15 N.Y.S.
Volume 15 — New York Supplement
502 opinions
- 15 N.Y.S. 1Nanz v. Oakley (1891)
Action by August O. ¡Nanz against Jesse Oakley. The court directed a verdict for plaintiff, and defendant moves for a new trial. Code Civil Proc.
- 15 N.Y.S. 2Dunlap's Cable News Co. v. Stone (1891)
Action for injunction by Dunlap’s Cable Hews Company, a corporation existing under the laws of Hew Jersey, and engaged in the business of collecting news, and furnishing the same to all newspapers which may apply therefor, against David M. Stone, as president of the Hew York Associated Press, an unincorporated association, existing under the laws of Hew York, also engaged in the business of collecting news and furnishing the same to the newspapers.
- 15 N.Y.S. 4Mackey v. Rausch (1891)
Action by William D. Mackey and another against Hugh Littlejohn. Defendant died pending an appeal from a judgment in his favor, and the action was thereupon revived against his executors, Benjamin Rausch and another.
- 15 N.Y.S. 6E. W. Bliss Co. v. Opera-Glass Supply Co. (1891)
Action by the E. W. Bliss Company against the Opera-Glass Supply Company. A motion was made to vacate an attachment based'on the papers on which the attachment was granted. The defect particularly relied upon was-that the affidavits failed to show that plaintiff was entitled to recover the sum stated therein over and above all counter-claims known to the plaintiff. The motion was denied, and defendant appeals. Code Civil Proc.
- 15 N.Y.S. 8Passavant v. Bowdoin (1891)
<p>1. Assignment for Benefit of Creditors—Parties.</p> <p>A complaint alleged that plaintiffs obtained a judgment in a prior action, declaring void an assignment made by a failing debtor preferring defendants’ debt, as having been executed with intent to defraud creditors, and that a receiver was appointed therein to take charge of the assets of the debtor and pay plaintiffs’ judgment out of the same. Plaintiffs ask that their said judgment be paid out of the moneys in defendants’ hands received by them under such fraudulent preferential assignment. Held, that the assignee in such assignment, notwithstanding its vacation at the suit of plaintiff, was a necessary party defendant to plaintiffs’ present proceeding.</p> <p>2. Same—Rights of Receiver.</p> <p>The complaint was also defective in that it appeared therefrom that plaintiff was seeking to recover from defendants assets fraudulently assigned, for the collection of which a receiver had been appointed at plaintiffs’ instance, to whom the legal title to such assets passed.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 10Korn v. New York Elevated Railway Co. (1891)
<p>1. Elevated Railroads—ISubsequent Purchaser—Right to Damages.</p> <p>An action, may be maintained by a party purchasing premises after the erection of an elevated railroad in front thereof, to recover damages resulting from such erection, though he paid a diminished price for the property on that account. Following WerfeVman v. Railway Co., 11N. Y. Supp. 66.</p> <p>3. Same—Damages—Rights of Remainder-Man.</p> <p>Under Code Civil Proc. N. Y. § 1665, which provides that a person seised of an estate in remainder or reversion may maintain an action for an injury to the inheritance, notwithstanding an intervening estate for life or for years, the purchaser of the fee of premises, subject to a lease, may recover damages to the rental value of the premises caused by the erection of an elevated railroad in front thereof during the existence of the lease.</p> <p>3. Same—Demised Premises—Measure of Damages. •</p> <p>In an action by the owner of premises to recover for damages to the rental value thereof caused by the erection of an elevated railway, the measure of damages is the difference between the rental value of the property before the erection of the railway and the rental value thereafter, without regard to the fact that plaintiff became the owner of the premises after the erection of the railway, and during the existence of a lease of the premises.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 12Potter v. New York Central & Hudson River Railroad (1891)
<p>Railroad Companies—Failure to Fence Track.</p> <p>A railroad company, in default of fencing its own land, lying along its track, from the track itself, is not liable to its own tenants for loss of cattle straying from such land onto its track.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 13Murray v. Cameron (1891)
<p>Appeal from circuit court, Erie county.</p> <p>.Action by Charles S. Murray against William T. Cameron. From a judgment for defendant, plaintiff appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 14Rock v. Doerr (1891)
<p>Appeal from judgment on report of referee.</p> <p>Action by James Bock against John Doerr. From a judgment for plain"tiff, defendant appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 15Thomas v. Thomas (1891)
<p>Mutual Benefit Policy—Change of Beneficiary—By-Laws of Society.</p> <p>A person holding a certificate of membership in a benefit society, which designated the holder’s daughter as the beneficiary thereof, on his second marriage inserted, immediately after the daughter’s name as beneficiary, the words, “and my wife. ” The by-laws of the society provided: “A member in good standing may at any time surrender his relief-fund certificate, and a new certificate shall thereafter be issued, payable to such person or persons as the member may direct. ” Held, that such certificate could only be made payable to any other person than the beneficiary therein mentioned by surrender to the society as provided by its by-laws, and that such member’s wife on his death acquired no title to any part of its proceeds on account of decedent’s alteration thereof in her favor.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 16Thomas v. Thomas (1891)
Action by Sarah A. Thomas against Mary E. Thomas, impleaded with the Mutual Aid & Accident Association. For a statement of facts, see Thomas v. Thomas, 15 N. Y. Supp. 15. From a judgment for defendants, Mary E. Thomas, plaintiff, appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 18Ottinger v. New York Elevated Railway Co. (1891)
<p>Appeal from special term, New York county.</p> <p>Action by Marx Ottinger and another against the New York Elevated Railway Company and another. From a judgment for plaintiff, defendant appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 19Simis v. McElroy (1891)
<p>Appeal from circuit court, Hew York county.</p> <p>Action by Mary O. Simis against Daniel S. McElroy. From a judgment for plaintiff, defendant appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 22Mayor of New York v. Mott (1891)
Ejectment by the mayor, etc., of the city of Hew York, against Hopper S-Mott and others. From a judgment entered on a verdict for defendants, and from an order denying a motion for a new trial, plaintiff appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 24Tauziede v. Jumel (1891)
Action by Jean A. Tauziede and Charles H. Holt against Francois H. Jumel and others. The plaintiff Tauziede was one of the “Jumel heirs,” entitled to an interest of one-twelfth in certain real estate in the city of Hew York, whereof Stephen Jumel died seised in 1832, and the plaintiff Charles H. Holt claims an interest therein under an assignment of one-fourth of the plaintiff Tauziede’s interest in the premises.
- 15 N.Y.S. 27Singer Manufacturing Co. v. Hill (1891)
Replevin by the Singer Manufacturing Company against Mary Hill to recover a sewing-machine. From a judgment of the county court affirming a judgment of a justice of the peace in lavor of plaintiff, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 29Kelly v. City of Rochester (1891)
<p>Inadequate Damages—Fracture op Ribs.</p> <p>A verdict for SI5 damages, rendered in favor of plaintiff in an action to recover for an injury sustained by a fall on defendant’s icy sidewalk, was properly set aside as inadequate, where it appeared that plaintiff sustained a fracture of two ribs by the fall, and was disabled from labor for several months thereby.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 29People ex rel. Titsworth v. Nash (1891)
Application by John P. Titsworth, commissioner of highways of the town •of Groveland, for certiorari to Edwin A. Nash, county judge of Livingston ■county, to review an order made by him, confirming the report of commissioners appointed by him in proceedings to lay out a highway.
- 15 N.Y.S. 33Rochester Electric Light Co. v. Rochester Power Co. (1891)
<p>Appeal from special term, Monroe county.</p> <p>Action by the Rochester Electric Light Company against the Rochester Power Company. From a judgment for defendant, plaintiff appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 35Chase v. Jamestown Street Railway Co. (1891)
<p>Appeal from circuit court, Cattaraugus county. ,</p> <p>Action by Cora Chase against the Jamestown Street-Bailway Company. From a judgment for plaintiff, defendant appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 37Harley v. Buffalo Car Manufacturing Co. (1891)
Action by Frank Harley against the Buffalo Car Manufacturing Company.. There was a judgment of nonsuit, and from an order denying a motion for a new trial, made on the minutes of the court, plaintiff appeals. •
- 15 N.Y.S. 39Brand v. McMahon (1891)
Exceptions from circuit court, Cattaraugus county. Action by George P. Brand against James W. McMahon. Verdict was directed for defendant, and exceptions ordered to be heard in the first instance at general term.
- 15 N.Y.S. 41Preuster v. Supreme Council of Order of Chosen Friends (1891)
Action by Frederika Preuster against the Supreme Council of the Order of Chosen Friends. From an order granting plaintiff’s motion for a new trial, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 42Carter v. Stevens (1891)
Action by Lad wick H. Carter against William Stevens, to recover personal property taken by defendant in execution. From an order made in favor of the execution creditor, George Carnahan, who was the real defendant in interest, William Stevens, a nominal defendant only, together with plaintiff, appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 44Fairman v. Brush (1891)
Action by Gibson AV.. Fairman against Charles B. Brush, executor of John McLaren, deceased. McLaren, in his life-time, was a manufacturer of steam-engines, and plaintiff claimed that he had an agreement with decedent whereby he (plaintiff) was to have commissions on all sales procured by him. He claimed to have procured eight different customers for decedent, and that he was entitled to 10 per cent, commission on the amount of decedent’s sales to them.
- 15 N.Y.S. 45Cook v. New York Central & Hudson River Railroad (1891)
<p>Railroad Companies—Injuries at Crossing-jN egligence—Evidence.</p> <p>In an action against a railroad company for negligently killing a traveler at a highway crossing, it appeared that, when deceased was at a point whence he could see the track, defendant’s train was not in sight, and that for the rest of the distance the view was obstructed. Defendant did not give the signals within the distance required by law. Near the crossing was another railroad, so that it would be difficult for a traveler to determine from the sound of an approaching train on which track it was. Held, that the case was for the jury.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 48Hayden v. Bank of Syracuse (1891)
- 15 N.Y.S. 49Martin v. Platt (1891)
Action by Howard A. Martin against Spencer B. Platt and others, as executors of William H. Platt, deceased, for services as an accountant. Defendants denied that they had employed plaintiff, or had authorized their attorney to employ him, as such accountant. There was a verdict for plaintiff, and defendants move for a new trial.
- 15 N.Y.S. 51Winchester v. Browne (1891)
<p>Action by George G. Winchester against T. Quincy Browne. Defendant demurs to plaintiff’s reply to new matter in the answer.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 51Foran v. Foran (1891)
Action by Thomas B. Foran, Jr., against Thomas E. Foran and others for the sale of certain real estate of which plaintiff’s mother died seised,'and for a division, after payment of liens thereon, of the balance of the proceeds among those entitled thereto. Defendants demur to the complaint on the ground that it does not state facts sufficient to constitute a cause of action.
- 15 N.Y.S. 55Schenck v. Irwin (1891)
<p>L Appealable Order—Supplementary Proceedings.</p> <p>Under Code Civil Proc. N. T. § 3433, providing for an appeal from “ an order made in the course of the proceedings * * * where the execution was issued out of a county court, ” an appeal will lie from an order of a judge of a county court vacating an order for the examination of a third person in supplementary proceedings. 3. Supplementary Proceedings—Sufficiency of Affidavit.</p> <p>An affidavit by a judgment creditor to obtain an order for the examination of a third person in supplementary proceedings, where the judgment debtor had removed from the county wherein the special proceeding was commenced,was fatally defccdve in not showing that the execution therein described had been delivered to the sheriff of the county where the judgment debtor resided at the time the affidavit was made, under Code Civil Proo. N. T. § 3458, which provides in such case that “the execution must have been issued * * * to the sheriff of the county where the judgment debtor has, at the time of the commencement of the special proceeding, a place for the regular transaction of business, in person. ”</p> <p>8. Same—Waiver of Defects—Jurisdiction.</p> <p>In such case, the attendance of the person to be examined before the referee, and' Ms submission to the examination, could not operate as a waiver by him of objections to the sufficiency of the affidavit, since without a sufficient affidavit the court could not have jurisdiction of the subject-matter.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 57Filon v. Miller Brewing Co. (1891)
<p>1. Corporations—Board of Directors—Acts of Individual Members.</p> <p>Special authority to aert for a corporation can be conferred by the board of directors only in its collective capacity, when convened as such board, and not by the assent of individual members.</p> <p>8. Same—Surety for Another—Ultra Vires.</p> <p>A brewing company cannot become surety for the payment of the rent of an hotel by the lessee thereof, though the lessee agrees to buy his beer from the company if it would guaranty the lease; such act not being within the scope of the business for which the brewing company was organized.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 58Kerr v. Dildine (1891)
Action by Abram T. Kerr and another against Zachariah Dildine. Defendant died pending the action, and the same was revived in the name of his administratrix, Anna Dildine. Decedent had demurred to the complaint in his life-time, and his demurrer was overruled, with leave to answer within 20 days. He died without answering the complaint in the specified time.
- 15 N.Y.S. 60People v. Trimble (1891)
Indictment against William Trimble for larceny in the first degree. Defendant pleaded a former conviction, and the jury rendered a verdict “for the people.” The court then allowed defendant to file a plea of “not guilty” to the indictment, and fixed a day for the trial of defendant on that plea, which, was thereafter had, and from a judgment of conviction then rendered defendant appeals. Code Crim. Proc.
- 15 N.Y.S. 62Grosser v. City of Rochester (1891)
Action by Anna Grosser against the city of Rochester and others. From a .judgment entered on the report of a referee, plaintiff appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 63In re Newland Avenue (1891)
Proceedings for the opening of Newland avenue, in the city of Jamestown. From an order confirming the report of the commissioners appointed to assess •damages, Almira E. Northrop, a land-owner, appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 64Abell v. Bradner (1891)
Action by Thurlow VV. Abell and another against Alonzo Bradner and Andrew J. Holden and others. From an order confirming in part and in part overruling the report of a referee, both parties appeal.
- 15 N.Y.S. 68Trimmer v. Fish (1891)
Action by Sylvester Trimmer against George T. Fish and B. Louisa Fish. From a judgment entered on a verdict of a jury, and from an order denying plaintiff’s motion for a new trial on the minutes of the court, plaintiff appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 71Griesa v. Massachusetts Benefit Ass'n (1891)
<p>1. Mutual Benefit Insurance—Reinstatement—Conditions.</p> <p>After a member of a mutual benefit association had forfeited her membership by failure to pay an assessment within the time required by the certificate, the assessment was paid, and a receipt given therefor, which recited that the payment was made and received and the receipt given by the association, and received by the member, on condition that such member “is now in good health, and free from all diseases, infirmities, or weaknesses. ” It appeared that the member’s health had begun to be affected about a year before the forfeiture by the natural decline of age, Which resulted in her death soon after the receipt was given, but that she "was subject to no disease, and that her only infirmities were those natural to old age. Held, that the evidence failed to show that the condition of the receipt was not fulfilled.</p> <p>2. Same—Waiver of Forfeiture.</p> <p>A member of a mutual benefit association failed to pay an assessment within the time required by her certificate of membership, which by its terms was to become void in the event of such failure to pay, but which might be reinstated by the officers of the association for reasons satisfactory to them, and on such conditions as they might require. A few days after the expiration of the time limited the member paid the assessment, and a receipt therefor was given, which declared that the payment was received on condition that the member was at the time “in good health, and free from all diseases, infirmities, and weaknesses, ” and that no subsequent payment to the association on the certificate shall “impair, waive, alter, or change any of the conditions of this receipt or of said certificate. ” Notices of subsequent assessments were given, which declared that payment of such assessments would be received only on the agreement that no condition on “ which any previous payment had been received is waived thereby, ” and these assessments were paid. Afterwards a notice of an annual assessment to pay the expenses of the association was sent to the member, which recited that “the sending of this notice shall not be held to waive any forfeiture or lapse of membership, if previous assessinents remain unpaid. ” Held that, though the condition of the first receipt was not fulfilled, tho subsequent dealings between the parties showed a waiver of the forfeiture for non-payment of the assessment within the required time.</p> <p>8. Corporations—Actions—Ultra Vires.</p> <p>A corporation cannot avail itself of the defense of ultravvres, unless it is pleaded.</p> <p>4. Foreign Insurance Companies—Retaliatory Laws.</p> <p>Laws N. Y. 1883, c. 175, which provides that; where any other state shall impose any obligation on co-operative life insurance companies of New York doing business in such other states, “the like obligations are hereby imposed on similar corporations of such other state transacting business in this state, ” does not impose on a Massachusetts corporation doing business in New York the prohibition of St. Mass. 1885, c. 183, § 10, that no policy or certificate shall be issued on “the life of any person more than 60 years of age, ” since it is the obligation, and not the prohibitions, imposed on foreign companies by the retaliatory act of 1883.</p> <p>6. Same—Action on Policy—Where Beowht.</p> <p>A cause of action on a policy of life insurance issued by a foreign corporation to a resident of New York, who dies in that state, arises in New York,- within Code Civil Proc. N. Y. § 1780, which provides that “an action against a foreign corporation may be maintained * * * by a non-resident, * * * where the cause of action arose within the state. ”</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 75Burns v. Norton (1891)
Action by John Burns against Theodore M. Norton, to recover the amount of an excessive fine paid by. plaintiff. Plaintiff was arrested and tried before-defendant, a justice of the peace, acting as a court of special sessions, and a jury, upon the charge of assault in the third degree, and on the trial the jury rendered a verdict of guilty.
- 15 N.Y.S. 79People v. Clark (1891)
At chambers. Indictment against Charles P. Clark and others for violating the car-heating act, (Laws N. Y. 1887, c. 616, as amended by Laws 1888, •c. 189; Laws 1889, c. 76; and Laws 1890, c. 421.) This act (section 1) forbids the heating of passenger cars by a stove or furnace inside the ears.
- 15 N.Y.S. 81Brush Electric Illuminating Co. v. Consolidated Telegraph & Electrical Subway Co. (1891)
<p>1. Board of Electrical Control—Regulation of Rates—Review on Appeal.</p> <p>Defendant constructed electrical subways in the streets of New York city under a contract (ratified by Laws N. Y. 1887, c. 716) with the board of electrical subways, by which defendant agreed that space in the subways should be leased to any corporation having lawful power to operate electrical subways in New York city, and to fix a fair scale of rent to be charged for the use of such subways; such scale of rents, however, to be subject to the control, modification, and revision by the board of electrical control. Held, that the determination as to whether the rents fixed by defendant were fair and reasonable was for the board of electrical control, and, where such board has passed on the question and fixed the rent, its decision is not reviewable by the courts.</p> <p>2. Same—Rights of Electric Light Companies—Injunction.</p> <p>In an action to restrain defendant from removing, from the electric subways so constructed by it, cables and conductors placed therein by plaintiff, an electric light company, it appeared that, after the rates fixed by defendant for such use of its subway had been communicated to plaintiff, a written application was presented by plaintiff to defendant for space in the subway for one year. No agreement was signed by defendant, nor did defendant agree to allow plaintiff to continue the use of the subway for any specified time. Held, that the acceptance by defendant of such application, and giving verbal permission to use the subway, was a mere license to use it for the period mentioned in the application, and that'the injunction would be denied.</p> <p>8. Same—Rights of Subway Company—Rent.</p> <p>Though defendant obtained permission from public authorities to build the subway in the public streets, and bound itself by contract with the board of electrical subways to furnish the use of its subway to such corporations or individuals as should have authority to use the streets for electrical purposes, it is not a common carrier, or possessed by such a franchise as is conferred on a ferry or turnpike company, and it may withdraw the use of the subway from one who refuses to pay for the same.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 84O'Neill v. Dry-Dock, East Broadway & Battery Railroad (1891)
Action by Margaret O’Neill against the Dry-Dock, East Broadway & Battery Railroad Company and Theodore Westing, for injuries to plaintiff caused by a collision between a truck of defendant Westing and a street-car of defendant railroad company, in which car plaintiff was a passenger at the time of the accident. Defendants appeared separately. From a judgment entered on a verdict for plaintiff, and from an order denying a motion for a new trial, defendants appeal.
- 15 N.Y.S. 86Wemple v. McManus (1891)
- 15 N.Y.S. 88Keller v. Metropolitan Elevated Railway Co. (1891)
. Action by Frederick K. Keller against the Metropolitan Elevated Railroad Company and another to restrain defendants from maintaining and operating tlieir elevated railroad in the street in front of plaintiff’s premises, known as “Kb. 662 Sixth Avenue,” and to recover damages for past injuries to the premises by the construction and operation of such elevated railroad.
- 15 N.Y.S. 89In re Marcial's Estate (1891)
Proceedings by Martin Marcial for the probate of the will of Enoch Marcial, deceased.
- 15 N.Y.S. 94Oliwill v. Verdenhalven (1891)
Action by Mary Oliwill against Daniel Verdenhalven. From a judgment -entered on a verdict for defendant, and from an order denying a motion for -a new trial, plaintiff appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 96Walsh v. Dolan (1891)
Action by Joseph Walsh against Thomas F. Dolan. From a judgment entered on a verdict for defendant, and from an order denying a motion for a new trial, plaintiff appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 98Hoffman v. Gundrum (1891)
Beplevin by Katharina Hoffman against Hartman E. Gundrum and others. Prom a judgment entered on a verdict for plaintiff, and from an order denying a motion for a new trial, defendants appeal.
- 15 N.Y.S. 101Ely v. Britton (1891)
<p>Usury—Evidence—Discounting Notes.</p> <p>In an action on a promissory note defendant alleged that he was an accommodation indorser, and that the note was usurious. Plaintiff testified as a witness for defendant, that G., the maker of the notes, wishing to borrow money, offered to give plaintiff his note for $100 indorsed by defendant in return for $90 cash, and that after the arrangement was made G. bought the $100 note so indorsed, and he (plaintiff) advanced $90 on it. Held that, since the note was accommodation paper and had no inception until its delivery to plaintiff, it was a question of fact whether the usurious agreement was in fact made, and it was error for the court to direct a verdict for plaintiff.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 102Auerbach v. Peetsch (1891)
Action by Simon Auerbach and others against Henry C. L. Peetsch and others. From a judgment entered on a verdict for plaintiffs, defendants appeal.
- 15 N.Y.S. 105Hoe v. Hoey (1891)
<p>Appeal from trial term.</p> <p>Action by Robert Hoe against John Hoey. Erom a judgment entered on a verdict for plaintiff for $100, and from an order denying a motion for a new trial, made by plaintiff on the ground that the verdict was for an insufficient amount of damages, and was contrary to the evidence and contrary to law, plaintiff appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 108De Soucey v. Manhattan Railway Co. (1891)
<p>Appeal from trial term.</p> <p>Action by Mary De Soucey against the Manhattan Railway Company for damages from an injury charged to have been caused by the negligence of the defendant. The alleged negligence consisted in starting the train with a jerk, whereby plaintiff was thrown down and hurt. Plaintiff, when she fell, was in the car, and near the third seat from the entrance.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 110Tanco v. Booth (1891)
Action by Jose Taneo, Jr., against Henry P. Booth and William P. Hughes, •impleaded with others, to recover possession of personal property. Judgment -of trial term of city court in favor of plaintiff was affirmed without opinion by the general term, and defendants again appeal.
- 15 N.Y.S. 113Hooper v. Beecher (1891)
Action by Nathaniel Hooper and another against Charles McC. Beecher and others. Prom a judgment dismissing the complaint on the merits, plaintiffs appeal.
- 15 N.Y.S. 114McGean v. Metropolitan Elevated Railway Co. (1891)
Action by James H. McGean, as executor and trustee under the last will and testament of Delia Powers, deceased, against the Metropolitan Elevated Railway Company and the Manhattan Railway Company.for'damages caused by the construction and operation of defendants’ elevated railroad, and for an injunction. The finding at folio 87, referred to in the opinion, is one of the conclusions of law, and is as follows: “Sixth.
- 15 N.Y.S. 114People ex rel. Rector v. Blackhurst (1891)
Petition by the people of the state of New York on the relation of the eor-poration of the Rector, Church-Wardens, and Vestrymen of the Protestant Episcopal Church of St. Stephens, in the city of New York, against James Blackhurst as treasurer and senior warden of said corporation, to obtain a mandamus to compel the defendant to affix the corporate seal of the relator -to an agreement for the consolidation and union of the relator with the Holy Trinity Church of Harlem.
