and there was no excess of authority in drawing the bill known at the time to the plaintiff. The jury found a verdict for the plaintiff.

/15/fcas/1014 · .json · Public domain