Ohio ___ (2018)
Slip opinions decided 2018 — Ohio Public Domain Citations
These decisions have not yet been assigned a bound volume and page in Ohio Public Domain Citations. Each case lives at a name-based URL and moves to its citation URL (with a redirect) the moment the official citation is assigned.
3,637 opinions
- 2018 Ohio 1N. Canton City School Dist. Bd. of Edn. v. Stark Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation-Real-property valuation-Presumption that forced sale was not at arm's length rebutted-Decision of the Board of Tax Appeals reversed and cause remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 2Notestine Manor, Inc. v. Logan Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation-Property-Valuation-Government-subsidized low-income housing under federal "Section 202" program-Preference for market-rent approach over contract-rent approach is presumptive, but not conclusive--Valuation method must account for affirmative value of government subsidies-Contract-rent approach is appropriate when contract rents do not exceed generally available market rents.
- 2018 Ohio 3State ex rel. Sunesis Constr. Co. v. Indus. Comm. (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Workers' compensation-Violation of specific safety requirement-Industrial Commission did not abuse it discretion in granting additional award-Record contained evidence supporting commission's finding that specific safety requirement applied, that employer violated it, and that violation was proximate cause of injury-Whether worker disobeyed employer's instruction to stay out of hazardous area is immaterial.
- 2018 Ohio 4Mahoning County Bar Association v. Cochran. (2018)
Attorneys-Misconduct-Making a false statement of fact or law to a tribunal-Committing an illegal act reflecting adversely on lawyer's honesty or trustworthiness-One-year suspension, stayed on condition.
- 2018 Ohio 5Disciplinary Counsel v. Goebl. (2018)
Attorneys-Misconduct-Violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct and the Rules for the Government of the Bar-Conditionally stayed six-month suspension.
- 2018 Ohio 7Disciplinary Counsel v. Demasi. (2018)
Attorneys-Misconduct-Violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct, including making a false statement to a tribunal, engaging in conduct prejudicial to the administration of justice, engaging in conduct that adversely reflects on the lawyer's fitness to practice law, failing to provide competent representation and failing to act with reasonable diligence in representing a client, failing to communicate with a client, engaging in conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation, and neglecting or refusing to assist in a disciplinary investigation-Indefinite suspension with no credit for time served under interim default suspension.
- 2018 Ohio 8Alford v. Collins-McGregor Operating Co. (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Oil and gas-Leases-Action seeking partial termination of lease for lessees' failure to explore or drill at depths below those currently being exploited-Motion to dismiss for failure to state claim properly granted-Ohio does not recognize implied covenant to explore further.
- 2018 Ohio 9Columbus Bar Association v. Nyce. (2018)
Attorneys-Misconduct-Violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct, including failing to advise clients in writing that attorney does not maintain professional-liability insurance, failing to maintain required records documenting funds held in client trust account, and making false statements of material fact in connection with disciplinary investigation-Permanent disbarment.
- 2018 Ohio 10Mahoning County Bar Association v. Atway. (2018)
Attorneys-Misconduct-Felony conviction for conspiring to prevent another person from freely exercising a legal right-Representing a client using means that have no other purpose than to embarrass or harass a third person-Committing illegal act reflecting adversely on lawyer's honesty or trustworthiness-Engaging in conduct prejudicial to administration of justice-Two-year suspension with no credit for time served.
- 2018 Ohio 11In Re Application of Winwood. (2018)
Attorneys-Character and fitness-Failures to disclose criminal record on law-school applications-Pending application to take bar exam disapproved-Reapplication permitted, for July 2018 bar exam.
- 2018 Ohio 12In re Application of Washington (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Attorneys-Character and fitness-Inaccurate recording of work hours during internship-Pending application to register as candidate for admission to practice of law disapproved-Reapplication permitted.
- 2018 Ohio 15Lucarell v. Nationwide Mut. Ins. Co. (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Contracts-Breach of contract-Punitive damages-Implied duty of good faith and fair dealing-Release of liability-Prevention-of-performance doctrine-Fraud-Punitive damages are not recoverable in a breach-of-contract action-When a breach of contract involves conduct that also constitutes a tort, punitive damages may be awarded only for the tort, not for the breach, and any punitive damages awarded are subject to the statutory limitations on punitive damages imposed in R.C. 2315.21-A party to a contract does not breach the implied duty of good faith and fair dealing by seeking to enforce the agreement as written or by acting in accordance with its express terms, nor can there be a breach of the implied duty unless a specific obligation imposed by the contract is not met-An unconditional release of liability becomes effective upon execution and delivery and bars any claims encompassed within it unless it was procured by fraud, duress, or other wrongful conduct-A party seeking to avoid a release of liability on the basis that it was procured under duress is required to prove duress by clear and convincing evidence-The prevention-of-performance doctrine, which states that a party who prevents another from performing a contractual obligation may not rely on that failure of performance to assert a claim for breach of contract, is not a defense to a release of liability and therefore cannot be asserted as a defense to a release-A fraud claim cannot be predicated on predictions or projections relating to future performance or on misrepresentations made to third parties.
- 2018 Ohio 16State v. Beasley (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Criminal law-No-contest pleas-Crim.R. 11-Trial court abused discretion in adopting blanket policy of refusing no-contest pleas-Defendant's failure to enter no-contest plea on record does not constitute waiver of claim of error when trial court informed defendant that it would not accept any plea of no contest-Defendant's conviction reversed and cause remanded for entry of new plea.
- 2018 Ohio 17In Re D.H. (2018)
Juvenile court-Appeals-R.C. 2505.02-Juvenile court's orders transferring jurisdiction to adult court are not appealable under R.C. 2505.02(B)(4)-Court of appeals' judgment granting state's motion to dismiss appeals for lack of final order affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 18State v. White (2018)
Criminal: motion to suppress investigative stop reasonable suspicion canine sniff length/duration of stop ineffective assistance.
- 2018 Ohio 19State v. Jackson (2018)
minor misdemeanor - fine waiver - final, appealable order - motion to suppress - motion to dismiss - traffic stop - speeding - bad faith - materially exculpatory - potentially useful - dash cam recording
- 2018 Ohio 22State v. Pountney (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Criminal law-R.C. 2925.11(C)(1)(c)-Aggravated possession of drugs-Fentanyl-Enhanced felony levels-R.C. 2925.01(D)(1)(d)-Definition of "bulk amount"-Because state failed to prove maximum daily dose in the usual dose range specified in a standard pharmaceutical reference manual for transdermal fentanyl, it failed to establish the "bulk amount" of that drug for purposes of increasing felony level-State may not rely on usual dose range of morphine to establish bulk amount of transdermal fentanyl-Judgment of the court of appeals affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 23In re R.K. (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Termination of parental rights-R.C. 2151.352-When the state seeks to terminate a parent's parental rights, the parent has the right to counsel-A parent cannot be deprived of the right to counsel at a permanent-custody hearing unless the juvenile court finds that the parent has knowingly waived the right to counsel-A parent's waiver of counsel cannot be inferred from the unexplained failure of the parent to appear at a permanent-custody hearing.
- 2018 Ohio 24Cyran v. Cyran (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Domestic relations-Domestic-violence civil protection orders-Appeals-Mootness-Collateral consequences-Absent a showing of legal collateral consequences resulting from an expired domestic-violence civil protection order, an appeal of that order is moot.
- 2018 Ohio 26State v. Childers (2018)
Criminal: motion to withdraw guilty plea trial court jurisdiction res judicata consecutive sentencing ineffective assistance of counsel.
- 2018 Ohio 27State v. Locke (2018)
Public indecency/Manifest weight of the evidence
- 2018 Ohio 28Bode v. Fairfield Cty. Pros. Atty.'s Office (2018)
Judgment on pleadings - wrongful imprisionment
- 2018 Ohio 29State v. Carter (2018)
App.R. 26(B) application for reopening, ineffective assistance of appellate counsel, res judicata. The applicant has filed a timely application for reopening pursuant to App.R. 26(B). The doctrine of res judicata, however, bars further review of the applicant's sole proposed assignment of error in support of his claim of ineffective assistance of appellate counsel. The applicant's proposed assignment of error was previously reviewed on appeal and found to be without merit. We further find that the application of the doctrine of res judicata is not unjust and thus deny the application for reopening.
- 2018 Ohio 32Mitchell v. Brownie's Indep. Transm. (2018)
The trial court did not err in overruling Appellant's motion to dismiss on statute of limitations grounds, as Appellee filed his complaint within the applicable statute of limitations period for breach of contract claims. However, the judgment of the trial court awarding Appellee $1,161.34 was not supported by sufficient evidence and was against the manifest weight of the evidence. Judgment Reversed.
- 2018 Ohio 33State v. Chipman (2018)
Defendant's no contest plea to cruelty against companion animal, in violation of former R.C. 959.131(C)(2), a second-degree misdemeanor, substantially complied with Crim.R. 11. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying defendant's presentence motion to withdraw her plea. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 34State v. Dorsey (2018)
The statutory provisions governing the mandatory transfer of juvenile cases to adult court, R.C. 2152.10(A)(2)(b) and R.C. 2152.12(A)(1)(b), are not unconstitutional accordingly, the trial court did not err in finding the same and overruling Appellant's motion to dismiss his indictment. In addition, Appellant's conviction for aggravated robbery with a firearm specification is not against the weight of the evidence. Affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 36Nicoll v. Centerville City Schools (2018)
Trial court properly granted summary judgment to school district on plaintiff's negligence claim. The defect in the curb/sidewalk on which plaintiff tripped and fell was open and obvious. The open and obvious doctrine was not negated by any attendant circumstances. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 38Bayview Loan Servicing, L.L.C. v. Vasko (2018)
Modification of loan priority between lienholders. Motion to substitute party plaintiff. Foreclosure. Motion for default.
- 2018 Ohio 39State v. Chudzinski (2018)
Trial court does not abuse its discretion in denying motion for new trial where appellant failed to demonstrate that he received ineffective assistance of counsel. Victim's testimony as to the value of the stolen property is sufficient evidence on which the jury can base its finding.
- 2018 Ohio 40State v. Reynolds (2018)
In Anders appeal, appellant's proposed assignments of error are not well-taken where (1) the trial court properly denied appellant's motions to sever and dismiss, (2) the trial court's admission of inadmissible hearsay was harmless, (3) appellant's convictions are supported by sufficient evidence and are not against the manifest weight of the evidence, and (4) trial counsel provided effective assistance. Counsel's motion to withdraw is granted.
- 2018 Ohio 42State v. Greeley (2018)
sufficiency - manifest weight - deadly weapon - aggravated burglary - attempt - hammer - break-in
- 2018 Ohio 43State v. Knox (2018)
Waiver of counsel, petty offense, Crim.R. 22, Crim.R. 44, App.R. 9
- 2018 Ohio 44Lance v. Boldman (2018)
R.C. 2109.50 - concealment of assets - estate - power of attorney - fiduciary - inter vivos gift - undue influence - decedent's statements - donative intent - hearsay - Evid.R. 804(B)(5) - cross-examination
- 2018 Ohio 45State v. Watkins (2018)
The trial court did not err by recasting appellant's so-called verified motion to correct sentence as an untimely petition for postconviction relief that was barred by the doctrine of res judicata where such a petition was filed nearly ten years after a jury found him guilty of murder, three counts of tampering with evidence, and intimidation of a witness, thereby alleviating any need for the trial court to hold an evidentiary hearing.
- 2018 Ohio 49In re T.S. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 50Wray v. Gahm Properties, Ltd. (2018)
petition to appropriate property agriculture agricultural purposes statutory construction plain language timber taking manifest weight of the evidence de novo legislative intent R.C. 163.21(C)(2) R.C. 303.01 R.C. 519.01 R.C. 5713.30
- 2018 Ohio 51State v. McIntosh (2018)
Validity of Guilty Plea Partial compliance - proof of prejudice Validity of Guilty Plea-Leniency to Third Party
- 2018 Ohio 52Gardner v. Paxton (2018)
motion to dismiss Civ.R. 12(B) res judicata affirmative defense convert to summary judgment Civ.R. 56 notice opportunity to respond de novo review Civ.R. 8(C) plain error
- 2018 Ohio 53State v. Morrison (2018)
plea, withdraw, ineffective assistance of counsel, murder, firearm, earned credit, plea colloquy
- 2018 Ohio 54Norris v. Riesbeck Food Markets, Inc. (2018)
slip and fall in a grocery store summary judgment in favor of store improper genuine issues of material fact as whether wet floor was open and obvious and whether store's warning was adequate
- 2018 Ohio 57Williams v. State Farm Fire & Cas. Ins. Co. (2018)
Where the plaintiff-appellant does not file a transcript of jury trial proceedings as part of the record in appealing the jury's determination and the trial court's judgments on the verdict and denying a new trial, assignments of error such as they may purport to exist in the brief must be overruled and the judgments of the trial court presumed valid.
- 2018 Ohio 58State v. Davis (2018)
During a bench trial on a charge of involuntary manslaughter arising out of appellant's single, lethal punch of another, the trial court did not improperly apply self-defense law in finding appellant did not have reasonable grounds to believe he was in imminent danger of bodily harm. Appellant's conviction was not against the manifest weight of the evidence where appellant's own testimony about his fear of bodily harm was equivocal and undermined by credibility issues, and testimony of an eyewitness undercut appellant's claim of self-defense. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 59In re Guardianship of Thomas (2018)
Probate court acted within its discretion in maintaining a guardianship.
- 2018 Ohio 60State v. Griffin (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying the defendant's post-sentencing motion to withdraw his guilty plea where the defendant's affidavit setting forth the basis for withdrawing the plea was contradicted by transcripts of proceedings before the trial court.
- 2018 Ohio 61State v. Harvey (2018)
Trial court was not shown to have erred in refusing to grant jail-time credit for time spent in a program at a halfway house.
- 2018 Ohio 63Bridgestone Americas Tire Operations, LLC v. Harris (2018)
Tire Dealership Agreement
- 2018 Ohio 64Pisoni v. McCord (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 65State v. Karl R. Rohrer Assocs., Inc. (2018)
Statute of repose - breach of contract - nullum tempus doctrine - R.C. 2305.131
- 2018 Ohio 67State v. Hill (2018)
CRIMINAL - Appellant's conviction for aggravated trafficking in drugs was properly supported by sufficient evidence in the record no error occurred regarding introduction of bad acts evidence, prosecutor misconduct, or authentication and hearsay on prescription pill bottles.
- 2018 Ohio 68State v. Daboni (2018)
CRIMINAL - Appeal dismissed as no final, appealable order exists in Case No. 16CA6 as nothing in the record indicates the trial court disposed of count number 4 in underlying criminal case 14CR232.
- 2018 Ohio 70Brannon v. Edman (2018)
motion to dismiss, Civ.R. 12(B)(6), statute of frauds, breach of contract, fraud, motion to amend
- 2018 Ohio 72Maxim Ents., Inc. v. Haley (2018)
intervene, Civ.R. 24, void, inherent authority
- 2018 Ohio 75Ohio Edison Co. v. Royer (2018)
utility pole, negligent destruction, measure of damages, cost to repair, depreciation, indirect costs
- 2018 Ohio 76Teague v. Schmeltzer (2018)
settlement agreement, evidentiary hearing
- 2018 Ohio 77Seaton v. City of Willoughby (2018)
R.C. 4123.74 - wrongful death - immunity - intentional - deliberate removal - safety guard - summary judgment
- 2018 Ohio 78State v. Trice (2018)
Motion to suppress, limited pat down, reasonable suspicion, armed and dangerous
- 2018 Ohio 79Mahoning Cty. Bar Assn. v. Verkhlin (2018)
On certification of default.
- 2018 Ohio 86State v. Barnes (2018)
Ineffective assistance of counsel motion to dismiss preindictment delay guilty plea. By pleading guilty, appellant waived any claim of ineffective assistance of counsel based on counsel's failure to file a motion to dismiss for preindictment delay. Even if appellant did not waive an ineffective assistance of counsel claim, he failed to demonstrate that he was actually prejudiced by the preindictment delay.
- 2018 Ohio 87Hammon v. Huntington Natl. Bank (2018)
Civ.R. 12(b)(6) motion to dismiss alternative motion for summary judgment Civ.R. 56 guardianship estate of minor ward final account res judicata statute of limitations. The trial court misapplied the discovery rule to plaintiff-appellant's fraud claim against the former guardian of his estate as a minor. The former guardian's administration of the estate was separate and distinct from assurances the guardian allegedly made to plaintiff-appellant's parents regarding trust investment returns upon which plaintiff-appellant alleges that he and his family relied. Issues of material fact remained as to when plaintiff-appellant should have discovered the basis for his fraud claim, specifically the fact that the trust documents themselves did not guarantee return of the principal amounts. Plaintiff-appellant's claims against the trust company and the attorney for the estate were properly dismissed. Plaintiff-appellant failed to plead with sufficient particularity his fraud claims against the trust company and the attorney. Additionally, the complaint conclusively showed on its face that the breach of trust claim was barred by the statute of limitations.
- 2018 Ohio 88State v. Brown (2018)
Sentencing sanctions community control conditions violation notification prison term journal entry resentencing restrictive remedy remand vacate. The trial court erred in imposing a term of imprisonment for the community control violation based on its failure to make the necessary advisements under R.C. 2929.19(B)(4). At the resentencing, the trial court must choose between the only options remaining under R.C. 2929.15(B): (1) impose a longer time under the same sanction or, (2) impose a more restrictive sanction.
- 2018 Ohio 89Adams v. McElroy (2018)
Motion to vacate motion for relief from judgment Civ.R. 60(B) default judgment service of process void judgment personal jurisdiction due process Civ.R. 4.1 evidentiary hearing abuse of discretion. Appellant's motion to vacate the default judgment entered against her based on lack of service contained operative facts that warranted relief from judgment. Thus, the trial court abused its discretion by denying appellant's motion to vacate without holding an evidentiary hearing.
- 2018 Ohio 90State v. Binford (2018)
Sufficiency of evidence manifest weight of evidence ineffective assistance of counsel consecutive sentences. Defendant's convictions for felonious assault, having weapons while under disability, and improperly handling firearms in a motor vehicle were supported by sufficient evidence and were not against the manifest weight of the evidence there is no requirement the state must produce the gun used by defendant, and two witnesses testified that they saw the defendant shooting out of his car window trial counsel was not ineffective for not introducing a police body camera video into evidence where counsel asked a witness about his inconsistent statements on the video and those statements were not necessarily helpful to the defendant's defense the trial court properly imposed an 11-year prison sentence where the record reflects the court considered the purposes and principles of R.C. 2929.11 and the factors of R.C. 2929.12, and made the R.C. 2929.14(C)(4) statutory findings for imposing consecutive sentences.
- 2018 Ohio 91State v. McNeir (2018)
Crim.R. 11, coercion, competency hearing, waiver, harmless waiver. The trial court's colloquy with the defendant was not coercive, and the defendant's guilty plea was voluntary. Further, the trial court did not err in failing to hold a competency hearing because the defendant failed to maintain his request for a hearing and, even if he did properly maintain his request, there was insufficient indicia of incompetence.
- 2018 Ohio 92State v. Carzelle (2018)
Allied offenses, felonious assault, discharging of a firearm on or near prohibited premises. The trial court did not err in imposing a consecutive sentence for felonious assault and discharging a firearm on or near prohibited premises because these offenses are not allied offenses. The offenses were committed with separate animus or motivation and caused a separate, identifiable harm.
- 2018 Ohio 93Butler v. Cleveland Clinic (2018)
Trip and Fall open and obvious. Trial court did not err in awarding Cleveland Clinic summary judgment in trip and fall case where plaintiff was hurt while stepping onto open and obvious raised concrete island.
- 2018 Ohio 94McMillan v. Lakewood (2018)
Administrative appeal variance setback air conditioner moot ordinance amended practical difficulty preponderance. Affirmed trial court's decision finding appellant's administrative appeal moot and, in the alternative, affirming the decision of the Lakewood Board of Zoning Appeals that granted a three-foot variance to an adjoining property owner for the installation of an air conditioner condenser unit. The zoning ordinance had been amended with regard to the setback requirement, and the trial court's decision was supported by the preponderance of substantial, reliable, and probative evidence where upon the evidence presented, the board could have reached a determination of practical difficulty and found in favor of granting the variance.
- 2018 Ohio 95State v. Burton (2018)
Consecutive sentences firearm specification R.C. 2929.14 due process forfeiture R.C. 2981.04. Pursuant to R.C. 2929.14(C)(1)(a), the trial court was required to impose consecutive sentences on the two firearm specifications. Appellant's due process rights were not violated regarding forfeiture of property seized from her home.
- 2018 Ohio 96In re J.F. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 98Akerstrom v. 635 W. Lakeside, Ltd. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 100Philbin v. City of Cleveland (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 103State v. Bennett (2018)
Inmate's effort to set aside his agreed upon sentence has no merit.
- 2018 Ohio 104State ex rel. Hairston v. State (2018)
For multiple reasons inmate's petition for a special writ should be denied.
- 2018 Ohio 105State v. Slaughter (2018)
AUTOMOBILES/CRIMINAL - CONSTITUTIONAL LAW/CRIMINAL - SEARCH AND SEIZURE - TRAFFIC STOP: In a prosecution for driving under the influence of alcohol and a marked-lanes violation, the trial court did not err in overruling defendant's motion to suppress evidence on the basis that the Ohio state highway patrol trooper had lacked probable cause or a reasonable and articulable suspicion to stop defendant's vehicle where the trooper testified that he had witnessed a marked-lanes violation, which was not inconsistent with a video recording of the traffic stop taken from his cruiser camera, even though the marked-lanes violation was not visible on the video due to the glare of oncoming headlights.
- 2018 Ohio 107AEP Energy, Inc. v. Vemulapalli (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in overruling Defendants' Civ.R. 60(B) motion for relief from default judgment since the fraud they alleged did not satisfy Civ.R. 60(B)(3)'s requirement of fraud involved in the obtaining of the default judgment. Defendants further did not demonstrate mistake justifying relief pursuant to Civ.R. 60(B)(1), since they failed to obtain new counsel as ordered and to defend in any manner. Defendants' arguments on appeal that AEP fraudulently obtained the default judgment were not raised before the trial court, and we will accordingly not consider them. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 108Boyd v. State (2018)
After his conviction for having weapons while under disability was reversed on appeal, plaintiff brought suit against the State of Ohio, seeking a declaration that he was a "wrongfully imprisoned individual," pursuant to R.C. 2743.48(A). The trial court dismissed the action, pursuant to Civ.R. 12(B)(6), on the ground that the plaintiff could not satisfy the fifth element of R.C. 2743.48(A). The trial court properly concluded that plaintiff could not state a claim under the "error in procedure" prong of R.C. 2743.48(A)(5) and that he could not state a claim of actual innocence based on the lack of a disability. Trial court erred in concluding that plaintiff could not state a claim of actual innocence based on his allegation that he never possessed the firearm. Judgment affirmed in part, reversed in part, and case remanded for further proceedings.
- 2018 Ohio 109State v. Burnett (2018)
The trial court did not err in refusing to give a requested jury instruction on operation and operability of the vehicle at issue during the appellant's OVI trial. The requested instruction was not an accurate statement of law, and the trial court correctly gave the jury the statutory definition of "operate" set forth in R.C. 4511.01(HHH). Defense counsel did not provide ineffective assistance by failing to request an instruction on the offense of having physical control of a vehicle while under the influence of alcohol in violation of R.C. 4511.194(B). The jury reasonably could not have acquitted the appellant of OVI and convicted him under the physical-control statute. The appellant's OVI conviction is supported by legally sufficient evidence that he operated a vehicle while intoxicated. Judgment affirmed. (Froelich, J., concurring.)
- 2018 Ohio 110In re C.M.R. (2018)
The trial court did not err in overruling a motion to suppress filed by Appellant, a juvenile, challenging the statements he made while being interviewed by an investigating detective. Appellant's statements were not made while he was in custody therefore, the investigating detective was not required to advise Appellant of his Miranda rights. In addition, because Appellant was not in custody, Appellant had no Fifth Amendment right to counsel, which he otherwise did not invoke, nor were Appellant's statements involuntarily induced by coercive police conduct. Furthermore, at the time of Appellant's interview with the investigating detective, no complaint had been filed against him and he had not made an initial appearance at juvenile court accordingly, Appellant did not have a statutory right to counsel under R.C. 2151.352 or a constitutional right to counsel under the due process clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. Lastly, Appellant's adjudication for rape was supported by sufficient evidence and was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 111State v. Contento (2018)
After conducting an independent review of the record as required by Anders, we find no issues with arguable merit for appeal. Appellant's guilty plea is valid and Appellant's jointly-recommended sentence is not appealable. Affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 112State v. Fyffe (2018)
Defendant pled guilty to three counts of unlawful sexual conduct with a minor, all third-degree felonies, for which he received consecutive sentences totaling nine years in prison. Defendant's plea was knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily made defendant knew, at the time of his plea, that the trial court was not bound by the sentencing range to which the parties had agreed. Because the trial court was not a party to the plea agreement and explicitly explained that fact during the plea colloquy, it was not error for the court to impose a sentence longer than that recommended by the parties, nor was it error for the court not to have offered, sua sponte, to allow the defendant to withdraw his plea. Trial court's imposition of consecutive sentences was not clearly and convincingly unsupported by the record the record supported the trial court's finding that defendant's criminal history warranted consecutive sentencing. Judgment affirmed. (Donovan, J., dissenting.)
- 2018 Ohio 113State v. Laraby (2018)
Defendant-appellant's counsel filed a brief under the authority of Anders v. California, 386 U.S. 738, 87 S.Ct. 1396, 18 L.Ed.2d 493 (1967). A thorough review of the record reveals no arguably meritorious appellate issues. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 114Brannon v. Persons (2018)
The trial court did not err in rendering summary judgment in favor of Appellees on their claim for attorney fees, as Appellant failed to submit any evidence that created a genuine issue of material fact regarding the reasonableness of the fees. Further, assuming for the sake of argument that the action was more properly based on quantum meruit rather than breach of contract, no prejudice occurred. Appellees also asked the court for equitable relief, and Appellant failed to provide the court with any evidence to challenge the fees that were requested. Appellant was entitled under the law to discharge her attorneys, but she was not entitled to breach the settlement agreement in an attempt to recover more money than the sum to which she had agreed. Finally, Appellant failed to submit any evidence indicating that Appellees committed legal malpractice. Affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 116State v. Caskey (2018)
Municipal court erred in finding that it lacked subject matter jurisdiction to consider appellant's appeal of his driver's license suspension, where such jurisdiction is vested in the court pursuant to R.C. 4510.73.
- 2018 Ohio 117State v. Brown (2018)
Once the juvenile court transferred a murder charge to the general division, it was not error to transfer any other charge founded on the same course of conduct. Exercising discretion in sentencing appellant to consecutive terms of life without parole for aggravated murders neither subjected him to cruel and unusual punishment, nor violated the mandates of Miller.
- 2018 Ohio 118Hetrick v. Lockwood (2018)
Dismissal is appropriate where appellant failed to file objections to the magistrate's granting of the civil protection order within 14 days as required by Civ.R. 65.1(F)(3)(d) and (G).
- 2018 Ohio 119Levy v. Huener (2018)
The trial court properly granted summary judgment on appellant's common law negligence claims because any danger was open and obvious. The trial court erred in granting summary judgment on the issue of proximate cause in appellant's statutory negligence claims because a genuine issue of material fact remains regarding whether the slope of the creek bridge proximately caused appellant's fall.
- 2018 Ohio 120Multibank 2009-1CML-ADC Venture, L.L.C. v. S. Bass Island Resort, Ltd. (2018)
Because the execution of a note and mortgage are separate contracts, res judicata does not prohibit a bank from seeking judgment on the note in an action in Erie County, and also seeking judgment in foreclosure of the mortgage in Ottawa County.
- 2018 Ohio 122State v. Wright (2018)
Felony domestic violence, improper joinder, manifest weight of the evidence, ineffective assistance of counsel
- 2018 Ohio 123State v. Hersi (2018)
Jury instructions, police officer, abuse of discretion, sufficiency of the evidence, manifest weight of the evidence
- 2018 Ohio 124State v. Wolfe (2018)
vehicular assault, R.C. 2903.08(A)(2)(b), recklessness, sufficiency of the evidence
- 2018 Ohio 128MultiBank 2009-1CML-ADC Venture LLC v. S. Bass Island Resort, Ltd. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 133State v. Hudson (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - sufficient evidence to support enhanced possession of cocaine conviction possession of cocaine conviction established via sufficient evidence circumstantial evidence of constructive possession of cocaine personal items in locked bedroom.
- 2018 Ohio 135State ex rel. Hudson v. Sloan (2018)
EXTRAORDINARY WRITS - alternative writs seeking release from prison prior decision reversing and vacating penalty enhancement based on Supreme Court's decision that was subsequently reconsidered State v. Gonzales, 150 Ohio St.3d 276, 2017-Ohio-777, 81 N.E.3d 419 summary judgment appropriate in warden's favor because Hudson is not entitled to release as a matter of law.
- 2018 Ohio 136Bank of Am., N.A. v. Brannon (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - R.C. 2505.02(B) appeal from an entry granting leave to file a motion for summary judgment is not a final appealable order.
- 2018 Ohio 137State v. Brown (2018)
Trial court did not err by finding that appellant's convictions for aggravated murder, aggravated burglary, and aggravated robbery were not allied offenses of similar import.
- 2018 Ohio 138In re T.L. (2018)
Sufficient credible evidence supported the juvenile court's decision to grant permanent custody of parents' child to children services agency where parents failed to complete their case plan for reunification including failing to improve their income and obtain safe and stable housing.
- 2018 Ohio 139State v. Warwick (2018)
The defendant failed to establish the trial court's noncompliance with the requirements of R.C. 2951.03 where there was no evidence in the record demonstrating the court failed to provide the defendant or her defense counsel with access to the presentence investigation report prior to sentencing. The defendant's claims of prosecutorial misconduct were without merit where there was no evidence in the record indicating the prosecutor had an ex parte communication with the judge prior to sentencing, the defendant failed to establish any prejudice from the alleged communication, the record demonstrated the prosecutor provided notice of its intent to call an expert witness at sentencing, and the materials the prosecutor introduced at the sentencing hearing were provided to defense counsel during discovery.
- 2018 Ohio 140State v. Raphael (2018)
Appellant's conviction for possession was valid where the evidence at trial demonstrated that appellant had constructive possession the marijuana because the drugs were located in close proximity to appellant, appellant exhibited signs of knowing about the marijuana when the stop occurred, and appellant took steps prior to the stop that showed his control over the marijuana such as depositing a large sum of cash in his checking account and purchasing bags meant to divide and distribute the marijuana.
- 2018 Ohio 141State v. Kautz (2018)
The trial court's decision finding appellant guilty of operating a vehicle under the influence of alcohol, his sixth such conviction in the past 20 years, was supported by the record where the trial court properly admitted a certified copy of a judgment entry and written waiver of counsel evidencing appellant's prior conviction for an equivalent operating while under the influence of alcohol offense issued by another court.
- 2018 Ohio 142State v. Hurst (2018)
The trial court erred by granting appellee 17 days of jail-time credit for the time she spent on electronically monitored house arrest following her conviction for one count of unauthorized use of property for, when applying the so-called "restraint of movement" reasoning rather than a strict textual interpretation of the relevant statutes, appellee's freedom of movement was not in any way restrained such that she could not leave her home on her own volition, despite the fact that it would constitute a violation of her community control sanctions and potentially subject her to prosecution for escape, so as to be entitled to receive jail-time credit for her time spent on electronically monitored house arrest.
- 2018 Ohio 143State v. Phillips (2018)
Sentence contrary to law
- 2018 Ohio 145In re Estate of Choe (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 147State v. Richmond (2018)
Judgment affirmed in part and reversed in part and case remanded with instructions to modify appellant's sentence by reducing the restitution amount from $3,773.26 to $2,006.26. The original restitution amount was clearly and convincingly contrary to law because it included $1,767.00 in damage that did not arise from a crime for which appellant was convicted, as required by R.C. 2929.18(A)(1).
- 2018 Ohio 148State ex. rel. Hairston v. Franklin Cty. Court of Common Pleas (2018)
Action dismissed. Relator did not comply with the mandatory requirements of R.C. 2969.25(C). Relator cannot cure this deficiency by attempting to comply with the statutory requirements after the fact. As such, we adopt the magistrate's decision as our own, including the findings of fact and conclusions of law.
- 2018 Ohio 149Wright v. Heller (2018)
RES JUDICATA/ESTOPPEL - ISSUE PRECLUSION - PRIVITY: The trial court did not err in granting summary judgment in favor of defendants on plaintiffs' claims for conversion, replevin and unjust enrichment related to personal property plaintiffs had failed to remove from their home after a foreclosure proceeding: plaintiffs were precluded from raising the claims because a federal court had issued a valid judgment on the merits in a prior proceeding, the parties to the state court proceeding were in privity with the party in the federal proceeding, the state action raised claims that could have been raised in the federal proceeding, and both actions arose from the same occurrence.
- 2018 Ohio 150State v. Reece (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 154State v. Wilson (2018)
Sexual Battery - Manifest weight and sufficiency
- 2018 Ohio 161City of Cleveland v. Laborers Int'l Union Local 1099 (2018)
Arbitration R.C. Chapter 2711 modification jurisdiction trial court's authority execution of judgment Civ.R. 52 findings of fact some evidence. Where the arbitrator's award of "reasonable and demonstrable lost back pay" was confirmed by the trial court and affirmed on appeal, the arbitrator lacked jurisdiction to revisit the award. The trial court's award thereafter of a sum certain was not a modification of the arbitrator's award but rather a proper exercise of the court's inherent authority to interpret and enforce judgments. The trial court's damage award was supported by some evidence. We therefore must presume regularity and affirm the trial court's award.
- 2018 Ohio 162State v. Jeffries (2018)
Prior nonconsensual sexual activity rape shield statute other acts evidence grooming kidnapping jury instruction released in a safe place unharmed ineffective assistance of counsel court costs indigent insufficient evidence manifest weight of the evidence witness testimony stricken relevant. Ohio's rape shield statute prohibits admission of evidence of both prior consensual and nonconsensual sexual activity of the victim testimony regarding prior sexual activity the defendant had with the child victim was not improper other acts evidence but was properly admitted to show the defendant's plan and scheme to groom the victim for sexual activity trial court did not err in not instructing the jury that it should find whether the victim was "released in a safe place unharmed" before finding the defendant guilty of kidnapping in violation of R.C. 2905.01(C)(3)(a) because the defendant did not argue that as an affirmative defense and offered no evidence that the victim was released unharmed counsel was ineffective for not moving to waive court costs where the trial court had found the defendant indigent and appointed counsel defendant's convictions for rape and kidnapping were supported by sufficient evidence and not against the manifest weight of the evidence where the victim's testimony showed she was physically restrained while the defendant raped and kidnapped her the evidence also showed that the defendant restrained the victim through the psychological pressure inherent in his position as a father figure to the victim trial court did not err in striking a witness's nonresponsive testimony that was not relevant to the victim's credibility.
- 2018 Ohio 163In re D.C. (2018)
Juvenile rape anal opening penetration buttock ineffective assistance of counsel allied offenses sufficiency of the evidence manifest weight of the evidence. Testimony that juvenile took victim's hand and "drove it" it into the victim's "bottom," without clarification as to what the victim meant by the word "bottom," is insufficient to establish penetration of the anal opening necessary for a charge of rape.
- 2018 Ohio 164State v. Young (2018)
Terry stop reasonable suspicion request for identification warrant search incident to arrest. Trial court does not err by allowing evidence seized pursuant to arrest after police discovered active warrant. Police request for identification is not inappropriate during a Terry stop.
- 2018 Ohio 165State v. Johnson (2018)
Manifest weight sufficiency of the evidence Evid.R. 404(B) other acts evidence R.C. 2929.14 controlled buy circumstantial evidence. Defendant-appellant's convictions for trafficking, drug possession, and possession of criminal tools was supported by the weight and sufficiency of the evidence. The circumstantial evidence presented by the state was sufficient to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that defendant-appellant had possessed and sold the drugs recovered from the informants. Defendant-appellant did not put forth any showing to overcome the presumption that the jury followed the court's curative instruction regarding other acts evidence, nor did defendant-appellant articulate that this error resulted in such prejudice to warrant a mistrial. The trial court made the required findings under R.C. 2929.14(C) to support its imposition of consecutive sentences and incorporated these findings in its sentencing journal entry as required by State v. Bonnell, 140 Ohio St.3d 209, 2014 Ohio 3177, 16 N.E.3d 659.
- 2018 Ohio 166State v. Bridge (2018)
Gambling, R.C. 3772.99, Dice Sliding, Other Acts Evidence. Sufficient evidence was presented to convict appellant of gambling in violation of R.C. 3772.99 by means of dice sliding. Appellant and his companions engaged in a deliberate effort to covertly remove the element of chance from the game of craps to their own wagering benefit and to the detriment of both the casino and the other gamblers at the table. Other acts evidence consisting of an attempt by appellant to slide dice at another casino was admissible to establish appellant's familiarity with the rules of craps and an absence of mistake in appellant's conduct.
- 2018 Ohio 167Cleveland v. Lucas (2018)
Final, appealable order appellate jurisdiction. The imposition of a single fine and community control sanction when there are multiple counts does not create a final appealable order.
- 2018 Ohio 168State v. Boyce (2018)
Remand mandate sexual offender classification sexual predator res judicata former R.C. 2950.09(B)(2) factors hearing evidence. Prior mandate from the appellate court in the case did not limit the record for the trial court's determination of appellee's sexual offender classification upon the earlier remand, and the trial court erred by failing to conduct a complete hearing and by failing to consider all available evidence in rendering its determination. The trial court's classification of appellee as a sexually oriented offender was reversed, and the case was remanded for the trial court to conduct a proper sexual offender classification hearing in accordance with former R.C. 2950.09 and State v. Eppinger, 91 Ohio St.3d 158, 743 N.E.2d 881 (2001).
- 2018 Ohio 169State v. Johnson (2018)
Motion to suppress search warrant affidavit probable cause Franks v. Delaware, 438 U.S. 154, 98 S.Ct. 2674, 57 L.Ed.2d 667 (1978) Illinois v. Gates, 462 U.S. 213, 294, 103 S.Ct. 2317, 76 L.Ed.2d 527 (1983) R.C. 2929.51(A) sentence modification invalid. The trial court did not err in denying defendant's motion to suppress under Franks and Gates where defendant failed to support his motion by more than general denials and allegations and the controlled buy leading to issuance of the search warrant was conducted within 48 hours of the search warrant execution. The trial court lacked authority to modify defendant's sentence.
- 2018 Ohio 170State v. Jones (2018)
Manifest weight unlawful sexual conduct with a minor. Jury verdict finding defendant guilty of unlawful sexual conduct with a minor was supported by competent credible evidence that defendant knew the victim was only 14 years of age and continued to engage in sexual conduct with her.
- 2018 Ohio 171Riddick v. Taylor (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 172State ex rel. Allen v. Vill. of Walton Hills (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 174State v. Weaver (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 174Bryant v. Indus. Power Sys., Inc. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 183Johnson v. Nemr (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 184Hillman v. Larrison (2018)
Judgment reversed case remanded. The trial court did not consider the documentary materials attached to appellant's affidavit before concluding that his private citizen complaint under R.C. 2935.09(D) was not meritorious and declining to issue a warrant. Under R.C. 2701.03, this court is without jurisdiction to consider appellant's accusations of the trial court's judicial bias.
- 2018 Ohio 185Orthopedic & Neurological Consultants, Inc. v. Cincinnati Ins. Group (2018)
In this insurance coverage dispute, the trial court did not err in granting summary judgment in favor of appellee because appellee has no duty to defend appellants in the underlying action initiated against them. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 186Kenneth's Hair Salons & Day Spas, Inc. v. Braun (2018)
Trial court order granting Civ.R. 27 petition to perpetuate testimony, and thereby ordering respondent to submit to deposition, was a final appealable order.
- 2018 Ohio 187Cincinnati Bar Assn. v. Wiest (2018)
On application for reinstatement.
- 2018 Ohio 188Cleveland Metro. Bar Assn. v. Mamone and Zoller (2018)
On application for reinstatement.
- 2018 Ohio 190State v. Anderson (2018)
The trial court did not err in overruling the appellant's suppression motion. A police officer possessed reasonable, articulable suspicion to justify briefly detaining the appellant to investigate a burglar alarm at a business where the officer observed the appellant acting suspiciously outside the business. The officer also was entitled to conduct a weapons frisk based on his reasonable belief that the appellant might be armed and dangerous. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 191State v. Armstrong (2018)
Trial court properly denied defendant's "motion for court to consider evidence that gun spec has already been served." Defendant cannot raise issues unrelated to the motion on appeal. Defendant was not convicted of a gun specification in this case, and defendant's motion was not the proper avenue to challenge the Ohio Department of Rehabilitation and Correction's determination of his sentence expiration date. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 192State v. Dixon (2018)
The trial court did not err in overruling the appellant's motion for relief from judgment on the basis of a void sentence. The appellant's motion alleged that the trial court should have merged allied offenses of similar import when it sentenced him in 2006 and that its failure to do so rendered his sentence void. Assuming, purely arguendo, that the appellant was entitled to merger, the failure to merge allied offenses of similar import renders a sentence voidable, not void. Therefore, the trial court correctly found the appellant's argument barred by res judicata. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 194Green & Green, Lawyers v. Trimbach (2018)
In claim for attorney fees, law firm supported its motion for summary judgment with affidavits from the attorney who worked on the case, which detailed the work performed and the fees charged, and attested to the reasonableness of those fees. In response, the defendants-clients presented affidavits and attachments which showed, very generally, their dissatisfaction with the pace of the litigation for which the firm had been hired, but did not claim that the work had not been performed or that the fees had been unreasonable. Under these circumstances, there was no genuine issue of material fact that the firm was entitled to collect the fees or as to the reasonableness of those fees, summary judgment in favor of the law firm on the account was appropriate, and expert testimony from another attorney about the reasonableness of the fees was unnecessary. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 195State v. Landgraf (2018)
Having conducted a thorough, independent review of the proceedings pursuant to Anders v. California, 386 U.S. 738, 87 S.Ct. 1396, 18 L.Ed.2d 493 (1967), there are no potential assignments of error having arguable merit. Appellant's appeal is wholly frivolous, and the judgment of the trial court is affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 196City of Dayton v. Patrick (2018)
Defendant-appellant, following a bench trial, was convicted of a violation of Dayton Revised Code General Ordinance 91.50(A)(5), a strict liability offense, as a result of her dog's attack upon a neighbor's cat. Defendant-appellant, despite her absence when the attack occurred with the dog being supervised by her teenage son, engaged in voluntary conduct by her ownership of the dog. The city, accordingly, established that Defendant-appellant suffered or permitted the dog's attack. The trial court, additionally, did not err by rejecting Defendant-appellant's trespass defense. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 198State v. Scott (2018)
The trial court did not err by overruling Defendant-appellant's motion to suppress identification testimony of two witnesses. The trial court did not err in the manner in which it handled the potential testimony of a witness who ultimately asserted her privilege against self-incrimination, and, further, the record does not support a prosecutorial misconduct conclusion regarding this issue. The trial court did not err by overruling Defendant-appellant's Crim.R. 29 motion for acquittal regarding the two murder counts. Further, the jury verdicts regarding the two murder counts are not against the manifest weight of the evidence. The trial court did not abuse its discretion by failing to charge the jury on involuntary manslaughter and reckless homicide. The trial court did not abuse its discretion by allowing the introduction of two photographs depicting Defendant-appellant holding a handgun matching witnesses' descriptions of the murder weapon. Finally, the record does not reveal any error associated with a detective's testimony regarding a surveillance video viewed by the jury. Judgment affirmed. (Donovan, J., concurring in judgment only.)
- 2018 Ohio 200State v. Hutchison (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 205State v. Shaffer (2018)
Sufficiency of the evidence, illegal assembly or possession of chemicals for the manufacture of drugs, NPLEx
- 2018 Ohio 207State v. Randle (2018)
On direct appeal, review is limited to the facts contained in the record. Further, the offenses of kidnapping and robbery do not merge where each of these offenses were undertaken with a different animus.
- 2018 Ohio 208Wittenbrook v. Elecs. Recycling Servs., Inc. (2018)
Single joint employer doctrine retaliatory discharge sexual harassment/hostile work environment jury interrogatories plain error closing arguments
- 2018 Ohio 212State v. Evans (2018)
Criminal: R.C. 2923.131 manifest weight of the evidence possession of deadly weapon while under detention.
- 2018 Ohio 213Technical Constr. Specialties, Inc. v. DeWeese (2018)
Writ of Prohibition and Mandamus
- 2018 Ohio 214State v. Shafer (2018)
Motion to continue-trial court did not abuse its discretion by overruling defendant's motion to continue sentencing hearing when appellant did not present any evidence that he was unable to attend hearing trial counsel not ineffective
- 2018 Ohio 217Barrow v. Vill. of New Miami (2018)
Trial court did not err in denying village's summary judgment motion requesting governmental immunity. Motorists' unjust enrichment/restitution claim was an equitable claim of restitution, and not a legal claim for money damages, and was not barred by sovereign immunity.
- 2018 Ohio 218State v. Carter (2018)
Trial court's sentencing decision was fully supported by the record and was not contrary to law.
- 2018 Ohio 219State v. Fryman (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 220State v. Payne (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 221State v. Whicker (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 222State v. Orellana-Rodas (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 223In re S.A.R. (2018)
Juvenile court did not err in denying appellant's motion to withdraw his no contest plea where the totality of the circumstances demonstrated the juvenile made a valid waiver of his right to counsel and the juvenile subjectively understood the implications of his plea. As the record demonstrated the plea was made knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily, the juvenile court did not abuse its discretion in denying the motion without holding a hearing.
- 2018 Ohio 224State v. Dutton (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 225State v. O'Neill (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 227Hodge v. Callinan (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 233State v. Buckner (2018)
Insufficient evidence
- 2018 Ohio 234Johnson v. Michael (2018)
No final appealable order - appeal of transfer of venue
- 2018 Ohio 235Disciplinary Counsel v. Simmonds (2018)
On certification of default.
- 2018 Ohio 236State ex rel. Ado Staffing, Inc. v. Indus. Comm. (2018)
Writ of mandamus denied as premature
- 2018 Ohio 237Hinton v. Ohio Bureau of Sentence Computation (2018)
Credit for good behavior and participation in prison programs is deducted from the minimum figure in an indefinite sentence such that the prisoner is eligible for parole sooner. It does not affect the maximum sentence. Declaratory judgment under R.C. 2721.12 has limited use in criminal post-sentence contexts because of its statutory requirements that are jurisdictional.
- 2018 Ohio 238Sullivan v. Ikharo (2018)
Property owner's extended absence from Ohio did not deprive the trial court of jurisdiction in a lawsuit to collect back taxes. Service by publication was perfected.
- 2018 Ohio 239State v. Jones (2018)
Trial court did not err in failing to give jury instruction on aggravated assault and defense of another and trial counsel was not ineffective for failing to request defense of another jury instruction.
- 2018 Ohio 240State v. Schwendeman (2018)
criminal damaging jury instruction landowner privilege to remove encroachment affirmative defense plain error failure to object ineffective assistance of counsel sound trial strategy
- 2018 Ohio 244In re J.B. (2018)
permanent custody - first-prong finding - 12 or more months of a consecutive 22-month period - notice - issue of first impression - spirit of the law
- 2018 Ohio 245State v. Oswald (2018)
sufficiency - weight - R.C. 2907.03(A)(3) - sexual battery - asleep - unconscious - knowingly - high probability
- 2018 Ohio 246State v. Purefoy (2018)
Motion to suppress, Miranda v. Arizona, voluntary, coercion, manifest weight of the evidence
- 2018 Ohio 253State v. Brown (2018)
Trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying the request for appointment of new counsel or, in the alternative, a continuance Menacing by stalking conviction was based on sufficient evidence Consecutive sentence was not contrary to law.
- 2018 Ohio 254State v. Telego (2018)
no prosecutorial misconduct by asking defendant certain questions when he testified no ineffective assistance of counsel by failing to retain medical expert or requesting a sanction after a prosecution expert arrived in town late.
- 2018 Ohio 259Meyer v. United Airlines, Inc. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 267Cleveland v. Battles (2018)
Criminal damaging sufficiency of the evidence manifest weight of the evidence. Conviction for criminal damaging is supported by sufficient evidence and not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 268State v. Mock (2018)
Motion to suppress manifest weight sufficiency Fourth Amendment reasonable expectation of privacy reasonable suspicion exculpatory evidence Brady violation ineffective assistance of counsel. The trial court properly denied appellant's suppression motions. Appellant's convictions are supported by sufficient evidence and are not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 269State v. Clifton (2018)
Voluntary plea Crim.R. 11(C)(2) maximum penalty prejudice aggravated murder postrelease control unclassified felony parole sentence contrary to law delayed appeal court costs indigency. The defendant was not prejudiced by the trial court incorrectly advising him at the plea hearing that he would be subject to five years of mandatory postrelease control if he was released from prison for aggravated murder, which was an unclassified felony not subject to postrelease control. The defendant was not prejudiced by the trial court's failure to advise him of the potential maximum fine for aggravated murder at the plea hearing because the trial court did not impose a fine. The defendant was not prejudiced by the trial court's failure to advise him of his appellate rights at the sentencing hearing because this court granted his motion for delayed appeal. The defendant's arguments relating to court costs were overruled because it was clear from the record that the trial court considered defendant's indigency and still imposed court costs. The postrelease control portion of defendant's sentence was vacated.
- 2018 Ohio 270Smoot v. Dir., Ohio Dept. of Job & Family Servs. (2018)
Discharge just cause unemployment benefits Review Commission appeal manifest weight of the evidence, evidence supported in record. Judgment reversed. The Review Commission's decision is not supported by the evidence in the record. The claimant was an 11-year employee at the YMCA without any disciplinary complaints in her file. Over the course of a year, the employee was involved in several physical and verbal incidents with a YMCA member. The employee advised the YMCA about these incidents. The YMCA indicated that the member's behavior would not be tolerated and the employee was to advise management if any other issues occurred. The employee and the member did have another incident. The employee advised the YMCA of the same and the YMCA did nothing to address the member's conduct. Approximately five months later, the employee and the member had the sixth and final incident that resulted in the termination of the employee's employment. The employee gave the YMCA the opportunity to correct the problem with the member and the YMCA neglected to do so. The YMCA's failure to act placed the employee in a position where she was subjected to abusive conduct while waiting for her employer to respond. This isolated incident of physical conduct with the member, when viewed along with the employee's good record of job performance and the circumstances prior to the altercation, is insufficient evidence to support the Review Commission's determination that the employee was terminated for just cause.
- 2018 Ohio 271State v. Carson (2018)
Manifest weight sufficiency circumstantial possession actual constructive ownership gunshot residue inference. Defendant's having weapons while under disability conviction is supported by sufficient evidence and is not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 272State v. Johnson (2018)
Maximum and consecutive sentence for manslaughter and assault with firearm specification affirmed. Court's sentence was not contrary to law, the record supports the court's findings, and the court considered the proper felony sentencing statutes.
- 2018 Ohio 273State v. Simmons (2018)
Crim.R. 29 motion for acquittal sufficiency of the evidence carrying a concealed weapon improper handling of a firearm in a motor vehicle. Defendant's convictions for carrying a concealed weapon and improper handling of a firearm in a motor vehicle were supported by sufficient evidence. Accordingly, the trial court did not err in denying defendant's Crim.R. 29 motion for acquittal. Cleveland Police officers recovered the firearm from underneath the driver's seat in the car he was operating. One officer observed defendant reaching down toward the floor near the center console, where the gun was found, as if to conceal something. The officer did not observe either of the two passengers make any movements toward this area, and none of the occupants of the vehicle made any statements regarding who possessed or owned the reportedly stolen firearm.
- 2018 Ohio 274State v. Santorella (2018)
Robbery theft assault coconspirators manifest weight sufficiency restitution. Defendant's convictions for robbery, theft and assault were supported by sufficient evidence and were not against the manifest weight of the evidence in light of coconspirators' testimony and defendant's statement to police restitution award was supported by competent, credible evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 276State v. Jackson (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 281Herman v. Sema (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 283Williams v. KIA of Bedford (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 284Mouded v. Khoury (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 286City of Euclid v. Cannon (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 289In re A.G. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 293Houston v. AT & T Teleholdings, Inc. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 296State v. Parker (2018)
Imposition of consecutive sentences was not contrary to law Guilty plea was entered into knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily Trial counsel was not ineffective.
- 2018 Ohio 297State v. Detamore (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 298State v. Conley (2018)
Sufficiency of the evidence
- 2018 Ohio 299Bilbaran Farm, Inc. v. Sandusky St. Invests., L.L.C. (2018)
Validity of Easement Frivolous Conduct Sanctions not Warranted
- 2018 Ohio 300Smith v. Marquis (2018)
Writ of Habeas Corpus
- 2018 Ohio 302Cleveland Metro. Bar Assn. v. Zoller and Mamone (2018)
On application for reinstatement.
- 2018 Ohio 304Baradji v. Zulily (2018)
Trial court did not err when it granted summary judgment.
- 2018 Ohio 305State v. Allen (2018)
The trial court did not err in revoking defendant's intervention in lieu of conviction when the defendant failed to satisfy the restitution condition of the intervention plan. The trial court did not err when it imposed restitution as a condition of community control when the record reflects that the trial court considered defendant's present and future ability to pay.
- 2018 Ohio 306State v. Jones (2018)
Trial court did not abuse its discretion by denying petition for postconviction relief under the doctrine of res judicata and the prohibition on successive petitions for postconviction relief in R.C. 2953.23. Appellant claimed that his conviction on charges of murder and felony murder of the same victim violated the merger statute and constitutional protections against double jeopardy, but this claim could have been asserted at trial or on direct appeal and, therefore, was barred by res judicata. Additionally, appellant had previously filed a petition for postconviction relief and failed to establish that any of the exceptions to the limitation on successive petitions for postconviction relief applied. Appellant's convictions for murder and felony murder were merged for purposes of sentencing therefore, the trial court did not violate the merger statute or the constitutional protections against double jeopardy.
- 2018 Ohio 307State ex rel. McBroom v. Indus. Comm. (2018)
Motion to strike denied motion for summary judgment grantes, write of mandamus granted.
- 2018 Ohio 309State v. Howard (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 310In re A.F. (2018)
As to Mother's appeal, the juvenile court's grant of legal custody of A.F. to Father's relatives was in A.F.'s best interest, and the court did not err in failing to grant a second extension of temporary custody. As to Father's appeal, the Agency made reasonable efforts to prevent the removal of A.F. from the parental residence, to eliminate the continued removal of the child from the parental home, or to make it possible for the child to return safely to the home of Mother and Father. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 311Williamson v. Caldwell (2018)
The trial court denied Appellant's petition seeking a civil stalking protection order (CSPO). Appellant asserts that the trial court's denial of the petition is against the manifest weight of the evidence. The Appellant did not file a transcript of the CSPO hearing, and without a transcript, a weight of the evidence argument may not be considered on appeal. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 312State v. Core (2018)
The appellant's conviction for promoting prostitution is based on legally sufficient evidence and is not against the manifest weight of the evidence. The evidence supports a finding that he knowingly supervised, managed, or controlled the activities of a prostitute in engaging in sexual activity for hire. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 313State v. Gause (2018)
The trial court erred in dismissing Appellee's indicted charge of having weapons while under disability. In dismissing the charge, the trial court misapplied the Supreme Court of Ohio's holding in State v. Hand, 149 Ohio St.3d 94, 2016-Ohio-5504, 73 N.E.3d 448, and erroneously concluded that the statute governing the offense of having weapons while under disability, R.C. 2923.13(A)(2), unconstitutionally permits a juvenile adjudication to serve as an element of the offense. Contrary to the trial court's holding otherwise, Hand does not ban the use of a prior juvenile adjudication as an element of an offense. Reversed and remanded for further proceedings. (Donovan, J., dissenting.)
- 2018 Ohio 314State v. Heard (2018)
Trial court properly denied defendant's motion to withdraw his plea due to a breach of the plea agreement contrary to defendant's assertion, the record reflects that defendant pled guilty to Counts One and Two, not just Count Two. Defendant's argument that the trial court had erred in imposing post-release control on Count One was barred by res judicata. Even assuming that the court erred in its imposition of post-release control on Count One, a fifth-degree felony, when it stated that defendant would be subject to three years, not "up to three years," of post-release control, defendant was also subject to a mandatory term of five years of post-release control for a first-degree felony accordingly, the trial court properly denied defendant's motion for a finding that the Parole Board lacked jurisdiction over him. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 316State v. Maloney (2018)
Appellant's convictions on two counts of rape (under 13) and two counts of sexual battery (natural parent) are supported by sufficient evidence and not against the manifest weight of the evidence. The record does not reflect that Appellant was denied effective assistance of counsel for defense counsel's alleged failure to engage in reasonable investigation and trial preparation, to communicate a plea offer, to subpoena expert testimony concerning DNA analysis and results, for advising Appellant to waive a jury, and for failing to file a motion to suppress. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 317State v. Meddock (2018)
Appellant's convictions for one count of murder, one count of involuntary manslaughter, one count of felonious assault, and two counts of endangering children were not against the manifest weight of the evidence. The evidence adduced by the State supports a finding that the fatal injury occurred during the time that appellant had exclusive care and control of the infant victim. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 318State v. Moore (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying Appellant's untimely motion for new trial without first holding an evidentiary hearing because Appellant failed to request leave to file the motion out of time and failed to establish by clear and convincing proof that Appellant was unavoidably prevented from timely filing the motion as required by Crim.R. 33(B). Affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 319State v. Morgan (2018)
Appellant's guilty plea to one count of rape was not made in a knowing, intelligent, and voluntary fashion. The trial court failed to inform appellant that he was subject to a mandatory prison term before it accepted his guilty plea to the rape count. The trial court also failed to inform appellant that because the prison time was mandatory for a rape conviction, he was ineligible for community control sanctions in lieu of prison. Furthermore, the plea form signed by appellant incorrectly stated that a mandatory prison term was "not applicable" to his conviction for rape. Judgment reversed and remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 320Parker v. ACE Hardware Corp. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 322Zifer v. Huffman (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 323State v. Everson (2018)
Appellant knowingly and voluntarily pleaded guilty to a traffic violation. Trial court's advice of rights form complied with Traf.R. 10(B) and (D) and sufficiently informed appellant of the effect of a guilty plea. Trial court failed to comply with Crim.R. 32(A)(1) by not addressing appellant at sentencing to ask if she wanted to make a statement on her behalf, but the error was harmless. R.C. 2929.25(A)(3) did not require the court to inform appellant of the consequences of violating community control.
- 2018 Ohio 324Ray v. Hidden Harbour Assn., Inc. (2018)
Planned community, fiduciary duty, R.C. 1702.30(B), Fair Housing Amendments Act, reasonable accommodation, restrictive covenants.
- 2018 Ohio 326State Ex Rel. McClair v. State Emp't Relations Bd. (2018)
Affirmed denial of a writ of mandamus SERB did not abuse its discretion by finding a lack of probable cause to issue a writ.
- 2018 Ohio 327O'Loughlin v. Ottawa St. Condominium Assn. (2018)
In a case stemming from liens due to nonpayment of condominium association dues, the trial court's verdict in the association's favor was not against the weight of the evidence. Award of full amount of attorney fees was not an abuse of discretion. Motion to dismiss R.C. Chapter 5311 negligence fiduciary duty breach of contract summary judgment motion in limine discrimination spoliation.
- 2018 Ohio 328State v. Simpson (2018)
Defendant's conviction was not contrary to the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 329State v. Walls (2018)
Trial court committed prejudicial error in refusing to limit expert's testimony not disclosed in written report as required by Crim.R. 16(K). No prejudicial error resulted where court advised witness how to phrase response to avoid disclosing inadmissible evidence. Identity as client and fact of communication not protected by attorney-client privilege. Creation of "materials" is not element of R.C. 2907.321(A)(3). Motion to return property properly denied where it may be used as evidence in later proceedings.
- 2018 Ohio 330State v. Myers (2018)
Most of appellant's postconviction relief claims are barred by res judicata however, his claim of ineffective assistance is not barred because his trial counsel represented him on direct appeal. Nevertheless, the petition was untimely under R.C. 2953.21(A)(2), and no exception in R.C. 2953.23 applies.
- 2018 Ohio 336State v. Penland (2018)
Ineffective assistance of counsel Strickland v. Washington, 466 U.S. 668, 104 S.Ct. 2052, 80 L.Ed.2d 674 (1984).
- 2018 Ohio 337City of Campbell v. Rosario (2018)
Crim.R. 16 a traffic ticket need only inform a defendant of the nature of the charge together with a citation of the statute or ordinance involved to convict a person of speeding, evidence must be introduced to show that the radar is in proper working condition for accurate readings, the officer is qualified to administer the device, and that the device is scientifically reliable.
- 2018 Ohio 339State v. Pirozak (2018)
No contest plea R.C. 2925.14 Crim.R. 11(E) meaningful dialogue effect of the plea R.C. 2937.07 explanation of circumstances jeopardy.
- 2018 Ohio 341McConnell v. Dudley (2018)
Civ.R. 9(A) requires parties to claim lack of capacity by "specific negative averment," or else the matter is waived immunity R.C. 2744.02(B)(1)(a) police pursuit determination of whether an officer's actions amount to willful, wanton, and reckless misconduct depends on the totality of the circumstances.
- 2018 Ohio 342State v. Anderson (2018)
nonsupport, R.C. 2919.21(B), community control, R.C. 2929.25(C)(2), anti-procreation, right to procreate, fundamental right, strict scrutiny
- 2018 Ohio 343State v. Chapman (2018)
nonsupport, R.C. 2919.21(B), community control, R.C. 2929.25(C)(2), anti-procreation, right to procreate, fundamental right, strict scrutiny
- 2018 Ohio 345Litchfield Twp. Bd. of Trustees v. Forever Blueberry Barn, L.L.C. (2018)
R.C. 519.21, injunction, zoning, viticulture
- 2018 Ohio 346Marquez v. Jackson (2018)
Civ.R. 59, motion for a new trial, abuse of discretion, law of the case, doctrine of laches, harmless error.
- 2018 Ohio 347State v. Riggs (2018)
misdemeanor conviction - appeal moot - voluntarily serve sentence - collateral consequences
- 2018 Ohio 348State v. Sisler (2018)
Crim.R. 29, fair trial, preservation of evidence, exculpatory evidence, bad faith
- 2018 Ohio 349State v. Dahms (2018)
Appellant's arguments are barred by the doctrine of res judicata.
- 2018 Ohio 350State v. Born (2018)
The trial court did not err in imposing Appellant's postrelease control sanction in accordance with R.C. 2929.191(C).
- 2018 Ohio 351State v. Bernard (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - aggravated robbery aggravated burglary felonious assault kidnapping jury trial judgments reversed and convictions vacated appellant was denied a fair trial because of the admission of prejudicial other acts evidence pursuant to Evid.R. 404(B) the evidence presented is not sufficient to support appellant's convictions as a matter of law the jury verdict was against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 353State v. Mathews (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 354State v. Ogle (2018)
CRIMINAL - As this appealed from entry does not contain findings of fact and conclusions of law, no final appealable order exists and we lack jurisdiction to consider this appeal and must dismiss it.
- 2018 Ohio 355City of E. Liverpool v. Boyd (2018)
sufficiency of the evidence, manifest weight of the evidence, nuisance, abatement.
- 2018 Ohio 356State v. Moses (2018)
trafficking in drugs, confidential informant, prosecutorial misconduct, prosecutor bolstered witness' credibility, new trial
- 2018 Ohio 357Bank of N.Y. Mellon v. Broyles (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 358Capital One Bank (USA), N.A. v. Caspary (2018)
creditor's bill, garnishment, summary judgment, money contract, judgment debtor.
- 2018 Ohio 361State v. J.A.C. (2018)
Municipal court did not err in denying motion to suppress where the affidavit submitted in support of the search warrant established probable cause to search defendant's cell phone for incidents of voyeurism. Defendant is precluded from challenging the juvenile court's denial of his motion to suppress on the basis of the good faith exception because defendant did not file objections to the magistrate's decision and does not claim plain error on appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 362State v. A.N.C (2018)
The trial court's decision to adjudicate appellant as a delinquent child for having committed an act that if charged as an adult would constitute burglary was supported by sufficient evidence and not against the weight of the evidence where the evidence indicated appellant and her two accomplices forced their way into the victims' garage by raising the garage door to a point where they were all able to crawl under at a time when another person, other than either of her two accomplices, was present or likely to be present.
- 2018 Ohio 363State v. Statzer (2018)
A trial court did not abuse its discretion in dismissing a defendant's petition for postconviction relief where the issues raised in the petition were raised and addressed in the defendant's direct appeal and where the defendant failed to support the petition with relevant, material evidence outside of the appellate record.
- 2018 Ohio 364In re A.H. (2018)
Juvenile court erred in accepting a juvenile's admission to a rape charge where the court first failed to rule on the juvenile's competency to stand trial and then subsequently failed to comply with the requirements of Juv.R. 29(D) by neglecting to inform the juvenile of the nature of the allegations against him, the consequences of an admission, and the rights he was waiving by entering an admission.
- 2018 Ohio 366State v. Kitts (2018)
Trafficking sentences
- 2018 Ohio 367Johnson v. Hershberge (2018)
Non-final appealable order
- 2018 Ohio 368State v. Church (2018)
Trial court did not abuse discretion by denying Petition for Post-Conviction relief without a hearing
- 2018 Ohio 371Lots of Love, Inc. v. Ohio Dept. of Dev. Disabilities (2018)
R.C. 119.12(E), unusual hardship
- 2018 Ohio 372Messer v. Summa Health Sys. (2018)
summary judgment - sex discrimination - gender discrimination - sexual harassment - privacy interest - R.C. 4112.02(A) - retaliatory discrimination - circumstantial evidence - R.C. 4112.02(I) - aiding and abetting to commit discrimination - R.C. 4112.02(J)
- 2018 Ohio 373State v. Hopkins (2018)
Sufficiency and manifest weight ineffective assistance murder aggravated murder
- 2018 Ohio 374State v. Leonard (2018)
Execution of costs indigent affidavit R.C. 2949.15
- 2018 Ohio 375Nicholson v. LoanMax, L.L.C. (2018)
Summary judgment immunity R.C. 2744 Political Subdivision Tort Liability Act negligent operation
- 2018 Ohio 377R. Kashmiry & Assocs., Inc. v. Ellis (2018)
Valuation of shares cross-appeal injunctive relief damages breach of fiduciary duty expert testimony
- 2018 Ohio 378State v. Kelly (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 379Stamatopoulos v. All Seasons Contracting (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 383Mitchell v. Babickas (2018)
Motion for summary judgment de novo Civ.R.56 service rebuttable presumption Civ.R. 5(D), vexatious litigator R.C. 2323.52 motion to hold case in abeyance Civ.R. 6(B)(2) abuse of discretion. Judgment affirmed. Trial court properly granted summary judgment in favor of defendant. Scotts' motion for summary judgment contained a certificate of service as required by Civ.R. 5(D). There is no evidence in the record that the motion had been returned to defendant indicating failure of delivery. Moreover, the evidence submitted to the trial court clearly demonstrated a pattern of conduct engaged in by plaintiff was designed to harass the defendant. Additionally, the trial court properly exercised its discretion in proceeding with the case.
- 2018 Ohio 388State v. Sims (2018)
Motion terminate counsel trial strategy effective assistance waiver guilty plea pretrial good cause conflict of interest breakdown of communication irreconcilable conflict abuse of discretion. Defendant waived the right to appeal all nonjurisdictional issues arising at prior stages of the proceedings by entering a plea of guilty. The trial court did not abuse its discretion by denying defendant's motion to terminate counsel. Defendant failed to demonstrate good cause to warrant the termination of counsel.
- 2018 Ohio 389City of Rocky River v. Zorc (2018)
Rocky River Codified Ordinances 333.031(A)(1), failure to change lanes when approaching safety vehicle with lights activated, Crim.R. 29(A), sufficiency of the evidence, manifest weight of the evidence, R.C. 4511.213(A)(1). The evidence was insufficient to support appellant's conviction for failing to change lanes when approaching a safety vehicle with lights activated. The video evidence depicts several vehicles in the center lane impeding appellant's ability to move to over. Appellant was unable to change lanes safely.
- 2018 Ohio 390City of Cleveland v. O'Donnell (2018)
Failure to comply no contest plea finding of guilt explanation of circumstances R.C. 2937.07 doubly jeopardy misdemeanor petty offense Crim.R. 11. The record from the plea hearing reflects that appellant did not expressly tender a no contest plea, and the trial court did not enter a finding of guilt. The trial court did not advise appellant of the effect of his no contest plea, and thus, failed to comply with Crim.R. 11(E). Accordingly, appellant's plea and the trial court's sentence must be vacated.
- 2018 Ohio 391State v. Frierson (2018)
Ineffective assistance of counsel, manifest weight of the evidence, inconsistent verdicts.
- 2018 Ohio 392M.W. v. D.M. (2018)
Civil stalking protection order R.C. 2903.214 Civ.R. 65.1 subject-matter jurisdiction personal jurisdiction manifest weight. The trial court had jurisdiction over the petition for a civil stalking protection order filed under R.C. 2903.214 by a Cuyahoga County resident, and the full order was based on competent, credible evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 395In re R.M. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 396State v. Wilson (2018)
Ineffective assistance/maximum sentence
- 2018 Ohio 398State v. McClellan (2018)
Post conviction relief
- 2018 Ohio 403State v. Shaw (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 404State v. Kinney (2018)
GUILTY PLEA - CRIMINAL RULE 11: Defendant's guilty pleas to two counts of aggravated burglary, two counts of aggravated robbery, two counts of kidnapping, each with a three-year gun specification, carrying a concealed weapon and vandalism were unknowing, unintelligent and involuntary where the trial court informed the defendant at the plea hearing that he was subject to a mandatory prison term on each of the first-degree felonies, but it misinformed him of the length of the mandatory prison terms and the effect on his eligibility for judicial release the defendant relied on the trial court's assurances that he would be eligible for judicial release after serving 18 years on the gun specifications and the trial court sentenced the defendant to 34 years in prison, 33 years of which was mandatory time.