- 15 N.Y.S. 117Rector v. Rector (1891)
Action by the rector, etc., of the Holy Trinity Church, etc., against the rector, etc,, of the Church of St. Stephens, James Blackhurst, Charles E. Fleming, and others. From order striking out, vacating, and setting aside notice of appearance and answer served by Andrew J. Shipman, attorney on behalf of defendant corporation, the latter appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 119Moody v. Belden (1891)
Action by William D. Moody against Francis A. Belden and others. From so much of an order as denied plaintiff’s motion for judgment and for a bill of particulars, and also denied his motion to make more definite and certain paragraphs of the answer containing denials and allegations of payment, plaintiff appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 120Strong v. Jenkins (1891)
<p>Appeal from municipal court.</p> <p>Action by Arthur E. Strong, by his guardian ad. litem, against Oliver A. Jenkins and Andrew J. Kurtz. The court granted a nonsuit as to defendant Kurtz, and rendered judgment against defendant Jenkins, who appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 122Schmidt v. Barry (1891)
<p>Sale under Execution—Validity—Postín» Notices.</p> <p>Where a constable levies on personal property in one town, but posts notices in and sells in another, in violation of Code Civil Proc. N. V. § 3039, which provides that the constable, after making a levy, shall “immediately post conspicuously, in at least three public places of the * * * town in which the property was taken, written or printed notices, signed by him, describing the property, and specifying" the place * * * within the same town where, and the time, not less than six days after the posting, when, it will be exposed' for sale, ” the sale is void, and a purchaser having notice of the levy, where and when made, takes no title under such sale, and he or his vendee must restore the property at the suit of the execution debtor.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 123In re City of Buffalo (1891)
<p>Eminent Domain—Street Condemnation—Rights or Owners.</p> <p>Where the legislature contera on a municipality the power to acquire the tee of one of its streets, a proceeding by the common council for that purpose regularly-conducted, wherein it is declared that the land of a certain street owned by individuals shall be taken “in fee for public streets, ” is conclusive upon the courts, and the owners cannot be permitted to introduce evidence to show that the street is-intended to be taken for a purpose other than that declared. Hatch, J., dissenting.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 128Woodard v. Holland Medicine Co. (1891)
Demurrer to complaint. Action by Charles H. Woodard against the Holland Medicine Company, J. W. Stanton, and others to charge the stockholders of defendant company with personal liability for a judgment recovered against the company. Code Civil Proc. H. Y. 524, provides that “the allegations or denials in a verified .pleading must, in form, be stated to be made by the party pleading.
- 15 N.Y.S. 135Stroub v. Manhattan Railway Co. (1891)
Action by John L. Stroub against the Manhattan Railway Company to restrain defendant from constructing an additional track in front of plaintiff’s premises. Plaintiff moves to continue preliminary injunction. The motion was granted, and defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 136Shanley v. Stanley (1891)
■ Appeal from jury term. Action by Michael Shanley against John Stanley. From judgment in favor of plaintiff entered on the verdict of a jury, and from an order denying a motion for a new trial, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 137Jackson Architectural Iron-Works v. Rouss (1891)
<p>Principal and Agent—Ratification—Change of Architect’s Plans.</p> <p>Where the owner of a building, during the progress of its erection, ratified the acts of his architect in departing from the plans and specifications in as many as 17 instances, the owner was properly held bound to the contractor for a further alteration made by the architect necessitating the insertion of a stairway, at an expense of 84,138, not included in the original plan, but which the owner received the benefit of.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 138Parsons v. Robinson (1891)
<p>1. Contracts—Consideration—Sbeeioienoy.</p> <p>Plaintiff gave defendant certain reliable information as to facts on which the future price of stocks would depend, under an agreement between them that defendant should advance the money and buy stocks, and share the profit with plaintiff, whenever he should furnish such information. Meld, that such information was a sufficient consideration for defendant’s promise.</p> <p>3. Same—Past Consideration.</p> <p>After furnishing such information, and after purchase made, plaintiff asked,“What will my interest be,—200 shares, as before?” to which defendant reuliedj “All right. ” Meld, that defendant could not object that such promise was'made on a past consideration, he having assented thereto, and received the benefit thereof.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 139City Savings Bank v. Stevens (1891)
- 15 N.Y.S. 140Miller v. Curtiss (1891)
Exceptions from jury term. Action by W. H. Haydn Miller against William. H. Curtiss. There was a verdict for plaintiff, and defendant’s exceptions were ordered to be heard at general term in the first instance. For former report, see 13 27. Y. Supp. 604.
- 15 N.Y.S. 141Mertage v. Bennett (1891)
Appeal'from special term. Action by James S. Mertage against Sydney A. Bennett.
- 15 N.Y.S. 142Heath v. Broadway & Seventh Avenue Railroad (1891)
Action by Mary Heath against the Broadway & Seventh Avenue Railroad Company. From a judgment for plaintiff entered on a verdict of a jury, and from an order denying a motion for a new trial made on the judge’s minutes, •defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 143Duffy v. Work (1891)
Action by Felix A. Duffy against James H. Work and others for the conversion of a deed.
- 15 N.Y.S. 144In re Christian Jensen Co. (1891)
- 15 N.Y.S. 146Shambow v. New York, New Haven & Hartford Railroad (1891)
Action by George T. Shambow against the Hew York, Hew Haven & Hartford Railroad Company. From a judgment entered in favor of plaintiff on the verdict of a jury, and from an order denying defendant’s motion on the judge’s minutes for a new trial, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 146Latham v. Delany (1891)
Action by Paul W. Latham against Patrick B. Delany. From a judgment entered in favor of plaintiff on the verdict of a jury, and from an order denying a motion for a new trial, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 147Gair v. Birmingham (1891)
<p>Action by Gerald Gair against Birmingham & Co. to recover for services ■rendered by plaintiff to defendants. Defendants move to strike the cause from the calendar, and plaintiff moves that his notice of trial and note of issue be amended nunc pro tune.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 148Burke v. New York, New Haven & Hartford Railroad (1891)
- 15 N.Y.S. 149Renwick v. New York Elevated Railroad (1891)
<p>Elevated Railroad—Injunction—Past Damages.</p> <p>In an action against an elevated railroad company for injunctive relief, and also for the recovery of past damages, the fact that defendant had procured a condemnation of plaintiff’s easement, and paid his prospective damages thereon awarded, was no defense, since plaintiff had a right to recover his past damages in such action, which defendant could not defeat by proof of partial satisfaction of plaintiff’s claim pending the action.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 150Moore v. Prentiss Tool & Supply Co. (1891)
Action by Frederic G-. Moore against the Prentiss Tool & Supply Company. From a judgment entered on the verdict of a jury, and from an order denying a motion for a new trial, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 155Berls v. Metropolitan Elevated Railroad (1891)
At chambers. Action by Robert Berls against the Metropolitan Elevated Railroad Company and another. Plaintiff moves to vacate the report of the referees to whom the cause was referred.
- 15 N.Y.S. 156King v. Todd (1891)
<p>Executors and Administrators—Costs—Presentment oe Claim.</p> <p>Under Code Civil Proc. N. Y. § 1836, which provides” that costs shall not be awarded against an executor or administrator, unless plaintiff’s demand was presented within the time limited by the notice to creditors, the claim must be presented in writing.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 158People ex rel. Nash v. Edwards (1891)
- 15 N.Y.S. 158Bradley Salt Co. v. Keating (1891)
- 15 N.Y.S. 159Wannamaker v. City of Rochester (1891)
- 15 N.Y.S. 159Shaw v. Broadbent (1891)
- 15 N.Y.S. 160Niagara Falls Hydraulic Power Co. v. Quigley (1891)
- 15 N.Y.S. 160People v. Featherly (1891)
- 15 N.Y.S. 160Wilcox v. Van Voorhis (1891)
- 15 N.Y.S. 160Woodworth v. Hodgson (1891)
- 15 N.Y.S. 160Schoellkopf v. Gluck (1891)
- 15 N.Y.S. 160Siefert v. Caverly (1891)
- 15 N.Y.S. 160Burlingame v. Shelmire (1891)
- 15 N.Y.S. 160Danihe v. Hyatt (1891)
- 15 N.Y.S. 160Kavanagh v. Barber (1891)
- 15 N.Y.S. 161French v. Brush-Swan Electric Light Co. (1891)
<p>Appeal from circuit court, New York county.</p> <p>Action by Lyman P. French against the Brush-Swan Electric Light Company. From a judgment for defendant, plaintiff appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 162Hilsenbeck v. Guhring (1891)
<p>Negligence—Dangerous Premises—Instructions.</p> <p>Defendant, the owner of premises, occupying the first floor himsel f, and renting the rooms above to tenants, allowed a dark hallway, in which-there were three adjacent doors,—one opening into defendant’s saloon; one opening on a flight of stairs; and the other, next and close to the last, opening into a water-closet used by all the occupants of the premises,—to remain unlighted. Defendant allowed the door opening on the stairs to remain unlocked on one occasion, and a visitor of one of his tenants, resorting to the water-closet, opened the stair-door by mistake for that of the closet, and fell down the stairs, sustaining serious injuries. Held, in an action to recover damages therefor, that the court properly refused defendant’s request to charge that leaving the stair-door unlocked was not negligence on his part.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 163Corrigan v. Ritter (1891)
<p>",1. Set-Off and Counter Claim—Independent Cause of‘Action.</p> <p>After the answer had been served in an action for breach of a contract by which defendant agreed to put two boilers on plaintiff’s steam-boat, the parties entered into a new contract, by which defendant was to take out the boilers which had been put in under the first contract, and was to put in new boilers, and, on the performance of this according to the terms of the new contract, the action was to be discontinued. Meld, that a claim for labor performed and materials furnished by defendant, at plaintiff’s request, for repairs to the steam-boat, in addition to those required under the new contract, was not “a cause of action arising out of the contract or transaction set forth in the complaint as the foundation of the plaintiff’s claim, or connected with the subject of the action, ” so as to constitute a counter-claim, under Code Civil Proc. N. Y. § SOI, subd. 1, but was a cause of action on another contract, within section 501, subd. 2, and, as it did not exist “at the commencement of the action, ” it could not be set up as a counter-claim by supplemental answer.</p> <p>■2. Same—Transaction Alleged in Complaint.</p> <p>Defendant’s claim that the second contract had been fully performed, whereby plaintiff’s cause of action was extinguished, arises “ out of the contract or transaction set forth in the complaint,’’(Code Civil Proc. N. Y. §501, subd. 1,) and maybe setup as a counter-claim by a supplemental answer.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 165Matthews v. Herdtfelder (1891)
<p>Appeal from circuit court, New York county.</p> <p>Action by Patrick Matthews against Jacob P. Herdtfelder and Francis P. Specht to recover damages for a personal injury alleged to have been sustained by plaintiff by reason of a collision of a truck owned by defendants, and driven by their employe, with the plaintiffs cart, thereby throwing him down and injuring him. Plaintiff offered evidence at the trial that one of the defendants had come to him at the instance of the other, conceded their driver’s fault, and desired plaintiff to accept a moderate sum in settlement of the claim, which evidence the court excluded. From an order granting plaintiff a new trial defendants appeal.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 166Mott v. Oppenheimer (1891)
<p>Party-Walls—Liability or Grantee.</p> <p>In an action to recover the expense of building one-half of a party-wall, it appeared that certain of defendants’ predecessors in title had conveyed" the lot subject to a party-wall agreement, but that the first grantor, and also defendants’ immediate grantor, had conveyed the lot without referring to the agreement. Held, that such facts were immaterial with respect to defendants’ liability; they having taken the property under immediate conveyances subjecting the lot to the party-wall agreement.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 168Sullivan v. Mayor of New York (1891)
Exceptions from circuit court, New York county. Action by John Sullivan against the mayor, aldermen, and commonalty of the city of New York. Defendant moves for a new trial on exceptions ordered to be heard in the first instance at general term.
- 15 N.Y.S. 169Robinson v. Wood (1891)
<p>Appeal from special term.</p> <p>Action by Thomas J. Bobinson against Arthur-E. Wood. Erom a judgment for plaintiff, defendant appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 171Tregoning v. Tregoning (1891)
<p>Appeal from special term, New York county.</p> <p>Action by Stephen P. Tregoning against Richard F. Tregoning, Margaretta Tregoning, Jennie Tregoning, Mary Agnes Rush, Mary Agnes McNevin, Margaretta McNevin, William McNevin, John C. Devine, Annie Devine; his wife, Michael J. Devine, William Wallberg, William Hoey, Charles Gray, John Elliott, Mary McKenna, John Muller, and William Connelly. From an ■ interlocutory judgment entered on an order overruling demurrer to the complaint, defendants appeal.</p> <p>Mr. Justice Lawrence delivered the following opinion at special term: “This is an action for the partition of land in the city of New York, and the complaint discloses the following facts: In 1858, one Patrick Devine, being the owner of the premises in question, conveyed the same to one David Stevenson, who, with his wife, reconveyed the same premises to Margaret Devine, wife of said Patrick Devine, for use during her natural life, and the said deed provided: ‘ And, after the decease of the said Margaret Devine, then the said house and lot shall belong and go to the children of said Patrick and Margaret Devine in equal shares, and the said parties of the first part hereby grant and convey said premises in fee to said children of Patrick and Margaret Devine, subject to the life-estate of said Margaret Devine, as above stated.’ Margaret Devine, the grantee in said conveyance named, died in 1890. At the date of the conveyance by Stevenson and wife to her, there were five children living, but at the time of her death three of them had died, leaving John C. Devine and Michael J. Devine, defendants in this action, her only surviving children. The children of Patrick and Margaret Devine, who died before the latter, all left issue. The plaintiff, and the children and heirs at law of the deceased children of Patrick and Margaret Devine, who are defendants herein, claim to hold the premises described in the complaint as tenants in common with John C. and Michael J. Devine. Demurrers to the complaint have been interposed by John 0. and Michael J. Devine, on the ground that no cause of action is stated therein. These demurrers are not, I think, well taken. A bare inspection of the deed will show that it was the intention of the grantors that the children of Patrick and Margaret Devine living at the time of its execution should have a remainder in fee, which vested immediately, subject to the life-estate of their mother. The conveyance is to Margaret Devine during her natural life; * * * * and, after the decease of the said Margaret Devine, then the said house and lot shall belong and go to the children of the said Patrick and Margaret Devine in .equal shares, and the said parties of the first part hereby grant and convey said premises in fee to said children of Patrick and Margaret Devine, subject to the life-estate of said Margaret Devine, as above stated.’ Language could not more clearly express the intention of the grantors to vest the fee in the children of Patrick and Margaret Devine. The case differs most essentially from Moore v. Littel, 41 N. Y. 66, the phraseology there used being to the grantee for life, ‘ and, after his decease, to his heirs and assigns forever.’ Here the conveyance vests the fee absolutely in the children, subject to the life-estate, and bv the provisions of the Revised Statutes there is a vested future estate, if, at the time of the creation of the estate, there is a person-in being who would have an immediate right to the possession of the lands upon the ceasing of the intermediate or precedent estate. 4 Rev. St. (8th Ed.) p. 2432, § 13. This estate is descendible, devisable, and alienable in the same manner as estates in possession. Id. p. 2434, § 35. I agree with the counsel for the plaintiff that the children of the deceased children of Patrick and Margaret Devine take, not as the grandchildren of the latter, but as the heirs of their respective parents, whose estates descended to them under the aforesaid statutory provision. I am therefore of the opinion that the plaintiff is entitled to judgment overruling the demurrers, with leave to the defendants to answer over on payment of costs.”</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 173Keiley v. Mechanics' & Traders' Bank (1891)
<p>Corporations—Insolvency—Transfer of Property.</p> <p>A manufacturing company which gives a bill of sale of all its machinery and other property to a creditor, who immediately takes possession of the same, makes a transfer of its property in contemplation of insolvency, since the bill of sale deprives it of the means to continue its business, and it is void as to other creditors, under 1 Rev. St. N. Y. p. 603, § 4.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 175Shepard v. New York Elevated Railroad (1891)
Action by Augustus D. Shepard against the Hew York Elevated Bailroad ■Company and the Manhattan Bail way Company for damages and for an injunction. From a judgment for plaintiff, which enjoined and restrained defendants from the further maintenance or operation of their elevated railroad in front of the premises Ho.
- 15 N.Y.S. 176Connelly v. Manhattan Railway Co. (1891)
Action by Arthur J. Connelly against the Manhattan Railway Company. From a judgment entered on a verdict for plaintiff, and from an order denying a motion for a new trial, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 181Sanford v. Fourth National Bank (1891)
<p>Action—Election of Remedies.</p> <p>Plaintiff alleged that one S. stole from her certain stock certificates, and pledged the same to defendants F. & K. to secure a loan, and that S. deposited in defendant bank the money so loaned to him by F. & K. The prayer of the complaint was that plaintiff recover from F. & K. the shares of stock, or their value; or if plaintiff is not entitled to recover from F. & K., then that the bank be required to pay over the amouni so deposited with it. Held, that the complaint did not state a cause of action against the bank, as the statement of the cause of action against F. & K. was an election of plaintiff’s right to pursue the stolen property, and she could not at the same time ratify the title of F. & K. thereto and sue for the proceeds.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 183Alkus v. Goettmann (1891)
Case submitted on agreed statement. Controversy between Isidor Alkus and Albert Goettmann, as executor of and trustee under the will of Henry Schreiber, deceased. The questions arising were submitted without'action.
- 15 N.Y.S. 185Sanguinnetti v. Roche (1891)
<p>Appeal from circuit court, New York county.</p> <p>Action by Herbert Sanguinnetti against Frances Boche. From a judgment for plaintiff, defendant appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 187Kuebler v. Mayor of New York (1891)
Exceptions from circuit court, Hew York county. Action by Christian ICuebler against the mayor, aldermen, and commonalty of the city of Hew York. The complaint was dismissed, at the close of plain tiff’s case, and his exceptions thereto were ordered to be heard in the first instance at general term.
- 15 N.Y.S. 188Cootey v. Chapman (1891)
<p>Pbincipal and Agent—Existence ov Agency—Evidence.</p> <p>Plaintiff’s husband managed an estate for its owner for more than 10 years. After the death of the owner, plaintiff preferred a claim against the estate for her husband’s services, alleging that he had acted as her agent in rendering the same. There was no evidence that plaintiff had ever employed her husband as agent for the management of the estate, or had any authority to do so, and there was a large number of unsatisfied judgments against the husband from which his motive in having the claim preferred in plaintiff’s name appeared. Held, that no agency for plaintiff was established, and that she was not entitled to recover.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 189Pollock v. Brooklyn & Cross-Town Railroad (1891)
Action by Rachael Pollock against the Brooklyn & Cross-Town Railroad Company for personal injuries. Prom a judgment for $1,096 entered on a verdict recovered by plaintiff, and from an order denying a motion for a new trial, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 191Livingston v. New York Elevated Railroad (1891)
Action by Caroline Livingston against the Hew York Elevated Railroad Company and the Manhattan Railway Company. From an order setting aside an execution issued on a judgment theretofore rendered in favor of plaintiff, plaintiff appeals. For former report, see 26 H. E. Rep. 751, 11 H. Y. Supp. 359.
- 15 N.Y.S. 193Babcock v. Schuylkill & Lehigh Valley Railroad (1891)
<p>Corporations—Stockholders—Consolidation.</p> <p>Plaintiff subscribed for certain shares of stock of theP. Ry. Go., and paid 10 per cent, of his subscription. Thereafter the P. Ry. Co. was consolidated with defendant, under an agreement by which the stockholders of the P. Ry. Co. were to receive consolidated in place of their original stock. Held, that plaintiff was not entitled to demand full-paid certificates of stock from defendant on account of his subscription to the P. Ry. Co. stock, without producing or showing that he was entitled to full-paid certificates from the P. Ry. Co., to be exchanged for defendant’s stock.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 196Dovale v. Ackermann (1891)
<p>Estoppel—Admissions.</p> <p>Plaintiff, having advanced money to a.firm of which defendant was formerly a partner, asserted a claim against defendant on the ground of such partnership. Defendant denied the liability, but promised to repay to plaintiff in monthly payments of $100 each the amount so loaned by her, and he made several payments under the agreement. Afterwards he refused to make further payments unless plaintiff would sign a paper admitting that defendant was under no legal obligation to pay her such amount, and that the promise.to pay on his part was purely voluntary. The writing also contained a promise by plaintiff that she would assert no claim against defendant. After the writing was signed, defendant continued to pay the S100 per month. Held, that plaintiff was estopped by such writing after-wards to assert a claim against defendant.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 198Romaine v. Chauncey (1891)
Action by Isaac Romaine, as receiver of the property, etc., of Maria L.. Ghauncey, against Michael Ghauncey and Maria L. Ghauncey. From an interlocutory judgment overruling the demurrers of defendants to the amended' complaint, and directing final judgment for plaintiff as demanded in the complaint unless the defendants answer within 20 days, etc., defendants appeal.
- 15 N.Y.S. 200Pease v. Eagan (1891)
<p>Appeal from special term, New York county.</p> <p>Action by Charles G. Pease, executor of Clara E. Pease, deceased, against Clara M. Eagan, executrix of John Eagan, deceased. From a judgment for defendant, plaintiff appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 202Glenn v. Garth (1891)
Exceptions from circuit court, Hew York county. Action by John Glenn, as trustee of and for the benefit of the creditors of the national Express & Transportation Company, against Samuel J. Harrison, David J. Garth, Wellington Goddin, James L. Apperson, Robert A. Lancaster, and Lewis Ginter, formerly partners under the firm name of Harrison, Garth & Co. A verdict was directed for plaintiff, and defendants’ exceptions were ordered to be heard at general term in the first…
- 15 N.Y.S. 206McQuillen v. Real-Estate Exchange & Auction Room, Ltd. (1891)
<p>Real-Estate Exchange—“Stands” not Assignable.</p> <p>A “stand” in the auction room of the Real-Estate Exchange & Auction Room, Limited, of 69 Liberty street, N. Y., cannot be sold or assigned by a member of the exchange who has sold his stock, even to another member; the .right to the stand being strictly personal, under rule 8 of the exchange, which provides that “no auctioneer shall be disturbed in the occupancy of the stand "* * * for the term of five years, provided he pays such annual rent as may be charged therefor, and remains a member of the exchange and an auctioneer. ”</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 208Manufacturers' National Bank v. Hall (1891)
Action by the Manufacturers’ Hational Bank against Dudley Hall and another. From a judgment for plaintiff, defendants appeal. Code Civil Proc. H. Y. § 636, provides: “If the action is to recover damages for a breach of a contract, the affidavit must show that the plaintiff is entitled to recover a sum stated therein over and above all counter-claims known to him.”
- 15 N.Y.S. 210Oliver v. Moore (1891)
Action by Margaret A. Oliver against William L. Moore, administrator with the will annexed of Harriet Gross, deceased. There was a judgment for plaintiff, and defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 211In re Home Provident Safety Fund Ass'n (1891)
Proceedings for the voluntary dissolution of the Home Provident Safety Fund Association of Hew York. On the 7th of May, 1884, the Home Provident Fund Association executed an instrument by which it agreed with its certificate holders to create a safety and a tontine pension fund, and constituted the Farmers’ Loan & Trust Company the trustee thereof.
