Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

18 F. Cas. 14

Nettleton v. Morrison

U.S. District Court

Decided July 1, 1877

U.S. District Court · decided 1877-07-01

Tills is an action to quiet title. Tlie complainant [Edward C. Nettleton] purchased a tract of land from Norbert Grignon, and received a conveyance of the same January 27th, 1876, which was properly recorded. The defendant [Dorilus Morrison] claims under a prior deed executed June 8th, 1874, by Peter Zanzius, in the name of Norbert Grignon, by virtue of a power of attorney dated May 30th, 1S74, properly executed to him by the latter.

Relies on People v. Kendall

Decided 1877-07-01

NELSON, District Judge.

¶1The minor having received the consideration for the property at the time of the conveyance under the power of attorney, made the deed his own act, and it was voidable, not void. When the previous deed to the defendant was revoked, the parties thereto were left to their legal rights and remedies. The defendant could recover from the minor the money paid, on account of failure of consideration, and, perhaps, under the circumstances, might subject him to a criminal prosecution [25 Wend. 401, and cases cited; but see 1 Johns. •Cas. 127]; 3 but he cannot insist in this suit that the complainant must restore to him the money paid out, as a condition of the relief asked. Although the complainant had notice of the previous transfer by the record •of the deed and the power of attorney, it is •evident he also knew that Grignon was not bound by it, and could avoid it. Decree as prayed.

/18/fcas/14 · .json · Public domain