- 2018 Ohio 405Stanfield v. Reading Bd. of Educ. (2018)
IMMUNITY - POLITICAL SUBDIVISION: The trial court erred in granting summary judgment to defendant board of education on the entirety of plaintiffs' complaint arising from injuries a high-school student suffered during track-and-field practice by an errantly-thrown discus: the physical-defect exception to political-subdivision immunity, R.C. 2744.02(B)(4), does not require that the political subdivision own the grounds where the injury occurs, and therefore, the physical-defect exception applied to plaintiffs' claims alleging that the discus-cage netting had holes and gaped, leading to the student's injury however, the board of education is immune under R.C. 2744.03(A)(5) with regard to plaintiffs' claims that the board failed to adequately supervise the students during track-and-field practice.
- 2018 Ohio 406Disciplinary Counsel v. Peck (2018)
On notice of violation and motion to lift stay.
- 2018 Ohio 407Cleveland Metro. Bar Assn. v. Butscher (2018)
On certification of default.
- 2018 Ohio 408Disciplinary Counsel v. Ore (2018)
On motion for immediate interim remedial suspension.
- 2018 Ohio 409In re Resignation of Brown (2018)
Attorneys at law-Resignation with disciplinary action pending-Gov.Bar R. VI(11)(C).
- 2018 Ohio 411In re Resignation of Moore (2018)
Attorneys at law-Resignation with disciplinary action pending-Gov.Bar R. VI(11)(C).
- 2018 Ohio 412Disciplinary Counsel v. McDaniel (2018)
On certified order of the Supreme Court of Arizona.
- 2018 Ohio 413In re Manore (2018)
On certified entry of felony conviction.
- 2018 Ohio 416Amesse v. Wright State Physicians, Inc. (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion when it admitted Plaintiff's Exhibits 29 and 36 into evidence during trial because the probative value of the exhibits substantially outweighed any danger of any prejudice to the appellants. The jury's verdict in favor of the plaintiff with respect to his claims for breach of contract, discrimination, and retaliation were not against the manifest weight of the evidence. The trial court did not err when it overruled the appellants' motions for directed verdicts and motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict. The trial court did not abuse its discretion when it denied the appellants' untimely motion for leave to amend their answer to include the after-acquired evidence defense. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 418State v. Carter (2018)
Defendant-Appellant's counsel filed a brief under the authority of Anders v. California, 386 U.S. 738, 87 S.Ct. 1396, 18 L.Ed.2d 493 (1967). A thorough review of the record reveals no arguably meritorious appellate issues. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 419State v. Danon (2018)
Defendant's no contest plea to aggravated robbery was knowing, intelligent, and voluntary. Trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying defendant's motion to continue the sentencing hearing. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 421State v. Florence (2018)
Since the trial court failed to properly advise Appellant regarding the imposition of post-release control for his having weapons while under disability offense, the matter is remanded for resentencing on that offense. Appellant's arguments that his aggravated murder and kidnapping offenses are allied offenses of similar import subject to merger, and that he is accordingly entitled to resentencing on those offenses, is barred by the doctrine of res judicata. The matter is remanded for resentencing on Count Five, having weapons while under disability, and the judgment of the trial court is affirmed in all other respects.
- 2018 Ohio 422State v. Hastings (2018)
Although the trial court mistakenly indicated at the plea hearing that post-release control for Appellant's attempted burglary offense in Case No. 2016-CR-910 was discretionary, the trial court nevertheless partially complied with Crim.R. 11 by informing Appellant that he could be placed on post-release control. Therefore, because Appellant failed to show that he was prejudiced by the trial court's misstatement at the plea hearing, Appellant's guilty plea is valid. Furthermore, while the sentencing entry in Case No. 2014-CR-3848 includes the incorrect terms of post-release control, the entry can be corrected via a nunc pro tunc order since the trial court imposed the correct terms of post-release control at the sentencing hearing. Affirmed and remanded for nunc pro tunc correction to the sentencing entry in Case No. 2014-CR-3848.
- 2018 Ohio 423State v. Hudson (2018)
Defendant's conviction for burglary in violation of R.C. 2911.12(A)(2), a second-degree felony, was not based on sufficient evidence and was against the manifest weight of the evidence. However, the State's evidence supported a conviction for trespass in a habitation when a person is present or likely to be present, in violation of R.C. 2911.12(B), a fourth-degree felony. Judgment vacated, and case remanded for the trial court to modify its judgment to indicate that Hudson was convicted of trespass in a habitation when a person is present or likely to be present, in violation of R.C. 2911.12(B), and for sentencing on that offense. (Hall, J., concurring in judgment only.)
- 2018 Ohio 424Stonebridge Neighborhood Assn., Inc. v. Knapinksi (2018)
Defendants-appellants own a home in a residential subdivision, and, as a result, they are subject to the "Declaration of Subdivision Establishing Covenants, Conditions and Restrictions for. [the] Subdivision." (the Declaration). The Plaintiff-appellee is the subdivision's neighborhood association (Association) with the Declaration providing that the Association's powers, rights, duties, and functions are exercised by a board of trustees. The presented issue is whether Defendants-appellants obtained approval for the construction of a pool house in conformity with the Declaration. The trial court correctly concluded that Defendants-appellants did not obtain such approval in the manner prescribed by the Declaration. However, the trial court, by ordering the removal of the completed pool house, did not give consideration to the economic waste doctrine. This matter, accordingly, must be remanded to the trial court to determine whether Defendants-appellants can cost-effectively conform the pool house to the Association's required standards. Judgment affirmed, in part, reversed, in part, and remanded to the trial court.
- 2018 Ohio 425Satya Hospitality Corp., L.L.C. v. Englewood (2018)
The trial court correctly determined that Appellant's due process rights were not violated Appellant received proper notice that conditions on its property constituted a nuisance. Appellant was afforded an opportunity to be heard before demolition of the property was ordered. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in affirming the decision of the property maintenance board that certain conditions on the property violated the Englewood Codified Ordinances. The trial court's decision is unambiguous regarding demolition of the property. Judgment affirmed. (Froelich, J., concurring).
- 2018 Ohio 426State v. Ricer (2018)
"under the influence" manifest weight
- 2018 Ohio 427State v. Mayle (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 428State v. West (2018)
Rape & kidnapping/Manifest weight of the evidence/Relevancy of evidence of intellectual impairment
- 2018 Ohio 429Zanesville v. Quinn (2018)
Appeal of restitution order
- 2018 Ohio 430State v. Evans (2018)
This is a brief submitted pursuant to Anders v. California, 386 U.S. 738, 87 S.Ct. 1396, 18 L.Ed.2d 493 (1967). After a thorough and independent examination of the record, the court is unable to find an issue of arguable merit and the judgment of the trial court is affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 431Skotynsky v. Jones (2018)
Trial court did not err in denying request for damages for client's breach of representation agreement. Assigned error not well-taken where appellant did not support contentions with citations to legal authority. Evidence was not against the manifest weight where the record supports appellant failed to fulfill contractual obligations.
- 2018 Ohio 432State v. Smith (2018)
Issues raised on appeal are barred by the doctrine of res judicata.
- 2018 Ohio 433St. James Therapy Ctr., Ltd. v. Ohio Vestibular & Balance Ctrs., Inc. (2018)
Attorney fees. Pattern of frivolous conduct.
- 2018 Ohio 434Tillimon v. Myles (2018)
Landlord made reasonable efforts to re-rent property following tenant's breach of rental agreement, thus trial court's decision denying damages was against manifest weight of evidence. Landlord entitled to damages for unpaid utilities for periods where tenant's usage could be ascertained. Tenant not liable for damage to property where landlord failed to inspect prior to tenant taking possession. Landlord entitled to lawn maintenance expenses incurred after breach.
- 2018 Ohio 435Kaufman v. Horvath (2018)
Trial court's grant of summary judgment to appellees was proper in foreclosure action in which appellant held a second mortgage on the property and appellees held a first mortgage. Appellant's claim of a charging lien was without merit given the language contained in the relevant loan documents demonstrating that he negotiated a mortgage with his client and not a charging lien.
- 2018 Ohio 436State v. Nettles (2018)
Testimony at trial was sufficient to establish that appellant constructively possessed cocaine and the jury's verdict was not against the weight of the evidence. Further, appellant's maximum sentence was not contrary to law.
- 2018 Ohio 437State v. Osley (2018)
: Following appellant's outburst in front of venire, trial court did not err in refusing to replace venire or declare mistrial because any error was invited by appellant, counsel had opportunity to question prospective jurors about bias, and trial court properly instructed venire and jurors to disregard outburst. Appellant's conviction was not against the manifest weight of the evidence where jury considered various evidence and made credibility determinations.
- 2018 Ohio 438Safran Family Trust v. Hughes Property Mgt. (2018)
Unrecorded, implied easements are enforceable against the subsequent purchaser of a servient estate where the subsequent purchaser had actual or constructive knowledge of the easements and was not a bona fide purchaser.
- 2018 Ohio 440Capital Care Network of Toledo v. Dept. of Health (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Ohio Adm.Code.3701-83-19(E)-R.C.119.12-Revocation of ambulatory-surgical-facility license for failure to have a written transfer agreement by Ohio Department of Health supported by reliable, probative, and substantial evidence and in accordance with law-Agreement with a hospital 52 miles away rather than nearby hospital does not allow for the transfer of patients "in the event of medical complications, emergency situations, and for other needs as they arise."
- 2018 Ohio 441Preterm-Cleveland, Inc. v. Kasich (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Standing-Challenge to constitutionality of certain provisions of 2013 Am.Sub.H.B. No. 59, a biennial budget bill-Party challenging multiple provisions in an enactment of the General Assembly as violating the Single Subject Clause, Article II, Section 15(D), Ohio Constitution, must prove standing as to each provision party seeks to have severed from the enactment by demonstrating it suffered or is threatened with direct and concrete injury in manner or degree different from that suffered by general public because of each provision-Party lacks standing to challenge legislative enactment as violating the Single Subject Clause, Article II, Section 15(D), Ohio Constitution, if challenged provision applies to other persons but does not cause or threaten direct and concrete injury to party asserting challenge.
- 2018 Ohio 442State v. Adames Deli & Grocery, Inc. (2018)
forfeiture, welfare fraud, electronic benefit transfer, Civ.R. 52, findings of fact and conclusions of law, R.C. 2913.46(B)
- 2018 Ohio 443House v. Iacovelli (2018)
employment at will doctrine - public policy exception - tort
- 2018 Ohio 444State v. Lawless (2018)
extent of cross-examination - pending case in another county - effective assistance of counsel - trial tactics - manifest weight of the evidence - credibility of witnesses
- 2018 Ohio 445Petroskey v. Martin (2018)
residential property disclosure form - caveat emptor - fraud - justifiable reliance - home inspection - defect
- 2018 Ohio 446State v. Cleavenger (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 447State v. Hodges (2018)
no prosecutorial misconduct conduct not performed with intent to precipitate mistrial retrial not barred by double jeopardy.
- 2018 Ohio 448In re Smith (2018)
mandamus Interstate Agreement on Detainers Act R.C. 2963.30
- 2018 Ohio 450State v. Sumner (2018)
Trial court did not err by not placing a rejected plea offer on the record as Crim.R. 11(F) only requires the terms of a plea agreement to be stated on the record when there is an actual agreement reached by the parties and the defendant accepts the plea offer and pleads guilty or no contest.
- 2018 Ohio 455Cintas Corp. v. Findlay Chrysler Dodge, Jeep, Ram, Inc. (2018)
The trial court did not err by determining that a contract existed between the Appellant and the Appellee. Further, the liquidated damages clause in the contract was not a penalty and the trial court's calculation of damages was supported by competent and credible evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 456State v. Taflinger (2018)
Subject to statutory exceptions specified in R.C. 2929.41(B)(3), a trial court may not impose a sentence for a misdemeanor consecutively to a sentence for a felony. Further, in order to impose consecutive sentences, the trial court must make findings, specified in R.C. 2929.14, at the sentencing hearing and must incorporate these findings into its judgment entry.
- 2018 Ohio 458State v. Lester (2018)
Sufficient evidence was presented to convict Lester of Speeding.
- 2018 Ohio 459State v. Soto (2018)
Charges of Aggravated Murder and Murder are barred by double jeopardy.
- 2018 Ohio 463State v. Garrison (2018)
domestic violence - admission of photos - ineffective assistance of counsel- manifest weight - maximum sentence - court costs
- 2018 Ohio 464State v. Wheatley (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 465Koprivec v. Rails-to-Trails of Wayne Cty. (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Real property-Deeds-Adverse possession-Court of appeals' determination that 1882 deed created a fee simple absolute affirmed-In re Petition of Copps Chapel Methodist Episcopal Church disapproved to extent it suggested that a deed can create a determinable fee only by including language explicitly saying that property would revert to grantor upon occurrence of stated event-A title holder's licensee may defeat exclusivity element of an adverse-possession claim if licensee performs acts on the land that would ordinarily require owner's permission-Licenses granted by railroad company that previously owned abandoned rail corridor to two telecommunications companies and associated corridor-maintenance activities failed to defeat exclusivity element of adverse-possession claims of neighboring landowners-Railroad companies' activities on corridor were insufficient to defeat exclusivity element of two adverse-possession claims but sufficient as to third-Court of appeals' determination that genuine issues of material fact exist and preclude summary judgment as to two adverse-possession claims affirmed, and cause remanded-Court of appeals' determination that genuine issues of material fact exist and preclude summary judgment as to third adverse-possession claim reversed.
- 2018 Ohio 467State v. Ciminello (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 468Smith v. Sheldon (2018)
Writ of Habeas Corpus
- 2018 Ohio 469Republic Steel v. Protrade Steel Co., Ltd. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 470Brack v. Dept. of Rehab. & Corr. (2018)
Writ of Habeas Corpus
- 2018 Ohio 476State v. Higgins (2018)
sufficiency, nunc pro tunc, clerical error, self-representation, jury instruction, plain error, sentence, other acts, ineffective assistance, speculation, subpoena witness
- 2018 Ohio 477State v. Powe (2018)
Motion to vacate the judgment/conviction, subject-matter jurisdiction, complaint, petition for post-conviction relief, untimely, successive
- 2018 Ohio 478Smith v. Golden Alliance (2018)
complaint - negligence - slip and fall - open and obvious - summary judgment - factual allegations
- 2018 Ohio 480State v. Gage (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 481Am. Express Bank, FSB v. Olsman (2018)
Civil: action to collect debt personal liability of business debts summary judgment.
- 2018 Ohio 483State v. Jenkins (2018)
Preindictment delay actual prejudice ineffective assistance of counsel motion to dismiss sufficiency of the evidence rape complicity to rape kidnaping unavailable witness unjustifiable reason for delay. Jenkins suffered actual prejudice based on the unavailability of a critical witness, and the state was unable to establish any justifiable reason for the nearly 20 year delay in prosecution. Therefore, his conviction is reversed.
- 2018 Ohio 484State v. McDonald (2018)
Drug trafficking and possession possessing criminal tools sufficiency of the evidence allied offenses of similar import anonymous tip trash pull. The state presented sufficient evidence that defendant was trafficking drugs, possessing drugs, and possessing criminal tools. The trial court erred by not merging the drug trafficking and drug possession counts.
- 2018 Ohio 485State v. Nave (2018)
Final appealable order, final judgment of conviction, nunc pro tunc, sentencing entry, blanket sentence. Consolidated cases were dismissed due to a lack of final appealable orders. In the first case the trial court imposed a blanket sentence that covered six counts and the error could not be fixed with a nunc pro tunc entry. In the second case the trial court's sentencing entry failed to conform to the requirements of State v. Lester, 130 Ohio St.3d 303, 2011-Ohio-5204, 958 N.E.2d 142 and State v. Baker, 119 Ohio St.3d 197, 2008-Ohio-3330, 893 N.E.2d 163.
- 2018 Ohio 486Alpha Plaza Invs., Ltd. v. City of Cleveland (2018)
Civ.R. 56/summary judgment R.C. 2744.02/political subdivision/immunity. The trial court did not err where it determined that appellant stated a negligent claim in its complaint appellant, as a political subdivision, acts through its employees and thus falls under the provisions of R.C. 2744.02(B) for purposes of liability the trial court's review of appellant's motion against appellee sought review of the merits of the case and was premature. The trial court's denial of appellant's motion for summary judgment was proper.
- 2018 Ohio 487State v. Perry (2018)
Sufficiency manifest weight R.C. 2925.11(A)/possession of drugs R.C. 2923.24(A)/criminal tools R.C. 2941.25/allied offenses. Based on the totality of the circumstances and the witness testimony, there was sufficient evidence to support appellant's convictions and forfeiture of appellant's property appellant's convictions are not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Appellant's counsel's decision to admit the video as trial tactic and strategy does not rise to the level of ineffective assistance of counsel. Appellant's constructive possession of two types of drugs constitutes two separate offenses and do not merge as allied offenses of similar import.
- 2018 Ohio 488State v. Young (2018)
R.C. 3772.99(E) gambling craps dice sliding unconstitutionally vague specificity in indictment differentiation other acts Evid.R. 404(B) knowledge absence of mistake identification sufficiency of the evidence manifest weight restitution R.C. 2929.18 abuse of discretion allied offenses. R.C. 3772.99(E)(5) and (7) are not unconstitutionally vague as relating to dice sliding. Although dice sliding is not specifically defined in Ohio's gambling statute, a person of average intelligence would have no difficulty understanding that the manipulation of the dice in a craps game by presetting the dice to a fixed number, throwing the dice in a way that prevents the dice from tumbling, using a third party to distract casino personnel during the throws, and placing wagers with knowledge of the attempted outcome is "acquiring knowledge that is not available to all players and concerns the outcome of the casino game" under R.C. 3772.99(E)(5) and/or "claiming, collecting, taking, or attempting to claim, collect, or take money" from a casino game with the "intent to defraud" under R.C. 3772.99(E)(7). The evidence presented at trial sufficiently differentiated the multiple, duplicative counts contained in Young's indictment such that the indictment did not lack specificity. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in permitting evidence of Young's dice sliding in another casino where the evidence was presented to show the defendant's knowledge and the absence of mistake pursuant to Evid.R. 404(B). The in-court identification was not error where it was used for proper Evid.R. 404(B) purpose and not for the purposes of identifying Young as the individual sliding dice at the Horseshoe Casino in Cleveland. The state presented sufficient evidence to support Young's conviction, and the conviction was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in ordering restitution in the amount of $39,342 as the order was supported by competent, credible evidence in the record. The trial court did not err when it did not merge Young's convictions. Every roll of the dice was a separate and distinct act with a separate animus, and each roll harmed different victims.
- 2018 Ohio 491WFG Natl. Title Ins. Co. v. Meehan (2018)
Defamation, breach of contract, breach of fiduciary duty, motion to dismiss, motion for summary judgment, admissions, motions to compel, privilege. Trial court did not err in granting a motion to dismiss portions of appellant's counterclaims against appellees stemming from communications made to the Ohio Department of Insurance and the Office of Disciplinary Counsel because the communications were privileged. Trial court did not err in denying appellant's untimely motions to compel. Trial court did not err in granting summary judgment against appellant based on facts deemed admitted due to appellant's untimely participation in discovery. Trial court did not err in failing to disqualify appellee's counsel after appellant's counterclaims added claims against said counsel.
- 2018 Ohio 492State v. Hakim (2018)
Motion to suppress search warrant probable cause scope of the search warrant Fourth Amendment particularity requirement plain view plain smell marijuana incriminating nature immediately apparent. The trial court's judgment granting defendant's motion to suppress was affirmed. The plain view doctrine did not apply to a common, orange translucent pill bottle because the incriminating nature of the contents in the pill bottle was not immediately apparent to the officer without the officer first manipulating the bottle. The plain smell doctrine did not apply to a "balled up" paper towel because the trial court implicitly found that the officer's testimony that he smelled marijuana lacked credibility the officer failed to include the fact that he smelled marijuana in his written report and did not mention it on direct examination.
- 2018 Ohio 494State v. Reyes (2018)
R.C. 2929.14(C) consecutive sentences R.C. 2953.08(G)(2) clearly and convincingly attempt aggravated arson. The trial court did not err in imposing consecutive sentences on defendant-appellant's attempted aggravated arson convictions. The trial court's finding that defendant's conduct warranted consecutive sentences was supported by the record, which reflected that the defendant poured gasoline on his girlfriend in the basement of his home during a domestic violence incident. Defendant threatened to burn down the home and his girlfriend's daughter stopped him from igniting the gasoline he had poured by knocking a lighter out of his hand.
- 2018 Ohio 498State v. Jones (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 499State v. Dotson (2018)
SEARCH AND SEIZURE - WAIVER - COUNSEL: A suspect may limit the scope of his or her consent and where defendant consented to a pat down search for weapons only and the state presented no evidence that the officer who conducted the pat down determined by "plain feel" that a thin straw found on defendant's person was most likely contraband, the seizure of the straw violated the Fourth Amendment. Where defendant affirmatively relinquished his right to challenge the search of his car, he waived review of the issue on appeal. Where the record does not show that any alleged deficiency in defense counsel's representation was outcome-determinative, defendant has failed to demonstrate ineffective assistance of counsel.
- 2018 Ohio 501State v. Fox (2018)
Appellant's felonious assault convictions were supported by sufficient evidence and were not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Additionally, the trial court did not err in not instructing the jury on the offense of negligent assault because the evidence at trial did not reasonably support both an acquittal for felonious assault and a conviction for negligent assault. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 502In re T.G. (2018)
The trial court did not err in terminating mother's parental rights because mother failed to substantially complete her case plan and it was in the best interest of the child.
- 2018 Ohio 507In re Adoption of A.L.S. (2018)
Probate court did not err in granting adoption petition without Mother's consent.
- 2018 Ohio 508Bank of New York Mellon v. Chrzan (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 509Peterson v. Marquis (2018)
Writ of Habeas Corpus
- 2018 Ohio 510In re Kraft v. Ault (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 511State v. Baker (2018)
The trial court did not err in imposing restitution, upon remand, in a written entry after a hearing, rather than in open court Baker had notice that restitution would be imposed. The trial court did not abuse it discretion in imposing restitution in the amount of $2,800.00 to the victim. Whether or not the victim abandoned his property, after Appellant destroyed it, has no relation or relevance to his right to restitution. Appellant's vandalism conviction was previously affirmed on her direct appeal, and she is barred by the doctrine of res judicata from asserting that her vandalism conviction is not supported by sufficient evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 512Geisel v. City of Dayton (2018)
Plaintiff-appellant appeals the trial court's decision upholding an order of the City of Dayton's Civil Service Board (Board) which affirmed his demotion from Firefighter Recruit to Emergency Medical Technician-Basic. The demotion occurred during Plaintiff-appellant's Firefighter Recruit probationary period with the demotion being triggered by an injury he sustained during recruit training which prevented him from completing the Firefighter Recruit training program. Plaintiff-appellant's demotion did not violate any state or federal law, and, further, it is not contrary to public policy. Plaintiff-appellant's demotion occurred in a manner consistent with Civil Service Rule 10, Section 5. The Board's reference to Rule 12, Section 3 in its order, though misplaced, does not affect the validity of the Board's determination. Plaintiff-appellant's demotion was not unreasonable. Finally, Plaintiff-appellant's appeal to the Board was not illusory. Judgment affirmed. (Froelich, J., concurring in judgment only.)
- 2018 Ohio 515Karras v. Karras (2018)
Plaintiff-Appellant's complaint, even construed liberally, does not constitute fair notice of a claim for damages other than unpaid rent. Defendant-appellee did not fail to deny the allegations against him so that they were admitted under Civ.R. 8(D). Judgment affirmed. (Froelich, J., concurring in part and dissenting in part.)
- 2018 Ohio 516State v. Mackey (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying the appellant's R.C. 2953.21 post-conviction relief petition after an evidentiary hearing on whether petitioner was unavoidably prevented from discovering the facts upon which he relied for the petition. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in declining to strike the appellee's tardy post-hearing memorandum. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 519Eubanks v. Simons (2018)
Because the appellant has not filed a transcript of the proceedings below or an acceptable substitute under App.R. 9, he cannot demonstrate that the trial court erred in finding him liable to the appellees. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 520State v. Carrisales (2018)
The trial court properly accepted appellant's guilty plea. The court was not required to elicit a factual basis for the charge to which appellant pleaded or tell appellant the elements of the offense. The totality of the circumstances shows that appellant understood the nature of the offense when he pleaded guilty. An appellate court cannot review a trial court's sentence for an abuse of discretion, and appellant's "near maximum" sentence is not contrary to law.
- 2018 Ohio 521State v. Clark (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion by failing to sanction the state for a discovery violation because the state did not violate Crim.R. 16. The state could not produce a statement that did not exist and the state did not have a duty to create a statement, even though it did so at appellant's request. Appellant's conviction of the history-of-violence element of menacing by stalking was supported by sufficient evidence and was not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 522In re D.R. (2018)
In Anders appeal, appellant's proposed assignments of error are not well-taken where (1) awarding custody to the public children services agency was in the children's best interest and (2) the trial court properly determined that the public children services agency made reasonable efforts to prevent the removal of the children from the home, return the children to the home, and finalize a permanency plan for the children.
- 2018 Ohio 523In re H.W. (2018)
Termination of parental rights. Anders brief. Consent to children services agency's motion for permanent custody. Motion for continuance properly denied. No ineffective assistance of counsel. Trial court's grant of permanent custody of child to agency not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 525State v. Powers (2018)
Imposition of consecutive sentences is contrary to law where, at the sentencing hearing, the trial court does not make the required finding that any of the factors in R.C. 2929.14(C)(4)(a), (b), or (c) apply.
- 2018 Ohio 526State v. Lyons (2018)
Appellant's conviction for failure to wear a seat belt is not against the manifest weight of the evidence where the officer testified that he observed that appellant was not wearing a seat belt. An electronic traffic ticket does not have to comply with the size and binding requirements of the "Ohio Uniform Traffic Ticket."
- 2018 Ohio 528McGarry & Sons, Inc. v. Constr. Resources One, L.L.C. (2018)
Grant of summary judgment to property owner was improper where issue of fact remained as to whether mechanic's lien was filed in good faith. Denying summary judgment was improper where the party asserting claim of fraud could not show reasonable reliance on misrepresentation and could not show, as to claim of intentional interference with business relation, that tortfeasor had knowledge of business relationship.
- 2018 Ohio 529Tillimon v. Pennington (2018)
Trial court did not abuse its discretion in dismissing a 14-year dormant case after appellant attempted to revive it based upon a claimed, non-existent judgment. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 535Rothwell v. Rothwell (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 536State v. Gavin (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 538State v. McClain (2018)
sufficiency, manifest weight, R.C. 4511.19(A)(1)(a), drug of abuse
- 2018 Ohio 539State v. McQuistan (2018)
aggravated vehicular assault - impaired driving - physiological factors - refusal - suppression - driving under the influence - new trial - recusal
- 2018 Ohio 540State v. Potts (2018)
attempted murder, felonious assault, aggravated robbery, tampering with evidence, dual representation, conflict of interest, consolidated trial, sufficiency, manifest weight
- 2018 Ohio 542Fetters v. Duff (2018)
Plaintiff-appellant had standing under R.C. 1337.36 to file a complaint requesting an accounting from a deceased principal's attorney-in-fact. Trial court did not abuse its discretion in dismissing plaintiff-appellant's complaint for an accounting.
- 2018 Ohio 543State v. McMahon (2018)
Trial court erred by failing to hold a hearing after appellant filed a petition to have his record sealed pursuant to R.C. 2953.31 and 2953.32 and the statute required that a hearing be set.
- 2018 Ohio 545Vill. of Fayetteville v. Adkins (2018)
The municipal court properly denied motorist's motion to dismiss the case against him where the mayor's court was not required to record its proceedings during motorist's speeding trial.
- 2018 Ohio 546Capella v. Historic Developers, L.L.C. (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion by granting appellant's Civ.R. 56(F) motion wherein it provided appellant with an additional 52 days to conduct discovery and respond to appellees' motions for summary judgment where appellant had over three years from the time of her fall giving rise to her claims to investigate, prepare her case, conduct discovery, and file a response by the trial court's imposed deadline. The trial court also did not err by granting appellees' motions for summary judgment on appellant's claims alleging negligence per se and common law negligence where the evidence properly before the court did not establish a genuine issue of material fact so as to support appellant's claims against appellees for the injuries she sustained after she slipped and fell on water and ice outside of her apartment building.
- 2018 Ohio 547In re B.L. (2018)
Father appeals juvenile court decisions awarding permanent custody of children to a children's services agency. Father's as-applied challenge to Ohio statute on the interstate compact on the placement of children, R.C. 5103.20, failed where he argued that the statute denied him the ability to appeal an out-of-state adverse decision on a home study concerning the suitability of placement with the children's grandmother. The court could not have granted grandmother legal custody as she did not move for legal custody herself or otherwise sign a statement of understanding as required by statute. Sufficient credible evidence supported the juvenile court's determination that a grant of permanent custody to the agency was in children's best interest.
- 2018 Ohio 548State v. Fraternal Order of Eagles, Aerie No. 1224 (2018)
The municipal court did not abuse its discretion in sentencing the Eagles without ordering forfeiture where the municipal court found no rational basis for including the forfeiture in the sentence.
- 2018 Ohio 549Cornell v. Hatfield (2018)
Trial court did not err by granting DVCPO in favor of appellant's ex-girlfriend, her fiancé, her fiancé's children, and her parents where the evidence showed that appellant threatened to harm her and her family or household members.
- 2018 Ohio 550State v. Caudill (2018)
Appellant's convictions were supported by sufficient evidence and were not against the manifest weight because his fingerprints were found on the materials used in the manufacturing process, as well as on the finished methamphetamine. However, the trial court could not sentence appellant on a second-degree felony where the jury verdict form did not state the degree designation, the jury made no finding as to what drug appellant manufactured, and where the statute provided for a third-degree felony option.
- 2018 Ohio 551Priconics, L.L.C. v. Amperor, Inc. (2018)
The trial court did not err by dismissing this action based on the jurisdictional-priority rule where the same dispute was already pending in Texas. Though dismissal of this action is appropriate, the dismissal is without prejudice.
- 2018 Ohio 552State v. Chaney (2018)
The trial court did not err by ordering appellant to pay restitution in the amount of $83,783.96 where the state provided evidence indicating that figure was the actual economic loss suffered as a result of appellant stealing and then selling items belonging to his employer.
- 2018 Ohio 560State v. El-Amin (2018)
Jail-time credit for multiple cases in which an offender was simultaneously jailed pretrial on two sentences was properly applied just once to a defendant's aggregate consecutive sentence in fulfilling constitutional requirements for equal protection under the law.
- 2018 Ohio 562State v. Jones (2018)
Inmate who has already pursued a direct appeal of his sentence cannot prevail on a petition for postconviction relief on the same issues.
- 2018 Ohio 563State v. Braden (2018)
EVIDENCE - BURGLARY - DOUBLE JEOPARDY - RECEIVING STOLEN PROPERTY: The trial court erred in convicting defendant of second-degree burglary under R.C. 2911.12(A)(2) where the state did not prove an element of the offense-that "any person other than an accomplice of the offender is present or likely to be present"-beyond a reasonable doubt and where defendant stipulated to committing third-degree burglary under R.C. 2911.12(A)(3), a conviction for third-degree burglary is not barred by double jeopardy even though defendant's previous conviction for receiving stolen property under R.C. 2913.51 involved the same property.
- 2018 Ohio 564State v. Finnell (2018)
COUNSEL - EVID.R. 606(B) - JURORS: Trial counsel was deficient in failing to notify the trial court of a stipulation of potential intimidation of the jurors by defendant and argue that the stipulation was sufficient under Evid.R. 606(B) to entitle defendant to the release of juror information under seal to secure juror testimony for a motion for a new trial where a different judge, who was unaware of the previous stipulation, presided over the hearing on the new-trial motion.
- 2018 Ohio 565State v. Jones (2018)
EVIDENCE - DANGEROUS DOG: The trial court erred in convicting defendant of failing to confine a dangerous dog under R.C. 955.22(D) where defendant's dog had not been previously designated dangerous under R.C. 955.11.
- 2018 Ohio 566Emergency Physicians Ins. Co. RRG v. Emergency Physicians Ins. Exchange (2018)
foreign judgment, full faith and credit
- 2018 Ohio 568State v. Hunter (2018)
Jury instructions, merger, manifest weight of the evidence
- 2018 Ohio 569In re D.J. (2018)
serious youthful offender, conduct, substantial risk, res judicata, R.C. 2152.14, R.C. 2152.83, R.C. 2950.01, Tier III sex offender
- 2018 Ohio 570State v. Sapper (2018)
felony sentencing factors, presentence investigation report
- 2018 Ohio 571Scott v. McCluskey (2018)
wrongful death, medical malpractice, interrogatories, proximate cause, heart attack, emergency room, JNOV, manifest weight, new trial
- 2018 Ohio 572Stowe v. Chuck's Automotive Repair, L.L.C. (2018)
magistrate's decision, independent review, Civ.R. 53(D)(4)(d)
- 2018 Ohio 573Deutsche Bank Natl. Trust Co. v. Taylor (2018)
res judicata, foreclosure, Civ.R. 60(B)
- 2018 Ohio 574State v. Yeager (2018)
appointed counsel - stand-by counsel - knowing, voluntary, and intelligent waiver - hybrid representation - costs - jail-time credit - waiver - ability to pay - restitution
- 2018 Ohio 581Booker v. Beauty Express Salons, Inc. (2018)
Jurisdiction motion to stay pending arbitration. The trial court did have jurisdiction to determine the validity and conscionability of the arbitration agreement and it was error to not do so prior to staying the proceedings.
- 2018 Ohio 582State v. M.H. (2018)
Application to seal record of conviction expungement R.C. 2953.32 R.C. 2953.31 R.C. 2953.36 rehabilitation nature of offense theft in office. The trial court's judgment denying defendant's application to seal his record of convictions was reversed because the trial court based its decision only upon the fact that the defendant was convicted of theft in office. Theft in office, however, is not exempt from being expunged under R.C. 2953.36. The trial court failed to consider the fact that the defendant established that he had been rehabilitated since he committed the acts in his criminal case, and thus, abused its discretion when it denied defendant's application.
- 2018 Ohio 583Cleveland v. Edwards (2018)
Crim.R. 11(E) no contest plea petty offense misdemeanor effect of the plea. Trial court erred in convicting defendant of petty misdemeanor where court failed to inform defendant of the effect of the plea and the defendant never entered a plea in open court and on the record.
- 2018 Ohio 584In re Estate of Abraitis (2018)
Probate court/jurisdiction R.C. 2113.18(a) and 2109.24/removal of fiduciary abuse of discretion/attorney standing. Under R.C. 2109.24 and 2113.18, the trial court had authority to pursue appellant's removal as executor of the estate. The trial court's findings, each one of them, were supported by the record and it was not an abuse of discretion where the trial court removed appellant as executor. At the hearing, the questions presented by the executor's successor were appropriate and did not have the appearance of being intimidating or harassing. The trial court committed no prejudicial error in allowing the questions.
- 2018 Ohio 585Flynn v. Cleveland Clinic Health Sys.-E. (2018)
Civ.R. 10(D)(2) affidavit of merit dismissal extension of time. Trial court did not abuse its discretion by refusing to grant a second extension of time to file an affidavit of merit in support of causes of action based on medical malpractice when motion for an extension of time claimed a need to conduct more discovery, but did not state what discovery was required and why discovery had not been completed.
- 2018 Ohio 586State v. Allen (2018)
Guilty Plea Crim.R. 11 R.C. 2905.32 Trafficking in Persons R.C. 2923.02(E) Attempt. Where defendant was charged with trafficking in persons in violation of R.C. 2905.32, and she subsequently pled to attempted trafficking in persons, trial court properly advised her, during plea colloquy that the original charge carried a mandatory prison term of 10-15 years, but amended charge was subject to sentencing within standard range for second-degree felonies.
- 2018 Ohio 587Deut Sche Bank Trust Co. of Ams. v. Jones (2018)
Foreclosure standing conditions precedent. Trial court did not err by adopting the magistrate's decision that granted judgment in favor of the bank in the foreclosure action. The bank's representative had personal knowledge of the appellants' loan showing that the appellants defaulted on the note secured by the mortgage and that the bank possessed both the note and mortgage at the time the complaint was filed.
- 2018 Ohio 591State v. Howell (2018)
AUTOS/CRIMINAL - CONSTITUTIONAL LAW/CRIMINAL - SEARCH AND SEIZURE - OVI: The trial court erred in denying defendant's motion to suppress the unlawful stop of her car and all evidence gathered as a result of the unlawful stop where the arresting state trooper had erroneously determined that defendant had committed a violation of R.C. 4513.15(A)(1): the trooper's mistake of law was not reasonable where the statute unambiguously regulated the distribution of light to be used when a driver approaches an oncoming vehicle, and the trooper had testified that defendant had failed to dim her headlights while traveling on the interstate behind and in the same direction as the trooper. The totality of the circumstances surrounding the stop of defendant's vehicle did not provide a reasonable, articulable suspicion that defendant had committed, or was engaged in committing, a crime. [But see DISSENT: At the time of the traffic stop, the trooper possessed a reasonable, articulable suspicion that defendant was driving while impaired where he had witnessed her vehicle "bouncing" within the marked lane, she had failed to dim her headlights when she approached him from behind, she had failed to pass him on the interstate when he slowed to 55 m.p.h., and he testified that he "continued to follow her just to see if there were any other signs."]
- 2018 Ohio 592State v. Kiger (2018)
Aggravated Vehicular Homicide/Motion to Suppress
- 2018 Ohio 593State v. Duncan (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 594State v. Luckie (2018)
Joinder of offenses and offenders - Bruton doctrine
- 2018 Ohio 595State v. Ramirez (2018)
Joinder of offenses and defendants - Bruton doctrine - ID evidence - suppression - warrant
- 2018 Ohio 596Canton v. Roth (2018)
Challenge to city ordinance limiting number of dogs or cats
- 2018 Ohio 598McCarthy v. Family Dollar Stores of Ohio, Inc. (2018)
Open and Obvious - Summary Judgment
- 2018 Ohio 600AM & JV, L.L.C. v. MyFlori, L.L.C. (2018)
Trial court did not err by overruling objections to magistrate's decision denying appellants' motion for a new trial, or, in the alternative, motions for additur and remittitur.
- 2018 Ohio 601State v. Fudge (2018)
Any error in excluding evidence under Evid.R. 403 was harmless in light of overwhelming evidence of appellant's guilt.
- 2018 Ohio 602State v. Oliver (2018)
Trial court did not err when it denied appellant's request for a continuance to hire private counsel.
- 2018 Ohio 603Woods v. Ohio Dep't of Rehab. & Corr. (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in adopting the magistrate's decision where Woods did not support his objections to the magistrate's decision with a transcript or a properly filed affidavit of evidence under Civ.R. 53(D)(3)(b)(iii).
- 2018 Ohio 604State v. Adams (2018)
Appellant's conviction for domestic violence is not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Contrary to Appellant's claim otherwise, the weight of the evidence establishes that Appellant was the primary aggressor during the physical altercation in question and that Appellant was not acting in self defense. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 605State v. Ball (2018)
Defendant's conviction for burglary, in violation of R.C. 2911.12(A)(3), was based on sufficient evidence and was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Defendant's sentence of three years in prison was not clearly and convincingly unsupported by the record. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 606Heard v. Dayton View Commons Homes (2018)
Trial court did not err in granting summary judgment to apartment owner on tenant's personal injury claim. Although tenant claimed that his neck pain and/or injury was caused by his fall on the threshold of his apartment because the pain started after the fall, the owner offered tenant's deposition testimony about his medical records, which acknowledged pre-existing neck problems. The tenant did not offer any expert opinion or other evidentiary materials that created a genuine issue of material fact that his neck pain and/or injury was caused by the fall. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 607State v. Haynes (2018)
The trial court did not err in overruling the appellant's motion to suppress an incriminating statement he made while being handcuffed after officers found a firearm in a car in which he had been a passenger. The appellant was lawfully detained at all times leading up to his incriminating statement because police were completing an investigation of the driver by confirming her identify and the validity of a warrant for her arrest and arresting her. In addition, a dog's free-air sniff around the driver's car, which occurred contemporaneously with her arrest, gave police probable cause to search the car. The search resulted in the discovery of the loaded handgun, which the appellant promptly admitted owning. Although the appellant had not been Mirandized when he made the admission, it was not the product of police "interrogation." Judgment affirmed. (Froelich, J., dissenting.)
- 2018 Ohio 608State v. Henderson (2018)
The doctrine of res judicata applies to the trial court's calculation of jail time credit, since Appellant did not appeal from the denial of his initial pro se motion for jail time credit, filed October 4, 2016, prior to filing his subsequent pro se motion for jail time credit on April 3, 2017, the denial of which is the subject of this appeal. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 609State v. Ivkovich (2018)
The trial court, following a no-contest plea, found Defendant-appellant guilty of aggravated vehicular homicide under R.C. 2903.06(A)(1)(a) for causing the death of another as the proximate result of the operation of a motor vehicle in violation of R.C. 4511.19(A). The trial court did not err by overruling Defendant-appellant's motion seeking to suppress the result of a blood test. The securing, testing, and retention of Defendant-appellant's blood substantially complied with the applicable Ohio Administrative Code requirements, and Defendant-appellant consented to provide samples of his blood for toxicological analysis. The trial court informed Defendant-appellant that a prison term was mandatory thus, it cannot be asserted that the plea was less than knowing and voluntary on this basis. Finally, the sentence imposed by the trial court is not contrary to law. Judgment affirmed. (Donovan, J., concurring in judgment only.)
- 2018 Ohio 610State v. Norris (2018)
Appellant's conviction for unauthorized use of a vehicle is not against the manifest weight of the evidence. The trial court did not lose its way by finding that Appellant failed to establish the affirmative defense that he reasonably believed he was allowed to use his employer's vehicle for personal matters. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 613State v. Howland (2018)
guilty plea knowing, intelligently and voluntarily impaired judgment sleep deprived Fifth Amendment Fourteenth Amendment de novo review Crim.R. 11(C) substantial compliance strict compliance
- 2018 Ohio 614In re B.S. (2018)
Permanent Custody Best Interest
- 2018 Ohio 618State v. Bracey (2018)
Anders brief. Guilty plea was entered into knowingly, voluntarily and intelligently. Sentence imposed was within confines of law and amply supported by the record, and the trial court considered the relevant sentencing criteria.
- 2018 Ohio 620State v. Highsmith (2018)
The trial court complied with all applicable sentencing statutes and appellant's sentence is not contrary to law.
- 2018 Ohio 621State v. Martin (2018)
This is a brief submitted pursuant to Anders v. California, 386 U.S. 738, 87 S.Ct. 1396, 18 L.Ed.2d 493 (1967). After a thorough and independent examination of the record, the court is unable to find an issue of arguable merit and the judgment of the trial court is affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 622State v. Williams (2018)
Manifest weight, sufficiency of the evidence, trespass into a habitation, clothing, one-on-one identification, tools.
- 2018 Ohio 623State v. Satchel (2018)
The trial court did not impose a "trial tax" on appellant when it sentenced him. The court's single statement does not demonstrate that it acted based on actual vindictiveness, and, therefore, appellant's sentence is not contrary to law.
- 2018 Ohio 624State v. $5,839 in U.S. Currency (2018)
Civil forfeiture of seized currency under R.C. 2981.05 was not in error where it was supported by facts alleged in the complaint and a trial to the court was held but no transcript on appeal was filed. Motion to intervene continuance regularity of proceedings.
- 2018 Ohio 625State v. Upham (2018)
Appellant's motion for postconviction relief filed four years after R.C. 2153.21 filing deadline without facts warranting an untimely filing properly denied. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 626State ex rel. Washington v. Krichbaum (2018)
mandamus foreclosure adequate remedy at law by way of direct appeal
- 2018 Ohio 627State v. Emich (2018)
double jeopardy, motion to dismiss, Blockburger, guilty plea, waiver, ineffective assistance of counsel, outside the record, speculation
- 2018 Ohio 628State v. Senz (2018)
petty theft, owner, sufficiency, Crim.R. 29, manifest weight, ineffective assistance, costs, fine, misdemeanor sentencing
- 2018 Ohio 629CitiMortgage, Inc. v. Tillman (2018)
summary judgment, foreclosure, forbearance agreement, default
- 2018 Ohio 631State v. Bradley (2018)
CRIMINAL - death of appellant during direct appeal State v. McGettrick, 31 Ohio St.3d 138 neither party moved to substitute a representative appeal is dismissed as moot and original judgment of conviction, original indictment, and related proceedings are vacated.
- 2018 Ohio 632State v. Wrona (2018)
The jury waiver of the Defendant-Appellant was made knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily and obviated the need for a jury instruction on self defense. Further, because competent and credible evidence exists in the record on the essential elements of assualt, the convictions of the Defendant-Appellant are not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 633Goerlitz v. SCCI Hosps. of Am., Inc. (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying Appellants' motion to stay the proceedings and compel arbitration.
- 2018 Ohio 634United Bank v. Lemon (2018)
The trial court has the authority to construe certain post-judgment motions for relief as Civ.R. 60(B) motions. When the Civ.R. 60(B) motion purports to disclose new evidence, the motion must be filed within one year of the final judgment and must have a meritorious claim or defense to present.
- 2018 Ohio 635State v. Perez (2018)
The trial court did not err in imposing consecutive sentences.
- 2018 Ohio 636Fostoria v. Heimberger (2018)
Sufficient evidence was presented to support conviction for red light violation and conviction was not against the weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 639McCoppin v. Camargo Sports & Apparel (2018)
Trial court did not err by granting a motion for relief from judgment pursuant to Civ.R. 60(B) where the motion was uncontested below and appellants, in fact, requested that the trial court grant the Civ.R. 60(B) motion.
- 2018 Ohio 640State v. West (2018)
Trial court did not violate a defendant's due process and equal protection rights in imposing a six-year prison term on the defendant where the record reflects that the defendant's inability to repay $2.2 million to victims in the two-year time period between the guilty plea being entered and sentence being imposed was not a sentencing consideration by the trial court. Further, the defendant failed to establish that an actual conflict of interest existed by defense counsel's joint representation of the defendant and another co-defendant who were both involved in the sale of an unregistered security and the fraudulent act or practice in the sale of securities.
- 2018 Ohio 641State v. Spencer (2018)
Trial court did not err in not providing jury instruction on inferior degree offense of aggravated assault.
- 2018 Ohio 642In re S.E. (2018)
Appellant could not challenge the juvenile court's decision adjudicating her three children neglected and granting temporary custody of the children to a children services agency since the determination that a child is abused, neglected or dependent that is followed by an award of temporary custody to a children services agency cannot be raised on appeal from a juvenile court's decision to grant permanent custody. In addition, the juvenile court's decision to grant permanent custody of appellant's children to a children services agency was supported by sufficient evidence and otherwise not against the manifest weight of the evidence where appellant was homeless and admitted to taking drugs during the pregnancy of her most recent child, had unresolved issues regarding her mental health, housing, and employment, and exhibited limited cognitive ability, whereas the children had since bonded with their respective foster parents and referred to their foster parents as their mothers and fathers.
- 2018 Ohio 644State v. Thyot (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW/CRIMINAL - CRIM.R. 12 (K) - MOTION IN LIMINE - AUTHENTICATION: The state may appeal from the granting of a motion in limine that is, in effect, a motion to suppress evidence, which renders the state's proof with respect to the pending charge so weak in its entirety that any reasonable probability of effective prosecution has been destroyed. The appellate court is without authority to review the prosecutor's Crim.R. 12(K) certification and may not dismiss the prosecutor's appeal for want of a final, appealable order based on the merits of the prosecutor's certification. When a motion in limine is the functional equivalent of a motion to suppress, the appellate court should use the standard of review applicable to a motion to suppress. The state adequately authenticated a video taken in the ordinary course of business outside of a gas station where the regional manager for the company that operated the gas station testified that the video was a recording of the area outside of a store with which he was familiar, he knew how the video security system recorded and stored videos in the ordinary course of business, he knew the system to be accurate, and he had used the system in previous investigations, even though he had no personal knowledge of the contents of the video and he was not present when it was burned onto a DVD.
- 2018 Ohio 645State v. Carter (2018)
DEATH PENALTY - SENTENCING - CONSTITUTIONAL LAW/CRIMINAL - SIXTH AMENDMENT: Ohio's death-penalty statute does not require judicial fact finding before the defendant can be sentenced to death, because the jury must find the defendant guilty beyond a reasonable doubt of an aggravating factor for the death penalty to be a sentencing option and therefore, Ohio's death-penalty statute does not violate the Sixth Amendment right to a jury trial. (Hurst v. Florida, ___ U.S. ___, 136 S.Ct. 616, 193 L.Ed.2d 504 (2016), distinguished.)
- 2018 Ohio 646In re A.M. (2018)
Permanent custody: manifest weight of the evidence best interests of the child reasonable efforts to reunify the family.
- 2018 Ohio 648State v. Howard (2018)
Trafficking in heroin
- 2018 Ohio 649Disciplinary Counsel v. Noel (2018)
On application for reinstatement.
- 2018 Ohio 650Disciplinary Counsel v. Cohen (2018)
On petition for reinstatement.
- 2018 Ohio 651Disciplinary Counsel v. Noel (2018)
On petition for reinstatement.
- 2018 Ohio 653Mahoning Cty. Bar Assn. v. DiMartino (2018)
On certification of default.
- 2018 Ohio 654In re Resignation of Green (2018)
Attorneys at law-Resignation with disciplinary action pending-Gov.Bar R. VI(11)(C).
- 2018 Ohio 656Cleveland Metro. Bar Assn. v. Austin (2018)
On certification of default.
- 2018 Ohio 657Disciplinary Counsel v. Hull (2018)
On certification of default.
- 2018 Ohio 659State ex rel. Smith v. Krueger (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 660Vill. of Albany v. Butler (2018)
Environmental Review Appeals Commission did not err by granting motion to dismiss appeal for lack of standing where appellant failed to establish that it would suffer injury in fact from issuance of permit-to-install on-site sewage treatment system.
- 2018 Ohio 661Ross Sinclaire & Assoc., L.L.C. v. Huntington Natl. Bank (2018)
In a case involving municipal revenue bonds for low income housing, the trial court did not err when it granted summary judgment in favor of the trustee bank as to bondholders' claims for breach of fiduciary duty and breach of trust. Bondholders' claims accrued when, from all the facts and circumstances known to the bondholders, the bondholders either knew or should have known of the breach of trust, not when the trust terminated. The statute of limitations barred the bondholders' claims against the trustee for breach of fiduciary duty and breach of trust because the bondholders did not file the complaint within four years of the date when the bondholders knew or should have known of the breach of trust. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 662State v. Mincey (2018)
COMPLICITY - EVIDENCE - EXPERT WITNESS - PROSECUTOR - JURY INSTRUCTIONS - MENS REA -COUNSEL - NEW TRIAL - SENTENCING: The trial court did not abuse its discretion in admitting cell phone video footage into evidence where the footage was properly authenticated and relevant, and its probative value was not outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice. [But see CONCURRENCE: The trial court abused its discretion in admitting the video footage because it was irrelevant however, the error was harmless.] The trial court did not abuse its discretion or violate defendant's right to due process in failing to appoint a second expert witness for defendant where defendant did not show how a second expert, who would have performed testing similar to that performed by defendant's first expert, would have aided in the defense, and the state's case was largely based on evidence other than that about which the expert would have testified. General claims of prosecutorial misconduct without a showing as to how the alleged misconduct deprived defendant of a fair trial will not serve as the basis for reversal on appeal. The trial court did not err in charging the jury on complicity where the court included all elements of the offense in the charge and the charge was not ambiguous. [But see DISSENT: The court's failure to follow the Ohio Jury Instructions and include the mens rea for complicity within the complicity instruction itself constituted reversible error.] Defendant's claim of ineffective assistance of counsel fails where she has not demonstrated how counsel's failure to object to allegedly improper statements by the prosecutor during closing argument deprived her of a fair trial. Viewing the evidence presented in a light most favorable to the prosecution, the jury's verdict was supported by sufficient evidence, and while the defendant presented a version of events that, if believed, would have exonerated her, there is no indication that, in weighing the evidence presented, the jury so lost its way as to create a manifest miscarriage of justice warranting a new trial. Where none of the grounds alleged in support of defendant's motion for a new trial constituted prejudicial error, the trial court properly denied the motion. [But see DISSENT: In light of the erroneous jury instruction, the trial court should have granted defendant a new trial.] The trial court did not err in sentencing defendant: while the court specifically referenced some of the R.C. 2929.11 and 2929.12 factors, in the absence of evidence to the contrary, it can be presumed that the court considered all the statutory factors and the trial court's failure to notify defendant that she would be required to submit to DNA testing and that she could not ingest or be injected with a drug of abuse while in prison was harmless error.
- 2018 Ohio 663State v. Cunningham (2018)
Appellant's motion to withdraw his Alford plea was properly denied where appellant was informed of the potential prison sentence he was facing as a consequence of the plea and affirmed that he had not been promised anything other than what was contained in the plea agreement. Appellant's conviction for complicity to commit felonious assault was supported by sufficient evidence and was not against the manifest weight of the evidence where he unlocked an entrance door at a bar, thereby granting entry to his friend who had been removed, resulting in a shooting that injured two individuals.
- 2018 Ohio 664Harris-Miles v. Lakewood Hosp. (2018)
In medical malpractice case, summary judgment in favor of surgeon and hospital was appropriate where patient's only expert failed to testify that the alleged negligence proximately caused her injuries.
- 2018 Ohio 665State v. Jeko (2018)
Trial court abused its discretion in granting a motion for new trial based on newly-discovered evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 666Lublinsussman Grp. LLP v. Lee (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 666LublinSussman Group, L.L.P. v. Lee (2018)
Cross-motions for summary judgment. Breach of contract claims. Wrongful termination claim. Ambiguous contract language.
- 2018 Ohio 667Toledo v. Whitfield (2018)
Municipal court's complete failure to comply with Crim.R. 11(E) requires that appellee's plea of no contest be vacated.
- 2018 Ohio 668State v. Wright (2018)
Trial court did not err in imposing sentences for discharge of a firearm upon or over a public road or highway and an attendant firearm specification because the specification does not merge with the principal offense as it is a penalty enhancement and not a separate offense. Trial court did not err in denying appellant's motion to dismiss on speedy trial grounds, where appellant was brought to trial within 90 days of his arrest, after taking into account time periods that were tolled under R.C. 2945.72.
- 2018 Ohio 669State v. Baker (2018)
After Baker entered pleas of no contest, the trial court did not abuse its discretion in overruling his oral motion to withdraw his pleas at sentencing without a hearing. Baker's motion falls under a post-sentence standard since Baker moved to withdraw his pleas upon discovering that the trial court fully intended to impose a prison term and not community control sanctions. A manifest injustice is not demonstrated. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 669State v. Dennis (2018)
After Baker entered pleas of no contest, the trial court did not abuse its discretion in overruling his oral motion to withdraw his pleas at sentencing without a hearing. Baker's motion falls under a post-sentence standard since Baker moved to withdraw his pleas upon discovering that the trial court fully intended to impose a prison term and not community control sanctions. A manifest injustice is not demonstrated. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 671State v. Jacobs (2018)
Trial court erred in ordering the payment of restitution in the full amount of the victim's medical expenses. Based on the testimony at the restitution hearing, it was clear that the victim had health insurance, and it was likely that some or all of the medical expenses would be covered by insurance. Double recovery is not permitted, and the court's failure to determine the amount of restitution to a reasonable degree of certainty was error. Judgment affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded for further consideration of restitution order.
- 2018 Ohio 672In re G.Y. (2018)
The trial court's determination that permanent custody to the county children services agency was in the best interest of the child was supported by clear and convincing evidence and was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Trial court did not err in granting permanent custody of the child to the agency. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 674State v. McComb (2018)
Defendant was granted a delayed appeal from his October 2015 conviction for aggravated robbery and felonious assault, for which he received a mandatory three-year sentence and a two-year sentence, respectively. Defendant challenges his sentence under State v. Hand, 149 Ohio St.3d 94, 2016-Ohio-5504, 73 N.E.3d 448. Hand applies to defendant's three-year sentence for aggravated robbery, which was made mandatory due to a prior juvenile adjudication. Having granted defendant's motion for a delayed appeal, pursuant to App.R. 5, defendant's conviction is pending on direct appeal, and his conviction was not final for purposes of applying Hand. Defendant has completely served his two-year sentence for felonious assault, and thus his appeal of that sentence is moot. Regardless, the trial court did not impose a mandatory sentence for the felonious assault. Judgment affirmed in part, modified in part, and remanded for the court to issue a revised judgment entry that eliminates the mandatory nature of defendant's sentence for aggravated robbery.
- 2018 Ohio 675City of Dayton v. Smith (2018)
Appellant's conviction for failing to control her dogs in violation of R.C.G.O. 91.50(A)(5) is not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Contrary to Appellant's claim otherwise, the weight of the evidence does not establish that Appellant proved the affirmative defense codified in R.C.G.O. 91.50(D)(2). Appellant's claim that the language in R.C.G.O. 91.50(D)(2) is void for vagueness also lacks merit, as the language in the ordinance sufficiently indicates what Appellant must prove to establish the affirmative defense described therein. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 676State ex rel. Jones v. Dayton Pub. Schools Bd. of Edn. (2018)
A school board's special meeting notice failed to comply with R.C. 121.22(F), because the board failed to properly state the purpose of the open session of the meeting. The board's resolution not to renew an employee's contract, therefore, was invalid, and the trial court erred in rendering summary judgment in the board's favor. Although the school board also failed to comply with certain requirements of R.C. 3313.16 when it sent out the notice for the special meeting, the trial court did not err in finding a lack of prejudice because the employee had actual notice of the meeting. In addition, the board's motion to go into executive session facially complied with R.C. 121.22(G)(1). Whether the Board improperly disguised its intentions in calling the meeting and in moving into executive session do not need to be considered, due to the invalidity of the resolution adopted at the special meeting. Reversed and remanded for further proceedings.
- 2018 Ohio 678State v. Labiaux (2018)
Application for reconsideration untimely App.R. 26.
- 2018 Ohio 679State v. Larkins (2018)
Application for reconsideration untimely App.R. 26.
- 2018 Ohio 680Black v. Hicks (2018)
Jurisdiction jury trial final appealable order notice of appeal. The trial court entered the May 9, 2016, June 3, 2016, and July 7, 2016 orders, commenced a jury trial on May 25, 2016, and accepted the jury's verdict on May 31, 2016, while it was divested of jurisdiction because of pending appeals. These orders and the jury's verdict are null and void, and therefore, must be vacated.
- 2018 Ohio 681State v. Campbell (2018)
Abuse of discretion, presentence motion to withdraw guilty plea. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying the appellant's presentence motion to withdraw his guilty plea because the appellant continued with pleading guilty after being allowed to recite his version of the facts.
- 2018 Ohio 682City of Cleveland v. Kalish (2018)
Motion to suppress reasonable suspicion traffic stop field sobriety tests. Trial court erred in granting defendant's motion to suppress results of field sobriety tests where, under the totality of the circumstances, the officer had a reasonable suspicion after a valid traffic stop that the defendant was driving while intoxicated, sufficient to extend the initial stop and administer field sobriety tests.
- 2018 Ohio 683State v. Curry (2018)
Preindictment delay commencement of prosecution summons Crim.R. 6(F) R.C. 2901.13(F) manifest weight sufficiency of the evidence rape aggravated robbery kidnapping allied offenses. A summons was issued on the final day of the statute of limitations, commencing the action for the purposes of R.C. 2901.13(F). The defendant did not demonstrate that he was prejudiced by the preindictment delay because the lost or missing DNA evidence did not pertain to his guilt or innocence, only that of the unknown accomplice. There was sufficient evidence in support of the convictions, and the trier of fact did not lose its way so as to create a manifest injustice.
- 2018 Ohio 684State v. Stewart (2018)
Guilty plea right to counsel motion to withdraw as counsel motion to withdraw guilty plea Crim.R. 32.1 competency evaluation R.C. 2945.37 due process abuse of discretion Crim.R. 11. Appellant was not denied his constitutional right to counsel. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying appellant's counsel's motions to withdraw as counsel or appellant's requests for new counsel. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying appellant's motion and requests to withdraw his guilty plea. Appellant stipulated to the court psychiatric clinic's report, and thus, his due process rights were not violated with respect to the results of the report.
- 2018 Ohio 685Vuyancih v. Jones & Assocs. Law Group, L.L.C. (2018)
Ohio Consumer Sales Practices (CSPA) R.C. 1345.09(B)/class actions R.C. 1345.05(B)(2)/prior notice. Appellants failed to establish that, either by legislation or a publicly available court decision, appellees had prior notice that appellees' actions were in violation of the Ohio Consumer Sales Practices Act.
- 2018 Ohio 686State v. Taylor (2018)
Sentence contrary to law. The trial court did not err in sentencing the appellant to 24 months incarceration because the sentence was not contrary to law.
- 2018 Ohio 687U.S. Bank Natl. Assn. v. Franko (2018)
Foreclosure decree standing assignment R.C. 1303.38 Civ.R. 56 material alteration personal knowledge affidavit. Summary judgment in favor of financial institution is affirmed because a mortgagor lacks standing to challenge the assignment of a mortgage, a missing allonge does not constitute a material alteration of the instrument, and the opposing party failed to demonstrate that an affiant lacked personal knowledge for the purposes of demonstrating genuine issues of material fact.
- 2018 Ohio 688State v. Williams (2018)
Vacate void judgment firearm specifications Crim.R. 32(B) former R.C. 2929.71(B) R.C. 2941.25 allied offenses direct appeal postconviction untimely res judicata. Affirmed trial court's decision that denied appellant's motion to vacate void judgment, which made a blanket assertion that the judgment of conviction did not conform with Crim.R. 32(B), and which claimed that the trial court violated R.C. 2929.71(B) when it imposed consecutive sentences for firearm specifications and that the offenses constituted allied offenses of similar import pursuant to R.C. 2941.25. The trial court correctly construed appellant's motion as a petition for postconviction relief under R.C. 2953.21 and found it was untimely and otherwise barred by res judicata.
- 2018 Ohio 690State v. Harper (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 691Bradshaw v. New Vill. Corp. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 694State v. Lawson (2018)
double jeopardy - magistrate's decision - Traf.R. 14 - Crim.R. 19 - court action on objections
- 2018 Ohio 695State v. Barnard (2018)
CRIMINAL - Anders frivolous appeal guilty plea suppresion of evidence sentencing ineffective assistance of counsel jail time credit speedy trial
- 2018 Ohio 696State v. Laudato (2018)
CRIMINAL - Engaging in a Pattern of Corrupt Acitivity R.C. 2923.32(A)(1) pedicate acts corrupt activity R.C. 2923.31(I)(2)
- 2018 Ohio 697State v. Taylor (2018)
CRIMINAL - Cruelty to Companion Animals R.C. 959.131 expert testimony Evid.R.702 speculative reliable abuse of discretion manifest weight of the evidence
- 2018 Ohio 698Centric v. Buehrer (2018)
CIVIL - workers' compensation R.C. 4123.512 administrative appeal limited right to appeal claimant's right to participate in workers' compensation fund causal connection between death and employment dependency claim subject matter jurisdiction
- 2018 Ohio 700State v. Ross (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - App.R. 4(A) thirty-day rule untimely appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 702State v. Wilson (2018)
Appellant's conviction for speeding was supported by sufficient evidence and the trial court did not err in finding the laser speed-measuring device scientifically reliable after taking judicial notice of previously heard expert testimony. Further, appellant's statutory speedy-trial rights were not violated as the time to bring appellant to trial was extended by appellant's request for discovery.
- 2018 Ohio 703State v. Sekse (2018)
The trial court did not err by ordering the forfeiture of three of appellant's vehicles where the state provided overwhelming evidence, albeit circumstantial, that the vehicles were purchased by using funds derived from appellant's extensive, long-lasting marijuana operation.
- 2018 Ohio 704State ex rel. Cincinnati Enquirer v. Oda (2018)
A writ of prohibition was proper to stop a judge from enforcing a gag order restricting the parties from speaking to any news outlets where the record did not contain evidence indicating such an order was necessary, nor any evidence indicating the judge fully considered any less restrictive alternatives before issuing the gag order at issue.
- 2018 Ohio 705State v. Vineyard (2018)
The trial court correctly dismissed the charges against appellee and determined that Ohio's Good Samaritan Statute applied to appellee where he had not been convicted or punished for his drug crimes and otherwise met the qualifications of the statute, even though appellee's drug overdose occurred before the Good Samaritan Statute became effective.
- 2018 Ohio 706JDH Mgt. Group, L.L.C. v. Pierce (2018)
The trial court properly denied a home builder's motion for judgment on the pleadings because the parties' repayment agreement was not a novation of the construction contract. The trial court abused its discretion in denying the builder's motion to stay the homeowners' counterclaims pending arbitration.
- 2018 Ohio 707Parmelee v. Schnader (2018)
summary judgment plaintiffs locked out of defendant's house 42 U.S.C. 1983 police officer and township entitled to qualified immunity police department could not be sued
- 2018 Ohio 709In re V.G. (2018)
Juvenile court's decision granting permanent custody was supported by clear and convincing evidence and not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 712Colfor Mfg., Inc. v. Ohio Civ. Rights Comm. (2018)
disability discrimination claim Ohio's Civil Rights Act trial court affirmed decision of the Ohio Civil Rights Commission finding discrimination Ohio Adm.Code 4112-5-08(E)(1) employee was otherwise qualified person capable of safely and substantially performing the essential functions employer failed to grant employee a reasonable accommodation employee adequately mitigated his damages
- 2018 Ohio 713State ex rel. Pruce v. Ohio Pub. Emp. Retirement Sys. Bd. (2018)
Relator did not establish that she was a public employee as opposed to an independent contractor.
- 2018 Ohio 714State ex rel. Demellweek v. Indus. Comm. (2018)
Evidence before the Industrial Commission did not support the finding that claimant voluntarily abandoned his employment. Writ granted to return the issue of entitlement to temporary total disability compensation to the commission for further review.
- 2018 Ohio 715Jackson v. Charter Properties (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying Jackson's motion for relief from judgment.
- 2018 Ohio 716Electronic Classroom of Tomorrow v. Ohio State Bd. of Edn. (2018)
Judgment on the pleadings for Ohio State Board of Education affirmed when Electronic Classroom of Tomorrow was unable to establish violation of Ohio's Open Meeting Act. Board of Education proceedings was quasi-judicial and therefore outside the purview of the Open Meetings Act.
- 2018 Ohio 717Gallick v. Franklin Cty. Bd. of Revision (2018)
Party appealing from decision of Board of Tax Appeals did not fufill statutory requirements to perfect appeal to court of appeals, and appeal was dismissed for lack of jurisdiction.
- 2018 Ohio 718Swift Transp. Co., Inc. v. Williams (2018)
Failure to establish performance by the plaintiff and breach by the defendant precludes summary judgment for the plaintiff in a breach of contract action.
- 2018 Ohio 719George v. Univ. of Toledo Med. Ctr. (2018)
Because appellant filed his medical negligence claim more than a year after there was a cognizable event that triggered the commencement of the one-year statute of limitations period, the action is time-barred.
- 2018 Ohio 720Phipps v. State (2018)
SEX OFFENSES - OUT-OF-STATE OFFENDER - PROOF OF CONVICTION - SUBSTANTIALLY EQUIVALENT - DUTY TO REGISTER: The trial court did not err in finding that the state was not required to prove defendant's New York conviction for a sexually-oriented offense with a document that complied with R.C. 2945.75(B) and Crim.R. 32(C): the procedures under former R.C. Chapter 2950 were civil in nature, and former R.C. 2950.07(F) did not require the state to prove the out-of-state sex offense in the same way it would have had to prove a prior conviction beyond a reasonable doubt in a criminal case where the prior conviction was an element of a new criminal offense or was required to elevate the level of a crime or enhance a sentence. The trial court erred in holding that defendant's New York conviction for sexual misconduct required him to register as a sex offender in Ohio, because the New York sexual-misconduct statute is not substantially equivalent to Ohio's unlawful-sexual-conduct-with-a-minor statute, R.C. 2907.04(A): the Ohio statute applies to persons over 18, while the New York statute does not set an age limit for the perpetrator Ohio's law prohibits sexual conduct with a victim between the ages of 13 and 15, while the New York prohibition extends to a victim under the age of 17 Ohio requires that the perpetrator knew the age of the victim or was reckless in that regard, while New York does not require a mens rea and the Ohio offense is a felony, while the New York offense is a misdemeanor. [But see DISSENT: The two statutes are substantially equivalent because they both criminalize sex with a teenager regardless of consent. Further, the New York statute is substantially equivalent to Ohio's sexual-imposition offense, R.C. 2907.06(A)(4).]
- 2018 Ohio 721State v. Bedell (2018)
SEX OFFENSES - GROSS SEXUAL IMPOSITION - EVIDENCE - COUNSEL - PROSECUTOR - PLAIN ERROR - SENTENCING: The defendant's convictions on two counts of gross sexual imposition involving a victim under the age of 13 were supported by sufficient evidence and were not against the manifest weight of the evidence where the victim unequivocally testified at a bench trial that the defendant had rubbed her vagina on more than one occasion when she was under the age of 13. The defendant failed to demonstrate that the prosecutor's asking of leading questions was prosecutorial misconduct that rose to the level of plain error where he failed to identify specific questions he contended were improperly leading or explain how they prejudiced him. The defendant could not establish an ineffective-assistance- of-trial-counsel claim where he failed to show any prejudice resulting from trial counsel's allegedly deficient performance. Where the record clearly demonstrates that the trial court used an incorrect and higher sentencing range when determining the defendant's sentences, and then sentenced the defendant to the minimum term within that higher range, the error rose to the level of plain error that should be corrected, even though the defendant failed to object below. [But see DISSENT: The defendant failed to demonstrate clear error because the judge's comments at the sentencing hearing could reasonably be interpreted to refer to something other than a misunderstanding of the applicable sentencing range.]