- 15 N.Y.S. 212In re Blair's Will (1891)
<p>Temporary Administrator—Power op Surrogate—Transfer to Common Pleas.</p> <p>Where proceedings for the probate of a will have been transferred by the surrogate of New York county to the court of common pleas under Code Civil Proc. N. Y. § 2547, which authorizes such transfer for the purpose of trying by jury issues of fact arising therein, the surrogate’s court,' while the proceeding is pending in the common pleas, is not deprived of the power to appoint a temporary administrator in order to preserve the estate, (section 2668;) the power of the common pleas in such case being restricted to the trial of the issues of fact involved and to certain appellate proceedings.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 215Robbins v. Robbins (1891)
<p>1. Malicious Prosecution—Probable Cause—Evidence.</p> <p>In an action for malicious prosecution, the defense was that the prosecution was dismissed on the promise of the party prosecuted to refrain from molesting the prosecutor in the future. The magistrate was unable to testify positively as to the circumstances under which the warrant was dismissed, but thought, from certain canceled indorsements thereon, that bail had been first required, but that the party prosecuted had been afterwards discharged on her promise not to further molest the prosecutor. Held, that the uncertainty of the magistrate’s testimony justified a submission to the jury of the question whether or not the dismissal was absolute, or as an act of clemency on the part of the magistrate. Barrett, J., dissenting.</p> <p>2. Same—Question for Jury.</p> <p>Where there are no disputed facts, the question of probable cause is one of law, otherwise, the question of its existence is to be submitted to the decision of the jury.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 217Pineiro v. Gurney (1891)
<p>Appeal from circuit court, Hew York county.</p> <p>Action by Modesto Pineiro against Bichard Gurney. From a judgment for plaintiff, defendant appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 219People ex rel. Westlotorn v. MacLean (1891)
Certiorari by Albert E. Westlotorn to review a decision of Charles E. MacLean and others, police commissioners, dismissing relator from the police force.
- 15 N.Y.S. 219Arkush v. Hanan (1891)
<p>Appeal from circuit court, New York county.</p> <p>Action by Samuel I. Arkush against James Hanan and another. .From an. order denying their motion for a new trial, and from an order directing that certain amendments, (which were disallowed,) together with an explanatory memorandum, and certain affidavits used in connection therewith, to be filed, added to the case, and printed with it, defendants appeal.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 221People ex rel. Costello v. McClave (1891)
Certiorari by James A. Costello to review a decision of John McClave and others, police commissioners, dismissing relator from the police force.
- 15 N.Y.S. 222Suarez v. Manhattan Railway Co. (1891)
Action by Peter Santos Suarez against the Manhattan Railway Company -and the Metropolitan Elevated Railway Company, to restrain the maintenance ■of an elevated railroad in front of plaintiff’s premises, and for damages.
- 15 N.Y.S. 224Metropolitan Elevated Railway Co. v. Siefke (1891)
Proceeding by the Metropolitan Elevated Railway Company for the purpose of acquiring title to so much of the easements of light, air, and access appurtenant to a lot of land of one Henry Siefke on the south-east corner of Sixth avenue and West Third street, as has been taken or interfered with by the construction, maintenance, and operation of petitioner’s elevated railway.
- 15 N.Y.S. 224Suarez v. Manhattan Railway Co. (1891)
<p>Eminent Domain—Outstanding Lease—Rights of Reversioner.</p> <p>Where an elevated railroad has been built in a street without making compensation to the abutting owners for the easements of light, air, and access, the right of an owner to enjoin the operation of the road is not affected by the fact that his premises are subject to an outstanding lease. Maeyv. Railway Co., 12 N. Y. Supp. 804, followed.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 225People v. New York City Central Under-Ground Railway Co. (1891)
Action by the people of the state of New York against the New York City Central Under-Ground Bailway Company and another. From an order denying a motion to strike out the complaint, defendant named appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 226People v. Wallach (1891)
Sampson Wallatih was indicted for knowingly permitting premises owned by him to be occupied as a house of ill fame, and from a judgment of the general sessions affirming a judgment of conviction by the special sessions defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 227In re Adler's Estate (1891)
Application by Caroline Schwab, as executrix, etc., of the will of Solomon Adler, deceased, from an order denying her application for an order requiring her co-executors, I. Richard Adler and Leon N. Adler, to show cause why the surrogate should not give direction respecting the custody of money or other property belonging to the estate, and for other relief. The application was denied, and petitioner appeals. Code Civil Proc.
- 15 N.Y.S. 229People v. Block (1891)
<p>1. Bubglaby—Evidence—;Pboof of Breaking.</p> <p>On an indictment for burglary, evidence that the door of the place alleged to have been entered was provided with a staple and a padlock, and that, when complainant came to the place after the alleged burglary, the staple was broken, was sufficient evidence that the door had been fastened.</p> <p>2. Labceny—Evidence—Possession of Goods.</p> <p>The unexplained possession by defendant of the box and wrapper in which stolen goods had been packed is evidence connecting defendant with the larceny, equalin probative force to possession of the stolen goods.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 230People v. McGuinness (1891)
Thomas McGuinness was indicted for rape alleged to have been committed on the person of. one Mary McGill, and from a judgment of conviction he appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 232Kingsland v. Mayor of New York (1891)
Action by William M. Kingsland, as sole surviving trustee under the last will and testament of Daniel C. Kingsland, deceased, against the mayor, aldermen, and commonalty of the city of New York, the department of docks of the city of New York, and John R. Voorhis, Lucius J. N. Stark, and William Laimbeer, composing the board of the department of docks of the city of New York. There was a judgment for plaintiff, and defendants appeal.
- 15 N.Y.S. 235Farmer v. Manhattan Savings Institution (1891)
Action by Ann Farmer, administratrix of Henry Fitzsimmons, deceased, against the Manhattan Savings Institution. There was a verdict and judgment for defendant, and plaintiff’s motion fora new trial on the case and exceptions was ordered to be heard in the first instance at general term.
- 15 N.Y.S. 237Ginsburg v. Kuntz (1891)
Action by Bernard Ginsburg against Lena Kuntz and others. The complaint was dismissed at the trial before a judge without a jury, and plaintiff appeals. Code Civil Proc.
- 15 N.Y.S. 239In re Johnston's Estate (1891)
Judicial settlement of the account of William T. A. Hart and David B. Johnston, administrators, etc., of Archibald Johnston, deceased. From a decree of the surrogate’s court confirming the report of the referee settling the accounts, Hugh Langan and Andrew Langan, composing the firm of Langan Bros., appeal.
- 15 N.Y.S. 240In re Green's Estate (1891)
Judicial settlement of the account of George Green', as executor of the last, will and testament of John Green, deceased. The surrogate sustained the exception that the infants, George H. Green and Leroy 1).
- 15 N.Y.S. 242People ex rel. Uhrie v. Gilroy (1891)
Application by George Uhrie for mandamus to Thomas Gilroy, as commissioner of public works of the city of New York, to compel the reinstatement •of relator in the employ of the department of public work from which he alleged that he had been discharged.
- 15 N.Y.S. 244People ex rel. Gardner v. McClave (1891)
Certiorari by Joseph A. Gardner to review a decision of John McClave and others, police commissioners, dismissing relator from the police force.
- 15 N.Y.S. 245People v. New York City Central Under-Ground Railway Co. (1891)
Action by the people of the state of Hew York against the Hew York City-Central Under-Ground Railway Company and the Hew York Under-Ground-Railway Company. From an order denying a motion to strike out certain-parts of the complaint, and that certain parts thereof be made more definite and certain, defendant Hew York Under-Ground Railway Company appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 249Prince Manufacturing Co. v. Prince's Metallic Paint Co. (1891)
<p>Appeal from special term, Hew York county.</p> <p>Action by the Prince Manufacturing Company against Prince’s Metallic Paint Company. The. complaint was dismissed, and, plaintiff appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 255Langdon v. New York, Lake Erie & Western Railway Co. (1891)
Action by Andrew Langdon and others against the Hew York, Lake Erie .& Western Bailway Company to recover damages for discriminating against plaintiffs as shippers of merchandise over defendant’s railroad. A motion to make the complaint more definite and certain, and to state separately several alleged causes of action, was denied, and defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 256Parker v. Knox (1891)
Action by Miles Parker against Orville M. Knox. The complaint alleges that on the 26th day of June, 1889, plaintiff was the owner of a quantity of hops, and that the defendant, “for the purpose of obtaining control of the same for speculative purposes, falsely and fraudulently represented and stated to the plaintiff that lie (the defendant) was duly authorized by one George W. Elkins, who was well known to the plaintiff to be a reputable and solvent hop-dealer, to buy the…
- 15 N.Y.S. 261Van Allen v. Glass (1891)
Action by Hattie E. Van Allen against James H. Glass and another, commenced in May, 1890, by a personal service upon both defendants in Oneida county. The defendants answered separately, and the date of the issue is July 30, 1890. The venue of the action was laid in Schuyler county.
- 15 N.Y.S. 263Olcott v. Powers (1891)
Action by Frederick P. Olcott and others against Deborah Powers and others. There was a judgment for defendants, and plaintiffs appeal.
- 15 N.Y.S. 270People v. Seaton (1891)
<p>Appeal from court of general sessions, New York county.</p> <p>Charles Seaton was indicted for receiving stolen goods, and from a judgment of conviction he appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 273Bandell v. May (1891)
<p>Malicious Prosecution—Want of Probable Cause.</p> <p>In an action for malicious prosecution, it appeared that plaintiff ordered from defendant 500 cases of goods, to be delivered in lots of 250 cases each; payment to be made before shipment. The first lot was paid for and delivered. Afterwards plaintiff ordered the remaining 250 cases, and sent his check to defendant for the price thereof. Defendant shipped only 200 of the cases, whereupon plaintiff stopped payment of his check. Defendant then caused plaintiff to come to his (defendant’s) place of business, and while there defendant procured plaintiff’s arrest on a charge of grand larceny for stealing the price of the second shipment of goods. Held, that there was no probable cause for plaintiff’s arrest.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 274Gilmore v. City of Utica (1891)
Action by Hiram Gilmore against the city of Utica and others to vacate a street assessment. Plaintiff was a tax-payer in the city of Utica, and the owner of property fronting on Genesee street, which street was repaved by the defendant the Warren-Scharf Asphalt Paving Company, in pursuance of a contract awarded to it by the common council.
- 15 N.Y.S. 278Lovelace v. Doran (1891)
<p>Corporations—Personal Liability or Directors—Complaint.</p> <p>The complaint alleged that defendants were directors of a certain compan y which, had made a certain promissory note therein set out; that the note remained a valid obligation, and unpaid; that at the time of making the note the company’s indebtedness exceeded its capital stock about $150,000; and that such indebtedness was created by and with defendants’ consent. Held, that the complaint sufficiently stated a cause of action under Laws N. Y. 1875, c. 611, § 22, which provides that, if the indebtedness of any such corporation shall at any time exceed the amount of its capital stock, the directors of the corporation creating the indebtedness shall be personally and individually liable for the excess to the creditors of the corporation.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 279Lovelace v. Doran & Wright Co. (1891)
Action by Frederick L. Lovelace against the Doran & Wright Company, Limited, and S. Gregor Doran and others.
- 15 N.Y.S. 281Storm v. Phenix Insurance (1891)
Action by John Storm and Charles Pierce against the Phenix Insurance Company of Brooklyn.
- 15 N.Y.S. 285Duford v. Patrick (1891)
Action by Francis Duford and Francis A. Duford against William Patrick. From a judgment entered on the verdict of a jury, and from an order denying .a motion for a new trial, defendant appeals;
- 15 N.Y.S. 288Eysaman v. Small (1891)
Action for waste by Adam H. Eysaman, as guardian of Lulu Eysaman, an infant, against Mary Small. On the 25th day of June, 1887, John Small died at his residence in German Flatts, seised in fee of the premises described in the complaint, leaving the defendant, his widow, him surviving, and an adopted daughter, the wife of Adam H. Eysaman, the said Adam and the said wife being the parents of the said Lulu Eysaman.
- 15 N.Y.S. 291In re Sanford (1891)
Proceedings instituted by Harmon D. Sanford and others for the appointunent of a committee of the person and property of one Jane Sanford, an alleged lunatic. Epenetus Howe and 23 others, as jurors on the inquisition of insanity, moved for an order requiring petitioners to pay their legal fees for •services as such jurors, and one Frank J. Norton asked that he be allowed $10 •for the use of the room in which the inquisition was held.
- 15 N.Y.S. 293W. D. Wilson Printing-Ink Co. v. Bowker (1891)
Action by W. D. Wilson Printing-Ink Company, Limited, against Bichard B. Bowker, on a note of which plaintiff was payee and “Hoffman Press” maker.
- 15 N.Y.S. 295Ferris v. Tannebaum (1891)
Action by Francis J. 0. Ferris against Adolph Tannebaum and Alexander Samuels upon an undertaking on arrest given pursuant to section 559, Code Civil Proc. Answer, that the defendants had duly appealed to the court of appeals from the order vacating the order of arrest, and that so the action was premature.
- 15 N.Y.S. 297Mayor of New York v. Dry-Dock, East Broadway & Battery Railroad (1891)
Action by the mayor, aldermen, and commonalty of the city of New York against the Dry-Dock, Bast Broadway & Battery Railroad Company. There was a judgment for plaintiffs, and defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 300Nesbit v. Bendheim (1891)
<p>1. Building Contract—Action by Material-Man—Evidence.</p> <p>In an action on an order drawn in plaintiff’s favor by a building contractor on defendant, who was advancing money for the building, and accepted by him, “ payable when the tenth payment is payable under building loan agreement, ” plaintiff testified that defendant told him that such “tenth payment” was due, but refused to pay the order, on account of the contractor’s objections to plaintiff’s account for materials furnished, unless plaintiff would get another order. This the defendant denied, alleging the contractor’s abandoment of his contract before earning the tenth payment. There was testimony that plaintiff had been told by defendant that the “tenth payment” would be due “when the doors and sashes were hung, ” and it was after this hanging that plaintiff demanded payment of the order. Held, that the evidence was sufficient to justify a finding by the jury that such “tenth payment” was due when plaintiff’s order was presented for payment.</p> <p>2. Same—Evidence.</p> <p>In such case, plaintiff having testified that he had never made certain representations to defendant respecting the price of material furnished the contractor, testified to by defendant, it was proper to submit the question to the jury whether such representations were in fact made, though there was some contradiction in plaintiff’s testimony with respect thereto.</p> <p>8. Submission to Jury—Evidence.</p> <p>Defendant denied that he had directed plaintiff to get a new order from the contractor, but, having admitted that he told plaintiff about the contractor’s claim for over charges, and that the second order in question was brought to him the next day, and plaintiff having testified that defendant, on presentment of the second order, had promised him a check for it next day, the question of defendant’s having promised to pay if plaintiff should produce a second order was properly submitted to the jury, and a finding by them in the affirmative justified by the evidence.</p> <p>4. New Promise—Consideration.</p> <p>In such case the procurement by plaintiff at defendant’s request of a withdrawal by the contractor of his objections to plaintiff’s account, was a sufficient consideration for defendant’s new promise.</p> <p>8. Same—Pleading.</p> <p>It was immaterial that such new promise was not pleaded, the cause of action being upon the original contract; the new promise being merely additional thereto.</p> <p>6. Same—Competency op Evidence.</p> <p>Plaintiff was properly allowed to testify with respect to defendant’s claim that the contractor’s work was unfinished, and that defendant did not point out to him any deficiency of work that he required to he done by the contractor before payment of the order.</p> <p>7. Same—Best Evidence.</p> <p>It was proper, in such case, to exclude the testimony of a witness that the inspector ot buildings had condemned one of the contractor’s walls, the inspector’s judgment condemning the wall being the best evidence of that fact.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 305People ex rel. Lester v. Mitchell (1891)
Application by George H. Lester for a writ of mandamus against Edward Mitchell, as mayor of the city of Oswego, and John Dowdle, commanding the mayor to appoint relator to the office of city chamberlain of that city, or show cause to the contrary. From an order granting an alternative, but denying a peremptory, writ of mandamus, defendants appeal.
- 15 N.Y.S. 306Salt Springs National Bank v. Sloan (1891)
Action by the Salt Springs National Bank of Syracuse against George B. Sloan. At the close of the plaintiff’s evidence the defendant moved for a non-suit upon the following grounds: “First.
- 15 N.Y.S. 308People ex rel. Steinson v. Board of Education (1891)
Application by George Steinson for mandamus to the board of education of New York city to pay a sum of money alleged to be due relator for salary as a teacher. The writ was denied, and relator appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 309Martin v. Manufacturers' Accident Indemnity Co. (1891)
Action by Eliza A. Martin against the Manufacturers’ Accident Indemnity Company.
- 15 N.Y.S. 314Griswold v. Burroughs (1891)
Replevin by John W. Griswold and Frank B. Griswold against Leander W. Burroughs, John Stimson, and others. Frederick W. Lipe, who is named as a defendant in the summons and proceedings, was not served with the summons. The defendants Burroughs and Stimson appeared and joined issue before the justice. The issues were tried before a jury, and the return of the justice is to the effect, viz.: “Jury retire, and return a verdict for plaintiffs for possession of property.
- 15 N.Y.S. 316Gilbert v. Shortsville Cart Co. (1891)
Action by George 8. Gilbert against the Shortsville Cart Company for the alleged conversion of tools used by plaintiff as a mechanic. From an order denying a motion to change the place of trial from Cortland county to Ontario county, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 317Quinlan v. Providence Washington Insurance (1891)
<p>Insurance—Conditions of Folioy^-Notice and Proofs of Fire.</p> <p>A provision of a fire insurance policy that, if a fire occurred, the insured should give immediate notice in writing to the company of any loss thereby, and within 60 days after the fire furnish to the company verified proofs of a loss, is a condition precedent, and no recovery can be had on such policy where notice of loss was not given until 33 days after the fire, and proofs of loss were not given until nearly 7 months after the fire.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 317Reuben v. Andorsky (1891)
Action by Robert Reuben against Joseph Andorsky. From an order denying a motion to change the place of trial from Chemung county to Monroe county on the ground of convenience of witnesses defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 318Alleman v. Bowen (1891)
Action by Charles Alleman against Ralph S. Bowen and another, as indorser and maker, respectively, of a promissory note. From a judgment entered on a verdict directed for plaintiff, defendant Bowen appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 320In re Williams' Estate (1891)
Williams and another as executors of the will qf Abijah Williams, deceased.
- 15 N.Y.S. 321Syracuse Moulding Co. v. Squires (1891)
Action by the Syracuse Moulding Company against Fred. D. Squires. A judgment for plaintiff was affirmed by the county court on appeal from a justice of the peace, and defendant again appeals. Code Civil Proc. N. Y. § 526, is as follows: “The affidavit of verification must be to the effect that the pleading is true to the knowledge of the deponent, except as the matters therein stated to be alleged on information and belief, and that as to those matters he believes to be true.
- 15 N.Y.S. 324Gardner v. Patten (1891)
Action by Walter D. Gardner, as assignee of F. A. Gardner, against E. Jarvis Patten, for work done and materials furnished in repairing certain machinery for defendant. The work, etc., extended through the months of September, October, and November, 1888, and appeared to have been without other contract than that it should be paid for at the end of the month. There was a judgment for plaintiff, and defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 325Scott Stamp & Coin Co. v. J. W. Scott Co. (1890)Dismissed
<p>Bill for injunction by the Scott Stamp & Coin Company, Limited, against the J. W. Scott Company, Limited.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 325Jube v. Hodge (1891)
- 15 N.Y.S. 327Amerman v. Deane (1890)
On motion for reargument. Action by Mary Y. Amerman against Bertha A. Deane for an injunction and damages. Judgment for plaintiff below reversed on appeal.
- 15 N.Y.S. 328Kronsberg v. Mayer (1890)
Action by Frederick Kronsberg against Hugo F. Mayer for libel. A judgment by default had been reopened, and both parties had announced themselves ready for trial, when they settled the case, defendant stipulating to pay taxable costs. A trial fee was taxed, and defendant moves for a relaxation.
- 15 N.Y.S. 328Flynn v. Central Railroad of New Jersey (1891)
Action by Thomas Flynn against the Central Eailroad of Hew Jersey. Defendant demurs to the complaint on the ground that it does not state a cause of action, and also on the ground that the court did not have jurisdiction. Code Civil Proc.
