Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

151 Pa. 185

Boyer v. Reading City

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania

Decided October 3, 1892

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · decided 1892-10-03

Appeal, No. 215, Jan. T., 1892, by defendant, from decree of Cr P. Berks Co., Equity Docket, 1890, No. 518, granting injunction on bill filed by Jerome L. Boyer. Held: as the settled law of Pennsylvania, that ‘ when a street is once opened and paved, and thus assimilated with the rest of the city and made part of it, all the particular benefits to the locality derived from the improvements have been received and enjoyed.

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1892-10-03

How this case has been cited

Cited by 5 later decisions — most recently December 1971

5 state decisions

20189219001910192019301940195019601970decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1Opinion by

Mr. Justice Sterrett,

¶2The facts of this ease, found by the learned master and approved by the court, together with the questions arising thereon, are fully and clearly presented in the record.

¶3The controlling questions are substantially the same as those in Harrisburg v. Segelbaum, No. 18 May Term 1891, in which an opinion has just been filed. [The preceding case.] In view of what has been said in that opinion, as well as what may be found in the able and exhaustive opinion of the learned president of the common pleas, in this case, bearing on the same questions, we deem it unnecessary to discuss either of them.

¶4After depicting in strong colors the disastrous consequences that are likely to result from being unable, under our decisions in Hammett v. Philadelphia, Beck v. Williamsport and others, to repair public streets at the expense of the abutting property owners, etc., the learned counsel for the defendant, with commendable frankness, admits -that the decree which he asks us to reverse is in full accord with the law as laid down by this court in the cases above referred to, and says: “ The' only remedy then is to prajr the Supreme Court to relax its rule or adopt another better suited to the necessities of the times.”

¶5We are far from being convinced that the “necessities of the times,” or any commendable consideration requires us to reverse or so modify the decisions, referred to, as to permit the cost of repaving public streets, for the benefit of the general public, to be assessed upon and collected from the property abutting on such streets; and, because we are not so convinced, we think there was no error in granting the injunction complained of.

¶6Decree affirmed and appeal dismissed with costs to be paid by the defendant.

/151/pa/185 · .json · Public domain