- 2018 Ohio 722State v. Brogden (2018)
THEFT - EVIDENCE - SENTENCING - ALLOCUTION: Defendant's conviction for theft was supported by sufficient evidence where the victim testified that the car belonged to her and the defendant refused to return the keys. Defendant's sentence must be reversed and the cause remanded for resentencing where the trial court denied defendant her right of allocution and the error was not invited or harmless.
- 2018 Ohio 723State ex rel. Clay v. Cuyahoga Cty. Med. Examiner's Office (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 724State v. Ingels (2018)
SENTENCING - JURISDICTION - APPELLATE REVIEW/CRIMINAL : Defendant's kidnapping sentences were void and thus subject to correction, because the trial court had no statutory authority to enhance those sentences pursuant to sexually-violent-predator specifications charged under former R.C. Chapter 2971, when the specifications were not, as former R.C. 2971.01(H)(1) had required, based on a sexually-violent-offense conviction that had existed prior to the indictment charging the specifications: the common pleas court did not err in overruling, because the doctrine of the law of the case precluded the court from granting, defendant's postconviction motion for resentencing on that ground but following the appeals court's decision overruling its prior decisions holding that the sentences were not void, the sentences are properly remanded to the common pleas court for resentencing under the jurisdiction to correct a void judgment. [But see DISSENT: Defendant's kidnapping sentences were not subject to correction, because the claimed error did not render those sentences void.]
- 2018 Ohio 726State v. Cutlip (2018)
motion to suppress, probable cause, failure to stop after accident, sufficient evidence, accident, collision, public roadway
- 2018 Ohio 727State v. Delaney (2018)
possession, trafficking, sufficiency, manifest weight, cross-examination, proffer
- 2018 Ohio 728Kuczirka v. Ellis (2018)
Civ.R. 3(A), refiled complaint, statute of limitations, R.C. 2305.19, savings statute, motion to dismiss, Civ.R. 12(B), motion for judgment on the pleadings, Civ.R. 12(C), matters outside of the pleadings
- 2018 Ohio 729State ex rel. Rossiter v. Batchelor (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 730State v. Underwood (2018)
Joint sentencing recommendation
- 2018 Ohio 733State v. Billiter (2018)
Criminal: validity of guilty plea knowing, intelligent, and voluntary plea Crim.R. 11 appealability of agreed upon sentence R.C. 2953.08(D)(1).
- 2018 Ohio 734Pflanz v. Sinclair (2018)
COLLATERAL ESTOPPEL - FORECLOSURE - CIV.R. 60(A): Plaintiff's cause of action against a neighboring property owner based on a claimed easement was barred under the doctrine of collateral estoppel, because the same issue was actually and finally litigated against plaintiff in a foreclosure action involving the neighbor's property and the resolution of the issue was essential to the judgment that set forth the property interests that would survive the foreclosure and sale of the property. A foreclosure order, which determines the property interests of the parties before the foreclosure sale, cannot be indirectly attacked in the ancillary proceedings confirming the sale. Civ.R. 60(A) provides the trial court with authority to correct clerical mistakes in its judgment at any time, but it could not authorize the foreclosure court to substantively modify a previously issued final judgment setting forth the property interests of the parties surviving the foreclosure and sale of the property.
- 2018 Ohio 735State v. Brogden (2018)
EVIDENCE - SUFFICIENCY - CIVIL PROTECTION ORDER: Defendant's conviction for violating a temporary civil protection order was not supported by sufficient evidence where the state failed to prove that the temporary protection order was in effect on the date of the alleged violation.
- 2018 Ohio 736State v. Harris (2018)
Reopening App.R. 26(B) Murnahan untimely application good cause delayed notice of appellate decision. Applicant's almost four-year delay in filing to reopen his appeal meant it was untimely. Applicant failed to show good cause when he argued he was not timely notified of the appellate decision.
- 2018 Ohio 737State v. Moton (2018)
Public trial spectators aggravated murder evidence hearsay. Court did not violate defendant's right to a public trial and instead exercised control over the proceedings by ordering three spectators to leave the courtroom. Sufficient evidence to support a finding of prior calculation and design to commit aggravated murder when defendant and victim knew each other, there were records of phone calls the defendant made to the victim just prior to the murder the defendant drove around the area where the murder occurred as though waiting for the victim to arrive fingerprints on victim's car doorhandle matched the defendant and the victim was shot execution-style from inches away.
- 2018 Ohio 738State v. Hernandez (2018)
Manifest weight of the evidence Crim.R. 8 Crim.R. 14 joinder Evid.R. 404(B) other acts evidence immigration status cross-examination credibility. Defendant-appellant's argument that his convictions were against the manifest weight of the evidence because the testimony of his minor victims lacked credibility was unpersuasive. The jury was in the best position to determine the credibility of each witness in light of inconsistent and contradictory testimony. It is well established that inconsistent or contradictory testimony alone does not render a conviction against the manifest weight of the evidence. Defendant-appellant was not denied a fair trial by the trial court's denial of his motion to sever the allegations of the two minor victims, the admittance of unindicted "other acts" evidence of sexual assault allegations made by the first victim, the investigating detective's passing reference to his immigration status, nor the trial court's refusal to allow defendant-appellant to attack the statements of his minor victims through the testimony of the investigating detective.
- 2018 Ohio 739State v. Brownlee (2018)
Aggravated murder informant mistrial continuance plea bargain ineffective assistance of counsel accomplice presumption of guilt allied offenses vindictive sentence. No plain error in failure to give jury instruction on accomplice testimony because the terms of the accomplice's plea deal were made known to the jury and the court otherwise instructed jury that it could weigh each witness's testimony based in part on witness's self-interest. Counsel may have employed trial strategy and not sought jury instruction on accomplice testimony because parts of the accomplice's testimony were highly favorable to the defense, so the instruction might have undermined defense argument that accomplice was credible. Court did not err by denying motion for mistrial based on failure to submit admitted exhibit to the jury for deliberations because defense counsel failed to ensure that the exhibit, a digital video file, had been put on disk and timely given to the jury before it began its deliberations.
- 2018 Ohio 740City of Cleveland v. Martin (2018)
Motion to suppress OVI marked lanes violation di minimis infraction reasonable suspicion intensity of alcoholic odor Evans factors. When all the applicable factors are considered in this case, the officer articulated a reasonable suspicion justifying the administration of field sobriety tests in consideration of the defendant's driving behavior, his bloodshot eyes, the odor of alcohol, and his admission to consuming alcoholic beverages before driving. The trial court erred in suppressing the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 741State v. Linder (2018)
Ineffective assistance of counsel disqualification of counsel. The record shows that appellant's counsel advocated for appellant during plea negotiation and that appellant was satisfied with his counsel. Appellant's counsel was not ineffective in his representation of appellant however, because of the breakdown in appellant's relationship with his counsel during the sentencing phase, the trial court should have disqualified appellant's counsel for the purpose of sentencing only.
- 2018 Ohio 742Montgomery v. Vargo (2018)
Civ.R. 56/summary judgment. Appellant's claims in their second complaint were not newly discovered and the trial court therefore did not err in granting appellee summary judgment.
- 2018 Ohio 743Cleveland v. Amazing Tickets, Inc. (2018)
Administrative subpoena, special statutory proceeding. An action to enforce an administrative subpoena is a special statutory proceeding to which the Rules of Civil Procedure generally do not apply. However, administrative subpoenas must comply with Civ.R. 45(A)(1)(c). Because the City of Cleveland's administrative subpoenas failed to conform to the requirements therein the municipal court erred in ordering appellant to comply with the subpoenas.
- 2018 Ohio 744State v. Evans (2018)
Drug possession motion to suppress limitation of cross-examination forfeiture. Jury did not err by rejecting defendant's claim that she was innocently transporting a package, unaware that it held nearly 25 pounds of marijuana, and finding her guilty of drug possession because evidence showed that her house contained marijuana, digital scales, vacuum sealing equipment, and large quantities of cash hidden in clothing.
- 2018 Ohio 745Boaeuf v. Memphis Station, L.L.C. (2018)
Conversion punitive damages manifest weight of the evidence. Court judgment on conversion claim not against the weight of the evidence where the seller of bar assets converted those assets by selling them to a third party because the seller had obtained a cognovit judgment based on buyer's defaulting on payment for the sale of the bar assets, yet proceeding to sell the bar assets to a third party despite knowing that the buyer of the bar assets had a replevin action pending.
- 2018 Ohio 746City of Cleveland v. Krebs (2018)
Written jury waiver Crim. R. 23(A) R.C. 2945.05 failure to comply with lawful order of police Cleveland Codified Ordinances 403.02(A) reckless failure to yield to public safety vehicle Cleveland Codified Ordinances 431.21 driving on the sidewalk, street, lawn, or curb Cleveland Codified Ordinances 431.37 sufficient evidence manifest weight of the evidence. The trial court failed to obtain a valid jury waiver on the defendant's failure to comply charge, but because the defendant did not have a right to a jury on his two minor misdemeanor offenses, failure to yield to a public safety vehicle and driving on the sidewalk, the trial court could conduct a bench trial on those charges. The city failed to present sufficient evidence of failure to comply and failure to yield to a public safety vehicle. Defendant's conviction for driving on a sidewalk, however, was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Thus, defendant's convictions for failure to comply and failure to yield to a public safety vehicle were vacated and defendant's conviction for driving on a sidewalk was affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 747Grill v. Artistic Renovations (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 750In re M.L. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 752Ohio Quay 55 L.L.C. v. City of Cleveland (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 757State v. Small (2018)
Trial court did not err when it denied appellant's motion to withdraw guilty plea.
- 2018 Ohio 758State v. Thomas (2018)
The trial court suppressed evidence and we affirmed from a warrantless search because under these circumstances, the police officers did not have reasonable and articulable suspicion to seize appellee.
- 2018 Ohio 759Wilkins v. Harrisburg (2018)
Application for en banc consideration is denied. No inconsistency in district decisions is discerned.
- 2018 Ohio 760In re Special Grand Jury Investigation (2018)
Because appellant did not affirmatively establish that an immediate appeal of the trial court's order to produce alleged work product is necessary in order to afford a meaningful and effective remedy under R.C. 2505.02(B)(4)(b), no final, appealable order exists pursuant to Smith v. Chen, 142 Ohio St.3d 411, 2015-Ohio-1480. Appeal dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 761Anderson v. WBNS-TV, Inc. (2018)
Summary judgment was not appropriate for a television station which accused a private citizen of being an armed robber and not just a suspect.
- 2018 Ohio 763Coleman v. KBO, Inc. (2018)
In considering claim for eligibility for workers' compensation on a summary judgment motion, the trial court erred in finding that there was no genuine issue of material fact as to whether claimant's psychological condition in 2015 was caused by a workplace injury several years earlier. Claimant's expert stated by affidavit that, in his opinion, claimant's depression was related to the workplace injury five years earlier. The trial court also erred in concluding, as a matter of law, that reasonable minds could not find a causal connection to the psychological condition five years after the physical injury. The trial court erred in concluding that claimant's expert's opinion could not be considered, because it was "self serving" and "contradicted" claimant's admissions about her medical history. Rules related to contradictory evidence offered by a party in support of or in opposition to a motion for summary judgment apply to contradictory statements by the same person no such evidence was offered here. Moreover, the expert's opinion and the claimant's admissions were not contradictory, and a non-party's statements are not "self serving" when offered to oppose a motion for summary judgment. Judgment reversed and remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 764Wright v. Cramer (2018)
The trial court erred in only one respect, and this was in connection with the court's judicial notice of S&P 500's return rates to calculate appreciation on the marital portion of Appellant's retirement accounts. In all other respects, the trial court did not abuse its discretion in classifying and dividing the parties' property. Affirmed in part and reversed in part, and remanded solely for the trial court to decide an appropriate method of calculating the appreciation of the marital portion of Appellant's retirement accounts.
- 2018 Ohio 765State v. Hare (2018)
The evidence is sufficient to show that Appellant committed aggravated robbery and felony murder. Although in dispute, the manifest weight of the evidence is not contrary to the jury's verdict finding that Appellant strangled the victim. The jury did not lose its way because it believed the state's witnesses over the defense's witnesses. Appellant fails to show that the trial court plainly erred by admitting evidence of his other bad acts. Defense counsel properly waived Appellant's presence at a jury view and at a conference on the admission of exhibits. Counsel was not ineffective for not objecting to the admission of the other-acts evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 766State v. Hazel (2018)
Defendant-appellant's counsel filed a brief under the authority of Anders v. California, 386 U.S. 738, 87 S.Ct. 1396, 18 L.Ed.2d 493 (1967) with Defendant-appellant filing a pro se brief. A thorough review of the record reveals no arguably meritorious appellate issues. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 767State v. Ritchie (2018)
Defendant-appellant's disorderly conduct conviction as a fourth degree misdemeanor is supported by sufficient evidence and it is not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 768State v. Shaffer (2018)
The trial court erred by sustaining Appellee's motion to dismiss. The 90-day time limit under R.C. 2945.71 in which to bring Appellee to trial had not yet expired when he filed his motion. Judgment reversed remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 769State v. Sims (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in admitting evidence of Appellant's prior convictions, since a prior violation of the protection order increases the degree of the offense and is accordingly an element thereof. The prior convictions were also admissible to show Appellant's knowledge of the protection order and the absence of mistake or accident. Appellant was properly served with the protection order. His convictions are supported by sufficient evidence and not against the manifest weight of the evidence, since Appellant acted recklessly in residing and working within 500 yards of Petitioner, in violation of the protection order. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 770DeLong v. Thompson (2018)
Employment termination
- 2018 Ohio 771State ex rel. Horton v. Fleegle (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 772State v. Boone (2018)
Appellant's burglary and grand theft of a motor vehicle convictions were supported by sufficient evidence and were not against the weight of the evidence. Infer possession circumstantial ability to pay.
- 2018 Ohio 773State v. Boyd (2018)
possession of drugs in vicinity of juvenile, trafficking of drugs in vicinity of juvenile, cocaine, fentanyl, drug paraphernalia, jail time credit, R.C. 2967.191, court appointed counsel, ineffective assistance, waiver of pre-sentence report, imposition of consecutive sentences, guilty plea not supported by the record
- 2018 Ohio 774State v. Gott (2018)
Trial court properly denied pro se appellant's motions in murder case affirmed 20 years ago on direct appeal. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 775State v. Leavell (2018)
Where appellant failed to object to his prosecution by a special prosecutor, appellant waived all but plain error.
- 2018 Ohio 776Millican v. Albrechta & Coble, Ltd. (2018)
Grant of summary judgment will be affirmed where, in viewing the evidence most strongly in favor of the nonmovant, there remains no potential dispute of material fact and judgment in favor of the movant is proper as a matter of law.
- 2018 Ohio 777State v. Poupard (2018)
Trial counsel not ineffective for failing to further investigate the case where there is no evidence in the record that further investigation would have changed the outcome. Conviction for tampering with records is based on sufficient evidence where appellant filled out and signed the records using his brother's name.
- 2018 Ohio 778State v. Welninski (2018)
Defendant's attempted murder and felonious assault convictions were allied offenses of similar import where the offenses were based on three gunshots fired in rapid succession, from the same location, at the same victim, and all bullets missed their intended victim. Although defendant was convicted on a complicity theory for felonious assault, that was immaterial to the Ruff analysis because the defendant, as accomplice, was found to have the same intent as the principal and was deemed to have committed every act of the principal offense.
- 2018 Ohio 779State v. Horn (2018)
Trial court properly convicted and sentenced appellant for six counts of rape with sexually violent predator specifications. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 781Mayberry v. Chevalier (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 783In re Resignation of Elsass (2018)
Attorneys at law-Resignation with disciplinary action pending-Gov.Bar R. VI(11)(C).
- 2018 Ohio 785State v. A.V. (2018)
sealing of record of conviction, R.C. 2953.32 - convictions excluded from sealing, R.C. 2953.36 - attempted unlawful sexual conduct with a minor, R.C. 2907.04 and R.C. 2923.02 - unambiguous
- 2018 Ohio 786Faber v. Seneca Cty. Sheriff's Dept. (2018)
The provisions of R.C. 2744.02 apply when an elected official is sued in his or her official capacity. An issue is moot if a controversy no longer exists.
- 2018 Ohio 788State v. Cook (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCING - R.C. 2953.08(G)(2) contrary to law R.C. 2929.11 R.C. 2929.12 sentencing factors purposes and principles of felony sentencing clearly and convincingly supported by the record. ALLIED OFFENSES - merger aggravated robbery kidnapping R.C. 2941.25 conduct of the accused separate animus.
- 2018 Ohio 789State v. Smith (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCING - R.C. 2953.08(G)(2) contrary to law R.C. 2929.11 R.C. 2929.12 sentencing factors purposes and principles of felony sentencing clearly and convincingly supported by the record.
- 2018 Ohio 790State v. Flores (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - App.R. 5(A) delayed appeal signed plea agreement shows appellant was clearly advised of appellate rights Civ.R. 58(B) service applies to civil cases.
- 2018 Ohio 791Fairport Real Estate L.L.C. v. Nautical Ridge Condominium Owners' Assn., Inc. (2018)
CIVIL - Ohio Condominium Act condominium development declaration declarant developer successor declarant assignment deed "stands in the same relation" obligations and liabilities express easement implied easement prior use necessity ingress and egress retention basin roadways storm and sanitary sewer lines utility lines sharing of expenses summary judgment.
- 2018 Ohio 793Paolucci v. Morgan (2018)
NEGLIGENCE - Injury or death of horses boarded in horse barn contract for maintenance duty of barn owner res ipsa loquitor not applicable when injury or death could have been attributed to cause other than owner's negligence no evidence of breach of duty replevin lack of required motion.
- 2018 Ohio 794State v. Clark (2018)
POSTCONVICTION RELIEF - appeal from denial of motion to vacate convictions de novo criminal complaint is not always required indictment issued by grand jury is sufficient to invoke jurisdiction.
- 2018 Ohio 795State v. Noling (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Criminal law-Postconviction DNA testing-An appellate court has jurisdiction over a claim raised by an offender who has requested postconviction DNA testing if the claim challenges any of the three discretionary decisions specifically listed as appealable in R.C. 2953.72(A)(8) or if the claim is that the trial court failed to fulfill a mandatory duty-R.C. 2953.81(C)'s requirement that the testing authority provide the subject offender with "the results of the testing" mandates that the offender be provided only the DNA profile created for the purpose of a comparison with the DNA profiles in the Combined DNA Index System.
- 2018 Ohio 796State v. Foster (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 798Hatfield v. Cornell (2018)
The juvenile court's decision to order appellant to submit to hair follicle drug testing was proper where the record indicates there was a reasonable suspicion that appellant may have been using drugs, thereby necessitating appellant to undergo drug testing to ensure the best interest of their daughter was being met. In addition, the juvenile court's decision to terminate a shared parenting plan and grant appellee custody of their daughter was in their daughter's best interest given appellant's admitted prior drug use and presence at a house where law enforcement had recently executed a search warrant and arrested several people for possession of drugs.
- 2018 Ohio 800In re T.G.O. (2018)
Juvenile court abused its discretion by denying a father's motion to find a mother in contempt for violating the juvenile court's order regarding the designated place for parenting exchange of the parties' child.
- 2018 Ohio 801State v. Alspaugh (2018)
The trial court did not err by denying appellant's motion requesting she be appointed new counsel where the record indicates appellant was adequately represented by her appointed counsel at all times relevant. This includes appellant's appointed counsel negotiating an advantageous plea deal that ultimately resulted in appellant being sentenced to a reduced sentence of five years in prison. The trial court also did not err by sentencing appellant to serve five years in prison for involuntary manslaughter when considering the serious nature of the charges appellant faced that resulted in the loss of a person's life.
- 2018 Ohio 802In re L.H. (2018)
Mother appeals decision adjudicating her children abused and dependent. Juvenile court erred in allowing social worker at children's advocacy center to testify as to child's statements implicating mother and father in physical abuse. Child's statements were not admissible under Evid.R. 803(4) because the record did not support the conclusion that the child made the statements for purposes of medical diagnosis or treatment. Error required reversal as no other evidence clearly and convincingly supported the adjudications.
- 2018 Ohio 803State v. Lloyd (2018)
The doctrine of res judicata applied to bar appellant's postconviction appeal challenging his conviction and sentence where appellant could have, and in most cases actually did, raise these issues as part of his direct appeal and subsequent motions and petitions before the trial court.
- 2018 Ohio 804State v. Foster (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 813State v. Paige (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Criminal law-Sentencing-Trial court did not impose improper split sentence by sentencing defendant to prison term on one count and concurrent community-control sanction on separate count-Trial court lacked authority under R.C. 2929.41(A) to order, as part of defendant's community-control sanction, that he be placed in a community-based-correctional facility ("CBCF") after his completion of separate prison term-Court of appeals' judgment reversed and sentence reinstated except for condition requiring placement in CBCF.
- 2018 Ohio 814Lower Valley Farm, L.L.C. v. Croskey (2018)
Ohio Dormant Mineral Act quiet title action summary judgment in favor of mineral rights holders Corban v. Chesapeake Expl., L.L.C., 149 Ohio St.3d 512, 2016-Ohio-5796, 76 N.E.3d 1089
- 2018 Ohio 815State v. Hunt (2018)
trafficking in drugs possession of drugs guilty plea trial court was not to merge convictions for possession of cocaine and possession of heroin trial court made required consecutive sentencing findings
- 2018 Ohio 816State v. Kozic (2018)
trial court's postrelease control advisement was incorrect R.C. 2967.28 appellate court cannot rule on issue of disqualification of a trial court judge
- 2018 Ohio 817State v. St. Thomas (2018)
jail-time credit Ohio Department of Rehabilitation and Correction appellant should have filed mandamus action
- 2018 Ohio 818Gallick v. Franklin Cnty. Bd. of Revision (2018)
This court lacked jurisdiction over some of appellant's appeals because (1) appellant did not timely appeal judgments affirming the orders of the Franklin County Board of Revision and (2) judgments denying his motions for new trial were nullities. In the remaining appeals, the trial court erred in not finding the recent sale prices the best evidence of the properties' true values for tax year 2013.
- 2018 Ohio 819Miracle v. Ohio Dept. of Veterans Servs. (2018)
The trial court erred in dismissing plaintiff's claims for wrongful discharge in violation of public policy under Civ.R. 12(B)(6).
- 2018 Ohio 820Crosier v. Ohio Dep't of Rehab. & Corr. (2018)
Judgment affirmed. ODRC presented reliable, probative, and substantial evidence demonstrating that appellant violated Rule 7 of the performance track of ODRC's standards of employee conduct when she failed to follow a written directive from her superior. Because appellant had previously entered into a last chance agreement with ODRC, wherein she agreed that any violation of the performance track of ODRC's standards of employee conduct would result in her termination from employment, the trial court did not abuse its discretion in affirming SPBR's order affirming ODRC's order removing appellant from her employment with ODRC. The trial court acknowledged that, pursuant to R.C. 124.34(B), SPBR's review was limited to determining whether appellant had violated the last change agreement.
- 2018 Ohio 821D.M.W. v. E.W. (2018)
Trial court erred when it granted CPO without first holding a proper full hearing.
- 2018 Ohio 8226800 Avery Rd., L.L.C. v. Franklin Cty. Bd. of Revision (2018)
Trial court did not abuse its discretion in retaining the auditor's value of appellant's real property in appellant's appeal from a decision of the Board of Review. Appellant failed to present competent and probative evidence at the Board of Review hearing in support of the request for a reduction in value. Appellant's comparison of the auditor's assessed value for surrounding properties, standing alone, is insufficient evidence to support a reduction in the auditor's value of appellant's property. Appellant's owner's opinion of fair market value was too vague and uncertain to qualify as competent probative evidence of value under the owner-opinion rule. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 823State v. Weldin (2018)
Judgment granting application to seal record of conviction reversed and matter remanded for a new hearing upon proper notice.
- 2018 Ohio 824Fleet Staff, Inc. v. Ohio Dept. of Job & Family Servs. (2018)
The trial court did not err in affirming the decision of the Ohio Unemployment Compensation Review Commission finding that appellant is a successor in interest to Stanley Staffing, Inc. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 826State v. Felder (2018)
State did not breach plea agreement
- 2018 Ohio 827State v. Taylor (2018)
Misdemeanor Sentencing
- 2018 Ohio 829State v. High (2018)
Resentencing upon remand
- 2018 Ohio 830State v. Morris (2018)
appellant not entitled to jail time credit when released on recognizance bond
- 2018 Ohio 831State v. Carey (2018)
Motion to suppress, traffic stop, cracked windshield, substantial, unsafe, R.C. 4513.02(A), reasonable suspicion, weaving, marked lanes, probable cause
- 2018 Ohio 832State v. Htoo (2018)
motion to withdraw plea, R.C. 2943.031, abuse of discretion, mootness
- 2018 Ohio 833State v. Stoddard (2018)
R.C. 2953.21, evidentiary hearing, affidavits, credibility, ineffective assistance of counsel
- 2018 Ohio 834State v. Wesson (2018)
R.C. 2953.21, R.C. 2953.23, successive petition for post-conviction relief, death penalty, intellectual disability, ineffective assistance of counsel
- 2018 Ohio 835Younker v. Hayes (2018)
mutual mistake - default judgment - damages hearing - breach of contract - money damages - fair market value - specific performance
- 2018 Ohio 840Riedel v. Akron Gen. Health Sys. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 841State v. Davis (2018)
Preindictment delay, sufficiency and manifest weight of the evidence, hearsay exceptions, Evid.R. 801, 802 and 803, R.C. 2907.02(A)(1)(c), constitutionally void for vagueness. Appellant failed to demonstrate actual prejudice from a 16-year preindictment delay as only appellant and the victim were present and the last-minute potential witness could only provide hearsay testimony that was not subject to exceptions. The trial court's decision was not against the sufficiency and manifest weight of the evidence where sexual penetration was undisputed and appellant admitted that the victim was sleeping at the time. R.C. 2907.02(A)(1)(c) is not constitutionally void for vagueness because it: (1) contains ascertainable standards of guilt, (2) provides sufficient notice of the conduct proscribed, and (3) contains sufficient guidelines to avoid arbitrary or discriminatory enforcement.
- 2018 Ohio 842State v. Looby (2018)
Guilty plea Crim.R. 11(C)(2)(c) constitutional rights waiver strict compliance. Defendant's guilty plea was invalid where court failed to explain that by pleading guilty, the defendant was waiving all constitutional rights associated with trial.
- 2018 Ohio 843State v. Miller (2018)
Guilty plea Crim.R. 11(C)(2)(c) constitutional rights waiver strict compliance. Defendant's guilty plea was invalid where court failed to explain that by pleading guilty, the defendant was waiving all constitutional rights associated with trial.
- 2018 Ohio 844Cleveland v. Cunningham (2018)
OVI field sobriety tests motion to suppress findings of fact and conclusions of law Crim.R. 12(F) R.C. 4511.19(D)(4) NHTSA standards substantial compliance police officer's observations cross examination relevance confrontation abuse of discretion. Appellant's request during the morning of trial for a "written ruling" does not amount to a timely request for findings and conclusions. Because the record contained a sufficient basis for review, the appellant was not prejudiced by the court's failure to issue findings and conclusions, and we are able to address the merits of her claims. The trial court properly considered the testimony of the arresting police officers where such testimony consisted of the officers' observations made during the appellant's performance during the field sobriety tests. Where the city presented competent testimony concerning the NHTSA standards and the officer testified as to numerous instructions he gave to the appellant in administering the walk and turn test, the trial court did not err in finding substantial compliance. The results of the walk and turn test were therefore properly admitted. The trial court did not abuse its discretion when it prohibited cross examination regarding the administration of the suppressed HGN test, and the appellant was not deprived of her right of confrontation.
- 2018 Ohio 846City of Cleveland v. Ohio Bureau of Workers' Comp. (2018)
Ohio Bureau of Workers' Compensation excessive workers' compensation insurance premiums premium overcharges public employers group rating program unjust enrichment equitable restitution R.C. 4123.29 R.C. 4123.34 R.C. 4123.39 subject matter jurisdiction failure to exhaust administrative remedies R.C. 4123.291 Ohio Adm.Code 4123-14-06 summary judgment Ohio Adm.Code 4123-17-17(C) statute of limitations R.C. 126.01 R.C. 2307.05 accrual of statute of limitations on unjust enrichment claim voluntary payment doctrine competing expert testimony manifest weight of the evidence. Trial court did not err in granting partial summary judgment as to liability in favor of city and against the Ohio Bureau of Workers' Compensation ("BWC") and thereafter awarding city over $4.5 million in restitution on the city's claim that it was unlawfully charged excessive workers' compensation insurance premiums in order to subsidize overly generous premium discounts to public employers who participated in the BWC's group rating program. Trial court did not err in refusing to dismiss city's amended complaint for lack of subject matter jurisdiction or failure to exhaust administrative remedies. Trial court properly determined that it had subject matter jurisdiction over city's unjust enrichment claim for equitable restitution to recover amount of premium overcharges. City was not required to comply with the administrative review process set forth in R.C. 4123.291 and Adm.Code 4123-14-06 prior to filing suit because adjudication of the lawfulness of the BWC's rating system and the relief sought by the city were outside the scope of the administrative review process. Trial court did not err in rejecting BWC's affirmative defenses. Ohio Adm.Code 4123-17-17(C)'s two-year limitation on premium adjustments and the five-year statute of limitations set forth in R.C. 126.301 did not apply to the city's unjust enrichment claim. City's cause of action for unjust enrichment was not barred by the applicable six-year statute of limitations. Voluntary payment doctrine did not apply because there was no evidence city had knowledge of all of the relevant facts when making premium payments. Restitution award was supported by substantial competent, credible evidence and was not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 847State v. Jones (2018)
Court costs R.C. 2947.23 plain error indigency R.C. 5145.16 Ohio Adm.Code 5120-3-05 Ohio Adm.Code 5120-3-08 R.C. 5120.133(A). The trial court did not err when it ordered the defendant to pay court costs or perform community service in prison in lieu of paying court costs. Defendant was going to serve four years in prison. Under R.C. 5145.16, there is a work program in prison. Inmates receive compensation for their services, which is placed in their personal institutional accounts. See Ohio Adm.Code 5120-3-05 and 5120-3-08. R.C. 5120.133(A) permits the Department of Rehabilitation and Correction to deduct payments toward a certified judgment from a prisoner's account. Furthermore, Ohio Adm.Code 5120 5 03(D) authorizes the garnishment of an inmate's account to satisfy the inmate's obligations to the court as long as the account retains $25 for inmate expenditures.
- 2018 Ohio 848State v. Jackson (2018)
Consecutive sentences for rape convictions affirmed. Court made the proper statutory findings at the sentencing hearing and the findings were supported by evidence in the record. Case remanded for the limited purpose of issuing a nunc pro tunc journal entry incorporating findings.
- 2018 Ohio 849Cleveland v. Boone (2018)
R.C. 2919.27, violation of protection order, Crim.R. 29, judgment of acquittal, sufficiency of the evidence, Evid.R. 902(4), certified journal entry, Evid.R. 201, judicial notice. The trial court erred in denying appellant's Crim.R. 29 motion for judgment of acquittal and finding appellant guilty of violating a temporary restraining order where the city failed to produce a certified copy of the order, the parties did not stipulate to the terms of the order or that the order was in effect on the date of the alleged violation. A trial court may not take judicial notice of the docket of another court.
- 2018 Ohio 850State v. Jones (2018)
Consecutive sentence R.C. 2929.14(C)(4) rape statutory findings journal entry. The trial court made the statutorily required findings necessary to impose consecutive sentences under R.C. 2929.14(C)(4). Because the findings were not incorporated in the sentencing journal entry, the case is remanded for the limited purpose of incorporating the findings into a journal entry.
- 2018 Ohio 853State ex rel. T.L. v. Corrigan (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 854Olmstead v. Risner (2018)
Writ of Habeas Corpus Modification of Bond Moot
- 2018 Ohio 855Seniah Corp. v. Buckingham, Doolittle & Burroughs, L.L.P. (2018)
Legal Malpractice Tolling Agreement Authority to Bind
- 2018 Ohio 856State v. Robinson (2018)
Petition for Post Conviction Relief - Res Judicata
- 2018 Ohio 857State v. Baugh (2018)
Officer Involved Shooting Attempted Murder Speedy Trial Ineffective Assistance of Counsel
- 2018 Ohio 858Martin v. Dockter (2018)
Trial court erred when it applied provisions in Civ.R. 53(D) rather than Civ.R. 65.1 to its adoption of a magistrate's decision granting a civil stalking protection order. Trial court had jurisdiction to decide Civ.R. 6(B)(2) motion.
- 2018 Ohio 865State v. Dehart (2018)
The trial court's decision to disregard its promise of community control at sentencing hearing and impose consecutive twelve-month prison terms rendered appellant's guilty pleas unknowing, unintelligent, and involuntary. Appellant's remaining assignment of error is rendered moot. Judgment reversed and cause remanded for either the imposition of community control sanctions or to allow appellant to withdraw his guilty pleas. (Tucker, J., concurring.)
- 2018 Ohio 866State v. Freeman (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion when it revoked appellant's community control and sentenced him to two years in prison. The evidence adduced at the revocation hearing established that appellant violated the requirements of his community control by failing to report to his probation officer upon being released from jail. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 869Montgomery v. Greene Co. Sheriff's Dept. (2018)
Plaintiff-Appellant asserted in his complaint that the Greene County Sheriff's Office and one of its deputies had engaged in malicious prosecution and had violated his constitutional rights by persuading a third party, his neighbor, to make false claims against him. The Sheriff's Office and deputy filed a motion for summary judgment, to which they attached affidavits from the neighbor and two deputies involved in the investigation denying that they had encouraged or been encouraged by others to make false statements. Because Plaintiff-Appellant did not create a genuine issue of material fact regarding the pertinent issues, the trial court properly granted summary judgment to the Sheriff's Office and deputy. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 870State v. Murrell (2018)
Defendant-appellant pleaded guilty to one count of domestic violence, a fourth degree felony under R.C. 2919.25(A) and (D)(3), with the trial court sentencing him to a prison term of twelve months. It cannot be found by clear and convincing evidence that Defendant-appellant's sentence is not supported by the record or that it is otherwise contrary to law. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 871State v. Oglesby (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying Defendant-appellant's petition for post-conviction relief filed under R.C. 2953.21. The petition was not timely filed, and Defendant-appellant failed to establish that the petition was not timely filed because he was unavoidably prevented from discovering the facts asserted in support of the petition. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 872State v. Patterson (2018)
Defendant-appellant, in 2011, pleaded guilty to one count of aggravated burglary and one count of aggravated robbery with these convictions being affirmed on direct appeal. Defendant-appellant, in March 2016, filed a motion to withdraw the guilty pleas with the trial court overruling the motion. A trial court is without jurisdiction to maintain and determine a motion to withdraw guilty pleas after the guilty pleas have been appealed and affirmed by an appellate court. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 873State v. Spencer (2018)
The record does not clearly and convincingly fail to support the trial court's imposition of an eleven-year prison sentence for the appellant's involuntary-manslaughter conviction. Although the appellant pled guilty to involuntary manslaughter, the record supports a finding that he beat his six-week-old child to death. The trial court was entitled to consider these circumstances when sentencing the appellant. The trial court erred, however, in imposing an additional 735-day prison sentence as a sanction for committing a felony while on post-release control from a previous case. The record reflects that post-release control was not properly imposed in connection with the appellant's prior burglary conviction. Because the part of appellant's prior burglary case imposing post-release control was void, the trial court lacked authority in the present involuntary-manslaughter case to sanction the appellant for violating post-release control. Judgment affirmed in part, reversed in part, and sentence partially vacated.
- 2018 Ohio 876In Re $18,823.06 U.S. Currency And (2018)
FORFEITURE: In a civil forfeiture proceeding, the state presented sufficient evidence for the trial court to order the forfeiture of funds in a checking account as proceeds properly seized by the state where the owner received cash from an individual engaged in a drug enterprise for renting vehicles used in drug trafficking however, there was not sufficient evidence for the trial court to order the forfeiture of three other bank accounts where the state did not demonstrate that the funds in those accounts were tied to proceeds from drug trafficking. [But see DISSENT: The trial court erred in ordering the forfeiture of the funds in the checking account, because the state did not prove that they were connected to illegal activity.]
- 2018 Ohio 877State v. Wright (2018)
ALLIED OFFENSES - SENTENCING: In sentencing defendant on eight counts of theft, the trial court erred in not merging two of the counts as allied offenses of similar import where defendant broke into a vehicle and stole two credit cards belonging to the same victim but the court did not err in imposing consecutive sentences on the other six counts, as the trial court's findings were made in accordance with R.C. 2929.14(C)(4) and supported by the record.
- 2018 Ohio 878State v. Allen (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion by denying appellant's petition for postconviction relief. The state properly sought a direct indictment against appellant, so the trial court had subject matter jurisdiction over appellant's case. The trial court's judgment entry is sufficient to constitute findings of fact and conclusions of law for purposes of R.C. 2953.21(D).
- 2018 Ohio 880State v. Haddox (2018)
Following a community control violation and imposition of a prison sentence, jail-time credit was properly calculated where the sentence included concurrent and consecutive prison terms. R.C. 2967.191 Fugate.
- 2018 Ohio 881State v. Holder (2018)
Assignment of error raises issue which were not asserted in the motion that was denied by the trial court and appealed and are also barred by the doctrine of res judicata. Notification of the mandatory nature of postrelease control was properly given.
- 2018 Ohio 882State v. Jones (2018)
Trial court errs when it imposes costs in its judgment entry of conviction that were not imposed at the sentencing hearing.
- 2018 Ohio 883In re Mar.H. (2018)
Termination of Parental rights. Competent, credible evidence supported trial court's finding that (1) children could not be placed with parents within a reasonable amount of time and should not be placed with parents and (2) granting permanent custody to children services agency was in the child's best interest.
- 2018 Ohio 884State v. Peters (2018)
Following child endangering conviction, trial court properly considered R.C. 2929.11 and 2929.12 in imposing sentence, and sentence was not clearly and convincingly contrary to law.
- 2018 Ohio 885In re R.P. (2018)
At hearing on motion for permanent custody, child's counselor did not provide improper opinion testimony about effect of child's brain injury on her cognition and memory, and children's services agency was not required to present medical expert testimony that injury did not affect child's memory and cognition. Trial court's findings under R.C. 2151.414(B)(1)(d) and (D)(1) were not against manifest weight of evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 886Steck's Buckeye Storage Unit, L.L.C. v. Catawaba Island Twp. Bd. of Trustees (2018)
Planned Unit Development. Minor deviation. Due process. Meaningful opportunity to be heard. Motion to supplement appellate record.
- 2018 Ohio 887State v. Allen (2018)
Appellant's conviction for possession and trafficking in heroin is supported by the evidence where, rather than merely being a backseat passenger in the car where the drugs were found, pictures from the phone of one of the other car occupants depicts appellant and the other occupants displaying guns and approximately $90,000. The pictures also show appellant driving the car. Finally, in the photographs, all of the occupants of the car are wearing the same clothes as at the time of their arrest.
- 2018 Ohio 892In re Guardianship of Nauth (2018)
termination of guardianship - attorney fees - three-part Wolfe test - guardian fees - duplicate entry - abuse of discretion
- 2018 Ohio 893Rogers v. Logan Cty. Health Dist. (2018)
Civil litigants generally do not have a right to appointed counsel appellate courts do not have jurisdiction to hear disqualification matters for trial judges. Further, mediation is not a required step in the trial process.
- 2018 Ohio 894State v. Frye (2018)
The defendant-appellant's having-weapons-while-under-disability, tampering-with-evidence, and possession-of-drugs convictions are based on sufficient evidence. The defendant-appellant's possession-of-drugs conviction is not against the manifest weight of the evidence. The trial court did not err by denying the defendant-appellant's motion to suppress evidence because the trash pulls did not violate his rights under the Ohio Constitution. The trial court did not err by denying the defendant-appellant's motion to dismiss one of the counts in the indictment because ADB Fubinaca was a schedule I controlled substance in Ohio at the time of the defendant-appellant's arrest. The trial court did not commit plain error by rejecting the defendant-appellant's request for immunity under R.C. 2945.44 for witnesses he intended to call as part of his defense. The trial court did not abuse its discretion by denying the defendant-appellant's motion for a new trial because the trial court's jury instruction was not an incorrect statement of law. The defendant-appellant was not denied a fair trial based on prosecutorial misconduct. The trial court correctly concluded that the defendant-appellant's having-weapons-under-disability and tampering-with-evidence convictions are not allied offenses of similar import.
- 2018 Ohio 895State v. Gamble (2018)
The trial court erred in its sentence of the Defendant-Appellant on the merged counts in the indictment. Further, the trial court erred in assessing the Defendant-Appellant with a mandatory fine without a showing of his present or future ability to pay the fine. Further, the trial court did not err by overruling Defendant-Appellant's motions to suppress and dismiss. Judgment affirmed in part and reversed in part.
- 2018 Ohio 898State v. Ellis (2018)
Trial court's denial of suppression motion affirmed where officer testified that defendant drove outside of his lane multiple times, supporting a stop for a marked lanes violation.
- 2018 Ohio 899State v. Brown (2018)
Under R.C. 2925.02(A)(3), the State must prove that the defendant knowingly furnished a controlled substance the State does not need to establish that the defendant was aware of what specific type of controlled substance he or she was furnishing.
- 2018 Ohio 900In re S.L. (2018)
Trial court's decision to terminate parental rights was supported by the record when it was shown that mother did not complete or even attempt to complete the requirements of the case plan and failed to substantially remedy the condistions causing the removal of the children from the home. The trial court's determination that the termination of parental rights was in the best interest of the children was supported by clear and convincing evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 902State v. Wilson (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - SEARCH & SEIZURE - officer had reasonable articulable suspicion of criminal activity that warranted his investigatory stop of appellant after his commission of a bank robbery Apprendi issue waiver plain error since appellant waived his right to have jury try his RVO specification during his no contest plea and admitted all facts necessary to enhance his sentence as an RVO, the trial court did not commit plain error in sentencing him.
- 2018 Ohio 903State v. Corti (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCING/FINES, RESTITUTION, EXPUNGEMENT - trial court's imposition of consecutive sentences on five counts of burglary was not contrary to law as the statutory findings for such sentences were supported by the record.
- 2018 Ohio 904State v. Stroud (2018)
CRIMINAL - Sexual Imposition R.C. 2907.06(A)(1) intent reckless sexual contact weight of the evidence ineffective assistance of counsel jury demand
- 2018 Ohio 905State v. Neuroth (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - motion to suppress evidence dispatch hotel report of chemical odor emanating from room possible stolen vehicle knock several minutes to respond officers notice no odor outside invited into room consent odor apparent probable cause exigent circumstances methamphetamine lab discovered in box springs no error in denying motion.
- 2018 Ohio 906In re K.Q. (2018)
JUVENILE - termination of temporary custody award of legal custody to a third party R.C. 2151.011(B)(21) legal custody intended to be permanent not as drastic as permanent custody best interest factors R.C. 3109.04(F) no abuse of discretion.
- 2018 Ohio 907Filby v. Filby (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - vexatious litigator R.C. 2323.52 leave to proceed lack of jurisdiction appeal dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 908Aston v. Aston (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - trial court did not abuse its discretion in granting motion to modify parenting time because appellant failed to comply with numerous Ohio Appellate Rules regarding the procedural requirements for a brief appellant failed to include table of contents, table of cases, statement of case, statement of facts supported by references to record, any assignments of error, a separate argument with citations to legal authority in support of each assignment of error, or a statement of issues presented for review.
- 2018 Ohio 909State v. Bolden (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCING/FINES, RESTITUTION, EXPUNGEMENT - since the trial court said it considered the seriousness factors in R.C. 2929.12 and discussed the pertinent factors as they related to this case, the trial court considered these factors and, for this reason, we cannot clearly and convincingly say appellant's sentence was contrary to law.
- 2018 Ohio 910State v. Karnofel (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - zoning two counts of exterior maintenance violations actively attempting to ameliorate challenges weight of the evidence defense to charges no transcript App.R. 9(B) appellate court cannot evaluate the evidence appellant cannot demonstrate error.
- 2018 Ohio 911State v. Curtis (2018)
Appellant's arguments pertaining to the trial court's imposition of his sentence for murder in 2009 were barred by res judicata where he could have, and should have, raised the arguments on direct appeal. Further, the trial court did not err in denying appellant's motion for a de novo sentencing hearing where the trial court complied with this court's remand instructions by issuing a nunc pro tunc entry to correct errors contained in the court's 2009 sentencing entry.
- 2018 Ohio 912State v. Cunningham (2018)
Trial court did not err in failing to sua sponte give a limiting instruction regarding appellant's prior OVI conviction. Trial counsel was not ineffective for failing to request a limiting instruction regarding appellant's prior OVI conviction. Appellant was not denied his right of allocution simply because the record does not show he was afforded such right before he was sentenced.
- 2018 Ohio 913Oney v. Dixie Imports, Inc. (2018)
Trial court did not err by denying a car dealership's motion to stay proceedings pending arbitration, as the dealership waived its right to arbitration by participating in the litigation in a manner inconsistent with the right to arbitrate.
- 2018 Ohio 914Fairfield v. Lopez (2018)
Trial court erred in denying motion for relief from judgment where it granted a hearing on the motion, but did not provide an opportunity for the presentation of evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 915State v. B.C.M. (2018)
The juvenile court properly classified appellant a Tier III juvenile sex offender after determining that appellant was 16 years old at the time of the offenses.
- 2018 Ohio 916State v. Evans (2018)
Trial court did not err in denying appellant's motion to suppress where appellant was not subject to a custodial interrogation requiring the issuance of Miranda warnings. Appellant's felonious assault and endangering children convictions were supported by sufficient evidence and were not against the weight of the evidence where there was ample medical evidence that the three-week-old infant was abused, that the injuries occurred around the time appellant was left alone with the infant, and appellant admitted to harming the infant. Appellant did not receive ineffective representation by his trial counsel, and appellant's three-year prison sentence was supported by the record and was not contrary to law.
- 2018 Ohio 917JP Morgan Chase Bank, N.A. v. Spears (2018)
The trial court's decision granting summary judgment on foreclosure complaint is affirmed and the alleged oral agreement regarding a loan modification is unenforceable under the statute of frauds.
- 2018 Ohio 918South-Western City Schools Bd. of Edn. v. Franklin Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation-Real-property valuation-Board of Tax Appeals erred in applying Bedford rule and in adopting county board of revision's determination of value-Record contains no probative evidence that tends to negate county auditor's valuation-Decision reversed and county auditor's valuation reinstated.
- 2018 Ohio 919South-Western City Schools Bd. of Edn. v. Franklin Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation-Real-property valuation-Board of Tax Appeals erred in remanding case to county board of revision after determining that there was no evidence in record to allow independent valuation to be performed-Decision reversed and county auditor's valuation reinstated.
- 2018 Ohio 920State v. Ferguson (2018)
Trial counsel did not render ineffective assistance of counsel.
- 2018 Ohio 922State ex rel. Quillen v. Wainwright (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Habeas corpus-Alleged sentencing error not cognizable in habeas corpus-Court of appeals' dismissal of petition affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 924Richards v. State (2018)
Writ of Prohibition and Mandamus
- 2018 Ohio 926State v. Stowers (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - PROCEDURE/RULES - CIV.R. 58(B) - SEX OFFENSES: Where defendant had been convicted in 1978 of attempted rape and adjudicated as a sexual predator in 1997 where, in 2006, defendant filed a motion pursuant to State v. Champion, 106 Ohio St.3d 120, 2005-Ohio-4098, 832 N.E.2d 718, to set aside the order requiring him to register as a sexual predator under former R.C. Chapter 2950 ("Megan's Law"), and the trial court overruled the motion, but never ordered the clerk to serve defendant with a copy of the order overruling the motion and where, in 2016, defendant filed a motion requesting that the trial court comply with Civ.R. 58(B) and serve him with the 2006 order overruling the motion, the trial court granted the motion and ordered the clerk to serve defendant with the 2006 order, and defendant filed a notice of appeal from the 2006 order within 30 days of service, defendant's 2016 appeal of the overruling of his 2006 motion was timely. The Ohio Supreme Court's holding in State v. Clayborn, 125 Ohio St.3d 450, 2010-Ohio-2123, 928 N.E.2d 1093, that a direct appeal from a sex-offender-classification judgment "is an appeal in a criminal case that must be filed pursuant to App.R. 4(A) within 30 days after judgment is entered," does not apply where defendant is not appealing from the initial sex-offender-classification judgment Civ.R. 58(B) service rules apply where defendant is appealing from a judgment overruling a motion filed after conviction to vacate his sex-offender classification. Where the record showed that defendant had completed his sentence for attempted rape well before July 1, 1997, Megan's Law's effective date, but was serving time on that date for two thefts, he has no duty to register as a sex offender.
- 2018 Ohio 927State v. Smith (2018)
AUTOS/CRIMINAL - UNAUTHORIZED USE OF A MOTOR VEHICLE - EVIDENCE - SUFFICIENCY: In a prosecution for unauthorized use of a motor vehicle in violation of R.C. 2913.03(A), where the record indicated that the defendant had retained possession of and control over the victim's vehicle, but had not used or operated the vehicle, the conviction was not supported by sufficient evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 929State ex rel. Hall v. Ohio Parole Bd. (2018)
Relator's petition for a writ of mandamus is sua sponte dismissed for failure to comply with the mandatory requirements of R.C. 2969.25. Objections to magistrate's decision are overruled with pending motions held moot, and relator is ordered to pay cost.
- 2018 Ohio 932State v. Prater (2018)
Defendant was properly convicted of multiple felonious assault counts where the evidence showed that he shot at several people despite the possibility he may have fired fewer times than the total number of counts.
- 2018 Ohio 933Ellis v. Columbus Dev. Ctr. (2018)
Trial court erred by granting directed verdict in favor of employer on claim for lumbar radiculitis. Although testimony from claimant's medical expert was equivocal on whether lumbar radiculitis was a pain symptom of another condition or an independent condition, it was not proper to weigh the credibility of various portions of the medical expert's testimony in ruling on a motion for directed verdict. Because portions of the medical expert's testimony constituted some evidence of substantive probative value, reasonable minds could not reach only one conclusion in favor of the employer.
- 2018 Ohio 934State v. Eisenman (2018)
Punch to the victim's head constituted felonious assault.
- 2018 Ohio 935State ex rel. Evans v. Mohr (2018)
The relator's action was rendered moot when the respondent provided the relief requested. We adopt the magistrate's decision dismissing the action as moot and waiving costs.
- 2018 Ohio 937Tomety v. Columbus City Schools (2018)
Trial court did not err by granting motion for judgment on the pleadings on claim for wrongful termination. Construing the material allegations contained in the complaint as true and in favor of appellant, the trial court properly concluded that appellant was a casual or day-to-day substitute teacher and thus was an at-will employee subject to termination with or without cause. Accordingly, the school district was entitled to judgment as a matter of law on appellant's wrongful termination claim.
- 2018 Ohio 938Cartwright v. Akron Gen. Med. Sys. (2018)
summary judgment, Civ.R. 56, statute of limitations, medical malpractice, cognizable event, R.C. 2305.113(A)
- 2018 Ohio 939State v. Deleon (2018)
final order, sentencing, substantial right, res judicata
- 2018 Ohio 940State v. Ecker (2018)
fentanyl overdose - involuntary manslaughter - joinder of indictments - simple and direct - admission of evidence - prosecutorial misconduct
- 2018 Ohio 941Stephens v. Akron (2018)
summary judgment, preliminary injunction, settlement agreement, res judicata, release, collateral attack doctrine
- 2018 Ohio 942State v. Harding (2018)
Criminal: validity of guilty plea Crim.R. 11 ineffective assistance of counsel.
- 2018 Ohio 943In re J.O. (2018)
Juvenile court's termination of parental rights was not against the manifest weight of the evidence where the record supported the court's finding that the children could not or should not be placed with mother within a reasonable period of time and permanent custody was in the children's best interests. Children services agency was not required to make reasonable effort to prevent the removal of the child from the home where father's parental rights had previously been terminated with respect to the child's sibling.
- 2018 Ohio 945Inventiv Health Communications, Inc. v. Rodden (2018)
Forum selection and choice of law clauses/Dismissal with prejudice/Release of bond
- 2018 Ohio 947State v. Richardson (2018)
Manifest weight & sufficiency/Attempted arson/Other acts evidence/Arson registry
- 2018 Ohio 949State v. Lilly (2018)
Ineffective assistance of counsel/Manifest weight of evidence/Insufficient evidence
- 2018 Ohio 950Kelly v. Stark Cnty. Comm'rs (2018)
Unemployment compensation/Whether quit with just cause
- 2018 Ohio 953Brook Park v. Wright (2018)
Speedy trial rights, R.C. 2945.71(B)(2). The trial court violated appellant's speedy trial rights, according to R.C. 2945.71(B)(2) when it waited more than 18 months to bring appellant to trial.
- 2018 Ohio 954State v. Jones (2018)
Motion to vacate guilty plea, nunc pro tunc, R.C. 2967.191, modify final orders. The trial court did not err in denying the appellant's motion to vacate his guilty plea because the plea was not induced by a threat or promise. The trial court erred by issuing a nunc pro tunc order to withdraw credit for jail-time served. A nunc pro tunc order may be used only to correct authentic clerical errors and not to effect what the judge intended to do or should have done. A defendant is not entitled to any jail-time credit for incarceration which arose from facts separate and apart from those facts on which his or her current sentence is based. A trial court has no authority to sua sponte vacate or modify its final orders.
- 2018 Ohio 955State v. Rieves (2018)
Search warrant affidavit Fourth Amendment "trash pull" "tear offs" anonymous tip probable cause motion to suppress drug trafficking no contest plea effect of the plea prejudice Crim.R. 32.1. The trial court did not err when it denied defendant's motion to suppress. When looking at the totality of the circumstances, the affidavit supporting the search warrant provided a substantial basis for the issuing judge to conclude that there was a fair probability that contraband or evidence of drug trafficking would be found in the home. The affidavit was based on two anonymous tips that were sufficiently corroborated by evidence of drug trafficking found in defendant's trash. Defendant was not prejudiced by the trial court's failure to inform him of the effect of his plea. The trial court did not violate defendant's due process rights when it did not permit him to withdraw his plea because he did not receive the sentence that he thought he was going to receive and there was nothing in the record establishing that the trial court had agreed to sentence the defendant to a particular sentence.
- 2018 Ohio 956State v. West (2018)
R.C. 2953.08(G)(2), maximum sentence, R.C. 2929.14(C)(4), consecutive sentences, court costs. The trial court's imposition of a maximum sentence was supported by the record and was not contrary to law, and the record supported the trial court's imposition of consecutive sentences. Further, because the lower court retains jurisdiction to waive, suspend, or modify the payment of the costs of prosecution, we do not need to remand this case for the appellant's assignment of error relating to court costs.
- 2018 Ohio 957State v. Christian (2018)
Terry stop reasonable suspicion motion to suppress hand-to-hand drug transaction. The detectives articulated a reasonable suspicion that the defendants were engaged in criminal conduct justifying the initial encounter and detention, and therefore, the trial court erred in suppressing the evidence based on its conclusion regarding the validity of the initial stop.
- 2018 Ohio 958City of Cleveland v. Collins (2018)
OVI R.C. 4511.19 traffic stop marked lane violation ALS suspension reasonable suspicion totality of circumstances motion to suppress field sobriety tests NHTSA standards substantial compliance speedy trial tolling events R.C. 2945.72. The trooper's observing appellant's vehicle cross the marked lane on the roadway at 1:00 a.m. provided the trooper with reasonable and articulable suspicion to initiate a traffic stop. Where the trooper then discovered the driver was under an ALS suspension for a prior OVI refusal and the trooper smelled alcohol on the driver's breath, under the totality of the circumstances, the trooper reasonably suspected the driver was intoxicated and he was justified in extending the scope of the detention to perform field sobriety tests. The trooper substantially complied with NHTSA standards in administering the field sobriety tests. The appellant's motion to suppress was therefore properly denied. Appellant's right to a speedy trial was not violated due to numerous tolling events.
- 2018 Ohio 959Blain's Folding Serv., Inc. v. Cincinnati Ins. Co. (2018)
Statute of frauds third party breach of contract lost profits. A nonparty to a contract cannot raise the defense of statute of frauds because it is an affirmative defense that is personal to a party to the contract. Plaintiff's breach of contract claim for lost profits failed because it failed to prove the existence of any contract that had been breached. What plaintiff claimed was an oral, three-year contract was a series of work orders that were separately quoted and billed. Expert opinion on lost profits using the plaintiff's gross profit margin for the preceding 13 years did not establish a claim of lost profits to a reasonable degree of certainty because it did not differentiate unrelated types of work performed for different customers.
- 2018 Ohio 960Lakewood v. Dobra (2018)
Misdemeanor petty offense sentence abuse of discretion no contest plea. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in imposing a sentence within the statutory range for defendant's first-degree misdemeanor conviction. The trial court was not required to specifically state its findings related to the overriding purposes of misdemeanor sentencing under R.C. 2929.21 and the required misdemeanor sentencing factors under R.C. 2929.22.
- 2018 Ohio 961State v. Eaddie (2018)
Consecutive sentences judicial bias. Trial court did not err in imposing consecutive sentences, and sentence was not tainted by judicial bias.
- 2018 Ohio 965State v. Wright (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 966State ex rel. Quinn v. Delaware Cty. Bd. of Elections (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Mandamus-Elections-R.C. 519.12(H)-Relator's petition satisfies statutory requirements for zoning-referendum-petitions-Writ requiring board to place referendum on May 2018 ballot granted.
- 2018 Ohio 968Williams v. Schneider (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 969State v. Hakim (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 971State v. Olmstead (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 974State v. Williams (2018)
The trial court did not err in its evidentiary rulings or its handling of the witnesses at appellant's trial. The evidence was legally sufficient to convict him of the two counts of robbery under R.C. 2911.02, and the convictions were not against the manifest weight of the evidence. The assignments of error are overruled and the judgment is affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 975City of Columbus v. Reiner (2018)
Judgment affirmed. There was competent, credible evidence for the trial court to find that appellant violated Columbus City Code ("CCC') 709.03(B), Standards Relative to Noxious Weeds, and CCC 707.03(A), Standards Relative to Solid Waste. In addition, regulations protecting the health, safety and welfare of the public, may be enforced against preexisting, nonconforming uses, and appellant failed to meet the two-part test for establishing a prima facie claim for selective prosecution.
- 2018 Ohio 976State v. Wade (2018)
Defendant's convictions for multiple counts of aggravated murder, kidnapping, aggravated robbery, and aggravated burglary, with associated gang and firearm specifications, were not against the manifest weight of the evidence and were affirmed. The state on appeal conceded error in sentencing and the matter was reversed in part and remanded for resentencing.
- 2018 Ohio 977Green Tree Servicing, L.L.C. v. Asterino-Starcher (2018)
Trial court properly granted summary judgment in favor of plaintiff in foreclosure action. Appellant, as a junior lienholder, did not have standing to challenge the negotiation of the original lender's note. Although the junior lienholder, as holder of a competing lien in the subject property, had limited rights to challenge the senior lien's mortgage assignments, the state of the evidence did not create a genuine issue of material fact regarding the relative priority of liens. Trial court did err in dismissing, without notice, an FDCPA counterclaim brought by junior lienholder. Judgment reversed and cause remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 978State ex rel. Webber v. Blue Ash Care Ctr. (2018)
The magistrate did not err in finding that the record contains some evidence supporting the Industrial Commission's decision to deny relator's application for permanent total disability ("PTD") compensation. Additionally, the magistrate did not err in finding that the commission did not abuse its discretion in considering the non-medical factors in connection with denying relator's request for PTD compensation. Objections overruled writ denied.
- 2018 Ohio 979Cameron v. Univ. of Toledo (2018)
Trial court did not err in finding that the affirmative defense of actively enforcing a policy against hazing applied to plaintiff's claim for hazing under R.C. 2307.44. Court of Claims erred in finding that the University did not owe a duty of care to plaintiff.
- 2018 Ohio 980Gamble Hartshorn, L.L.C. v. Lee (2018)
Trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying Civ.R. 60(B) motion as appellant failed to demonstrate excusable neglect.
- 2018 Ohio 981State v. Hudson (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 982Nat'l City Real Estate Servs. LLC v. Frazier (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 985State v. Clay (2018)
postconviction petition nine years after trial transcripts filed in direct appeal petition denied without hearing or findings and conclusions unaware of postconviction deadline unconveyed plea offer subject matter jurisdiction state's correction of police report upon which complaint was based voir dire res judicata.
- 2018 Ohio 987State v. Ferguson (2018)
Although there was evidence presented at trial and information contained in the presentence investigation which could support an inference that defendant had a form of mental illness at some point, there was no evidence to suggest that any such illness called into question his competence to stand trial or his sanity at the time of the offense. Defendant was not denied the effective assistance of counsel, and the trial court did not abuse its discretion or commit plain error in failing to order mental health testing on its own initiative. Under the facts of this case, counts of rape and kidnapping were properly merged as allied offenses of similar import. Judgment affirmed. (Welbaum, P. J., concurring.)
- 2018 Ohio 988In re January 27, 2017 Order Releasing Grand Jury Materials (2018)
The trial court erred by ordering the release of grand jury testimony. Judgment reversed.
- 2018 Ohio 991State v. Juarez (2018)
Appellant's conviction for complicity to burglary was supported by sufficient evidence and was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. In addition, Appellant's trial counsel did not provide ineffective assistance by failing to object to the trial court's jury instruction on aiding and abetting, as the instruction was a correct statement of law on which there was no basis to object. Affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 992State v. Mattox (2018)
Defendant-appellant, following a bench trial, a jury having been waived, was convicted on seven counts of rape of a person less than 13 years of age, two counts of kidnapping, two counts of gross sexual imposition of a person under 13 years of age, and nine counts of illegal use of a minor in nudity-oriented materials or performances. The trial court properly overruled Defendant-appellant's motion to suppress because the first two interviews were non-custodial obviating the need for Miranda warnings, and, as to the last interview, Defendant-appellant validly waived his Miranda rights in advance of the interview. The trial court properly overruled Defendant-appellant's Crim.R. 29 motion for acquittal, and the trial court's verdict is supported by the weight of the evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 993State v. Norman (2018)
At a combined hearing and pursuant to the parties' plea agreement, defendant entered admissions to community control violations and pled guilty in a new case of having weapons while under disability. The trial court did not err in accepting defendant's admissions to the community control violations after informing him that he faced two years in prison, even though defendant had previously been told at the time he was originally placed on community control that he faced 30 months in prison. The trial court erred, however, in subsequently imposing 30 months in prison for the violations. Counsel did not render ineffective assistance in failing to object at the plea/admissions hearing. The trial court did not err in sentencing defendant to a maximum term of 36 months in prison for having weapons while under disability, and the imposition of consecutive sentences was not clearly and convincingly unsupported by the record. Judgment affirmed with respect to the having weapons while under disability case. Judgment concerning the community control violations is reversed in part, and the matter is remanded for the trial court to impose a sentence not to exceed two years in prison. (Hall, J., concurring in part and dissenting in part.)
- 2018 Ohio 994U.S. Natl. Bank Assn. v. Conrad (2018)
After the trial court entered a judgment and decree of foreclosure, but prior to the sheriff's sale, neighbor filed a motion to stay the sheriff's sale and a notice of a claim of interest in the foreclosed property. Trial court did not err in denying the motion to stay and in ultimately confirming the sale of the foreclosed property. Neighbor's notice and motion did not explain his interest in the property or provide any documentation to substantiate his claim. Even if construed as a motion to intervene, pursuant to Civ.R. 24, the trial court did not err in denying neighbor's motion. Neighbor's motion was filed post-judgment, he did not seek to vacate the judgment, and he failed to accompany his motion to intervene with a pleading setting forth his claim and/or defense, as required by Civ.R. 24(C). Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 996State v. Sheets (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 997State v. Gueli (2018)
Trial court erred in failing to give appellant credit for time served when sentencing appellant. Sentencing judgment reversed and remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 998State v. Hite (2018)
An 18-month prison sentence is not error, despite the stated term being the maximum possible sanction within the statutory range of R.C. 2929.14(A)(4), where the sentence is supported by the record and the trial court considers R.C. 2929.11 and 2929.12 in imposing the sentence.
- 2018 Ohio 999State v. Mick (2018)
The defendant, who was convicted of multiple sexual offenses against children and sentenced to life in prison, was denied effective assistance of trial counsel where his counsel refused to participate in any phase of the trial.
- 2018 Ohio 1000State v. Williams (2018)
Trial court erred in accepting a no contest plea when the court had not informed the defendant of the effect of the plea as required by Crim.R. 11(E).
- 2018 Ohio 1002State v. Blom (2018)
Appellant's untimely, successive postconviction petition was barred by res judicata. Appeal rights Crim.R. 32 R.C. 2953.23 void ineffective assistance of counsel.
- 2018 Ohio 1003State v. Elmore (2018)
Trial court did not err in sentencing appellant. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1005State v. Panaro (2018)
reasonable suspicion, traffic violation, alcohol, turn signal
- 2018 Ohio 1006Pietrangelo v. Avon Lake (2018)
contempt, discovery sanction, prior appeal, law of the case, abuse of discretion
- 2018 Ohio 1007State v. Wolfenbarger (2018)
The trial court is required to notify a defendant of post release control during sentencing.
- 2018 Ohio 1009State v. Marcum (2018)
State proved defendant's identity in robberies where several witnesses identified the defendant as the person depicted in security camera footage by their familiarity with his appearance, gait, and mannerisms. Trial court properly found that police could reasonably rely on defendant's wife's apparent authority to consent to search the defendant's home where they understood the wife left the home temporarily because of an argument, wife left her possessions at the home, and wife knew how to enter home despite not having a key. Error to admit evidence of other bad acts. However, the error did not raise to the level of plain error because the testimony was brief, not focused on by the parties, and substantial other evidence in the record supported the defendant's convictions. Counsel was not ineffective for failing to object to the improper evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 1011Rarden v. Ewen (2018)
Trial court's decision denying a motion to vacate a void judgment was appropriate where the trial court had jurisdiction over the matter and the parties, and the order dismissing the case was not void.
- 2018 Ohio 1012State v. Harris (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1013State v. Gingerich (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1014State v. Lilly (2018)
Trial court did not err in sentencing defendant to aggregate 60-month prison term.
- 2018 Ohio 1015State v. Pettiford (2018)
The trial court correctly overruled appellant's motion to suppress where officers seized evidence in plain view and entered appellant's home because of exigent circumstances where officer safety, safety of others, and possible evidence destruction created probable cause of an emergency situation.
- 2018 Ohio 1016State v. Powih (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1017Large v. Lilley (2018)
Trespass Statute of Limitations Waiver
- 2018 Ohio 1018Armstrong v. Lakes Golf & Country Club, Inc. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1019State ex rel. Dunkle v. Marcelain (2018)
Mandamus Municipal Court Complaint Indictment
- 2018 Ohio 1020Windsor v. Bristow (2018)
Stalking civil protection order/Consent order
- 2018 Ohio 1023State v. Martin (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - R.C. 2901.11(A) jurisdiction over criminal offense commission of element within Ohio applicable to citizen or noncitizen jurisdiction of county court over traffic offense testimony of citing officer sufficient to establish jurisdiction and elements.
- 2018 Ohio 1024State v. Thomas (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - violation of community-control sanctions due process failure to afford allocution right Crim.R. 32(A)(1) court must afford offender opportunity for allocution at a community-control revocation hearing second sentencing hearing reversed for resentencing.
- 2018 Ohio 1025Bridges v. King (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - App.R. 4(A) thirty-day rule Civ.R. 58(B) untimely appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 1027State v. Flenner (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - Tampering with evidence sufficiency "destruction" of evidence of rape seminal fluid manifest weight credibility of victim's testimony logical reason for inconsistent statements allied offenses of similar import rape and kidnapping separate animus substantial period between onset of kidnapping and first rape substantial risk of harm separate from rape no merger.
- 2018 Ohio 1028State v. Thorn (2018)
interstate agreement on detainers, theft, sufficiency, jail credit, recognizance bond.
- 2018 Ohio 1029Herron v. Bramel (2018)
vexatious litigator, intent, summary judgment.
- 2018 Ohio 1031State v. Churchill (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1032State v. Bush (2018)
Consecutive Sentences
- 2018 Ohio 1034Wendt v. Dickerson (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1035Evans v. Ohio Dep't of Rehab. & Corr. (2018)
The trial court did not err in finding that appellant's complaint presented a medical claim as his claims focused on the quality of the medical treatment he received. In addition, the trial court did not err in granting judgment to appellee because appellant failed to present any expert testimony to establish the standard of care and failed to provide a transcript of the proceeding before the magistrate or an affidavit of evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1036State v. Purnell (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying Purnell's pre-sentence motion to withdraw his guilty plea.
- 2018 Ohio 1038Appenzeller v. Dept. of Rehab. & Corr. (2018)
Court of Claims did not abuse its discretion by denying motion for relief from judgment under Civ.R. 60(B). The provision of the local rules of court cited by the appellant relating to case numbers did not substantiate appellant's claim that sentencing entries attached to affidavit in support of motion for summary judgment were fraudulent. Therefore, the Court of Claims did not abuse its discretion by concluding that appellant failed to demonstrate he was entitled to relief from the entry granting summary judgment.