- 15 N.Y.S. 330Serat v. Smith (1891)
<p>Appeal from Chemung county court.</p> <p>Action by Mortimer E. Serat against Gabriel L. Smith and Andrew J. Robertson. The plaintiff’s complaint alleges that on the 12th day of July, 1883, he made an agreement with the defendants, who were practicing lawyers in the city of Elmira, “ whereby it was contemplated and agreed that these defendants should receive and retain for themselves as and for full payment and compensation by plaintiff for their costs and disbursements and all claims for services performed and to be performed and costs earned and disbursements incurred, then past and prospective, in relation to or arising out of a claim of this plaintiff against the Utica, Ithaca & Elmira Railroad Company, one-third of the amount collected as damages in behalf of the plaintiff against the said railroad company, and should pay to plaintiff the remaining two-thirds of such amount as soon as the same was received by defendants, together with such interest thereon as might be received by defendants when said damages might be paid to them by said railroad company. ” The complaint also alleged that on the 10th day of May, 1886, “after these defendants had performed all the services contemplated by said agreement, and relating to the plaintiff’s said claim against said railroad company, the defendants received under said agreement from said railroad company the sum of $1,516.50, the amount of the damages obtained by plaintiff against said company, and also the sum of $237.78, the interest on said $1,516.50 from September 29, 1883, the date when said sum was awarded as damages to plaintiff against said company, to-May 10, 1886, the date when said damages and interest was paid, amounting in all to the sum of $1,754.28.” Plaintiff alleged that he had demanded payment of the sum of $1,169.52, “but defendants failed and refused to pay the same, or any part thereof, to plaintiff until March 21, 1887, when defendants paid to plaintiff, to apply thereon, the sum of $1,054, “the amount then due and payable from defendants to plaintiff being $1,230.09; * * * and there remained due to plaintiff and unpaid, after deducting said sum of $1,054, paid to apply, the sum of $176.09.” The answer of the defendants was a denial of the allegations of the complaint, and an averment of “settlement and satisfaction and payment, and a counter-claim for services to the value of $250, and demand judgment for $250.” On page 490 of the defendants’ register was the following agreement:</p> <p>“Supreme Court. Chemung County.</p> <p>“Mortimer E. Herat ag’st The Utica, Ithaca & Elmira Railroad Company-</p> <p>“The agreement between plff. and his attys. as to pay for their services is as follows: If the suit is tried, and plff. is beaten, they are to have nothing, and if plff. succeeds on trial or by settlement they are to have one-third the amount obtained by plff. and all the costs recovered or received by deft. This is tlie agreement made in this action.</p> <p>“July 12th, 1883. M. E. Serat.</p> <p>“Smith & Robertson, Attys.”</p> <p>At that time the plaintiff claimed that the railroad company had forcibly ousted him from a trestle-work, which he claimed to own, and the action was brought to recover its value, which action resulted in a judgment on the 29th of September, 1883, for $1,516.50 damages. The company appealed from this-judgment to the general term. Pending that action, and on or about the 3d of October, 1883, the defendants prepared papers in an action of sequestration, and at Delhi obtained an order to show cause returnable at the Madison special term, requiring the defendant to show cause why a receiver should not be appointed, and upon the court’s attention being called to the fact that a bond had been given on appeal no order was made. The appeal was heard in the general term, and the judgment affirmed. The railroad company appealed to the court of appeals, where the judgment was affirmed, (6 N. E. Rep. 795,) and the remittitur was entered in the Chemung county clerk’s office on the 24th day of April, 1886. On the 10th day of May, 1886, the defendants executed and delivered to the railroad company a receipt for the amount of money then received, to-wit, $2,108.19. In the statement, to which the receipt is attached, it appears that the amount of the first judgment (September 9,1883) was $1,598.08, and interest thereon to May 9,1886, at 6 per cent., was $250.63. Other items in the statement appear to be for costs in the general term and in the court of appeals. On February 26, 1887, the plaintiff, by telegram to the defendants, asked, “Has suit been decided?” On February 28, 1887, a telegram was sent to plaintiff at Lexington, Mo., to the effect that one of the members of the firm was absent from home, and that he would write on his return. On March 11, 1887, from Cherokee, Kan., the plaintiff sent a letter to one of the defendants, making inquiry in respect to the suit, iu which he says: “If the suit is undecided, please so notify.” On March 19, 1887, a letter was addressed to the plaintiff by one of the defendants, which contained the following language: “I have just tills week returned from Albany and the court of appeals, and am now happy to announce to you that I have succeeded in collecting your money, and will send it to you just as soon as 1 can get into the bank to get a draft. It is now Saturday afternoon, and I cannot do so until Monday morning. I have expected for months to be able to send you your money every mail, and therefore have neglected writing until today, every day expecting to be able to send you a draft to-morrow. But it has been prevented until now; and now that I have got something to write you, I do so. This explains why I have not written you sooner; at least, it is the only explanation I have to give.” On the 21st of March, 1887, one of the defendants sent to plaintiff by mail a letter addressed to him at Cherokee, Kan., with a draft for $1,054, which draft was to the order of one of the attorneys. The letter stated the draft to be “in full of balance collection against the Utica, Ithaca & Elmira R. R. Co.” The letter contained the following;</p> <p>“Amt. of judgment, ------ $1,516 50</p> <p>Deduct one-third, • • - - - 505 50</p> <p>Two-thirds, - - - - - - $1,011 00</p> <p>Charge for sequestration action, - - - - 100 00</p> <p>Balance, - - - - - - - $ 911 00</p> <p>Interest, ------- 143 00</p> <p>Draft for total, ------ $1,054 00</p> <p>“I have had more trouble getting this than any money, I think, I ever got. You remember that I had to bring a second action for you outside of the one in which I made the collection, for the purpose of sequestrating the -road, which compelled them to give security, and that this action came on at Morris ville, before Judge Murray, and for this I charge you $100. This was entirely outside of this action, and was really the proceeding that caused our success. 1 had to pay out a very large part of this charge for expenses in getting papers served, going to Morris ville,' Madison county, etc., in the case. I have expected all this year, from week to week, to be able to send you the money, and in such expectation neglected writing you. I was before the court of appeals in Albany last week.” The plaintiff testified that the letters of the 19th and 21st of March were the only letters that he received “after the decision of the court of appeals up to the time of receiving them.” The plaintiff testified that after he received the letter of March 21st, and on the 21st of April, 1887, at Parsons, Kan., he wrote to the defendants a letter containing a statement of the amount of the original judgment, and the interest thereon, and claiming therein that there was due him $1,230.20, less the remittance of $1,054, leaving the balance due the plaintiff of $176.20, and closing his communication with the following words: “I have drawn on you at sight for the above balance, $176.20. Please protect and oblige.” The draft was produced in evidence, having been returned to the plaintiff. It is conceded that the payment of this draft was “refused.” It appears by the evidence that the draft of March 21, 1887, for $1,054, was an ordinary bank draft issued by the Chemung Canal Bank, Elmira, payable to the order of G. L. Smith, and bore upon it an indorsement as follows: “Pay to the order of M. E. Serat in full for balance due on collection of judgment’against the Utica, Ithaca & Elmira Railroad Company, in his favor. G. L. Smith. ” And under the indorsement and signature, as already stated, was the signature of the plaintiff, to-wit, “M. E. Serat. ” In the letter of April 5th, which the plaintiff sent to the defendants, he stated: “You charge me $100 more than you agreed to conduct the suit for. Second. You do not remit all the interest I am entitled to. With the information now at hand, I cannot say exactly what the interest should be; but $143 does not cover it. Please remit the $100 above and balance of interest at once, and oblige.” On the 9th of April the defendants wrote the plaintiff a letter addressed to him at Parsons, Kan., in which they say, viz.: “The statement we sent you is entirely correct. We made an agreement as to the one case, and after that agreement was made another action was commenced for you, in which we paid out about $40 in cash, and which action was the one that compelled them to give security on their appeal, and so enable us to collect in the end. We charged you for the same $100, which is a very reasonable charge. .The interest, as we figure it, is correct.” The complaint in the second action was verified by the plaintiff on the 3d day of October, 1883, and it stated that the execution on the judgment had been returned by the sheriff of Chemung county “wholly unsatisfied, and that said judgment is wholly unpaid, and the said plaintiff is unable in any way to obtain satisfaction thereof.” Plaintiff verified an affidavit which was used to obtain the order “to show cause on the 9th day of October, 1883.” The order to show cause was signed October 10, 1883, and was returnable at a special term in Morrisville on the 16th day of October, 1883. One of the defendants testifies that the plaintiff directed the commencement of the sequestration action, and also that “there was nothing said between myself and him with reference to the expense of it, or as to whether or no it would be included in the agreement that I had with him in the other action. I did not tell him at that time what the probable expense of the other action would be, or what the charge would be. There never was any statement made by me in the conversation with him, in which I said that notwithstanding the commencement of this action of sequestration, so called, that the only expense to him would be the printing of points for the court of appeals. ” The plaintiff testifies that on one occasion he obtained a copy of the agreement from one of the defendants, “and I asked him if that would cover all the costs that I would be liable for in the action. I didn’t know but there might be something outside that I did not understand. I asked him if that would cover all, and he told me that that would cover all the expenses that I would be liable for, with the possible exception of printing something that had togotothe courtof appeals. I don’t know what; some argument or something that had to go to the court of appeals. Question. Points? Answer. Yes, sir; but beyond that I was responsible for nothing but the one-third. This was after this sequestration action had been commenced.” One of the defendants testifies that on the 4th of May, 1886, he addressed a letter to the plaintiff at Lexington, Mo., in which he stated: “We have beaten them in court appeals, and hope to get our money soon, but they may keep us out of it a year or two by compelling us to sue on the bonds; but I hope not. Let me hear from you, so I may know your address in case the money comes.” And one of the defendants testifies that he did not know prior to the 19th of March, 1887, that the plaintiff “had changed his residence from Lexington, Mo. At least, I heard that he had changed it, but I did not know where.” From a judgment of the county court affirming a judgment of the justice’s court for plaintiff, defendants appeal.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 335Briggs v. Gardner (1891)
Action by Smith Briggs against Robert B. Gardner on a promissory note. From a judgment of the county court affirming a judgment of a justice’s court for plaintiff, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 337Hoyt v. Cline (1891)
Action by Horace P. Hoyt and Edgar S. Hoyt against John H. Cline to recover damages for and an injunction against the wrongful use by defendant of the water in a stream flowing past the mill-sites owned by plaintiffs and defendant, respectively.
- 15 N.Y.S. 341Hymes v. Van Cleef (1891)
Action by Jehiel Hymes against Mynderse Van Cleef, as administrator with the will annexed of Joseph Esty, deceased. From a judgment for plaintiff for $812.30 damages, and $1,141.20 costs, entered March -31, 1890, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 344Durnherr v. Rau (1891)
Action by Benedicta Durnlierr against Joseph Bau to recover damages for breach of covenant made by defendant with plaintiff’s husband. From an order setting aside the verdict in favor of plaintiff and granting a new trial, plaintiff appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 348Spies v. Rome, Watertown & Ogdensburgh Railroad (1891)
Action by George Spies against the Rome, Watertown & Ogdensburgh Railroad Company to recover the possession of a small parcel of real estate in the city of Watertown.
- 15 N.Y.S. 350Strever v. Earl (1891)
Action by Almira N. Strever against Oren B. Earl to foreclose a mort-gage. On the 27th day of December, 1875, Lydia Weser, of the town of Sandy Creek, -executed and delivered to the defendant her mortgage, under seal, covering the land described in the complaint, to secure the payment of $400 one year from • date, which mortgage was recorded on the 80th of December, 1875, in Book 107 of Mortgages, at page 491.
- 15 N.Y.S. 353Chester v. Broderick (1891)
<p>Appeal from judgment on report of referee.</p> <p>Action by Jane E. Chester and another against Lucy Broderick and EdwinH. Ellsworth, executors. From a judgment for plaintiffs, defendants appeal.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 356Ellison v. Jones (1891)
. Action by George E. Ellison against John W. Jones to recover for services rendered. When the verdict for plaintiff for $64.54 was delivered, the plaintiff’s attorneys stipulated that the sum of $4.54 be deduced therefrom. The deduction was made. Thereupon defendant’s counsel stated: “We desire to make a formal motion in behalf of defendant for a new trial upon the minutes. The Court. Denied.
- 15 N.Y.S. 359Baker v. Thomas (1891)
<p>Appeal from special term, Oneida county.</p> <p>Action by Philip J. Baker against John B. Thomas and Clinton B. Thomas and others to foreclose a mortgage. There was a judgment for plaintiff, and defendants Thomas appeal.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 362People v. Brooks (1891)
<p>Appeal from court of sessions, Onondaga county.</p> <p>Rachel Brooks was indicted for arson in the first degree. On the trial, after the defendant, who was called as a witness in her own behalf, had testified that a' personal affray occurred between herself and Charlotte Brooks, who was a material witness for the people, the following questions were asked by the defendant’s counsel: “Eow, state whether or not Charlotte was friendly with you or unfriendly. (Objected to as incompetent.) The Court. That is pretty general,—any evidence of unfriendliness. By Mr. Gfoodelle. Did you and Charlotte have frequent difficulties during that time? (Objected to as incompetent.) The Court. You had the witness here, and can ask anything she has testified in regard to, and if you don’t think she has told the truth, you can ask the witness about it, and I think that is as far as you can go. Mr. Goodelle. As I said before, I cannot be mistaken. It seems to me, under the rule, that it is always competent to show by third parties, or by the parties themselves, feeling or ill will against a witness who swears against another. It would be competent for me to call other witnesses in this case to show what Charlotte said against Mrs. Brooks, and would indicate her feeling as a question of motive. I cannot be mistaken as to that rule. I wish the stenographer would take my objection to this. And, that being the case, much more is it competent to show the act of the party, which is always stronger than the declaration of the party, which indicates ill will or hostility. How, it is with that view that this evidence is offered. I do not offer it to contradict Charlotte. I offer it as evidence in chief in this case on the part of the defense, and that the jury may see that the principal witness in this case who has testified against Mrs. Brooks testifies from feelings of enmity towards her. The Court. I think the rule is this: That a witness may be cross-examined as to his or her attitude of mind in regard to the defendant, and his attention must be called to each and all the transactions upon which the counsel for the defendant desires to give evidence. If the witness admits the acts and declarations that the defendant claims were made and done, that is the end of it. If - the witness denies, then I think it is competent to call other witnesses to contradict those matters; but to let a witness go off the stand, not having questioned the witness as to the particulars, and then calling third parties to prove independent transactions showing the attitude of the mind of the witness towards the party, I think is not the rule. So I have allowed and do allow this witness to testify as to any transactions bearing upon that point in regard to which the witness Charlotte was examined. Mr. Goodelle. And that is the extent to which you allow the defendant to go? The Court. That is the rule which I should apply in regard to any question which should be put. Mr. Goodelle. I take an exception to the ruling. The Court. And I should say, further, that the witness referred to is in court now,, so that there is no loss to the defendant by the application of the rule as I understand it. Mr. Goodelle. Mrs. Brooks, did Charlotte assault you on other occasions, but a short time previous to this fire? (Objected to upon the ground that the attention of the witness Charlotte ought to have been brought to it, and it is incompetent as evidence in this case.) The Court. Of course, the application of the rule as I have stated it, and as I understand it, would exclude that, unless her attention was called to it. Do you say the attention of Charlotte was called to that point? Mr. Goodelle. The attention of Charlotte was called in this way: If your honor will remember that, Charlotte put it that every rainy day they had trouble; that it was their custom to have some trouble every rainy day. That was about as far as I could get the witness to go upon that question. The Court. Did you put the question involving any specific occasion? Mr. Goodelle. I think not, except the one to which she has already testified when Mr. Lacy was there. The Court. Then I will exclude the question, and sustain the objection. (Exception taken by the defendant’s counsel.) Mr. Goodelle. The purpose being to show the animus of the witness Charlotte towards the defendant at about the time at which Charlotte claims Mrs. Brooks said to her that she was going to set the store on fire. That is the purpose of the testimony. The Court. Yes; I understand.”</p> <p>The court in its charge instructed the jury as follows: “The question of good character—we mean by that reputation—is one that enters into a case. Where a man is charged with a crime, and he has borne among his friends and neighbors—people who have known him in ins daily life come in and say that his reputation among the people where he has lived has been good,—that is to be taken into account in his favor; it is to be added to the presumption of innocence, and is positive testimony in his behalf. Well, does that mean that no man shall be convicted of crime who has previously borne a good reputation,—indeed, who has never been known to have committed any crime or done any wrong? Not at all. It does not mean that, but it means that we find by experience that men do not suddenly go all wrong, and commit some crime. It is a sort of presumption that it' a man had been upright, borne a good character, been honest and upright among his friends and neighbors, for a course of years, that it is not to be expected that he will lapse into crime. Well, it would hardly be just to the law, or to this proposition of law, to say that that stands in the way of the conviction of a man of crime who has heretofore borne a good reputation. You should be more careful when you find such a man in saying that he has gone all wrong, and committed a crime, then you should in the case of a man who is shown positively, by positive testimony, to have been a criminal before, and in the trial of a case, if that reputation has been shown to be good,—or character ’ is the word used, has been shown to be good,—yet if the evidence in the case on the trial of the case,—the evidence shows corruptness, fraudulent practice, bad heart, dishonesty, fraud,—it rebuts, so far as it goes, the reputation for good character; that is to say, positive testimony of the commission of a crime extinguishes it altogether, if you believe the testimony.” At the conclusion of the charge, the defendant’s counsel said: “The charge is very satisfactory, and I do not rise to find any fault with it. Your honor has charged that if the jury find that there is a reasonable doubt that they must acquit. Now, I ask your honor to charge that good character may be sufficient to raise that reasonable doubt which requires the jury to acquit. The Court. I charge that. Mr. Goodelle. I have simply one exception to take to your honor’s charge. Do you desire me to take it at this time? The Court. Yes. Mr. Goodelle. Your honor charged that if, on the trial of a case, it is shown that the person has been corrupt and guilty of fraudulent practices, it rebuts the evidence, and the importance attached to it of good character,—is an answer to it. I do not give your honor’s precise language, but that, in substance, and what your honor did charge upon that question, and all, I take an exception. The Court. Yes. Mr. Goodelle. And, furthermore, I ask your honor to charge that these remarks are not applicable to this case. The Couit. I refuse to charge that,—to say that. (Exception taken by defendant’s counsel.)”</p> <p>Six witnesses testified on the trial that they knew the defendant, and knew her reputation and character in the neighborhood where she resided, and that her. character was good. Upon the motion for a new trial the affidavits of William P. Goodelle, Frank Hopkins, Louis Marshall, and Harry Brill were presented, stating that the district attorney, while engaged in addressing the jury on behalf of the people, among other remarks made the following: “This woman belongs to a race that worships money as it worships its Jehovah. As its golden calf was raised by the Israelites of old, it has been held aloft ever since. Give me money if I peril my own soul and my own salvation! Any doubt about it? Is there any doubt that that woman loves the gold that her race loves?” The affidavit of the district attorney was also read, which, in effect, denies the use of the language attributed to him, and states that what was said was in answer to the argument of the defendant’s counsel. No objection or exception was taken by the defendant’s counsel to the remarks of the district attorney. The absence of such exception is sought to be explained by the defendant’s counsel upon the ground that the remarks were made before an objection could be interposed. Defendant was convicted and sentenced to 15 years’ imprisonment in the Onondaga penitentiary, aud from the judgment of conviction, and from an ordér denying a motion for a new trial, defendant appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 366Tyler v. Board of Supervisors (1891)
<p>J. Acting Surrogate—Compensation.</p> <p>Relator's intestate was elected special county judge of T. county, under Laws If. Y. 1858, c. 279, which authorizes the election of such special county judge “to discharge the duties of county judge and surrogate of said county in case of vacancy, in the absence or other inability of such officer, ” and provides that he shall receive for the services rendered by him under the provisions of this act such compensation as shall be allowed to him by the board of supervisors in said county. Held, that intestate’s right to act in the absence of the surrogate was conferred by the act of 1858, and not by Code Civil Proc. § 2484, which provides that, in the absence of the surrogate of any county, the duties of the office must be discharged by the special county judge, where “ special provision is not made by law for the discharge of the duties of his office in that contingency;” and hence his compensation is regulated by the act of 1858, and not by Code Civil Proc. Ñ. Y. § 2493, which provides that an officer who acts as surrogate “as prescribed in the last 9 sections” must be paid for the time he so acts a compensation equal pro rata to the salary of the surrogate.</p> <p>•2. Same—Proof of Authority.</p> <p>The requirement of Code Civil Proc. NT. Y. §§ 2487, 2488, that the absence or disqualification of the surrogate must be proved either by the certificate of the surrogate or by an order of a justice of the supreme court, which order must also recite the cause of the making thereof, and must designate the officer to discharge the surrogate’s duties, is a condition precedent to the authority of an officer specified by section 2484 to act as surrogate.</p> <p>3. Same—Unauthorized Acts—Ratification.</p> <p>A special county judge discharged the duties of surrogate during the absence of ■ the surrogate, without proving his authority so to act, as required by Code Civil Proc. N. Y. §§ 2487, 2488. Afterwards Laws N. Y. 1889, c. 221, was enacted, legalizing the acts performed by the special county judge acting as surrogate. Held, that the effect of such statute was only to make the special county judge’s acts as surrogate legal as to third persons, and did not charge his status so far as compensation was concerned.</p> <p>■4. Same—Amount of Compensation.</p> <p>Code Civil Prae. N. Y. % 2493, which provides that an officer acting as surrogate “must be paid for the time during which he so acts a compensation equal pro rata to the salary of the surrogate, ” authorizes such compensation only while the officer is acting as surrogate, and not when he is not so acting.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 369Crouse v. Reichert (1891)
Action by Charles E. Crouse et al. against Frederick Reichert. From an order denying a motion to set aside a judgment entered by default, defendant appeals. Code Civil Proc. H. Y. § 419, provides: “A copy of the complaint may be served with the summons.
- 15 N.Y.S. 370Duffus v. Cole (1891)
Action by William Duffus against Rose Cole. From an order adjudging defendant guilty of contempt in transferring her property after service on her of an injunction order, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 370In re Clark's Estate (1891)
<p>Appeal from surrogate’s court, Otsego county.</p> <p>Proceeding to appoint an administrator of the estate of George Clark, •deceased. Ichabod McIntosh, the petitioner, was appointed, and Daniel R. Bennett appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 371Tompkins v. City of Oswego (1891)
Action by Emily Tompkins, administratrix of David C. Tompkins, deceased, against the city of Oswego, to recover damages for the alleged negligence of the defendant in not properly maintaining a fence or guard railing along the side of West First street, in the city of Oswego. The plaintiff claims that, by reason,of the defendant’s omission to maintain such fence or railing, the plaintiff’s intestate met with the accident which caused his death.
- 15 N.Y.S. 374Dexter v. Riverside & Oswego Mills (1891)
Action by Edward Dexter against the Riverside & Oswego Mills, (o recover damages for an alleged trespass in digging a ditch in front of plaintiff’s premises. On September 10, 1877, the Oswego Falls Manufacturing Company was the owner of the fee of the street known as “Broadway,” and of the lands on each side of the same between the river and Granby lake, in the village of Oswego Falls.
- 15 N.Y.S. 377McCabe v. Goodfellow (1891)
Action by James E. McCabe against John T. Goodfellow, treasurer of the Law and Order League of the town of Kirkland.
- 15 N.Y.S. 380York v. Conde (1891)
. Action by Anson E. York and Wallace W. Starkweather against William Conde and John C. Streeter.
- 15 N.Y.S. 382Moore v. American Loan & Trust Co. (1891)
- 15 N.Y.S. 384Larow v. New York, Lake Erie & Western Railroad (1891)
Action by Ella Larow, as administratrix of George W. Larow, deceased, against the Hew York, Lake Erie & Western Kailroad Company for negligently causing the death of plaintiff’s intestate. From a judgment entered on a verdict for plaintiff, and from an order denying a motion for a new trial on the minutes, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 387Paddock v. City of Syracuse (1891)
<p>.Municipal Corporations—Defective Sidewalks—Notice of Injury.</p> <p>Plaintiff, who was injured by a fall on a sidewalk in defendant city, served on the proper officers of defendant a notice specifying the injuries, and stating that they were received at a certain time, and were caused by a certain defective and dangerous sidewalk, and that “said defective and dangerous sidewalk and said injuries were caused by the negligence of the city of Syracuse, [defendant,] its agents, officers, ” etc. Held, that the averment of such notice as to the cause of the injury was a mere- conclusion, and was insufficient, under Laws N. T. 1888, c. 449, amend- „ ing the charter of defendant, which provides that defendant shall not be liable to an action for injuries resulting from any defect in any street or sidewalk, “unless written notice, specifying the time, place, and cause of such injury or damage, shall be served on the mayor or city clerk” within a certain time.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 389First National Bank v. Moffatt (1891)
Action by the First National Bank of Lowville against George D. Moffatt and others on two notes made by M. M. Noble to the order of and indorsed by defendant Moffatt, payable two months from date at the bank of plaintiff, one for $700, dated September 18, 1886, and the other for $500, dated October 8, 1886.
- 15 N.Y.S. 391Gilmore v. Ham (1891)
Action by William W. Gilmore against Edward E. Ham to recover half of a judgment against a partnership consisting of plaintiff and defendant, which judgment had been paid by plaintiff, and for an accounting.
- 15 N.Y.S. 393Hill v. Mayor of New York (1891)
<p>1, Wharves—Use as E> empino Ground—Inconsistent Statutes.</p> <p>Laws N. Y. 1881, c. 3»7, creating the “department of street cleaning,” in New York city, provides (section 4) that the authorities having the management and control of the public docks, piers, and slips of said city shall designate and set apart for the use of the commissioners of street cleaning suitable and sufficient slips, etc., for his use id executing his duties, “excepting slips, docks, and piers on the East river set apart for the use of canal-boats. ” Section 12 repeals all “acts and parts of acts inconsistent herewith. ” Laws N. Y. 1875, c. 249, (regulating the use of slips, eto., in New York city,) § 3, provides that it shall not be lawful to permit, for the use as a dumping ground, of any slip, etc., on East river, “ which has heretofore been used for the loading and discharging of sailing vessels regularly employed in foreign commerce: * * * provided, however, that nothing in this section contained shall apply to any wharf, pier, slip, or bulk-head * * * reserved for a special use by any existing law. ” Section 4 of the act of 1881 was re-enacted by Laws N. Y. 1883, c. 410, (consolidation act,) §§ 706, 738; and section 3 of the act of 1875 was re-enacted by section 773 of the consolidation act. Held, that sections 706, 738, 773, of the consolidation act would be construed together, and section 773, (re-enacting Laws 1875, o. 349, § 3,) which is apparently inconsistent with sections 706, 738, (re-enacting Laws 1881, c. 367, § 4,) would be construed as limiting to “a special use, ” existing in 1875, the proviso therein contained, as to the prohibition against the use as a.dumping ground of any pier, etc., theretofore used by “sailing vessels regularly employed in foreign commerce,’’except piers, etc., “reserved for a special use by any existing law; ” and a pier which had been set apart under existing laws as a dumping ground when the consolidation act took effect was not affected by section 773.</p> <p>B. Nuisance—Irreparable Injury—Injunction.</p> <p>The designation of piers as dumping grounds for the use of the street-cleaning department of New York city being necessary for the preservation of the health of the citizens, such use will not be enjoined as a nuisance on the ground that one individual is inconvenienced thereby, unless it appears that such individual would suffer irreparable as well as special injury.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 398Porter v. Gardner (1891)
Action by Fred Porter against Nelson Gardner, as administratrix of Jane P. Markham, deceased, for the conversion of a colt of the value of $90. Defendant claimed that the colt was a part of the estate of Jane P. Markham, ■deceased, of whose will he is the executor. The main issue at the trial was whether Mrs. Markham before her death gave plaintiff the colt. At the close •of the evidence the court ordered a nonsuit.
