[Cite as State v. Curry,
2018-Ohio-3271.]
Court of Appeals of Ohio
EIGHTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
COUNTY OF CUYAHOGA
JOURNAL ENTRY AND OPINION
No. 105638
STATE OF OHIO
PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE
vs.
RONALD CURRY
DEFENDANT-APPELLANT
JUDGMENT:
APPLICATION DENIED
Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas
Case No. CR-15-597049-A
Application for Reopening
Motion No. 517569
RELEASE DATE: August 10, 2018
FOR APPELLANT
Ronald Curry, pro se
Inmate No. 693852
Belmont Correctional Institution
68518 Bannock Road
Saint Clairsville, Ohio 43950
ATTORNEYS FOR APPELLEE
Michael C. O’Malley
Cuyahoga County Prosecutor
By: Daniel T. Van
Assistant County Prosecutor
8th Floor Justice Center
1200 Ontario Street
Cleveland, Ohio 44113
SEAN C. GALLAGHER, P.J.:
{¶1} Applicant, Ronald Curry, through App.R. 26(B), seeks to reopen his appeal where
this court affirmed his convictions for rape, attempted rape, aggravated robbery, and kidnapping
that occurred in Cuyahoga C.P. No. CR-15-597049-A. State v. Curry, 8th Dist. Cuyahoga No.
105638, 2017-Ohio-683. He claims that his appellate counsel was ineffective for failing to raise
and argue a claim of ineffective assistance of trial counsel based on an allegation that trial
counsel should have challenged the admissibility of certain DNA evidence by filing a motion to
suppress. We deny the application to reopen.
BACKGROUND
{¶2} Curry was convicted of numerous crimes in the above case and sentenced to a
nine-year prison term. This court affirmed his convictions. He then timely filed an application
to reopen pursuant to App.R. 26(B), presenting one proposed assignment of error. The state
filed an untimely brief in opposition, which this court struck.
STANDARD FOR REOPENING AN APPEAL
{¶3} Ohio has created a postappeal procedure to allow an indigent appellant to raise a
claim that appellate counsel rendered ineffective assistance. App.R. 26(B); Morgan v. Eads,
104 Ohio St.3d 142,
2004-Ohio-6110,
818 N.E.2d 1157, 22. Similar to claims of ineffective
assistance of trial counsel, “[t]he two-pronged analysis found in Strickland v. Washington (1984),
466 U.S. 668, 687,
104 S.Ct. 2052,
80 L.Ed.2d 674, is the appropriate standard to determine
whether a defendant has received ineffective assistance of appellate counsel.” State v. Were,
120 Ohio St.3d 85,
2008-Ohio-5277,
896 N.E.2d 699, ¶ 10, citing State v. Sheppard,
91 Ohio
St.3d 329, 330,
744 N.E.2d 770 (2001). That means Curry must demonstrate that appellate
counsel’s performance was deficient and that but for the deficient performance, there is a
reasonable probability that the result of the appeal would have been different. State v. Reed,
74
Ohio St.3d 534,
660 N.E.2d 456 (1996).
{¶4} Further, in order for this court to grant an application for reopening, Curry must
establish that “there is a genuine issue as to whether the applicant was deprived of the effective
assistance of counsel on appeal.” App.R. 26(B)(5). To satisfy these requirements Curry
“bears the burden of establishing that there was a ‘genuine issue’ as to whether he has a
‘colorable claim’ of ineffective assistance of counsel on appeal.” State v. Spivey, 84 Ohio St.3d
24, 25,
701 N.E.2d 696 (1998).
ADMISSIBILITY OF DNA EVIDENCE
{¶5} Curry contends that appellate counsel was ineffective by not raising a claim that trial
counsel was ineffective for not challenging the admission of the results of DNA testing related to
one of Curry’s victims. He argues that the victim’s DNA profile was not found in the results of
the testing of a vaginal swab, so there was no indication that those results pertained to the
allegations leveled against him. He asserts that trial counsel was required to file a motion to
suppress or otherwise challenge the admissibility of the DNA results.
{¶6} “The Sixth Amendment does not require counsel to pursue a motion to suppress in
every case.” State v. Bell, 11th Dist. Lake No. 2015-L-017, 2015-Ohio-4775, 48, citing State v.
Jefferson, 9th Dist. Summit No. 20156,
2001 Ohio App. LEXIS 1281 (Mar. 21, 2001). “Rather,
t. he failure to file a motion to suppress constitutes ineffective assistance of counsel only when
the record demonstrates that the motion would have been successful if made.” State v. Moon,
8th Dist. Cuyahoga No. 101972,
2015-Ohio-1550, ¶ 28.
{¶7} Curry’s argument contends that the evidence is not what it purports to be. Evid.R.
901 provides “[t]he requirement of authentication or identification as a condition precedent to
admissibility is satisfied by evidence sufficient to support a finding that the matter in question is
what its proponent claims.”
{¶8} A forensic DNA analyst employed by the Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation
testified at trial. He stated that, among others, three samples from a rape kit came to his
attention in the course of the investigation: A vaginal swab, a slide containing a specimen, and a
saliva sample taken from the victim. They were labeled as taken from the victim with the
appropriate case number and documentation. Of these three samples, he tested the vaginal swab
for DNA. He also testified that a DNA sample from Curry was later submitted for testing and
comparison.
{¶9} The analyst opined that a DNA profile was developed from a sperm fraction
contained in the sample from the vaginal swab, and that profile was consistent with Curry’s DNA
standard. He also testified that there was an unidentified female DNA profile contained in the
tested sample. The analyst clarified that there were no other male DNA found.
{¶10} The analyst laid out a proper foundation for the admission of the evidence. Curry
has not pointed to a rule of evidence that would preclude the admission of the DNA test results.
The lack of testing of a reference sample of the victim to the unknown female DNA profile
developed from the swabs collected from the rape kit was highlighted by defense counsel at trial.
This was properly an attack on the credibility or weight of the evidence, not its admissibility.1
1
For instance, if Curry is attempting to argue without stating that there is a break in the chain of custody of
the sample, the Ohio Supreme Court has indicated that so long as there is sufficient evidence to support a finding that
the matter in question is what its proponent claims, the evidence is admissible, but its weight or credibility may be
subject to challenge. State v. Richey, 64 Ohio St.3d 353, 360,
595 N.E.2d 915 (1992).
There are no grounds to believe that an attack on the admissibility of the DNA test results would
be successful given the proper foundation laid for their admission.
{¶11} There are no grounds presented in this record to exclude this evidence. Therefore,
Curry has failed to demonstrate a colorable claim of ineffective assistance of appellate counsel.
{¶12} Application denied.
SEAN C. GALLAGHER, PRESIDING JUDGE
PATRICIA ANN BLACKMON, J., and
FRANK D. CELEBREZZE, JR., J., CONCUR