- 2018 Ohio 1039Roberts v. Jones Lang LaSalle Ams., Inc. (2018)
CONTRACTS: The trial court did not err in granting judgment in favor of defendant former employer on plaintiff real-estate broker's claim for breach of contract for failing to pay him a commission on two leases that neither party negotiated. Where the terms of the parties' severance agreement provided that if defendant did not receive a commission, plaintiff was not entitled to a commission and that defendant had the authority to determine whether to collect or enforce a claim for a commission, defendant did not breach the agreement by failing to pursue a claim for a commission or by not paying a commission to plaintiff. [But see DISSENT: The severance agreement prohibited defendant from waiving plaintiff's commission, and defendant's refusal to collect the commission constitutes a waiver of the commission in breach of the agreement.]
- 2018 Ohio 1040State v. Williams (2018)
SEX OFFENSES - FAILURE TO VERIFY - R.C. 2950.06: Where the sheriff mailed the seven-day warning letter required by R.C. 2950.06(G) a day late resulting in defendant having only six days to verify his address, and not the required seven, the sheriff failed to strictly comply with the statute and defendant cannot be prosecuted for failure to verify a current address.
- 2018 Ohio 1041Hughes v. Deutsche Bank Natl. Trust Co. (2018)
foreclosure - default judgment - Civ.R 60(B) - jurisdiction - void -voidable
- 2018 Ohio 1046State v. Clark (2018)
Motion to suppress/Urinalysis/Compliance with regulations
- 2018 Ohio 1047State v. Brown (2018)
bond forfeiture - good cause - impossibility
- 2018 Ohio 1048State v. Garrison (2018)
Confrontational clause - Ineffective assistance of cousel - aggravated burglary - manifest weight - maximum sentence
- 2018 Ohio 1052In re A.J. (2018)
Appellant appeals from the juvenile court's order granting permanent custody of his son to Montgomery County Children Services (MCCS). The record supports the juvenile court's conclusion that an award of permanent custody to MCCS is in the child's best interest. The juvenile court did not abuse its discretion by denying Appellant's motion for a continuance. Finally, trial counsel's representation, even if deficient, did not, on this record, prejudice Appellant. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1053Howard v. HCR Manorcare, Inc. (2018)
The trial court did not err in denying Appellants' motion for judgment on the pleadings, as Appellants admitted liability for wrongful death, and any alleged prior error with respect to Appellee's Civ.R. 10(D)(2) affidavit is irrelevant. By admitting liability, Appellants waived any error and are precluded from raising this error on appeal. Furthermore, compliance with Civ.R. 10(D)(2) does not pertain to a court's subject matter jurisdiction and can be waived. Appellants are also precluded from raising issues regarding the jury interrogatories and verdict form, as Appellants told the court its instructions were correct. Even if this issue were considered on a plain error basis, there was no error that would warrant reversal. Additionally, the trial court did not err in failing to include an instruction on negligence and proximate cause, as there was no basis for such an instruction. Appellee's closing argument was also not prejudicial, and the court did not err in failing to give a curative instruction in connection with one isolated comment that Appellee's counsel immediately corrected. Concerning Appellee's cross-assignments of error, the trial court did err in granting a motion for judgment on the pleadings in connection with the survival claims of the decedent. Based on the content of the pleadings, Appellants' corporate defendants were not medical providers, and the survival claims were also not "medical claims" under R.C. 2305.113(E)(3). Finally, the trial court did not abuse its discretion when it refused to grant a continuance so that Appellee could conduct discovery regarding his motion for prejudgment interest. Appellee would have been well aware of his right to conduct discovery, but failed to even mention discovery until the day before the scheduled non-oral evidentiary hearing. Affirmed in part and Reversed in part, and remanded for further proceedings solely on the survival claims.
- 2018 Ohio 1054Dibert v. Carpenter (2018)
The trial court erred in filing an order requesting that Appellant show cause why he should not be held in contempt for failing to pay court costs, and in filing an entry reflecting that a show cause hearing for contempt had been held. Because court costs are a civil debt, the trial court could not file a show cause order, but instead was required to use only the methods provided for the collection of civil judgments. Reversed in part and remanded for further proceedings. Affirmed as to denial of a motion to correct the record and a motion seeking recusal of the trial judge.
- 2018 Ohio 1055State v. Moughler (2018)
Defendant appeals from the revocation of his community control and the imposition of consecutive jail sentences. Because defendant has completely served the sentences imposed, the appeal is moot. Appeal dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 1056Ocwen Loan Servicing, L.L.C. v. Malish (2018)
The appealed foreclosure order is a final, appealable order. The award of lawful costs and expenses incurred to enforce the note and mortgage without a specific amount is ministerial and does not prevent the order from being final and appealable. The trial court did not err by overruling Appellants' motion to strike the payment histories attached to Appellee's affidavit supporting its motion for summary judgment. The documents were admissible under the business records hearsay exception in Evid.R. 803(6). The trial court did not err by rendering a summary judgment of foreclosure for Appellee. There is no genuine issue as to whether Appellee complied with the condition precedent to foreclosure that it send Appellants a written notice of default. And there is no genuine issue as to the amount of principal due. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1058State v. Tamas (2018)
Because appellant has completed his sentence for his misdemeanor convictions and because he has presented no evidence from which this Court could conclude he has suffered a collateral legal disability or loss of civil rights, we dismiss appellant's appeal as moot. We therefore need not address the merits of appellant's five assignments of error.
- 2018 Ohio 1059U.S. Home Ownership, L.L.C. v. Collin L. Young (2018)
The trial court, in this mortgage foreclosure cause of action, granted summary judgment in favor of the Plaintiff-appellee. The trial court correctly concluded that Plaintiff-appellee established that it has possession of the note and mortgage and that it had such possession when the complaint was filed. Plaintiff-appellee, therefore, had standing to file the complaint. The trial court, however, erred in concluding there is not a genuine dispute of fact concerning Plaintiff-appellee's satisfaction of the mortgage's notice condition precedent. Finally, the trial court, when applying R.C. 1303.38, erred in concluding there is not a genuine issue of fact concerning whether Plaintiff-appellee may rely upon the lost mortgage modification agreement. Judgment reversed and remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 1060State v. Carberry (2018)
JUVENILE - BIND OVER - PROCEDURE/RULES - SEX OFFENSES - CONSTITUTIONAL LAW/CRIMINAL - COUNSEL - JAIL-TIME CREDIT: The juvenile court did not abuse its discretion in transferring defendant's three gross-sexual-imposition cases to the common pleas court, and trial counsel was not ineffective in that regard, where the juvenile court ordered a mental evaluation pursuant to Juv.R. 30, held a hearing, discussed on the record the factors weighing in favor of transferring jurisdiction, and recorded the factors on a worksheet attached to the entry transferring jurisdiction: the juvenile court complied with all the requirements for discretionary transfer, and the court's amenability determination was supported by the record and evinced a sound reasoning process. The common pleas court did not violate defendant's constitutional right to due process or right to be free from cruel and unusual punishment by classifying him as a Tier II sex offender under R.C. Chapter 2950 after defendant had pleaded guilty to gross sexual imposition, and trial counsel was not ineffective in that regard: once defendant had been properly bound over to the adult court, his classification under the adult sex-offender-classification scheme did not violate his constitutional rights. The cause must be remanded, when the trial court did not, as required by R.C. 2967.19(B)(1)(g)(i) and 2967.191, determine and include in the sentencing entry the proper amount of jail-time credit to which defendant is entitled.
- 2018 Ohio 1061State v. Martin (2018)
IDENTIFICATION - ATTEMPTED MURDER - TAMPERING WITH EVIDENCE - EVIDENCE - CONSTITUTIONAL LAW/CRIMINAL - COUNSEL - PROSECUTOR - SENTENCING: Three witnesses' identifications of defendant during one-person arrest-scene show-ups were reliable under the totality of the circumstances where they had a good opportunity to view defendant during the commission of the crimes, they provided consistent and thorough descriptions of him to the police and to the 911 operator, they were certain of their identifications at the time, and they identified the defendant within 30 minutes after the crimes. R.C. 2933.83 is limited to live lineups. Defendant's convictions for attempted murder and tampering with the evidence were supported by sufficient evidence and were not contrary to the manifest weight of the evidence where the state presented testimony from three eyewitnesses who had seen defendant attack an unarmed man with a butcher knife cutting him on the head, face, and torso one of those eyewitnesses followed defendant, alerting police to his whereabouts, and watched as the police took him into custody and the police immediately recovered the knife used in the attack hidden underneath a vehicle near where defendant had been taken into custody. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying defendant's motion for a mistrial based on prosecutorial misconduct during closing argument, because the prosecutor merely responded to defense counsel's arguments and did not improperly shift the burden of proof to defendant. Defendant's claims that his two trial attorneys had rendered ineffective assistance by failing to adequately prepare for trial and failing to seek a continuance to determine whether he wanted to testify were not supported by the record where defendant had indicated his confidence in his attorneys' representation, and the record shows that defendant's failure to testify was the result of his own knowing and intelligent decision. The trial court's imposition of consecutive sentences was not contrary to law where the trial court orally stated at the sentencing hearing and journalized in the sentencing entry the findings required by R.C. 2929.14(C)(4), and the record supported those findings.
- 2018 Ohio 1062City of Blue Ash v. Price (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW/CRIMINAL - CONSTITUTIONAL LAW/CRIMINAL: Where the trial court found defendant not guilty of a violation of a traffic ordinance after a criminal trial, the court of appeals has discretionary authority under R.C. 2945.67(A) and App.R. 5(C) to review substantive legal rulings made in the criminal case, so long as the verdict itself is not appealed. The trial court erred in determining that a municipal ordinance prohibiting toy vehicles in streets violated defendant's constitutional right to travel: although a citizen has a fundamental right to intrastate travel, an ordinance which burdens a single mode of transportation, here toy vehicles, does not implicate the right to travel. The trial court erred in determining that a municipal ordinance prohibiting toy vehicles in streets was void for vagueness as applied to defendant's conduct in riding a motorized skateboard: although the toy-vehicle ordinance does not specifically mention motorized skateboards among the prohibited modes of transportation on streets, nothing in the ordinance suggests that the prohibition is limited to human-powered modes of transportation, and because the ordinance prohibits riding a "skateboard" in the street, a motorized skateboard could be considered a "skateboard" or a "similar device."
- 2018 Ohio 1063State v. Murphy (2018)
CONSTITUTIONAL LAW/CRIMINAL - RIGHT TO COUNSEL - WAIVER: Defendant's waiver of trial counsel was valid: the trial court's inquiry to determine whether defendant fully understood and intelligently relinquished his constitutional right to counsel with respect to a prosecution for canoeing without a life jacket aboard the vessel was sufficient where defendant had told the court of his experience in the court system, expressed his appreciation of the charges and told the court of his defense, and he further acknowledged that he was facing a jail term, knew the role of counsel, and had some appreciation of the hazards inherent in self-representation.
- 2018 Ohio 1065Roubanes-Luke v. Roubanes (2018)
The trial court erred in concluding that a party's false testimony regarding his annual income constituted a fraud upon the court justifying relief from judgment under Civ.R. 60(B)(5). The trial court properly found that a party's misstatements regarding the value of a marital asset did not qualify as a fraud upon the court warranting relief from judgment under Civ.R. 60(B)(5).
- 2018 Ohio 1066State ex rel. Pritt v. Indus. Comm. (2018)
Because some evidence in the record supports the commission finding relator is medically capable of engaging in sustained remunerative employment of a sedentary nature and the relevant nonmedical disability factors do not preclude relator from currently engaging in such employment, the fact that the commission incorrectly relied on relator's non-allowed conditions as a basis for denying PTD in a separate portion of the order does not constitute grounds for the granting of a writ of mandamus. Writ denied.
- 2018 Ohio 1067State ex rel. Brust v. Mohr (2018)
Inmate was not entitled to a writ to change facts in his Ohio Parole Board Information Sheet.
- 2018 Ohio 1072Hadler v. Thompson (2018)
Failure to enter an appearance in a foreclosure case made setting aside the judgment through use of Civ.R. 60(B) inappropriate.
- 2018 Ohio 1073State v. Rogers (2018)
Judgment affirmed. Because the indictment was not defective, appellant's claim that the trial court lacked subject-matter jurisdiction is without merit. Moreover, as appellant's conviction was not void, res judicata bars any claims that appellant could have raised in the trial court before conviction or on appeal after conviction.
- 2018 Ohio 1076State v. Persinger (2018)
Post Release Control Nunc Pro Tunc Necessary to Correct
- 2018 Ohio 1078State v. Lynch (2018)
Rape kidnapping preindictment delay actual prejudice prosecutorial misconduct ineffective assistance of counsel double jeopardy plain error Crim.R. 52 mistrial manifest necessity. Appellant failed to demonstrate actual prejudice resulting from the delay in prosecution, and thus, the trial court did not err in denying appellant's motions to dismiss for preindictment delay. The prosecutor's comments during closing arguments did not constitute prosecutorial misconduct. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in determining that there was a manifest necessity to declare a mistrial. The state's subsequent prosecution was not barred by the Double Jeopardy Clause. Appellant was not denied his constitutional right to the effective assistance of counsel.
- 2018 Ohio 1080Blisswood Village Home Owners Assn. v. Genesis Real Estate Holdings Group, L.L.C. (2018)
Foreclosure confirmation of sale R.C. 2329.45 moot attorney fees. Appellant property owner's consolidated appeals from the order of foreclosure and the order confirming the sale of the property are moot. Appellant never sought a stay of the foreclosure proceedings nor a stay of the distribution of the proceeds from the sale prior to the order of confirmation. The property has been sold to a third party and the proceeds of the sale have been distributed. Thus, there is no available relief and the appeal is moot. The trial court did not abuse its discretion by awarding attorney fees to the foreclosing home owners association under R.C. 5311.081(A)(1)(b).
- 2018 Ohio 1081State v. Thomas (2018)
Guilty plea robbery R.C. 2905.02 ineffective assistance of counsel motion to withdraw guilty plea Crim.R. 11 manifest injustice Crim.R. 32.1 allied offenses of similar import R.C. 2941.25 plain error. Appellant was not denied his constitutional right to the effective assistance of counsel. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in failing to vacate appellant's guilty plea sua sponte, nor by denying appellant's postsentence motion to withdraw his guilty plea without a hearing. The robbery and abduction counts were not allied offenses of similar import, and thus, the trial court did not err by imposing consecutive sentences on these counts.
- 2018 Ohio 1083State v. Passafiume (2018)
Crim.R. 32.1 manifest injustice ineffective assistance of counsel guilty plea withdrawal noncitizen client deportation consequences Padilla v. Kentucky new rule retroactive application. Because Padilla v. Kentucky announced a new rule in Ohio regarding the duty of trial counsel to advise a noncitizen client of deportation consequences at a plea hearing, it cannot be applied retroactively to convictions that had become final before March 31, 2010, when Padilla was decided. Thus, appellant cannot rely on Padilla to establish counsel's deficient performance in the plea proceedings from 2009. Additionally, the record demonstrates the trial court fully complied with Crim.R. 11 and appellant knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily entered guilty pleas. Thus, appellant has not demonstrated that counsel's performance resulted in a fundamental flaw in the plea proceedings.
- 2018 Ohio 1084N. Olmstead v. Rock (2018)
North Olmsted Ordinances 1363.105, 1363.302.1, 1363.302.2 sufficiency first- degree misdemeanor sentencing R.C. 2929.25. Defendant's convictions for failing to remove rubbish and discarded items from her yard, and failing to comply with a notice of violations were supported by sufficient evidence. Defendant's sentence was not erroneous.
- 2018 Ohio 1086State v. Buchanan (2018)
Crim.R. 29/motion for acquittal manifest weight prejudicial error plain error allied offenses R.C. 2929.14(C)(4)/consecutive sentences R.C. 2929.14(B)(2)(a)/repeat violent offender. The trial court's denial of appellant's motion for acquittal was proper. The state provided sufficient evidence to sustain the element of serious physical harm the jury had the task of determining how much weight to give to the victim's in-court identification of appellant. The kidnapping and rape offenses were separate crimes with a separate animus and therefore not allied offenses. The trial court considered and stated its findings pursuant to R.C. 2929.14(C)(4) regarding consecutive sentences, and found that appellant qualified as a repeat violent offender under R.C. 2929.14(B)(2)(a). Appellant's sentence is supported by the record and is not contrary to law.
- 2018 Ohio 1087In re Invenstigation into the November 22, 2014 Shooting Death of Tamir Rice (2018)
Petition for release grand jury transcripts Crim.R. 6(E) public interest particularized need that outweighs need for secrecy. Trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying petitioners' petition for the release of grand jury transcripts and exhibits. Petitioners' request for disclosure was not for a purpose authorized under Crim.R. 6(E) and petitioners did not demonstrate a particularized need for disclosure that outweighs the need for secrecy.
- 2018 Ohio 1093State v. Grooms (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1095Huffman v. Vill. of Newburgh Heights (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1098State v. Martin (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1105State v. Bradshaw (2018)
Tampering with evidence-sufficient evidence showed that defendant knew of official investigation or likely investigation when officers arrested his for parole violations and informed defendant of consequences of carrying contraband into jail trafficking in heroin-sufficient evidence showed that defendant trafficked in heroin by admitting that he intended to deliver heroin to third party possession of heroin-sufficient evidence showed that defendant possessed heroin when officer saw item in defendant's hand and saw defendant throw item in trash can.
- 2018 Ohio 1107Portage Cnty. Bd. of Developmental Disabilities v. Portage Cnty. Educators Ass'n for Developmental Disabilities (2018)
CIVIL - arbitration exceed authority language of the agreement ambiguous extrinsic evidence employee's favor application to vacate upheld construed in context of the evidence drawn from the essence of the agreement no error in confirming award.
- 2018 Ohio 1108State v. Weideman (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - notice of appeal taken from an entry in another defendant's case matter remains pending before the trial court no final, appealable order lack of jurisdiction appeal dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 1109State v. Hogue (2018)
Trial court did not err in denying petition for post-conviction relief without a hearing.
- 2018 Ohio 1110In re M.M. (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion by imposing the adult portion of the defendant-appellant's serious-youthful-offender-dispositional sentence.
- 2018 Ohio 1112In Re Eisaman of Eisaman (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion by denying petitioner-appellant's petition to disinter her deceased brother's remains.
- 2018 Ohio 1114State v. Huddleston (2018)
The defendant-appellant was not denied the effective assistance of counsel. Further, plain error is not present in the trial court's jury instructions and in the admission of the defendant-appellant's recorded statements. Judgment Affirmed
- 2018 Ohio 1115State v. Singletary (2018)
Trial court did not err by denying appellant's motion to dismiss his indictment for failure to register based on arguments that Megan's Law was unconstitutional.
- 2018 Ohio 1116State v. Scott (2018)
The trial court did not err by sentencing appellant to six years in prison after she pled guilty to single counts of robbery and aggravated possession of drugs where the trial court's decision finding appellant was not amenable to community control sanctions, of which placement in a community based correctional facility would be a component, was supported by the record given the serious nature of the offenses, coupled with the serious psychological harm suffered by the victim, fully justified the trial court's decision.
- 2018 Ohio 1117In re M.M.-P. (2018)
The trial court erred by adjudicating the child dependent by taking judicial notice of a prior adjudication. The prior adjudication was dismissed, and thus it was as if no adjudication ever existed. The trial court was required to hold a hearing and take evidence to support by clear and convincing evidence an adjudication of dependency.
- 2018 Ohio 1118Roberts v. Boehl (2018)
Plaintiff in personal injury action appeals decision granting summary judgment in favor of defendant who claimed to have fallen unconscious while operating motor vehicle before it impacted plaintiff's vehicle. Court found defendant proved that the accident was the result of defendant's unforeseeable and sudden medical emergency while operating his vehicle. There were genuine issues of fact for trial as to whether the defendant's medical emergency was foreseeable where the defendant testified that several years prior he had experienced the same sensation of lightheadedness before falling unconscious while driving and causing an accident.
- 2018 Ohio 1119State v. Walters (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1120State Ex Rel. Deem v. Vill. of Pomeroy (2018)
Civil: tort liability negligence political subdivision immunity R.C. 2944.02 R.C. 2944.03 summary judgment.
- 2018 Ohio 1121Gambino v. Pugh (2018)
summary judgment, negligence, inmate, access to the court, service, court-appointed attorney.
- 2018 Ohio 1124State v. Grajales (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1127State v. Saunders (2018)
CRIMINAL - Appellant's appeal is dismissed in part because it is untimely and the remaining part of his appeal addressing the denial of his motion to withdraw his pleas is without merit.
- 2018 Ohio 1128State v. Henry (2018)
Appellant's convictions for assault and obstructing official business were supported by sufficient evidence and were not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 1129State v. Wallace (2018)
POSTCONVICTION-JURISDICTION-ALLIED OFFENSES-INEFFECTIVE COUNSEL-POSTRELEASE CONTROL: Defendant's postconviction allied-offenses and ineffective-counsel claims were subject to dismissal for lack of jurisdiction: the claims were reviewable under R.C. 2953.21 et seq., governing the proceedings on a petition for postconviction relief, because they sought relief based on alleged constitutional violations during the proceedings leading to defendant's convictions, R.C. 2953.21(A)(1) but the postconviction statutes did not confer jurisdiction to entertain those claims, because they did not satisfy R.C. 2953.21(A)(2)'s time restrictions or R.C. 2953.23's jurisdictional requirements for entertaining a late postconviction claim and the claims, even if demonstrated, would not have rendered the convictions void. The common pleas court erred in failing to correct that part of defendant's aggravated-robbery sentence that was void because it was not imposed in conformity with the statutory mandates concerning postrelease control: the postrelease-control notification provided at sentencing, that defendant was subject to postrelease-control supervision for "up to five years," did not adequately inform him that postrelease control was for a mandatory five-year period and the language included in the judgment of conviction stating that he was "subject to the post release [sic] control supervision of R.C. 2967.28" was inadequate to inform him of the duration or mandatory nature of his postrelease control.
- 2018 Ohio 1130State v. Jones (2018)
AGGRAVATED ROBBERY - WEAPONS - FIREARM - EVIDENCE - WITNESSES - PROSECUTOR - COUNSEL - HEARSAY: Where a witness was cooperative until days before trial, the state was not required to follow the procedures set forth in R.C. 2939.26 before the trial court could find that the state had used reasonable efforts to secure the witness's appearance and declare the witness unavailable. The trial court did not abuse its discretion when it found that the state had used reasonable efforts to secure a witness's appearance before declaring that witness unavailable where officers had tried to contact the witness through different phone numbers, social media, and her mother, and the witness no longer lived at her last known address. Although using analogies to attempt to explain reasonable doubt is discouraged, the prosecutor's comparison of reasonable doubt to putting together a jigsaw puzzle did not prejudice defendant where the trial court properly instructed the jury on reasonable doubt. Defendant was not prejudiced by trial counsel's failure to offer to stipulate to his prior conviction, which constituted an element of the charge of having a weapon while under a disability, where the failure to offer to stipulate did not change the outcome of the trial. Testimony of a police officer about speaking to third parties did not violate the prohibition in State v. Ricks, 136 Ohio St.3d 256, 2013-Ohio-3712, 995 N.E.2d 1181, where the officer never testified to what the third parties actually told him. The evidence presented by the state, including that defendant had pointed a firearm at the cashier and demanded money, implying that he would shoot the cashier if the cashier failed to comply with his demand, was sufficient to show that the firearm was operable. For purposes of defendant's aggravated-robbery conviction, the cashier of the store defendant robbed was the "owner" of the money in the cash register and the store's inventory.
- 2018 Ohio 1132State v. Capps (2018)
Manifest weight - sufficiency
- 2018 Ohio 1134State v. York (2018)
PRC violation - sentence completed - moot
- 2018 Ohio 1135State v. Marcum (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1136State v. Kopchak (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1138State ex rel. McCabe v. State (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1139State v. Ash (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1142State v. Chapman (2018)
sufficiency-of-the-evidence analysis does not apply to affirmative defenses - absent plain error, appellant cannot raise new grounds for exclusion of evidence on appeal
- 2018 Ohio 1145State v. Lehman (2018)
manifest weight - R.C. 2911.12(A)(2) - burglary - likely to be present
- 2018 Ohio 1146State v. Walker (2018)
Motion for sentencing, relief from dormant judgment, void sentences, voidable sentencing errors, direct appeal, res judicata
- 2018 Ohio 1148State v. Harding (2018)
Amendment to criminal complaint - change in name and identity of offense.
- 2018 Ohio 1151The State Ex Rel. Stevens v. Fairfield County Board of Elections. (2018)
Mandamus-Elections-R.C. 3513.05 and 3517.03-County board of elections abused its discretion in refusing to certify relator's name for placement on the May 2018 primary-election ballot-Writ granted.
- 2018 Ohio 1152State ex rel. Heavey v. Husted (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Mandamus-Elections-R.C. 3513.05-Joint candidates for governor and lieutenant governor did not show by clear and convincing evidence a legal right to have their names placed on the ballot-Writ denied.
- 2018 Ohio 1154State v. Davis (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1155State v. Clark (2018)
Imposition of remainder of community control - failure to calculate sentence
- 2018 Ohio 1156State v. Skaggs (2018)
Criminal: constitutional speedy trial rights Sixth Amendment to the United States Constitution Section 10, Article I of the Ohio Constitution.
- 2018 Ohio 1157State v. Dawson (2018)
Criminal: felony sentencing R.C. 2953.08(G)(2) R.C. 2929.11 R.C. 2929.12.
- 2018 Ohio 1158Busy Bee Nursery & Preschool, Inc. v. Ohio Dep't of Job & Family Servs. (2018)
Trial court did not err when it granted motion to dismiss.
- 2018 Ohio 1159JDS So Cal, Ltd. v. Dept. of Natural Resources (2018)
The trial court erred in (1) granting summary judgment to plaintiff on its claim for breach of contract and (2) denying defendant summary judgment on that same claim.
- 2018 Ohio 1160State ex rel. Owens v. Indus. Comm. (2018)
Mandamus denied no due process violation where relator had notice and participated in multiple levels of administrative review. Doctor report is some evidence supporting the commission's decision.
- 2018 Ohio 1161State ex rel.l Williams v. Indus. Comm. (2018)
Industrial Commission did not apply improper standard in determining issue of voluntary abandonment. Relator's objections overruled and request for writ of mandamus denied.
- 2018 Ohio 1162State v. Collins (2018)
Juvenile who shot a thirteen year old was properly bound over to adult court. Juvenile court, in following the applicable statutes, did not have to follow the psychologist's recommendation to retain jurisdiction.
- 2018 Ohio 1164Beauchamp v. Petit (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in finding the decision of the Ohio Bureau of Motor Vehicles cancelling appellant's license, pursuant to R.C. 4507.19, was supported by reliable, probative, and substantial evidence and was in accordance with the law. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1165Starner v. Merchants Holding, L.L.C. (2018)
Because appellant failed to present meritorious defense, the trial court did not abuse its discretion by denying appellant's Civ.R. 60(B) motion for relief from judgment on cognovit note
- 2018 Ohio 1166State v. Robinson (2018)
The trial court did not err in denying appellant's motion for new trial and modification of verdict/sentence. The motion was untimely and appellant did not present clear and convincing evidence that he was unavoidably prevented from filing his motion as required by Crim.R. 33(B). Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1167Chojnacki v. Mohr (2018)
declaratory judgment - parole eligibility date - summary judgment - justiciable controversy - rights and obligations
- 2018 Ohio 1168Molnar v. Green (2018)
motion to dismiss, de novo review, political subdivision immunity, reviewing court
- 2018 Ohio 1169Clark v. Corwin (2018)
settlement agreement, motion to enforce, sufficient evidence, abuse of discretion, sanctions, post-settlement interest, due process
- 2018 Ohio 1170Farakhan v. Wade (2018)
Civ.R. 55(A) - application for default judgment - premature - nullity - default arises - 28 days to file answer - Civ.R. 12(A)
- 2018 Ohio 1172State v. Miller (2018)
R.C. 2945.42 - spousal privilege - harmless beyond a reasonable doubt - ineffective assistance of counsel - flight instruction - overwhelming evidence of guilt - safecracking
- 2018 Ohio 1174Talarek v. Walls (2018)
exhaustion of administrative remedies doctrine, R.C. 5715.19, foreclosure
- 2018 Ohio 1175State v. Walters (2018)
rape, gross sexual imposition, child sexual abuse, manifest weight, competency, mistrial, outside communication with juror, hearsay
- 2018 Ohio 1176State v. West (2018)
motion to withdraw, timing, pre-sentence, post-sentence, hearing, App.R. 16(A)(7)
- 2018 Ohio 1180State v. Hawthorne (2018)
Crim.R. 30(A)/jury instruction ineffective assistance of counsel prosecutorial misconduct joinder moot. The trial court erred to appellant's prejudice where it informed appellant that he had to testify in order to advance a self-defense claim.
- 2018 Ohio 1182State v. W.C. (2018)
R.C. 2953.52, sealing records, acquittal, meaningful appellate review Trial court failed to set forth in the record its findings indicating the requisite interests of the defendant and the state, and weighing those interests against each other for this court to engage in meaningful appellate review of the decision to deny the appellant's motion to seal his arrest record following an acquittal.
- 2018 Ohio 1183Tanglewood Shopping Ctr., L.L.C. v. Riser Foods Co. (2018)
Summary judgment commercial lease unjust enrichment trespass. The trial court did not err in granting summary judgment in favor of defendant-appellee because there is no genuine issue of material fact as to whether the amended lease governs the entire expansion.
- 2018 Ohio 1184State ex rel. Branch v. Pitts (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1185State v. Cleveland (2018)
Discretionary transfer of jurisdiction, R.C. 2152.10(D), victim impact, seriousness of crime, R.C. 2152.12, transfer factors. The Juvenile Court's decision to transfer the appellant to the trial court for adult prosecution did not constitute an abuse of discretion. The trial court fully considered and stated for the record the statutory factors supporting and opposing transfer for adult adjudication and concluded that, based on the totality of the circumstances, the seriousness of the crime supported the transfer.
- 2018 Ohio 1186Kenney v. Cleveland (2018)
Breach of contract promissory estoppel statute of limitations governmental immunity summary judgment. The court did not err by granting defendant's summary judgment motion as plaintiff's claims were barred by the statute of limitations.
- 2018 Ohio 1188State v. Crawford (2018)
Date of indictment Megan's Law S.B. 2 Adam Walsh Act H.B. 86 R.C. 2929.11 and 2929.14/minimum and consecutive sentences. The trial court proceeding on the indictment was proper. The indictment on Count 1 stated that the offense was alleged to have occurred on or about December 22, 2004. Appellant committed one of his offenses prior to the enactment of the Adam Walsh Act and was therefore not constitutionally subject to its requirements. R.C. 158(B) allowed appellant the sentencing benefit of a reduced sentence where appellant had not yet been sentenced before the enactment of H.B. 86. The trial court considered the factors and the principles and purposes for sentencing and the trial court made the necessary findings to impose consecutive sentences. Appellant's consecutive sentences were not contrary to law.
- 2018 Ohio 1190State v. Bryan (2018)
Death penalty motion for leave motion for a new mitigation trial Hurst untimely Crim.R. 33 postconviction independently legally correct App.R. 12(A)(1)(c). In a death penalty case, trial court's denial of defendant's Crim.R. 33 motion for leave to file a motion for a new mitigation trial, which was premised on Hurst v. Florida, 577 U.S. __, 136 S.Ct. 616, 193 L.Ed.2d 504 (2016), was upheld because the motion for leave was untimely. Although the trial court incorrectly determined the motion should have been filed under R.C. 2953.23, when Crim.R. 33 procedures for a new trial exist independently from the procedure for postconviction relief, an appellate court may affirm the decision of the trial court as long as it is legally correct on other grounds.
- 2018 Ohio 1191State v. Brooks (2018)
Consecutive sentences, Eighth Amendment rights, res judicata, nunc pro tunc. The appellant claims that the trial court erred in its consecutive sentencing and violating his Eighth Amendment rights are barred by res judicata because he could have argued both claims in his previous appeal to this court. This matter is remanded to the trial court for the limited purpose of issuing a nunc pro tunc entry to reflect what actually occurred in open court.
- 2018 Ohio 1192State v. Huffman (2018)
Agreed sentence plea agreement accept reject expressly concurrent consecutive recommended sentence due process. Appellant's sentence was vacated, and the case was remanded for the trial court to resentence appellant under the plea agreement or to allow appellant to withdraw his guilty plea. Agreed sentences are distinct from recommended sentences. Where a plea agreement includes an agreed sentence, it is incumbent upon the trial court to expressly accept or reject that agreement. Moreover, due process requires the trial court to put the defendant on notice of the possibility that it could impose a longer prison term than negotiated under a plea agreement before accepting a guilty plea. Because no appeal was taken in a separate case for which a joint sentencing hearing was held, any challenge to the imposition of consecutive sentences in that case could not be addressed.
- 2018 Ohio 1193State v. Echevarria (2018)
Felonious assault self-defense jury instructions R.C. 2901.09(B) castle doctrine duty to retreat R.C. 2901.05(B) presumption of self-defense prejudicial error manifest weight of the evidence. Trial court did not abuse its discretion or otherwise err in failing to specifically instruct the jury that defendant had no duty to retreat based on the castle doctrine where trial court did not instruct the jury that defendant must prove that she did not violate a duty to retreat in order to find that she acted in self-defense. Trial court did not abuse its discretion or otherwise err in failing to give jury instruction regarding presumption of self-defense where it was undisputed that victim entered the defendant's residence at defendant's invitation. Defendant's felonious assault convictions were not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 1194State v. Elem (2018)
Attempted murder aggravated robbery juvenile court bindover merger consecutive sentences plain error R.C. 2929.14(C) guilty plea Crim.R. 11 plea colloquy knowing, intelligent, and voluntary. The offenses should not have been merged for sentencing because they were not allied offenses of similar import. The appellant received effective assistance of counsel, consecutive sentences were clearly and convincingly supported by the record, and the appellant's plea was knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily entered.
- 2018 Ohio 1195Myocare Nursing Home, Inc. v. Hohmann (2018)
Creditor's bill garnishment legal malpractice manifest weight attorney fees. The summary judgment entered in favor of the attorney and law firm upon the legal malpractice claims is affirmed because as a matter of law, the attorney did not breach a standard of care by losing priority over certain monies the debtor received through an unrelated settlement. The trial court's award of attorney fees is not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 1196Barno v. Dir., Ohio Dept. of Job & Family Servs. (2018)
Unemployment compensation just cause to quit failure to pay as promised. UCRC's decision finding no just cause to quit and disallowing employee's unemployment compensation benefits was against the manifest weight of the evidence. Hearing officer's decision improperly found that employee's failure to quit "immediately" and failure to notify anyone other than his immediate supervisor of workplace issues did not amount to just cause to quit. Furthermore, hearing officer improperly concluded that the employer's failure to address the employee's concerns was reasonable just cause to quit, under unemployment compensation law, focuses on the conduct of the employee, not the employer.
- 2018 Ohio 1197Thayer v. B.L. Bldg. & Remodeling, L.L.C. (2018)
Civ.R. 56 summary judgment trip-and-fall genuine issues of material fact open and obvious hazard negligence contributory negligence proximate cause. Trial court erred in granting summary judgment in favor of defendant contractor in trip-and-fall case where plaintiff fell through a partially constructed window during a hospital remodeling project. Open and obvious doctrine did not bar negligence claims against contractor. Genuine issues of fact existed as to whether contractor breached its duty of ordinary care to plaintiff and whether any such breach was the proximate cause of plaintiff's injuries. Genuine issues of fact also existed as to whether plaintiff was contributorily negligent in failing to observe and avoid the hazard presented by the partially constructed window and, if so, the extent to which plaintiff's own negligence was the proximate cause of her injuries.
- 2018 Ohio 1198State v. Alexander (2018)
Sentence judgment of conviction fact of conviction void postconviction relief untimely jurisdiction Crim.R. 32 allocution mitigation hearing appointed counsel presentence investigation prison term. The record and petition do not identify an error that would render defendant's sentences void. Accordingly, the trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying the petition for postconviction relief without holding a hearing. An indigent petitioner has neither a state nor a federal constitutional right to be represented by appointed counsel in a postconviction proceeding.
- 2018 Ohio 1199State v. D.H. (2018)
R.C. 2953.32 R.C. 2953.52 eligible offender expungement seal record of conviction felony misdemeanor vacate. Court did not err in denying an R.C. 2953.52 (R.C. 2953.32) motion to seal the record of a conviction where defendant's criminal history makes him statutorily ineligible to have his record sealed.
- 2018 Ohio 1204Millstein v. Millstein (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1207Kisling, Nestico & Redick, L.L.C. v. Progressive Max Ins. Co. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1209Lake Ski I-80, Inc. v. Habowski (2018)
CIVIL - summary judgment pursuant to R.C. 2117.12, if a claim against an estate is rejected, the claimant must commence an action on the claim within two months mootness App.R. 3(C) R.C. 2502.22.
- 2018 Ohio 1211In re Estate of Andolsek (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - R.C. 2505.02 Civ.R. 54(B) entry contemplates further action lack of a final appealable order.
- 2018 Ohio 1212Girard v. Oakman (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - notice of trial date, judgment entry conflicting notice sent by clek of court after issuance of judgment reliance upon notice from clek reasonably Crim.R 24(A) jury demand in petty offense case insufficient time to file demand obstructing official business sufficiency of evidence failure to comply with order of police officer.
- 2018 Ohio 1212City of Girard v. Oakman (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1213State v. Ross (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - App.R. 4(A)(1) untimely appeal remedy under App.R. 5(A) to file an untimely criminal appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 1214Belt v. Belt (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - App.R. 4(A) thirty-day rule Civ.R. 58(B) untimely appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 1215Parker v. Wilcox (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - App.R. 4(A) thirty-day rule Civ.R. 58(B) untimely appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 1216Jori, L.L.C. v. B2B Internatl., L.L.C. (2018)
CIVIL - de novo standard of review summary judgment matters of law evaluation of statutory claims license agreement business opportunity plan R.C. 1334.01(D) R.C. 1334.02 R.C. 1334.06(B) parol-evidence rule whether the email in question satisfies R.C. 1334.01(D)(3)(c) is an issue of fact that must be resolved by the trial court.
- 2018 Ohio 1217Lower Valley Farm, L.L.C. v. Croskey (2018)
oil and gas lease motion to enforce a settlement agreement summary judgment Corban v. Chesapeake Expl., L.L.C., 149 Ohio St.3d 512, 2016-Ohio-5796, 76 N.E.3d 1089 appeal rendered moot by ruling in Lower Valley Farm, LLC v. Croskey, et al., 7th Dist. Nos. 16-HA-0010, 16-HA-0011, and 16-HA-0012, 2018-Ohio-814
- 2018 Ohio 1218State v. Chambliss (2018)
Anders brief Trial court did not abuse its discretion in revoking community control Sentencing issue is moot because sentence has been served motion to withdraw granted.
- 2018 Ohio 1219Huntington Natl. Bank v. CPW Properties, Ltd. (2018)
motion to intervene, receivorship, bankruptcy, voluntary dismissal of complaint, appeal moot
- 2018 Ohio 1220State v. Duffield (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1221State v. Barron (2018)
The appellant's negotiated guilty plea waived his ability to challenge the trial court's ruling on his suppression motion. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1222State v. Lawson (2018)
The State concedes, and this court agrees, that Appellant did not knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily enter his guilty plea due to the trial court improperly advising Appellant about post-release control at the plea hearing and in the written plea form. As a result, Appellant's additional claim alleging that his trial counsel provided ineffective assistance in failing to object to the erroneous post-release control advisement is no longer ripe for review and moot. Judgment reversed, plea vacated, and matter remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 1223State v. Powell (2018)
The trial court did not err in overruling Appellant's motion to suppress. R.C.G.O. 71.31 is not vague, and the ordinance imposes an absolute duty on giving turn signals that is not conditioned on prevailing traffic conditions. The fact that Appellant failed to continuously maintain a turn signal prior to turning provided the police officer with a reasonable, articulable suspicion that Appellant had committed a traffic violation and justified the stop of Appellant's vehicle. Affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1224State ex rel. Englewood Dir. of Law v. Red Carpet Inn (2018)
Plaintiff-appellant filed a complaint against Defendants-appellees' business, a motel, asserting that it qualified as a nuisance under R.C. 3767.01(C)(2). The trial court entered judgment against Plaintiff-appellant prompting this appeal. Thereafter, Defendants-appellees voluntarily razed the motel. This action has made the legal controversy moot, and, finding no exceptions to the mootness doctrine, this appeal is dismissed. Appeal dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 1225State v. Rich (2018)
The appellant's convictions for receiving stolen property are based on legally sufficient evidence and are not against the manifest weight of the evidence. The State also presented legally sufficient evidence to support the appellant's convictions for engaging in a pattern of corrupt activity and money laundering. The trial court did not err in overruling the appellant's objection to purported "other acts" evidence on the basis that it was irrelevant and unduly prejudicial. Ohio's receiving-stolen-property statute, R.C. 2913.51(A), does not unlawfully criminalize civil negligence. The trial court did not err in denying the appellant's pre-trial suppression motion, which challenged a search-warrant affidavit. The trial court did not err in denying the appellant's Crim.R. 29 motion. The trial court adequately instructed the jury with regard to receiving stolen property being "corrupt activity" and with regard to the definition of "reasonable cause to believe." No cumulative error deprived the appellant of a fair trial. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1226State v. Rich (2018)
The appellant's convictions for receiving stolen property are based on legally sufficient evidence and are not against the manifest weight of the evidence. The State also presented legally sufficient evidence to support the appellant's convictions for engaging in a pattern of corrupt activity and money laundering. The trial court did not err in overruling the appellant's objection to purported "other acts" evidence on the basis that it was irrelevant and unduly prejudicial. Ohio's receiving-stolen-property statute, R.C. 2913.51(A), does not unlawfully criminalize civil negligence. The trial court did not err in denying the appellant's pre-trial suppression motion, which challenged a search-warrant affidavit. The trial court did not err in denying the appellant's Crim.R. 29 motion. The trial court adequately instructed the jury with regard to receiving stolen property being identified as "corrupt activity" and with regard to the definition of "reasonable cause to believe." No cumulative error deprived the appellant of a fair trial. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1227State v. Shumway (2018)
The record establishes that the trial court complied with the requirements of Crim.R. 32.3 when it accepted appellant's admissions to violating his community control at the revocation hearing held on August 17, 2017. Trial court was not required to make inquiries pursuant to Crim.R. 11 prior to accepting appellant's admissions and revoking his community control. Appellant's argument that his sentence is contrary to law demonstrates that, at most, his sentence is voidable. Because appellant's sentence, assuming his argument had merit, would be voidable, he is barred by the doctrine of res judicata from challenging his sentence on that basis in the instant appeal. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1228State v. Thomason (2018)
Defense counsel was not ineffective for failing to ask the trial court to instruct the jury to disregard comments made by a State witness after he made two separate objections to specific portions of her testimony that were sustained. Trial counsel was not ineffective for failing to request a jury instruction for self-defense since the evidence adduced at trial did not support that affirmative defense. The State adduced sufficient evidence to support appellant's conviction for felonious assault with a deadly weapon, and the verdict was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1229State v. Tipton (2018)
Defendant-appellant's sole assignment of error attacks the trial court's imposition of a now served nine month prison term. As such, Defendant-appellant's appeal is moot and subject to dismissal. Appeal dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 1230State v. Ward (2018)
Defendant, who was 19 years old, pled guilty to two counts of burglary, in violation of R.C. 2911.12(A)(3), both third-degree felonies, and was sentenced to 30 months in prison on each count, to be served consecutively. The trial court did not err in imposing prison terms instead of community control and in ordering the sentences to be served consecutively trial court properly considered the defendant's extensive juvenile record in determining that a prison term was appropriate and that defendant's "history of criminal conduct demonstrates that consecutive sentences are necessary to protect the public from future crime by the offender." In addition, trial court's finding that the harm caused by defendant's two offenses was so great or unusual that no single prison term for any of the offenses adequately reflected the seriousness of the offender's conduct was not clearly and convincingly unsupported by the record. Based on the record, the trial court could have reasonably found that defendant had the ability to pay restitution. The parties agree that the trial court erred in ordering defendant to pay court-appointed counsel fees without notifying the defendant of that requirement at sentencing. Trial court's order requiring defendant to pay court-appointed counsel fees is vacated. In all other respects, the trial court's judgment is affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1233State v. Banda (2018)
Res judicata bars a defendant from challenging multiple sentences on the ground that the offenses were allied offenses of similar import once the trial court either makes a finding that the offenses are not allied offenses or fails to consider the issue prior to sentencing and the defendant did timely file a direct appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 1234State v. Belcher (2018)
Trial court did not err in imposing costs of confinement and counsel. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1235Hardy v. Maveric Properties, L.L.C. (2018)
Pro se appellant's mistake in appearing for trial at 1:00 p.m. instead of 9:00 a.m. did not demonstrate "a complete disregard for the judicial system" and constituted excusable neglect under Civ.R. 60(B)(1) where she attended all other scheduled court dates, engaged in mediation efforts, and simply made mistake as to trial time.
- 2018 Ohio 1237State v. Hughes (2018)
Trial court did not err by permitting injured victim's presence in the courtroom. Appellant did not point to any evidence that victim's presence prejudiced his right to a fair trial. Court properly denied Crim.R. 29 motion because reasonable minds could reach different conclusions about whether state proved appellant's guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. Appellant's conviction is not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Court properly imposed costs of prosecution without considering ability to pay.
- 2018 Ohio 1239State v. Konneh (2018)
Where driver crossed marked divider lanes without signaling, traffic stop was properly initiated. Ensuing questioning did not constitute custodial interrogation. Motion to suppress did not toll speedy-trial time as to new charge brought after motion filed. Photos depicting Qur'an and prayer mat not unfairly prejudicial. State showed constructive possession of items in vehicle rented by appellant where he was passenger and offered explanation for possessing items.
- 2018 Ohio 1240Toledo v. Molina (2018)
The trial court attempted to merge appellant's offenses pursuant to R.C. 4511.19(C). The prosecution must elect which offense it will pursue, and the trial court must sentence in accordance with this election.
- 2018 Ohio 1241State v. Oehmke-Dunbar (2018)
Trial court did not err in denying motion for trial continuance. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1242State v. Bachman (2018)
Conviction for permitting drug abuse was not supported by sufficient evidence where there was no evidence that appellant used his automobile to facilitate a drug offense but, rather, merely drove himself to and from the scene of the drug offense where the drugs were already located.
- 2018 Ohio 1248New Asian Super Mkt. v. Jiahe Weng (2018)
The trial court abused its discretion in adopting the magistrate's decision where the record shows the municipal court was without jurisdiction to determine landlord's forcible entry and detainer claims once tenants' related counterclaim that exceeded the jurisdiction of the municipal court had been filed. Tenants' first assignment of error sustained remaining assignments of error mooted. Judgment reversed and case remanded with instructions that the trial court to enter an order transferring this action to common pleas court for determination of all issues raised by the parties in their pleadings in this case.
- 2018 Ohio 1249In re S.S. (2018)
The trial court did not err when it granted PCC of four children to Franklin County Children Services.
- 2018 Ohio 1250State v. Valladares (2018)
Appellant's convictions for domestic violence and assault were supported by sufficient evidence and were not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Appellant failed to establish his claim of ineffective assistance of counsel. There was no evidence in the record that the appointment of the Acting Judge to the case was improper.
- 2018 Ohio 1251McBride v. Butler (2018)
The trial court did not err in granting the insurance company's motion for summary judgment because the primary assumption of the risk doctrine barred plaintiff's recovery for injuries sustained as a result of an ATV accident.
- 2018 Ohio 1253State v. Golden (2018)
The trial court did not err in sentencing defendant to a maximum sentence when the sentence was within the statutory range and the trial court considered the statutory factors, including the fact that defendant had previously served a prison sentence.
- 2018 Ohio 1254State v. Pearson (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1255State v. Armstrong (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1256Allstate Ins. Co. v. Wiant (2018)
The trial court erred in granting relief from judgment where the trial court did not first give appellant the ability to respond to appellees' motion for relief. The trial court should have waited the 14 days provided for in the local rules for a response from the opposing party before deciding the issue.
- 2018 Ohio 1257State v. Whitt (2018)
Appellant's convictions for attempted trespass into a habitation and criminal damaging were supported by sufficient evidence and were not against the manifest weight of the evidence where the homeowners testified that appellant was beating on their doors and windows with an object to gain entrance into their residence while appellant was "tweaking" on methamphetamine.
- 2018 Ohio 1259State v. Barney (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1260In re R.Mc. (2018)
permanent custody kinship placement clear and convincing evidence R.C. 2151.414
- 2018 Ohio 1261State v. Rinehart (2018)
postconviction relief petition untimely R.C. 2953.21 standard of review abuse of discretion R.C. 2953.08 judicial fact-finding voidable void
- 2018 Ohio 1263State v. Hurtt (2018)
Criminal: motion to suppress Fourth Amendment consensual encounter versus investigative stop reasonable suspicion.
- 2018 Ohio 1264State v. Such (2018)
Traffic Stop, Reasonable Suspicion To Conduct Field Sobriety Testing
- 2018 Ohio 1266State v. Palmer (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1267State v. Elkins (2018)
Obstructing official business
- 2018 Ohio 1268Johnson v. Aultman Hosp. (2018)
Employment at-will Defamation
- 2018 Ohio 1269State v. Roden (2018)
Felonious assault domestic violence weight/sufficiency
- 2018 Ohio 1270State v. Hill (2018)
Denial of fifth petition for post confiction relief
- 2018 Ohio 1273State v. Monford (2018)
Judgment affirmed. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in finding that the appellant failed to establish that he was unavoidably prevented from obtaining the alleged new evidence and, as a result, denying appellant's motion for leave to file a delayed motion for a new trial.
- 2018 Ohio 1274State v. Jama (2018)
State's appeal from a trial court order granting appellee additional jail-time credit rendered moot when, during the pendency of the appeal, appellee is released from confinement after serving the full prison term, without the benefit of the additional jail-time credit in the journal entry appealed from. Appeal dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 1276State v. Powell (2018)
Criminal: motion to suppress Fourth Amendment warrantless search and seizure statutory speedy-trial rights R.C. 2945.73(B).
- 2018 Ohio 1278State v. Blanton (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1279State v. Craig (2018)
CRIMINAL - Appellant's appeal based on ineffective assistance of counsel is barred by the doctrine of res judicata.
- 2018 Ohio 1280State v. Landrum (2018)
CRIMINAL - Trial court did not err in overruling Appellant's motion for new trial and sentencing hearing as it was untimely pursuant to Crim.R. 33.
- 2018 Ohio 1284State v. Hendon (2018)
Ineffective assistance of counsel, plain error, motion to suppress, GPS tracking data, unreasonable search, exclusionary rule, motion in limine, Daubert challenge, admissibility of evidence
- 2018 Ohio 1285State v. Jackson (2018)
Motion to suppress, Miranda rights, involuntary, coercion, search warrant, supporting affidavit, probable cause, other acts, sufficiency of the evidence, manifest weight of the evidence
- 2018 Ohio 1286State ex rel. Beard v. Hardin (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Mandamus-Writ of mandamus sought to compel city council and county board of elections to place proposed charter amendment on the ballot-City council did not have a clear legal duty to submit the proposal to the board of elections-Proposal violated Columbus City Charter 42-2(d), which states that the proposal to be submitted may not address multiple or unrelated subject matters-Board of elections did not have a clear legal duty to place a proposed charter amendment on the ballot when city council had not passed an ordinance approving the placement of the amendment on the ballot-Writs denied.
- 2018 Ohio 1289Calanni v. Kolodny (2018)
Magistrate decision abuse of discretion credibility trier of fact. Judgment affirmed. Trial court's decision adopting magistrate's decisions was not an abuse of discretion. When testimony is in dispute, we defer to the trier of fact's credibility determination. Here the factfinder found in favor of defendants on some claims and in favor in plaintiff on other claims.
- 2018 Ohio 1290Diemer v. Minute Men, Inc. (2018)
Negligent promotion negligence summary judgment Civ.R. 56 employment relationship proximate cause supervisor authority knowledge borrowed or loaned servant control imputed knowledge reasonable care. The trial court erred in granting summary judgment in favor of an employer that had knowledge of circumstances of an individual it promoted to a position of authority that could endanger other employees. Material questions of fact remain. The court did not err in granting summary judgment in favor of another appellee where it had no knowledge of such circumstances and knowledge could not be imputed to it.
- 2018 Ohio 1292State v. Strowder (2018)
R.C. 2152.10 R.C. 2152.12 juvenile bindover instructions - attorney jurors R.C. 2903.11(A)(2) felonious assault sentencing juveniles. R.C. 2152.10 and 2152.12 do not violate due process or equal protection guarantees of Ohio and United States Constitutions court's instruction to attorney-juror was not erroneous conviction for felonious assault under R.C. 2903.11(A)(2) was supported by sufficient evidence convictions for rape, kidnapping and robbery were not against the manifest weight of the evidence nonhomicide juvenile offender was entitled to resentencing under State v. Moore, 149 Ohio St.3d 557, 2016 Ohio 8288, 76 N.E.3d 1127.
- 2018 Ohio 1293State v. Gray-Cole (2018)
Plea agreement, merger. The appellant's plea was made knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily. The trial court is instructed to follow the plea agreement made between the state and the appellant that the aggravated assault and attempted abduction counts merge for the purpose of sentencing.
- 2018 Ohio 1294Vannucci v. Schneider (2018)
Abuse of discretion small claims adopt objections overrule legal services attorney fees representation attorney-client relationship benefit retainer signature written agreement implication. The trial court properly relied on defendant's conduct to conclude that an attorney-client relationship was formed by implication. Therefore, the trial court did not arbitrarily conclude that defendants had a legal obligation to compensate counsel for unpaid legal services. The trial court did not abuse its discretion by overruling defendant's objections and adopting the magistrate's decision in its entirety.
- 2018 Ohio 1295Wesolowski v. Broadview Hts. Planning Comm. (2018)
Subdivision sketch plan approval city planning commission R.C. 711.09(C) for a "certificate in lieu of endorsement of approval" summary judgment declaratory judgment de novo "home rule" administrative appeal R.C. Chapter 2506. Judgment affirmed. The trial court properly granted summary judgment as to Wesolowski's declaratory judgment claim. A plain reading of the statute reveals the legislature intended that the remedial procedures in R.C. 711.09 apply to both cities and villages. The City's subdivision planning ordinances are an exercise of "local police power" the ordinances must be reconciled with the "general laws" of the state. Here, the lack of a time frame in the City's codified ordinances impermissibly conflicts with the procedures set forth in R.C. 711.09(C). To the extent that this ordinance allows for more than 30 days to approve or disapprove the proposed of division land, that regulation is invalid as conflicting with R.C. 711.09(C). As a result, the remedial procedures set forth in R.C. 711.09(C) are applicable to the City. R.C. 711.09(C) specifically sets forth the plaintiff's remedy, which is a petition in the court of common pleas. Therefore, any remedy plaintiff may have in her R.C. Chapter 2506 appeal does not preclude her from obtaining a declaratory judgment on the basis of R.C. 711.09(C).
- 2018 Ohio 1296State v. Benton (2018)
Motion to suppress evidence, probable cause, exigent circumstances, police interrogation. The trial court properly denied the appellant's motion to suppress the gun evidence because the appellant signed a consent to search, and the police searched the appellant's vehicle in accordance with a valid search warrant. Even if the police officers did not have a warrant, there were exigent circumstances that existed to provide them probable cause to search the appellant and briefly question him.
- 2018 Ohio 1297State v. Williams (2018)
Jail-time credit R.C. 2967.191 R.C. 2929.19(B)(2)(g)(i) Ohio Adm.Code 5120-2-04(B) R.C. 2953.08(G)(2) R.C. 2929.11 R.C. 2929.12 principles and purposes of sentencing seriousness and recidivism factors youth as a mitigating sentencing factor. The trial court erred when it failed to calculate the amount of jail-time credit the defendant should receive. The defendant's sentence was not excessive under R.C. 2929.11 and 2929.12. The trial court properly considered the relevant factors when sentencing the defendant.
- 2018 Ohio 1298GGNSC Lima, L.L.C. v. LMOP, L.L.C. (2018)
Service jurisdiction affidavit sworn statement abuse of discretion vacate hearing place of business complaint merits rebuttable presumption agent authorized representative credibility. A trial court commits reversible error by "summarily overruling a defendant's motion to set aside a judgment for lack of service, when the defendant submits a sworn statement that she did not receive service of process, without affording the defendant a hearing." The trial court abused its discretion by denying appellants' motion to vacate default judgment without holding a hearing.
- 2018 Ohio 1303Michelson v. Volkswagen Aktiengesellschaft (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1306State v. Jackson (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1307In re M.C.M. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1311Lemay v. Univ. of Toledo Med. Ctr. (2018)
Court of Claims of Ohio does not have jurisdiction to adjudicate issues governed by a collective bargaining agreement because it had no jurisdiction over the claim. The Court of Claims could not grant summary judgment of any party but had to dismiss the claim.
- 2018 Ohio 1312Bales v. Dept. of Agriculture (2018)
Ohio State Department of Agriculture could order the killing of a herd of deer privately owned based on the threat of infection with chronic wasting disease.
- 2018 Ohio 1315State v. Robinson (2018)
DRUGS - EVIDENCE - PLEAS: Where defendant entered a no-contest plea to possessing drug-abuse instruments under R.C. 2925.12, which applies only where the instrument involved is a hypodermic or syringe, and the state's explanation of the circumstances showed that defendant possessed a crack pipe, the state failed to establish all of the elements of the offense, and the trial court erred in finding defendant guilty of possessing drug-abuse instruments.
- 2018 Ohio 1316In re K.R. (2018)
permanent custody - withdrawal of counsel - knowing waiver of the right to representation by counsel
- 2018 Ohio 1318Ibrahim v. City of Dayton (2018)
The trial court correctly granted summary judgment to Defendants-appellees, a municipality and a police officer employed by the municipality, regarding an automobile accident between the police officer and Plaintiff-appellant. The trial court, based upon the Civ.R. 56 record, correctly concluded that Plaintiff-appellant did not meet her burden to establish that there is a genuine issue of material fact on the questions of whether the police officer was responding to an emergency call, as this term is statutorily defined, or whether the police officer's operation of the police cruiser was willful, wanton, or reckless. The trial court, accordingly, properly decided that the municipality and the police officer are entitled to immunity regarding the automobile accident. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1319City of Dayton v. King (2018)
Since Robert King's tenant, Thaddeus Earl, was required by law to keep the leased premises safe and sanitary, and dispose of waste in a sanitary manner, and since Earl, in executing the lease, further assumed the responsibility of complying with the housing code, the trial court erred in convicting King for the violation of R.C.G.O. 93.46(E), failure to maintain exterior premises. Judgment reversed and vacated.
- 2018 Ohio 1320State v. Lane (2018)
After conducting a review of the record as prescribed by Anders, we find no issues with arguable merit for appeal. The sentencing issues raised by Appellant in his supplemental, pro se brief lack arguable merit because Appellant's sentence is not clearly and convincingly contrary to law, and we do not find by clear and convincing evidence that the record does not support Appellant's sentence. In addition, Appellant waived his right to challenge his conviction on speedy-trial grounds by entering a guilty plea. Affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1321State v. McKenzie (2018)
Defendant's convictions for aggravated burglary, abduction, and assault were not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1322State v. Wilcoxin (2018)
The trial court did not err in finding a photospread not "unduly suggestive" based on the appellant being the only person pictured with a "not accentuated" "barely visible" "teardrop" facial tattoo. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1323State v. Yeldell (2018)
The trial court did not err in allowing the State to amend the appellant's indictment. With the agreement of defense counsel, the amendment merely changed the date of the appellant's prior conviction for a sexually-oriented offense. Contrary to the appellant's argument, the amendment did not expand the date range for his current failure-to-notify offense to include dates after the grand jury returned its indictment. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1324BAS Broadcasting, Inc. v. Fifth Third Bank (2018)
Summary judgment, fraudulent inducement, loan, banking, Small Business Administration, arm's length, fiduciary relationship, fiduciary duty
- 2018 Ohio 1325Toledo v. Files (2018)
The trial court did not err in resolving conflicts in the evidence and finding appellant guilty of assault and domestic violence. Sufficiency manifest weight.
- 2018 Ohio 1326State v. Knott (2018)
In an Anders case, appellant's maximum sentence was not contrary to law where the court considered the statutory factors and imposed a sentence within the statutory range. R.C. 2929.11 2929.12.
- 2018 Ohio 1329State v. Harris (2018)
kidnapping, abduction, sufficiency of the evidence, manifest weight of the evidence, R.C. 2938.11(F), verdict, open court
- 2018 Ohio 1332State v. Paolucci (2018)
CRIMINAL - OVI marked lanes violation motion to suppress extra-jurisdictional stop R.C.2935.03(D) pursuit unreasonable delay chargeable offense R.C. 4510.036
- 2018 Ohio 1334State v. Owens (2018)
CRIMINAL - Aggravated Possession of Drugs Illegal Assembly or Possession of Chemicals for the Manufacture of Drugs Possessing Criminal Tools manifest weight of the evidence sufficiency of the evidence constructive possession conscious of the presence of an object circumstantial evidence credibility criminal purpose complicity.
- 2018 Ohio 1335Puruczky v. Corsi (2018)
CIVIL - preliminary injunction due process de novo hearing notice Civ.R. 65 constructive notice unreasonable notice First Amendment free speech prior restraint abuse of discretion.
- 2018 Ohio 1336State v. Lewis (2018)
Postconviction petition petition untimely filed and failed to demonstrate that untimeliness should be excused pursuant to R.C. 2953.23(A)(1)(a)-(b) claims barred by res judicata.
- 2018 Ohio 1337Schaefer v. Bolog (2018)
Will contest summary judgment testamentary capacity undue influence Continental Ins. Co. v. Whittington, 71 Ohio St.3d 150, 156, 642 N.E.2d 615 (1994) Civ.R. 50 motion for a directed verdict opening statement.
- 2018 Ohio 1338State v. Goad (2018)
Crim.R. 11 State v. Toney, 23 Ohio App.2d 203, 262 N.E.2d 419 (7th Dist.1970) R.C. 2929.14(C)(4) consecutive sentencing State v. Bonnell, 140 Ohio St.3d 209, 2014-Ohio-3177, 16 N.E.3d 654, 29.
- 2018 Ohio 1339State v. White (2018)
R.C. 4510.16 driving under suspension motion to suppress search incident to an arrest Arizona v. Gant, 556 U.S. 332, 129 S.Ct. 1710, 173 L.Ed.2d 485 (2009) Miranda v. Arizona, 384 U.S. 436, 86 S.Ct. 1602 (1966) waiver of Miranda rights.
- 2018 Ohio 1340State v. Hopkins (2018)
No merit plea plea colloquy strict compliance constitutional rights.
- 2018 Ohio 1341State v. Scott (2018)
No merit brief State v. Toney, 23 Ohio App.2d 203, 262 N.E.2d 419 (1970) driving under OVI suspension R.C. 4510.14 no motorcycle endorsement R.C. 4510.12(A)(2) no motorcycle helmet R.C. 4511.53 guilty plea Crim.R. 11 Traf.R. 10(D) R.C. 2929.21(A) R.C. 2929.22(A) misdemeanor sentence.
- 2018 Ohio 1342State v. Black (2018)
Evid.R. 901(A) felonious assault R.C. 2903.11(A)(2), (D) R.C. 2941.145(A) weapon while under disability R.C. 2923.13(A)(3), (B) Evid.R. 901(B)(1) manifest weight consecutive sentences R.C. 2929.14(C)(4) State v. Bonnell, 140 Ohio St.3d 209, 2014-Ohio-3177, 16 N.E.3d 654 written judgment entry.
- 2018 Ohio 1343Tangler v. Vill. of Carrollton (2018)
political subdivision immunity, summary judgment, sewer, maintenance, negligence.
- 2018 Ohio 1344Tharp v. Whirlpool (2018)
Trial court erred in granting summary judgment to employer where, at the very least, evidence was in conflict.
- 2018 Ohio 1345State v. Hill (2018)
The trial court substantially complied with Crim.R. 11(E) when it accepted Appellant's guilty plea to a petty offense. Due to the indicators in the record that a Notary Public was present at the time the complaint was executed but failed to sign the document, the case is remanded for a hearing to determine whether the complaint was sworn to under oath in the presence of someone authorized to administer an oath as required by Crim.R. 3.
- 2018 Ohio 1346State v. Parsons (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion by dismissing the defendant-appellant's petition for post-conviction relief because there is no judgment from which the defendant-appellant can seek post-conviction relief.
- 2018 Ohio 1347State v. Hartshorn (2018)
Competency to stand trial - not demonstrated by the record
- 2018 Ohio 1348State v. Simpson (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1349In re S.S. (2018)
Permanent custody-trial court's decision not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 1350State v. Buell (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying appellant's motion for a new trial where the evidence appellant claimed was newly discovered was available to appellant before her trial started.
- 2018 Ohio 1352State v. Reeder (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1353State v. Saag (2018)
Trial court did not err in denying appellant's motion to set aside judgment as appellant's crimes were committed before the effective date of Senate Bill 2, which replaced parole with postrelease control. As appellant's offenses were committed before Senate Bill 2 because effective on July 1, 1996, he was not subject to postrelease control.
- 2018 Ohio 1354State v. Simpson (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1355State v. Hentenaar (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1356State v. Rogers (2018)
Appellant's felonious assault conviction was not against the manifest weight of the evidence where he failed to prove he acted in self-defense and under serious provocation.
- 2018 Ohio 1358State v. Williams (2018)
Defendant, sentenced to death for aggravated murder, appeals trial court's denial of his motion for a new mitigation trial on the basis that a recent United States Supreme Court decision, Hurst v. Florida, rendered Ohio's capital sentencing scheme unconstitutional. Ohio's death-penalty scheme did not violate the defendant's Sixth Amendment right to a trial by impartial jury where the law required the jury to make the critical findings that rendered the defendant eligible for the death penalty.
- 2018 Ohio 1360State v. Whitling (2018)
Though the trial court complied with the requirements of R.C. 2945.37 by holding a competency hearing, it committed reversible error by failing to journalize an entry finding appellant competent to stand trial prior to accepting appellant's guilty plea.
- 2018 Ohio 1362Murphy Elevator Co., Inc. v. 11320 Chester L.L.C. (2018)
CONTRACTS - DAMAGES: Where the parties' elevator-maintenance contract clearly and unambiguously provided that defendant would be responsible for paying the difference between plaintiff's regular and overtime billing rates if it requested that plaintiff perform services outside of the contractually specified dates and times, the trial court did not err in accepting testimony from plaintiff as to the amount plaintiff charged for regular and overtime services in a given year, or in awarding damages accordingly. Where the contract did not specify the hourly rate that defendant would be required to pay plaintiff for performing requested services that were not covered under the contract, the trial court did not err in awarding plaintiff damages for the services in the amount of plaintiff's standard rates. The trial court erred in awarding plaintiff the gross revenue that it would have received under the second year of the parties' contract where plaintiff stopped performing contractual services due to defendant's nonpayment the court should have awarded plaintiff its lost profits.
- 2018 Ohio 1363Deutsche Bank Natl. Trust Co. v. Mallonn II (2018)
Summary judgment/Foreclosure
- 2018 Ohio 1365State v. Curtis (2018)
Female defendant who urged her boyfriend who had a gun in his hand to "Get them all" was guilty of complicity in the crimes he committed when he shot at people, killing one.
- 2018 Ohio 1367Twinsburg v. Milano (2018)
guilty plea - Crim.R. 11(B) - petty offense - misdemeanor - effect of guilty plea - complete admission of guilt
- 2018 Ohio 1368State v. Garrett (2018)
manifest weight, inconsistent verdict, felonious assault, knife, self-defense
- 2018 Ohio 1369State v. Boggs (2018)
R.C. 2981.02(A)(2) - forfeiture specification - proceeds - competent, credible evidence - car - vehicle
- 2018 Ohio 1371Armatas v. Haws (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1373State v. Holman (2018)
Harmless error Suffiency/Weight
- 2018 Ohio 1375State v. Anders (2018)
constitutional right to speedy trial presumptively prejudicial delay negligence of the state in causing delay, particularized trial prejudice manifest weight of the evidence
- 2018 Ohio 1376State v. Payton (2018)
felony sentence R.C. 2953.08(D)(1) R.C. 2953.08(D)(3) aggravated murder agreed sentence hearing
- 2018 Ohio 1377State ex rel. Seabolt v. State Hwy. Patrol Retirement Sys. (2018)
Record contained sufficient evidence to support respondent's determination approving relator's application for disability retirement "not in the line of duty."
- 2018 Ohio 1378Chibinda v. Ohio Bureau of Motor Vehicles (2018)
Judgment on the pleadings in favor of Ohio Bureau of Motor Vehicles affirmed. Trial court did not err in changing common pleas case classification from administrative appeal to declaratory judgment, since BMV's order did not result from an adjudication. BMV has authority to promulgate Ohio Administrative Code rules and standards in issuing nonrenewable driver's licenses and to determine documents necessary to establish an applicant's legal status.
- 2018 Ohio 1379Katz v. Ohio Real Estate Comm'n (2018)
Investigation of real estate salesperson's activities was not barred by three-year time limit in R.C. 4735.32 because complaint involved a continuing agreement and charges were limited to acts occurring during the three-year period before the complaint was filed. Common pleas court did not abuse its discretion by concluding there was reliable, probative, and substantial evidence to support real estate commission's conclusion that appellant committed misconduct subject to disciplinary action. Appellant's due process rights were not violated because he was given notice of the charges pending against him and an opportunity to be heard at an impartial hearing.
- 2018 Ohio 1380State v. Lewis (2018)
SEX OFFENSES - CLASSIFICATION - REGISTRATION - NOTIFICATION: Where the trial court correctly classified defendant as a Tier I sex offender under the Adam Walsh Act, but provided defendant with incorrect notice of his registration requirements, the remedy is to remand the cause for the court to correctly notify defendant of his Tier I registration and verification duties and their duration.