- 15 N.Y.S. 400Flood v. Western Union Telephone Co. (1891)
Action by Mary Flood, as administratrix of Timothy Flood, deceased, against the Western Union Telegraph Company for injuries causing the death of plaintiff’s intestate. From a judgment entered on a verdict for plaintiff for $3,000, and from an order denying a motion for a new trial made on the minutes, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 402Holden v. O'Donohue (1891)
<p>Appeal from circuit court, Onondaga county.</p> <p>Action by Edwin R. Holden and another against John O’Donohue and others. From a judgment for plaintiffs, defendant O’Donohue appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 403Kealey v. Murray (1891)
Action by Michael Healey and another against Dwight H. Murray and others to foreclose a mechanic’s lien. There was a judgment for plaintiffs, and •defendant Murray appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 405Ballard v. Hitchcock Manufacturing Co. (1891)
Action by Ellen I. Ballard, executrix of William P. Ballard, against the Hitchcock Manufacturing Company, to recover for injuries causing the death of plaintiff’s testator. From a judgment entered on the verdict of a jury, and from an order denying a motion for a new trial, made on a case and exceptions, and from a judgment entered thereon, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 408Crouse v. First National Bank (1891)
Action by Charles E. Crouse against the First National Bank of Penn Yan to recover damages for the alleged negligence of defendant in failing to collect a draft drawn by Crouse & Walrath on P. M. Dinehart, on February 14, 1884, for $400. From a judgment for plaintiff, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 410Gibbons v. Village of Phœnix (1891)
Action by Elizabeth Gibbons against the village of Phcenix to recover damages sustained by plaintiff in falling upon a sidewalk in the village of Phcenix on the 24th June, 1890. From a judgment entered on the verdict of a jury, and from an order denying a motion for a new trial made on the minutes, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 411Snell v. Thorp (1891)
Action by Irving Snell against Robert Thorp. From a judgment, entered on the verdict of a jury, and from an order denying his motion for a new trial, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 412Burtis v. Burtis (1891)
Action by Sarah Burtis, in her own right, and as executrix of Elizabeth Cleveland, deceased, against Sarah Burtis, as administratrix of James G. Cleveland, deceased, and Caroline L. Kerr, and other defendants. The complaint is for the foreclosure of one mortgage given by James G. Cleveland, now deceased, to secure the payment of two bonds,—one for $1,142.55, to the plaintiff, Sarah Burtis, and the other, for $1,021.53, to Elizabeth Cleveland, now deceased.
- 15 N.Y.S. 414People v. Rouse (1891)
Action by the people of the state of Hew York against Hiram Bouse to remover penalties for killing woodcock, and for having in possession woodcock after the same had been killed, in violation of section 9 of chapter 534 of the Laws of 1879, as amended by chapter 269 of the Laws of 1884. The killing and possession are alleged in the complaint as occurring in Fulton county, in ■July, 1889.
- 15 N.Y.S. 416Kenyon v. Olney (1891)
<p>Appeal from circuit court, Oneida county.</p> <p>Action by Henry Kenyon and Nancy H. Williams, as administrators of Isaac N. Williams, deceased, against William It. Olney and' others. From a judgment of nonsuit plaintiffs appeal.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 418Ten Eyck v. Witbeck (1891)
<p>Appeal from circuit court, Albany county.</p> <p>Action by Maria Ten Eyck and Cornelius H. Slingerland against Catherine A. Witbeck and others. From a judgment for defendants, plaintiffs appeal.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 420Kingsland v. Mayor of New York (1891)
Action by William M. Kingsland against the mayor, etc., of the city of New York. From an order denying a resettlement of the case defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 420Tolhurst v. Powers (1891)
<p>Appeal from judgment on report of referee.</p> <p>Action by William H. Tolhurst and another against Joseph A. Powers. From a judgment dismissing the complaint, plaintiffs appeal.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 423Winne v. City of Albany (1891)
Action by Elizabeth Winne against the city of Albany for personal injuries» A nonsuit was granted, and plaintiff appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 424Houghtaling v. Lloyd (1891)
Action by Harmon Houghtaling against Harriet L. Lloyd. A judgment rendered by a justice of the peace in favor of plaintiff was affirmed by the county court, and defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 425In re Smith's Will (1891)
Proceedings for the probate of the will of Matthew Smith, deceased. The proponents, decedent’s wife, Mary, and his nephew James Smith, appeal from an order of the surrogate refusing to admit the will to probate.
- 15 N.Y.S. 427Merchants' National Bank v. Chapin (1891)
Action by the Merchants’ National Bank against S. Edward Chapin, Harriet Chapin, and others, to set aside alleged fraudulent conveyances. Erom a judgment for plaintiff, defendants appeal.
- 15 N.Y.S. 429Weed v. Hamburg-Bremen Fire Insurance (1891)
<p>Appeal from circuit court, Rensselaer county.</p> <p>Action by Henry E. Weed against the Hamburg-Bremen Eire Insurance Company. From a judgment for plaintiff defendant appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 431Davis v. Noyes (1891)
Action by Anna Davis against Frances A. Noyes. From a judgment for plaintiff defendant appeals. Code Civil Proc. H. Y. § 395, provides that “an acknowledgment of promise, contained in a writing signed by the party to be charged thereby, is tlmonly competent evidence of a new or continuing contract whereby to take a case out of the statute of limitations.”
- 15 N.Y.S. 433Beiermeister v. City of London Fire Insurance (1891)
Action by Frederick Beiermeister, Jr., and George A. Spicer against the City of London Fire Insurance Company. Judgment was entered on a verdict directed for defendant, and plaintiffs appeal.
- 15 N.Y.S. 435People v. Wilber (1891)
Edward Wilber was convicted of violating the excise laws of the state of New York, in selling intoxicating liquors in quantities less than five gallons at a time, to be drank on his premises, without having a license so to do, and sentenced to “be imprisoned in the Albany county penitentiary ninety days, and that he pay a fine of fifty dollars, and be imprisoned in said penitentiary until said fine is paid, not exceeding fifty days; in addition to said ninety days,” and from…
- 15 N.Y.S. 437People v. Carnrick (1891)
Charles H. Carnrick was arrested on a criminal warrant charging him with the crime of assault in the third degree. Prom a judgment of the court of sessions, affirming a judgment of conviction of the recorder’s court of the city of Gloversville, ÍL Y., defendant appeals. Codé Crim. Proc. S'. Y. §§ 57, 58, are as follows: “Sec. 57.
- 15 N.Y.S. 438Bumstead v. Sanders (1891)
• Appeal from circuit court, Rensselaer county. Action by Amelia H. Bumstead, an infant, against Walter T. L. Sanders and others. From a judgment for defendants, plaintiff appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 440People v. Phelps (1891)
Lawrence county. ■ John H. Phelps was indicted as follows: “The grand jury of the county of St. Lawrence by this indictment accuse John H. Phelps of the crime of abortion, committed as follows: The said John H. Phelps on the 1st day of July, 1889, at the town of Hermon, in this county, did with intent thereby to procure a miscarriage of a woman, to-wit, Sarah Nicholson, advise her, the said Sarah Nicholson, to take a medicine, drug, or substance, and to use means to procure…
- 15 N.Y.S. 442Bonney v. Paul (1891)
Lawrence county court. Action by Walter B. Bonney against James Paul and another. From a judgment of the county court affirming the judgment of a justice’s court, defendant Paul appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 443Young v. Rondout & Kingston Gas-Light Co. (1891)
Action by Edwin Young, as executor of the last will and testament of Thomas Cornell, deceased, against the Rondout & Kingston Gas-Light Company and Frank P. Slade.
- 15 N.Y.S. 444Duffus v. Bangs (1891)
<p>Appeal from circuit court.</p> <p>Action for conversion of personal property by William Duffus against Eli Bangs and others. From an assessment of damages defendants appeal.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 446People ex rel. Southern Cotton Oil Co. v. Wemple (1891)
Certiorari at the relation of the Southern Cotton Oil Company to review 'the proceedings of Edward Wemple, comptroller of the state of New York, in making an assessment of taxes on relator under the corporation tax-laws -of New York, 1880 and 1881.
- 15 N.Y.S. 448Manette v. Simpson (1891)
Action by Jonathan D. Manette against William Simpson. From a judgment of the county court, affirming the judgment of a justice of the peace in favor of plaintiff, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 449Martin v. Crehan (1891)
Action by Henry Martin, as assignee, against Thomas 0. Crehan and another for goods alleged to have been sold by plaintiff’s assignor to defendants for use in a business carried on by them jointly. A nonsuit was granted, and plaintiff appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 450Murray v. Friensberg (1891)
Action by Michael Murray against Louis Friensberg for false imprisonment. From a judgment for $387.69 damages and costs in favor of plaintiff, •entered on a verdict, and from an order denying defendant’s motion to set ■aside the verdict, and for a new trial, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 452Collamer v. Farrington (1891)
Action by Warren B. Collamer against Albert H. Farrington on a contract of suretyship for the performance by a lessee of the conditions of a lease. There was a judgment for plaintiff, and defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 455Preston v. Hawley (1891)
Action by George C. Preston against Samuel R. Hawley for the use and occupation of certain premises. Prom a judgment entered on a verdict for plaintiff, and from an order denying motion for a new trial, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 458Donohue v. Jackson (1891)
<p>Chattel Mortgages—Change oe Possession—Lien op Execution.</p> <p>Plaintiff was appointed receiver in supplementary proceedings against a judgment debtor. Defendants took a mortgage on the debtor’s property prior to plaintiff’s appointment, but suffered the property to remain in the possession of the mortgagor, who delivered the same to a purchaser under a bill of sale, and defendants foreclosed his mortgage while the property was in such purchaser’s hands. The judgment creditor never made a levy on the property in question. Meld that, defendants having reclaimed their property by foreclosure before the judgment creditor acquired a specific lien, defendants could not be held liable for conversion thereof.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 459Doane v. Anderson (1891)
<p>1. Execution of Search-Warrant—Trespass against the Person.</p> <p>The complaint alleged and the evidence showed that defendant had falsely accused plaintiff of theft, and maliciously, and without probable cause, procured a warrant to search plaintiff’s house and person, and had caused it to he executed by a search of her house, and in such manner as to grossly humiliate her. Held, that a trespass was sufficiently shown for which defendant was liable, and that it was unimportant whether the action be considered as one for libel, for slander, for false imprisonment, or malicious prosecution.</p> <p>3. Malicious Prosecution—Evidence.</p> <p>Where it did not appear that certain diamonds, alleged by a female boarder to have been stolen from her, were in fact missing at all, and that defendant, who had procured a warrant to search plaintiff’s boarding-house for their recovery, had formerly paid his attentions to plaintiff, but had lately become attentive to such female boarder, and defendant himself testified that he could not honestly believe that plaintiff stole the diamonds, the evidence was sufficient to justify the jury in finding a verdict against defendant for maliciously causing a search of plaintiff’s premises and person for the recovery of the diamonds.</p> <p>3. Same—Excessive Damages.</p> <p>A verdict for plaintiff for $3,500 damages for maliciously causing a search of plaintiff’s premises and person for the recovery of diamonds alleged to have been stolen, wherein plaintiff, a young woman, was compelled to disrobe herself in the presence of the constable, and to submit to the insertion of his fingers in her hair in the progress of his search, was not excessive.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 461In re Stringer's Estate (1891)
Proceedings for the settlement of the accounts of William Lang, executor of Eliza Stringer, deceased. From an order disallowing his claim for board • of the testatrix and for taxes paid for her the executor appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 461People ex rel. Nichols v. Board of Supervisors (1891)
Application by George H. Nichols and William H. Nichols for mandamus to compel the board of supervisors of Queens county to make provision for -the payment of certain expenses incurred b'y the sheriff of the county in projecting relators’ property from a threatened attack of “strikers,” which expenses had been paid out of funds-advanced by relators, to whom the sheriff assigned his claim therefor.
- 15 N.Y.S. 462Wheeler v. Simmons (1891)
<p>¿Bankruptcy—Revival oe Debt—Payments.</p> <p>A debt from which the debtor "has been discharged in bankruptcy cannot be revived by partial payments, or anything short of an express and distinct promise of payment. Lawrence v. Harrington, 188 M". Y. 408, 85 N. E. Rep. 406, followed.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 463Warburton Hall Ass'n v. Flannery (1891)
Action by the Warburton Hall Association against Patrick J. Flannery and the city of Yonkers.
- 15 N.Y.S. 464Eighmie v. Townsend (1891)
Action by Edgar Eiglimie against Jacob Townsend to recover on a promise made by defendant to pay a debt due from one Belle Cunningham to plaintiff. The consideration of such promise was the conveyance to defendant by Belle Cunningham of certain property to defendant by chaltel mortgage. Defendant released the property without paying plaintiff’s debt, and plaintiff seeks to enforce the same against defendant personally.
- 15 N.Y.S. 465Breichelbiel v. Powles (1891)
Action by John E. Breichelbiel, as overseer of the poor of the town of Orangetown, against George H. Powles and Ella T. Powles, on a bond given by defendants to secure the town against the wife and children of George H. Powles becoming a charge on the town.
- 15 N.Y.S. 466Banks v. Goodliffe (1891)
.. Action by Charles G. Banks against John T. Goodliffe and others to foreclose a mortgage. Defendant Goodliffe, while the owner of two certain tracts of land, on January 15, 1877, executed a mortgage thereon to one Richard Burnett; and on July 27, 1877, Goodliffe conveyed one of said tracts to Fannie E. Banks, the wife of plaintiff. On November 16,1878, Burnett assigned the mortgage to Sarah S. Banks, the sister-in-law of plaintiff.
- 15 N.Y.S. 467Velie v. Titus (1891)
Claim by Anna Mary Velie against Samuel Titus, as executor of the will -of John H. Titus, deceased, on a note executed by testator, as follows: “$1,000. “On demand, I promise to pay to Anna Mary Velie (my granddaughter) one thousand dollars, in consideration of five dollars in hand paid, and for services rendered me, and for other good and valuable consideration equivalent to the above-named sum; which sum, when paid, shall be in full of all demands for services or otherwise…
- 15 N.Y.S. 468In re Whitney's Estate (1891)
' Application by Mary A. Whitney for the judicial settlement of the accounts of Constant White and Isabel Whitney, as administrators of Seth Whitney, deceased. Petitioner presented to the administrator a note of decedent for $600 as a claim against the estate, and the claim was by them rejected.
- 15 N.Y.S. 469Woerman v. Baas (1891)
. Action for partition by Joseph Woerman against Berend Baas and others. All the parties except defendant Baas, who was joined on his own application, in order to obtain an adjudication of his rights as executor of the will of Wilhelm Bonthrup, deceased, were the heirs of the said Bonthrup. The first clause of the will of Wilhelm Bonthrop, deceased, was as follows: “First.
- 15 N.Y.S. 470Todd v. Doremus (1891)
Action by James W. Todd against Morton R. Doremus. From a judgment of the county court, reversing a judgment rendered by a justice of the peace, plaintiff appeals. Code Civil Proc. FT. Y. § 2934, provides as follows: “At the place and within one hour after the time specified in the summons for the return thereof, * * * the pleadings'of the parties must be made, and issue must be joined.
- 15 N.Y.S. 470In re Tienken (1891)
Application by Anna M. Tienken to require Anna Tienken, as executrix, and John BulLwinkel, as executor, of the will of Henry Tienken, deceased, to render an account, and for a decree requiring the executor and executrix to pay to petitioner her distributive share of the legacy given to Henry ÍT. Tienken, deceased, petitioner’s husband, by the will of Henry Tienken, deceased.
- 15 N.Y.S. 474Vaughn v. Village of Port Chester (1891)
Action by Jerusha Vaughn against the village of Port Chester to recover the amount of a street assessment paid by plaintiff, on the ground that such payment was made involuntarily, and under threats and coercions which amounted to duress, it being conceded that the assessments were illegal and void. There was a judgment for plaintiff, and defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 475In re Brownell's Estate (1891)
Proceedings for the settlement of the accounts of Myron Brownell and William H. Brownell, executors of Hiram Brownell, deceased. From a decree disallowing credit for a payment made by them the executors and Jane Brownell, to whom the claim was paid, appeal. »
- 15 N.Y.S. 476In re Griffin's Estate (1891)
Proceeding for the judicial settlement of the account of Hiram B. Rosa, as executor of the will of Amelia.Caroline Griffin, deceased. After payment of various legacies given by the will, there remained for distribution a fund of $2,000, the income of which for life had been given to Delia Van Wyck, a cousin of testatrix’s, and other moneys, amounting in all to $2,288.
- 15 N.Y.S. 477Enggren v. Prinz (1891)
Action by Lizzie Enggren against Christian J. Prinz for the conversion of a horse named Julia, alleged to be the property of plaintiff. It appeared that one Nicholas Ryder obtained a judgment against Gustave L. Enggren, the husband of plaintiff. An execution was issued thereon and delivered to a constable, who'levied on the horse in question and sold it to satisfy the execution to defendant. From a judgment entered on the verdict for plaintiff, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 477Brush Electric Illuminating Co. v. Consolidated Telegraph & Electrical Subway Co. (1891)
Action by the Brush Electric Illuminating Company against the Consoli■dated Telegraph & Electrical Subway Company. From an order denying its motion to continue ah injunction pendente lite plaintiff appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 486In re Portingall's Will (1891)
Proceedings for the probate of the will of Julia Portingall, deceased, propounded by Alice Tomb, who Was named therein guardian of testatrix’s infant, children. Probate was resisted by John Wallace, who had been appointed such guardian by a prior will. From an order of the surrogate admittingthe second will, said contestant, Wallace, appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 487Molloy v. Board of Health (1891)
Action by William Y. Molloy and Frank W. Molloy against the board of health of the town of Mamaroneck to recover a balance due on a contract made between plaintiffs and defendant for the construction of a sewer. From a judgment for defendant, plaintiffs appeal.
- 15 N.Y.S. 488Brian v. Mead (1891)
<p>Appeal from special term, Westchester comity.</p> <p>Action by Oscar G. Brian against Solomon Mead. From a judgment for plaintiff, defendant appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 488In re Shay (1891)
<p>Peremptory Mandamus—When Lies—Issue op Pact.</p> <p>A discharged veteran made application for a writ of mandamus to restore him to his position, and opposing affidavits were filed that he gave no notice of his veteran rights till the commencement of legal proceedings after the discharge. Held, that a question of fact was thus raised, preventing the issue of a peremptory mandamus.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 489In re Peterson (1891)
<p>Removal op Justice—Proof op Misconduct.</p> <p>On a motion to remove a justice of the peace it appeared that, while the justice was temporarily acting as a police justice, one C. was brought before him, duly charged with the commission of a criminal offense. The justice required C. to give!l,000 bail. The bondsman offered was not a resident of the city in which the proceeding was had, and the justice adjourned the hearing for five days, to enable C. to procure a city bondsman. The petition for removal stated that on the day to which the hearing was adjourned the justice fixed the bail at $2,000, which averment the justice denied. It was also charged by C., and denied by the justice, that the justice denied C. the right of counsel before he pleaded. No new bail was given, and the case was again adjourned for five days, during which the complaint against C. was transferred to the grand jury by a certificate of a justice of the supreme court. Held, that no such evil or oppressive conduct on the part of the justice as would justify his removal from office was shown.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 490Lashaway v. Tucker (1891)
Action by Edward Lashaway against George W. Tucker to recover for conversion of personal property claimed to have been exempt from execution. The execution was levied on a quantity of Indian corn meal, among other things. From a-judgment for plaintiff, entered on the verdict of a jury, and from an order denying a motion for a new trial, made on the minutes of the judgment, defendant appeals. Code Civil Proc.
- 15 N.Y.S. 490Donnelly v. Woolsey (1891)
<p>Motion for reargument.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 491Minor v. Baron (1891)
Action by Leman G. Minor, Jr., against Bernhard Baron and Henry Kraus. After plaintiff had rested his case, defendants moved for leave to amend their answer, which was denied. From a judgment entered on the verdict of a jury, and from an order denying a motion for a new trial made on the minutes of the court, defendants appeal.
- 15 N.Y.S. 491La Bau v. Huetwohl (1891)
<p>Appeal from special term, Kings county.</p> <p>Action by Richard R. La Bau and Alice J. La Bau against Frank Huet.wolil and another. From a judgment for plaintiffs, defendants appeal. Argued before Barnard, P. J., and Dykman and Pratt, JJ.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 492Weill v. Malone (1891)
Action by Elie Weill, Alphonse D. Weill, and Elle Lazard against Joseph Malone and Margaret McCabe, to recover for the conversion of certain steel shipped by plaintiffs to defendants to be used by defendants in their business, and to be paid for as used.
- 15 N.Y.S. 493Steffen v. Schaefer (1891)
Action by Aloys Steffen against Frank Schaefer and Joseph Gerard, for slander. Paragraphs 9,10,11 of the answér are as follows: “(9) The aforesaid defendants further show and state to this court as a special and separate defense herein that about five years ago they were members, and defendant Schaefer was the trustee, in the Catholic Church at Woodhaven, Queens county, and state of Hew York, and that said plaintiff was pastor of said church at the same time.
- 15 N.Y.S. 495Dexter v. Ivins (1891)
Action by Andrew J. Dexter against William Ivins and others to recover wages alleged to be due under a contract of hiring. From a judgment entered on the verdict for plaintiff, defendants appeal.
- 15 N.Y.S. 495Underhill v. Collins (1891)
<p>Appeal from circuit court, Kings county.</p> <p>Action by Jeronemus S. Underhill against Samuel Collins. From a judgment tor plaintiff, defendant appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 496People v. McHale (1891)
James McHale was indicted for grand larceny in the first degree, and from a judgment entered on a verdict of guilty defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 500In re Marvin (1891)
Petition by Francis Marvin, a tax-payer,. to compel James Williams, the county treasurer, to apply taxes derived from railroads to the satisfaction of bonds issued in aid of the construction thereof, as required by Laws Y. Y. 1869, c. 907. Pending the proceedings, the county treasurer died, and an order substituting his successor, William M. Murray, as defendant, was made, from which order defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 501Mahoney v. New York Central & Hudson River Railroad (1891)
Action by Anna Mahoney, administratrix of James Mahoney, deceased, against the New York Central & Hudson Biver Bailroad Company, lessee, to recover damages for the death of plaintiff’s intestate, who was killed while attempting to couple defendant’s cars in the night-time. From a judgment for plaintiff, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 502In re Gordon (1891)
Proceedings for the settlement of the accounts of Henry B. Gordon, administrator, with the will annexed, of Cuthbert C. Gordon, deceased. Prom a decree of the surrogate, settling and allowing the administrator’s account, 0. Gordon Bogart, executor of Cuthbert O. Gordon, deceased, appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 504Wright v. Reusens (1891)
Action by James B. Wright against Guillaume A.Beusens, impleaded with others. Prom a judgment for defendant, plaintiff appeals. Code Civil Proc. N. Y. § 3252, provides that “where an action is brought * * * to compel the determination of a claim to real property” a certain percentage on the value of the property, the claim to which is determined, shall be allowed the plaintiff as additional costs.
- 15 N.Y.S. 504People ex rel. Clinch v. Moore (1891)
<p>Application by Charles J. Clinch and others to review an order laying out a public highway.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 505McBride v. Orange County Railroad (1891)
Action by John McBride against the Orange County Bailroad Company to recover damages for breach of a contract by defendant to construct a grade crossing over its road for plaintiff’s use. From a judgment entered on a verdict for plaintiff, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 506Hynes v. Campbell (1891)
Action by Michael J. Hynes, who sues as well for himself as for others similarly situated, against William A. Campbell and Daniel Van Winkle, to require an accounting by said Campbell as assignee under an assignment made by Van Winkle for the benefit of his creditors. Plaintiff Hynes died pending the action, and Margaret Hynes and Henry H. Bowers, as administrators, were substituted as plaintiffs.
