Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

15 N.Y.S. 143

Duffy v. Work

The Superior Court of the City of New York and Buffalo · decided 1891-07-02

Action by Felix A. Duffy against James H. Work and others for the conversion of a deed.

Decided 1891-07-02

Dugro, J.

¶1The plaintiff appeals from a judgment dismissing his complaint entered upon the findings and decision of a judge at special term. At the trial both parties gave evidence. A careful examination of the papers presented fails to disclose any ground which calls for a reversal of the judgment. The burden of establishing his cause of action by a fair preponderance of evidence was not satisfactorily borne by the plaintiff at the trial. If the second conveyance is considered to have been given as security, and so a mortgage, it would not help the plaintiff’s case, as by his conduct he has es-topped himself from claiming that the sale to Sexton was a conversion; for he took service to find a purchaser, and when unsuccessful in his efforts accepted $1,000 to give possession to a purchaser. The judgment is affirmed, with costs. All concur.

/15/nys/143 · .json · Public domain