- 2018 Ohio 1382State v. Littlepage (2018)
POSTCONVICTION-DNA TESTING: The common pleas court did not err in denying defendant's 2016 application under R.C. 2953.71 et seq. for DNA testing regarding his aggravated-murder offense, because his guilty plea to that offense excluded him from eligibility to request that testing. R.C. 2953.72(C)(2) and 2953.71(F).
- 2018 Ohio 1387State v. Johnson (2018)
Improperly discharging firearm into a habitation improperly discharging a firearm on or near a prohibited premises felonious assault guilty plea elements of an offense subjective understanding Alford plea allied offenses different victims. Guilty pleas were entered knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily where record indicated that defendant understood nature of the charges to which he pleaded guilty. Trial court was not required to conduct an Alford inquiry because the defendant never protested his innocence. Defendant's convictions were not allied offenses that should merge because they each involved a separate victim.
- 2018 Ohio 1388State v. Bridges (2018)
Manifest weight of evidence, allied offenses, ineffective assistance of counsel. The appellant's conviction for rape was not against the manifest weight of the evidence because the victim's testimony was consistent and credible. However, the trial court did err in failing to merge the rape and kidnapping counts because they were allied offenses in accordance with R.C. 2941.45. The appellant was not denied effective assistance of counsel. The decision to not testify at trial was a tactical decision, and the record does not demonstrate that the appellant was coerced to not testify.
- 2018 Ohio 1389State v. Johnson (2018)
Confrontation clause Daubert hearing hearsay prosecutorial misconduct, sufficiency of the evidence manifest weight of the evidence ineffective assistance of counsel cell phone evidence expert layperson murder credibility. Judgment affirmed. A Daubert hearing was not necessary because the expert did not testify about "how cellular networks operate" or "the process by which a cell phone connects to a given tower," but testified about testimony regarding a comparison of cell phone data records to locations where crimes occurred. This type of testimony does not require "`specialized knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education'" regarding cellular networks. The confrontation clause was not violated when the testimony in question was not testimonial. There was sufficient evidence to sustain the convictions, and the convictions were not against the manifest weight of the evidence when an eyewitness placed the defendant as one of the shooters and the circumstantial evidence resulted in the defendant as a suspect. The jury weighed credibility and found defendant guilty. The prosecutor did not vouch for credibility in closing, and defense counsel was not ineffective.
- 2018 Ohio 1390State v. McGuire (2018)
Brady v. Maryland exculpatory evidence impeachment evidence aggravated murder body camera evidence potentially useful evidence bad faith. McGuire's right to a fair trial was not violated. Brady v. Maryland did not obligate the state to turn over evidence that a responding officer was under investigation for an unrelated incident. Lost body camera evidence also did not create a Brady violation because it was not materially exculpatory evidence, only potentially useful evidence, and McGuire was unable to show bad faith on the part of the police in failing to preserve the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 1391State v. Medley (2018)
Sufficiency manifest weight R.C. 229.22(A)/child endangerment. Sufficient evidence was presented appellant was found to have created a substantial risk to the safety of the child, and appellant's conviction was not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 1392State v. Newton (2018)
Motion to dismiss destruction of evidence due process bad faith rape gross sexual imposition kidnapping sexual battery. Trial court did not abuse its discretion in granting defendant's motion to dismiss charges against him where, during trial, it was revealed that the investigating detective destroyed potentially useful evidence in bad faith. Bad faith was established by the fact that the detective was in sole possession of the missing or destroyed evidence after its creation, attempted to conceal its destruction or loss from the defense, the prosecuting attorney and another detective prior to trial, lied to the trial judge when confronted about the matter in court and made inappropriate statements during the investigation. Dismissal was appropriate because the destruction of evidence central to the case permanently deprived the defendant of due process.
- 2018 Ohio 1393State v. Thompson (2018)
Contrary to law R.C. 2953.08 R.C. 2929.11 R.C. 2929.12 R.C. 2929.13 R.C. 2929.14 offense of violence attempted domestic violence. The trial court's sentence is within the permissible statutory range under R.C. 2929.14(A)(5) and the trial court considered the purposes and principles of felony sentencing set forth in R.C. 2929.11 and the seriousness and recidivism factors set forth in R.C. 2929.12. Accordingly, the trial court's sentence is not contrary to law.
- 2018 Ohio 1394State v. Pratt (2018)
Child endangering worst form of the offense sexual abuse misdemeanor sentence hybrid community control jail term. Combination of jail term and community control sanctions was not authorized by statute where defendant was ordered to serve maximum jail term followed by community control.
- 2018 Ohio 1395Altenheim v. Januszewski (2018)
Final appealable order Civ.R. 54(B) R.C. 2505.02 summary judgment counterclaims. Trial court order entering summary judgment for defendant on plaintiff's claims for relief, which did not dispose of defendant's counterclaims for relief, is not a final, appealable order.
- 2018 Ohio 1396State v. Harrison (2018)
Postconviction R.C. 2953.21 unavoidably prevented res judicata. Court did not err by dismissing petition for postconviction relief as untimely because the petitioner's evidentiary materials demonstrated that he had long been aware of the basis for the claims made in the petition, thus belying his assertion that he had been unavoidably prevented from filing the petition at an earlier date. Claims made and addressed in federal habeas proceedings are res judicata for same claims made in state court petition for postconviction relief.
- 2018 Ohio 1397State v. Kafantaris (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1401State v. Hill (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1404State v. Seymour (2018)
CRIMINAL - Appellant's conviction for failure to comply is supported by the record and no error occurred as to court costs.
- 2018 Ohio 1405State v. Lamb (2018)
CRIMINAL - Trial court did not err in convicting appellant of aggravated robbery and failure to comply relating to: ineffective assistance of counsel speedy trial juror selection error 6th amendment cumulative error and the record supports the convictions.
- 2018 Ohio 1406In re Criminal Charges Against Groves (2018)
CRIMINAL - Trial court did not err in overruling Motion for Appointment of Uninterested Special Prosecutor under R.C. 2935.09 and 2935.10.
- 2018 Ohio 1409Sosnoswsky v. Koscianski (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1411City of Maple Heights v. State Emp't Relations Bd. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1412Natale v. Frantz Ward, L.L.P. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1417State v. Bradford (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1420Conner v. Scott (2018)
The record does not portray error in the trial court's dismissal of two competing small-claims complaints on the basis that the claims they asserted were required to have been raised in a prior lawsuit between the parties. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1421State v. DeVaughns (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in overruling Appellant's Crim.R. 33 motion for new trial, as the motion was untimely and Appellant failed to provide clear and convincing proof that he was unavoidably prevented from timely filing the motion. In addition, Appellant's challenge to this court's decision in one of his prior appeals is not properly before this court, as Appellant's recourse was to seek reconsideration pursuant to App.R. 26(A), or to have the decision be considered by the Supreme Court of Ohio. Affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1422State v. Gray-Mosher (2018)
The trial court did not err in overruling the appellant's suppression motion. The record reflects a knowing, intelligent, and voluntary waiver of the appellant's Miranda rights prior to his jailhouse interview with a detective. Nothing in the record suggests that the appellant's statements during the interview were involuntary. The appellant's seven-year prison sentence for felonious assault is not contrary to law, and the record does not clearly and convincingly fail to support it. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1423State v. Heggem (2018)
The appellant's conviction for aggravated drug possession is supported by legally sufficient evidence and is not against the manifest weight of the evidence. The trial court acted within its discretion in denying a continuance to locate a defense witness where the witness' whereabouts and the length of the required delay were unknown. Defense counsel did not provide ineffective assistance by failing to obtain personal service of a subpoena on the missing witness. A proffer of the missing witness' testimony established that it would have been unlikely to change the result of the appellant's trial. Therefore, no prejudice resulted from the witness' absence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1424State v. Lynch (2018)
Defendant-appellant was convicted and sentenced for murder under R.C. 2903.02(B), having a weapon while under a disability under R.C. 2923.13(A)(4), trafficking in a counterfeit controlled substance under R.C. 2925.37(B), intimidation of a witness under R.C. 2921.03, and aggravated possession of fentanyl under R.C. 2925.11(A). Defendant-appellant's appeal challenges only the murder conviction. The murder conviction is supported by the manifest weight of the evidence. Trial counsel did not provide ineffective assistance of counsel by not requesting the trial court, acting as the trier of fact, to consider finding Defendant-appellant guilty of the lesser included offense of involuntary manslaughter. The trial court, finally, did not commit plain error by finding Defendant-appellant guilty of murder instead of involuntary manslaughter. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1425State v. Maranger (2018)
The trial court did not err when it overruled appellant's motion to suppress with respect to search warrants issued on September 22, 2015, November 10, 2015, November 12, 2015, and May 4, 2016. Appellant's live-in girlfriend possessed the apparent authority to allow police into appellant's residence and to take possession of appellant's computer to which the girlfriend stated everyone in the house had access. The search warrants issued for appellant's residence, computer, and motor vehicle were supported by probable cause, were not stale, and were not overbroad nor lacking in specificity. Additionally, pursuant to R.C. 2971.01(H)(2)(f), the evidence obtained from the search warrants issued and executed in Wisconsin is admissible in the instant case because it can be used to support appellant's convictions for the sexually violent predator specifications. Since none of the evidence seized as a result of the search warrants issued for appellant's cellphone and 3 x 5 binder was admitted at trial, any invalidity of those warrants is moot. Because appellant did not make incriminating statements to law enforcement from Wisconsin regarding sex offenses alleged to have occurred, any purported Miranda violation is moot. Because appellant's earlier written and oral statements were obtained as a result of his sex offender treatment and not the result of a custodial interrogation, it was not necessary for parole officers to advise appellant of his Miranda rights. Furthermore, even if the admission of these statements was error, it was harmless and did not ultimately affect the outcome of the trial in light of the overwhelming evidence of his guilt. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1426State v. Reyes (2018)
Anders appeal. Trial court did not err in denying, without a hearing, defendant's post-sentence motion to withdraw his guilty plea. Defendant's motion was based on State v. Gonzales, 150 Ohio St.3d 261, 2016-Ohio-8319, 81 N.E.3d 405 (Gonzales I), which was vacated on reconsideration in State v. Gonzales, 150 Ohio St.3d 276, 2017-Ohio-777, 81 N.E.3d 419 (Gonzales II). No non-frivolous issues found related to defendant's motion to withdraw his guilty plea. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1427State v. Robinson (2018)
Crim.R. 11 does not apply to Robinson's guilty plea for physical control, and the record reflects substantial compliance with Traf.R. 10(D). Robinson did not proclaim his innocence until after the court accepted his guilty plea and imposed sentence, and no inquiry by the court was required regarding Robinson's reasons for pleading guilty, since Robinson did not enter an Alford plea. Appellant's correspondence wherein he sought to withdraw his guilty plea was insufficient to invoke the jurisdiction of the trial court since he failed to properly serve the State as required by Crim.R. 49. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1428State ex rel. Schuck v. Columbus (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Elections-Mandamus-Writ of mandamus sought to compel removal of proposed city charter amendment from the ballot-Ballot summary conveys sufficient information to inform voters what they are being asked to vote on-Writ denied.
- 2018 Ohio 1430Aquatic Renovations Sys., Inc. v. Vill. of Walbridge (2018)
Judgment affirmed. Summary judgment. Breach of contract claims. Statutory requirements for valid contract with municipality. Quantum meruit. Unjust enrichment.
- 2018 Ohio 1431State v. Hale (2018)
Free speech, fighting words, disorderly conduct, police officer, circumstances, foul language
- 2018 Ohio 1432Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. v. Mayo (2018)
Trial court did not err in holding that the sending of a notice of default by a prior holder of a promissory note satisfies the condition precedents of the current holder to file an action to foreclose the mortgage securing a promissory note.
- 2018 Ohio 1433State v. Alexander (2018)
R.C. 2903.02(B) murder R.C. 2903.11(A)(2) felonious assault motion to suppress failure to provide transcript of proceedings App.R. 9(B) Miranda v. Arizona, 384 U.S. 436, 86 S.Ct. 1602, 16 L.Ed.2d 694 (1966) waiver sufficiency of the evidence manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 1434Disciplinary Counsel v. Moore (2018)
On certification of default.
- 2018 Ohio 1435Disciplinary Counsel v. Potts (2018)
On certification of default.
- 2018 Ohio 1437Glyptis v. Cuyahoga Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation-Real-property valuation-Casualty-loss exception to rule barring successive valuation complaints within a triennium applies because evidence of casualty loss was not taken into consideration with respect to prior complaint.
- 2018 Ohio 1438State v. Syed (2018)
slot machines, casino gaming operation, manifest weight, sufficiency, defective indictment, forfeiture, possession of criminal tools, complicity
- 2018 Ohio 1439Matus v. Jacts Group, L.L.C. (2018)
summary judgment, Civ.R. 56, negligence, slip and fall, open and obvious doctrine, attendant circumstances, issue of fact
- 2018 Ohio 1441Echemann v. Echemann (2018)
The trial court abused its discretion by granting plaintiff-appellee's motion for relief from judgment under Civ.R. 60(B).
- 2018 Ohio 1443Santomieri v. Mangen (2018)
The trial court did not err in enforcing promissory note against defendant-appellant because the trial court's conclusion that there was consideration for the promissory note is not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 1444State v. Smith (2018)
Miranda warnings must reasonably convey the rights of a suspect. The police may search voluntarily abandoned property. At a minimum, reasonable suspicion is required to effect a traffic stop.
- 2018 Ohio 1445State v. Bradley-Lewis (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW-CRIMINAL - R.C. 2505.02 denial of motion to recuse a judge is not a final order in a criminal case, a sentence which disposes of the cause is the basis for appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 1446In re L.R.R. (2018)
JUVENILE - legal custody dependent extension of temporary custody children's services R.C. 2151.417 retain custody best interest abuse of discretion
- 2018 Ohio 1447In re L.R.R. (2018)
JUVENILE - legal custody dependent arbitrary totality of the circumstances equally suitable custodians child's adjustment to the home abuse of discretion
- 2018 Ohio 1448In re L.R.R. (2018)
JUVENILE - legal custody standing dependent totality of the circumstances foster a relationship equally suitable custodians child's adjustment to the home abuse of discretion
- 2018 Ohio 1449State Ex Rel. Cahill v. Vill. of Madison (2018)
CIVIL - taxpayer action R.C. 733.59 mandamus injunction abuse of corporate powers gross abuse of legislative discretion conflict of interest fire districts R.C. 505.371 official capacity production of documents motion to compel
- 2018 Ohio 1450Vill. of Timberlake v. Graham (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - Defendant's discovery request Service upon prosecutor Civ.R. 5(B)(2)(e) inability to locate address verification of steps taken to locate address request not properly before trial court when rule for service is not satisfied sufficiency of traffic citation to state offense Traff.R. 3(B) officer's qualification to operate radar gun waiver written certification unnecessary.
- 2018 Ohio 1453State v. Figueroa (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - felonious assault three counts cautionary instruction provided no evidence of prejudice no abuse of discretion Crim.R. 29 intention to harm surrounding circumstances attempt criminal purpose substantial step verbal threat violent behavior brandishing relatively large knife sufficient evidence knowingly attempted.
- 2018 Ohio 1455State v. Plummer (2018)
Defendant's convictions for gross sexual imposition were not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 1458State v. Lewis (2018)
The trial court is presumed to have denied appellant's motion requesting the trial court stop his transfer from the local county jail to prison where the trial court did not specifically rule on the motion. Regardless, even if the trial court had ruled on the motion, nothing in the record indicates the trial court would have erred had it specifically rendered such a decision. In addition, the trial court's decision to order consecutive sentences for violating his community control sanctions by pleading guilty to another felony offense is presumed proper where appellant failed to provide the necessary trial transcripts for appellate review.
- 2018 Ohio 1459State v. Brightman (2018)
Appellant's sentence was proper where the trial court sentenced appellant within the statutory range, considered all statutory factors, and imposed postrelease control. The trial court properly issued a certificate of judgment where appellant owed restitution of $2,200 to the victim, the victim requested the restitution, and the clerk of courts issued the certificate on order of the trial court.
- 2018 Ohio 1460State v. Eury (2018)
Appellant's sentence was not contrary to law where the trial court considered the relevant statutory factors, made the requisite findings, and sentenced appellant within the permissible ranges. The sentence was also supported by the record where appellant's sexual abuse went on for eight years and impacted the victims in several negative ways.
- 2018 Ohio 1461State v. Marfel Motors, Inc. (2018)
Appellant's misdemeanor conviction for operating an auto sales business without being issued a certificate of zoning compliance from the city of Hamilton was supported by sufficient evidence and was not against the manifest weight of the evidence where a planning and zoning specialist employed by the city testified that he had reviewed the city's paper files and electronic records and no certificate had been issued to appellant.
- 2018 Ohio 1462State v. Mason (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Criminal law-Sixth Amendment to the United States Constitution-Death penalty-Right to trial by jury-Ohio death-penalty scheme does not violate the Sixth Amendment, because the jury must find that offender guilty beyond a reasonable doubt and that an aggravating circumstance exists.
- 2018 Ohio 1463State ex rel. Cowan v. Gallagher (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Mandamus-Inmate failed to show that trial court disobeyed court of appeals' remand order to conduct de novo sentencing hearing-Inmate's allied-offense claims are barred by res judicata-Court of appeals' denials of writs affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1465Bunting v. Weaver (2018)
No final, appealable order.
- 2018 Ohio 1466State v. Farey (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1466State v. Farley (2018)
DUI Probable cause to arrest
- 2018 Ohio 1467Arbor Grove Properties v. Clear Sky Realty, Inc. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1468State v. Fears (2018)
Confrontation, hearsay and community control/probation revocation hearings
- 2018 Ohio 1469King v. Wings & Brews, Inc. (2018)
Summary judgment on slip and fall
- 2018 Ohio 1470State v. Leasure (2018)
Concurrent sentencing for misdemeanor and felony
- 2018 Ohio 1472Wells Fargo Fin. Ohio 1, Inc. v. Doe(s) (2018)
Trial court granted default judgment on claim for breach of promissory note but denied default judgment on claim for foreclosure of mortgage because acknowledgment clause in mortgage was defective. Because it was unclear whether trial court considered effect of recent amendment to R.C. 5301.07(C) on defective acknowledgment clause in mortgage, decision was reversed in part and remanded for consideration of that issue.
- 2018 Ohio 1473State of Ohio v. [A.G.] (2018)
The trial court erred when it granted [A.G.]'s application to seal the record of his dismissed indictment.
- 2018 Ohio 1475Slater v. Ohio Dep't of Rehab. & Corr. (2018)
The trial court possessed the subject-matter jurisdiction to determine the enforceability of the intervenor's alleged charging lien. The trial court did not err in allowing the law firm asserting the charging lien to intervene in the action, but the trial court erred in enforcing the alleged charging lien.
- 2018 Ohio 1476State v. Brown (2018)
The trial court erred when it analyzed Brown's motion to suppress under the standard of reasonable suspicion rather than probable cause.
- 2018 Ohio 1480Pavilonis v. Cuyahoga Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation-Real-property valuation-R.C. 5715.19(A)(2)-Second claim filed within triennial by not barred when complainant differs from entity that filed first complaint-When county board of review fails to object to possible unauthorized practice of law at a hearing, it forfeits argument that conduct should be considered as error.
- 2018 Ohio 1481Bur. of Workers' Comp. v. Verlinger (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Workers' compensation-R.C. 4123.931(G)-A claimant becomes eligible for benefits at time of injury or death that occurred during course of employment and remains eligible unless and until a determination that claimant is not entitled to benefits has been made and has become final (i.e., is no longer subject to appeal) or, if no claim is filed, until time allowed for filing a claim has elapsed-Benefits applicant was a claimant at time she settled with insurance companies-Applicant and insurance companies are jointly and severally liable to statutory subrogee, Bureau of Workers' Compensation, for full amount of its subrogation interest-Court of appeals' judgment affirming trial court's summary-judgment entry vacated and cause remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 1483In re Resignation of Joltin (2018)
Attorneys at law-Resignation with disciplinary action pending-Gov.Bar R. VI(11)(C).
- 2018 Ohio 1484In re Resignation of Ore (2018)
Attorneys at law-Resignation with disciplinary action pending-Gov.Bar R. VI(11)(C).
- 2018 Ohio 1486State v. Palmer (2018)
post-conviction relief, ineffective assistance of counsel, sufficient operative facts, res judicata
- 2018 Ohio 1488State v. Boware (2018)
gross sexual imposition - newly discovered evidence - motion to withdraw - petition for post-conviction relief - res judicata
- 2018 Ohio 1490State v. Cobb (2018)
Ineffective counsel/plain error re: instruction on "possession" maximum sentence
- 2018 Ohio 1491State v. Janes (2018)
Denial of motion to suppress
- 2018 Ohio 1492JSS Props., II, LLC v. Liberty Twp. Bd. of Zoning Appeals (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1493State v. Green (2018)
Post-release control sentence
- 2018 Ohio 1494State v. Sheppard (2018)
Allied offenses/consecutive sentences
- 2018 Ohio 1495State v. Smith (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1496State v. Solis-Garcia (2018)
Conviction for rape of person less than 13 years of age not against sufficiency or weight of evidence
- 2018 Ohio 1497State v. Taylor (2018)
Anders - probation violations sentenced
- 2018 Ohio 1498Evans v. Hunter (2018)
Personal injury - Motion for new trial - Directed verdict
- 2018 Ohio 1499Johnson v. Dept. of Youth Servs. (2018)
Summary judgment Civ.R. 56 employment discrimination retaliation R.C. 4112.02. As plaintiff could not show that a similarly situated, non-protected person was treated more favorably, she did not establish a prima facie case of discrimination. Additionally, the court determined that no reasonable finder of fact could conclude that plaintiff established a prima facie case of retaliation. Plaintiff failed to adduce evidence of a causal connection between her participation in an interview with an investigator and her termination. Defendant's motion for summary judgment was granted.
- 2018 Ohio 1500Current v. Dept. of Rehab. & Corr. (2018)
Negligence bifurcated trial inmate. The magistrate determined that defendant did not have sufficient notice to be liable for plaintiff's injuries from the March 25, 2011 attack, and plaintiff's contention that he told ODRC employees that his presence at LCI posed a danger to him was belied by other evidence and lacked credibility. Further, while prison officials knew of plaintiff's work as an informant, that knowledge alone did not equate to notice of an impending attack on plaintiff, and they were sensitive to keeping plaintiff safe. The magistrate recommended judgment in favor of defendant.
- 2018 Ohio 1501Dunlap v. Dept. of Pub. Safety (2018)
Motor vehicle accident bifurcated trial wanton negligence. The magistrate determined that although the State Trooper was at fault in causing the accident, his actions did not rise to the level of wanton misconduct. Further, the totality of the evidence did not establish a failure to exercise any care on the part of the State Trooper. Plaintiff failed to prove her claim, and judgment was recommended in favor of defendants.
- 2018 Ohio 1502Zavinski v. Dept. of Transp. (2018)
Wrongful death damages R.C. 2125.02 apportionment. The magistrate found plaintiff's economic damages expert persuasive, and recommended damages for loss of support and services of plaintiff's decedent in the amount of $478,522. For non-economic damages, the magistrate recommended damages in the amount of $2,500,000. During the liability trial, the court determined that fifty percent of the damages awarded was apportioned to the driver of the truck that struck plaintiff's decedent. Finally, the magistrate recommended a reduction of $1,293,475.28 for collateral sources. The magistrate recommended a total of $195,810.72 in damages.
- 2018 Ohio 1503Zavinski v. Dept. of Transp. (2018)
Wrongful death damages R.C. 2743.02 collateral benefit objections. The court concluded that if a collateral benefit does not compensate for a loss that is included in the damage award, then such a collateral benefit should not be deducted from a recovery against the state pursuant to R.C. 2743.02(D). The court determined that the magistrate erred in determining that the sums of $125,000 for the interest in plaintiff's decedent's law firm, and $33,475.28 for the fees earned by plaintiff's decedent before he died, constituted other collateral recovery and should be applied to reduce the award against ODOT. Plaintiff was awarded $354,286 in damages.
- 2018 Ohio 1504State v. Dilley (2018)
Postconviction relief subject matter jurisdiction probate general division R.C. 2931.03 R.C. 2931.01. Court of Common Pleas, General Division, had subject matter jurisdiction to convict defendant of theft and other offenses where he served as financial advisor for a person who was incompetent and executed amended trust which named himself as beneficiary interpleader action involving trust proceeds did not vest all jurisdiction over defendant's conduct in the probate division.
- 2018 Ohio 1505Houston v. Morales (2018)
Motion for summary judgment Civ.R. 56 fellow employee immunity R.C. 4123.471 injury occurring in the course of and arising out of the plaintiff's employment. - Judgment affirmed. The trial court properly determined that the fellow employee immunity statute applied to the instant case. First, the injury was caused by another employee. There is no dispute that both plaintiff and defendant were employees at Hose Master, and plaintiff was injured as a result of the accident. Second, the injury occurred in the course of and arising out of plaintiff's employment. There is no dispute that plaintiff was awarded workers' compensation benefits for the injuries he sustained from the accident with the defendant.
- 2018 Ohio 1506State v. Copley (2018)
Presentence motion to withdraw no contest plea motion to disqualify counsel ineffective assistance of counsel. The trial court did not err when it denied Copley's presentence motion to withdraw his no contest pleas and his motion to disqualify appointed counsel counsel was not ineffective for advising Copley to plead no contest in light of the compelling evidence obtained by the state and given that this strategy resulted in a sentence that was shorter than the state's best offer.
- 2018 Ohio 1507State v. Colon (2018)
Felonious assault, aggravated assault, self-defense, R.C. 2907.05. The United States Supreme Court's decision in District of Columbia v. Heller, 554 U.S. 570, 128 S.Ct. 2783, 171 L.Ed.2d 637 (2008) did not render Ohio's self-defense statute, R.C. 2907.05, unconstitutional. The jury's decision to reject appellant's affirmative defense of self-defense was not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 1508Woodmere v. Young (2018)
Ineffective assistance of counsel failure to object. Trial counsel was not ineffective for failing to object to certain testimony presented in the state's case-in-chief. It is within the court's discretion whether to admit leading questions on direct examination, and, because this case was tried to the bench, we presume the court did not rely on inadmissible hearsay.
- 2018 Ohio 1510State v. May (2018)
Sufficiency, aggravated vehicular assault, R.C. 2903.08(A)(1)(a), R.C. 4511.19(A)(1)(a).
- 2018 Ohio 1511State v. Duncan (2018)
Crim.R. 11 Crim.R. 32 guilty plea judicial release substantial compliance. Court substantially complies with Crim.R. 11 when defendant does not claim prejudice, and under totality of circumstances, it is clear that defendant understood judicial release ineligibility was term of guilty plea. It is harmless error when the court fails to inform defendant of right to appeal where defendant is appointed counsel for appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 1513State v. Nagy (2018)
Restitution amount R.C. 2929.18(A)(1) plea agreement payments account vacate reversed remanded instructions modify. The trial court erred by imposing restitution in an amount that was not consistent with the plea agreement and failed to credit appellant for payments that had been made to the victim. Appellant was not entitled to vacate her plea rather, the case was reversed as to the order of restitution only, remanded to the trial court with instructions to modify the restitution order, and affirmed in all other respects.
- 2018 Ohio 1514State v. Jung (2018)
R.C. 2929.11 R.C. 2929.12 violation of community control sanctions maximum sentences postrelease control R.C. 2967.28 unclassified felony. When sentencing defendant on felony convictions after he violated community control sanctions, it was presumed that trial court considered principles and purposes of sentencing under R.C. 2929.11 and relevant sentencing factors under R.C. 2929.12 where defendant did not affirmatively show otherwise. Defendant's sentences on felony convictions were not clearly and convincingly contrary to law and the record did not otherwise clearly and convincingly fail support his sentences. Portion of sentence that imposed postrelease control for violation of R.C. 3734.03, an unclassified felony, was contrary to law and is, therefore, vacated.
- 2018 Ohio 1518Brobst v. City of Lyndhurst (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1521State v. Hugley (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1523State v. Lee (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1525State ex rel. Newcomb v. Thalheimer (2018)
Because relator failed to satisfy the statutory requirements, we adopt the magistrate's decision as our own and grant respondent's motion to dismiss. Action dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 1526State v. Williams (2018)
The trial court did not plainly err in instructing the jury that the verdict must be unanimous as to all charges and specifications, but it did err when it sentenced the defendant to consecutive terms of imprisonment for two one-year gun specifications even though both specifications arose from a single act or transaction.
- 2018 Ohio 1527Wild v. Midwest Gift Assn., Inc. (2018)
The trial court erred in granting summary judgment to warehouse lessee and booth operator sublessee when it did not draw all reasonable inferences in favor of the plaintiff and treated certain admissible matters of evidence as "hearsay" and "pure speculation."
- 2018 Ohio 1528State v. Taylor (2018)
Trial court partially complied with Crim.R. 11 by advising defendant that he was subject to a period of post-release control of "up to" five years when defendant was subject to mandatory five years for post-release control. Therefore, defendant must demonstrate prejudice to invalidate his plea. Defendant failed to do so.
- 2018 Ohio 1529State v. Allen (2018)
The trial court erred in ordering the defendant to pay restitution to three banks. Although the banks cashed the forged checks, the economic loss was initially suffered by the account holders. The banks were third parties that reimbursed the accounts. As such, the banks were not the victims of the offenses and not entitled to restitution.
- 2018 Ohio 1530Dept. of Youth Servs. v. Grimsley (2018)
Where the common pleas court correctly overruled the legal errors asserted by the appellant, but committed legal error in misstating and thereby misapplying a result not reached by an order of the State Personnel Board of Review, that portion of the appellant's assignment of error challenging the common pleas court's reading and application of the SPBR order is sustained. Judgment reversed in part and cause remanded for correction of this error.
- 2018 Ohio 1531Smith v. Smith (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in terminating the parties' shared parenting agreement and designating mother as the legal and custodial parent. The parties had not actively engaged in "shared" parenting or had any direct communication for many years. Further, child's desire for a change in the parenting arrangement was entitled to significant weight. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1532State v. Lawson (2018)
Defendant-appellant has not demonstrated by clear and convincing evidence that the record does not support the sentences imposed by the trial court. Further, Defendant-appellant's sentences are not subject to vacation under R.C. 2929.13(B)(1)(c), and the trial court correctly calculated the amount of jail time credit to which Defendant-appellant is entitled. Judgment affirmed. (Froelich, J., concurring.)
- 2018 Ohio 1533State v. Kaeser (2018)
We find no arguable merit to this appeal under Anders v. California, 386 U.S. 738, 87 S.Ct. 1396, 18 L.Ed.2d 493 (1967). Appellant had pled guilty to one count of Unlawful Sexual Conduct with a Minor and one count of Corrupting Another with Drugs, and he was sentenced to community control sanctions in October 2014. He did not appeal the convictions. In July 2015, he failed to report and absconded. On October 6, 2017, appellant admitted to community control violations and was sentenced to prison consistent with the sentences reserved at the time of the original conviction. There are no non-frivolous issues supporting a potential assignment of error of arguable merit. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1535Gillespie v. Waterwheel Farms, Inc. (2018)
The trial court erred in entering summary judgment against the appellant on his strict-liability dog-bite claim under R.C. 955.28(B). Genuine issues of material fact exist as to whether a criminal-trespass affirmative defense to strict liability applied. Judgment reversed and cause remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 1541World Business Servs., Inc. v. Yoest (2018)
The grant of summary judgment will be reversed where there remain genuine issues of material fact and, when viewing the record strongly in favor of appellant, appellees are not entitled to judgment as a matter of law.
- 2018 Ohio 1542State v. Tingler (2018)
Trial court did not err in denying appellant's motion to re-enter a prior journal entry in order to enable appellant to perfect an appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 1546State v. Maurer (2018)
In a probation violation proceeding, the court was presumed to have personally addressed the defendant prior to her waiver of counsel to ensure the waiver was fully informed. Crim.R. 32.3 Crim.R. 44(C) regularity of the proceedings.
- 2018 Ohio 1547State v. Lamb (2018)
Appellate counsel's motion to withdraw granted.
- 2018 Ohio 1548In re Kail.K. (2018)
Termination of parental rights. Trial court's grant of permanent custody of five children to agency not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Consideration of mother's marijuana use not improper.
- 2018 Ohio 1549State v. Gibbs (2018)
Motion to suppress properly denied upon consideration of the totality of the circumstances trial counsel did not render ineffective assistance.
- 2018 Ohio 1550Cousino v. Mercy St. Vincent Med. Ctr. (2018)
Hospital established that all documents within credentialing file were generated by or exclusively for peer review committee and are therefore privileged under R.C. 2305.252. If there are documents outside of the credentialing file that are protected by the peer review and/or the attorney-client privilege, hospital must establish that the privilege(s) apply, as to each document, identify the document(s) on a privilege log, and submit the documents, under seal, to the trial court for in-camera inspection.
- 2018 Ohio 1551State v. Bolton (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1561Dana Corp. v. Testa (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation-Commercial-activity-tax credit-R.C. 5751.53(F) does not authorize an adjustment of the amortizable amount-Board of Tax Appeals' decision reversed and amortizable amount modified.
- 2018 Ohio 1562State v. Wilks (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Criminal law-Aggravated murder-Convictions and death sentence affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1563Wade v. Mancuso (2018)
pedestrian, motor vehicle, accident, admission of expert testimony, voir dire, manifest weight
- 2018 Ohio 1564State v. Smith (2018)
warrantless search - motion to suppress - consent to search - plain view - drugs - drug paraphernalia - Article I, Section 14, Ohio Constitution - Fourth Amendment
- 2018 Ohio 1565State v. Henderson (2018)
R.C. 2945.67(A) - jurisdiction - entry failing to specify relief
- 2018 Ohio 1566State v. Frederick (2018)
pro se, suppression, reasonable suspicion, field sobriety tests, OVI, marked lanes violation, judicial bias, sufficiency
- 2018 Ohio 1567State v. Mercer (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1568State v. Landingham (2018)
The trial court did not err in making its sentencing decision. Any penalty imposed for violating the conditions of community control is a punishment for that violation and not for the original underlying offense.
- 2018 Ohio 1569State v. Risner (2018)
Defendant appeals convictions related to a methamphetamine manufacturing operation at his home. Court did not err in denying defendant's motion to suppress evidence where a search warrant affidavit provided the court with probable cause to issue a warrant. Affidavit stated a civilian witnessed a man removing items used in the manufacture of methamphetamine from a vehicle at the residence and the residence had previously been used to manufacture methamphetamine. Defendant's convictions were supported by sufficient evidence and manifest weight of the evidence where methamphetamine and all the necessary chemicals to manufacture methamphetamine were in the defendant's home. Evidence further demonstrated that the manufacturing process was active when police executed the search warrant and had been ongoing.
- 2018 Ohio 1571Taylor v. Taylor (2018)
Trial court erred in determining that a restriction contained in a conservation easement, which restricted the parties' ability to divide the property into two or more parcels was uinenforceable.
- 2018 Ohio 1572State v. Julien (2018)
Trial court did not err in imposing the sentence when it was within the statutory range and was supported by competent, credible evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 1574State v. Briscar (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - App.R. 4(A)(1) untimely appeal remedy under App.R. 5(A) to file an untimely criminal appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 1575State v. Howard (2018)
CRIMINAL - manifest weight of the evidence credibility Evid.R. 401 Evid.R. 402 relevant evidence Evid.R. 608 character for truthfulness or untruthfulness Evid.R. 609 R.C. 2929.12.
- 2018 Ohio 1576State v. Luther (2018)
Ample circumstantial evidence supported appellant's conviction for criminal damaging.
- 2018 Ohio 1583State v. Cruz-Ramos (2018)
no merit briefs no longer accepted on appeal Anders v. California, 386 U.S. 738 (1967) procedure no longer followed State v. Toney, 23 Ohio App.2d 203 (1970) overruled if the defendant does not wish to dismiss the appeal, appointed counsel must file a merit brief.
- 2018 Ohio 1584State v. Miku (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1585State v. Barnes (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1587Dept. of Taxation v. Dunlap (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1588Schutz v. Cuyahoga Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation-Real-property valuation-Board of Tax Appeals acted reasonably and lawfully in retaining county fiscal officer's valuation-Property owner failed to carry burden of proving that value he advocated is correct value-Decision affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1589Bronx Park S. III Lancaster, L.L.C. v. Fairfield Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation-Real-property valuation-Board of Tax Appeals failed to consider property owners' appraisal evidence-Decision vacated and cause remanded for Board of Tax Appeals to weigh and address the evidence presented below, including the appraisal evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 1590Portage Cnty. Bd. of Developmental Disabilities v. Portage Cnty. Educators' Ass'n for Developmental Disabilities (2018)
When reviewing a decision of a common pleas court confirming, modifying, vacating, or correcting an arbitration award, an appellate court should accept findings of fact that are not clearly erroneous but decide questions of law de novo.
- 2018 Ohio 1591State v. Horsley (2018)
CRIMINAL - Appellant's rape conviction was supported by the record and no error occurred below as to speedy trial, or selective prosecution and not against the sufficiency or manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 1592Fox v. City of Pataskala (2018)
Summary judgment re:city charger provision on attorney fees cross-appeal on attorney fees to file subject case)
- 2018 Ohio 1593McFarren v. Emeritus at Canton (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1595Cain v. Panitch (2018)
Probate court did not err in dismissing appellants' claim for legal malpractice, nor did court err in finding that claims for fraud, conversion, negligence, and breach of fiduciary duty were barred by applicable statute of limitations.
- 2018 Ohio 1597Byrd v. Ohio Dept. of Job & Family Servs. (2018)
Where the Ohio Court of Claims dismisses a county child support enforcement agency and substitutes for it the Ohio Department of Job and Family Services, altering the case caption to reflect a proper state agency as the defendant, it is error to dismiss the complaint for subject-matter jurisdiction under Civ.R. 12(B)(1) for having sued a county agency.
- 2018 Ohio 1598Rogowski v. Barnes (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying Plaintiff-Appellant's request for an additional extension of time and for leave to file an affidavit opposing the motion for summary judgment where Plaintiff-Appellant could not provide anything to refute the evidence in the record. There being no genuine issues of material fact for trial, the trial court appropriately entered summary judgment against Plaintiff-Appellant. Assignments of error overruled. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1602State ex rel. Khumprakob v. Mahoning Cty. Bd. of Elections (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Mandamus-County board of elections abused its discretion in finding that proposed charter amendment exceeds city's legislative power-Writ compelling board to place proposed amendment on May 2018 ballot granted.
- 2018 Ohio 1604State v. Castagnola (2018)
pro se motion - hybrid representation - nunc pro tunc - invalid - jurisdiction - appeal pending
- 2018 Ohio 1605State v. Fields (2018)
motion to correct sentencing, allied offenses, merger, direct appeal, subsequent order utilized to appeal a prior order, res judicata
- 2018 Ohio 1607State v. Suttles (2018)
motion for relief from disability - transcript - appeal - hearing - presume regularity
- 2018 Ohio 1608Timber Top Apts. v. Klinkiewicz (2018)
forcible entry and detainer, eviction, service of process, R.C. 1923.06
- 2018 Ohio 1610State v. Skeens (2018)
State's appeal of order granting motion to suppress
- 2018 Ohio 1611Arbors E. RE, L.L.C. v. Franklin Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation-Real-property valuation-Board of Tax Appeals erred in failing to exercise its statutory authority to obtain a complete record and in holding as matter of law that any allocation of a property's sale price to goodwill is improper-Decision vacated and cause remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 1612Lone Star Steakhouse & Saloon of Ohio, Inc. v. Franklin Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation-Real-property valuation-A facially qualifying sale enjoys presumption of recency even when it postdates tax-lien date by more than 24 months-Board of Tax Appeals erred in finding that sale of property was too remote from tax-lien date and in requiring property owner to present evidence showing that either market conditions or character of property had remained the same between sale date and tax-lien date-Decision reversed and cause remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 1613The STATE EX REL. GARRETT v. COSTINE, Judge. (2018)
Prohibition-Writ sought to require Ohio probate-court judge to vacate adoption decree-Parental Kidnapping Prevention Act, 28 U.S.C. 1738A-West Virginia court had exclusive continuing jurisdiction over proceedings involving minor child when adoption petition was filed in Ohio-Ohio court lacked jurisdiction to issue adoption decree-Writ granted.
- 2018 Ohio 1614State ex rel. Drum v. Ohio Pub. Emps. Retirement Sys. (2018)
Motion to dismiss writ of mandamus granted.
- 2018 Ohio 1616State ex rel. Bristow v. Baxter (2018)
Petition for writ of mandamus denied where it does not meet the basic requirements for filing in that it does not comply with Civ.R. 10 and 11 requiring an address for relator.
- 2018 Ohio 1618Wentling v. David Motor Coach Ltd. (2018)
Summary judgment/Employer intentional tort/Spoliation of evidence/Property claims
- 2018 Ohio 1619State v. Stutler (2018)
Standard of review for R.C. 2945.401 hearing
- 2018 Ohio 1620State ex rel. Harris v. Adult Parole Auth. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1621Gianetti v. Teakwood, Ltd. (2018)
The trial court did not err in awarding attorney fees to appellee due to appellant's frivolous conduct in continuing to litigate claims with no evidentiary basis. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1627State v. Cliff (2018)
Substantial compliance mandatory sentence firearm specification Crim.R. 11 understood ineligible community control totality of circumstances. The trial court substantially complied with the requirements of Crim.R. 11(C)(2)(a) by ensuring that defendant subjectively understood the mandatory nature of the prison sentence associated with a firearm specification.
- 2018 Ohio 1628State v. Strimpel (2018)
Guilty plea Crim.R. 11 group plea psychological evaluation mental health appeal jurisdiction motion to withdraw guilty plea. Appellant's group guilty plea was knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily made. There is nothing in the record indicating the group plea dynamic interfered with his plea. Also, the fact that the court ordered a psychological evaluation for mitigation in sentencing does not establish that the appellant had mental health issues that prevented his plea from being knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily made, where the record of the proceeding lacks any evidence that appellant suffered from a mental condition.
- 2018 Ohio 1629State v. Rhodes (2018)
Sufficient evidence, R.C. 2905.01(A)(3), manifest weight of the evidence. There was sufficient evidence to convict the appellant of kidnapping in violation of R.C. 2905.01(A)(3) because he restrained the victim's liberty in order to inflict serious physical harm on her. In reviewing the record, it has not been demonstrated that the jury clearly lost its way and created such a manifest miscarriage of justice that the conviction must be reversed. The appellant's convictions were not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 1630Thomas v. PSC Metals, Inc. (2018)
Summary judgment, negligence, workers' compensation immunity, R.C. 4123.74, R.C. 4123.35, loss of consortium. The trial court properly granted summary judgment to the employer because it complied with the relevant workers' compensation statutes and, therefore, was immune to the plaintiff's negligence claim. The trial court properly granted summary judgment to the employer as to the plaintiffs' claim for loss of consortium because that claim was dependent upon the plaintiffs' underlying claims, which were dismissed on summary judgment.
- 2018 Ohio 1631State v. Parham (2018)
Ineffective assistance object hostile judicial bias plea Crim.R. 11 nature of offense elements substantial compliance nonconstitutional recommended sentence record knowing voluntary intelligent. The record demonstrates that defendant subjectively understood the nature of the felonious assault offense. The trial court substantially complied with the requirements of Crim.R. 11(C)(2)(a). Defendant failed to demonstrate that counsel rendered ineffective assistance of counsel during the plea hearing. The record does not demonstrate that the parties agreed to a jointly recommended sentence. Thus the trial court had no obligation to forewarn defendant that it would not be bound by a jointly recommended sentence.
- 2018 Ohio 1632Cleveland v. Sowders (2018)
Manifest weight assault reasonable force. Trial court did not lose its way by finding that body camera video of police officer striking a subdued and handcuffed suspect depicted an unreasonable amount of force that constituted an assault.
- 2018 Ohio 1633State v. Jackson (2018)
Plea agreement compulsory process material favorable. Where the defendant's codefendants entered into plea agreements that improperly precluded them from testifying for the defense, defendant's conviction was affirmed and the violation of defendant's right to compulsory process held to be harmless where the defendant did not make the required showing that the codefendants' testimony would have been material and favorable to his defense.
- 2018 Ohio 1634State v. Magwood (2018)
Rape manifest weight credibility sexual assault nurse examiner hearsay Evid.R. 803(4) maximum and consecutive sentence R.C. 2929.11 and 2929.12 R.C. 2953.08(G)(2) R.C. 2929.14(C)(4) supported by the record. The conviction for rape was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. The factfinder found the victim more credible and the victim's testimony was supported by other witness testimony. The sexual assault nurse examiner's reading of the victim's narrative regarding the theft of the victim's money was not protected by the hearsay exception of Evid.R. 803(4), and because this narrative was the only evidence of the theft, admission of this testimony amounted to plain error and Magwood's conviction for petty theft must be reversed. Magwood's maximum sentence was supported by the record. The sentence was within the statutory range, and the court considered R.C. 2929.11 and 2929.12. Additionally, we cannot clearly and convincingly find that the record does not support consecutive sentences.
- 2018 Ohio 1635City of Beachwood v. Pearl (2018)
Cruelty to companion animals Fifth Amendment self-incrimination expert testimony sufficiency manifest weight plain error Crim.R. 52 Crim.R. 29 Evid.R. 701. Appellant was not prejudicially misled regarding the offense with which he was charged and convicted as a result of the clerical error in the complaint. Appellant's constitutional right to remain silent and privilege against self-incrimination were not violated. The trial court did not arbitrarily disregard the testimony of the defense's expert witness. Appellant's conviction for cruelty to companion animals is supported by sufficient evidence and not against the manifest weight of the evidence. The trial court's imposition of inactive probation in its sentencing judgment entry is vacated because the trial court did not sentence appellant to probation in open court during the sentencing hearing. This matter is remanded to the trial court for the limited purpose of issuing nunc pro tunc journal entries to accurately reflect the offense with which appellant was charged and convicted.
- 2018 Ohio 1638Bowen v. Farmers Ins. Co. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1640State v. Robertson (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1647State v. Williams (2018)
The appellant's convictions for murder and discharging a firearm on or near prohibited premises are not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Defense counsel did not provide ineffective assistance when, in the in presence of the jury, after testimony of expertise and qualifications of a forensic pathologist and a firearms examiner, the prosecution "tendered" them as experts in their fields, defense counsel replied "no objection" and the trial court indicated "so noted" and "so designated," respectively. Both experts were eminently qualified, both testified to issues that were not controversial or in dispute. On this record the trial court's responses to the tender of experts did not constitute plain error, and therefore counsel's failure to object did not constitute ineffective assistance of counsel. The trial court also did not commit plain error by failing to merge murder and discharging a firearm on or near prohibited premises as allied offenses of similar import. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1648State v. Wheaton (2018)
Appellant's convictions for failing to maintain reasonable control of her vehicle and for leaving the scene of an accident were supported by sufficient evidence and were not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1649State v. Taylor (2018)
Trial court abused its discretion in denying defendant's post-conviction motion to vacate or suspend court costs. Court lacked statutory authority to vacate the restitution order, and defendant's challenge to the restitution order was barred by res judicata. The trial court's judgment affirmed as to restitution and reversed as to court costs, and case remanded for consideration of Taylor's indigency and his present and/or future ability to pay court costs. (Tucker, J., concurring.)
- 2018 Ohio 1650Matlock v. Reck (2018)
Appellant's breach of the valid oral contract between the parties for the purchase of a mobile home entitled Appellee to damages in the amount of $3,000.00. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1651State v. Davis (2018)
Defendant-appellant was convicted of rape in violation of R.C. 2907.02(A)(1)(b) and kidnapping in violation of R.C. 2905.01(A)(4). The trial court committed plain error by not ordering the merger of the rape and kidnapping counts. The merger conclusion renders Defendant-appellant's argument regarding the trial court's imposition of consecutive sentences moot. The trial court did not err by allowing the State to cross-examine Defendant-appellant about the notice of alibi he filed but did not pursue. The trial court erred by allowing the submission of victim impact evidence, but, given the overwhelming evidence of Defendant-appellant's guilt, the error was harmless. Finally, the admission of other acts evidence was elicited by defense counsel, and, thus, the trial court did not err regarding the admission of this testimony. Judgment affirmed, in part, reversed, in part, and remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 1652JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A. v. Asbury (2018)
Appellees are entitled to a directed verdict on appellant's claims for violation of the Ohio Corrupt Practices Act and the federal RICO Act, and for civil conspiracy, where appellant has failed to provide any evidence that appellees were involved in an enterprise or had a common purpose to deprive appellant of the equity in the home.
- 2018 Ohio 1653State v. Schoenlein (2018)
Trial court did not err in appellant's rape, kidnapping, and abduction convictions. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1654State v. Reese (2018)
Motion to suppress was properly denied where reasonable suspicion supported the 1:00 a.m. traffic stop that was initiated after the police officer ascertained that the owner of the vehicle was under a license suspension with limited driving privileges.
- 2018 Ohio 1655State v. Leggett (2018)
Petition for postconviction relief untimely and the issues raised are barred by the doctrine of res judicata.
- 2018 Ohio 1656State v. Johnson (2018)
Trial court does not abuse its discretion in denying appellant's postconviction motion to withdraw his guilty plea where appellant was informed of the nature of the charges and his plea was knowingly, voluntarily, and intelligently made. Any defect in waiving the right to an indictment is procedural and is waived by a subsequent guilty plea.
- 2018 Ohio 1657State v. Johnson (2018)
Aggravated robbery and felonious assault convictions did not merge where the evidence established that the aggravated robbery was completed before the defendant shot the victim, and thus the felonious assault was not in furtherance of the aggravated robbery.
- 2018 Ohio 1658In re R.J. (2018)
Appellant's 2010 sexual offender classification judgment was made in plain error. It resulted in a manifest miscarriage of justice. Denial of motion to vacate is reversed and remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 1659Caruso v. Erie Shoreline Properties, L.L.C. (2018)
summary judgment, slip and fall, open and obvious, business invitee, Ohio Basic Building Code, attendant circumstances, putt-putt golf
- 2018 Ohio 1660State ex rel. Emhoff v. Medina Cty. Bd. of Elections (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Prohibition-Writ of prohibition sought to prevent judicial candidate's name from appearing on ballot-Relators allege candidate failed to satisfy R.C. 2301.01's six-years-of-practicing-law requirement-Secretary of state did not abuse his discretion in breaking tie in favor of certifying candidates name to the ballot-Writ denied.
- 2018 Ohio 1663Klossner v. Burr (2018)
specific performance, abuse of discretion, forfeiture, condition precedent, App.R. 16(A)(7)
- 2018 Ohio 1666Alexander v. Dept. of Rehab. & Corr. (2018)
Negligence bailment- Plaintiff, an inmate, sought damages for property defendant's agents lost after packing up plaintiff's belongings before his transfer to another correctional facility. Plaintiff provided inconsistent documentation. The court found plaintiff failed to prove a loss as to some of the items but awarded damages to plaintiff for other items after determining depreciation.
- 2018 Ohio 1669GMAC Mtge., L.L.C. v. Giuliano (2018)
CIVIL - foreclosure repayment agreement violations established plaintiff as servicer in possession of note with rights of enforcement has standing servicing guide governs relations between servicer and owner of note, not the borrower summary judgment proper.
- 2018 Ohio 1670Edwards v. Plalan Lake Road Maintenance, Inc. (2018)
REAL PROPERTY - Creation of subdivision payment of yearly fee by lot/tract owner to maintain roads restrictive covenant application of general constract law ambiguous language unenforceable tracts originally intended for park/resort now used for personal recreation definition of term "managed" for determining amount of maintenance fee.
- 2018 Ohio 1671State v. Bradley (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - direct appeal following plea agreement sufficiency of the evidence plea is complete admission of guilt Crim.R. 11(B)(1) waiver of right to challenge evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 1674Rootstown Twp. Bd. of Trustees v. Portage Self Storage (2018)
ZONING - township board of zoning appeals exclusionary zoning nonconforming use variance conditional use development plan self storage facility storage containers outdoor storage boats, campers, and other recreational vehicles summary judgment injunctive relief jury demand findings of fact and conclusions of law Civ.R. 56.
- 2018 Ohio 1675Cunningham v. Fisher (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - App.R. 4(A) thirty-day rule Civ.R. 58(B) untimely appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 1676State v. Hall (2018)
CRIMINAL - Burglary R.C. 2911.12(A)(2) jury instructions lesser-included offense R.C. 2945.74 Crim.R. 31(C) nondisclosure of discoverable material Crim.R. 16(B)(3) and (L)(1) sufficiency of the evidence manifest weight of the evidence
- 2018 Ohio 1677State v. Dewees (2018)
CRIMINAL - Attempted Rape R.C. 2907.02(A)(2) Kidnapping R.C. 2905.01(A)(4) allied offenses R.C. 2941.25 weight of the evidence
- 2018 Ohio 1678State v. Stewart (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCING - R.C. 2929.14 imposition of consecutive sentences statutory findings trial court is not required to set forth the reasons to support its findings failure to incorporate findings in the sentencing entry nunc pro tunc entry.
- 2018 Ohio 1680State v. Walton (2018)
Trial courts must consider a list of factors addressing the seriousness of the offense and likelihood of recidivism in the process of imposing felony sentences. Consideration of these factors helps to ensure the overriding purposes of felony sentencing are followed.
- 2018 Ohio 1681State v. Coleman (2018)
The defendant-appellant's gross-sexual-imposition conviction is based on sufficient evidence and is not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 1682State v. Gault (2018)
Trial court's deviation from jointly recommended sentence was not clearly and convincingly contrary to law.
- 2018 Ohio 1684State v. Peters (2018)
Convictions for Aggravated Murder, Felonious Assault and Endangering Children were not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 1686State v. Mayweather (2018)
Anders/Sentences/Sentencing/Manifest weight of the evidence/Prosecutoral misconduct
- 2018 Ohio 1687In re J.C. (2018)
The juvenile court's decision finding it was in a child's best interest to grant permanent custody to appellee was not against the manifest weight of the evidence where appellant failed to complete many aspects of his case plan services, including parenting classes and a psychological evaluation, thereby leaving unresolved concerns regarding his substance abuse and untreated mental health issues.
- 2018 Ohio 1690State v. Beyduk (2018)
Appellate court lacked jurisdiction to review the merits of the appeal where appellant failed to file a notice of appeal within 30 days of the trial court's judgment entry succinctly overruling his motion
- 2018 Ohio 1693State ex rel. Witt v. Indus. Comm. (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Workers' compensation-Claimant's average weekly wage incorrectly calculated, resulting in overpayment of claim-Upon discovery of error, Bureau of Workers' Compensation adjusted claimant's average weekly wage-Industrial Commission affirmed adjustment and directed bureau to recoup overpayment from claimant's future benefits-R.C. 4123.52 grants the bureau and the commission authority to exercise continuing jurisdiction-Commission may modify former findings or orders if modification is justified-Court of appeals' judgment denying writ of mandamus to compel commission to vacate its order affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1694Giancola v. Azem (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Judgments-Remand-Law-of-the-case doctrine-Only those legal questions resolved by a reviewing court are the law of a case-On remand, parties are returned to the same position they were in prior to the appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 1696State v. King (2018)
Post Conviction Relief Barred by Res Judicata
- 2018 Ohio 1697Mathers v. Gibson (2018)
Complaint to sell trust real estate - SJ granted to guardian and against co-successor trustees
- 2018 Ohio 1698Appenzeller v. Dept. of Rehab. & Corr. (2018)
Court of Claims did not abuse its discretion by denying motion for relief from judgment under Civ.R. 60(B). The provision of the local rules of court cited by the appellant relating to case numbers did not substantiate appellant's claim that sentencing entries attached to affidavit in support of motion for summary judgment were fraudulent. Therefore, the Court of Claims did not abuse its discretion by concluding that appellant failed to demonstrate he was entitled to relief from the entry granting summary judgment.
- 2018 Ohio 1699Bates v. Merchants Holding, L.L.C. (2018)
Trial court erred by dismissing pursuant to Civ.R. 41(B)(1) cross-complaint and third-party complaint without providing requisite notice
- 2018 Ohio 1700State ex rel. Beyer v. Autoneum N. Am., Inc. (2018)
The magistrate erred in determining that the commission did not err in denying relator's request for compensation for partial loss of vision. Relator met his burden of demonstrating that his industrial injury is the proximate cause of his 35 percent loss of vision in his right eye. Objection sustained writ granted.
- 2018 Ohio 1701State v. Daniels (2018)
CRIM.R. 48(A) - COUNSEL - DOMESTIC VIOLENCE - R.C. 2919.25(A) - EVIDENCE - PHYSICAL HARM: The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying the state's Crim.R. 48(A) motion to dismiss the complaint, because the state did not establish good cause where the complaint was sufficient to charge a domestic-violence offense, the victim was present to testify, and the only explanation given by the state for the motion was that the victim, defendant's wife, had indicated that the charge stemmed from a heated argument with defendant. Defendant failed to show ineffective assistance of trial counsel where counsel's decision to try the case to the court was trial strategy, counsel's failure to object to certain evidence was not outcome determinative, and counsel's eliciting of allegedly prejudicial testimony from the victim was an attempt to impeach the witness. Defendant's conviction for domestic violence was not against the manifest weight of the evidence where the victim testified that the injury inflicted by defendant caused her pain, and the trial court found the victim to be more credible than defendant.
- 2018 Ohio 1702State v. Flagg (2018)
CONSTITUTIONAL LAW/CRIMINAL - DOUBLE JEOPARDY - AGGRAVATED MURDER - AGGRAVATED ROBBERY - EVIDENCE - ALLIED OFFENSES - R.C. 2941.25: Defendant's second trial on charges of aggravated murder, aggravated robbery, tampering with evidence and gross abuse of a corpse was not barred by double jeopardy where the judicial conduct giving rise to defendant's successful motion for a mistrial during her first jury trial was not intended to provoke the defendant into moving for a mistrial. Where defendant was charged with stabbing the victim to death, the trial court did not err in admitting into evidence four kitchen knives, none of which were the murder weapon, that were found at the scene of the crime, because the knives were admitted only to show the extent of the police investigation. The trial court did not err in admitting into evidence a folding knife, which was not the weapon that had caused the fatal wound, where the knife contained fibers that the trace-evidence expert testified could have come from the shirt the victim had been wearing at the time of the murder and where the coroner's report indicated that the folding knife could have made the three stab wounds on the victim's upper back. Defendant's convictions were supported by sufficient evidence and were not contrary to the manifest weight of the evidence where it was undisputed that the victim was killed shortly before 3:00 p.m. defendant's drug dealer testified that he picked defendant up close to 2:30 p.m. outside of the victim's apartment, and defendant had offered him the victim's cell phone in exchange for drugs a paper towel shaped like it had been wrapped around a door knob contained the defendant's DNA and was found just inside the victim's apartment and the state showed that defendant's half-brother, whom defendant claimed she believed killed the victim, was at work at the time of the murder. Aggravated murder and aggravated robbery were not allied offenses of similar import because the offenses were committed with a separate animus where the jury found that defendant's conduct demonstrated a specific intent to kill while in the course of committing the aggravated robbery.
- 2018 Ohio 1703State v. Barrow (2018)
KIDNAPPING - EVIDENCE - CONSTITUTIONAL LAW/CRIMINAL - OTHER ACTS - EVID.R. 404(B) - R.C. 2945.59 - COUNSEL - CONFLICT OF INTEREST: In a kidnapping prosecution, the trial court did not err in admitting a police officer's testimony regarding the state's investigation of and defendant's conviction for a prior kidnapping where the prior conviction was relevant to prove defendant's motive and intent, and therefore, did not violate the prohibition against "other acts" evidence in Evid.R. 404(B) and R.C. 2945.59, and the trial court properly instructed the jury that it could not consider the evidence to prove the defendant's character or that he had acted in conformity with that character but the trial court erred in permitting the officer to testify regarding a second kidnapping investigation in which defendant had not been charged, however, the testimony was harmless where the state presented overwhelming evidence of the defendant's guilt. The trial court did not abuse its discretion when it overruled defendant's motion for a mistrial, which was based on defendant's assertion that the state had failed to disclose the kidnapping victim's second interview with the investigating police officer in violation of Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 87, 83 S.Ct. 1194, 10 L.Ed.2d 215 (1963), because the defendant could not show that there was a reasonable probability that the outcome of the trial would have been different had the second statement been disclosed to defense counsel prior to trial. Defendant's kidnapping conviction was based on sufficient evidence where the state presented evidence, through testimony and telephone records, that defendant had arranged a meeting with the victim, defendant and his accomplices had removed the victim by force and held him for ransom in a van, telephone records connected defendant and his accomplices to a cell phone used to make ransom demands, and defendant's fingerprints and mail were found in the van where the victim had been held. Defendant's kidnapping conviction was not contrary to the manifest weight of the evidence where the jury chose to accord more weight to testimony of the state's witnesses than to defendant's testimony that he and the victim had devised a plan with others to extort $100,000 from the victim's brother and that victim was to receive $40,000 of the ransom money. Where a codefendant informed the trial court before closing arguments that he had been represented by defendant's counsel nine years earlier in an unrelated matter, and defendant did not raise any objection to the purported conflict, the trial court did not err by failing to conduct a further inquiry into the alleged conflict of interest, and defendant's counsel was not ineffective for failing to ask the court to further investigate the matter where the codefendant did not testify at trial and defendant testified against his counsel's advice that his codefendant had nothing to do with the kidnapping.
- 2018 Ohio 1705State v. Martin (2018)
motion to suppress - OVI - reasonable suspicion - probable cause - chemical testing - breath test - blood test - refusal
- 2018 Ohio 1706Hall v. Silver (2018)
rebuttable presumption of service - business address - hearing - service of process - due process - reasonably calculated - motion to vacate - Civ.R. 60(B) - common law - void
- 2018 Ohio 1707State v. Sky Lake (2018)
CRIMINAL - Trial court properly denied Appellants' motion to suppress as no constitutional violations occurred in the warrentless search of law enforcement as implied consent was given, or in the subsequent search of the premises with a warrant.
- 2018 Ohio 1708In re H.J.H. (2018)
permanent custody reasonable reunification efforts manifest weight of the evidence best interest of the child case plan compliance R.C. 2151.413 R.C. 2151.414 R.C. 2151.419 R.C. 2151.353
- 2018 Ohio 1709State v. Coleman (2018)
Criminal: validity of restitution award to law enforcement agency for recovery of cost of investigation R.C. 2929.18 plain error review.
- 2018 Ohio 1711State ex rel. Keith v. Adult Parole Auth. (2018)
Because relator did not set forth the account balance for the month immediately preceding the filing of his mandamus complaint, he did not comply with the filing requirements of R.C. 2969.25(C)(1). The court adopts the magistrate's decision fining the same and overrules relator's objection. The court sua sponte dismisses relator's request for a writ of mandamus.
- 2018 Ohio 1713Steele v. Chillicothe Corr. Inst. (2018)
The trial court ordered appellant to re-plead his complaint and notified appellant that failure to comply could result in dismissal of the complaint. Appellant did not comply. The trial court did not err in dismissing the complaint. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1714State ex rel. Vonderheide v. Multi-Color Corp. (2018)
Relator's objection sustained and writ of mandamus granted for TTD workers compensation benefits for woman who was family farm worker after being widowed, based undisputed evidence of her work on family farm. Magistrate's findings of fact adopted and additional findings made by appeals court. Magistrate's findings of law not adopted and appeals court holds decision of the Industrial Commission of Ohio is not based on some evidence, and thus abuse of discretion, reversing and remanding it to Industrial Commission for decision consistent with law.
- 2018 Ohio 1715Johnson v. Cleveland Police Dept. (2018)
Core Terms: public record court of claims R.C. 2743.75 R.C. 149.43 sui juris inmate R.C. 149.43(B)(8). Overview: Inmate sought investigatory records from his criminal prosecution. Respondent argued that as a police department it was not sui juris in this court. The special master recommended that the court find that R.C. 2743.75 and R.C. 149.43 make every public office sui juris for enforcement of violation of R.C. 149.43(B). The special master further recommended that the court find requester had not provided respondent with the judicial finding required from inmates under R.C. 149.43(B)(8) and that respondent had properly denied his public records request for criminal investigatory records.
- 2018 Ohio 1716Parks v. Webb (2018)
Core Terms: public record court of claims R.C. 2743.75 R.C. 149.43 R.C. 9.01 format metadata. Overview: Requester sought draft meeting minutes in the format they were kept at the time of the request. Respondent stated it had no duty to provide a document that could be edited, and produced the record in PDF format that was both less functional and contained less or different metadata. The special master recommended that the court order respondent to provide the record in the format in which it was kept. Outcome: The court determined that there was no error of law or other defect evident on the face of the special master's decision. The court adopted the special master's report and recommendation as its own, including findings of fact and conclusions of law contained therein.
- 2018 Ohio 1717Chernin v. Geauga Park Dist. (2018)
Core Terms: public record court of claims R.C. 2743.75 R.C. 149.43 R.C. 149.011(G) non-record constituent actual use. Overview: Requester sought letter used by park district board member to convey a constituent's opinions as well as support board limits on public participation at meetings. Respondent argued the letter was not shared with other members and therefore was not a "record." The special master found that the board member had made actual use of the letter to carry out and document the board's responsibilities, and it therefore met the definition of a record. Outcome: The court determined that there was no error of law or other defect evident on the face of the special master's decision. The court adopted the special master's report and recommendation as its own, including findings of fact and conclusions of law contained therein.
- 2018 Ohio 1718Naymik v. Northeast Ohio Areawide Coordinating Agency (2018)
Core Terms: public record court of claims R.C. 2743.75 R.C. 149.43 trade secret. Overview: Requester sought data, statistics and maps prepared by regional planning organization for inclusion in a bid to host a second national headquarters for Amazon, Inc. Respondent argued that the records were trade secret in their entirety. The special master recommended the court find that no part of the records were trade secret.
- 2018 Ohio 1720Sheil v. Horton (2018)
Core Terms: public record court of claims R.C. 2743.75 R.C. 149.43 R.C. 149.011(A) public office functional equivalent person responsible foundation trade secret. Overview: Requester sought a speaker contract entered into by Tri-C Foundation, a non-profit entity incorporated to solicit and receive contributions for a community college. Respondent argued that the foundation was not the functional equivalent of a public office. The special master recommended that the court find the foundation was both the functional equivalent of a public office, and a "person responsible for public records." The special master further recommended that the court find no part of the contract constituted trade secret, and that the court should grant requester's claim for disclosure.
- 2018 Ohio 1721Williams v. Dept. of Rehab. & Corr. (2018)
Inmate trial wrongful death survivorship bifurcated. The magistrate determined that defendant did not have sufficient notice, actual or constructive, to be liable for the fatal injuries that plaintiff's decedent sustained. Further, there was no credible evidence that the inmate that stabbed plaintiff's decedent ever threatened to harm plaintiff's decedent. Judgment recommended in favor of defendant.
- 2018 Ohio 1722State v. Rozell (2018)
The trial court did not err in overruling Appellant's presentence motion to withdraw guilty plea. The trial court also did not err in allowing Appellant's former defense counsel to testify at the hearing on the motion to withdraw guilty plea. Contrary to Appellant's claim otherwise, Appellant waived the attorney-client privilege when he testified at the hearing and published information regarding the communications he had with his former counsel. In addition, Appellant's ineffective assistance of counsel claim fails because Appellant failed to establish that his defense counsel performed deficiently. Affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1723In re Forfeiture of Property of Astin (2018)
The trial court erred in dismissing Appellant's civil forfeiture action for failing to state a claim upon which relief can be granted. In dismissing the action, the trial court retroactively applied a recent amendment to the civil forfeiture statute, R.C. 2981.05. The amendment at issue prevents the State from pursuing civil forfeiture actions against persons who received, retained, or possessed proceeds derived from a criminal offense in amounts less than $15,000. The retroactive application of this provision was improper because the General Assembly did not expressly indicate that amended R.C. 2981.05 should apply retroactively. Reversed and remanded for further proceedings. (Froelich, J., dissenting.)
- 2018 Ohio 1724State v. Harrison (2018)
Harrison was found not guilty of felonious assault and having weapons while under disability, and the trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying his pro se R.C. 2953.52 application to seal his record of acquittal for felonious assault after a hearing. Any error by the trial court in allowing the State to orally object to Harrison's application at the hearing as opposed to in writing is harmless. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1725Fredette v. Rion, Rion, & Rion (2018)
The plaintiff-appellant has appealed pro se from a final order entering summary judgment against him on the appellee's counterclaim. His assignments of error, however, relate exclusively to an earlier final order that contained Civ.R. 54(B) certification and entered judgment against him on his complaint. Because the appellant did not appeal from the final order entering judgment against him on his complaint, we cannot reach the merits of his arguments. While prior interlocutory orders will merge into a subsequent final judgment, that rule does not apply when the prior order is final at an earlier time. The trial court's entry of summary judgment against the appellant on his complaint was not an interlocutory order. It was a final order by virtue of the Civ.R. 54(B) certification it contained. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1726Evans v. Jeff Wyler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Ram of Springfield (2018)
The trial court erred in taking judicial notice of weather conditions, on the date of Appellant's slip and fall on ice, from an internet website that was introduced for the first time in Appellee's reply to Appellant's memorandum in opposition to Appellee's motion for summary judgment. Furthermore, the website evidence was not competent summary judgment evidence. Nevertheless, the trial court did not err in granting summary judgment in favor of Appellee. There was no genuine issue of material fact regarding the nature of the accumulation of ice upon which Appellant slipped and fell since the accumulation/formation was naturally occurring, Appellee had no duty to remove the ice. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1727State v. Buis (2018)
The trial court erred in finding that pre-indictment delay of a little more than two years resulted in actual prejudice to the defendant and warranted dismissing the indictment against him. The defendant made purely speculative arguments that missing evidence would have assisted him in attacking the credibility and weight of the prosecution's case against him. Judgment reversed and remanded. (Froelich, J., concurring.)