- 15 N.Y.S. 506Malone v. Knowlton (1891)
Action by Michael Malone against Gussie Knowlton, for personal injuries inflicted on plaintiff by a bull alleged in the complaint to have been kept by defendant on premises owned or occupied by her, well knowing him to be of a ferocious and mischievous disposition, and accustomed to attack mankind. From a judgment for $62.98 costs, entered on a verdict for defendant, plaintiff appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 508Quimby v. Claflin (1891)
Action by Charles J. Quimby against John Claflin and others, composing the firm ot' H. B. Claflin & Co., to recover the proceeds of certain notes or acceptances, amounting to $2,987, “made or drawn by divers parties, * * * left in the hands of the said defendants under a written contract or agreement bearing date April 12,1873, by which the said defendants acknowledged the receipt thereof, and agreed, in consideration of the premises, to collect, account for, and apply the…
- 15 N.Y.S. 509Larkin v. Brouty (1891)
<p>Appeal from special term, Westchester county.</p> <p>Action by-Francis Larkin against Barbara Brouty. From a judgment for plaintiff, defendant appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 509Rumsey v. New York & New England Railroad (1891)
<p>Appeal—Decision—Second Appeal.</p> <p>Where an appeal was taken to the court of appeals, the judgment reversed, and a new trial bad in conformity with the decision of the court of appeals, the case being substantially the same, the judgment entered therein will not be disturbed on a second appeal.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 510Sares v. Matthews (1891)
Action by Aaron R. Sares against John W. Matthews. From an order denying a motion for the relaxation of costs defendant appeals. Code Civil Proc. -FT.
- 15 N.Y.S. 510In re Ockershausen's Estate (1891)
Proceedings for the judicial settlement of the estate of Adolphus F. Ockershausen, deceased. From a decree directing the payment of a balance ascertained against him, the executor, George P. Ockershausen, appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 511Sanger v. Merritt (1891)
<p>Appeal from circuit court, Suffolk county.</p> <p>Action by Mary B. Sanger and others against John G. Merritt. From a judgment for defendant, plaintiffs appeal.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 512People v. Trezza (1891)
Indictment against Nicola Trezza for homicide. Defendant was convicted for murder in the first degree, and sentenced to be executed. The warrant directed that defendant be executed “in the mode, manner, and way and at the place by law prescribed and provided. ” Code Grim. Proc.
- 15 N.Y.S. 513People v. Trezza (1891)
Indictment against Nicola Trezza for homicide. Defendant was convicted of murder in the first degree, and from an order denying his motion fora new trial on the ground of newly-discovered evidence he appeals. Code Crim Proc.
- 15 N.Y.S. 514Fleer v. Finken (1891)
Action by Henry Fleer against John Finken and Gasper Koster, administrators of Treno J ung, deceased, on an account for board, lodging, and washing furnished decedent in her life-time. Plaintiff was decedent’s nephew, who occupied her house under an agreement that plaintiff should pay rent. Plaintiff presented an account beginning June 1, 1879, and ending June 1, 1887, on which there was allowed a credit for sums paid during the years 1885 and 1886.
- 15 N.Y.S. 514Cudahy v. Rinehart (1891)
Cross-appeals from special term, Kings county. Action by Patrick Cudahy and John Cudahy against Clarke D.-Rinehart, as sheriff of Kings county, to recover the proceeds of certain property sold under an attachment against John H. Yani and Patrick H. Turner. It appeared that several attachments had been issued against the debtors’ property, ■of which plaintiffs’ was first in point of time.
- 15 N.Y.S. 516In re Kings County Elevated Railway Co. (1891)
Application by the Kings County Elevated Railway Company to acquire title to certain interests in the real estate of Eliza J. Smith, on Fulton street, in the city of Brooklyn. From the appraisal and report of the commissioners, and from the order confirming such appraisal and report, petitioner appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 516People v. Miller (1891)
Jane Louisa Miller was convicted of keeping a disorderly house, and from a judgment of conviction, adjudging that defendant be confined in the Albany county péniténtiary for the term of six months at hard labor, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 517New York Chemical Co. v. Halleck (1891)
Action by the Hew York Chemipal Company against Richard F. Halleck. Defendant moves for injunction pendente lite restraining defendant from obstructing the plaintiff in the use of the factory, stable, and other property-now in the possession and under the control of the defendant, and revealing: the secret of the formula or preparation of a certain compound called “WashOut,” and from giving his services to any other person or persons than the plaintiff.
- 15 N.Y.S. 517In re Kings County Elevated Railway Co. (1891)
Application by the Kings County Elevated Railway Company to acquire title to certain interests in the real estate of Joseph Bryan on Pulton street, in the city of Brooklyn. From the appraisal and report of the commissioners, and from the order confirming such appraisal and report, petitioner appeals. For former report, see 12 N. Y. Supp. 198.
- 15 N.Y.S. 519Kaliski v. Pelham Park Railroad (1891)
Action by Frederick Kaliski against the Pelham Park Railroad Company for personal injuries. Plaintiff recovered $40 damages, and defendant moves for a taxation of costs in his favor.
- 15 N.Y.S. 520O'Brien v. Mayor of New York (1891)
Action by John O’Brien and others against the mayor, etc., of the city of New York, for moneys alleged to be due under a contract for constructing a portion of the new aqueduct.
- 15 N.Y.S. 528People v. Brickner (1891)
<p>1. Indictment—Setting Aside—Inherent Power of Court.</p> <p>Though the only grounds on which an indictment may be set aside on defendant’s motion are stated by Code Grim. Proo. N. Y. § 313, to be when the indictment is not properly indorsed, or when improper persons were permitted to be present during the session of the grand jury, the court has inherent power, in furtherance of justice, to set aside an indictment on the ground that there was no evidence before the grand j ury to support it, and that material illegal evidence was received by the grand jury.</p> <p>2. Conspiracy—Evidence—Setting Aside Indictment.</p> <p>An indictment for conspiracy cannot be sustained without proof of the fact of the conspiracy, and it cannot be aided by the averments of acts done in furtherance of the objects of the alleged conspiracy.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 533Wing v. De la Rionda (1891)
<p>Appeal from trial term.</p> <p>Action by Charles U. Wing against B. de la Rionda and others. There was a judgment for plaintiff, and defendants appeal.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 539In re Wolfe's Estate (1891)
Proceeding by the district attorney of the county of New York under Laws N. Y. 1887, c. 713, to compel legatees under will of Catharine L. Wolfe, deceased, to pay the collateral inheritance tax, and to impose a personal liability therefor, under the statute, upon the executors of testatrix’s will.
- 15 N.Y.S. 550Bohn v. Hatch (1891)
Action by Joseph and Catherine Bohn against Henry Zink and Albert Hatch to restrain defendants from prosecuting summary proceedings to remove plaintiffs from certain premises occupied by them. Henry Zink having died pending the action, the same was continued against defendant Hatch.
- 15 N.Y.S. 554Wood v. Davis (1891)
Actioh by William H. S. Wood against F. A. Davis. Plaintiff demurs to the answer on the ground that it does not state any defense or counter-claim to the action.
- 15 N.Y.S. 556Schneider v. Second-Avenue Railroad (1891)
Action by Frederick Schneider against the Second-Avenue Railroad Company and the Houston, West-Street & Pavonia Ferry Railroad Company. From a judgment for plaintiff entered on the verdict of a jury, and from an order denying their motions for a new trial, defendants appeal.
- 15 N.Y.S. 561Oakes v. De Lancey (1891)
Action by Thomas F. Oakes against Edward F. de Lancey to recover an amount alleged by plaintiff to have been overpaid by him to defendant on the purchase of a tract of land. The land was purchased as containing 22.57 acres at the price of $3,125 per acre. Plaintiff.alleged that it contained only 18.734, by reason of the fact that a portion of the premises were covered by the waters of Long Island sound.
- 15 N.Y.S. 562Lethbridge v. Mayor of New York (1891)
Action by Eugene Lethbridge against the mayor, etc., of Hew York city. The following opinion was filed by McAdam, J., before whom the case was tried without a jury: “ There was an appropriation sufficient to cover all the expenses of the department of public works at the time the plaintiff was appointed to the clerkship therein, so that the appointment was a valid exercise of power by the commissioner. The plaintiff passed the requisite civil service examination.
- 15 N.Y.S. 564Avery v. Jacob (1891)
Action by George P. Avery against William H. Jacob, as executor, and Josephine P. Clason, as executrix, of the will of Elizabeth Carter, deceased, to recover the value of services rendered to testatrix by plaintiff as an attorney and counselor at law.
- 15 N.Y.S. 573Baumgartel v. Providence Washington Insurance (1891)
Action by Louis H. Baumgartel against the Providence Washington Insurance Company of Providence, K. I., on a policy of fire insurance.
- 15 N.Y.S. 577Lawrenceville Cement Co. v. Parker (1891)
Action by the Lawrenceville Cement Company against S. Webber Parker, Charles Warren Parker, and Edward Burns, to set aside two deeds from S. Webber Parker to Charles Warren Parker, and a mortgage for $30,000 from Charles Warren Parker to Edward Burns.
- 15 N.Y.S. 579In re Citizens' Water-Works Co. (1891)
Application by the Citizens’ Water Works Company to condemn lands of David Parry and another. The application was denied by the special term, an appeal taken, and the order of the court below affirmed. From the order of affirmance an appeal was taken to the court of appeals, after which appellant moved for a reargument of the appeal from the special term.
- 15 N.Y.S. 579Goldberg v. New York Central & Hudson River Railroad (1891)
<p>Appeal from circuit court, Westchester county.</p> <p>Action by Philip Goldberg against the New York Central & Hudson River Railroad Company. From a judgment for plaintiff entered on the verdict of .a jury, and from an order denying a motion for a new trial defendant appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 580People ex rel. Morgan v. Board of Supervisors (1891)
Action by the people of the state of Hew York at the relation of Charles V. Morgan against the board of supervisors of Westchester county, under the statute for the protection of tax-payers, to restrain defendant from levying a tax for $25,000 illegally and fraudulently appropriated at a town meeting in Eastcliester to highway purposes.
- 15 N.Y.S. 581Cornell v. Skaneateles Railroad (1891)
Action by Walter H. Cornell and Amy Cornell against the SkaneatelesRailroad Company for injuries to plaintiffs’ horse while attempting to go over a private railroad crossing used by one McPeak. The crossing run into McPeak’s yard, and nowhere else. The highway runs north and south past McPeak’s house, and through the highway runs the railroad track of defendant, in front of McPeak’s house, which house is on the west side.
- 15 N.Y.S. 584Eylers v. Coens (1891)
<p>Appeal from city court of Yonkers.</p> <p>Action by John Eylers and John Hogan against Mary Coens. From a judgment for plaintiff's, defendant appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 585Becken v. Weeks (1891)
<p>Boundary Lines—Evidence.</p> <p>Where the location of a disputed boundary line of unfenced and uncultivated land in an action of trespass was dependent on evidence of matters occurring more than 40 years past, resting only in the memory of men from 70 to 80 years of age, from which it appeared that a certain road, tree, and fence were regarded as monuments of a boundary line, the court properly refused to disturb a verdict for plaintiff.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 586In re Blauvelt (1891)
<p>Appeal from surrogate’s court, Rockland county.</p> <p>Proceedings for the settlement of the accounts of Catherine Blauvelt and Julia F. Mansfield, executrices of the will-of Isaac L. Blauvelt, deceased. Testator’s widow sold certain of his real estate, and claimed the proceeds as her own. The will provided as follows: “First. I order all my debts and funeral expenses to be paid as soon as possible. Secondly. I give unto my wife, Catherine, during her widowhood, the use of all my real and personal estate, authorizing her to sell and dispose of any of my real estate as to her shall seem just, giving and executing all deeds and writings necessary to secure the purchasers in all rights of ownership, in the same manner as I could have done if living. After the death of my wife, Catherine, I order that my property be equally divided among my children,” etc. There was no further provision in the will as to the wife’s right to dispose of any of testator’s property. From a decree holding that the widow, Catherine Blauvelt, was-only entitled to a life-estate in the property devised, she appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 587Baldwin v. Citizens' Insurance (1891)
<p>1. Insurance—Waiver of Condition—Evidence.</p> <p>Plaintiff's insurance policy contained a provision that it should be void if the subject thereof was on ground not owned by the insured in fee-simple. Plaintiff’s broker, at the time of applying for the policy, stated to defendant’s assistant secretary that the land on which the house to be insured was situated belonged to the city of Brooklyn. The assistant secretary took time to consider the application, and then issued the policy to the broker. Held that, the policy having been issued with full notice that the building was on leased land, the condition requiring the inter- - est of the assured to be in fee was thereby waived.</p> <p>2. Same—Avoidance of Condition.</p> <p>Where an insurance policy contains a condition that the property insured shall be detached not less than 100 feet from other buildings, and the jury find that certain property insured was not detached the required distance, but that the risk to the property was not thereby increased, the insured, in case of loss, may recovei notwithstanding such condition.</p> <p>3. Same—Parol Evidence.</p> <p>A waiver of a condition of an insurance policy maybe shown by paroi evidence, though the policy calls for a written indorsement of the waiver thereon.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 588Crowther v. City of Yonkers (1891)
Action by Catherine Crowther against the city of Yonkers for injuries caused by falling into an unguarded sewer-trench on a dark night. Plaintiff’s mind became so affected after the accident that she was incompetent to testify. From a judgment entered on a verdict for plaintiff for $5,000, together with an extra allowance of $250, and $125.82 costs, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 589Shiels v. Wortman (1891)
<p>Motions for reargumenb.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 589Gaunt v. Taylor (1891)
Action by William I. Gaunt against Ira P. Taylor. A judgment in favor of plaintiff was reversed by the county court, and plaintiff appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 590Wright v. Reusens (1891)
<p>Mechanics’ Liens—Payment to Contractor—Certificate of Architect.</p> <p>Plaintiff contracted to do certain building for defendant, to be paid for in installments as the work progressed, on certificates of defendant’s architect that the work was done to his satisfaction. After a part of the work had been done, the architect unreasonably refused to give such certificate, and defendant thereupon discharged plaintiff. Held, in an action to foreclose a mechanic’s lien for the work done, that . judgment was properly entered for plaintiff on the report of a referee showing these " facts.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 591Van Slooten v. Wheeler (1891)
Proceeding by Mary L. Van Slooten against Charles H. Wheeler, as executor of the will of Harry E. Dodge, deceased, to establish against testator’s estate two claims, one for a diamond ring and the other for $20,000. The ■claim was disallowed, and the claimant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 596Hegeman v. Moon (1891)
Action by Joseph Hegeman against ChristinaS. Moon and Morse Burtis, as executors of the will of Cornelia W. Hegeman, deceased. A demurrer to the complaint was overruled, and defendants appeal.
- 15 N.Y.S. 597Klupp v. United Ice Lines (1891)
<p>1. Master and Servant—Defective Appliances—Knowledge of Master.</p> <p>When a servant is injured through a defect of machinery furnished by the master, knowledge of such defect must be brought home to the master, or proof given that he was ignorant of the same through want of proper care, in order to render him liable. Following Martin v. Cook, 14 IT. Y. Supp. 329.</p> <p>2. Same—Knowledge of Foreman.</p> <p>Where a foreman directs an employe to perform an act not manifestly improper in itself, and which the foreman had no reason to suspect could result in an accident, and from which the employe himself evidently did not anticipate danger, a prima facie case of negligence is not made out against the master merely by the happening of the accident. Following Martin v. Cook, 14 N. Y. Supp. 329.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 598Chadwick v. Brewsher (1891)
Action by James H. Chadwick against William Brewshér. The plaintiff was a journeyman house painter in the employ of the defendant, who was a master house painter. Plaintiff brought this action to recover damages because of injuries sustained by him in consequence of the fall of a scaffold upon which lie stood while engaged in the defendant’s service.
- 15 N.Y.S. 600Redding v. Redding (1891)
Action by Moses W. Bedding against Abbey L. Bedding for divorce. From an order denying a motion to set aside a decree for divorce entered therein defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 601In re Stewart's Will (1891)
<p>Appeal from surrogate’s court, Kings county.</p> <p>Proceedings for the probate of the last will of James Stewart, deceased. The will was propounded by testator’s widow, Eleanor Stewart, and James B. Aliben, and contested by James 0. Stewart, Gilla Alma Gates, and others, children of the testator. From a decree of the surrogate refusing probate of the will, proponents appeal.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 602McCulloch v. Dobson (1891)
•Appeal from judgment on report of referee. Action by Robert McCulloch against John and James Dodson. From a judgment for defendants, from an order refusing to set aside the report of the referee, and from an order refusing to set aside an extra allowance for costs, plaintiff appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 604Behrman v. Von Heyn (1891)
Case submitted on agreed statement. Action by MaryS. Behrman against MethaYon Heyn to compel the specific performance of a contract of sale of lands by acceptance of plaintiff’s title, the validity of which was denied by defendant. A case was agreed and submitted; and the facts therein contained, so far as necessary to an understanding of the point in dispute, are stated in the opinion.
- 15 N.Y.S. 605Kerr v. Hammer (1891)
Lawrence county court. Action by Alexander H. Kerr, as commissioner of highways of the town of Edwards, against Mary Hammer for encroachment on a highway. Eroin a judgment of the county court affirming a judgment of a justice of the peace, by which the fence of defendant was adjudged an encroachment on the highway, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 607Zimmer v. Matteson (1891)
Action by Alvah J. Zimmer against John J. Matteson and Hubbard L. Matteson. Code Civil Proc. § 780, enacts that, “where special provision is not otherwise made by law, or by the general rules of. practice, if notice of a motion, or of any other proceeding in an action before a court or a judge, is necessary, it must, if personally served, be served at least eight days before the time appointed for the hearing,” with exceptions under certain conditions.
- 15 N.Y.S. 607Crate v. Dacora (1891)
Action by Delia Crate against Jarvis Dacora for slander. From a judgement entered on a verdict for plaintiff, and from an order denying a motion -for a new trial, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 608Longstreet v. Sawyer (1891)
Action by Aaron Longstreet against Cyrus M. Sawyer and others. Plaintiff moves to vacate an order of the county judge, requiring security for costs. Code Civil Proc.
- 15 N.Y.S. 609Morgan v. Hudson River Ore & Iron Co. (1891)
<p>Appeal from circuit court, Columbia county.</p> <p>Action by Thomas F. Morgan against the Hudson River Ore & Iron Company. From a judgment entered on a verdict for plaintiff, defendant appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 612People v. Kane (1891)
Henry E. Kane and William Ford were indicted as follows: “The grana jury of the county of Suffolk by this indictment accuse Henry B.- Kane and William Ford of the crime of unlawfully and willfully injuring the personal property of another, committed as follows: The said Henry E. Kane and William Ford, now or late of the town of Smithtown, in the county of Suffolk, aforesaid, on the 8th day of July, 1890, at the town and county aforesaid, unlawfully injured and destroyed a…
- 15 N.Y.S. 613Shields v. New York Central & Hudson River Railroad (1891)
<p>Liability of Master—Action for Injuries—Contributory Negligence.</p> <p>Deceased had charge of the movement of all of defendant’s freight-cars in its yards at Poughkeepsie. On the day of his injury he directed a yard-engine to move a car of coal which was standing under a chute. After the engine was coupled to the car, deceased got on the car, and it moved off, and he was seen no more until found under a mass of coal, which had escaped through the trap at the bottom of the car. The chain which held the trap up had been broken and mended with wire two weeks before, and the bottom of the car had been repaired by putting boards into it to prevent the coal from falling through the trap, which could not be entirely closed. Deceased was aware of the defective condition of the car. Held, that the question whether deceased was guilty of contributory negligence in the use of the car was properly submitted to the jury, and that their verdict for plaintiff would not be disturbed.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 614Olena v. Huntington (1891)
<p>Appeal from circuit court, Kings county.</p> <p>Action by Theophilus D. Olena against Austin Huntington. From a judgment for plaintiff, defendant appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 615Haynes v. Hatch (1891)
Action by Edward Haynes against Edward Hatch. Plaintiff moved for an order for the examination of defendant in order to enable plaintiff to prepare his complaint.
- 15 N.Y.S. 616Toub v. Schmidt (1891)
<p>Appeal from Orange county court.</p> <p>Action by Benjamin Toub against Adam Schmidt. From a judgment for plaintiff, defendant appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 618Clark v. Corwin (1891)
Action by Ruama Clark, administratrix of Ruama Wilcox, deceased, against one Wheeler, and Susan M. Corwin and Gilbert L. Noble, executors of .James Corwin, deceased, to recover on a promissory note, the defense to which was forgery.
- 15 N.Y.S. 618People ex rel. Crouse v. Leavitt (1891)
Application by Orville Crouse for a writ of habeas corpus to John E. Leavitt, as sheriff of Fulton county. The writ was dismissed, and relator appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 620Van Tassell v. Manhattan Eye & Ear Hospital (1891)
' Action by Bruce Van Tassell against the Manhattan Eye & Ear Hospital to recover damages for the alleged negligent treatment of plaintiff while a patient in defendant hospital, whereby plaintiff lost the sight of one of his eyes. Prom a judgment for plaintiff, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 622Donohue v. Whitney (1891)
<p>Boundaries—Hearsay Evidence—Ancient Maps.</p> <p>In an action involving the location of the boundary line between the lands of plaintiff and defendant, it appeared that the lands were part of an ancient grant, and were wild, unfenced mountain land.. The deeds to the parties referred to the “Livingston line” as the boundary, but neither deed contained sufficient data to locate the line. At the time of the conveyance, 30 years before the action was brought, and before any controversy had arisen as to the Livingston line, plaintiff’s grantor had a survey and map made of the premises conveyed to plaintiff, and also of an adjoining tract conveyed to one W. The surveyor, since dead, went around plaintiff’s parcel, and pointed out to plaintiff the corners and monuments as he (the surveyor) had established or identified them. The m&p remained in the possession of W. Plaintiff’s surveyor testified that he found some of the monuments which the deceased surveyor had established. Held, that the map made by the deceased surveyor and the deed to W., and certified copies of older maps of the patent of which the land in question was part, which were on file in the office of the secretary of state, and on which the Livingston line was marked, were admissible, in the absence of better evidence, as indicating common reputation as to the location of the line.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 624Consumers' Gas & Electric Light Co. v. Congress Spring Co. (1891)
Action by the Consumers’ Gas & Electric Light Company against the Congress Spring Company and Hiram A. Hays to restrain defendants from removing a pole placed by plaintiff in the street in front of the premises of defendant the Congress Spring Company.
- 15 N.Y.S. 626Doyle v. Rector (1891)
<p>Appeal—Review—Presumptions.</p> <p>Where the evidence adduced on the trial is not set out in the case on appeal, it will he presumed that the findings are justified by the evidence. Pratt, J., dissenting.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 627People ex rel. Wallace v. Ryan (1891)
<p>.Emotions and Voters—Nominations—Printing Ballots.</p> <p>Under Laws N. Y. 1890, o. 262, which provides that all ballots to be used in any election for public office shall be printed at the public expense, and that any assemblage of voters or delegates representing a political party which, at the last election before the convention, polled at least 1 per cent, of the entire vote cast, may make nomination to public office, tickets containing the names of persons nominated by a convention pursuant to “a call for a meeting of Republicans” will be ordered printed at the public expense, and it cannot be objected that the convention did not represent the Republican party.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 628Nanny v. Fancher (1891)
Action by Oliver T. Nanny against Amzi L. Rancher and others. Rrom the complaint it appears that in October, 1869, defendant named entered into an agreement with Juliet Nanny and others for the purchase and sale of a farm containing 100 acres, which had belonged to the father of all the parties, and had on his death descended to them, subject to the dower right of his wife, Maria Rancher.
- 15 N.Y.S. 630People v. Hulett (1891)
Prosecution of William H. M. Hulett for keeping a disorderly house. From a judgment of the court of sessions affirming a judgment of the recorder’s-court of Gloversville, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 632Warner v. Schoharie & Schenectady Counties Farmers' Mutual Fire Insurance (1891)
Action by Phillip J. Warner against Schoharie, and Schenectady Counties Farmers’ Mutual Fire Insurance Company upon an insurance certificate issued by the defendant to the plaintiff for $450 on hay and grain, and $125 on farming utensils, to run from September 7, 1889, to September-7, 1894. On the 11th of December, 1889, the property was destroyed by fire, This action was brought to recover the loss.
- 15 N.Y.S. 635People v. New York, Chicago & St. Loius Railroad (1891)
Case submitted on agreed statement of facts. Proceedings against the New York, Chicago & St. Louis Railroad Company to determine the liability of defendant to pay the organization tax imposed by Laws N. Y. 1886, c. 143.
