Nelson v. Kralick

                                                                                             May 19 2015


                                            DA 14-0421
                                                                                          Case Number: DA 14-0421

                 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF MONTANA

                                           

JEANNIE NELSON,

              Plaintiff and Appellee,

         v.

JENNIFER KRALICK and KARLA KRALICK,

              Defendants and Appellants.



APPEAL FROM:           District Court of the Fourth Judicial District,
                       In and For the County of Missoula, Cause No. DV 13-1064
                       Honorable Edward P. McLean, Presiding Judge


COUNSEL OF RECORD:

                For Appellant:

                       Jennifer Kralick, Self-Represented, Lolo, Montana

                For Appellee:

                       Ted Hess-Homeier, Attorney at Law, Missoula, Montana



                                                    Submitted on Briefs: April 29, 2015
                                                               Decided: May 19, 2015


Filed:

                       __________________________________________
                                         Clerk
Justice Patricia Cotter delivered the Opinion of the Court.

¶1     Pursuant to Section I, Paragraph 3(c), Montana Supreme Court Internal Operating

Rules, this case is decided by unpublished opinion and shall not be cited and does not serve

as precedent. Its case title, cause number, and disposition shall be included in this Court’s

quarterly list of noncitable cases published in the Pacific Reporter and Montana Reports.

¶2     Jennifer Kralick and her mother, Karla Kralick, appearing pro se, appeal the order of

the Fourth Judicial District Court, Missoula County, authorizing the auction sale of their

mobile home. We affirm.

                 FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

¶3     Beginning in December 2008, Kralicks rented a mobile home space in the Lolo,

Montana, Hollyhock Court Mobile Home Park owned by the Nelson Family Trust, of which

Jeanie Nelson was the executor. Nelson and the Kralicks entered into an oral agreement

under which the Kralicks would rent the space from month-to-month. In January 2013,

Nelson gave notice to the Kralicks to vacate the premises by March 30, 2013, on the grounds

that they were “breaching the peace.” Nelson cited numerous police visits and complaints

from neighbors about noise, traffic, and unknown persons and vehicles at the Kralicks’

residence for extended periods of time. Kralicks did not vacate the premises and on April 2,

2013, Nelson sued for possession in the Missoula County justice court.

¶4     By order of justice court, the parties, with counsel, attended mediation. They reached

a settlement agreement that was signed by both parties and counsel. Under the agreement,

the Kralicks agreed to move their modular home and vacate the mobile home park on or

before August 29, 2013. Nelson agreed to pay Kralicks’ moving costs provided Kralicks


                                             2
used one of the agreed-upon movers. In the meantime, Kralicks were allowed to remain in

the mobile home park without paying rent.

¶5       Kralicks did not move their modular home by August 29. On August 30, 2013,

Nelson moved the justice court for permission to take possession of the Kralicks’ trailer

home. The justice court granted the motion and issued a Writ of Assistance. Kralicks then

moved to set aside the settlement agreement for various reasons. The justice court

subsequently quashed the order granting Nelson possession and set an emergency hearing for

September 6, 2013. On September 6, 2013, Nelson moved to have the Writ of Assistance

reissued. Justice court granted the motion. On September 13, 2013, the Kralicks filed an

appeal to the Fourth Judicial District Court from the justice court’s September 6 Writ of

Assistance. Consequently, justice court issued an order staying the Writ pending appeal.

¶6       A non-jury trial was conducted by the Fourth Judicial District Court on February 27,

2014. At trial, Nelson sought enforcement of the settlement agreement while the Kralicks

sought rescission based upon mutual mistake.         Following the testimony of multiple

witnesses, the District Court concluded that the settlement agreement was enforceable. The

court instructed Kralicks to move their mobile home by June 15, 2014, or the court would

authorize its sale at auction. The court issued its written order on March 7, 2014. On June

20, 2014, having been informed that the Kralicks had not moved their mobile home, the

District Court issued an order authorizing sale of the home by auction. On July 2, 2014,

Kralicks filed their Notice of Appeal seeking review of the District Court’s June 20, 2014

order.




                                              3
¶7     Kralicks’ appeal fails on the ground that they seek review of issues that are outside the

scope of the District Court’s orders. The June 2014 order is an order merely enforcing the

March 7 order; it contains no analysis. Moreover, Kralicks’ brief on appeal presents multiple

allegations concerning provisions of the lease. These issues are well outside the scope of the

District Court’s March 7 order enforcing the parties’ settlement agreement and are raised for

the first time on appeal. It is well established that appellants may not raise legal issues,

arguments, or theories for the first time on appeal. Unified Indus., Inc. v. Easley, 

, 

, 

.

¶8     We have determined to decide this case pursuant to Section I, Paragraph 3(c) of our

Internal Operating Rules, which provides for noncitable unpublished opinions. In the

opinion of this Court, the case presents a question controlled by settled law or by the clear

application of applicable standards of review.

¶9     We affirm.

                                                   /S/ PATRICIA COTTER

We Concur:

/S/ JAMES JEREMIAH SHEA
/S/ MICHAEL E WHEAT
/S/ LAURIE McKINNON
/S/ JIM RICE




                                               4