- 2018 Ohio 1728Bland v. Toyota Motor Sales U.S.A., Inc. (2018)
The trial court did not err in dismissing the appellants' complaint under Civ.R. 12(B)(6). The trial court correctly found that the complaint failed to state a claim for breach of contract. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1729State v. Bendolph (2018)
Both parties were surprised at trial by the testimony of an expert witness called by the defense, which revealed serology findings (the presence of semen on the victim) that had not previously been disclosed to either party. On this record and under the circumstances presented, defense counsel was not ineffective in calling the expert witness. Moreover, defendant's due process rights were not violated, because the defendant had not set forth a defense that conflicted with the expert's testimony and because the trial court instructed the jury to disregard the undisclosed evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1730State v. Link (2018)
Traffic: disobeying the instructions of a traffic control device, i.e., a stop sign R.C. 4511.12 R.C. 4511.43(A) statutory construction.
- 2018 Ohio 1731Bd. of Educ. of the Loveland City Sch. Dist. v. Bd. of Trs. of Symmes Twp. (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW/CIVIL - PROCEDURE/RULES - TAX - TOWNSHIPS - STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS - CONTINUOUS-VIOLATION DOCTRINE - DELAYED-DAMAGE RULE - DISCOVERY RULE: Because the township did not seek to change the judgment being appealed, its use of a "cross-appeal" to assert its arguments was improper and its "cross-appeal" was dismissed. Former R.C. 5715.27(F) did not provide the school board's exclusive remedy to challenge the tax exemptions granted as part of the amendment and expansion of the township's tax-increment fund ("TIF"), because the statute applied to a property owner seeking a real-property tax exemption. The two-year statute of limitations set forth in R.C. 2305.14 for actions against a political subdivision did not apply in an action where the school board challenged the township's amendment and expansion of the TIF, because the essence of the school board's claims was not money damages, but equitable relief. The statute of limitations in R.C. 2305.07 for liability created by a statute applied to the school board's action against the township relating to the amendment and expansion of the TIF, because the township could not have enacted the resolutions amending the TIF without the statutes specifically authorizing it to do so. The school board's cause of action accrued in 2003 when the township amended the TIF and allegedly improperly expanded the scope of the public improvements funded by the TIF, because that was when the alleged statutory violation had occurred. The continuous-violation doctrine did not apply because all of the alleged tortious activity was completed in 2003 the township's acts after that time were merely a continuation of the effects of the 2003 TIF amendment, and the school board knew or should have known about the amendment. The appellate court declined to apply the delayed-damage rule where R.C. 2305.07 applied even if the rule had applied, the damage occurred in 2003 when the amendment to the original TIF had been made. The discovery rule did not apply where by at least 2004 the school board had information sufficient to put it on notice of the possibility of wrongdoing that gave it a duty inquire into the matter.
- 2018 Ohio 1732State v. Steelman (2018)
CONSTITUTIONAL LAW/CRIMINAL - FIFTH AMENDMENT - EXCITED UTTERANCE - CONFRONTATION CLAUSE - PROSECUTORIAL MISCONDUCT - PLAIN ERROR - HARMLESS ERROR: Where the state presented evidence of defendant's silence and his refusal to talk to police as probative of defendant's guilt his Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination was violated however, there was no plain error because, absent the tainted evidence, there was overwhelming evidence of defendant's guilt. The trial court abused its discretion in admitting a witness's statement under the excited utterance exception to the hearsay rule where the statement did not relate to the startling event, was clearly self-serving, and was not the type of reactive statement contemplated by Evid.R. 803(2) but the error was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt where, even without the statement, there was overwhelming evidence of defendant's guilt. The prosecutor committed misconduct during closing argument by commenting on defendant's silence as evidence of his guilt and stating that the prosecutor knew several things "for a fact" but there was no plain error where the evidence of defendant's guilt was overwhelming.
- 2018 Ohio 1733In re B.M. (2018)
SELF-DEFENSE - EVIDENCE: The juvenile court erred in determining that the juvenile did not establish each element of the affirmative defense of self-defense using deadly force where she had stabbed her step-father in the arm and leg with a kitchen knife to free herself from his chokehold.
- 2018 Ohio 1734Disciplinary Counsel v. Brazil (2018)
Attorneys at law-Reciprocal discipline from the District of Columbia Court of Appeals-Five-year suspension-Gov.Bar R. V(11)(F)(4).
- 2018 Ohio 1736State v. Stokes (2018)
Appellant was not given an opportunity to allocute prior to probation violation sentencing. Judgment reversed.
- 2018 Ohio 1737State Ex Rel. Kenney v. City of Toledo (2018)
Six-year statute of limitations in R.C. 2305.07 applies because case does not involve "payment of unpaid minimum wages," as required for application of two-year statute of limitations in R.C. 2305.11(A). Appellees' claims not barred by laches when appellant did not show material prejudice because of the delay. Municipal code entitles appellees to payment for pension pick-ups, but not health insurance premiums, so court properly issued writ of mandamus for pension pickups and not premiums.
- 2018 Ohio 1738Houtz v. Houtz (2018)
The trial court did not err when it found appellant was not entitled to intervention under Civ.R 24(A), because appellant failed to satisfy the necessary elements.
- 2018 Ohio 1739State v. Edwards (2018)
Appellant's conviction for identity fraud was not supported by sufficient evidence. Manifest weight sufficiency complicity circumstantial evidence Miranda custodial interrogation.
- 2018 Ohio 1740State v. Dean (2018)
Two oral rape convictions did not merge with each other where the rapes, though occurring in close succession to one another, were each compelled by distinct threats of force. Kidnapping and rape convictions did not merge where the kidnapping involved a prolonged period of restraint, secret confinement, and substantial movement from the point of origin.
- 2018 Ohio 1741Bryant v. Indus. Power Sys., Inc. (2018)
Summary judgment for defendants in a slip and fall case is appropriate where the record contains no evidence that defendants had knowledge of the condition and thus were not actively negligent in permitting the unnatural accumulation of ice and snow.
- 2018 Ohio 1747State ex rel. Home Savings Bank v. Gallagher (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1748Ohio Plumbing, Ltd. v. Fiorilli Constr., Inc. (2018)
Arbitration provision commercial parties failure to pay presumption of arbitrability motion to stay pending arbitration R.C. 2711.02(B) in default of proceeding with arbitration procedural unconscionability substantive unconscionability. Trial court erred in denying contractor's motion to stay pending arbitration pursuant to R.C. 2711.02(B). Subcontractor's claims for breach of contract and violation of Ohio Prompt Payment Act were within the scope of arbitration provision. Contractor was not in default of proceeding with arbitration where it did not initiate arbitration proceedings prior to filing motion to stay. Arbitration provision was not unenforceable due to unconscionability grounds where subcontractor failed to offer any evidence of procedural unconscionability.
- 2018 Ohio 1749State v. Wimbley (2018)
Consecutive sentence R.C. 2929.14(C)(4) statutory findings R.C. 2953.08. The trial court made the statutorily required findings necessary to impose consecutive sentences under R.C. 2929.14(C)(4), and the findings were clearly and convincingly supported by the record.
- 2018 Ohio 1750State v. Bozso (2018)
R.C. 2943.031(D)/postsentence motion to withdraw plea INA 212(c)/immigration consequences.Appellant was prejudiced where his trial counsel failed to inform appellant that relief from immigration consequences was wholly unavailable to appellant.
- 2018 Ohio 1751Adams v. Relmax (2018)
Residential lease holdover tenant security deposit month-to-month tenancy lease agreement R.C. 5321.16(B) R.C. 5321.17(B). The lower court's judgment ordering landlord to return month-to-month holdover tenant's security deposit was in error where tenant failed to provide landlord 30 days notice of her intent to terminate the tenancy.
- 2018 Ohio 1752State v. Khoshknabi (2018)
Motion to withdraw guilty plea Crim.R. 32.1 manifest injustice deportation immigration passing bad checks theft ineffective assistance of counsel R.C. 2943.031 8 U.S.C. 1227. Appellant's trial counsel failed to properly advise him about the deportation consequences of his guilty plea. Appellant demonstrated a reasonable probability that but for counsel's erroneous advice, and had he known about the mandatory deportation consequences of his guilty plea, he would not have pled guilty and would have insisted on going to trial. Accordingly, the trial court abused its discretion in denying appellant's motion to withdraw his guilty plea.
- 2018 Ohio 1753State ex rel. McElrath v. City of Cleveland (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1754Kinasz v. Dickson (2018)
Summary judgment Civ.R. 56 legal malpractice statute of limitations R.C. 2305.11 cognizable event attorney-client relationship. Appellant failed to demonstrate a genuine issue of material fact as to when the statute of limitations for her legal malpractice claim accrued. Accordingly, the trial court properly granted summary judgment in favor of defendants-appellees.
- 2018 Ohio 1755Kobal v. Kobal (2018)
Divorce termination date de facto marital property separate property pro se. The trial court's order adopting the magistrate's decision granting plaintiff-appellee wife a divorce decree is affirmed. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in refusing to find a de facto termination date of the marriage earlier than the date of the final hearing because the parties presented no evidence of marital assets on the dates for which each party advocated. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in determining that the home defendant-appellant husband purchased prior to the marriage was not his separate property nor subject to a division of a property order because he transferred his interest in the home to his wife during the marriage who, in turn, transferred the home to the parties' adult sons. Likewise, the trial court did not abuse its discretion in finding that the funds from appellant's inheritance were no longer his because he had transferred the funds to a limited liability company owned by appellee without restriction. The appellant did not demonstrate that the trial court abused its discretion in adopting the magistrate's decision and the division of property order. A review of the record did not lead to the conclusion that the order was inequitable.
- 2018 Ohio 1756State v. Smith (2018)
Felonious assault aggravated assault inferior offense mistrial hung jury double jeopardy jury instructions final appealable order interlocutory appeal. Appellant was acquitted of felonious assault during the first trial, and thus, retrial on this count is barred by the Double Jeopardy Clause. Double jeopardy does not bar the state from retrying appellant on the abduction count because the jury was unable to reach a verdict on this count during the first trial. The trial court's judgment permitting the state to retry appellant for felonious assault is reversed and the matter is remanded for a new trial on only the abduction count.
- 2018 Ohio 1757Berryhill v. Khouri (2018)
Civ.R. 60(B), motion to vacate judgment, res judicata, law of the case. Appellant's claims under Civ.R. 60(B) lacked merit, and the trial court properly denied appellant's motion to vacate the judgment. Appellant's claims, sounding in liability, are barred by the doctrines of res judicata and law of the case.
- 2018 Ohio 1758Cleveland v. Calhoun (2018)
Domestic Violence, endangering children, sufficient evidence. Appellant's convictions of domestic violence and endangering children were not supported by sufficient evidence in the record. Appellant disciplined his 11 year old son by removing him from a car, shaking his arm, poking him in the chest with a finger and raising his voice. Appellant's son was unharmed and the state failed to present sufficient evidence of abuse to support a conviction for child endangering. Appellant's conviction for domestic violence also lacked sufficient evidence where appellant used his forearm to push his son's mother away from him when she intervened in the discipline.
- 2018 Ohio 1759State v. Grant (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1760State v. Perry (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1762State v. Newsome (2018)
right to testify at trial, failure to inquire, sufficiency of the evidence, self-defense, affirmative defense
- 2018 Ohio 1763State v. Davis (2018)
Miranda, public safety exception, homicide
- 2018 Ohio 1765Cavalry SPV I v. Taylor (2018)
complaint on credit card account Civ.R. 56(E) genuine issue of material fact existed to preclude summary judgment failure to file response to summary judgment, response to judgment
- 2018 Ohio 1766State v. Mencer (2018)
rape of a child under ten years of age sexual battery convictions supported by sufficient evidence jury's verdict was not against the manifest weight of the evidence trial court did not err in overruling motion for mistrial
- 2018 Ohio 1767State v. Teeple (2018)
The trial court erred by finding the defendant-appellant guilty of "hit-skip" upon his plea of no contest. Judgment affirmed in part and reversed in part
- 2018 Ohio 1768State v. Valdez (2018)
Defendant-appellant's convictions are not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Further, the prosecuting attorney's comments made during closing arguments did not affect the defendant-appellant's substantial rights. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1769State v. Craw (2018)
The trial court did not err in denying defendant-appellant's motions to suppress evidence because probable cause existed to issue a search warrant for defendant-appellant's travel trailer. The trial court did not err in denying defendant-appellant's motions to suppress evidence because the search warrant describes the items to be seized with sufficient particularity. The trial court did not err in denying defendant-appellant's motions to suppress evidence because defendant-appellant's pre-Miranda statements are admissible under the public-safety exception to the Miranda rule.
- 2018 Ohio 1770Roweton v. Willis (2018)
The trial court did not err in denying defendants'-appellants' motion for relief of judgment under Civ.R. 60(B).
- 2018 Ohio 1771State v. Dildine (2018)
The trial court did not err in sentencing the defendant-appellant to maximum consecutive sentences. The judgment of the trial court is affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1772State v. Carter (2018)
Defendant-appellant's post conviction motion was properly denied by the trial court on the basis of res judicata.
- 2018 Ohio 1773State v. Moore (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCING - R.C. 2929.14(C)(4) consecutive sentence failure to make findings for consecutive sentence at the sentencing hearing nunc pro tunc entry remand for resentencing.
- 2018 Ohio 1774State v. Leasock (2018)
CRIMINAL - manifest weight of the evidence credibility R.C. 2911.02(A)(2) robbery attempt to commit a theft offense complicity.
- 2018 Ohio 1775State v. Lusane (2018)
DRUNK DRIVING - R.C. 2941.1413 repeat OVI offender specification nature of previous five offenses misdemeanor or felony no requirement that at least one prior OVI be a felony res judicata.
- 2018 Ohio 1776State v. Anderson (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCING - trial court's imposition of two, one-year prison terms for post-release control violations is contrary to law R.C. 2929.141 only allows the sentencing court to impose one prison term for a post-release control violation.
- 2018 Ohio 1777State v. Clayton (2018)
Trial court properly dismissed defendant's postconviction relief petition alleging that the judge's signature on the search warrant was forged, because the claim was barred by res judicata.
- 2018 Ohio 1778State v. Moore (2018)
Trial court did not err in denying appellant's motion to suppress where appellant was not subject to a custodial interrogation requiring the issuance of Miranda warnings and the totality of the circumstances demonstrated the statement was voluntarily made. Appellant's 36-month prison sentence for tampering with evidence was supported by the record and was not contrary to law.
- 2018 Ohio 1779State v. Davidson (2018)
Appellant's convictions for unlawful sexual conduct with a minor and aggravated possession of drugs was supported by sufficient evidence where the state introduced testimony from the victim that appellant had engaged in sexual conduct with her after meeting on an online hookup website.
- 2018 Ohio 1780State v. Hines (2018)
Trial court did not abuse its discretion by refusing to provide jury instructions on lesser included offenses and admitting "other acts" evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 1781In re J.W. (2018)
Mother appeals juvenile court decision granting permanent custody of her children to a children services agency. Mother failed to object to magistrate's decision prior to appeal. Mother failed to demonstrate civil plain error in juvenile court's decision to grant permanent custody to children services agency where the court considered the appropriate statutory criteria and the evidence at the hearing supported the decision. Mother, a recovering heroin addict, failed to complete any case plan services. Mother failed to demonstrate civil plain error where she alleged the guardian ad litem failed to determine the children's wishes. The children were too young to express an informed choice to the guardian ad litem.
- 2018 Ohio 1782State v. Moore (2018)
Appellant's sentence was not contrary to law and was supported by the record where the trial court sentenced appellant within the sentencing guidelines and considered all required sentencing factors. The trial court was also not required to make findings before sentencing appellant to consecutive sentences because the statute requires a sentence for a violation of postrelease control sanctions to run consecutive to the sentence for the new felony.
- 2018 Ohio 1783Elliott-Thomas v. Smith (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Torts-Intentional spoliation of evidence-Allegations of intentional interference with or concealment of evidence are not actionable under the independent tort of intentional spoliation of evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 1785In re C.W. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1787In RE ADOPTION OF M.G.B.-E. Et Al. (2018)
Adoption-R.C. 3107.07(A)-A probate court must consider the existence of pending parenting matters when determining whether an exception to the requirement of parental consent to adoption applies.
- 2018 Ohio 1788Lazzerini v. Maier (2018)
Writ of Habeas Corpus
- 2018 Ohio 1790Trilogy Health Servs., L.L.C. v. Frenzley (2018)
Appeal of order granting motion for default judgment/Personal jurisdiction
- 2018 Ohio 1791Waterfall Victoria Master Fund 2008 1 v. Rittenhouse (2018)
Transfer of Mortgage Interest Substitution of Party
- 2018 Ohio 1792In re D.F. (2018)
Juvenile - serious youth offender - guardian ad litem - sex offender registration
- 2018 Ohio 1793State v. Kusmisz (2018)
Sentence Drug Trafficking
- 2018 Ohio 1794State v. Phillips (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1797State v. Robinson (2018)
DRUGS - EVIDENCE - PLEAS: Where defendant entered a no-contest plea to possessing drug-abuse instruments under R.C. 2925.12, which applies only where the instrument involved is a hypodermic or syringe, and the state's explanation of the circumstances showed that defendant possessed a crack pipe, the state failed to establish all of the elements of the offense, and the trial court erred in finding defendant guilty of possessing drug-abuse instruments.
- 2018 Ohio 1798McLaughlin v. Andy's Coin Laundries, L.L.C. (2018)
NEGLIGENCE - PRODUCTS LIABILITY: Where plaintiff was injured in a laundromat when he forced open the door on a malfunctioning washing machine with a screwdriver and then reached into the rotating drum to retrieve a comforter the trial court did not err in granting summary judgment on plaintiffs' claim for negligence, because the danger posed by the rotating washing machine drum was open and obvious and defendant laundromat owner owed no duty of care to the plaintiff to protect him from such danger. Because plaintiff's actions of forcing open a locked washing machine door with a screwdriver while the machine's drum was rotating, and then reaching into the rotating drum to remove a comforter, constituted misuse of the product and were not foreseeable, the trial court did not err in granting summary judgment on plaintiffs' products liability claims. [See CONCURRENCE: While plaintiff's act of reaching into the rotating washing machine drum was foreseeable, summary judgment was nonetheless appropriately granted to defendants on plaintiffs' products liability claims, because plaintiff assumed the risk of injury by voluntarily reaching into the rotating washing machine drum.]
- 2018 Ohio 1799State v. Vento (2018)
Ineffective assistance
- 2018 Ohio 1800Aljaberi v. Neurocare Ctr., Inc. (2018)
Privileged medical reports
- 2018 Ohio 1801Dean v. Marquis (2018)
Writ of Habeas Corpus
- 2018 Ohio 1802State v. Bilyk (2018)
Domestic violence/Threat of force/Manifest weight/Insufficient evidence
- 2018 Ohio 1803In re K.O. (2018)
Manifest Weight - Permanent Custody
- 2018 Ohio 1805State v. Watkins (2018)
Granting of judicial release is vacated and the case is remanded for additional fact finding.
- 2018 Ohio 1806State ex rel. Nationwide Children's Hosp. v. Indus. Comm. (2018)
Case in mandamus where self-insured employer is attempting to overturn the granting of permanent total disability compensation since the evidence before the Industral Commission fully supported the commission's order, the request for a writ is denied.
- 2018 Ohio 1807State v. Braden (2018)
Trial court did not err when it denied appellant's motion for new trial based on res judicata.
- 2018 Ohio 1808Eschborn v. Ohio Dep't of Transp. (2018)
Ohio Court of Claims' grant of summary judgment to Ohio Department of Transportation reversed when appellate court de novo found Court of Claims weighed evidence and decided witness credibility about statements made under oath offered to refute summary judgment. Judgment reversed and cause remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 1809State v. Robinson (2018)
Appellant's convictions for trafficking heroin were supported by sufficient evidence and were not against the manifest weight of the evidence. The intercepted telephone calls between appellant and his supplier constituted substantial circumstantial evidence that supported appellant's convictions.
- 2018 Ohio 1810Walker v. Nationwide Mut. Ins. Co. (2018)
Judgment affirmed. The trial court did not err when it granted summary judgment in favor of appellee. Under Ohio's borrowing statute, R.C. 2305.03, and controlling choice of law principles, Tennessee law applied to appellant's wrongful termination claims. Consequently, appellant's claims were time-barred under that state's statute of limitations.
- 2018 Ohio 1811Doran v. Heartland Bank (2018)
Appeal dismissed. Since the non-compete and non-solicitation covenants are the subject of the parties' assignments of error, and said provisions expired on May 9, 2017, any judgment of this court would not have any impact on a genuine, live controversy. As such, the parties' assignments of error are moot and this matter is dismissed for lack of jurisdiction.
- 2018 Ohio 1812State v. Upkins (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Appeal dismissed as having been improvidently accepted.
- 2018 Ohio 1813State v. McShaffrey (2018)
Gross sexual imposition, R.C. 2907.05(A)(5) Crim.R. 29, sufficiency of the evidence, sexual contact, purpose of sexually arousing or gratifying, manifest weight of the evidence, maximum sentence, State v. Marcum, R.C. 2953.08(G)(2), presentence investigation report, incomplete record
- 2018 Ohio 1814In re J.B. (2018)
appointed counsel - substitution of counsel - necessary inquiry - adequate representation
- 2018 Ohio 1815State v. Ammons (2018)
R.C. 2929.14(C)(4), R.C. 2921.331, consecutive sentences, R.C. 2929.19(B)(2)(f)
- 2018 Ohio 1816State v. Lincoln (2018)
Criminal: Trial court erred in fashoning sanctions for the State's Crim.R. 16 discovery violation requiring reversal and remand for new trial in drug trafficking and drug possession case.
- 2018 Ohio 1817Bear v. Buchanan (2018)
rape R.C. 2907.02(A)(2) habeas R.C. 2725.01 R.C. 2152.12(J) transfers of case from juvenile court juvenile court without jurisdiction when defendant not taken into custody or apprehended until after the person attains twenty-one years of age
- 2018 Ohio 1818State v. McKinnon (2018)
application to reopen, untimely App. R. 26 (B)(2)(d)
- 2018 Ohio 1819State v. Haddix (2018)
Jurisdiction/Post conviction relief
- 2018 Ohio 1822State ex rel. Bristow v. Brown (2018)
Petition for writ of mandamus denied where it does not meet the basic requirements for filing in that it does not comply with Civ.R. 10 and 11 requiring an address for relator.
- 2018 Ohio 1824State v. Yavorcik (2018)
R.C. 2923.32, Ohio Corrupt Practices Act, pattern of corrupt activity, criminal enterprise, R.C. 2923.01, conspiracy to engage in a pattern of corrupt activity, R.C. 2901.12(H), venue, course of conduct, Crim.R. 29(C), motion for judgment of acquittal for lack of venue. The trial court erred in denying defendant's motion for judgment of acquittal for lack of venue pursuant to Crim.R. 29(C) and determining that venue was proper in Cuyahoga County. Venue lies where a member of an enterprise conducts an illegal act in furtherance of the purpose of the enterprise. The evidence is insufficient to support that the alleged conspiracies are related to the affairs of the same enterprise and formed for a common purpose. A pattern of corrupt activity by a criminal enterprise is not established by asserting that various unindicted individuals engaged in predicate crimes at various times independently and without coordination. Separate conspiracies by different enterprises for different purposes may not be boot strapped in an attempt to support a pattern of corrupt activity for the purpose of establishing venue in a legally remote jurisdiction.
- 2018 Ohio 1825State v. Moore (2018)
Sexual battery, coercion, sufficiency of the evidence, manifest weight of the evidence, credibility, inconsistency, DNA. Appellant's conviction for sexual battery is supported by sufficient evidence because under the sufficiency standard, a reasonable juror could find that the appellant knowingly coerced the victim to engage in sexual conduct, if the jury believed the victim's testimony. However, his conviction is against the manifest weight of the evidence because the victim's trial testimony was inconsistent and contradictory with her narrative given to medical professionals a day after the incident, and with the statement given to police. These inconsistencies coupled with no DNA evidence substantiating the victim's testimony, warranted reversal.
- 2018 Ohio 1826Neel v. A. Perrino Constr., Inc. (2018)
Motion to stay proceedings arbitration R.C. 2711.02 unconscionability ambiguity consumer construction contract R.C. 4722.02 waiver of right to arbitrate loser-pays provision. The trial court did not err in granting a motion to stay pending arbitration because the arbitration clause of the agreement was not unconscionable or ambiguous and Perrino did not waive their right to arbitration. The trial court erred in failing to stay all claims against all parties pending arbitration.
- 2018 Ohio 1827State v. McSwain (2018)
App.R. 26(B) application for reopening, untimely filed, failure to establish good cause for untimely filing. The applicant has filed an untimely App.R. 26(B) application for reopening. No attempt was made by the applicant to establish "good cause" for the untimely filing of the application for reopening. The application for reopening is denied.
- 2018 Ohio 1829Woods Cove III, L. L.C. v. Am. Guaranteed Mgmt. Co. (2018)
Summary judgment constitutionality tax certificate foreclosure statute attorney general R.C. 5721.371 magistrate's decision extension of time motion to reconsider jurisdiction declaratory judgment. Trial court properly granted summary judgment ordering foreclosure on tax certificate holder's certificates where delinquent property owners did not produce any evidence demonstrating a genuine issue of material fact regarding the certificate owner's right to foreclose or the amounts due trial court was without jurisdiction to render a declaratory judgment regarding the constitutionality of Ohio's tax certificate legislation because the Ohio attorney general was not served in the action as required by R.C. 2721.12(A) the trial court did not err in adopting the magistrate's decision awarding attorney fees even without a determination of the reasonableness of the fees because the magistrate awarded attorney fees less than $2,500 and under R.C. 5721.371(B)(1), attorney fees less than or equal to $2,500 are presumptively reasonable trial court did not err in denying appellants' motion for extension of time to respond to magistrate's decision where appellants' counsel was not newly retained and had been working on the case for two months before he filed a notice of appearance trial court did not err in denying appellants' motion for reconsideration because it raised new issues that were not raised in appellants' motions for summary judgment and responses to plaintiff's summary judgment motion.
- 2018 Ohio 1830State ex rel. McKernan v. Seven Hills City Council (2018)
Declaratory judgment, Ordinance, R.C. 733.59, R.C. 731.30. In a statutory taxpayer's action for injunctive relief pursuant to R.C. 733.59, the trial court erred in denying appellant's motion for summary judgment as moot as to her request for costs and reasonable attorney fees pursuant to R.C. 733.61 where the action was rendered moot by the municipality's repeal of the ordinance in question prior to judgment.
- 2018 Ohio 1831Fannie Mae v. Hicks (2018)
Foreclosure damages possession purchaser jurisdiction pending appeal abeyance. Trial court erred in denying motion for a hearing on damages where court denied the motion due to a pending appeal rather than holding the motion in abeyance until the appeal was decided. And principles of equity and fairness require the trial court hold a hearing on damages sustained to the property while it was in bank's possession before being returned to the property owner as a result of a vacated judgment in foreclosure.
- 2018 Ohio 1832State v. Rucker (2018)
Motion for a mistrial, discovery violations, jail house phone calls, sufficient evidence, consecutive sentences. Trial court did not err in denying appellant's motion for a mistrial based on a surprise in-court identification made by a police officer who engaged in a footchase with appellant. Appellant could not establish that the prosecutor committed a willful violation of the discovery rules. Calls to appellant from associates in jail were properly authenticated. The state presented sufficient identification evidence tying appellant to the offenses in an aiding and abetting role. The trial court did not err in imposing consecutive sentences but appellant's journal entry did not comply with State v. Bonnell, 140 Ohio St.3d 209, 2014-Ohio-3177, 16 N.E.3d 659.
- 2018 Ohio 1833Bank of New York Mellon v. Primes (2018)
Foreclosure mortgage promissory note personal knowledge Civ.R. 56(E) standing equitable assignment. Loan analyst who stated he worked for both parent company and subsidiary company that serviced loan documents established firsthand knowledge that bank possessed promissory note. Debtor's standing arguments rendered immaterial because bank possessed promissory note indorsed in blank, established that it was a person entitled to enforce the note, so an equitable mortgage arose under law that security follows the debt.
- 2018 Ohio 1834State v. Morgan (2018)
Restitution, stipulation, ability to pay, consideration, sentence, contrary to law, supported by the record. The record demonstrates that the trial court considered appellant's present and future ability to pay restitution when sufficient information was contained in the presentence investigation report. Additionally, the appellant stipulated to the restitution amount and order. Appellant's maximum sentence is not contrary to law and is supported by the record.
- 2018 Ohio 1835State v. Ellison (2018)
Because the trial court's judgment is ambiguous regarding whether the court made the two findings required in R.C. 2945.39(A)(2) using the correct standard of review, the matter is remanded to the trial court to clarify the ambiguity.
- 2018 Ohio 1836State v. Scarbrough (2018)
Where a trial court sentence imposed on a defendant is consistent with and in furtherance of a jointly recommended sentence contained in a plea agreement and where that sentence was not unlawful, a motion for resentencing was appropriately denied.
- 2018 Ohio 1837Rieger v. Giant Eagle, Inc. (2018)
Directed verdict Civ.R. 50 de novo negligence negligent entrustment punitive damages R.C. 2315.21 punitive damages cap unconstitutional as applied Gore Factors reprehensibility excessive admissibility of evidence. Compensatory damages award affirmed, punitive damages award reversed and remanded to trial court with instructions to enter award twice the compensatory damages amount. Trial court did not err when it denied defendant's motion for directed verdict with respect to negligence, negligent entrustment, and punitive damages. The $1,198,000 punitive damages award was unconstitutionally excessive under the Gore factors. There was no evidence of reprehensibility by the defendant. Therefore, the punitive damages award should be capped at $242,000 or twice the compensatory damages award. The trial court's admissions of post-incident accidents was harmless error. The admission of prior similar incidents was not an abuse of discretion.
- 2018 Ohio 1838State v. Trussell (2018)
Challenge for cause Crim.R. 24(C) manifest weight of the evidence credibility ineffective assistance of counsel. Defendant-appellant's jury convictions for rape, kidnapping, and domestic violence affirmed. Defendant was not prejudiced by the trial court's denial of his challenge for cause that caused his counsel to exercise the final peremptory challenge. The trial court heard the challenged juror testify that she could be fair and impartial in the present case even though she volunteered at a rape crisis telephone hotline 25 years prior. Defendant's convictions for rape and kidnapping were not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Defendant's attacks of the victim's credibility ignored important aspects of her testimony. Defense counsel was not ineffective for failing to subpoena video surveillance footage to impeach the victim's credibility. Defendant failed to demonstrate that counsel's failure to subpoena this evidence fell below an objective standard of professional reasonableness or resulted in prejudice to the defense.
- 2018 Ohio 1839State v. Lee (2018)
R.C. 2953.08(D)(1) agreed sentence appellate review. Appellant's sentences are authorized by law and are ones that were jointly recommended by the parties and imposed by the trial court. There was no mandatory duty for the court to address R.C. 2941.25 in this case, and thus, the sentences were authorized by law.
- 2018 Ohio 1840T.D. v. C.N. (2018)
Civil Stalking Protection Order R.C. 2903.211 sufficiency manifest weight First Amendment. Petitioner established requirements of R.C. 2903.211 by a preponderance of the evidence so CSPO was properly granted grounds for relief from judgment were not established, but First Amendment concerns required limiting the 500 feet restriction.
- 2018 Ohio 1850Graham v. City of Lakewood (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1853State v. Owens (2018)
SENTENCING - MANDATORY FINE - INDIGENCY: Even though defendant did not file an affidavit of indigency under R.C. 2929.18(B)(1) to avoid the imposition of mandatory fines, defendant did not waive his right to challenge on appeal the imposition of mandatory fines where the trial court's insistence on defendant's submission of five years of tax returns before it would consider whether he was indigent made clear that the filing of an affidavit of indigency would be of no consequence and a futile act. The trial court's imposition of mandatory fines pursuant to R.C. 2929.18(B)(1) was contrary to law where the court required as a prerequisite to a finding of indigency the submission of five years of defendant's tax returns.
- 2018 Ohio 1854The STATE EX REL. GADELL-NEWTON v. HUSTED Et Al. (2018)
Elections-Request for declaration that digital ballot images are public records subject to R.C. 149.351(A) and for writ of mandamus ordering boards of elections to refrain from deleting digital ballot images dismissed for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction.
- 2018 Ohio 1856Disciplinary Counsel v. Brown (2018)
On certification of default.
- 2018 Ohio 1857Disciplinary Counsel v. Bennett (2018)
On certification of default.
- 2018 Ohio 1859Tackle Constr. Group, L.L.C. v. Pedtke Ents., Inc. (2018)
The trial court did not err by granting Appellee a set-off from the amount that it owes Appellant. The manifest weight of the evidence shows that Appellant wrongfully failed to complete construction work on a project, that this caused Appellee to lose the project, and that the loss of the project led to Appellee suffering monetary damages. The trial court also did not err by not awarding Appellant prejudgment interest. Appellant did not ask for prejudgment interest timely. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1860State v. Swiadek (2018)
Anders appeal. After a bench trial, defendant was convicted of public indecency and sentenced to a suspended jail term, probation, and a $50 fine. Upon our independent review of the record, no non-frivolous issues found. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1862In re C.P. (2018)
Anders appeal. No non-frivolous issues for appellate review. The record supports the trial court's award of permanent custody to Clark County Department of Job and Family Services. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1863State v. Howard (2018)
The juvenile court did not abuse its discretion in transferring Appellant's case to adult criminal court, as the juvenile court weighed the required statutory factors under R.C. 2152.12(D) and (E), and provided specific reasons for finding Appellant unamenable to care and rehabilitation in the juvenile justice system, all of which were rationally supported by the record. Affirmed. (Donovan, J., concurring.)
- 2018 Ohio 1864State v. Hopkins (2018)
Defendant-appellant, following a jury trial and merger determinations, was convicted and sentenced for murder (purposeful) and an attached repeat violent offender specification, felonious assault (serious harm) and an attached repeat violent offender specification, and having weapons under disability. The trial court did not abuse its discretion by admitting into evidence, under Evid.R. 404(B), Defendant-appellant's prior assault upon the felonious assault victim which occurred approximately six weeks prior to the events leading to Defendant-appellant's indictment. The trial court did not abuse its discretion by admitting statements made by the felonious assault victim as excited utterances. The trial court did not err by its failure to merge the murder and felonious assault counts because the murder involved the felonious assault victim's viable fetus. Thus, each count involved a separate victim. The record does not demonstrate ineffective assistance of counsel or prosecutorial misconduct. The weapons under disability conviction is supported by sufficient evidence. The trial court did not err by overruling Defendant-appellant's motion to suppress statements. The issue of the trial court's failure to conduct a community control sanctions revocation hearing in a separate case is not before the court. The trial court did not abuse its discretion by the admission of autopsy photographs. Defendant-appellant did not timely assert any challenge to the array of potential jurors. Finally, Defendant-appellant has not demonstrated cumulative error. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1865State v. Baker (2018)
Defendant was convicted in 2004 of attempted felony murder (Count I) and two counts of felonious assault (Counts II and IV) Counts I and II involved victim 1, and Count IV involved victim 2. After merging Count IV for sentencing, defendant was originally sentenced on Counts I and II, the attempted felony murder and felonious assault on victim 1. In 2017, upon motion by the defendant based on an Ohio Supreme Court case, the trial court vacated the conviction for Count I the court then resentenced defendant on Counts II and IV, stating that its original sentence on Count II was a "scrivener's error" and should have been on Count IV and that Count II had been merged with Count I. The trial court did not violate double jeopardy when it sentenced defendant on Count IV. The trial court's statement in the original judgment entry that defendant was acquitted of Count IV was a typographical error the jury had found defendant guilty of Count IV and the trial court stated at the original sentencing that it was merging that count for sentencing as an allied offense of similar import. The trial court's imposition of sentence on Count II at the original sentencing was not a "scrivener's error." Although the trial court may have intended to sentence the defendant on Count IV (felonious assault on victim 2) and merge Count II (felonious assault on victim 1), the court orally imposed sentence on Count II and expressly stated that Count IV would be merged. Even if erroneous, that sentence was not challenged on direct appeal, was now final, and could not be changed upon resentencing. And, because the trial court apparently merged Count IV into Count II at the original sentencing hearing, the trial court lacked authority in 2017 to impose a sentence on Count IV upon vacating Count I. Judgment reversed, and case remanded for an amended judgment entry consistent with this Opinion.
- 2018 Ohio 1866State v. Aicher (2018)
The trial court did not err in overruling Appellant's motion to suppress evidence flowing from field sobriety tests and a breath sample. Contrary to Appellant's claim otherwise, the officer on duty had a reasonable, articulable suspicion that Appellant was driving under the influence of alcohol to justify performing the field sobriety tests. In addition, the State provided sufficient evidence that Aicher's breath sample was tested in substantial compliance with the Ohio Department of Health's regulations. Affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1867Woods v. Progressive Direct Ins. Co. (2018)
In successive actions regarding the interpretation of an automobile insurance policy, the trial court did not err in either granting motions for default judgment or summary judgment. Declaratory judgment counterclaim request for admissions res judicata collateral estoppel issue preclusion summary judgment.
- 2018 Ohio 1868State v. Williams (2018)
Appellant's motion for a new trial lacks merit, and also, is barred by res judicata. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1869State v. Tucker (2018)
Failure to conduct preliminary hearing within ten days did not entitle appellant to dismissal of charges where he failed to object and was later indicted. Court committed no plain error in instructing jury on "knowingly." State presented evidence of "force" element of robbery and jury did not clearly lose way in finding element proven. Trial court was not required to consider ability to pay costs of prosecution. Prosecutor's improper comments during closing did not rise to level of plain error.
- 2018 Ohio 1870State v. Ramirez (2018)
State appeal. Insufficient evidence to sustain jury's verdict. Judgment of acquittal. Double jeopardy.
- 2018 Ohio 1871State v. Myers (2018)
Trial court's denial of appellant's motion to vacate was a nullity as a motion for a delayed appeal in this case was pending before our court at the time the trial court issued its decision and, therefore, the trial court was without jurisdiction to act on appellant's motion to vacate.
- 2018 Ohio 1872State v. Jividen (2018)
An entry on the trial court's docket, which found that appellant pleaded guilty to the charges, sentenced appellant, and dismissed any remaining pending charges, and which was separately signed by the trial court judge and file stamped as a judgment entry by the clerk, was a final appealable order.
- 2018 Ohio 1873State v. Madrid (2018)
Trial court properly denied appellant's motion to vacate his postrelease control sanction where his sentencing entry complied with the sentencing statutes as interpreted by the Ohio Supreme Court at the time of sentencing and subsequent case law is not retroactively applied.
- 2018 Ohio 1874State v. Lear (2018)
Crim.R. 5(B)(1) does not apply to require bind over of misdemeanor where defendant has not been charged with related felony in municipal court. Trial court could not properly rely on this rule to dismiss misdemeanor charge under Crim.R. 48. Under "same elements" test, double jeopardy not violated by successive prosecutions for felony domestic violence and misdemeanor violation of protection order.
- 2018 Ohio 1875State v. Gates (2018)
Rape and gross sexual imposition were not allied offenses of similar import where the convictions were based on separate acts. Corpus delecti is satisfied where appellant's confession is supported by circumstantial evidence tending to demonstrate that appellant committed the offenses to which he pleaded guilty.
- 2018 Ohio 1876State v. Reed (2018)
Anders brief. Potential error where trial court may not have properly granted confinement credit for appellant's time served on electronic monitoring.
- 2018 Ohio 1878State v. Biggins (2018)
Ineffective assistance of counsel - stipulation - restitution - insurance proceeds - prejudice.
- 2018 Ohio 1879Bank of New York Mellon v. Chappell (2018)
Foreclosure - Note - Mortgage - payment increase - condition precedent - equitable remedy.
- 2018 Ohio 1881PNC Bank v. Myers (2018)
note - mortgage - default - foreclosure - double-dismissal rule - Civ.R. 41 - res judicata - common nucleus of operative facts - payments
- 2018 Ohio 1883State v. Gilbert (2018)
Aggravated menacing, music video, Facebook, sufficiency of the evidence, manifest weight of the evidence
- 2018 Ohio 1884State v. Carroll (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - robbery theft from a person in a protected class theft forgery bench trial evidentiary rulings abuse of discretion standard of review. INEFFECTIVE ASSISTANCE OF COUNSEL - two-prong test Evid.R. 801 Evid.R. 802 Evid.R. 803(6) Evid.R. 901(A) and (B) photocopies of bank checks are self-authenticating restitution Crim.R. 52(B) PSI trial court considered appellant's present and future ability to pay R.C. 2929.18(A)(1).
- 2018 Ohio 1885State v. Zakrajsek (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - denial of motion for judicial release is not a final appealable order.
- 2018 Ohio 1886State v. Tell (2018)
CRIMINAL - Rape R.C. 2907.02(A)(2) relevant evidence unfair prejudice Evid.R. 403(A) victim impact evidence weight of the evidence felony sentencing R.C. 2929.19(B)(2)(f)
- 2018 Ohio 1887JP Morgan Chase Bank v. Ritchey (2018)
CIVIL - foreclosure sheriff's sale confirmation of sale Lake County Local Rules 7.03 and 7.04 notice of sale R.C. 2329.26(A) unsupported argument App.R. 12(A)(2) and (7) appraisal R.C. 2329.17
- 2018 Ohio 1888State v. Zakrajsek (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - denial of motion for judicial release is not a final appealable order.
- 2018 Ohio 1890Knapp v. Defiance Therapeutic Massage & Wellness Ctr., LLC (2018)
The trial court did not err by affirming the Unemployment Compensation Review Commission's decision allowing claimant-appellee's application for unemployment compensation. There is some competent, credible evidence supporting the Commission's determination that claimant-appellee worked in covered employment with appellant.
- 2018 Ohio 1891Cline v. Defiance Therapeutic Massage & Wellness Ctr., LLC (2018)
The trial court did not err by affirming the Unemployment Compensation Review Commission's decision allowing claimant-appellee's request for unemployment compensation. There is some competent, credible evidence supporting the Commission's determination that claimant-appellee worked in covered employment with appellant.
- 2018 Ohio 1892State v. DeWitt (2018)
Appellant's conviction for aggravated possession of drugs and possession of drug paraphernalia was not against the manifest weight of the evidence where the record contained ample evidence indicating the drugs and drug paraphernalia located in and around a car driven by appellant were in appellant's constructive, if not actual, possession so as to support the jury's guilty verdict.
- 2018 Ohio 1893State v. Allgeyer (2018)
Defendant, the former director of a Pee Wee cheerleading organization, appeals her conviction for grand theft, arising out of allegations that she used the organization's bank card to obtain cash and pay for thousands of dollars of unauthorized meals, fuel, and personal goods. Defendant's convictions were supported by sufficient evidence and the manifest weight of the evidence where the evidence indicated that the director would have known that her use of the bank card would not be permitted by the organization and where she failed to provide receipts for suspect transactions to the organization treasurer. Circumstantial evidence established that the defendant possessed and used the bank card.
- 2018 Ohio 1894State v. Reese (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1895Navistar, Inc. v. Testa (Slip Opinion) (2018)
R.C. 5751.53-Commercial-activity-tax credit-Board of Tax Appeals ("BTA") properly carried out our instructions on remand-BTA's decision holding that the original valuation allowance reported on taxpayer's Amortizable Amount Report was not in compliance with generally accepted accounting principles affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1896In re Mitchell (2018)
On certified entry of felony conviction.
- 2018 Ohio 1899State v. Beebe (2018)
Aggravated Menacing Road Rage Incident Admissibility of Victim's Concealed Carry Permit
- 2018 Ohio 1900State v. Akusoba (2018)
Sentence already served - Appeal Moot
- 2018 Ohio 1903State v. Myers (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Criminal Law-Aggravated murder-Convictions and death penalty affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1904Dayton Bar Assn. v. Strahorn (2018)
On order to show cause.
- 2018 Ohio 1905State v. Poole (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1909Cordell v. White (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1910Stroud v. Four E Properties, Inc. (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW/CIVIL - CIV.R. 15 - PROCEDURE/RULES: Where appellant failed to transmit all parts of the record necessary to resolve an assignment of error, appellant was unable to demonstrate that error, and the appellate court presumed the regularity of the proceedings below and affirmed the trial court's judgment. Where the trial court had entered a final judgment, appellant's Civ.R. 15 motion for leave to file an amended complaint was a legal nullity.
- 2018 Ohio 1911State v. Lewis (2018)
Counsel was not ineffective for allegedly arguing a sentence lower than the statutorily mandated sentence at the sentencing hearing. Defendant was aware of the correct sentence before she changed her plea. Thus, there was no prejudice.
- 2018 Ohio 1912State v. Pilkington (2018)
Trial court did not err in compelling defendant to submit to psychological evaluation for motion to suppress when defendant placed her mental state at the time of police interrogations at issue.
- 2018 Ohio 1915Cleveland Plating, L.L.C. v. Dept. of Job & Family Servs. (2018)
On the authority of State ex rel. Valley Roofing, L.L.C. v. Ohio Bur. of Workers' Comp., 122 Ohio St.3d 275, 2009-Ohio-2684, we conclude that the trial court did not err in reversing a decision of the Ohio Unemployment Compensation Review Commission finding that appellee is a successor in interest pursuant to R.C. 4141.24(F). Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1917State v. Wilburn (2018)
The trial court properly considered the overriding purposes of sentencing and the seriousness and recidivism factors of R.C. 2929.12 when it imposed prison terms for the violation of defendant's community control. The trial court also did not err in sentencing defendant to more than the minimum term.
- 2018 Ohio 1918State v. McDonald-Glasco (2018)
The sufficiency and manifest weight of the evidence supports McDonald-Glasco's convictions, the trial court did not abuse its discretion in instructing the jury, and the trial court did not err in denying McDonald-Glasco's Crim.R. 29 motion for acquittal.
- 2018 Ohio 1919Research Group, Inc. v. Akron Baptist Temple, Inc. (2018)
venue - transfer - Civ.R. 3 - motion to dismiss - Civ.R. 12(B)(6)
- 2018 Ohio 1920State v. Hudson (2018)
robbery - theft offense - threat of force - sufficiency - manifest weight - gas station - racial slur
- 2018 Ohio 1921Unifund CCR, L.L.C. v. Husain (2018)
default judgment, service, Civ.R. 4.6, Civ.R. 55, abuse of discretion
- 2018 Ohio 1922State v. Rinella (2018)
jail time credit - work release program - Oriana House
- 2018 Ohio 1923State v. Coleman (2018)
Illegal use of food stamps or WIC program benefits, assault, improperly handling firearms in a motor vehicle, sufficiency of the evidence, manifest weight of the evidence
- 2018 Ohio 1924State v. Gheen (2018)
burglary State v. Toney, 23 Ohio App.2d 203, 262 N.E.2d 419 (7th Dist. 1970) counsel's motion to withdraw granted Crim.R. 11(C)(2)(c) strict compliance for advisement of constitutional rights plea
- 2018 Ohio 1925State v. Kosto (2018)
Involuntary manslaughter
- 2018 Ohio 1926State v. Korbel (2018)
Indictment Not Fatally Defective Bill of Particulars
- 2018 Ohio 1927Hinerman v. Grill on Twenty First, L.L.C. (2018)
Discovery - attorney client privilege - joint representation
- 2018 Ohio 1928State v. Rembert (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1931Huth v. Kus (2018)
Statements of a party opponment are not hearsay, therefore trial court erred by excluding statements under Evid. R. 804(B)(5)
- 2018 Ohio 1933In re K.W. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1934Mid Ohio Coal Co. v. Brown (2018)
Construction of deed/Mineral, gas, oil interests
- 2018 Ohio 1935State v. Rardon (2018)
Drug trafficking and possession/Other acts evidence/Evid. R. 701/Inconsistant verdicts/Manifest weight
- 2018 Ohio 1937State v. Smith (2018)
An appellate court is empowered by both App.R. 12(A)(1)(a) and R.C. 2953.08(G)(2) to modify a sentence imposed by a trial court.
- 2018 Ohio 1938State v. Cox (2018)
When a suspect admitted to having contraband in a car and in her purse, it was not error to fail to suppress the warrantless search of that purse. When only one or two hours had elapsed since a Miranda warning was given to a suspect in custody, the warning had not yet become stale at the time of questioning. Where a defendant admitted to having attempted to dispose of guns she correctly believed were illegally carried, her conviction for tampering with evidence was sufficiently supported and not contrary to the manifest weight of the evidence. And where the evidence permitted a reasonable juror to infer that the defendant either possessed heroin because it was hers or possessed it because she was hiding it for another, the defendant was properly found guilty of heroin possession.
- 2018 Ohio 1939State v. Gray (2018)
State concedes error in that appellant was charged under an incorrect code section and his conviction for R.C. 4511.48(C) was not supported by sufficient evidence and was against the manifest weight of the evidence. Accordingly, the court reverses and vacates the judgment of the trial court.
- 2018 Ohio 1940Vossman v. AirNet Sys., Inc. (2018)
The trial court erred in awarding appellee attorney fees for alleged frivolous conduct by appellant pursuant to R.C. 2323.51(A)(2)(a)(ii). The court sustains appellant's assignment of error that the trial court erred in finding appellant's claims of age discrimination were not warranted under existing law as it cannot find that "no reasonable lawyer would have brought the action in light of existing law." Judgment reversed.
- 2018 Ohio 1943State v. Salahuddin (2018)
Appellant's trial counsel did not render ineffective assistance. The record establishes that appellant's guilty pleas were knowingly, voluntarily, and intelligently made, and there is no evidence in the record that his counsel was in any way ineffective for advising him to enter guilty pleas to any of the charged offenses, specifically Count IX, aggravated possession of drugs. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1944State v. Reed (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion by denying Appellant's motion to stay the execution of court costs. The trial court rationally determined that Appellant's ability to pay court costs was limited, but not completely absent given that Appellant had been making installment payments toward the court costs owed. Affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1945Poirier v. Tipp City Process Equip. Co. (2018)
The trial court lacked jurisdiction over Appellant's action after Appellant filed a notice of dismissal under Civ.R. 41(A)(1). While the trial court had filed a summary judgment decision, the decision was interlocutory and not a final order, because the issue of attorney fees had not been resolved and the trial court had not included a Civ.R. 54(B) certification in its decision. Because the decision was interlocutory, Appellant had the ability to file a notice of dismissal. Once the notice of dismissal was filed, the action was if it had never been filed, and the trial court erred in striking the notice of dismissal. Reversed and remanded for further proceedings. (Hall, J., dissenting.)
- 2018 Ohio 1946State v. Payson (2018)
The trial court prematurely determined that Huber Heights Code Section 505.11 is unconstitutionally vague. This conclusion is reached because it is possible the City can establish that Defendant-appellee violated Huber Heights Section 505.01(a) without reference to, or reliance upon, any presumption created by Section 505.11. Judgment reversed and remanded for further proceedings.
- 2018 Ohio 1948State v. Maston (2018)
Trial court did not err in overruling defendant's motion to suppress. The officer diligently performed tasks needed to complete the traffic stop until back-up arrived, at which time he conducted a free-air sniff by his canine partner the stop was not unreasonably extended to conduct the canine sniff. Defendant was not in custody when he made incriminating statements. Trial court erred in allowing the State to use at trial the laboratory report of the drug analysis, pursuant to R.C. 2925.51. The State's service of a copy of the lab report on an attorney at the Public Defender's Office did not satisfy R.C. 2925.51(A) when that attorney was no longer defendant's attorney of record at the time of service. Defendant did not demonstrate ineffective assistance of counsel based on counsel's failure to renew at trial the motion to suppress defendant's statements. Judgment reversed as to possession of a controlled substance, and case remanded for further proceedings on that charge. Judgment affirmed as to possession of marijuana. (Tucker, J., concurring.)
- 2018 Ohio 1949State v. Lumford (2018)
The trial court's imposition of three consecutive one-year prison sentences, and an additional nine-month agreed sentence, after revoking the appellant's community control is neither contrary to law nor clearly and convincingly unsupported by the record. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1950State v. Harwell (2018)
The trial court properly imposed a five-year mandatory term of post-release control for Appellant's first-degree felony kidnapping convictions. Although the trial court failed to impose the applicable three-year mandatory term of post-release control for Appellant's felonious assault conviction, that term of post-release control is subsumed by the five-year term imposed for Appellant's kidnapping convictions, as "the period of post-release control for all of the sentences shall be the period of post-release control that expires last[.]" R.C. 2967.28(F)(4)(c). In addition, Appellant's claim that the trial court failed to merge allied offenses of similar import at sentencing was waived for appeal and barred by the doctrine of res judicata. Affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1951State v. Coleman (2018)
Defendant was involved in an altercation with a store security officer when the officer attempted to bring defendant back into the store to discuss the behavior that the officer found to be suspicious, the defendant hit the officer multiple times. Trial court's finding that defendant had committed assault, and its rejection of the argument that he had acted in self-defense, were not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1952State v. Wolfe (2018)
Because appellant's arguments were barred by res judicata, the trial court did not err when it overruled his Motion to Dismiss on Double Jeopardy Grounds without considering the merits of his motion. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1954Toledo v. Williams (2018)
Plain error. Amendment of complaints. Degree of offenses and penalties changed. Nature or identity of charges changed. Plea. Insufficient evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 1955State v. Roberson (2018)
Trial court did not commit plain error by failing to merge aggravated burglary in violation of R.C. 2911.11(A)(1) and rape in violation of R.C. 2907.02(A)(2) and (B) because the two offenses were of dissimilar import. The aggravated burglary conviction resulted in harm, i.e., theft of the victim's belongings, that was separate and identifiable from the physical harm that resulted from the rape.
- 2018 Ohio 1956State v. Perez (2018)
No abuse of discretion in denying appellant's motion for continuance. Crim.R. 29 motion properly denied where sufficient evidence satisfies elements of felonious assault. Trial court complied with sentencing criteria under R.C. 2929.11 and 2929.12. Appellant failed to show conviction was against manifest weight because evidence was competent and credible and supported the verdict and conviction.
- 2018 Ohio 1958State v. Osley (2018)
Anders appeal. Appellant's sentence is not clearly and convincingly contrary to law where it is within the statutory range, postrelease control was properly imposed, and the trial court stated that it had considered R.C. 2929.11 and 2929.12.
- 2018 Ohio 1959State v. Cowdrey (2018)
Trial court properly denied appellant's motion to suppress. Appellant's sentence was not unlawful. Judgement affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1961Foster v. Foster (2018)
Summary judgment Civ.R. 56 fraud final appealable order R.C. 2505.02 Civ.R. 54 statute of limitations R.C. 2305.09 discovery rule constructive knowledge cognizable event laches. Appellant failed to demonstrate a genuine issue of material fact as to when the statute of limitations for his fraud claims began to run. Accordingly, the trial court properly granted appellees' motion for summary judgment.
- 2018 Ohio 1962State v. Kronenberg (2018)
R.C. 2903.211/ menacing by stalking Crim.R. 7(B)/indictment sufficiency consecutive sentences. The trial court did not err by considering appellant's prior history. Evidence showed that appellant harassed the victims for over 15 years causing the victims mental distress and creating fear in the victims and was sufficient enough to establish that appellant engaged in a pattern of conduct toward the victims.
- 2018 Ohio 1963State v. Walton (2018)
Anders nonfrivolous issue guilty plea consecutive sentences R.C. 2929.14(C)(4) plea agreement breach R.C. 2929.12 due process juvenile adjudication. An independent review of the record reveals that there are no nonfrivolous issues to argue in this case involving appellant's guilty plea or the trial court's imposition of consecutive sentences. The prosecutor's statements during the sentencing hearing did not constitute a breach of the parties' plea agreement. The trial court did not err or violate appellant's due process rights by considering appellant's juvenile record during the sentencing hearing.
- 2018 Ohio 1964State v. Hicks (2018)
Guilty plea motion to withdraw ineffective assistance of counsel Crim.R. 32.1 hybrid representation. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in failing to hold a hearing on appellant's pro se request to withdraw his guilty plea. Appellant was not denied his constitutional right to the effective assistance of counsel.
- 2018 Ohio 1965State v. Greene (2018)
Community control sanctions violation probable cause revocation due process plain error Crim.R. 52 substantial evidence R.C. 2929.15. The trial court did not commit plain error by consolidating the preliminary probable cause hearing and the revocation hearing into a single hearing, and appellant was not prejudice by the trial court's failure to hold two separate hearings. The trial court's determination that appellant violated the terms of his community control sanctions is not supported by substantial and competent evidence in the record. Accordingly, the trial court abused its discretion in revoking appellant's community control sanctions and imposing a prison sentence.
- 2018 Ohio 1966Georgetown of the Highlands Condominium Owners' Assn. v. Nsong (2018)
Civ.R. 56(C)/summary judgment dispositive motion R.C. 5311.18(C)/discharge of condominium liens Evid.R. 702/expert witness/attorney fees relief from judgment. Where appellee filed its motion for summary judgment and appellant did not oppose the motion disputing the alleged amount owed or file any dispositive motion to demonstrate that there was no genuine issue of material fact as to appellant's counterclaims, the trial court did not err or abuse its discretion in granting appellee's motion. Appellant failed to establish that her property was trespassed against by an unauthorized intentional act neither was appellee negligent in the manner in which it responded to the emergency situation going on in appellant's unit. Appellant's argument disputing the amount owed to appellee failed where appellant did not oppose appellee's summary judgment motion. Appellant's invasion of privacy claim fails where appellant failed to show that appellee made any type of public disclosure about appellant that would have put appellant in a false light. Based on the terms of the association's declaration and bylaws, appellee was permitted to enter appellant's unit where an emergency existed. Appellant's breach of contract claim fails. The expert witness established that the attorney's hourly rate charged was reasonable and appellant failed to present any evidence that the fees charged were unreasonable. The trial court did not err in denying appellant's motion for relief from judgment. It was established that appellant was indebted to the United States and appellant failed to present evidence demonstrating otherwise.
- 2018 Ohio 1967State v. McCullough (2018)
Motion to dismiss, Cleveland Municipal Court, Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court, Crim.R. 48(B), harmless error. The trial court did not err by granting the appellee's motion to dismiss because the appellee had a reasonable belief that his plea agreement and sentence from municipal court barred any subsequent felony charges in common pleas court. The trial court did not fully comply with Crim.R. 48(B) and state on the record its findings of fact and reasons for dismissing the indictment, but the error was harmless because the reasoning is evident in the hearing transcript.
- 2018 Ohio 1968State v. Eaton (2018)
Crim.R. 13/joinder of offenses/indictment ineffective assistance of counsel. The multiple indictments were properly tried together. Evidence showed that the offenses shared a common purpose, motive or scheme and involved the same victim. Moreover, trial was continued so that the cases could be tried together and appellant was aware both cases would be tried together. Appellant failed to show that his trial counsel's representation fell below the objective standard of reasonableness.
- 2018 Ohio 1969Estate of Hunter v. Dept. of Job & Family Servs. (2018)
Medicaid benefits state hearing notice. Trial court did not err by affirming administrative decision denying Medicaid benefits because party who failed to pursue administrative appeal in first application for benefits could not raise the issue in a subsequent application for benefits.
- 2018 Ohio 1970State v. Foreman (2018)
Intervention in lieu of conviction eligible offense R.C. 2951.041. The trial court erred by granting appellee's motion for intervention in lieu of conviction on Counts 1 and 3 because the eligibility requirement set forth in R.C. 2951.041(B)(7) was not satisfied. The trial court did not err by granting appellee's motion on the remaining counts in the indictment that are eligible offenses.
- 2018 Ohio 1972State v. Shine (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1974Lowe's Home Ctrs., Inc. v. Washington Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation—Real-property valuation—Board of Tax Appeals failed to evaluate and weigh property-rights-conveyed analysis contained in appraisal report of county's appraiser—Collateral estoppel precludes inquiry into whether subject property is "special purpose" in nature—Decision vacated and cause remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 1975State v. Gordon (Slip Opinion) (2018)
R.C. 2929.19(B)(2)(e) does not require that at an offender's initial sentencing hearing, the trial court notify the offender of the penalty provisions in R.C. 2929.141(A)(1) and (2).
- 2018 Ohio 1978Wadsworth Pointe Health Care Group, Inc. v. Baglia (2018)
Civ.R. 12(B)(6), motion to dismiss, failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted, personal guarantee, action on account, unjust enrichment, quantum meruit
- 2018 Ohio 1979State ex rel. Kirklin v. Doherty (2018)
EXTRAORDINARY WRIT - Mandamus used to compel performance of duty judgment issued duty completed judge has no duty to explain basis of jurisdiction in mandamus action.
- 2018 Ohio 1980State v. Bruce (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW- SPEEDY TRIAL - speedy trial time is extended during period between defendant's arrest on warrant and order to appear in court to resolve warrant and the time he appeared in court six years later was due to his own neglect or improper act and is attributable to him appellant's failure to clear up warrant when he was ordered to do so resulted in his hampering his Sixth Amendment right and he cannot overcome fact that genesis of the delay was his own failure to comply with court's order that he appear in court to resolve warrantwhere indictment was filed and warrant was executed by an arrest within the limitations period, there is no violation of statute of limitations.
- 2018 Ohio 1983State v. Hawkins (2018)
Trial court did not err in denying appellant's motion to suppress, as reasonable and articulable suspicion existed to authorize law enforcement's stop of appellant's vehicle. The color discrepancy between the vehicle's actual paint color (black) and the BMV's registration (white) gave the officer reason to believe that the vehicle may have been stolen or the license plate switched from another vehicle where the officer testified in his 14 years of experience, car thieves often replace a vehicle's original license plate with a stolen plate taken from a similar vehicle to conceal the theft.
- 2018 Ohio 1984State v. Aburas (2018)
Appellant's sentence was not contrary to law where the trial court sentenced appellant within the statutory range, considered the necessary statutory requirements, and advised appellant of postrelease control sanctions. The sentence was supported by the record where appellant showed no remorse for perpetrating a violent sexual act against his close friend who he knew had been scarred by a previous sexual assault.
- 2018 Ohio 1985State v. Hawkins-Stephens (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1986Oliver v. Marysville (2018)
The trial court did not err in granting appellee's motion for judgment on the pleadings and summary judgment and in dismissing appellant's complaint. The judgment of the trial court is affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 1987State v. Craig (2018)
Verdict form - double jeopardy - character evidence - leave to file motion to suppress - consecutive sentencing
- 2018 Ohio 1988State v. Price (2018)
Plain error/Weight/Sufficiency of Evidence/ineffective assisatnace of counsel
- 2018 Ohio 1991State v. Shilbaya (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 1993McCarthy v. Anderson (2018)
Corporate Dissolution
- 2018 Ohio 1994McCarthy v. Anderson (2018)
Corporate Dissolution
- 2018 Ohio 1995State v. Fox (2018)
Hearsay competency to testify
- 2018 Ohio 1996Dublin City Schools Bd. of Edn. v. Franklin Cty. Bd. of Revision (2018)
The Ohio Board of Tax Appeals erred in dismissing as untimely appellant's appeal from a Franklin County Board of Revision decision valuing a property owned by Lowe's Home Centers, LLC. Appellant's appeal to the Board of Tax Appeals was timely because the 30-day appeal window did not begin until the Board of Revision sufficiently notified appellant of its decision regarding the valuation of the property. Decision reversed cause remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 1997State v. Thompson (2018)
Criminal defendant who moved to set aside his plea bargain 9 years after his entering guilty pleas did not show a manifest injustice for purposes of Crim.R. 32.1.
- 2018 Ohio 1998Ditech Fin., L.L.C. v. Global Capital Partners (2018)
The trial court did not err in denying appellant a continuance to conduct discovery or in granting appellee summary judgment in a foreclosure action.
- 2018 Ohio 1999State ex rel. Digiacinto v. Indus. Comm. (2018)
Relator's objections sustained and limited writ of mandamus granted in voluntary abandonment case for partial total disability workers compensation. Social Security Administration administrative law judge previously found Relator disabled as result of industrial injury and unfit for vocational rehabilitation. Magistrate's findings of fact adopted with additional findings of fact made by appeals court. Magistrate's findings of law not adopted, and Industrial Commission's decision vacated and matter remanded for new hearing consistent with the law as stated in appeals court's decision.
- 2018 Ohio 2000Lawrence v. Larose (2018)
Habeas corpus failure to file commitment papers failure to file affidavit of prior civil actions state court of appeals lacks jurisdiction over federal inmates dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 2001State v. McIntyre (2018)
res judicata, law of the case, Crim.R. 32(C), final appealable order
- 2018 Ohio 2003Third Federal S. & L. v. Sutton (2018)
default judgment, Civ.R. 55, Loc.R. 7.04, failure to appear, service of motion, motion to vacate, Civ.R. 60(B)
- 2018 Ohio 2004State v. Johnson (2018)
nunc pro tunc, final appealable order, R.C. 2505.02(B), substantial right, Batson, speedy trial, R.C. 2945.71, R.C. 2941.401, ineffective assistance of counsel, allied offenses, animus, rape, kidnapping, aggravated assault
- 2018 Ohio 2010State v. Jeffries (2018)
JURIES: The trial court's decision overruling the defendant's Batson challenge was not clearly erroneous where the state offered the race-neutral explanation that the prospective juror had been pulled over for OVI, the same offense for which the defendant was being tried.
- 2018 Ohio 2011Ronald J. Solomon, D.D.S., Inc. v. Davisson (2018)
CONTRACTS – R.C. 1343.03(A) – PREJUDGMENT INTEREST – PROCEDURE/RULES – CIV.R. 53(D)(4)(c): Where the parties entered into a contract specifying a rate of interest to be charged when money owed under the contract became due and payable, plaintiff, as the prevailing party, was entitled to the contractual rate of interest rather than the statutory rate pursuant to R.C. 1343.03(A). Where no objections were filed to the magistrate's decision, Civ.R. 53(D)(4)(c) required the trial court to review the decision for errors of law and defects evident on its face and where the trial court failed to correct a clear error in the magistrate's award of late charges from a certain date, the cause must be remanded for correction of the error.
- 2018 Ohio 2012Brooklyn Estates Homeowners' Assn. v. Miclara, L.L.C. (2018)
Civil: The trial court erred as a matter of law by vacating the arbitrator's decision without a motion as prescribed in R.C. 2711.13 and without reviewing the decision under R.C. 2711.10(D). The judgment of the trial court is reversed.
- 2018 Ohio 2016Bixby v. Ohio State Univ. (2018)
Trial court did not err in dismissing complaint on medical claim where plaintiff failed to include affidavit of merit as required by Civ.R. 10(D)(2).
- 2018 Ohio 2017Lytal v. Crawl for Cancer, Inc. (2018)
Judgment affirmed and assignment of error overruled. The trial court did not error when granting appellees' motion for judgment on the pleadings under Civ.R. 12(C), dismissing appellants' claims for negligence and loss of consortium, as appellees did not owe appellants a duty of care.
- 2018 Ohio 2018State v. Simmons (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2020In re J.W. (2018)
JUVENILE - TERMINATION OF PARENTAL RIGHTS - Remand necessary to determine if actual conflict of interest exists State v. Gillard, 64 Ohio St.3d 304 (1992).
- 2018 Ohio 2023Novita Industries, L.L.C. v. Lorain Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation—Real-property valuation—R.C. 5715.19(D)—Requirement that proposed value be set forth applies to filing original complaints but not to invoking continuing-complaint jurisdiction of a county board of revision—Property owner properly invoked continuing-complaint jurisdiction of board of revision over owner's challenge to county auditor's valuation of subject property for tax year 2014—Board of Tax Appeals' decision reversed to extent it refused to exercise jurisdiction over property's 2014 value—Board of Tax Appeals ordered to assign aggregate value of $750,000 to parcels at issues for tax years 2012, 2013, and 2014, and to allocate that value to the individual parcels.
- 2018 Ohio 2024Lorain County Bar Association v. Lewis. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct, including committing an illegal act and engaging in conduct involving dishonesty—Submitting a false written witness statement to police—Two-year suspension, with six months stayed on conditions.
- 2018 Ohio 2027State v. Sewell (2018)
The trial court did not err in denying Appellant's motion for acquittal. Appellant had notice of the robbery charge against him pursuant to the indictment, and the State did not commit to a specific theory of the case during opening statement with respect to whether the underlying theft offense for robbery was of a backpack or of a lighter, or both. Furthermore, during its case, the State presented sufficient evidence to prove that Appellant had intent to deprive the victim of a lighter and caused physical harm to the victim as he was committing the theft or fleeing immediately after the theft. The State also did not change its theory of the case during trial. In addition, Appellant's conviction for robbery was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. The trial judge was the fact-finder and found the victim credible. In contrast, the trial judge did not find Appellant credible. We defer to the trier of fact on credibility issues, and there was no manifest miscarriage of justice. Finally, trial counsel did not provide ineffective assistance of counsel. Assuming for purposes of argument that trial counsel should have filed a motion for a bill of particulars, there is no reasonable probability that the result of the trial would have been different. Appellant did not deny striking the victim his defense was that the lighter that was allegedly taken belonged to him. However, the trial court did not find Appellant credible. Trial counsel also did not provide ineffective assistance by discontinuing his cross-examination of the victim with respect to ownership of the lighter. While the victim had a hearing problem and some difficulty in communicating, he clearly indicated the facts as to his ownership of the lighter during both direct and cross-examination. Moreover, in view of the trial court's credibility decisions, there is no reasonable probability that the result of the trial would have been otherwise if counsel had persisted. Affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2028State v. Seals (2018)
In an Anders case, the trial court erred in imposing the costs of appointed counsel and confinement without first finding that the defendant had the ability to pay.
- 2018 Ohio 2029State v. Clark (2018)
Ohio Adm.Code 5537-2-09 conflicts with R.C. 4511.25(B) where both cover the same subject matter and Ohio Adm.Code 5537-2-09 improperly adds to the rule provided in R.C. 4511.25(B)(1). Ohio Adm.Code 5537-2-09 is unconstitutional as applied.
- 2018 Ohio 2030Robinson v. Mercy St. Vincent Med. Ctr. (2018)
Trial court abused its discretion in allowing evidence of prior successful deliveries by obstetrician in violation of Evid.R. 402, 404(B), and 403(A), thus motion for new trial should have been granted. Rebuttal evidence was properly excluded where proffered evidence crossed line into medical testimony by lay witness. Appellant waived error in admission of expert opinion where not raised in motion for new trial.