- 15 N.Y.S. 644People ex rel. Blakslee v. Commissioners of Land-Office (1891)
Certiorari at the relation of E. G. Blakslee to review the action of the commissioners of the land-office in granting land under water in the Hudson river, near Sing Sing, to the E. L. Blakslee Manufacturing Company.
- 15 N.Y.S. 647Woolsey v. Trustees of Ellenville (1891)
Action by Rachel A. Woolsey against the trustees of the village of Ellen-ville for an alleged injury to the. plaintiff from falling upon the sidewalk of the village of Ellenville,. which the plaintiff claims were negligently permitted to be out of repair by the defendants, by reason of which the plaintiff was injured. The jury rendered a verdict in favor of the plaintiff for $5,000, on which judgment was rendered, and the.defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 649In re Malone Water-Works Co. (1890)
Application by the Malone Water-Works Company for the appointment of commissioners to appraise damages for water taken for petitioner’s uses under Laws 2L Y. 1857, c. 156, entitled “An act to incorporate the Malone WaterWorks Company,” as amended by Laws 2L Y. 1868, c. 148; Laws If. Y. 1886, c. 161; Laws If. Y. 1870, c. 291; Laws 1879, c. 129; and Laws If. Y. ' 1890, c. 36.
- 15 N.Y.S. 657Freeman v. Glens Falls Paper-Mill Co. (1891)
Action by Louisa Freeman, administratrix, etc., of George Freeman, deceased, against the Glens Falls Paper-Mill Company, for the alleged negligence of the defendant in the construction and operation of its pulp-mills, by reason of which the plaintiff’s intestate was killed while engaged as an employe of the defendant in repairing the mills, where he had been engaged in ■similar service for four or five weeks immediately prior to the accident by which he was killed.
- 15 N.Y.S. 657In re Long (1891)
Motion at general term to retax costs on appeal to general term. Application by Edward B. Long and others, as trustees of the village of White Plains, to acquire land for the purpose of sewers. From an intermediate order made by the court at special term in Dutchess county, overruling certain issues raised by land-owner’s answer, after a trial of the issues of fact, the land-owner- appealed to the general term, which affirmed the order, with costs.
- 15 N.Y.S. 662Broadway & Seventh-Avenue Railroad v. Metzger (1891)
Summary proceedings by the Broadway & Seventh-Avenue Railroad Company against Lewis Metzger and one Schiff. Judgment was entered on a verdict fur defendants, and plaintiff appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 664Thebaud v. Hume (1891)
Action in ejectment by John J. Thebaud against Eliza Hume and others. From an order “for an examination of plaintiff as to the source and character of tlie title to the lands mentioned in the complaint,” plaintiff appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 670Campanello v. New York Central & Hudson River Railroad (1891)
Action by Dominico A. Campanello, by guardian, against the Hew York Central & Hudson Biver Bailroad Company. From an order granting a motion made by plaintiff to set aside a verdict in favor of defendant and granting a new trial, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 671Meissner v. Brennan (1891)
<p>Appeal from special term.</p> <p>Action by Henry J. Meissner against Michael B. Brennan. From an order granting a new trial plaintiff appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 673Mullenhoff v. Gensler (1891)
<p>Real-Estate Agents—Right to Commissions.</p> <p>Defendant authorized plaintiff to sell a piece of property for him, his proposal being “to sell for 810,000 if a purchaser were produced with $10,000 the next morning. ” Plaintiff produced a person who wanted to buy it for $10,000, and who could pay cash for it if given about 30 days to raise the money upon his property already owned. Held., in an action to recover commissions, that plaintiff did not produce a party able, willing, and ready to accept defendant’s offer, and was not entitled to commissions. Distinguishing Hart v. Hoffman, 44 How. Pr. 168, and Duelos v. Cunningham, 103 N. Y. 678, 6 N. E. Rep. 790.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 674Flechter v. Franko (1891)
<p>Service of Process—Privilege of Witness—Supplementary Proceedings.</p> <p>• A resident debtor, while attending court as a witness, is not exempt from service of an order for his examination in supplementary proceedings.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 675Becker v. Janinski (1891)
<p>Action by Bosa Becker against Janinski, a physician, for malpractice, • $50,000 being claimed as damages.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 679Turney v. Guthrie (1891)
Action by Thomas Turney against James J. Guthrie for the conversion of money. Judgment for plaintiff. Defendant moves to set aside a body execution.
- 15 N.Y.S. 680People ex rel. Cosford v. Board of Supervisors (1891)
- 15 N.Y.S. 683Monzani v. Monzani (1891)
Action by Bichard P. Monzani against Julian T. Monzani and Eliza J. Monzani to set aside a decree foreclosing a mortgage on certain land, and to procure an adjudication that plaintiff was the owner of such land. In 1876, plaintiff’s mother, who was the owner of the land, then subject to mortgages amounting to $800, died intestate.
- 15 N.Y.S. 684People ex rel. New York, Lake Erie & Western Railroad v. Zoeller (1891)
Certiorari against Frederick Zoeller and others, assessors of the town of Alden, and another, to review the assessment of property of the New York, Lake Erie & Western Railroad Company for the year 1388.
- 15 N.Y.S. 689Weinckie v. New York Central & Hudson River Railroad (1891)
Action by Delia Weinckie against the New York Central & Hudson River Railroad Company, to recover damage alleged to have been sustained by her in the depreciation of the value of her property in Schenectady by the act of the defendant in closing up Liberty street, in that city, and erecting a footbridge across the railroad track about 20 feet above the track, parallel or nearly parallel with the original line of the street, which acts are alleged to have been done in…
- 15 N.Y.S. 694Barney v. Fuller (1891)
Action by Martin Barney against Louis E. Fuller and Truman K. Fuller. From a judgment entered on a verdict for plaintiff for $2,208.47, and from an order denying a motion for a new trial on the judge’s minutes, defendants appeal.
- 15 N.Y.S. 697Walsh v. Mutual Life Insurance (1891)
<p>Appeal from special term, Albany county.</p> <p>Action by Patrick E. Walsh, assignee, against the Mutual Life Insurance Company. From an order overruling a demurrer to plaintiff’s complaint, defendant appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 701Rowland v. Miller (1891)
<p>Action by Mary Eliza Rowland against Charles Miller and the Taylor Company to enjoin the use of certain premises for a purpose alleged to be “injurious and offensive to the neighboring inhabitants.”</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 705Corrigan v. Coney Island Jockey Club (1891)
<p>Action by Edward Corrigan against the Coney Island Jockey Club for a mandatory injunction to compel defendant to permit plaintiff’s colt to enter a race.</p> <p>The plaintiff is in the business of breeding and running race-horses for purses and stakes at the different race tracks, having stables on all of them. The defendant is engaged in conducting a race track at Sheepshead Bay, Kings county, N. Y. One of its objects is to improve the breed of horses, and for that purpose stakes and purses are made up, and horses are run to test their, power, speed, and endurance. Entrance fees are paid by those entering horses; and these, together with a purse contributed by the defendant, form the “stake, ” which is either given to the owner of the horse winning the race, or divided in certain proportions among the owners of the first, second, and third horses. These stakes are open for entries many months, and sometimes two or three years, before the day fixed for the running of the race. In stake races, each owner is compelled to enter his horse before a certain date, and to pay a certain amount, which is forfeited in ease the owner shall, within a certain time, declare that his horse shall not enter the contest. Among the stake races so arranged by the defendant is one called the “Futurity.” This is a stake race in which the owner of a mare in foal enters the get of such mare to run at the age of two years. Thus, the entry to the Futurity must be made more than two years before the day fixed for the race, and actually before the horse which is to take part in it is born. In the year 1888 the defendant opened entries for a race known as the “Futurity, ” to be run on Saturday, August 29, 1891, and in providing fpr it offered great pecuniary inducements to breeders and owners falling within said conditions, provided their animals developed superior endurance and speed, and came in, at the termination of the race, first, second, or third. In accordance with these • terms, Gen. Jackson, the owner of the Belle Meade stud farm of Nashville, entered for the race the get of a certain thoroughbred mare known as “Brunette,” then in foal, which had been covered during the year 1888 by a certain thoroughbred race-horse known as “Iroquois.” In the spring of 1889 the mare foaled a certain bay colt, which was named “Huron.” On April 25, 1890, the colt, then known as a “yearling,” was purchased at auction by the plaintiff. The catalogue described the pedigree of the colt, and contained these words: “Eligible to Coney Island Futurity, 1891. ” The plaintiff claims that the purchase included the entry, or what is technically known as “the engagement,” of the colt, and that he became entitled to run said colt in the race. The horse is ready for the contest, but the defendant refuses to permit it to take part, although it is conceded the colt was properly entered, and the plaintiff had offered to pay the $250 fee required and comply with all the conditions precedent. The stake is about $70,000, and unless the colt is allowed to take part in the race, the damages will be irreparable, because incapable of oral or written proof. If the colt wins the stake, its value will be increased, while no injury can result to the defendant by allowing it to run. Upon these facts, the plaintiff, by bill in equity, applies for a mandatory injunction in the natur.; of a specific performance, to the end that the defendant be enjoined from preventing the colt from running according to the agreement aforesaid.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 707Lawson v. Stanley (1891)
Action by Frederick B. Lawson against Davis A. Stanley and the Harris .& Dew Faucet, Plug & Bung Company. Plaintiff sued as well for the benefit of himself as of all other stockholders of defendant company, similarly situated, and who may come in and contribute to the prosecution thereof and become parties thereto. The corporation was created September 9, 1882, with a capital of $800,000, for the manufacture and sale of plugs and bungs.
- 15 N.Y.S. 711People ex rel. Edison Electric Illuminating Co. v. Wemple (1891)
Certiorari at the relation of the Edison Illuminating Company of New York, to review the proceedings of Edward Wemple, comptroller of the state of New York, in levying and assessing taxes upon the franchise and business of the relator, under chapter 542 of the Laws'of 1880, and the various acts amendatory thereof and supplementary thereto, and in declining to revise and readjust such taxes.
- 15 N.Y.S. 718People ex rel. Brush Illuminating Electric Co. v. Wemple (1891)
Certiorari, at the relation of the Brush Illuminating Electric Company, to review an assessment and taxes imposed by Edward Wemple, comptroller of ■the state of Hew York, upon the relator, under chapter 542 of the Laws of 1880, and the various acts amendatory thereof.
- 15 N.Y.S. 720Wurz v. Wurz (1891)
Action by Charles Wurz against Katherine Wurz, his wife, for partition of lands conveyed to plaintiff and defendant to hold as joint tenants.
- 15 N.Y.S. 721Boyd v. Kerwin (1891)
<p>Preliminary Injunction—Doubtful Terms—“Tenement-House. ”</p> <p>The question whether apartment houses or “flats” are “tenement-houses” within the meaning of an 'agreement not to erect on certain premises “any house of the character or description commonly known as ‘ tenement-houses,’ ” is not so reasonably free from doubt as to authorize a preliminary injunction in an action to restrain the erection of “flats” on such premises.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 724City of Schenectady v. Furman (1891)
Action by the city of Schenectady against Robert Furman to recover the cost of grading a water-course running through defendant’s land. Judgment for plaintiff. Defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 729In re Stark's Estate (1891)
Application by Emily Chase, as a person interested in the trust fund in the hands of the testamentaiy trustee, for an order under sections 2807, 2808, and 2809 of the Code of Civil Procedure, requiring the trustee to show cause •why he should not render and settle his accounts.
- 15 N.Y.S. 734Fifth Avenue Bank v. Parker (1891)
Action by the Fifth Avenue Bank of New York against Samuel W. Parker. Jndgment was entered on a verdict for plaintiff, and pending an appeal therefrom defendant (appellant) moved to insert in the case on appeal certain exceptions to rulings made at the trial, which were not then taken.
- 15 N.Y.S. 735Granger v. Lyman (1891)
<p>Action by William H. Granger against Margaret Ann Lyman to set aside a judgment confessed to defendant by debtors of plaintiff as well as of defendant.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 737Sistare v. Heckscher (1891)
Action by Margaret Sistare against Austin Heckscher to have a deed theretofore executed by her declared null and void, and for a reconveyance to her.
- 15 N.Y.S. 739Starr v. Patterson (1891)
Action by Charles F. Starr against Charles Gordon Patterson on two promissory notes executed by defendant to plaintiff. Plaintiff having obtained a judgment and issued execution thereon, defendant moved for a perpetual stay of the execution, on the ground that he liad obtained a discharge from all his debts under the insolvency laws of Massachusetts. The matter was referred to IS.
- 15 N.Y.S. 741Marvin v. Rector (1891)
<p>Wills—Construction.</p> <p>A will bequeathing $25,000 to a library for the purchase of oil paintings which shall “possess merit as works of art, ” and $5,000 for “useful and suitable books, ” both of which the executors are to procure and “deliver, ” and bequeathing all the rest of the estate to a residuary legatee, must be construed as intending that the expense of procuring and delivering the books and pictures shall be paid out of the legacies to the library.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 743Hoag v. Town of Greenwich (1891)
<p>1. Railroad Aid Bonds—Issuance by Town—Validity.</p> <p>Laws N. Y. 1869, c. 907, amending the general railroad act, authorized any municipal corporation, through commissioners, to aid any railroad company by issuing its bonds payable 30 years from date. Laws N. Y. 1871, c. 925, passed May 12th, provided that the commissioners might issue the said bonds payable at any time they might elect, less than 30 years. But they shall not so issue said bonds that more than 10 per ci nt of the principal of the whole amount of bonds issued shall become due or payable in any one year. Held, that bonds issued for said purpose by a town prior to May 12,1871, payable 20 years after date, are void. Potter v. Greenwich, 92 Ñ. Y. 062, followed.</p> <p>2. Same—Rights of Purchasers.</p> <p>But bonds issued by the commissioners after May 12,1871, payable 20 years after date, are valid, though more than 10 per cent, of the whole amount issued became due in one year, since a purchaser had no means of knowing the amount falling due in any one year.</p> <p>8. Judgment—Res Judicata.</p> <p>The complaint in Potter v. Greenwich, 92 N. Y. 662, alleged in the first count that by mistake the bonds were made payable in 20 instead of 30 years. The second offered to surrender the bonds as illegal. The third was a simple count for money paid and laid out for the city’s benefit, and a reformation of the bond or recovery of the amount was demanded. Defendant’s demurrers to the second and third counts were overruled, but judgment was rendered for plaintiff only on the first count. The general term reversed tbe judgment on the first count, and sustained the demurrers. The court of appeals affirmed the judgment- of the supreme court, and dismissed the complaint, but not on the merits. Held, that such judgment constituted no bar to a subsequent action on the same bonds, under Code Civil Proc. N. Y. § 1209, which provides that “a final judgment dismissing a complaint * * * does not prevent a new action for the same cause of action, unless .it expressly declares or it appears by the judgment roll that it is rendered upon the merits. ”</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 748People ex rel. Bliss v. Board of Supervisors (1891)
William Y. Bliss applied for a writ of mandamus to the board of supervisors of Cortland county to audit and allow his bill of $150 for six days’ services as an expert physician and witness in a murder trial, rendered, as lie alleged, on an agreement with the district attorney that lie should receive $25 per day therefor. An alternative writ was allowed.
- 15 N.Y.S. 752Hudson River Telephone Co. v. Watervliet Turnpike & Railroad (1891)
Action by the Hudson River Telephone Company against the Watervliet Turnpike & Railroad Company, for an injunction to restrain defendant from operating its electric railway. Plaintiff appeals from a judgment entered upon the report of a referee dismissing the complaint.
- 15 N.Y.S. 763Hudson River Telephone Co. v. Watervliet Turnpike & Railroad (1891)
<p>Costs—Additional Allowance.</p> <p>In an action by a telephone company against an electric railway company, in which plaintiff seeks nothing more than to restrain defendant from operating its road along a certain portion of a street, an additional allowance under Code Civil Proc. N. Y. § 3353, providing that in a difficult or extraordinary case the court may award, as additional costs, a sum not exceeding 5 per cent, on “the sum recovered or claimed, or the value of the subject-matter involved, ” is properly refused on the ground that there is no basis on which an allowance can be estimated.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 765Rumsey v. Boutwell (1891)
Action by Israel P. Rumsey and another against Charles A. Boutwell, as •surviving partner, etc., to recover the balance due on a purchase of corn. There was a judgment for plaintiffs, and defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 765Quilty v. Battie (1891)
<p>Appeal from circuit court, Washington county.</p> <p>Action by Josie Quilty, an infant, etc., against Bebecca B. Battie and Joseph M. Battie to recover damages for the bite of a dog. There was judgment for plaintiff, and defendants appeal.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 768In re Champion's Estate (1890)
Proceedings for the settlement of the estate of Thomas Champion, deceased.
- 15 N.Y.S. 770In re Hulse's Estate (1890)
<p>Proceedings to subj'eet the estate of Sarah M. Hulse, deceased, to the payment of the legacy tax.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 775In re City of Buffalo (1891)
Motion by the corporation counsel of the city of Buffalo to confirm a report-of commissioners fixing compensation to be paid by the city for taking the fee of land within the boundaries of The Terrace and Washington streets, in that city. See 15 N. Y. Supp. 123.
- 15 N.Y.S. 778People v. Olson (1891)
Gottschalk Olson and others were indicted for a conspiracy to cheat and defraud the city of Buffalo. Defendants demur to the indictment.
- 15 N.Y.S. 781Niagara Falls Cider & Vinegar Co. v. Knell (1891)
<p>Action by theNiagara Fails Cider & Vinegar Company against Lewis Knell. Plaintiff moves to strike out the amended answer as sham.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 782Mixer v. Schreiner (1891)
<p>Action by Harrison B. Mixer and others against Niekolaus Schreiner. Plaintiffs move for judgment on the answer as frivolous.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 783Pullutro v. Delaware, Lackawanna & Western Railroad (1891)
Action by Giovanni Pullutro against the Delaware, Lackawanna & Western Railroad Company for personal injuries. There was a verdict for plaintiff, and defendant moves for a new trial on the minutes of the trial judge.
- 15 N.Y.S. 785Covart v. Johnston (1891)
<p>Appeal from circuit court, Sullivan county.</p> <p>Action by James M. Covart against John M. Johnston. There was a judgment for plaintiff, and defendant appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 787Schuyler v. Curtis (1891)
<p>At chambers. Action by Philip Schuyler against Ernest Curtis, Alice Donlevy, and others for an injunction. Plaintiff moves for the continuance ■of a preliminary injunction. Granted.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 789Pratt v. Poole (1891)
Action by Mary Pratt against Sidney G. Poole and others to foreclose a mortgage given by Poole and wife to John Henry Elliott and others, April 2, 1883, to secure the payment of $5,000, May 1, 1885. This mortgage was on January 7, 1889, assigned by the mortgagees to plaintiff for the consideration of $350, at which time (as found by the referee) there, was due to the mortgagees for principal and interest of their debt over $5,000.
- 15 N.Y.S. 790Ogden v. Welden (1891)
Action by Caroline E. Ogden and others against George W. Welden to restrain defendant from moving and repairing a barn within the fire limits of the city of Binghamton. There was a judgment for defendant, and plaintiffs appeal.
- 15 N.Y.S. 793Jackson v. Town of Fort Covington (1891)
- 15 N.Y.S. 795Taylor v. Town of Constable (1891)
Action by Herbert M. Taylor against the town of Constable for injuries sustained by the fall of a defective bridge in defendant town while plaintiff was driving on it. Plaintiff was nonsuited, and on his appeal the judgment was reversed, and a new trial granted. 10 H. Y. tiupp. 607. On the second trial he obtained a verdict, and from the judgment entered thereon defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 795Gaylord v. Board of Supervisors (1891)
<p>Mandamus—Formal Order—Entry Nuno pro Tunc.</p> <p>The failure to make and enter the formal order on the granting of an alternative writ of mandamus is no ground for setting aside the mandamus, as the entry of the order is a mere clerical duty, and the same will be allowed to be entered nunc pro tune.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 798In re Vedder's Will (1891)
Judicial settlement of the trustees and executors, etc., of Nicholas S. Tedder, deceased. Nicholas S. Tedder died in 1879, leaving a will, which was shortly thereafter duly admitted to probate by the surrogate of Rensselaer county. He left, him surviving, a widow, Nancy A. Tedder, but no children or descendants. Ida Angelí, a child of about nine years of age, was a member of his family at the time of his decease, and had been such for about six years.
- 15 N.Y.S. 809Lorillard v. Clyde (1891)
Action by Jacob Lorillard against William P. Clyde and another for money alleged to be due under a contract. The pla.ntiif and delendants were engaged in the business of transporting freight between Kew York and Philadelphia. The plaintiff owned what was called the “outside” line, and the defendants ran what was known as the “inside” route. They were competing for trade, a course detrimental to both.
- 15 N.Y.S. 815People v. Rose (1891)
<p>Edward W. Bose was indicted for burglary, petit larceny, and receiving stolen goods, and he demurs to the indictments.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 817In re Carpenter (1891)
Application by Elvira J3. Carpenter for the appointment of a new trustee in the place of George A. Pierce, deceased. The application was granted, and the administrator of Pierce appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 818O'Neil v. Battie (1891)
Action by Minnie O’Neil, by her father as guardian ad litem, against Fred. Held: and Bat-tie was duly elected trustee. He thereupon refused to allow plaintiff to continue to teach the school, whereupon she brought this action to recover for services rendered under the contract, and for damages for its breach by defendant. The court directed a verdict for plaintiff. Defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 819Gardenier v. Eldred (1891)
Action begun by Lovinia Downs against Hiram Eldred. After the complaint had been dismissed, and costs of a subsequent motion awarded defendant, the cause of action was assigned to Wilson H. Gardenier, who was after-wards substituted as plaintiff. Without paying the costs of the motion, plaintiff served a notice of appeal from the judgment on defendant, and afterwards served on him the case and exceptions.
- 15 N.Y.S. 821People ex rel. Egan v. Columbia Club (1891)
Application by Patrick J. Egan for an alternative writ of mandamus against the Columbia Club to compel relator’s reinstaiment as a member.
- 15 N.Y.S. 822Leonard v. Bowman (1891)
Action by Charles P. Leonard against James P. Bowman and Edward J. Boshart. Plaintiff obtained an order for the examination of a third person, in supplemental proceedings, under Code Civil Proc.
- 15 N.Y.S. 823Grindal v. De Lano (1891)
Action by Herbert W. Grindal against George W. De Lano. From so much of an order opening an inquest as imposes $30 costs, and directs that the judgment in plaintiff’s favor stand as security, as a condition of granting the same, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 825Kruse v. Seeger & Guernsey Co. (1891)
Action by Charles Kruse against the Seeger & Guernsey Company. From a judgment entered on the verdict of a jury in favor of the plaintiff and from the order denying a new trial defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 825Luce v. Knowlton (1891)
<p>Deposition—Use by Adverse Party—Harmless Error.</p> <p>Though it is error to refuse to allow plaintiff to read in evidence on his own behalf a deposition taken at defendant’s instance, it is of no avail for a reversal of the court’s ruling dismissing the complaint where such deposition contains no evidence to sustain plaintiff’s case.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 826Blumenthal v. Hudson River Boot & Shoe Manufacturing Co. (1891)
<p>Attachment—Domestic Corporations—“Principal Place oe Business.’’</p> <p>Under Code Civil Proc. N. Y. § 3169, allowing writs of attachment to issue out of the city court of New York against “a domestic corporation whose principal place of business is not within the city of New York, ” the “principal place of business”' is that designated as such in the certificate of incorporation or amended certificate p and, that not being within the city of New York, it is immaterial that the corporation has a place of business in the city.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 836Matthiessen v. Kohlsaat (1891)
<p>Usury as a Defense—Failure to Plead.</p> <p>Though there is evidence from which a jury might have found that defendant agreed to pay usurious interest had the issue been presented to them, defendant cannot avail himself of the defense of usury, where his only plea was the general denial, and usury does not conclusively appear as matter of law from the evidence.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 837Murphy v. Suburban Rapid Transit Co. (1891)
Action by Mary Murphy against the Suburban Bapid Transit Company for personal injuries caused by defendant’s alleged negligence in maintaining a defective platform approach to the stairway leading to the footway of its bridge across the Harlem river. There was a verdict for plaintiff for $5,000. From a judgment thereon, and from an order denying its motion for a new trial, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 838Fleeman v. Fleeman (1891)
Action by Adam Fleeman, Jr., against Olive E. Fleeman and others, to settle conflicting claims to the proceeds of-a certificate of membership issued by the Masonic Life Association of Western Hew York to Adam Fleeman, deceased.
