Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

2 Watts 74

Boyer v. Aurand

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania

Decided September 15, 1833

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · decided 1833-09-15

Debt on bond by Peter Aurand against John K. Boyer, in which this agreement was made by the parties. “ We agree to refer the above action, under the act of 1705, to James L. Dunn and Samuel Baird as referees, with liberty, in case of disagreement, to choose an umpire; report tobe made by the next or any subsequent court of common pleas of Perry county, proceedings in said court to stay in meantime.

Decided 1833-09-15

Per Curiam.

¶1The award in the case of an umpirage, is the act of the umpire, and here we have it. But it is said that it must purport to have been made by him either alone or conjointly with all the arbitrators; and that here but one of them joined. Does that make the award less the act of the umpire'! The joinder of the arbitrators is but surplusage at best; on which ground alone it is held not to vitiate, and it might, therefore, be supposed that the less there is of it the better. As to the allegation that the interference of the arbitrator who signed may have had an undue influence in the absence of the other, it is enough to say, that it is the joinder in signing and delivering the award, and not the joinder in consultation which was, at one time, deemed material; and even that is now disregarded. The award is, therefore, unexceptionable.

¶2Judgment affirmed.

/2/watts/74 · .json · Public domain