- 2018 Ohio 2031State v. Pitts (2018)
Trial court did not err in appellant's misdemeanor convictions.
- 2018 Ohio 2032E.G. Licata, L.L.C. v. E.G.L., Inc. (2018)
Tenant is not entitled to a setoff from a damages award in the landlord's favor where the expenses it bore were for repairs, not capital improvements, and the tenant was responsible to make "all repairs" under the terms of the lease.
- 2018 Ohio 2033State v. Jones (2018)
Conceded error. Failure to allow defendant to speak before sentencing. Consecutive sentences. Resentencing.
- 2018 Ohio 2035State v. Hartings (2018)
The State adduced sufficient evidence at trial to support the appellant's conviction for rape (by force or threat of force), in violation of R.C. 2907.02(A)(2), a felony of the first degree. The appellant's rape conviction was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. The ten-year sentence imposed upon the appellant was within the permissible statutory range and therefore not contrary to law. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2036State v. Eytcheson (2018)
Appellant was not entitled to a trial by jury for failure to reinstate a license and for a seatbelt violation. The trial court did not err in overruling Appellant's motion to dismiss, since the right to operate a motor vehicle upon the highways is not unrestricted but is subject to reasonable regulation. Officer Colon did not violate R.C. 4513.263(D) in initiating Appellant's traffic stop, since the stop was based upon an improper turn and not the seatbelt violation. Officer Colon was not required to advise Appellant of his Miranda rights in the course of the stop. The trial court had discretion to limit the duration and scope of Appellant's closing argument. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in excluding a "statement" or "document" from evidence Appellant did not make a proffer of the document, but R.C. 2319.02 requires Appellant to submit an affidavit, and Appellant testified that his injury that arguably prevents him from wearing a seat belt occurred in 2012. The State was not required to prove that Appellant acted knowingly or willfully strict liability attaches to Appellant's offenses. The corpus delicti rules does not apply to Appellant's offenses. The trial court did not lack subject matter or personal jurisdiction. The trial court, as the fact-finder in a bench trial, was authorized to question a witness and did not assume the role of the prosecutor. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2037Cianciola v. Johnson's Island Property Owners Assn. (2018)
Trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying appellants' motion to show cause where the claims raised in appellee's complaint were premised upon common law principles and not upon an operating agreement and code of regulations the enforcement of which was enjoined in a prior action involving these parties.
- 2018 Ohio 2039Buckingham v. Buckingham (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in finding Appellant in contempt for failing to comply with requirements for paying a property settlement, nor was the court's decision against the manifest weight of the evidence. The court also did not abuse its discretion in rejecting the use of Appellant's health savings account to pay the property settlement, in failing to find Appellee in contempt, or in awarding most of the attorney fees and litigation expenses requested by Appellee. The court did err in awarding $1,250 for one expert, because the record did not include adequate documentation of the expert's fees. The judgment of the trial court is reversed with respect to the trial court's award of expert fees for David Suich in the amount of $1,250. In all other respects, the trial court's judgment is affirmed. (Hall, J., concurring.)
- 2018 Ohio 2040State v. Bourn (2018)
Trial court failed to comply with Crim.R. 11. Plea is vacated, judgment reversed, and case remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 2041Blevins v. Green Acres Mobilehome Park, Inc. (2018)
Summary judgment for defendants on negligence claim is appropriate where plaintiff fails to present any evidence that defendants breached a duty of care, or that any purported breach proximately caused plaintiff's injuries.
- 2018 Ohio 2042State v. Benton (2018)
Counsel for Benton's potential assignments of error, namely that his conviction for obstructing official business, a felony of the fifth degree, is against the manifest weight of the evidence, and that the trial court erred in sentencing Benton to a twelve-month term, are wholly frivolous. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2044State v. Barker (2018)
In this appeal under Anders v. California, 386 U.S. 738, 87 S.Ct. 1396, 18 L.Ed.2d 493 (1967), there are no potential assignments of error having arguable merit. Any challenge to Appellant's sentence is barred by res judicata. Any issue regarding counsel's alleged ineffective assistance during the appellant's trial is barred by res judicata. The record establishes that appellant did not receive ineffective assistance of counsel at his resentencing hearing. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2045Adams v. Ohio Dep't of Job & Family Servs. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2046Hilliard City Schools Bd. of Edn. v. Franklin Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Real-property valuation—Property owner failed to negate presumption of recency of sale—Date of sale is the date that real-property conveyance-fee statement is filed in auditor's office—Board of Tax Appeals' decision affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2047Lafarge N. Am., Inc. v. Testa (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Use tax—Pelletized-slag manufacturer's breaking up and transport of solidified slag are part of its "manufacturing operation" under R.C. 5739.02(B)(42)(g) such that use tax applies to its purchases of fuel and repair parts for its equipment used primarily to break up and transport slag—Board of Tax Appeals' decision reversed and cause remanded for it to determine extent to which fuel and repair parts are used in slag manufacturing for purposes of R.C. 5739.011(D) and to determine extent to which penalty must be abated.
- 2018 Ohio 2048State v. J.M. (2018)
Conceded error seal records following dismissal R.C. 2953.52(B) hearing. The trial court erred when it summarily denied appellant's application to seal court records pursuant to R.C. 2953.52(B) without holding a hearing.
- 2018 Ohio 2049Assn. of Cleveland Firefighters, Local 93 I.A.F.F. v. Cleveland (2018)
Civ.R. 24 intervention as a matter of right abuse of discretion untimely. The trial court did not abuse its discretion when it denied the appellants' second motion to intervene as untimely because the appellants had voluntarily withdrawn their first motion to intervene after it had been pending for just two months. Further, the appellants' interests were adequately represented by the plaintiffs in the case.
- 2018 Ohio 2050State v. Anthony (2018)
Appellate mandate, remand for resentencing, res judicata, allied offenses, R.C. 2929.11 and 2929.12. On a limited remand for resentencing on the issue of merger of allied offenses, the trial court is limited only to addressing that issue res judicata bars assignments of error challenging issues that could or should have been raised in the direct appeal but does not bar issues arising from the resentencing.
- 2018 Ohio 2051State v. Harian (2018)
Guilty plea R.C. 2945.37 competency hearing harmless error Crim.R. 11 nonconstitutional right substantial compliance notice of prior conviction specification. Because the record failed to reveal sufficient indicia of incompetency, the trial court's failure to hold a competency hearing as required by R.C. 2945.37(B) was harmless error. Appellant's guilty pleas were knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily entered.
- 2018 Ohio 2052State v. Cruz (2018)
Guilty plea substantial compliance potential penalty misleading advice counsel ineffective assistance of counsel mandatory fine inability to pay indigency court costs. Defendant's guilty plea was made knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily even though trial counsel gave misleading advice about the potential for judicial release where the defendant understood the potential penalties he could receive and that there was no guarantee of judicial release. Counsel's failure to file affidavit of indigency did not amount to the ineffective assistance of counsel where the record showed that the defendant owned valuable assets and was capable of paying the fine in the future. Although the trial court erred by imposing court costs in the journal entry without advising the defendant of the costs in open court and the record, there is no need to remand the case to the trial court because the defendant can file a motion to waive costs at any time.
- 2018 Ohio 2053State v. Johnson (2018)
Consecutive sentences, R.C. 2929.14. Appellant's sole assignment of error, that the trial court failed to make the findings required under R.C. 2929.14(C)(4) prior to imposing consecutive sentences, was without merit as the trial court made the required findings on the record and incorporated them into appellant's sentencing entries.
- 2018 Ohio 2054Howell v. Park E. Care & Rehab. (2018)
In camera review discovery privilege motion to compel R.C. 2317.02 R.C. 2305.353 HIPAA R.C. 3721.02. The trial court did err in ordering discovery of nursing home's incident reports and medical records pertaining to nonparty nursing home patient who allegedly assaulted plaintiff's decedent, because the trial court did not first conduct an in camera review of the disputed documents.
- 2018 Ohio 2055State v. Jones (2018)
Crim.R. 11(C)(2)/guilty plea Crim.R. 32.1/withdrawal of guilty plea/hearing named victim in indictment. A discussion on the merger of offenses is a sentencing issue and the trial court's advisement of the possibility of a maximum sentence at the plea hearing was not misleading resulting in error. The trial court did not commit prejudicial error regarding conducting a hearing prior to sentencing. Appellant was allowed, prior to sentencing, to state his reasons for withdrawing his guilty plea, and appellant failed to establish a reasonable and legitimate basis for withdrawal. The indictment held sufficient language to inform appellant of the charges against him. Listing the victim's name was not an essential element of the crime and was therefore not required to be included in the indictment.
- 2018 Ohio 2056Pales v. Fedor (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2057Kassay v. Niederst Mgmt., Ltd. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2059Disciplinary Counsel v. Thomas (2018)
On certified order of the Supreme Court of West Virginia, No. 17-0131.
- 2018 Ohio 2064SMS Fin. 30, L. L.C. v. Frederick D. Harris, M.D., Inc. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2073In re J.L. (2018)
DOMESTIC RELATIONS - CHILD CUSTODY- under R.C. 2151.414(D)(2), if all four factors listed therein apply, permanent custody is in the best interests of the child and the court is required to grant permanent custody to the agency since the trial court found that each of the four factors applies, the court was required to find that permanent custody is in the best interests of the children and to grant permanent custody although the trial court correctly stated that a trial court is not required to apply both best interest tests in R.C. 2151.414(D)(1) and (D)(2), the court also made the findings required under R.C. 2151.414(D)(1).
- 2018 Ohio 2074State v. Potts (2018)
CIVIL - expungement seal the record of conviction R.C. 2953.31 R.C. 2953.32 statutory law in effect at the time of filing is controlling first offender eligible offender law of the case doctrine statutory interpretation unambiguous legislative intent.
- 2018 Ohio 2075State v. Carnes (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - PLEAS - Crim.R. 32.1 post-sentence motion to withdraw guilty plea indictment manifest injustice res judicata.
- 2018 Ohio 2076In re Rosenberger (2018)
PROBATE - guardianship R.C. 2111.50(A)(1) motion to intervene nomination of power of attorney R.C. 2111.121 interested party R.C. 2111.02(A) notice of hearing R.C. 2111.04(A)(2)
- 2018 Ohio 2077Willoughby Supply Co. v. Villhauer (2018)
CONTRACTS - account personal quarantee motion to dismiss filed by purported guarantor trial court erred in granting motion to dismiss complaint on an account because complaint provided for relief on four different potential legal theories.
- 2018 Ohio 2078State v. Croskey (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2079State v. Owens (2018)
Jail Time Credit Res Judicata
- 2018 Ohio 2080State v. Gordon (2018)
Motion to Suppress Pat-down of Driver Inevietable Discovery
- 2018 Ohio 2082In re J.Q. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2083State v. Constable (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2086State v. Holmes (2018)
A defendant appeals his convictions for rape and gross sexual imposition. There was no prosecutorial misconduct in calling for justice for the victim during closing argument and where the state published a recording of the victim's statement that the defendant had agreed could be admitted into evidence. Related claims of ineffective assistance of counsel were meritless.
- 2018 Ohio 2087Reigert v. Ruscin (2018)
concealment of assets, bias, manifest weight of the evidence
- 2018 Ohio 2089Tesar Indus. Contractors v. Republic Steel (2018)
motion for a new trial, judgment notwithstanding the verdict, remittitur, breach of contract, jury instructions, fraud in the inducement.
- 2018 Ohio 2092R. C. Costello & Assoc., Inc. v. Energy Technologies, Inc. (2018)
"Implied-in-fact contract"
- 2018 Ohio 2093State v. Freeman (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2094State v. Buxton (2018)
"Implied-in-fact contract"
- 2018 Ohio 2100Johnson v. Am. Italian Golf Assn. of Columbus (2018)
Summary judgment in favor of defendant-appellee golf course association reversed for impermissible weighing of evidence to reach legal conclusion based on no duty to warn under open-and-obvious doctrine. Assignments of error sustained. Judgment reversed matter remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 2101State ex rel. Robinson v. Adult Parole Auth. (2018)
Mandamus action sua sponte dismissed because relator failed to comply with the mandatory filing requirements set forth in R.C. 2969.25.
- 2018 Ohio 2102State ex rel. Oliver v. Turner (Slip Opinion) (2018)
R.C. 2929.41—Because sentencing entry for offense committed while petitioner was on parole did not specify that sentence was to be served consecutively to sentence for prior offense, sentence for later offense was to be served concurrently with sentence for prior offense—Petition not barred by res judicata—Writ of habeas corpus granted—Warden ordered to release petitioner.
- 2018 Ohio 2104Dalton v. Massillon (2018)
Lease, deed, declaratory judgment, summary judgment, maintenance, replacement, final appealable order.
- 2018 Ohio 2108Weadock v. Taha (2018)
This appeal arises from the trial court's decision disqualifying Plaintiff-appellant's attorney from continuing to represent her in the pending litigation. The trial court, given the attorney's participation in a meeting – the details of which are contested – central to Plaintiff-appellant's spoliation cause of action, did not abuse its discretion when concluding that the attorney was a necessary witness under Prof.Cond.R. 3.7(a) and that the attorney's continued representation was otherwise inappropriate. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2109Sideline, Inc. v. Mosketti (2018)
In the absence of a transcript or acceptable substitute, we presume the regularity of the proceedings and validity of the trial court's rulings without reaching the merits of Appellant's assignments of error. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2111State v. Moore (2018)
Trial court did not commit error, plain or otherwise, in failing to merge one count of robbery with the abduction count, both of which stemmed from the robbery of a gas station defendant's act of pursuing a fleeing employee and bringing him back to the store's register constituted an abduction separate from the robbery. Trial counsel did not act deficiently in failing to request merger of the robbery and abduction counts. The trial court's imposition of consecutive sentences was not clearly and convincingly unsupported by the record. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2112City of Centerville v. Leonard (2018)
Appellant's conviction for criminal trespass is supported by sufficient evidence. And the conviction is not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2113Johnson v. Miller (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion by its issuance of a Civil Stalking Protection Order (CSPO) against Appellant. Further, the CSPO's restrictions, with one exception, are reasonable, and, thus, not an abuse of discretion. The exception, constituting an abuse of discretion, is the CSPO provision that Appellant, even in Appellee's absence, may not visit the homes of Appellee's relatives. Judgment affirmed, in part, reversed, in part, and remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 2115State v. Goney (2018)
The trial court erred when it imposed a definite prison term for the appellant's repeat violent offender specifications pursuant to R.C. 2929.14(B)(2)(b)(iii). Appellant's convictions for robbery and kidnapping were not allied offenses, and therefore are not subject to merger. Appellant did not receive ineffective assistance because his counsel was unaware of the nature of a witness's alleged arrest warrant from another jurisdiction. Further, his failure to discover a cell phone found by jurors during deliberations inside a brown purse marked as State's Exhibit 55 does not constitute ineffective assistance. Appellant's argument that his counsel was ineffective for failing to inform him of the alleged plea deal offered by the State after the trial began pertains to matters outside the record, and is therefore more suited as a basis for a post-conviction relief petition. Trial court did not err when it overruled appellant's motion for a mistrial because appellant's argument was speculative, and there is no reasonable probability that, had the evidence been disclosed to the defense before trial, the result of the proceeding would have been different. Appellant's convictions for robbery, kidnapping, and abduction were supported by sufficient evidence, and the jury's guilty verdicts were not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Appellant's sentences for the RVO specifications are reversed and vacated. In all other respects, the judgment of the trial court is affirmed, and this matter is remanded for proceedings consistent with this opinion.
- 2018 Ohio 2116State v. Beverly (2018)
The trial court erred at resentencing by modifying the appellant's sentence to resentence him consecutively on those counts for which he already had completed his previously imposed concurrent prison terms. Judgment reversed and remanded for resentencing. (Donovan, J., concurring.)
- 2018 Ohio 2117Draper v. N. Am. Science Assocs., Inc. (2018)
Trial court's grant of summary judgment in favor of appellant's employer and the Administrator of the Bureau of Workers' Compensation on the basis of res judicata was improper where one of appellant's prior workers' compensation claims was vacated prior to adjudication and a question of fact exists as to whether the other prior claim involved the same injury alleged in the present claim.
- 2018 Ohio 2118State v. Davis (2018)
Appellant's subjective belief regarding the accuracy of the official record of his criminal history cannot serve as grounds for ineffective assistance of trial counsel. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2119State v. Wolke (2018)
CRIMINAL - Appellant's Verified Motion to Correct Sentence was properly denied by the trial court and we modify the judgment below to reflect dismissal of any constitutional claims raised in the motion.
- 2018 Ohio 2120Johnson v. Sloan (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Habeas corpus—Prohibition and mandamus—Inmate fails to state claim cognizable in habeas corpus—Inmate failed to raise on direct appeal his challenge to adult court's jurisdiction to convict him—Court of appeals' judgments dismissing petitions affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2121Pelletier v. Campbell (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Torts—Political-subdivision immunity—R.C. 2744.02(B)(3)—Whether a stop sign is "in repair" depends on its physical condition, not whether it no longer serves its purpose due to an extraneous factor—The duty to "remove obstructions from public roads" applies only to obstructions that originate on the public road and does not apply to conditions that are only near or in the vicinity of public roads.
- 2018 Ohio 2122State ex rel. Belle Tire Distribs., Inc. v. Indus. Comm. (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Workers' compensation—Commission's decision to reconsider denial of claim for benefits was an exercise of its continuing jurisdiction—Whether an error occurred that was sufficient to invoke commission's continuing jurisdiction is a proper subject matter for an action seeking a writ of mandamus.
- 2018 Ohio 2123Broderick v. Paris (2018)
Prohibition, mandamus, probation, conditions of probation, firearms, discretion, abuse of discretion, appeal, and R.C. 2929.25(A)(1)(a). The court dismissed the applications for writs of mandamus and prohibition to prevent the trial court from enforcing a condition of probation that there would be no weapons in the marital home during a one-year probation. R.C. 2929.25(A)(1)(a) grants the court broad authority and discretion in imposing conditions of probation. Because the judge was acting within her statutorily granted jurisdiction, prohibition would not lie. Mandamus does not lie for an abuse of discretion.
- 2018 Ohio 2124State ex rel. McDuffie (2018)
Procedendo motion for costs mootness and R.C. 2969.25(C). Procedendo action to compel judge to rule on motions to vacate costs and to approve a partial payment plan was rendered moot when the judge denied both motions. The relator also failed to submit a proper poverty affidavit under R.C. 2969.25(C).
- 2018 Ohio 2125State v. Comstock (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2127State v. Miller (2018)
Allied offenses of similar import R.C. 2941.25 separate victims robbery R.C. 2911.02(A)(2) theft R.C. 2913.02(A)(1) sentencing package doctrine court costs. The trial court did not err when it denied defendant's request to merge his two robbery convictions because there were two victims. Although defendant argued that there was only one victim, the bank who lost money in the robbery, the defendant threatened two bank tellers with his note that stated, "follow my directions and no one will get hurt." Although the bank was the victim of the theft offense (which the trial court did merge into the robbery convictions), the bank was not the victim of the robbery offense. Robbery is an offense against persons, while theft is an offense against property. The trial court did not violate the sentencing package doctrine because it imposed six years on each robbery offense. The trial court did not err when it imposed court costs on the defendant because there was nothing in the record to indicate that defendant, despite his indigency, could not pay his court costs.
- 2018 Ohio 2129WRRS, L.L.C. v. Cleveland (2018)
Administrative appeal standard of review preponderance of substantial, reliable, and probative evidence maintenance violations waiver res judicata. Judgment affirmed. The issue on appeal is specific as to what was cited in 2016 — the removal of the currently existing debris piles. The Board's 2012 decision on a different violation did not waive the City's right to cite WRRS for a violation resulting from conditions on the property in 2016. On review, we conclude that the preponderance of substantial, reliable, and probative evidence supports the trial court's decision.
- 2018 Ohio 2130State v. Travis (2018)
Search and seizure, suppression of evidence, probable cause, lawful search of vehicle, disclosure of confidential informant. The trial court properly denied defendant's request to disclose the identity of the confidential informant due to concerns for the safety of the informant, and defendant's failure to establish that the information was vital to an element of the offense or required to prepare a defense. The warrantless search of defendant's vehicle was lawful because it occurred incident to his arrest after contraband was discovered on his person and also for vehicle inventory purposes to protect the contents prior to towing.
- 2018 Ohio 2131State v. Jackson (2018)
Inconsistent verdicts motion to suppress exclusionary rule warrantless search of vehicle Crim.R. 29 ineffective assistance of counsel. Defendant's aggravated robbery conviction affirmed. It is not inconsistent to convict a defendant of aggravated robbery and acquit him of firearm specifications when the deadly weapon may be something other than a gun. The police acted in good faith when they arrested the defendant and they had probable cause to search the car used in the robbery. Defendant's conviction is supported by sufficient evidence in the record and there is no evidence in the record that his trial counsel was ineffective.
- 2018 Ohio 2132Daniels v. Northcoast Anesthesia Providers, Inc. (2018)
Cumulative error. The cumulative effect of multiple trial errors deprived the defendants of a fair trial.
- 2018 Ohio 2133Barno v. Dir., Dept. of Job & Family Servs. (2018)
Unemployment compensation just cause to quit failure to pay as promised. UCRC's decision finding no just cause to quit and disallowing employee's unemployment compensation benefits was against the manifest weight of the evidence. Hearing officer's decision improperly found that employee's failure to quit "immediately" and failure to notify anyone other than his immediate supervisor of workplace issues did not amount to just cause to quit. Furthermore, hearing officer improperly concluded that the employer's failure to address the employee's concerns was reasonable just cause to quit, under unemployment compensation law, focuses on the conduct of the employee, not the employer.
- 2018 Ohio 2135State v. Hagerman (2018)
4511.19(D)(4)(b), motion to suppress, motion in limine, field sobriety testing, probable cause to arrest
- 2018 Ohio 2136State v. Darr (2018)
motion to suppress, reasonable suspicion, stop, weight of the evidence, firearm specification, R.C. 2941.145, R.C. 2903.11(A)(2)
- 2018 Ohio 2137State v. Camacho (2018)
rape, police interview, App.R. 16(A)(7), Evid.R. 803(8), Evid.R. 801(D)(1)(a), transcript
- 2018 Ohio 2138State v. Burchell (2018)
sufficiency, R.C. 2921.36, conveyance by another
- 2018 Ohio 2139State v. Westerfield (2018)
Appeal dismissed where defendant acquitted of all crimes, second appeal denied where appellant did not demonstrate ineffective assitance of counsel.
- 2018 Ohio 2141In re D.A.S.H. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2142State v. Minton (2018)
Appellant's conviction for OVI was not against the manifest weight of the evidence where the state presented overwhelming evidence of his guilt.
- 2018 Ohio 2143In re S.B. (2018)
The trial court properly granted permanent custody of appellant's child to the agency where the child had been in foster care for 29 consecutive months and it was in the child's best interest. The child did very well in foster care while appellant was unable to care for the child who has special needs.
- 2018 Ohio 2145State ex rel. Hull v. Culotta (2018)
PROCEDENDO - petition is moot because court addressed motion petitioner failed to comply with mandatory filing requirements petitioner has adequate remedy via direct appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 2146State v. Jackson (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - motion for leave delayed "motion for new mitigation trial" death penalty Sixth Amendment jury trial Hurst v. Florida not appropriately raised in Crim.R. 33 motion unavoidably prevented timeliness harmless error R.C. 2953.21 postconviction relief violation of constitutional rights untimely R.C. 2953.23 retroactivity collateral review Ring v. Arizona unnecessary to reach constitutional issue State v. Mason.
- 2018 Ohio 2147In re Allender (2018)
CIVIL - relief from weapons disability R.C. 2923.14 permissive statute abuse of discretion firearm specification criminal history offense of violence.
- 2018 Ohio 2148State v. Rinda (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - App.R. 4(A) Loc.R. 3(D)(2) untimely appeal has not sought leave to appeal pursuant to App.R. 5(A).
- 2018 Ohio 2150State v. Bowshier (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Appeal dismissed as having been improvidently accepted.
- 2018 Ohio 2151State ex rel. Daily Servs., L.L.C. v. Morrison (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Workers' compensation—Bureau of Workers' Compensation did not abuse its discretion when it determined that short-term temp agency wholly succeeded the business operations of long-term temp agency for purposes of transferring long-term agency's unpaid premium liabilities to short-term agency under former Ohio Adm.Code 4123-17-02(C)(1)—Court of appeals' judgment granting writ of mandamus reversed.
- 2018 Ohio 2153State ex rel. Penske Truck Leasing Co., L.P. v. Indus. Comm. (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Workers' compensation—Industrial commission failed to explain the basis for its specific allocations of cost for permanent-total-disability award among the worker's three claims—Court of appeals' judgment granting writ of mandamus affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2156Lang v. Piersol Outdoor Advertising Co. (2018)
Civil: declaratory judgment action contract interpretation summary judgment right of first refusal.
- 2018 Ohio 2158First World Architects Studio, PSC v. McGhee (2018)
FEDERAL PREEMPTION – COPYRIGHT: The trial court did not err by dismissing for lack of subject- matter jurisdiction a copyright holder's complaint alleging the infringement of its copyrights in architectural drawings, because the copyright holder did not allege a breach-of-contract claim falling outside the subject matter of copyright law, and the copyright holder's infringement claims fell within the exclusive jurisdiction of the federal courts and were preempted, even though the copyright holder did not register its architectural drawings.
- 2018 Ohio 2159State v. Bullucks (2018)
SPEEDY TRIAL — INSTRUCTIONS — RAPE — FELONIOUS ASSAULT: Defendant was not denied his Sixth Amendment right to the effective assistance of counsel by defense counsel's failure to move to dismiss on speedy-trial grounds his rape and felonious assault charges: defendant, who had been held in jail without bail, was brought to trial within the 90 days required by R.C. 2945.71 et seq., because defense counsel had signed two of the three continuance entries, each entry contained an asterisk next the signature line with the words, "Defense counsel waives all speedy trial rights in accord with R.C. 2945.71 et seq.," and with those continuances, only 47 days chargeable to the state had elapsed from the date of defendant's arrest through the trial date. The trial court did not commit plain error by returning the jury to its deliberations without giving the instruction set forth in State v. Howard, 42 Ohio St.3d 18, 537 N.E.2d 188 (1989), after the jury had indicated it was deadlocked four hours into its deliberations nor did the court abuse its discretion by giving the Howard charge over defendant's objection, or by failing to declare a mistrial, after the jury had reported that it was deadlocked a second time, because the jury's submission of an additional question showed that it had remained engaged in reviewing the evidence related to the rape counts, and because the jury reached a unanimous verdict the following day. The jury's verdicts finding defendant guilty of the forceful vaginal rape of a 15-year-old girl and the felonious assault of her stepmother were not contrary to the manifest weight of the evidence: the rape victim testified that defendant had forced her to engage in vaginal sex, her DNA was found on defendant's penis, and the victim had sustained a tear and abrasion to her cervix consistent with a penetrating trauma and the assault victim testified that defendant had choked, punched, bitten, and stabbed her, and her testimony was corroborated by photographs and her medical and dental records.
- 2018 Ohio 2160State v. Jeffries (2018)
CONSTITUTIONAL LAW/CRIMINAL – SEX OFFENSES – RAPE – GROSS SEXUAL IMPOSITION – EVIDENCE – RAPE-SHIELD STATUTE – JOINDER – COUNSEL – SENTENCING – CONSECUTIVE SENTENCES: Ohio's rape-shield statute, R.C. 2907.02, prohibits evidence of the victim's nonconsensual sexual activity, unless that evidence falls under a specific exception for admission, such as to show the origin of a disease, and the evidence is both material to a fact at issue and its probative value is not outweighed by its inflammatory or prejudicial nature. In a trial that included charges involving the defendant's sexual abuse of his daughter, the trial court did not err by excluding evidence of the daughter's prior nonconsensual sexual activity with another perpetrator that led to her contraction of a genital medical condition, because how the victim contracted the condition was not material to a fact at issue with respect to the offenses charged, and because the exclusion of the irrelevant evidence did not infringe on the defendant's constitutional rights to confront witnesses and present a defense. Under Crim.R. 8(A), it was proper to charge in the same indictment the offense of aggravated drug trafficking, which included the element that it had occurred in the vicinity of a juvenile, and sex offenses against the defendant's juvenile daughter, because the facts showed the offenses charged were "part of a course of criminal conduct": the drug offense occurred around the same time and at the same location—the defendant's home—as one of the sex offenses, the evidence was interrelated because the daughter provided testimony establishing the juvenile-vicinity element of the drug offense, and the offenses were investigated at the same time, resulting in additional overlapping witnesses. The trial court did not abuse its discretion by refusing to sever a drug offense from sex offenses where the evidence for each count was sufficiently separate and distinct such that the jury, as instructed, could separate and analyze the proof of each offense independently, as evinced by an acquittal on one count in the case. The defendant's conviction for the aggravated trafficking of oxycodone in an amount equaling or exceeding bulk was supported by sufficient evidence and not against the manifest weight of the evidence where the evidence showed that the defendant obtained at least 85 Percocet pills containing oxycodone, put a few in a container marked "personal," and put the rest aside in two other containers with the intent that those pills would be sold and either crushed for regular customers who kept snorting straws in the defendant's home, or placed in one of the miniature zip-lock like bags recovered with the pills in the defendant's laundry basket. The defendant's convictions for sex offenses against his daughter, including rape and gross sexual imposition, were supported by sufficient evidence and not against the manifest weight of the evidence, even though the state did not present DNA test results to corroborate his daughter's testimony, where the daughter's testimony was unequivocal, detailed, and credible, and bolstered by other evidence, including incriminating text messages from the defendant. The defendant failed to demonstrate that defense counsel was ineffective for not presenting an expert witness to testify about DNA test results of items recovered from the rape victim's room, and for not hiring an expert to examine those items, because there is nothing in the record from which the court can determine that such testimony or additional testing would have been favorable to the defendant and outcome determinative. The trial court did not err by ordering that the defendant serve his sentence for a drug offense consecutively to sex-offense sentences where the trial court made the appropriate R.C. 2929.14(C)(4) findings at the sentencing hearing and included those findings in the sentencing entry.
- 2018 Ohio 2161In re D.L. (2018)
JUVENILE – GUN SPECIFICATIONS – R.C. 2152.17 – COUNSEL – CONSTITUTIONAL LAW/CRIMINAL – DOUBLE JEOPARDY – EQUAL PROTECTION: The juvenile court did not err in imposing, and counsel was not ineffective in failing to challenge the constitutionality of, multiple, cumulative commitments for firearm specifications to underlying felonies committed as part of the same transaction: the commitments were permitted under R.C. 2152.17 and the statute did not violate rights secured by the United States Constitution under the Double Jeopardy Clause of the Fifth Amendment, because firearm specifications are sentencing enhancements, not offenses, or under the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment, because the statute is rationally related to a legitimate governmental purpose.
- 2018 Ohio 2162Pratt v. Univ. of Cincinnati (2018)
The trial court did not err in granting the university's motion for summary judgment and did not abuse its discretion in denying Pratt's Civ.R. 60(B) motion for relief from judgment.
- 2018 Ohio 2163Ray v. Ohio Dep't of Health (2018)
We affirmed the Court of Claims' judgment which granted the Civ.R. 56 motion for summary judgment of appellee finding appellant's termination was not based on her disabilities and that appellee was not required to engage in the interactive process for a reasonable accomodation.
- 2018 Ohio 2164State ex rel. Farrell v. Indus. Comm. (2018)
The magistrate correctly determined that the doctrine of stare decisis does not compel the commission to grant Farrell's application for PTD compensation. Writ of mandamus denied.
- 2018 Ohio 2165Harris v. Ohio Dep't of Veterans Servs. (2018)
Trial court's Civ.R. 12(B)(6) dismissal of declaratory judgment claim in combined complaint for mandamus and declaratory judgment reversed. Decision on appeal addresses when those two causes of action may be brought in same complaint. Withdrawn administrative appeal by unclassified employee not sufficient to overcome enforcement of former employee's claims by declaratory judgment. Judgment reversed.
- 2018 Ohio 2166State v. Crawford (2018)
CRIMINAL - Appellant was not deprived of due process as his plea to robbery was knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily made to the trial court. The trial court was not required to inform Appellant that a jury verdict must be unanimous before accepting his plea.
- 2018 Ohio 2168The State Ex Rel. Doe v. Gallia County Common Pleas Court. (2018)
Mandamus—Procedendo—R.C. 2953.52(A)(1)—Sealing of official records—Request for writ of mandamus sua sponte converted to request for writ of procedendo—Writ of procedendo granted.
- 2018 Ohio 2169State v. Jackson (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Criminal law—Fifth and Sixth Amendments—A social worker's statutory duty to cooperate and share information with law enforcement with respect to child-abuse investigations does not render social worker an agent of law enforcement for purposes of Fifth and Sixth Amendments to United States Constitution when social worker interviews an alleged perpetrator unless other evidence demonstrates that social worker acted at direction or under control of law enforcement—Record does not support court of appeals' conclusion that social worker was acting as law-enforcement agent when she interviewed child-abuse suspect—Court of appeals' judgment reversing suspect's convictions reversed and cause remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 2170Cleveland Metropolitan Bar Association v. Gay. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct, including failing to properly safeguard client funds in a client trust account—Conditionally stayed one-year suspension.
- 2018 Ohio 2172State v. Beavers (2018)
sufficiency – manifest weight – felony murder – felonious assault – identity – circumstantial evidence
- 2018 Ohio 2173State v. Crangle (2018)
motion to withdraw guilty plea, void sentence, res judicata, rape, R.C. 2907.02(A)(1)(b)
- 2018 Ohio 2174State v. Henry (2018)
robbery, theft, sufficiency, manifest weight, R.C. 2911.02(A)(3)
- 2018 Ohio 2176In re M.O. (2018)
visitation – nunc pro tunc – Civ.R. 60(A) – on the court's own initiative – res judicata – law of the case – jurisdiction – perfected appeal
- 2018 Ohio 2177State v. Ivery (2018)
aggravated murder, murder, Batson challenge, challenge for cause, jury instructions, manifest weight, sufficiency, App.R. 16(A)(7)
- 2018 Ohio 2178Pryamid Ents., L.L.C. v. Akron Dept. of Neighborhood Assistance (2018)
administrative appeal of a demolition order, Chapter 2506 – perfecting administrative appeal, R.C. 2505.04 – untimely, R.C. 2505.07 – dismissal – lack of subject matter jurisdiction – competing affidavits – hearsay in affidavits
- 2018 Ohio 2179Taylor v. Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co. (2018)
summary judgment, Civ.R. 56, products liability, res judicata, asbestos, Civ.R. 54(B)
- 2018 Ohio 2180State v. Tucker (2018)
R.C. 4511.19(A)(1)(a), OVI, operating a vehicle under the influence of alcohol or drugs, motion to suppress, ineffective assistance of counsel, field sobriety test, urine test
- 2018 Ohio 2181In re Polizzi (2018)
On certified entry of felonly conviction.
- 2018 Ohio 2184State v. Glaze (2018)
R.C. 2929.14/sentencing R.C. 2953.08(D)(1) ineffective assistance of counsel. The trial court acknowledged the agreed-upon sentencing range between the state and appellant appellant's sentence was within the sentencing range and included nonmandatory consecutive sentences. Appellant's sentence was not contrary to law. Appellant failed to show that his counsel's performance fell below an objective standard of reasonableness and that he was prejudiced by counsel's performance.
- 2018 Ohio 2185Gerston v. Parma VTA, L.L.C. (2018)
Standing necessary parties jurisdiction R.C. 1335.04/statute of frauds contract documents manifest weight statute of limitations. Decedent's will established that his remaining assets transferred to the Trust thereby giving the Trust a vested interest giving appellee standing to bring forth its complaint against appellant. None of appellee's claims included a claim for conversion. Appellee's declaratory judgment action was not untimely for failing to fall within the statute of limitations for conversion. Appellee joined all necessary parties in its original action the trial court had jurisdiction to proceed on appellee's complaint. The statute of frauds was applicable where it was shown that a proper transfer had not occurred. Contract documents stipulated that any modification, transfer, or assignment of interest must be done so in writing. Appellants submitted no evidence of a written agreement. The trial court did not err in finding that any alleged oral assignment was improper.The trial court's judgment resolving the ownership dispute was supported by competent, credible evidence and was not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 2186Clifton Steel Co. v. Trinity Equip. Co. (2018)
Contract interpretation ambiguous preliminary injunction noncompete clause motion to dismiss final appealable order. Court did not err by finding contract language ambiguous and granting the appellee's motion for preliminary injunction.
- 2018 Ohio 2187Cleveland v. Henderson (2018)
Motion for acquittal right to obtain counsel. The trial court erred where it did not grant appellant's motion for continuance in order to obtain new counsel.
- 2018 Ohio 2188State v. Shutes (2018)
Excited utterance manifest weight of the evidence. Trial court erred in admitting witness's statement about what the declarant told her as an excited utterance because the declarant was no longer under the stress of the event when he made the statement, although the error was harmless because the statement did not contribute to the guilty verdict even though there were inconsistencies in the witnesses' testimony and conflicts in the evidence, defendant's conviction was not against the manifest weight of the evidence where the jury heard significant evidence that demonstrated defendant's guilt.
- 2018 Ohio 2189State v. Fisher (2018)
Sufficient evidence, manifest weight of the evidence, prior acts testimony, consecutive sentences, R.C. 2929.14(C)(4), imposition of court costs. There was sufficient evidence to convict the appellant of aggravated arson. The evidence was not against the manifest weight because there was substantial evidence upon which a jury could reasonably conclude that all the elements have been proved beyond a reasonable doubt. Testimony concerning the appellant's prior acts of arson was admissible for other purposes, such as proof of motive, opportunity, intent, preparation, plan, knowledge, identity, or absence of mistake or accident. The trial court did not err when it sentenced the appellant to serve consecutive sentences because it properly followed the guidelines and principles of R.C. 2929.14(C)(4).
- 2018 Ohio 2190MRI Software, L.L.C. v. W. Oaks Mall FL, L.L.C. (2018)
Contractual obligations unjust enrichment attorney fees. The trial court did not err where it found that appellant provided the necessary notice to appellee of the problems with appellee's delivered product. The trial court's allowance of parol evidence was not error where the terms of the contract were ambiguous and clarification was needed on particular terms the court's finding that appellee failed to perform was supported by competent, credible evidence. Where a valid, enforceable contract exists, an unjust enrichment claim fails. The trial court erred where it failed to award attorney fees pursuant to the contract agreement.
- 2018 Ohio 2191State v. Foster (2018)
Ineffective assistance of counsel guilty plea motion to withdraw guilty plea Crim.R. 32.1 abuse of discretion Crim.R. 11. Appellant was not denied his constitutional right to the effective assistance of counsel. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying appellant's motion to withdraw his guilty plea.
- 2018 Ohio 2192Magnus Int'l Grp., Inc. v. Forster (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2193Agaj v. Univ. Hosps. Health Sys., Inc. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2198City of E. Cleveland v. Hall (2018)
Criminal simulation East Cleveland Codified Ordinances 545.13 attempt to cash altered check alteration of check payee and amount sufficiency of the evidence manifest weight of the evidence. Defendant's conviction for criminal simulation in violation of East Cleveland Codified Ordinances 545.13(a) was not supported by sufficient evidence. Construing ambiguous ordinance strictly against the city and liberally in favor of defendant, altering a check to erase and replace the payee and amount of the check did not constitute "alter[ation]" of the "source" or "authorship" of an "object" within the meaning of E.C.C.O. 545.13(a).
- 2018 Ohio 2200Manley Architecture Group, L.L.C. v. Santanello (2018)
Judgment affirmed in part and reversed in part. Because the scope of the "construction management" role in the parties' contract did not authorize Manley Architecture Group to recover for advances to subcontractors after Dr. Santanello stopped payment, the award of $55,577.68 in its favor is reversed. Furthermore, because the agreement did not made Manley Architecture Group the guarantor of each subcontractor's work, the award of $160,000 in favor of Dr. Santanello for the complete replacement of the barn roof is reversed. In all other respects, the judgment of the trial court is affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2202State v. Ramey (2018)
Guilty plea was knowingly and intelligently entered
- 2018 Ohio 2203State v. Caldwell (2018)
Community Control Revocation
- 2018 Ohio 2204State v. Embry (2018)
SEX OFFENSES – CLASSIFICATION – REGISTRATION – NOTIFICATION: Where the trial court correctly classified defendant as a Tier II sex offender under the Adam Walsh Act, but the notice form given to defendant was blank where it indicates whether defendant is a sex offender or child-victim offender, the boxes on the form that indicate defendant's tier classification were left blank, and the boxes that indicate the duration and frequency of defendant's registration duties were left blank, and where the trial court did not inform defendant that she had to register with the sheriff or orally provide any of the R.C. 2950.03(B) notifications, the trial court failed to provide defendant with the required notice of her registration duties, and the cause must be remanded for the trial court to correctly notify defendant of her Tier II registration and verification duties and their duration. [See CONCURRENCE: The only error committed by the trial court was failing to check the appropriate boxes on the notification form.]
- 2018 Ohio 2205State v. Furr (2018)
CONSTITUTIONAL LAW/CRIMINAL – RIGHT TO COUNSEL – WAIVER – DUE PROCESS – JAIL CLOTHES: Defendant's waiver of trial counsel was valid where the trial court made a sufficient inquiry to determine whether defendant fully understood and intelligently relinquished his constitutional right to counsel with respect to a prosecution for burglary and possessing criminal tools, defendant clearly and unequivocally asserted his right to represent himself on multiple occasion, and the court warned of the disadvantages of proceeding without counsel, explained that defendant would be required to follow the rules of procedure and evidence, and thoroughly explained the nature and elements of the charges, possible defenses to the charges, and the potential sentences that defendant faced. Defendant failed to demonstrate that his constitutional right to due process was violated when he stood trial before a jury while dressed in identifiable jail clothes where the trial court informed defendant of the option of wearing civilian clothes, defendant failed to object to being tried in jail clothes, and the court told the jurors to disregard the fact that defendant was wearing jail clothes.
- 2018 Ohio 2206In re D.C. (2018)
CHILDREN – DELINQUENCY – JURISDICTION: Where the juvenile court failed to independently adjudicate the juvenile delinquent, the dispositional order was not final therefore, the juvenile's appeal from the dispositional order must be dismissed for lack of jurisdiction.
- 2018 Ohio 2207State v. Dick (2018)
Presentence Motion to Withdraw Guilty Plea Crim.R. 32.1 Factors to determine Motion to Withdraw Traf.R. 8(D) Arraignment Right to Counsel Traf.R. 10(D) Plea of Guilty Duty to provide accurate information in accepting guilty plea
- 2018 Ohio 2208In re Z.E.N. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2209Capital One Bank v. Rose (2018)
Motion to dismiss Personal Jurisdiction: Ohio resident Summary Judgment Pro se appellant Failure to request continuance to respond to motion for summary judgment Attorney: authority to act for client
- 2018 Ohio 2210State v. Brooks (2018)
R.C. 2945.71 speedy trial sua sponte continuance: requirement to state reasons to toll period reasonableness of continuance
- 2018 Ohio 2214State v. Coleman (2018)
Trial court did not err in denying defendant's motion to suppress the robbery victim's show-up identification of defendant. The State presented sufficient evidence that defendant had an operable firearm during the robbery. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in allowing the admission of a gun and ammunition located 18 days after the robbery in the location where defendant had fled from the police. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2215State v. Blackson (2018)
Appellant's conviction for rape of a person under the age of thirteen is not against the manifest weight of the evidence. The weight of the evidence supports finding that when the sexual conduct occurred, the victim was eleven years old. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2216State v. Cencebaugh (2018)
Appellant's 11-month sentence for aggravated possession of drugs, felony of the fifth degree, is not contrary to law and is supported by the record, given Appellant's lengthy criminal history. Judgment affirmed. (Hall, J., concurring.) (Tucker, J., concurring.)
- 2018 Ohio 2217State v. Day (2018)
This court is unable to review the trial court's judgment granting Appellee's motion to suppress evidence because the trial court failed to make a finding as to whether there was probable cause to arrest Appellee for drug trafficking. The judgment of the trial court is therefore reversed and the matter is remanded so that the trial court can issue a decision indicating whether there was probable cause to arrest Appellee. (Donovan, J., dissenting.)
- 2018 Ohio 2218Howard v. Howard (2018)
Appellant appeals pro se from a judgment granting Appellee a domestic violence civil protection order. Appellant did not file a transcript, or a proper substitute, of the hearing resulting in the issuance of the protection order. In the absence of a transcript, or an appropriate substitute, the regularity of the proceedings before the trial court must be presumed unless the limited record for review demonstrates error. The limited record does not demonstrate any error therefore, based upon the presumption of regularity, the trial court's judgment must be affirmed. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2219State v. Jones (2018)
Defendant-appellant's counsel filed a brief under the authority of Anders v. California, 386 U.S. 738, 87 S.Ct. 1396, 18 L.Ed.2d 493 (1967) concluding that there are no meritorious issues to present on appeal. After conducting an independent review of the record, consistent with our duty under Anders, we also find no issues with arguable merit for appeal. Affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2220State v. Mayberry (2018)
Anders appeal with pro se brief. No non-frivolous issues found regarding the trial court's denial of defendant's motion to suppress, the plea hearing, and defendant's sentence. No potentially meritorious claim of ineffective assistance of counsel exists. No non-frivolous issues found upon an independent review. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2221State v. Miller (2018)
Trial court did not err in denying defendant's motion to dismiss the indictment on double jeopardy grounds. Applying the test set forth in Blockburger v. United States, 284 U.S. 299, 52 S.Ct. 180, 76 L.Ed. 306 (1932), the State was not barred from bringing a successive prosecution for receiving stolen property (a motor vehicle) after defendant's conviction in another county for grand theft of the same motor vehicle. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2223State ex rel. Haber Polk Kabat, L.L.P. v. Sutula (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2226State v. Williamson (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2228U.S. Bank Trust Nat'l Ass'n v. Janossy (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2236State v. High (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2238State v. Carter (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2239State v. Tinley (2018)
App.R. 9 – audio-recording – transcript – presume regularity – speedy trial – new trial – acting judge
- 2018 Ohio 2240State v. Perkins (2018)
magistrate's decision, objections to magistrate's decision, Crim.R. 19, specificity requirement
- 2018 Ohio 2241Lorain Cnty. Cmty. Coll. v. Ohio Dep't of Jobs & Family Servs. (2018)
unemployment compensation benefits, just cause, manifest weight of the evidence, R.C. 4141.282(H)
- 2018 Ohio 2242State v. Benvenuto (2018)
The trial court did not err in overruling Defendant-Appellant's motino to suppress. Additionally, Defendant-Appellant's RICO conviction, through his plea of no contest, is supported by sufficient evidence in the record. Further, the trial court did not err in failing to merge three charges into a single offense. Lastly, the trial court did not err in its sentence of the Defendant-Appellant. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2243State v. Lundy (2018)
The trial court abused its discretion by denying the defendant-appellant's motion to waive, suspend, or modify payment of costs.
- 2018 Ohio 2244State v. Close (2018)
Forfeiture specifications need not be addressed in the sentencing entry as they are not part of the punishment. The sentence was supported by the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 2245State v. Stewart (2018)
Convictions for Corrupting Another with Drugs supported by sufficient evidence and not against the weight of the evidence. Appellant failed to demonstrate ineffective assistance of trial counsel.
- 2018 Ohio 2246State v. Kimpel (2018)
A trial court may allow a defendant to withdraw a guilty plea after he or she has been sentenced if the defendant demonstrates a manifest injustice.
- 2018 Ohio 2247State v. McGowan (2018)
CIVIL - post-conviction relief second request to set aside conviction res judicata no argument App.R. 16(A)(7).
- 2018 Ohio 2248Illuminating Co. v. Wiser (2018)
ENERGY & UTILITIES LAW - measure of damages for negligent destruction of utility pole is cost of pole and facilities attached thereto based on reproduction cost less accrued depreciation of damaged pole and facilities attached thereto indirect costs of repairs (overhead) are a proper element of damage for which recovery may be had in case involving damage to utility pole where such costs can be proved with reasonable certainty and have been correctly made in accord with sound accounting principles.
- 2018 Ohio 2249State v. Cozzone (2018)
CRIMINAL - felony sentencing R.C. 2929.11 R.C. 2929.12 silent record failure to comply with the conditions of intervention and community control R.C. 2929.14 consecutive sentences clearly and convincingly find the record does not support the trial court's findings R.C. 2929.15(B) technical violation of community control sanctions motion for reconsideration nullity remand for sentencing.
- 2018 Ohio 2250State v. DiBiase (2018)
POST CONVICTION RELIEF - a trial court's decision to grant or deny a petition for post conviction relief is reviewed for abuse of discretion a petition for post conviction relief must be filed within 180 days after the trial transcript is filed in the court of appeals unless the petitioner can meet the criteria set forth in R.C. 2953.23(A)(1) R.C. 2953.21(A)(1)(b) defines actual innocence for purposes of post conviction relief proceedings Herrera v. Collins, 506 U.S. 390 (1993) and Schlup v. Delo, 513 U.S. 298 (1995) construed.
- 2018 Ohio 2251State v. Yallah (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - OVI traffic stop identified citizen informant vehicle color and model direction of travel driving recklessly officer observations potential marked lanes violation weaving within lanes erratic acceleration hard braking reasonable suspicion valid investigative stop.
- 2018 Ohio 2252State v. Lee (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying defense counsel's request to continue trial when he was advised by the state four days earlier that co-defendant would testify against defendant where defendant did not agree to continuance but rather wanted trial to proceed at that time and would not agree to speedy trial waiver although time was about to expire in few weeks. CRIMINAL LAW - EVIDENCE - state presented sufficient evidence to support firearm specification to aggravated burglary where defendant used gun after he forced his way into victim's home, although he did not use the gun to gain entry into the home. CRIMINAL LAW - ALLIED OFFENSES LESSER INCLUDED - trial court did not err in not merging aggravated burglary and aggravated robbery convictions where offenses were committed separately and were of dissimilar import since different harm was committed with respect to aggravated robbery.
- 2018 Ohio 2253State v. Reese (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - duplicate appeal App.R. 26(B) cannot determine the substance or intention of appellant's pleading.
- 2018 Ohio 2254State v. Hovatter (2018)
Motion to suppress - warrantless arrest
- 2018 Ohio 2256Fine v. French (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2257State v. Harris (2018)
Consecutive sentences
- 2018 Ohio 2258State v. Rippey (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2259Bavis v. Deimling (2018)
Trial court did not err by finding that an easement had terminated where the undisputed evidence showed that the former private roadway was no longer in existence, there was a new paved roadway, and there were various homes, curbs, and a cul-de-sac where the former private road existed.
- 2018 Ohio 2260In re D.M. (2018)
Juvenile court did not err in granting permanent custody to children services agency where decision was supported by clear and convincing evidence and not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 2261State v. Laghaoui (2018)
The trial court did not err by finding appellant competent to stand trial where appellant failed to meet his burden of proof establishing his incompetence by a preponderance of the evidence. The trial court also did not err by instructing the jury on intoxication where appellant's intoxication was raised as part of his not guilty by reason of insanity defense, nor did the trial court err by excluding testimony from appellant's intended expert witness where the proffered testimony was an unreliable, untested assumption that was inadmissible pursuant to Evid.R. 702.
- 2018 Ohio 2264State v. Comer (2018)
Appellant's OVI convictions were supported by sufficient evidence and were not against the manifest weight of the evidence where appellant admitted to taking a drug of abuse (Neurontin), he was observed weaving back and forth on the road, he had droopy eyelids and slurred his speech, and he refused to take a chemical test after being arrested.
- 2018 Ohio 2265State v. Parr (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2267State v. Brown (2018)
R.C. 2925.11(B)(2)(b)–prosecution invited any error that trial court may have committed by applying drug-immunity statute to individual who allegedly committed minor drug possession offense before effective date of statute trial court did not err by finding that individual sought and obtained a screening and received a referral to treatment within thirty days of needing medical assistance for a drug overdose when evidence showed that individual admitted into a treatment program, which would have involved a screening and a treatment-referral.
- 2018 Ohio 2268State v. Lusane (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - App.R. 5(A) delayed appeal not diligent in taking the proper steps to protect his own rights reasons do not justify length of time to appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 2269In re A.E.B (2018)
mother permanently surrendered drug-addicted child after birth father found to have abandoned child termination of father's parental rights permanent custody to agency.
- 2018 Ohio 227017AP-230 (2018)
Objections to magistrate's decision overruled in workers compensation original action brought by injured worker. No abuse of discretion by Industrial Commission of Ohio in denying ongoing psychological counseling recommended by psychologist professional who was not a psychiatrist. Issue of the psychologist's qualifications was waived for purposes of mandamus action when not first administratively addressed at the commission. Magistrate's decision adopted and writ of mandamus denied.
- 2018 Ohio 2271State v. Smith (2018)
Appellant's plea of guilty was not the result of improper inducements offered by the prosecution and was knowing, voluntary, and intelligent. Appellant received effective assistance of trial counsel at the plea hearing and sentencing. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2272Gordon v. State Dept. Rehab. & Corr. (2018)
Prisoner Gordon sues the Ohio Department of Rehabilitation and Correction. The Court of Claims of Ohio's decision to deny Gordon's second amended complaint for failure to comply with Civ.R. 15(A) is affirmed for not being timely filed or seeking leave of the court. Gordon's first amended complaint was properly dismissed for a lack of subject matter jurisdication and for failure to state a claim upon which relief could be granted. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2273Engler v. Adjutant Gen. (2018)
The Court of Claims of Ohio did not err in dismissing appellant's complaint. His claims are barred by the applicable statute of limitations. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 227418AP-11 (2018)
Where the record does not indicate that the magistrate or trial court committed plain error, and appellant's brief did not provide legal errors for review nor a transcript that would support any conclusion otherwise, an appellate court must presume the regularity of the trial court's proceedings and affirm its decision. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2276Harris v. Dept. of Rehab. & Corr. (2018)
Negligence- Plaintiff, an inmate in Defendant's custody, fell and sustained broken ribs while pushing a rack filled with pans of food after the rack got caught on a recessed floor drain. The magistrate, after finding the 2-inch rule did not apply, found that Defendant nonetheless lacked notice regarding the floor drain's condition and recommended judgment for Defendant.
- 2018 Ohio 2277Poole v. Ohio State Univ. Wexner Med. Ctr. (2018)
Assault and Battery- Plaintiffs, a mother and daughter, sought recovery for injuries allegedly resulting from a physical altercation with hospital security guards which occurred after the mother sought treatment at Defendant's emergency room. The magistrate found plaintiffs' testimony regarding the incident and their claimed injuries lacked credibility and that hospital security staff used reasonable and non-excessive force after plaintiffs initiated the altercation and refused to leave the emergency room. As such, hospital security staff were privileged in using reasonable force to control the situation. The magistrate recommended judgment for Defendant.
- 2018 Ohio 2280King v. Divoky (2018)
Civ.R. 12(B)(6), motion to dismiss, justiciability, declaratory judgment
- 2018 Ohio 2283In re Durkin (2018)
disqualification, R.C. 2705.05(A), contempt hearing
- 2018 Ohio 2285State v. Baker (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2286State v. Stengel (2018)
Consent to search voluntarily given, Community caretaking exception justified bedroom entry statements were voluntarily given
- 2018 Ohio 2287Turner v. Univ. of Cincinnati (2018)
Summary judgment Civ.R. 56. The court found that the driver of the car in an accident was not an employee of defendant and there was not a principal-agent relationship between defendant and the driver. Further, the court determined that judicial restraint cautioned against issuing a premature ruling on a potential declaratory judgment claim relative to defendant's automobile liability coverage agreement. Summary judgment granted in favor of defendant.
- 2018 Ohio 2289Black v. Hicks (2018)
<p> ON RECONSIDERATION 1 </p>
- 2018 Ohio 2290State v. Soloman (2018)
Motion to withdraw guilty plea res judicata.
- 2018 Ohio 2291Mccall v. Sage (2018)
Appeal No. 106126 — Antoinette McCall v. Liana Sage
- 2018 Ohio 2292State v. Gordon (2018)
Murder identity of the accused sufficiency of the evidence manifest weight of the evidence admission of evidence authentication of evidence jail calls social media posts other acts evidence harmless error flight instruction.
- 2018 Ohio 2293State v. Freeman (2018)
Promoting prostitution, consecutive sentences, R.C. 2929.12, Motion to withdraw plea.
- 2018 Ohio 2294State v. Ware (2018)
R.C. 2929.11(B) inconsistent and disproportionate sentence clearly and convincingly contrary to law R.C. 2929.12(B), (E) seriousness and recidivism factors.
- 2018 Ohio 2295Millstein v. Millstein (2018)
Trust equitable relief, equitable reimbursement, income taxes, Civ.R. 12, motion to dismiss, R.C. 5804.16, R.C. 5804.10.
- 2018 Ohio 2296State v. Flips (2018)
Assault on a peace officer, manifest weight.
- 2018 Ohio 2297State v. Ross (2018)
Consecutive sentences, R.C. 2929.14(C)(4), plain error, allied offenses.
- 2018 Ohio 2298Sunshine Ltd. v. C.A.S.T.L.E., Inc (2018)
Default judgment answer complaint Civ.R. 60(B).
- 2018 Ohio 2306In re Plesich (2018)
On certified entry of felony conviction.
- 2018 Ohio 2307Merletti v. E-Merging Techs. Grp., Inc. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2309Raudins v. Hobbs (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2310State v. Durgan (2018)
CONSTITUTIONAL LAW/CRIMINAL – MIRANDA – APPELLATE REVIEW/CRIMINAL – BATSON – COUNSEL: Where police believed defendant to be a witness to a murder and drove him to the police station in an unmarked car without restraints, defendant appeared eager to help and provided information voluntarily, and police drove him back to the scene of the crime to pick up his truck, defendant was not in custody, and no Miranda warnings were required. Where defendant was interviewed several days after the murder, came voluntarily in his own truck to the police station, was not handcuffed or searched, and provided more information on who may have wished to harm the victim, defendant was not in custody, and no Miranda warnings were required even though the police had suspicions about defendant and used the opportunity to put a GPS device on his car. The totality of the circumstances showed that defendant voluntarily waived his Miranda rights and made statements to the police where, even though the interrogation was lengthy, defendant was allowed to use the restroom and was given food, and defendant never stated that he did not wish to talk to the police, that he wanted to leave, or that he wanted a lawyer, and he never confessed to killing the victim. In reviewing the trial court's ruling on a motion to suppress, the appellate court may only consider evidence presented at the suppression hearing. The trial court's acceptance of the prosecutor's race-neutral reasons to excuse two African-American prospective jurors was not clearly erroneous where the first prospective juror stated that he had a pending theft charge and did not feel be was being treated fairly by the justice system and the second prospective juror said his religion would not permit him to sign a guilty verdict and that he worked at the same company as defense counsel's wife. Defendant was not denied the effective assistance of counsel where his counsel did not present expert testimony on police interrogation techniques and false confessions, because the decision not to call an expert witness is a matter of trial strategy, and counsel extensively cross-examined the lead detective about interrogation techniques.
- 2018 Ohio 2311Evendale v. Lindsey (2018)
CRIMINAL MISCELLANEOUS – JURISDICTION – R.C. 1905.032: Where the mayor's court failed to certify the case upon transfer to the municipal court as required by R.C. 1905.032(B)(1), the municipal court lacked jurisdiction over it.
- 2018 Ohio 2312Dixon v. Anderson (2018)
REAL PROPERTY/LANDLORD AND TENANT – FORCIBLE ENTRY AND DETAINER: In a forcible-entry-and-detainer action, the trial court erred in issuing a writ of restitution where the tenant had vacated the leased premises prior to issuance of the writ.
- 2018 Ohio 2314In re: P.A. (2018)
The trial court did not err in concluding that appellant was a mentally ill person subject to court order and, thus, subject to involuntary commitment to a mental hospital. The trial court did not err in permitting the forced medication of appellant with psychotropic medication.
- 2018 Ohio 2315McDougald v. ODRC (2018)
Court of Claims did not err in granting appellee's motion to dismiss appellant's complaint.
- 2018 Ohio 2316State v. Dilo (2018)
Judgment affirmed. Because the evidence presented by the state against defendant-appellant was not legally insufficient to convict him of aggravated possession of drugs under R.C. 2925.11 and aggravated trafficking in drugs under R.C. 2925.03, his convictions were not against the manifest weight of the evidence, and did not receive ineffective assistance of trial counsel, the three assignments of error are overruled.
- 2018 Ohio 2317Bahgat v. Kissling (2018)
Appellant's contention that the trial court erred in denying an extension of time to file a hearing transcript to support his factual objections to a magistrate's decision lacked merit, and, concomitantly, the trial court did not err in sanctioning appellant under R.C. 2323.51. Appellant likewise did not demonstrate the trial court erred in regard to adjudicating his Consumer Sales Practices Act claim. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2318State v. Jackson (2018)
The judgment of the trial court dismissing defendant-appellant's motion for a new mitigation trial under Crim.R. 33 is affirmed, as the Supreme Court of Ohio's opinion in State v. Mason, ___Ohio St.3d ___, 2018-Ohio-1462, precludes his challenge to the constitutionality of Ohio's death penalty statute, R.C. 2929.03-04, under the holding of Hurst v. Florida, ___U.S.___, 136 S.Ct. 616, 193 L.Ed.2d 504 (2016).
- 2018 Ohio 2319State ex rel. Boddie, Jr. v. Baldwin (2018)
Petition dismissed. The magistrate recommends dismissing the petition because petitioner failed to comply with the requirements of R.C. 2969.25(C). No objections to the magistrate's decision have been filed. The decision is adopted.
- 2018 Ohio 2320DiCuccio v. Lindsmith (2018)
Judgment affirmed. Based on the evidence presented at the sanctions hearing, the trial court found that appellant clearly abused the judicial process and thwarted the administration of justice. Our review shows that the record contains competent, credible evidence to support the trial court's findings and judgment entry, including the allocation of attorney fees and expenses.
- 2018 Ohio 2321State v. Hall (2018)
The trial court did not err when it overruled appellant's motions to suppress. The record establishes that the police did not extend appellant's detention beyond what was reasonably necessary to resolve the issues associated with the traffic stop and to issue a traffic citation. The 19-minute time period between when the officer began writing the citation and when the K-9 unit alerted on appellant's vehicle was therefore reasonable under the facts presented in the instant case. The record establishes that the park ranger initiated the traffic stop of appellant after observing him run a stop sign located in an area which is adjacent to park grounds. Trial court did not err when it overruled appellant's motions to suppress regarding spontaneous statements he made before being arrested, as well as statements he made after waiving his rights pursuant to Miranda v. Arizona, 384 U.S. 436, 444, 86 S.Ct. 1602, 16 L.Ed.2d 694 (1966). Trial court did not err when it overruled his motion to dismiss because appellant was unable to provide any evidence of "actual prejudice" based upon a six-month delay between his arrest and the filing of his indictment. Pursuant to R.C. 1545.13(B), a park ranger has jurisdiction over criminal offenses committed on park grounds and on property adjacent to park grounds. The trial court did not abuse its discretion when it imposed a mandatory fine of $10,000.00 on appellant. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2322West Carrollton City Schools Bd. of Edn. v. Montgomery Cty. Bd. of Revision (2018)
The Board of Tax Appeals did not act unreasonably or unlawfully, nor did it abuse its discretion when it found Appellee's appraisal to be competent and probative evidence of the market value of the subject property. In addition, the BTA did not improperly consider the subject property's present use when deciding market value the BTA considered the present use in conjunction with the highest and best use of the property and did not improperly exclude other factors. The BTA also did not either abuse its discretion or err in accepting the capitalization rate of Appellee's expert rather than the rate used by Appellant's expert. Finally, the BTA did not abuse its discretion by recognizing Appellee's appraiser as an expert witness. All the BTA's decisions were supported by reliable and probative evidence. Affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2323Kettering City Schools Bd. of Edn. v. McDonald's USA, L.L.C. Montgomery Cty. Bd. of Revision (2018)
The Board of Tax Appeals (BTA) did not act unreasonably or unlawfully, nor did it abuse its discretion when it found Appellee's appraisal to be competent and probative evidence of the market value of the subject property. In addition, the BTA did not improperly consider the subject property's present use when deciding market value the BTA considered the present use in conjunction with the highest and best use of the property and did not improperly exclude other factors. The BTA also did not either abuse its discretion or err in accepting the capitalization rate of Appellee's expert rather than the rate used by Appellant's expert. Finally, the BTA did not abuse its discretion by recognizing Appellee's appraiser as an expert witness. All the BTA's decisions were supported by reliable and probative evidence. Affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2324West Carrollton City Schools Bd. of Edn. v. Montgomery Cty. Bd. of Revision (2018)
The Board of Tax Appeals did not act unreasonably or unlawfully, nor did it abuse its discretion when it found Appellee's appraisal to be competent and probative evidence of the market value of the subject property. In addition, the BTA did not improperly consider the subject property's present use when deciding market value the BTA considered the present use in conjunction with the highest and best use of the property and did not improperly exclude other factors. The BTA also did not either abuse its discretion or err in accepting the capitalization rate of Appellee's expert rather than the rate used by Appellant's expert. Finally, the BTA did not abuse its discretion by recognizing Appellee's appraiser as an expert witness. All the BTA's decisions were supported by reliable and probative evidence. Affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2325Kettering City Schools Bd. of Edn. v. Montgomery Cty. Bd. of Revision (2018)
The Board of Tax Appeals (BTA) did not act unreasonably or unlawfully in adopting the evidence of the board of education (BOE) with respect to the valuation of a McDonald's. The experts' selections of comparable properties for sales and income capitalization analyses varied significantly. The owner's valuations were based on restaurants of any type and one which was sold for a non-restaurant use, all of which were located within Montgomery County, whereas the BOE's expert focused more specifically on fast-food restaurants, which place a higher value on accessibility using a drive-thru, and included properties in a wider geographical area. The BTA did not act unreasonably in concluding that one appraisal more accurately valued the McDonald's property. Although the BOE's expert stated that the McDonald's might have been valued as a special-purpose property, he did not, in fact, value the McDonald's in this manner. The BTA's rejection of an appraiser's valuation in another case did not, in itself, disqualify the expert or impugn his opinions in this case. Decision and Order of the BTA affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2326State v. Glenn (2018)
In pretrial motions, the defendant alleged that the person he was charged with murdering had raped his young daughter. He sought to obtain (and presumably admit) extrinsic evidence to substantiate the alleged rape and to show that he had committed voluntary manslaughter, rather than murder, because the rape had caused him to act in sudden passion or fit of rage. He also sought an expert's evaluation of his state of mind at the time of the shooting. The trial court did not err or abuse its discretion in concluding that, because defendant had learned of the alleged rape four months prior to the shooting, and because he had had a "cooling off" period of more than eight minutes between the time of his first altercation with the victim and the shooting of the victim, he was not entitled to argue that he had committed voluntary manslaughter rather than murder and was not entitled to a jury instruction on voluntary manslaughter. Based on this record, the trial court did not abuse its discretion in concluding that an expert's report regarding defendant's subjective state of mind (which was not made a part of the record) was inadmissible because defendant's actions were not objectively and/or subjectively reasonable. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2327State v. Ogletree, Jr. (2018)
The trial court did not err when it overruled appellant's motion to suppress. The record establishes that the police did not unreasonably extend appellant's detention beyond what was reasonably necessary to resolve the issues associated with the traffic stop and to issue a traffic citation. The appellant did not receive ineffective assistance when his counsel failed to ask the arresting officer additional questions regarding the time it took him to complete appellant's traffic citation. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2328Brown v. Burnett (2018)
The trial court's entry overruling objections and adopting a magistrate's decision is not an appealable order under Bennett v. Bennett, 2012-Ohio-501, 969 N.E.2d 344 (2d Dist.). Accordingly, this court lacks jurisdiction to address the merits of the appellant's arguments. Appeal dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 2330State v. Jones (2018)
The appellant's convictions on two counts of felonious assault are supported by legally sufficient evidence and are not against the weight of the evidence. Although the number of shell casings recovered at the crime scene did not match the number of shots allegedly fired by the appellant, the jury reasonably could have concluded that not all of the casings were recovered in the dark and that enough shots were fired for the appellant to have fired at three people. The trial court did not err in overruling the appellant's motion to suppress a pretrial photo identification where the photospread was not unduly suggestive. Any question about whether an eyewitness identified Jones as the shooter or merely as someone he had seen in the neighborhood went to the weight and significance of the identification rather than its admissibility. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2331Bogart v. Gutmann (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2333State v. McLaughlin (2018)
IAC - allied offenses - theft - aggravated robbery -kidnapping - felonious assualt
- 2018 Ohio 2335State v. Hall (2018)
Whether defense of R.C. 959.131(B) applied to preclude conviction
- 2018 Ohio 2336State v. Feister (2018)
Appellant not entitled to jail time credit for unrelated case mootness doctrine
- 2018 Ohio 2338State v. Harris (2018)
Trial court denial of appellant's Crim.R. 29 motion was proper. Verdict was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2339Lemay v. Univ. Toledo Med. Ctr. (2018)
No error disposing case because no issue of material fact existed to challenge whether employment was governed by CBA no jurisdiction.
- 2018 Ohio 2340State v. McCullough (2018)
Appellate counsel's motion to withdraw granted.
- 2018 Ohio 2341Wheeler v. NN Metal Stampings, Inc. (2018)
Unemployment Compensation Review Commission's denial of appellant's application for unemployment benefits was not against the manifest weight of the evidence, where the record revealed that appellant quit his employment without affording the employer an opportunity to address his safety concerns, and therefore without just cause.
- 2018 Ohio 2343Birkmeier v. St. Rita's Med. Ctr. (2018)
The trial court did not err in granting Appellees' motion for summary judgment. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2344State v. Hefner (2018)
The trial court did not commit error when it sentenced the defendant-appellant to consecutive prison terms. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2345State v. Stein (2018)
Appellant failed to establish that he was denied effective assistance from his trial counsel.