- 15 N.Y.S. 841Murzynowski v. Delaware, Lackawanna & Western Railroad (1891)
Action by Magdalena Murzynowski, as administratrix of Paul Murzynowski, deceased, against the Delaware, Lackawanna & AVestein Railroad Company. Defendant moves to set aside a verdict for plaintiff, and for a new trial on the judge’s minutes.
- 15 N.Y.S. 844Reinhardt v. City of Buffalo (1891)
Action by William Reinhardt and another against the city oí Buffalo to set- aside :m assessment made on the property benefited, to pay for opening a street. A land-owner had opened an alley through his land in the line of the street, and had sold lots abutting thereon, and buildings were erected on such lots; but the alley was never accepted by the city, and the land embraced in the alley was taxed as the private property of the land-owner.
- 15 N.Y.S. 849Hope v. Brewer (1891)
<p>Action by John Hope against William Brewer, Jr., and others, as executors of the will of Thomas Hope, deceased.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 851Crouse v. Whittlesey (1891)Reversed
Motion by Walter Whittlesey, a judgment debtor, to procure the judgment to be discharged of record, on the ground that he had been discharged in bankruptcy from the payment thereof.
- 15 N.Y.S. 852Smith v. Harrigan (1891)
At chambers. Action by Orison B. Smith, as trustee, against Susan Har- ' rigan to foreclose a mortgage. The property having been sold under a decree of foreclosure, the purchaser refused to take title, and plaintiff now moves for an order that the purchaser be held for any deficiency that may arise on a resale.
- 15 N.Y.S. 855McCarthy v. Innis (1891)
<p>Appeal from special term, New York county.</p> <p>Action by Charles P. McCarthy against William J. Innis -for libel. From an order denying defendant’s motion for costs, defendant appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 857Grimshaw v. Woolfall (1891)
Action by Robert Grimshaw against Frederick Hartley Woolfall and others. Defendants demurred to the complaint on the grounds (1) that there was a misjoinder of causes of action; and (2) that the complaint aid not state facts sufficient to constitute a cause of action.
- 15 N.Y.S. 858In re City of Buffalo (1891)
Motion to confirm awards of the commissioners in proceedings instituted by the city of Buffalo to condemn land for public parks.
- 15 N.Y.S. 863Duff v. Mayor of New York (1891)
Exceptions from jury term. Action by Fannie J. Duff against the mayor, aldermen, and commonalty of the city of Yew York for personal injuries caused by stepping into a hole which defendants negligently suffered to exist in a cross-walk at the intersection of two streets.
- 15 N.Y.S. 864Akersloot v. Second Avenue Railroad (1891)
Action by George C. Akersloot, an infant, by Henry S. Akersloot, his guardian, against the Second-Avenue Railroad Company, for personal injuries.
- 15 N.Y.S. 865In re Board of Street Opening (1891)
Application by the board of street opening and improvement of New York city, on behalf of the mayor, etc., for the opening of Lexington avenue from 97th street to 102d street, in that city. From an order denying a motion to discontinue the proceedings, the New York Elevated Railroad Company appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 867In re Clarke's Estate (1891)
Petition by Eliza W. Clarke, as administratrix with the will annexed of David Clarke, deceased, and acting as trustee under the will, for leave to mortgage real estate of said testator.
- 15 N.Y.S. 868Richardson v. New York Central & Hudson River Railroad (1891)
Action by Ida G. Richardson, by her guardian ad litem, against the New York Central & Hudson River Railroad Company, for personal injuries. From a judgment entered on á verdict for plaintiff, and from an order denying a motion for a new trial, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 870Wilder v. Stace (1891)
<p>Appeal from Monroe county court.</p> <p>Action by Samuel Wilder against William O. Stace. The action was first tried in the municipal court of Bochester. Erom a judgment entered on a verdict, and from an order denying a motion for a new trial on the minutes, defendant appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 872Rock v. Retsoff Mining Co. (1891)
Action by Edward Rock against tile Retsoff Mining Company to recover for personal injury. From a judgment dismissing complaint and denying motion for new trial plaintiff appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 873Lathrop v. Ellsworth (1891)
Action by Edward F. Lathrop and Harry E. Lathrop against Henry M. Ellsworth, John Luther, John J. Blake, and another. From a judgment, entered on the findings and decision of the court plaintiffs appeal.
- 15 N.Y.S. 875Shailer v. Corbett (1891)
<p>Appeal from special term, New York county.</p> <p>Action by William Shailer against Eugene Corbett arid another. From a judgment recovered by defendants on the report of a referee, plaintiff appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 875Shults v. Shults (1891)
Ap) eal from judgment on report of referee. Aci on by Josiah Shults against Nellis Shults and others. From a judgment entered on the report of the referee dismissing the complaint on the merits, with costs, plaintiff appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 878Falvey v. Bridges (1891)
<p>".1. Specific Performance—Contract—Marketable Title.</p> <p>Land sold under foreclosure of a mortgage was purchased for the benefit of W., and the purchaser executed an agreement wherein he covenanted to allow W. and his representatives to let the land and receive the rents, to convey the premises on W.’s request to whomsoever he designated, and to execute deeds on sales made by W., and allow him to receive the proceeds thereof. Held, that whatever objection to a title conveyed by such purchaser might exist by reason of this instrument is removed by an instrument executed by W., and reciting that he “had requested and doth request” such purchaser “to sell,,and convey the lands already conveyed or to be hereafter conveyed, ” and that title is sufficient to support a suit for specific performances.</p> <p>2. Same—Adverse Possession.</p> <p>In a suit for a specific performance of a contract to buy land it is no objection to the validity of plaintiff’s title that a part of the lot—in the city of New York—was the bed of a Dutch road, where there is evidence that the same had been discontinued by the city, and one under whom he claims had for more than 20 years been in possession under a deed from the city.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 881Selye v. Zimmer (1891)
<p>Appeal from circuit court, Monroe county.</p> <p>Action by De Villo W. Selye against Frederick Zimmer. From a judgment entered on a verdict directed by the court in favor of plaintiff, and from an order denying a motion for a new trial on the minutes, defendant appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 883Toomey v. Lyman (1891)
Action by Catherine Toomey against Arnold Lyman. The cause was first tried in the court of a justice of the peace, and afterwards in the county court on' appeal. From a judgment entered on a verdict for plaintiff, and from an order denying a motion for a new trial on the minutes, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 885Mark v. Hyatt (1891)
Action by Jacob Mark against Elizabeth A. L. Hyatt and Thaddeus Hyatt to recover damages against defendants for procuring an injunction against plaintiff from the superior court, which that court had no jurisdiction to grant. From a judgment dismissing the complaint on the merits plaintiff appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 887Mathews v. Associated Press (1891)
Actions by George E. Mathews and others, and by George Bleistein, as president of the Courier Company, respectively, against the Associated Press of the State of New York and others. Prom an order in both causes continuing a preliminary injunction, defendants appeal.
- 15 N.Y.S. 890Michael v. Eley (1891)
<p>L Contracts op Agents—Scope of Authority.</p> <p>A contract made by plaintiffs with the agents of defendant for the purchase of land, which provides that @10,000 be paid down and a mortgage for balance of pur: chase price be given, payable in 10 years from the date thereof, with interest, and . that the mortgage shall contain “a clause permitting payments to be made sooner than the time fixed therein in sums not less than $1,000, and providing for an equitable release of parts of the mortgaged premises commensurate with the amounts paid on said mortgage, ” will not be enforced specifically where such agents were only authorized to sell the premises at a stipulated price per acre, §10,000 to be paid down, and a mortgage to be given by the purchaser for the balance in 10 equal-annual installments, with interest semi-annu&lly, and the purchaser to have the privilege of paying at any time $1,000, and obtain therefor a release of one acre of the mortgaged premises. '</p> <p>2. Same—Knowledge of Agent’s Authority.</p> <p>Plaintiffs, having knowledge that defendant’s agents were acting under special authority in the sale of the land, were put on inquiry as to the extent of such au- . ■ thority, and were bound to know whether such authority warranted the agents in making the contract sought to be enforced.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 892Fera v. Wickham (1891)
<p>Appeal from special term, New York county.</p> <p>Action by Henry Fera against Daniel H. Wickham and others. From an order overruling a demurrer to the complaint, defendants appeal.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 893Enright v. Montauk Fire Insurance (1891)
Action by John Enright against the Montauk Fire Insurance Company of the city of Brooklyn to recover for a loss accruing under a policy issued by ■defendant. Plaintiff appeals from a judgment entered upon a verdict in his ■own favor directed by the court, and from an order denying a motion for a new trial on the judge’s minutes.
- 15 N.Y.S. 895Gould v. Chicago, Burlington & Quincy Railroad (1891)
<p>1. Abatement—Foreign Suit Pending—Garnishment.</p> <p>In an action against a railroad company by the assignee of one of its creditors,</p> <p>' the pendency, in another jurisdiction, of a suit against this creditor, in which plaintiff has intervened, and in which the railroad company was summoned to answer as garnishee, will not support a plea in abatement when the company has already paid the claim here sued on to one claiming under an assignment subsequent to plaintiff’s.</p> <p>2. Judgment—Res Judicata—Intervention. ••'</p> <p>A judgment for plaintiff in another suit against this creditor; in another state; in • which the railroad- company was garnished and this plaintiff intervened, is not a bar to his action, when the record shows that he afterwards dismissed his petition of intervention, and that the court in its decree recognized it as having been dismissed.</p> <p>8. Appeal—Review—Harmless Error—Evidence.</p> <p>The error in receiving in evidence on a trial by the court a judgment which is inadmissible is cured when the court refuses afterwards to treat it as conclusive.</p> <p>4. Same.</p> <p>On a trial by the court, the erroneous admission in evidence of a judgment is without prejudice, when the facts sought to be established by it are amply proved by other witnesses.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 898Haviland v. Manhattan Railway Co. (1891)
Action by Merritt E. Haviland, executor of Mima Atkins, deceased, against the Manhattan Elevated Railway Company, to recover damages for personal injuries to plaintiff’s testatrix. From a judgment entered on the verdict of a jury, and from an order denying a motion for a new trial, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 900Ladew v. Hudson River Boot & Shoe Manufacturing Co. (1891)
ew York county. Action by Edward R. Ladew and Joseph II. Ladew against the Hudson River Boot & Slice Manufacturing Company. From an order denying a motion to vacate an attachment, William M. Ketcliam, who had been appointed a temporary receiver of defendant’s property, appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 901Del Valle v. Hyland (1891)
Action by Jose A. Del Valle against J’osiah A. Hyland and Jose F. Navarro to set aside an alleged fraudulent transfer of policies of life insurance. From a judgment dismissing the complaint on the merits plaintiff appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 904Mayor of New York v. Cunard Steam-Ship Co. (1891)
Action by tlie mayor, aldermen, and commonalty of the city of New York against tlie Cunard Steam-Ship Company, Limited, to secure the removal of a shed erected on the north side of pier 40, North river, New York city. From a judgment for plaintiffs, defendants appeal.
- 15 N.Y.S. 908Comstock v. Hopkins (1891)
Action by Keuben Comstock against John II. Hopkins and others for damages resulting from the death of plaintiff’s son while intoxicated by liquor sold him by defendant. From a judgment of nonsuit plaintiff appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 909In re New York Elevated Railway Co. (1891)
The New York Elevated Railway Company instituted proceedings to condemn the property of Adolpli Hoffman, and from the order confirming the report of the commissioners it appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 911Newell v. Mayor of New York (1891)
Action by William R. Newell and John W. Freligh against the mayor, aldermen, and commonalty of the city of New York. From a judgment for defendants, entered on the verdict of a jury, plaintiffs appeal.
- 15 N.Y.S. 913Marcus Ward & Co. v. Ward (1891)
<p>Appeal from special term, New York county.</p> <p>Action by the firm of Marcus Ward & Co., Limited, against William H. Ward and It. Ward Carroll, partners as William H. Ward & Co. From a judgment for defendants, plaintiff appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 915Pelly v. Onderdonk (1891)
Action by Herbert Cecil Pelly against William■ M. Onderdonk, impleaded with others, on a promissory note. Prom a judgment recovered by plaintiff •on the verdict of a jury by the direction of the court defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 917People v. Meakim (1891)
This was an indictment against Alexander Meakim, Joseph Koch, and Edward T. Fitzpatrick, commissioners of excise, charging them witli a misdemeanor in willfully neglecting for an unreasonable time to decide a complaint before them of the sale of liquor in a certain saloon on election day. From an order arresting judgment on a verdict in their favor on the trial of a plea of former acquittal, interposed by defendants, the people appeal.
- 15 N.Y.S. 919Hasbrouck v. Young (1891)
Action by Louis B. Hnsbrouck, as assignee for the benefit of creditors of Bichard D. Young, against Emma B. Young, to set aside a deed and bill of sale. There was judgment for plaintiff, and defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 922Bukofzer v. United States Grand Lodge of the Independent Order Sons of Benjamin (1891)
Action by Meyer Bukofzer against the .United States Grand Lodge of the Independent Order Sons of Benjamin for an endowment due plaintiff. From a judgment for the plaintiff entered up upon a verdict directed by the court, and from an order denying a motion for a new trial on the judge’s minutes, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 923Willetts v. New York Elevated Railroad (1891)
Hew York county. This was an equitable action by William Henry Willetts against the Hew York Elevated Railroad Company and the Manhattan Railroad Company, to obtain an injunction nisi against the operation of defendants’ road in front of plaintiff’s premises, and to recover damages and loss of rents occasioned by such operation. There was judgment for plaintiff, and defendants appeal.
- 15 N.Y.S. 924Conable v. Smith (1891)
<p>Appeal from circuit court, Erie county.</p> <p>Action by Benjamin B. Conable against Edgar K. Smith and another. From a judgment entered on a verdict for plaintiff, defendant Smith appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 926Woodbury v. Conger (1891)Affirmed
Action by William Woodbury against Ansel E. Conger for services ren•dered defendant as an attorney. There was a verdict for plaintiff, and from -a judgment entered thereon defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 927Gray v. Rochester City & Brighton Railroad (1891)
<p>Street Railways—Injury to Passengers—Evidence.</p> <p>In an action against a street-railway company for personal injuries, it appeared that plaintiff, while standing on the side step of a crowded carón defendant’s road, was, without fault on his part, struck and injured by another car going in the opposite direction on the adjoining track. There was evidence that at the place of the accident the tracks were nearer to each other than at other places along the road, and also that, by the sinking of the inside rail on one of the tracks, the cars pitched towards each other, making the position of a person standing on the step dangerous. Held, that a verdict for plaintiff, on the ground of defendant’s negligence, was warranted.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 928Koch v. Le Frois (1891)Reversed
<p>Appeal from circuit court, Monroe county.</p> <p>Action by Mary Koch, an infant, by guardian, against Jacob Le Proís, for fraud in the sale by defendant, as special guardian, of plaintiff’s land. From a judgment entered on an order dismissing the complaint, plaintiff appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 930Shaver v. Eldred (1891)Beversed
<p>- Appeal from Cayuga county court.</p> <p>Action by Abram Shaver against Kelson B. Eldred for trespass. From a judgment for plaintiff, defendant appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 933Oishei v. Lazzarone (1891)
<p>Appeal from Erie county court.</p> <p>Action by Acliille J. Oishei against Giuseppe Lazzarone on a contract. From an order denying a motion to vacate an order of his arrest defendant appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 934In re Soule's Will (1891)
Proceeding by Henry Beaver and Emily Beaver for the probate of a lost or destroyed will of Maria Soule, deceased. The probate was resisted by William Soule, the husband of testatrix, and was denied by the surrogate, and proponents appeal. 7
- 15 N.Y.S. 936Bernhard v. Rice (1891)
Action by Charles Bernhard and others against R. 0. Rice. On defendant’s motion tlie service of summons on him was set aside, and, in addition to tlie $10 costs of the motion, he was awarded the costs of the action. Plaintiffs appeal.
- 15 N.Y.S. 937Brewer v. Longnecker (1891)Modified
Action by Francis B. Brewer against Frank C. Longnecker and others for foreclosure of mortgage. From an order made on application of plaintiff, amending the judgment, after sale of the premises, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 938Herbst v. Vacuum Oil Co. (1891)
Actum by Ludwig Herbst against the Vacuum Oil Company for personal injuries. From an order granting a motion to set aside the verdict of the jury in favor of plaintiff and for a new trial plaintiff appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 940Bigelow v. Garwitz (1891)
Action by Charles C. Bigelow against Joseph Garwitz. From an order granting defendant's motion on the minutes to set. aside a verdict for plaintiff, and for a new trial, plaintiff appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 941Whalen v. New York Central & Hudson River Railroad (1891)
Action by Carrie Whalen against the New York Central & Hudson River Railroad Company. From a judgment entered on a verdict for plaintiff, and from an order denying a new trial, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 942Brown v. Burgett (1891)
Action by William M. Brown against Frank A. Burgett. From a judg- . ment entered on the report of the referee in favor of defendant, plaintiff appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 944Rhines v. Town of Royalton (1891)Affirmed
Action by Thomas M. Rhines against the town of Royalton to recover for personal injuries caused by a defective highway. Verdict and judgment for plaintiff. At a special term defendant moved for a new trial, and from an order denying the motion it appealed.
- 15 N.Y.S. 946In re Grandin (1891)Affirmed
■ Appeal from special term, Chautauqua county. ■ - Petition of Belle E. Grandin and others to compel an accounting by William H. Fenton, special guardian. From an order confirming the report of a referee in favor of petitioners the special- guardian appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 949Shannon v. Pickell (1891)
<p>Appeal from special term.</p> <p>Action by Robert H. Shannon and wife against John W. Pickell and others for partition, and judgment was entered for plaintiffs. From the taxation of defendants’ costs on report of referee, and confirmation of referee’s report, plaintiffs appeal.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 950Hamilton v. New York Sensation (1891)
This was a proceeding for the distribution of the proceeds of the sale of a canal-boat known as the “New York Sensation,” growing out of attachments under builders’ liens, Charles J. Hamilton and Adam Homer claimants. The proceeds were awarded to Homer, and Hamilton appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 952Dudley v. Westcott Express Co. (1891)
Action by Florence Dudley against the Westcott Express Company for personal injuries. From a judgment entered on a verdict for plaintiff, and from an order denying a motion for a new trial, defendant appeals.
- 15 N.Y.S. 953Gray v. Tompkins (1891)
<p>Appeal from trial term.</p> <p>Action by William Gray against Calvin Tompkins. There was a judgment of nonsuit, and plaintiff appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 954Wallerstein v. American Surety Co. (1891)
<p>I. Pleading—Demubrbe.</p> <p>Od trial of demurrer to answer for insufficiency defendant may attack the complaint for insufficiency, but only at the trial, and must then impress his attack on the record, so as to inform the appellate authority that he has so attacked it; otherwise his objection will not be heard on appeal from the judgment.</p> <p>2. "Appeal-Bond—Sureties.</p> <p>An undertaking whereby a surety undertakes that an appellant will pay the value of the use and occupation of premises if a judgment is affirmed is a contract of suretyship, and the respondent need not first resort to his remedy against appellant, but may proceed directly against the surety upon defendant’s failure to pay when the judgment is affirmed.</p> <p>• (Syllabus by the Court.)</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 958Teamans v. Tannehill (1891)
<p>Appeal from trial term.</p> <p>Action by Annie Teamans and Jennie Teamans against Prank A. Tanne-Tiill. From a judgment entered on a verdict in favor of plaintiffs, defendant -appeals.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 960Alger v. New York Elevated Railroad (1891)
Action by Henry C. Alger, as administrator of Daniel S. Alger, against tlie New York Elevated Railroad Company and the Manhattan Railway Company.
- 15 N.Y.S. 961Hannaman v. Muckle (1891)
Action by Lemuel B. Hannaman, as overseer of the poor of the town of Brunswick, against Thomas Muckle, before a justice of the peace, to recover a penalty for defendant’s selling liquor without a license, in violation of the excise law. The justice issued the summons in the case, signed in blank, to plaintiff’s attorneys. They then inserted the names of the parties and the date, and delivered it to an officer to be served.
- 15 N.Y.S. 964Pelly v. Naylor (1891)
<p>Appeal from circuit court, New York county.</p> <p>Action by Herbert Cecil Felly against Henry Naylor and others.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 965Pelly v. Robinson (1891)
<p>Appeal from circuit court, Hew York county.</p> <p>Action by Herbert Cecil Pelly against Andrew J. Robinson and others.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 965Langdon v. Mayor of New York (1891)
<p>Action by Walter Langdon against the mayor, etc., of the city of Hew York. Motion to confirm referee's report and for judgment.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 966Langdon v. Mayor of New York (1891)
Action by Marion Langdon against the mayor, etc., of the city of New York. Motion to confirm report of referee and for judgment.
- 15 N.Y.S. 966Riker v. Leo (1891)
Action by John H. Biker, as sole surviving executor of the last will and testament of Sampson Simson, deceased, and trustee under said will, against Jochebed M. S. Leo, as executor of the last will and testament of Moses A. Isaacks, deceased, Sampson Simson Leo, and the North American Belief Society for the Indigent Jews in Jerusalem, Palestine, and all corporations in the city of New York (not including the corporation above named) existing on August 2,1885, whose permanent…
- 15 N.Y.S. 967Colyer v. Williams (1891)
<p>Appeal from special term, Kings county.</p> <p>Action by Joseph Colyer against Mary Louise Williams and others.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 967Hartwick v. McGinnis (1891)
<p>Appeal from Rockland county court.</p> <p>Action by James E. Hartwick against John McGinnis and another.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 968Renderle v. Finken (1891)
<p>Appeal from special term, Kings county.</p> <p>Action by Margarethe Renderle against Elizabeth Finken, and John Finken and another, administrators of Treno Jung, deceased.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 968Kitson v. Blake (1891)
<p>Action by Thomas Kitson against Sarah F.JBIake, and action by Thomas Kitson against Frederick D. Blake and others.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 969Rose v. Hawley (1891)
<p>Appeal from special term, Westchester county.</p> <p>Action by Levi P. Rose against David Hawley, the city of Yonkers, and others.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 970In re Jubin (1891)
- 15 N.Y.S. 970Crooks v. Milwaukee & Michigan Insurance (1891)
- 15 N.Y.S. 970Dillon v. Lee (1891)
- 15 N.Y.S. 970Fire Department of Kingston v. Derrenbacher (1891)
- 15 N.Y.S. 973Malcolm v. Manhattan Railway Co. (1891)
<p>Appeal from special term, New York county.</p> <p>Action by James F. Malcolm against the Manhattan Railway Company and the New York Elevated Railroad Company for injuries to plaintiff’s property. There was judgment for plaintiff granting an injunction nisi, and defendants appeal.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 974Boehm v. Shedlinsky (1891)
<p>Appeal from first district court.</p> <p>Action by Fanny Boehm against Moses Shedlinsky.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 974Mayor of New York v. Central Park, N. & E. R. R. Co. (1891)
- 15 N.Y.S. 974Leocioni v. Post (1891)
<p>Appeal from eleventh district court.</p>
- 15 N.Y.S. 975Bauer v. Consumers' Ice Co. (1891)
Action by Charles C. Bauer against the Consumers’ Ice Co. for personal injuries due to plaintiff’s being run over by a wagon of defendant.
- 15 N.Y.S. 976Gabrielson v. Waydell (1891)
<p>Appeal from jury term.</p> <p>Action by Charles G. Gabrielson against Frederick Waydell and others.</p>