- 2018 Ohio 2346Alt v. Pazmino-Stanfield (2018)
The trial court did not err in granting summary judgment in favor of the Seneca County Treasurer in its foreclosure complaint. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2347Copen v. CRW, Inc. (2018)
summary judgment, Civ.R. 56, App.R. 16(A)(7), disability discrimination, R.C. 4112.02, workers' compensation, retaliation, R.C. 4123.90
- 2018 Ohio 2348In re K.C. (2018)
permanent custody – manifest weight of the evidence – cannot or should not be returned to parents – failure to remedy – chronic mental illness – best interest of the child
- 2018 Ohio 2350State v. Noggy (2018)
CRIMINAL - sentencing clear and convincing evidence contrary to law R.C. 2929.12 factors seriousness recidivism remorse
- 2018 Ohio 2351State v. Lett (2018)
CRIMINAL - postconviction petition guilty plea constitutional right de novo untimely res judicata void subject-matter jurisdiction
- 2018 Ohio 2352Grubbs v. Delphi Automotive Sys. (2018)
CIVIL - summary judgment Civ.R. 56(C) employment discrimination R.C. 4112.02(A) disparate treatment retaliation R.C. 4112.02(I) nondiscriminatory and pretextual reasons for termination
- 2018 Ohio 2353Peck c/o Legacy Health Servs v. Dept. of Job and Family Servs. (2018)
ADMINISTRATIVE - medicaid undue hardship exemption termination of jurisdiction principle legal capacity to initiate appeal authorized representative Adm.Code 5160-1-33(A) real party in interest substitution Civ.R. 25(A) "appellant" R.C. 5101.35(E)
- 2018 Ohio 2358Toledo v. State (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Separation of powers—Trial court lacked authority to enjoin enforcement of spending provisions, because no action has been filed challenging the provisions' constitutionality—Trial court abused its discretion when it enjoined enforcement of spending provisions as punishment for contempt—Court of appeals' judgment reversed, contempt order vacated, and injunction dissolved.
- 2018 Ohio 2359State v. Schleiger (2018)
The trial court did not err by permitting the state to introduce evidence of appellant's three prior offense of violence convictions to raise the charge of carrying a concealed weapon to a fourth-degree felony where appellant did not stipulate to any of the three offenses, which required the state to offer evidence to meet its burden of proof that appellant had previously been convicted of an offense of violence.
- 2018 Ohio 2363Hubbard v. Aase Sales, LLC (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2364A.L.R.L. Family Trust v. Bowman (2018)
Summary judgment - residential sale, faulty septic system
- 2018 Ohio 2365State v. Ramsey (2018)
Manufacturing meth-sufficiency/manifest weight ineffective assistance of counsel denial to dismiss counsel
- 2018 Ohio 2366State v. Smith (2018)
Possession and cultivation of marijuana
- 2018 Ohio 2367State v. Sowers (2018)
Receiving stolen property
- 2018 Ohio 2368State v. Feister (2018)
speedy trial manifest weight
- 2018 Ohio 2369Smith v. Laurels of Canton, L.L.C. (2018)
Complaint dismissed for inadequate affidavit of merit
- 2018 Ohio 2370ABC Home Care & Nursing Servs., Inc. v. Molina Healthcare of Ohio, Inc. (2018)
Home care agency's contract claim would be resolved without reference to an agreement between the agency and its healthcare provider. Therefore, it was not subject to the arbitration provision in the agreement. However, the agency's tort claims arose from the agreement and were therefore subject to arbitration.
- 2018 Ohio 2371Hunter v. Rhino Shield (2018)
In a case involving the allegedly faulty application of ceramic coating on a residence, the trial court did not err in determining, based on the facts of the case, that it lacked personal jurisdiction under Civ.R. 4.3(A) and R.C. 2307.382 over an out-of-state corporate defendant who supplied the coating to the entity that contracted with the homeowners. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 237217AP-845 (2018)
As the defendant's sentence was prescribed by law, the trial court's error in failing to allow him to allocute was harmless. The trial court's failure to inform the defendant of his appellate rights should have been challenged by a direct appeal (either timely or delayed), not by a motion for reconsideration.
- 2018 Ohio 2373State v. Wimbley (2018)
Judgment affirmed. Appellant's postconviction petition is untimely, resulting in a lack of jurisdiction. In addition, even if the trial court had jurisdiction, both of appellant's claimed grounds for relief are barred by res judicata and are meritless.
- 2018 Ohio 2376State v. Giuggio (2018)
GUILTY PLEA – CRIM.R. 11 – APPELLATE REVIEW/CRIMINAL – COUNSEL – SENTENCING: Before a trial court accepts a guilty plea in a felony case, Crim.R. 11(C)(2) requires the court to personally address the defendant, ascertain that the plea is voluntary, and entered with an understanding of the effect of the plea, the nature of the charges, and the maximum penalty that may be imposed. In addition, the court must inform the defendant, and determine that the defendant understands, that by pleading guilty, the defendant is waiving her or his constitutional rights (1) to a jury trial, (2) to confront witnesses against her or him, (3) to have compulsory process for obtaining witnesses, (4) to require the state to prove the defendant's guilty beyond a reasonable doubt, and (5) to the privilege against self-incrimination. An appellate court is unable to determine on appeal whether ineffective assistance of trial counsel occurred where the allegations of ineffectiveness are based on facts outside the record. The trial court's imposition of a maximum prison term was not contrary to law where the record reflected that the court considered the purposes and principles of sentencing in R.C. 2929.11 and the factors in R.C. 2929.12, and the sentence fell within the permissible range.
- 2018 Ohio 2377State v. Wilson (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW/CRIMINAL – CONSTITUTIONAL LAW/CRIMINAL – SEARCH AND SEIZURE: Where the trial court specifically found that a marijuana cigarette in defendant's vehicle had been in the plain view of an officer, a search of the vehicle was supported by both the automobile and plain-view exceptions to the warrant requirement, and the trial court erred in suppressing all items found during the search of the vehicle. The trial court erred in suppressing money given by defendant to, and seized by police from, a third party where the money was recovered based on information received from a source independent of a statement made by defendant to police.
- 2018 Ohio 2378State v. Green (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW/CRIMINAL – NO-ERROR BRIEF: Where counsel has filed a no-error brief pursuant to Anders v. California, 386 U.S. 738, 87 S.Ct. 1396, 18 L.Ed.2d 493 (1967), and where the record indicates that, in accepting the defendant's guilty pleas, the trial court failed to notify the defendant of his constitutional right to confront his accusers, the appellate court must appoint new counsel to address legal points arguable on the merits with respect to the validity of the guilty pleas and any other issues counsel may wish to raise.
- 2018 Ohio 2379Boehm v. Black Diamond Casino Events, L.L.C. (2018)
TRADE SECRETS – MISAPPROPRIATION: A company's client list and financial data are trade secrets where the client list and financial data derive independent value from not being generally known, and where the company has made efforts to maintain their secrecy. The unauthorized sharing of a company's trade secrets with an accountant, even for the purposes of due diligence for an investment in the company, and the disapproved retention of trade secrets, even for the purposes of preparing for litigation, are misappropriations under Ohio's Uniform Trade Secrets Act. A claim for misappropriation of trade secrets does not require proof of damages.
- 2018 Ohio 2381Fairfield Twp. Bd. of Trustees v. Testa (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation—Exemption—R.C. 5709.07(A)(2)—House of public worship—Tax-increment-financing agreement—Priority of exemptions under R.C. 5709.911—When tax-increment-financing agreement was approved prior to the effective date of R.C. 5709.911, but a township did not preserve its right to service payments under the agreement, the house-of-public-worship exemption has priority.
- 2018 Ohio 2382State ex rel. Johnson v. Kral (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Mandamus—Appellant has adequate remedies in ordinary course of law—Court of appeals' dismissal of complaint affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2383State v. Hunt (2018)
Application for reopening sentence counsel not deficient
- 2018 Ohio 2384Estrada v. Larose (2018)
Habeas corpus failure to file commitment papers failure to file affidavit of prior civil actions state court of appeals lacks jurisdiction over federal inmates dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 2385State v. McKee (2018)
Appeal of consecutive sentences
- 2018 Ohio 2386State v. Dunwoody (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2387State v. Johnson (2018)
Sentencing/Post release control/Notice
- 2018 Ohio 2388State v. Fortson (2018)
Having weapons under disability charge based upon juvenile record
- 2018 Ohio 2390Cleveland Metropolitan Bar Association v. Horton. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct—Two-year suspension, with one year conditionally stayed.
- 2018 Ohio 2392City of Hudson v. State (2018)
Amended complaint supersedes prior/original complaint, abandoned complaint, nonexistent complaint, judgment based upon a prior complaint is a nullity when there is an amended complaint, limited remand, clear and convincing evidence of clerical error
- 2018 Ohio 2393Phoenix Lighting Group, LLC v. Genlyte Thomas Group, LLC (2018)
tortious interference with a business relationship, at-will employees, privileged conduct, misappropriation of trade secrets, civil conspiracy, judgment notwithstanding the verdict, directed verdict, sufficiency of the evidence, exclusion of evidence, abuse of discretion, duplicative damages, punitive damages, manifest weight of the evidence, Ohio Uniform Trade Secrets Act, R.C. 1333.63
- 2018 Ohio 2394State v. Taylor (2018)
App.R. 4(A) – motion to vacate – res judicata – renumbered counts
- 2018 Ohio 2395In re Complaint of Harris Design Servs. v. Columbia Gas of Ohio, Inc. (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Public utilities—R.C. 4905.22—Utility provided adequate notice of disconnection—Orders of Public Utilities Commission affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2396State ex rel. Smith v. Schweitzer (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Habeas corpus—Prison sentences run consecutively by operation of statute—Immediate release denied, and judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2397State v. Jenkins (2018)
In-court identification, impermissibly suggestive, Telfaire instruction, sufficiency of the evidence, manifest weight of the evidence, allied offenses, R.C. 2923.16, maximum sentence, consecutive sentences, right to remain silent. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in allowing a witness to identify the defendant as the shooter because the witness observed the defendant get into a fight from a short distance away and saw him two more times throughout the night. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying the defendant's request for a Telfaire instruction because such an instruction is not required in every case and the trial court gave a general instruction regarding eyewitness identification. The defendant's convictions were supported by sufficient evidence and were not against the manifest weight of the evidence. The trial court did not err when it found that the defendant's convictions under R.C. 2923.16 were not allied and, therefore, did not merge for sentencing purposes. The defendant's sentence was not contrary to law. The witness-detective's comment — "Mr. Jenkins knows where he went. Other than that, I'm not aware of anyone who does." — did not violate the defendant's right to remain silent as it was responsive to a question concerning his investigation.
- 2018 Ohio 2398Kurutz v. cleveland (2018)
Zoning use variance economic hardship. Court erred by affirming decision of board of zoning appeals to grant a use variance to operate a motorcycle dealership in a local retail business district because there was no evidence that the applicant would suffer any economic hardship if the requested variance was denied. The applicant admitted that there were other viable economic uses for the property, but that it rejected those because it believed the dealership was better suited to the area.
- 2018 Ohio 2399State v. Michailides (2018)
Speedy trial, reindictment, motion for speedy trial. The State violated defendant's right to a speedy trial. The speedy trial time clock restarted when the defendant was arrested under a subsequent indictment that was premised on the same underlying facts that were known to the state in the previous indictment. However, any time period that has elapsed under the original indictment was added to the time period commencing with the second indictment. Defendant's pro se motion for speedy trial did not stop the speedy trial clock because it was not seeking a dismissal, but merely requesting the trial court to set a trial date.
- 2018 Ohio 2402State v. Woodward (2018)
Burglary theft having weapons while under disability receiving stolen property Crim.R. 11(C)(2) guilty plea consecutive sentences maximum restitution abuse of discretion plain error. Defendant-appellant's guilty plea and sentence affirmed. The trial court strictly complied with Crim.R. 11(C) in advising the defendant of his constitutional rights. The trial court offered to more fully explain any of these rights to the defendant if he did not understand. The defendant replied "yes" to the trial court's question of whether he understood each of these rights. Thus, his argument that the trial court failed to fully comply with Crim.R. 11(C) by more fully explaining the legal principles behind his constitutional rights was unpersuasive. The trial court did not err in sentencing defendant. Defendant's sentence was not contrary to law, and the trial court properly made all findings required by R.C. 2929.14(C) in support of its imposition of consecutive sentences. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in ordering amounts of restitution recommended by each of the victims. Defendant failed to object, and the record does not demonstrate plain error
- 2018 Ohio 2403State v. Robinson (2018)
Appeal No. 106329 - State v. Robinson Contingent plea offer appoint counsel. The requirement of unanimity among codefendants in accepting a plea offer does not violate due process standards, and a trial court does not abuse its discretion in denying a motion for new trial counsel on the day of trial without the defendant demonstrating a complete breakdown in the attorney-client relationship.
- 2018 Ohio 2406State v. T.A. (2018)
R.C. 2953.52(B)(1)/application to seal official records. The trial court erred where it did not hold a hearing prior to denying appellant's motion to seal the record.
- 2018 Ohio 2407Disciplinary Counsel v. McDaniel (2018)
On certified order of the Supreme Court of Arizona, No. PDJ-2017-9097.
- 2018 Ohio 2408Boggs v. Denmead (2018)
Trial court did not err in overruling appellant's objections to magistrate's decision and granting appellees' motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction.
- 2018 Ohio 2409Hillman v. Brown (2018)
Petition for writ of procedendo rendered moot action dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 2411Ocwen Loan Servicing, L.L.C. v. Graf (2018)
In a foreclosure action, the trial court did not err when it granted summary judgment to mortgagee where mortgagor's affidavit did not contain admissible evidence to rebut mortgagee's evidence that it did not have a branch office within 200 mile of the mortgaged property for purposes of the face-to-face interview requirements of 24 C.F.R. 203.604. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2412State ex rel. Guilfoyle (2018)
Evidence before the staff hearing officer did not support a finding that the claimant abandoned the workforce. Additional proceedings are necessary to determine if claimant is entitled to permanent total disability compensation.
- 2018 Ohio 2414State ex rel. DeWine v. Precourt Sports Ventures L.L.C (2018)
Trial court order that imposed an equitable tolling period on running of negotiation period under statute was not a final appealable order under R.C. 2505.02(B)(2) or (B)(4) because appellants did not lack a remedy through appeal at a later stage in proceedings.
- 2018 Ohio 2415Julia Realty, Ltd. v. Cuyahoga Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation—Real property—Collateral estoppel—Arm's-length character of recent sale was litigated in prior proceedings and may not be relitigated in later proceedings—Decision affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2417Thomasson v. Thomasson (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Divorce—A trial court's order appointing a guardian ad litem to represent an adult in a divorce case is a final, appealable order under R.C. 2505.02(B)(2) when adult has not been adjudicated incompetent subsequent to providing parties with notice and opportunity to be heard on issue of adult's competency—Court of appeals' judgment reversed, trial court's order appointing guardian ad litem vacated, and cause remanded to trial court.
- 2018 Ohio 2420State v. Combs (2018)
Defendant-appellant's conviction for possession of heroin is supported by sufficient evidence and it is not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2421State v. Dillon (2018)
The State presented legally sufficient evidence to support the appellant's misdemeanor assault conviction. The victim's testimony that the appellant punched him in the face, if believed, is legally sufficient to support the conviction. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2422James v. Hoffman (2018)
Appellants' complaint asserts defamation and false light invasion of privacy causes of action against Appellees, who are not Ohio residents. The trial court dismissed the complaint finding it could not, consistent with due process, exercise personal jurisdiction over Appellees. The trial court's personal jurisdiction conclusion is correct because the Appellees did not purposefully avail themselves of the privilege of conducting activities in Ohio and the Appellants' claims did not arise out of Appellees' activities in Ohio. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2423State v. Kiinley (2018)
The trial court did not err in denying petitioner's successive petition for postconviction relief without a hearing. Because petitioner failed to satisfy the jurisdictional requirements of R.C. 2953.23(A) for a second or successive petition, he was not entitled to discovery as now provided in R.C. 2953.21(A)(1)(d) and Crim.R. 42(C). Moreover, petitioner's central arguments, based on recanted trial testimony, had been raised in the prior petition, albeit with a different type of evidence, and do not demonstrate that he was unavoidably prevented from presenting them in his first postconviction petition. Judgment affirmed. (Brogan, J., concurring.)
- 2018 Ohio 2424State v. Matthews (2018)
The appellant's aggravated menacing conviction is based on legally sufficient evidence and is not against the manifest weight of the evidence. The conviction is supported by the testimony of prosecution witnesses who claimed the appellant had threatened to "bash" an apartment manager's head into a wall and to "f her up." Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2425State v. McCain (2018)
The trial court properly overruled Appellant's request for records. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2427State v. Pelfrey (2018)
Defendant obtained a power of attorney from his grandmother, altered the date of it, and used it, unbeknownst to the grandmother, to obtain a $75,000 mortgage loan on her home grandmother did not receive the money. After defendant was aware of the criminal investigation, defendant had two different individuals fabricate documents to help his case. Defendant's convictions for theft, forgery, and tampering with evidence were based on sufficient evidence and were not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Trial court did not abuse its discretion in excluding defendant's handwriting expert, whose report was not timely disclosed. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying defendant's motion to continue the trial, which was made orally immediately before jury selection and in response to the exclusion of his handwriting expert. Grandmother's testimony regarding the power of attorney did not violate the parol evidence rule. Defendant did not demonstrate that his speedy trial rights under R.C. 2945.71 were violated. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2428State v. Shawhan (2018)
The trial court, based upon the parties' merger stipulation, did not err by failing to merge the rape counts as allied offenses of similar import. Further, Defendant-appellant's trial counsel did not provide ineffective assistance of counsel by recommending that Defendant-appellant, as part of a plea agreement, agree that the rape counts did not merge. Finally, Defendant-appellant's assertion regarding the imposition of a consecutive sentence without making the R.C. 2929.14(C)(4) findings is not subject to appellate review under R.C. 2953.08(D)(1). Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2432State v. Beavogui (2018)
Three-week continuance necessitated by death in family of assistant prosecutor tolled speedy-trial time—purpose for and length of continuance were reasonable. Evidence was sufficient to sustain conviction and verdict was not against manifest weight of evidence where state presented evidence of constructive possession of evidence found in vehicle. Appellant's explanation was credibility issue for the jury.
- 2018 Ohio 2433Dazley Admr. v. Mercy St. Vincent Med. Ctr. (2018)
Plaintiff-appellant's medical expert opined as to applicable standard of care as related to facts of the case. Appellee-physician offered proper habit evidence to support his motion for summary judgment, but plaintiff-appellant offered competing evidence challenging whether physician acted in conformity with habit, thereby creating genuine issue of material fact preventing summary judgment. Factual issues remain concerning causation.
- 2018 Ohio 2436In re Estate of Hudson (2018)
The probate court's failure to provide appellants notice of the appointment of fiduciaries was harmless error where appellants are minors and cannot administer the estates and where appellants raised no arguments that the appointed fiduciaries were incompetent to administer the estates. Probate court's denial of motion to remove administrator of estate is a final appealable order since it determines the action with respect to a provisional remedy and prevents a judgment in favor of the moving party since no meaningful or effective remedy could be granted on an appeal following final resolution of the estate.
- 2018 Ohio 2439State v. Fisher (2018)
A legal challenge to the imposition of jail credit time must be raised in a timely filed direct appeal. Otherwise, the legal challenge will be barred by res judicata. However, a defendant may submit a motion for correction to address a mathematical calculation issue after the time for direct appeal has expired.
- 2018 Ohio 2440State v. Woodum (2018)
The trial court did not err by failing to inform the defendant that he could not use drugs of abuse while in prison. The trial court considered all of the statutory sentencing guidelines and the sentence was within the sentencing range, so there was no abuse of discretion.
- 2018 Ohio 2441Smith v. Wyandot Mem'l Hosp. (2018)
The trial court did not err by dismissing plaintiff-appellant's wrongful-death action asserting a medical claim against defendants-appellees because it is barred by Ohio's medical-malpractice statute of repose.
- 2018 Ohio 2443State v. Wade (2018)
motion to discharge bond – motion to release surety – R.C. 2713.21 and R.C. 2713.23 regarding discharge and exoneration of bond in civil matters are not applicable in criminal cases
- 2018 Ohio 2444Runyon v. Hawley (2018)
default judgment – motion to vacate – common law – Civ.R. 60(B) – void – service of process – presumption of service – uncontradicted affidavit – rebutting defendant's affidavit with an affidavit or request a hearing – statutory agent – R.C. 1705.06
- 2018 Ohio 2445Townhomes at French Creek Homeowners Assn., Inc. v. Woods (2018)
planned community, R.C. 5312.01, et seq, late fees, attorney's fees, declaration
- 2018 Ohio 2446Westlake Assocs. LLC v. C Supermarket (2018)
broker agreement, delay in ruling, R.C. 2701.02, demonstrate prejudice, manifest weight, non-circumvention clause
- 2018 Ohio 2448State v. Sandercock (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - failure to appear pretrial hearing knowledge of hearing identity of defendant must be proven beyond a reasonable doubt defendant's name alone insufficient state established name state established man with defendant's name failed to appear state failed to establish defendant was the person who failed to appear reversed and vacated.
- 2018 Ohio 2449Discover Bank v. Bruckman (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - App.R. 4(A) thirty-day rule Civ.R. 58(B) untimely appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 2450In re: T.M. (2018)
JUVENILE - No-contact order authority of juvenile court to impose commitment to ODYS R.C. 2152.19(A)(8) broad authority to set terms of commitment authority to enforce no-contact order R.C. 2152.16(A)(2) R.C. 2152.22(A) minimum period of commitment no authority thereafter petition to modify or terminate sexual offender status, necessity to hold hearing when dispositional order no longer enforceable.
- 2018 Ohio 2451Andolsek v. Hurley (2018)
MALPRACTICE - legal where appellant discharged her attorney by letter in July 2015 and a cognizable event occurred in November 2015 when she signed a grievance against her attorney with Disciplinary Counsel, appellant's cause of action accrued and the statute of limitations began to run in November 2015 and the statute of limitations expired in November 2016 since appellant did not file her complaint until January 2017, the trial couirt did not err in finding that appellant's claim was time-barred and in granting Hurley's motion for summary judgment.
- 2018 Ohio 2452State v. Baugh (2018)
CRIMINAL - motion to withdraw guilty plea Crim.R. 32.1 manifest injustice
- 2018 Ohio 2453State ex rel. Shannon v. Logan (2018)
ORIGINAL ACTION- habeas corpus double jeopardy motion to dismiss Civ.R. 12(B)(6) adequate remedy at law direct appeal subject matter jurisdiction indictment
- 2018 Ohio 2454State v. Fetterolf (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - burglary guilty plea R.C. 2953.08(G) R.C. 2929.11 R.C. 2929.12 R.C. 2929.13 R.C. 2929.14(A)(2) appellant's sentence is not clearly and convincingly contrary to law.
- 2018 Ohio 2455State v. Anderson (2018)
CRIMINAL - motion to suppress traffic stop reasonable suspicion front license plate plain view R.C. 4503.21 pobable cause search subjective belief marijuana shake odor of burnt marijuana
- 2018 Ohio 2456Cintas Corp. v. Great Lakes Best One Tire & Serice, L.L.C., d.b.a. Terrys Tire Town (2018)
CONTRACTS - purchase agreement successor liability first exception applicable the trial court committed no error in finding Great Lakes liable for the assumed debts and obligations of Terry's Tire Town, specifically the sum of $5,450.44 due to Cintas.
- 2018 Ohio 2462State v. Edwards (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2467Ohio State Bar Assn. v. Jacob (2018)
On application for reinstatement.
- 2018 Ohio 2468Disciplinary Counsel v. Smith (2018)
On application for reinstatement.
- 2018 Ohio 2469Disciplinary Counsel v. Schuman (2018)
On application for reinstatement.
- 2018 Ohio 2473D & L Ferguson, L.L.C. v. Thompson (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2474Williams v. Canton School Emps. Fed. Credit Union (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2478State v. Bruce (2018)
: guilty plea to felonious assault, aggravated burglary, kidnapping, and attempted murder appellant's sentence not contrary to law aggravated burglary and felonious assault convictions did not merge for purposes of sentencing
- 2018 Ohio 2480RBS v. Sharp (2018)
foreclosure compliance HUD face-to-face meeting timing summary judgment.
- 2018 Ohio 2481State v. Dotson (2018)
confrontation clause inadmissible hearsay felony sentencing restitution reasonable suspicion probable cause receiving stolen property tampering with vehicle identifying numbers.
- 2018 Ohio 2483State v. Reinthaler (2018)
App.R. 26 reopening Crim.R. 43(A) variance uncharged conduct.
- 2018 Ohio 2486State v. Barnett (2018)
traffic sign conflicting traffic signs reasonable suspicion suppression motion to suppress attenuation doctrine turn signal
- 2018 Ohio 2487State v. Vargo (2018)
R.C. 4511.28 sufficiency manifest weight of the evidence discovery violation plain error.
- 2018 Ohio 2491State v. Shine (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2493Harris v. Delong (2018)
The trial court dismissed appellant's complaint for an allocation of parental rights without prejudice. We dismissed his appeal for lack of a final, appealable order.
- 2018 Ohio 2494Summit Servicing Agency, L.L.C. v. Hunt (2018)
moot – proceeds distributed – no stay requested
- 2018 Ohio 2495State v. Dennis (2018)
motion to suppress, standing, Evid.R. 612, refresh recollection, Evid.R. 803(5), harmless error
- 2018 Ohio 2496State v. Bralek (2018)
OVI, reasonable suspicion, weaving, violation of traffic ordinance
- 2018 Ohio 2497State v. Lee (2018)
assault – violating a protection order – nunc pro tunc – lay witness – testify – intoxicated
- 2018 Ohio 2498State v. Wilson (2018)
Crim.R. 11 Knowing, Intelligent, and Voluntary Plea Plea Agreement
- 2018 Ohio 2499Lopez v. Hulburt (2018)
motion for summary judgment – initial burden – burden shifting – denial of motion for summary judgment – request for admissions – Civ.R. 36 – discovery – moot
- 2018 Ohio 2501Breen v. Summit Cty. ,C.S.E.A. (2018)
moot – jurisdiction – child support – default – CSEA – administrative lien – discharge – common pleas court – general division – domestic relations
- 2018 Ohio 2502Roman v. Kalk (2018)
pet cemetery, deed restrictions, finality, declaratory judgment, Civ.R. 54(B), property
- 2018 Ohio 2503Brown v. Terrell (2018)
Summary judgment, dog bite, R.C. 955.28, harborer, possession, control, acquiescence
- 2018 Ohio 2504State v. Smith (2018)
CONSTITUTIONAL LAW/CRIMINAL – EVIDENCE – SELF-DEFENSE – SENTENCING – WITNESSES: The trial court did not err under R.C. 2941.25, Ohio's multiple-count statute, in imposing separate and consecutive sentences for the offenses of murder and having a weapon while under a disability where the offenses were committed separately and with a separate animus. The trial court did not err when it refused to suppress statements made by defendant during a police interview, and recorded electronically in their entirety, where the 27-year-old defendant had executed a written Miranda rights waiver form, willingly answered police questions, did not exhibit any behavior that would have indicated that he was under the influence of pain medications, had extensive experience with the criminal justice system, and there was little evidence of police coercion or overreaching and where nothing in the recorded interview refuted the presumption, under R.C. 2933.81(B), that defendant had knowingly and voluntarily made statements to the police. The trial court did not abuse its discretion by allowing the state to impeach its own witness with her prior inconsistent statements made to police investigators where the state made a showing of surprise or affirmative damage as the witness's denials of her prior statements were hardly neutral answers such as "I don't remember," and where the witness had affirmatively challenged the veracity of the assistant prosecuting attorney's claims that the witness had made the prior statements and had challenged the state to produce the recordings of the police interview. Self-defense is an affirmative defense that legally excuses admitted criminal conduct where defendant establishes by a preponderance of the evidence (1) that he was not at fault in creating the violent situation, (2) that he had a bona fide belief that he was in danger of imminent death or great bodily harm and that the only means of escape was by use of force, and (3) that he did not violate any duty to retreat or avoid the danger these elements of self-defense are cumulative, and if defendant fails to prove any one of these elements by a preponderance of the evidence he has failed to demonstrate that he acted in self-defense. We cannot say that the jury, sitting as the trier of fact, lost its way in rejecting defendant's defense of self-defense where there was no evidence establishing that he was not at fault in creating the violent situation when defendant had brought a handgun with him to an apartment, brandished the gun and readied it for action by cocking the hammer, and remained in the apartment even though one of his victims had confronted him and ordered him to leave, where record also contains no evidence establishing that defendant was in danger of imminent death or great bodily harm when he was substantially younger than his victims and employed brutal measures in response to the victims' alleged attack, and where no evidence established that defendant had not violated any duty to retreat or avoid the danger when, from the forensic physical evidence, it was clear that defendant had reasonable means to retreat and could have ended the altercation or fled at almost any point. Where the trial court failed to include its consecutive-sentencing findings in its sentencing entry as required by the Ohio Supreme Court's decision in State v. Bonnell, 140 Ohio St.3d 209, 2014-Ohio-3177, 16 N.E.3d 659, the trial court's failure does not render the sentence contrary to law instead, this clerical mistake may be corrected by the court through a nunc pro tunc entry to reflect what actually occurred in open court.
- 2018 Ohio 2505Lohmann v. Cincinnati (2018)
CIVIL SERVICE – PROCEDURE/RULES: In an appeal from a decision of the civil service commission pursuant to R.C. 2506.04, the trial court properly denied the employees' request to supplement the administrative record by taking judicial notice of public records, because R.C. 2506.03 permits the introduction of additional evidence only under the statutory criteria. The trial court did not abuse its discretion by declining to strike, pursuant to Loc.R. 14(B) of the Hamilton County Court of Common Pleas, the city's memorandum opposing the employees' motion to supplement the administrative record as untimely where the employees could not demonstrate prejudice. The trial court's judgment, which affirmed the decision of the civil service commission that denied three civil service employees the ability to sit for a promotional examination on the basis that their applications were incomplete because they did not resubmit their educational transcripts, was not supported by a preponderance of the evidence as a matter of law where the administrative record reflected that all three employees' applications had initially been accepted for an examination that had been postponed, there was no evidence that the applications for the postponed examination were deficient, and email correspondence from the city had informed them there was nothing more for them to do.
- 2018 Ohio 2506State ex rel. The Community Press v. Blue Ash (2018)
PUBLIC RECORDS: Documents requested by relator media outlet, which related to a professional development program for respondent city's management employees, were not subject to a public records request, because those documents were not "records" as that term is defined in R.C. 149.011(G). Emails transmitting documents relating to a professional development program for the city's management employees were not public records therefore, the media outlet requesting those emails could not be aggrieved by the city's failure to maintain them. Where the media outlet was not entitled to documents relating to a professional development program for the city's management employees, the trial court's decision not to award attorney fees for the media outlet's litigation relating to those documents was not erroneous.
- 2018 Ohio 2507Williams v. Metro (2018)
PUBLIC EMPLOYEE – COLLECTIVE-BARGAINING AGREEMENT – UNFAIR LABOR PRACTICE – WRONGFUL DISCHARGE – DISCRIMINATION – JURISDICTION: The State Employment Relations Board has exclusive jurisdiction over a wrongful-discharge claim brought against a public employer by an employee subject to a collective-bargaining agreement. Pursuant to R.C. 4117.11(B)(6), the State Employment Relations Board has exclusive jurisdiction over claim against a union for a breach of the duty to fairly represent a public employee. R.C. Chapter 4117 does not provide the exclusive remedy for a claim of disparate-treatment discrimination, which does not arise from or depend on a collective-bargaining agreement.
- 2018 Ohio 2508State v. Bryan (2018)
Consecutive sentences - allied offenses - res judicata
- 2018 Ohio 2509State v. Weaver (2018)
Postconviction relief - right to a hearing -res judicata
- 2018 Ohio 2510Johnson v. St. Claire (2018)
Final, Appealable Order
- 2018 Ohio 2511State v. Mayle (2018)
Murder - Admission of autopsy photos
- 2018 Ohio 2513City of Cleveland v. Embassy Realty Invs., Inc. (2018)
Demolition costs collection C.C.O. 3103.09 statute of limitations Civ.R. 19 indispensable party piercing the corporate veil. The trial court properly denied defendant-appellant's motion to dismiss the city's amended complaint in a collection action seeking its nuisance abatement costs for demolition of a condemned commercial building once owned by defendant-appellant. After defendant had received notice of the building code violations and the building's condemnation, he transferred his interest in the property by quitclaim deed to a corporate entity of which he was the sole officer and shareholder. However, the trial court improperly granted summary judgment against defendant and in favor of the city under a piercing-the-corporate-veil theory of liability because the city failed to satisfy all elements under the test established by the Ohio Supreme Court in Belvedere Condominium Unit Owners' Assn. v. R.E. Roark Cos., 67 Ohio St.3d 274, 1993 Ohio 119, 617 N.E.2d 1075, and as modified by Dombroski v. WellPoint, Inc., 119 Ohio St.3d 506, 2008 Ohio 4827, 895 N.E.2d 538. A genuine issue of material fact exists as to whether the defendant personally maintained the nuisance after he sold the property to the corporate entity.
- 2018 Ohio 2514Illuminatiny Company v. Cochran (2018)
Motion for summary judgment genuine issue of material fact damages indirect damages reasonable certainty depreciation utility pole. Judgment reversed. The trial court's decision granting summary judgment in favor of utility company was improper when genuine issues of material fact remain with respect to indirect costs and depreciation.
- 2018 Ohio 2515State v. Burks (2018)
Gross sexual imposition sexual imposition kidnapping Evid.R. 404(B) other acts evidence limiting instructions sufficiency of the evidence manifest weight of the evidence. The trial court did not abuse its discretion by permitting the other acts evidence. The trial court did not commit plain error by providing the entirety of the language of Evid.R. 404(B) as its limiting instructions to the jury. Testimony did not support an instruction of "safe place unharmed" instruction regarding the kidnapping count. The state presented sufficient evidence to support the sexual imposition, gross sexual imposition, and kidnapping convictions and those convictions were not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 2516State v. Betley (2018)
Restitution R.C. 2929.18 economic loss credit card theft evidentiary hearing. The trial court's restitution order was not supported by sufficient competent, credible evidence to establish the appropriate amount of restitution to a reasonable degree of certainty. The trial court based the restitution orders in each of the defendant's two cases on the amounts recommended by the victim in his victim impact statements. These amounts varied from the restitution amount noted in the PSI and as reported by the victim in the police report. The victim was not present at the sentencing hearing to explain the discrepancy, nor did the state introduce separate evidence to support either amount. An evidentiary hearing is required to determine the appropriate amount of restitution.
- 2018 Ohio 2517Bellaire Corp. v. Am. Empire Surplus Lines Ins. Co. (2018)
Insurance coverage breach of contract declaratory judgment occurrence property damage legally obligated to pay acid mine drainage routine business expenses preventive measures past remediation. Trial court properly granted summary judgment to insurers on corporation's claims for breach of contract and declaratory judgment where flooding of coal mine was a foreseeable responsibility of the corporation pursuant to its mining permit and was therefore not a covered occurrence under the insurer's policies.
- 2018 Ohio 2519Blisswood village home owners Assn. v. Genesis real estate holdings group, L.L.C. (2018)
Foreclosure confirmation of sale mootness party purchaser subject matter jurisdiction. Appeal from confirmation of foreclosure sale was moot because defendant-appellant failed to obtain a stay of the distribution of the proceeds of the sale. Thus, the judgment was satisfied and there was no live controversy before the court. Defendant-appellant's argument that Fannie Mae v. Hicks, 2016 Ohio 8484, 77 N.E.3d 380 (8th Dist.), created an exception to the mootness doctrine was unpersuasive. The foreclosing plaintiff's purchase of the property did not negate defendant-appellant's failure to file an appeal from the foreclosure order or its subsequent failure to obtain a stay of the distribution of the proceeds of the sheriff's sale of the property.
- 2018 Ohio 2520Parmatown south assn. v. Atlantis realty co., L.T.D. (2018)
Summary judgment fraud Uniform Fraudulent Transfer Act. Court did not err by granting summary judgment on fraud claim where there was no evidence to show that general contractor agreed that its acceptance of payment for work previously done on construction project induced the client to believe that it would encompass payment for additional work required to complete the project. Plaintiff did not assert a viable claim under the Uniform Fraudulent Transfer Act because it was not a creditor as required by the act — it was the debtor who made a payment to the creditor-general contractor.
- 2018 Ohio 2521Elsner v. Birchall, M.D. (2018)
New trial, Civ.R. 59(A), juror misconduct, Evid.R. 606(B), manifest weight. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying the appellant's motion for a new trial based on juror misconduct. Further, because the appellant failed to file a transcript of the proceedings, we cannot say that the jury's verdict was against the manifest weight of the evidence. Finally, it was not error for the original trial judge, who did not preside over the trial, to rule on the appellant's motion for a new trial because the original trial judge had a copy of the voir dire transcript.
- 2018 Ohio 2522State v. D.K. (2018)
Application to seal record of convictions R.C. 2953.32 weighing of interests of applicant in having record of conviction sealed against the legitimate needs of the state to maintain record of conviction. Trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying defendant's application to seal record of convictions under R.C. 2953.32 where it found that the state's interests in maintaining the record of convictions to enforce condition of plea agreement that defendant would not start another daycare business and to minimize the likelihood that defendant would become involved in some other business that handled government vouchers or other forms of state funding outweighed defendant's interest in having the record sealed so that he could secure better employment.
- 2018 Ohio 2523In re S.C. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2525State v. Winston (2018)
Judgment affirmed. Appellant's convictions for three counts of rape with firearm specifications, two counts of attempted rape with firearm specifications, and kidnapping with a firearm specification, were supported by sufficient evidence to overrule a Crim.R. 29 motion, and were not against the manifest weight of the evidence. In addition, the trial court did not abuse its discretion by allowing victim impact testimony, and by qualifying the SANE nurse as an expert. Finally, the trial court did err in admitting testimony that a month after the incident a police officer saw appellant "in the area where a firearm was found," and subsequently admitting the gun into evidence, when there was no evidentiary link between the gun and appellant. However, under the facts of this case, such error was harmless.
- 2018 Ohio 2526State ex rel. Crowley v. Dept. of Rehab. & Corr. (2018)
Inmate could not get a writ of mandamus to force the Ohio Department of Rehabilitation and Correction to change his release date.
- 2018 Ohio 2528Sourial v. Nationwide Mut. Ins. Co. (2018)
Trial court did not err in granting appellee's unopposed motion for summary judgment where the evidence in support of the motion established as a matter of law that the contractual limitations period barred appellant's claims for breach of contract and breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing, the integration clause and the release of claims in the parties' agreement barred appellant's claims for promissory estoppel and unjust enrichment, and the release of claims barred any actionable claims for fraud in the inducement and fraudulent misrepresentation alleged in the complaint. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying appellant's Civ.R. 56(F) motion for a continuance because appellant failed to support the motion with a particularized factual basis on which to determine further discovery was necessary in order for appellant to show a genuine factual issue remained for trial. Because of our disposition of appellant's assignment of error challenging the trial court's decision to grant appellee's unopposed summary judgment and to deny appellant's Civ.R. 56(F) motion for a continuance, any trial court error in denying appellant's motion to compel discovery is harmless error. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 252917AP-762 (2018)
Where a judgment of conviction imposes post-release control but neither cites the appropriate statute nor mentions the potential consequences of violating the conditions of post-release control, it is legally insufficient but may be corrected nunc pro tunc if post-release control is otherwise appropriately imposed.
- 2018 Ohio 2529State v. Harper (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2531Evans v. Henderson (2018)
Evans did not present sufficient evidence to rebut the presumption of proper service of the motion to dismiss, and the trial court did not err in granting the Civ.R. 12(B)(6) motion to dismiss.
- 2018 Ohio 2532Youngstown City Sch. Dist. Bd. of Educ. v. State (2018)
Trial court decision denying declaratory judgment and motion for permanent injunction affirmed. Legislation adopted by the General Assembly did not violate Article II, Section 15(C) of the Ohio Constitution because the final, amended version of it shared a common purpose with the original version and was not vitally altered by the amendments. The legislation did not violate Article VI, Section 3 of the Ohio Constitution because it did not usurp all powers of the elected school board. The legislation did not violate the Equal Protection Clauses of the Ohio Constitution and United States Constitution because it was rationally related to the state's legitimate interest in ensuring quality public schools. Trial court did not abuse its discretion by concluding appellants' failed to establish irreparable harm would occur if injunction was not granted, nor that appellant's failed to show injunction would not cause harm to third parties and would serve the public interest.
- 2018 Ohio 2533State v. Battin (2018)
The trial court did not err in denying Battin's untimely petition for postconviction relief.
- 2018 Ohio 2534State v. Evans (2018)
AGGRAVATED BURGLARY – EVIDENCE – OTHER ACTS – OPINION TESTIMONY – PROSECUTOR — CONSTITUTIONAL LAW/CRIMINAL – FIFTH AMENDMENT – HARMLESS ERROR – PLAIN ERROR – COUNSEL — WITNESSES: In a prosecution for aggravated burglary and felonious assault, the trial court did not err in admitting the victim's testimony regarding defendant's prior instances of physical violence against the victim where the testimony was relevant to prove defendant's motive and intent, and therefore, did not violate the general prohibition against "other acts" evidence in Evid.R. 404(B). The trial court erred in admitting at trial evidence of defendant's prior misdemeanor-assault conviction in violation of Evid.R. 609 and 404(B), but the error did not rise to the level of plain error where defendant was tried before the court and the erroneous admission of his prior misdemeanor-assault conviction did not affect the outcome of the trial. The trial court did not err in admitting, pursuant to Evid.R. 701, the opinion testimony of a responding police officer and the victim's supervisor that scratches on the victim's face were "fresh" injuries where their testimony was based on their personal observation of the victim and their common understanding of scratches and cuts. The defendant was not denied a fair trial due to prosecutorial misconduct where the victim's testimony regarding prior instances of physical harm was properly admissible under Evid.R. 404(B). The assistant prosecuting attorney's erroneous impeachment of the defendant with a prior misdemeanor assault conviction did not deny him a fair trial. In a bench trial for aggravated burglary and felonious assault, any alleged error by the trial court in compelling defendant to testify in violation of his Fifth Amendment privilege against self-incrimination was harmless under the three-part test articulated in State v. Harris, 142 Ohio St.3d 211, 2015-Ohio-166, 28 N.E.3d 1256, because the admission of defendant's testimony had no effect on the trial court's verdict. The actions and omissions by defense counsel alleged to constitute ineffective assistance of trial counsel did not provide a basis for overturning the defendant's aggravated-burglary conviction where counsel's questioning of the victim as to prior instances of physical harm could be construed as legitimate trial strategy counsel's failure to object to other-acts testimony and testimony from the victim's supervisor and the responding police officer about the age of the victim's facial injuries was properly admitted and counsel's failure to object to the prosecutor's erroneous impeachment of defendant with a prior misdemeanor-assault conviction and to the trial court's alleged compelling of defendant to testify in violation of the Fifth Amendment were not outcome determinative. Defendant's conviction for aggravated burglary was supported by sufficient evidence and was not contrary to the manifest weight of the evidence where the victim testified that defendant had kicked in the sidelight to the front door of her workplace, entered, and punched her in the face multiple times the victim's supervisor and the responding police officer testified that the victim had sustained facial injuries, including fresh scratches to her face the victim's medical records showed that she had been treated for a nasal fracture and the state introduced the victim's 911 calls, as well as the jail-house phone calls between defendant and his ex-girlfriend, in which defendant had admitted hitting the victim and knocking her to the ground, and the trial court chose to accord more weight to testimony of the state's witnesses and a 911 recording than the testimony of defendant and his witness that defendant had kicked in the door to the victim's workplace, but he had not gone inside or punched the victim.
- 2018 Ohio 2535Beattie v. McCoy (2018)
INSURANCE – CONTRACTS – EVIDENCE – PROCEDURE/RULES – EXPERT: Under Civ.R. 56(E), an affidavit must be made on personal knowledge, must "set forth such facts as would be admissible in evidence," and must "show affirmatively that the affiant is competent to testify to the matters stated in the affidavit" thus a party offering a witness as an expert has the burden of establishing that the witness is qualified to competently give such testimony in compliance with Evid.R. 702, 703, and 705. In order to comply with Civ.R. 56(E) and Evid.R. 702 and 705, an expert affidavit must set forth the expert's credentials, and the facts supporting the expert's opinion which would be admissible into evidence an expert's affidavit may not set forth conclusory statements without sufficient supporting facts. Evid.R. 702(B) requires an expert to testify within the area of his or her expertise, and when a psychologist's affidavit fails to disclose any specialized knowledge, skill, training, or treating experience regarding transference phenomenon or patients that suffer from it, and fails to disclose whether the psychologist had any experience with regard to what training physicians receive in the diagnosis and treatment of psychological conditions in general, or specifically of transference phenomenon, that witness is not qualified to opine that any physician should have known about transference as part of their training and education. Under the natural and commonly accepted meaning of terms in a professional-liability insurance policy issued to a physician, the insured does not provide a "professional service" by engaging in sexual conduct with a patient. Under a professional-liability insurance policy, which provides that the insurer will pay claims that its physician "insured becomes legally obligated to pay because of professional services which should have been provided," the insurer is not obligated to pay when the insured has engaged in only a limited therapeutic relationship with a patient with whom he conducts a sexual affair factors indicating that a physician has only a limited therapeutic relationship with a patient include when the physician has referred the patient to a clinical psychologist for treatment of reported worsening depression and anxiety and has not engaged in an intimate psychological therapy relationship.
- 2018 Ohio 2536Danopulos v. American Trading II, LLC (2018)
CONVERSION - PAWNBROKER: The trial court erred by entering judgment for defendant pawnbroker on plantiff's claim of conversion where the undisputed evidence at trial demonstrated that the pawnbroker had intentionally disassembled and sold plantiff's stolen property without her permission.
- 2018 Ohio 2538Alicea v. City of Lorain (2018)
Summary judgment, immunity, political subdivision, R.C. 2744.02(B)(5)
- 2018 Ohio 2539State v. Andrews (2018)
Resentencing, allied offenses of similar import, repeat violent offender, judicial fact-finding, scope of appeal, res judicata
- 2018 Ohio 2540Bonkoski v. Lorain Cnty. (2018)
Immunity—surface water—trespass—reasonable use
- 2018 Ohio 2541State v. Boone (2018)
Trial court did not err when it overruled appellant's motion to suppress. The record establishes that the trial court had a substantial basis for concluding that probable cause existed to issue the search warrant for appellant's residence and person. The trial court did not err when it found that appellant made a knowing, intelligent, and voluntary waiver of his rights pursuant to Miranda v. Arizona, 384 U.S. 436, 86 S.Ct. 1602, 16 L.Ed.2d 694 (1966) before making incriminating statements to police. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2542State v. Bracy (2018)
endangering children, reckless, hot water, bathtub, burns, sufficiency, manifest weight
- 2018 Ohio 2543Brown v. Farley (2018)
child support – lump sum – monthly payments – arrearages – civil debt – contempt – imprisonment
- 2018 Ohio 2544State v. Bugg (2018)
motion to suppress, aggravated vehicular homicide, R.C. 4511.19(D), Ohio Adm.Code 3701-53-05, chemical test, blood sample, blood alcohol content
- 2018 Ohio 2545Clardy v. Medina Twp. Bd. of Trustees (2018)
R.C. 3313.76, judgment on the pleadings, declaratory judgment, de novo review
- 2018 Ohio 2547Cooper v. City of West Carrollton, Ohio (2018)
The trial court did not err in dismissing Appellant's action for breach of an oral agreement. Even if one assumes that the parties agreed to promote Appellant to a supervisor's position, the alleged agreement was unenforceable because the parties never discussed compensation, which was an essential term of the contract. The trial court also did not err in dismissing the action based on the statute of limitations for oral agreements. The alleged breach occurred more than six years before the action was filed. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2549Dixon v. Caesarscreek Twp. Board of Zoning Appeals (2018)
The trial court, in this R.C. 2506.01 administrative appeal, did not err by not conducting an evidentiary hearing under R.C. 2506.03 to supplement the administrative record. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2550Easley v. Akron (2018)
administrative appeal, record of proceedings, App.R. 9
- 2018 Ohio 2556In re J.R. (2018)
Trial court's decision awarding permanent custody of child to Children Services was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Father did not make significant progress toward case plan goals of employment, safe and appropriate housing, and engaging with and understanding the child's medical and educational needs. The record does not reflect that the trial court erred in denying parent's discovery request after conducting an in camera review of the Children Services' file. Any potential error in trial court's finding that child could not be returned to his father within a reasonable period of time was not determinative, as the court's other findings, including that the child had been in the temporary custody of Children Services for 12 or more months of a consecutive 22-month period, provided an alternate basis for the award of permanent custody. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2561State v. Moody (2018)
The trial court did not err in denying the appellant's petition for post-conviction relief where the petition was untimely and the appellant failed to make the showings required to overcome his untimeliness. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2567State v. Smith (2018)
Trial court properly employed the three-prong analysis of Batson v. Kentucky, 476 U.S. 79, 106 S.Ct. 1712, 90 L.Ed.2d 69 (1986) when, after the prosecutor articulated a race-neutral reason for the peremptory challenge, the court determined that the proffered reason was credible and not a pretext for discrimination. The trial court did not abuse its discretion by excluding evidence of a victim's character (dangerousness) and specific acts of violence. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in permitting evidence that defendant, as part of the series of encounters with one victim, fired gunshots at that victim's grandmother's home. Judgment affirmed. (Hall, J., concurring.)
- 2018 Ohio 2571State v. Russell (2018)
The trial court erred in ordering defendant to pay a specific amount of restitution in its judgment entry when it failed to notify the defendant of the amount of restitution at the sentencing hearing. Trial court partially complied with Crim.R. 11 when it incorrectly notified defendant at the plea hearing that his sentence included a discretionary, not mandatory, three-year term of post-release control. Because the record does not demonstrate that defendant was prejudiced by the court's misstatement, defendant has not shown that his plea was not knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily made. Judgment affirmed in part, reversed in part, and case remanded for resentencing on restitution only.
- 2018 Ohio 2572State v. Ward (2018)
Appellant incorrectly argues that he would have been statutorily ineligible for a prison term under R.C. 2929.13(B)(1)(b)(iii) had he not been compelled to answer incriminating questions about his drug use during his presentence investigation interview. Regardless of his admitted drug use, Appellant was eligible to receive a prison term under R.C. 2929.13(B)(1)(b)(iii) because he violated a condition of his bond requiring him to cooperate with the probation department during the presentence investigation. In addition, the incriminating information elicited during the presentence investigation process was not in violation of Appellant's Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination because Appellant failed to invoke the protections afforded by the Fifth Amendment and none of the exceptions for failing to invoke those protections apply. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2573State v. White (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2574State v. Petromilli (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - kidnapping felonious assault merger sufficiency of the evidence manifest weight of the evidence conviction supported by sufficient, credible evidence additional arguments pro se no ineffective assistance of counsel.
- 2018 Ohio 2575Unifund CCR Partners v. Piaser (2018)
CIV.R. 23 - class action debt collector fair debt collection practices act plaintiff allegedly violated act that prohibited debt collector from using any false or misleading representation in collection of debt by alleging in its complaint that it was the owner of the account without obtaining assignment from third party class definition was overbroad because it included consumers who have no claim class definition, as amended by trial court, defines improper fail safe class because it requires court to rule on merits of claim at class certification stage in order to tell who is included in class case was remanded for court to modify class definition to eliminate fail safe language case remanded because, without plaintiff's compliance with court-ordered discovery, trial court was unable to determine at the certification stage whether "marking" process resulted in transfer of ownership to third party, thus requiring assignment to plaintiff.
- 2018 Ohio 2576State v. Mayle (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - Petition for postconviction relief R.C. 2952.21(A)(2) untimely submission basis for dismissal affirming trial court's judgment for different reason.
- 2018 Ohio 2578Village of Mantua v. Sobczak (2018)
CRIMINAL - right to compulsory process due process witness necessary to an adequate defense ordinance not in conflict with statute car horn sound making device or instrument ejusdem generis statutory interpretation blanket sentence sentencing package.
- 2018 Ohio 2579Muldowney v. Portage Cty., Ohio Board of Cty. Commissioners (2018)
CIVIL - disability discrimination retaliatory discharge collateral estoppel res judicata grievance process used collective bargaining agreement statutory claims not barred separate not actually or necessarily litigated separate remedies are not jointly exhaustive summary judgment reasonable and nondiscriminatory basis for termination no evidence of pretext no genuine issue of material fact.
- 2018 Ohio 2580Lloyd v. Thornsberry (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - R.C. 2505.02(B) provisional remedy no release of privileged information no final appealable order.
- 2018 Ohio 2581State v. Harper (2018)
CRIMINAL - motion to suppress involuntary statements police coercion totality of the circumstances. LESSER INCLUDED OFFENSES - sufficiency of the evidence analysis de novo two-part inquiry.
- 2018 Ohio 2582Blank v. Allenbaugh (2018)
CIVIL - forcible entry and detainer action merits are rendered moot when the tenant has vacated the premises R.C. 1923.14(A) defendant may maintain or recover possession by filing a timely notice of appeal, obtaining a stay, and filing any required bond exceptions to mootness doctrine capable of repetition but evading review great public importance.
- 2018 Ohio 2583Norman v. Bracy, Warden (2018)
EXTRAORDINARY WRITS - habeas corpus petitioner's complaint does not allege facts showing that his maximum prison sentence has expired or that he is entitled to immediate release from prison. Rather, he is merely seeking a court order to correct his release date, for which a proper and adequate remedy is a writ of mandamus thus, petitioner's habeas-corpus claim is not legally cognizable the petition fails to state a claim on which habeas relief can be granted and the warden's Civ.R. 12(B)(6) motion to dismiss is granted.
- 2018 Ohio 2585Petersen & Petersen, Inc. v. Dinardo (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2588State v. Adkins (2018)
Trial court erred in the conviction of appellant for murder as a result of appellant demonstrating actual prejudice for the preindictment delay and appellee failing to demonstrate justification. Judgment reversed and conviction vacated.
- 2018 Ohio 2589State v. Cousino (2018)
Trial court failed to make all required findings under R.C. 2929.14(C)(4) before imposing consecutive sentences, requiring reversal and remand for new sentencing hearing.
- 2018 Ohio 2590State v. Wenner (2018)
Potential assignment of error exists where trial court may not have complied with R.C. 2929.13(B)(1). Anders briefs prohibited in criminal appeals.
- 2018 Ohio 2591State v. Skiles (2018)
This is a brief submitted pursuant to Anders v. California, 386 U.S. 738, 87 S.Ct. 1396, 18 L.Ed.2d 493 (1967). After a thorough and independent examination of the record, the judgment of the Lucas County Court of Common Pleas is affirmed, in part, and reversed, in part.
- 2018 Ohio 2592Toledo v. Jackson Industries Corp. (2018)
Insufficient evidence. Nuisance. Abate. Urban farming.
- 2018 Ohio 2593Sate v. Caldwell (2018)
The judgment of the Lucas County Court of Common Pleas is affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2595Meyer v. United Airlines, Inc. (2018)
Summary judgment will be affirmed where judgment as a matter of law is appropriate and there remains no dispute of material fact.
- 2018 Ohio 2596State/Toledo v. Neal (2018)
Appellant properly waived the explanation of circumstances required by R.C. 2937.07. When appellant waived the explanation of circumstances, he consented to the trial court making its determination of guilt based on the facts as admitted in the complaint. The complaint, however, failed to support each element of the offense charged. Thus, the trial court's finding of guilt was not supported by sufficient evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 2597State v. Rhea (2018)
Motion for leave to file an untimely motion to suppress properly denied motion in limine properly denied appellate court cannot consider the merits of the motion to suppress for the first time on appeal
- 2018 Ohio 2600State v. Ryan (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2602Claris, Ltd. v. Hotel Dev. Servs., L.L.C. (2018)
The trial court erred in denying defendant's motions for directed verdict because plaintiff failed to adduce sufficient evidence that a breach of the parties' contract proximately caused plaintiff's damages.
- 2018 Ohio 2603Greenawalt v. Freed (2018)
Trial court did not err in granting summary judgment in favor of appellees on appellants' claim for legal malpractice based on application of the statute of limitations.
- 2018 Ohio 2604Young v. Dept. Rehab. & Corr. (2018)
Court of Claims erred in granting summary judgment in favor of ODRC on appellant's claim for false imprisonment.
- 2018 Ohio 2605Mansour v. State Med. Bd. (2018)
Common pleas court did not abuse its discretion in affirming medical board's decision to revoke physician's license. Evidence showed that physician knowingly failed to disclose to the board concerning an action by the Arizona Medical Board against him, and pled guilty and was convicted of two counts of possession of drugs.
- 2018 Ohio 2607In re Acubens, L.L.C. (2018)
Trial court erred in denying applications to receive transfers of future lottery prize installment payments based on the plain language of R.C. 3770.121 in conjunction with R.C. 3770.10.
- 2018 Ohio 2608Disciplinary Counsel v. Land (2018)
On petition for reinstatement.
- 2018 Ohio 2609Redman v. Sheward (2018)
Appellant could not use a declaratory judgment action to collaterally attack his criminal convictions. Accordingly the trial court did not err in dismissing the declaratory judgment complaint for failure to state a claim.
- 2018 Ohio 2610Glenn v. The Ohio State Univ. (2018)
Plaintiff filed a wrongful termination case on the basis of racial discrimination as well as intentional infliction of emotional distress and retaliation against The Ohio State University. Plaintiff failed to file within the two year statute of limitation and the longer federal time period in this case is not applicable. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2611In re Resignation of Crosser (2018)
Attorneys at law—Resignation with disciplinary action pending—Gov.Bar R. VI(11)(C).
- 2018 Ohio 2612Sceptre, Inc. v. Big Sandy Distrib. Inc. (2018)
R.C. 2505.02 final appealable order Civ.R. 54(B) certification denial of summary judgment motion interlocutory
- 2018 Ohio 2613State v. Berecz (2018)
motion to memorialize judgment final appealable order R.C. 2505.02(B) lack jurisdiction
- 2018 Ohio 2616Spalsbury v. Gill Construction Co., Inc. (2018)
statute of limitations, R.C. 2305.07, summary judgment, Civ.R. 56, oral contract, unjust enrichment
- 2018 Ohio 2618Green v. Admr., Ohio Bur. of Workers Comp. (2018)
Workers compensation: trial court's findings of fact and conclusions of law were sufficient for appellate court to conduct review trial court did not err in admitting testimony competent and credible evidence supports judgment of the trial court.
- 2018 Ohio 2619In re K.B. (2018)
Juvenile did not demonstrate ineffective assistance of counsel.
- 2018 Ohio 2620State v. Rhoads (2018)
Escape under R.C. 2921.34(A)(3) and failure to notify of change of address under R.C. 2950.05(F)(1) are offenses of dissimilar import and defendant-appellant can be convicted of both offenses. The trial court did not err by sentencing defendant-appellant without obtaining a new or updated presentence investigation because the trial court did not sentence defendant-appellant to a community-control sanction or probation.
- 2018 Ohio 2621State v. Stein (2018)
Counsel was ineffective for not objecting to testimony regarding the fact that defendant was a thief and a drug dealer when the charges were unrelated to those prior bad acts. The State then argued that testimony as a basis for finding that the defendant was not entitled to a verdict of self-defense. Given that the remaining testimony was conflicting, the evidence is not overwhelming that a jury would have convicted the defendant. Thus, the appellant was prejudiced.
- 2018 Ohio 2623State v. Grigsby (2018)
Theft Lottery Tickets Manifest Weight
- 2018 Ohio 2624State v. Saunders (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2625State v. Graft (2018)
The trial court's decision sentencing appellant to serve a total of 36-months in prison after he pled guilty to two counts of nonsupport of dependents, the maximum sentence permitted by law when sentencing on two fourth-degree felonies, was not contrary to law or unsupported by the record where the record indicates the trial court properly considered the necessary sentencing factors prior to imposing its sentence, as well as appellant's criminal history that included two prior convictions for the same offenses.
- 2018 Ohio 2626Ford v. West (2018)
The term "heirs of the body" creates a class gift that cannot be determined until the class is closed, i.e., with the death of the final life tenant. Therefore, a claim for adverse possession will not begin to run against a remainder interest until they have possession of the property.
- 2018 Ohio 2628State ex rel. Arnold v. Gallagher (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Mandamus—Procedendo—Court of appeals' dismissal of complaint affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2629State ex rel. Fuller v. Eppinger (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Mandamus—Statute corrects minimum sentence imposed in excess of the statutory limit by operation of law—Court of appeals' dismissal of complaint affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2630Mahoning County Bar Association v. Mickens. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct—Conditionally stayed six-month suspension.
- 2018 Ohio 2631Akron Bar Association v. Tucker. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct—Conditionally stayed six-month suspension.
- 2018 Ohio 2632Bob Bay & Son, Co. v. Circle Inv. Corp. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2634State v. Schrader (2018)
Manifest weight/sufficiency - Assualt, Domestic Violence
- 2018 Ohio 2635State v. Brown (2018)
Criminal: The relevant time requirement in R.C. 2945.38 is directory, not mandatory. The trial court was properly vested with jurisdiction, and its findings were supported by clear and convincing evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 2636In re H.H. (2018)
JUVENILE - Trial court did not err in designating the biological father the child's legal guardian and as the custodial parent.
- 2018 Ohio 2637State v. Nance (2018)
CRIMINAL - Trial court erred by denying Appellant's motion to withdraw his guilty pleas and we reverse and remand.
- 2018 Ohio 2641State v. Hartman (2018)
Fellatio sexual conduct sleeping Evid.R. 404(B) other acts evidence flight instruction. Evidence sufficient to sustain count of forcible rape and substantially impaired rape when victim testified that she thought the person with whom she engaged in sexual conduct while asleep was her boyfriend before discovering that the person was, in fact, the defendant. Court abused its discretion by allowing other acts testimony because it was irrelevant, prejudicial, and used to show the defendant's character and that he acted in conformity therewith. Court's instruction on other acts testimony compounded the error. Court abused its discretion by giving flight instruction when state's request plainly showed that the defendant left the scene because the victim demanded that he leave, not for the purpose of eluding apprehension by the police.
- 2018 Ohio 2642State v. Walker (2018)
Jurisdiction resentencing double jeopardy res judicata. The trial court had jurisdiction to resentence appellant. After the trial court vacated appellant's original sentence, he was placed back in the same position as if he had never been sentenced at all. Appellant's argument that the trial court erred in imposing consecutive sentences is barred by the doctrine of res judicata. Appellant failed to appeal the consecutive sentences on direct appeal. 10543
- 2018 Ohio 2645State v. Stevenson (2018)
Crim.R. 11(C)(2)(a) guilty plea maximum penalty presumption of prison time. The Crim.R. 11(C)(2)(a) duty to inform a defendant of the maximum sentence does not require the court to determine that the defendant has an understanding of any statutory presumption in favor of incarceration.
- 2018 Ohio 2646State v. Pierce (2018)
Final order record on appeal judicial notice.
- 2018 Ohio 2647N.P. v. T.N. (2018)
Upheld trial court's decisions to issue civil stalking protection orders against appellants, and to find appellee/cross-appellant in contempt of court for violating conditions stated in an earlier civil stalking protection order that had been issued against her. Competent, credible evidence was presented to show appellants knowingly engaged in a pattern of conduct that caused appellee mental distress by continuously monitoring appellee's activities on her property by video camera, constantly reporting unfounded activities to authorities, and disregarding property lines. Contempt finding against cross-appellant was also supported by the record. Upheld trial court's decisions to issue civil stalking protection orders against appellants, and to find appellee/cross-appellant in contempt of court for violating conditions stated in an earlier civil stalking protection order that had been issued against her. Competent, credible evidence was presented to show appellants knowingly engaged in a pattern of conduct that caused appellee mental distress by continuously monitoring appellee's activities on her property by video camera, constantly reporting unfounded activities to authorities, and disregarding property lines. Contempt finding against cross-appellant was also supported by the record.
- 2018 Ohio 2648State v. Powell (2018)
The court considered the principles and purposes of felony sentencing set forth in R.C. 2929.11 and the sentencing factors set forth in R.C. 2929.12 before imposing a maximum sentence. The imposition of a maximum sentence is therefore supported by the record. Maximum sentence felony sentence review R.C. 2953.08(G)(2) supported by the record R.C. 2929.11 and 2929.12. State v. Powell, App. No. 106375
- 2018 Ohio 2649State v. B.H. (2018)
Trial court's judgment summarily denying defendant's application for expungement reversed where trial court did not place its findings on the record to demonstrate compliance with R.C. 2953.32, including whether trial court exercised its discretion under R.C. 2953.32(C)(2) to not consider applicant's prior sealed convictions in considering her application. R.C. 2953.32(C)(2) prior sealed record expungement findings.
- 2018 Ohio 2650In re: Germalic (2018)
The trial court did not err where it denied appellant's motion regarding disposition of decedent's residential home without first conducting a hearing. The matter was settled by the validity of decedent's will that the residence be bequeathed to appellant's brother.
- 2018 Ohio 2651State v. Buttery (2018)
CRIMINAL MISCELLANEOUS – JURISDICTION – SENTENCING – COMMUNITY-CONTROL VIOLATION: A trial court has jurisdiction to sentence a defendant for a community-control violation during the pendency of the defendant's appeal from the underlying judgment of conviction.
- 2018 Ohio 2655State v. Castorela-Sotela (2018)
The record does not portray ineffective assistance of counsel based on defense counsel's failure to question witnesses at trial regarding the appellant's and the victim's immigration statuses or the victim's awareness of a visa available to certain crime victims. Judgment affirmed. (Froelich, J., concurs in judgment only.)
- 2018 Ohio 2656Cox v. Dayton Public Schools Bd. of Edn. (2018)
The judgment of the trial court vacating the award of the arbitrator that terminated Cox's continuing teaching contract is reversed and vacated. The trial court, upon remand from this Court, erred in concluding that Cox's waiver of her statutory rights to proceed with a case under R.C. 3319.16 was not clear and unmistakable. (Welbaum, P.J., concurring.) (Hall, J. concurring in both the majority opinion and the concurrence.)
- 2018 Ohio 2658John W. Judge Co. v. USA Freight, L.L.C. (2018)
The trial court abused its discretion in granting Appellee's Civ.R. 60(B) motion to vacate a default judgment on grounds of excusable neglect. When a company is required by law to maintain a statutory agent to receive service of process, and when certified mail service is successful at the statutory agent's address that is on record with the Ohio Secretary of State, the subsequent mishandling of the served documents by the person who signed for and received the documents at the statutory agent's listed address does not amount to excusable neglect. Judgment reversed.
- 2018 Ohio 2659State v. McNeill (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying Appellant's request for an interpreter at her jury trial on one count of theft the record reflects that Appellant's grasp of English, though imperfect, allowed her the ability to understand and communicate sufficiently for purposes of the proceedings. Appellant's theft conviction was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2660Harold J. Pohl, Inc. v. Cotterman (2018)
Trial court did not err when it denied appellant's Civ.R. 60(B) motion for relief from judgment. Appellant failed to argue sufficient operative facts in order to establish a meritorious defense, and the trial court did not abuse its discretion by finding that he failed to establish the first prong of the test for relief pursuant to Civ.R. 60(B). Therefore, the trial court did not err by failing to afford appellant an evidentiary hearing on his motion for relief from judgment. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2661State v. Skapik (2018)
Defendant-appellant's counsel filed a brief under the authority of Anders v. California, 386 U.S. 738, 87 S.Ct. 1396, 18 L.Ed.2d 493 (1967). A thorough review of the record reveals no arguably meritorious appellate issues. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2665Cirino v. Bur. of Workers' Comp. (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Recipient of worker's compensation benefits brought action in common pleas court challenging the legality of fees incurred by some benefit recipients when accessing their benefits—Court of Claims has exclusive jurisdiction over this action because claim seeks legal relief rather than equitable relief—Court of appeals' judgment reversed.
- 2018 Ohio 2667State v. Mallory (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2668Berkheimer v. REKM, L.L.C. (2018)
Plaintiff, who was injured by a chicken bone ingested while consuming a "boneless" chicken wing at a restaurant, appeals decision granting judgment on the pleadings to the restaurant, its food supplier, and the food manufacturer. The trial court erred in granting judgment to defendants where material facts remained undetermined at the pleading stage such that the court could not find beyond doubt that the Plaintiff could prove no set of facts entitling him to relief.
- 2018 Ohio 2669State v. Rhymer (2018)
Appeal challenging the trial court's calculation of jail-time credit dismissed where appellant had completed his prison sentence, thereby render the appeal moot.
- 2018 Ohio 2670State v. Dallman (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2671State v. McQueen (2018)
Offender's 60-month prison sentence for sexual battery was not contrary to law and was supported by the record.
- 2018 Ohio 2672State v. Davis (2018)
Trial court did not err in sentencing defendant to 11 months in prison following his violation of community control under newly amended R.C. 2929.15(B)(1)(c)(ii).
- 2018 Ohio 2673In re B.C. (2018)
Juvenile court did not err in granting permanent custody of children to Warren County Children Services where its decision was supported by clear and convincing evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 2675State v. Weaver (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - motion to suppress execution of arrest warrant failure to appear Sudafed reports that residence was used to make methamphetamine noxious odors frequent foot traffic officers observed activities through window consistent with meth manufacture one-pot method volatile probable cause exigent circumstances justified in entering residence.
- 2018 Ohio 2676Cragon v. Shinkle (2018)
EVIDENCE - Hearsay exception for public records or reports Evid.R. 803(8) R.C. 2317.42 admission of real estate tax bill for property produced by county treasurer sufficient to establish delinquent property taxes.
- 2018 Ohio 2677State v. Sankey (2018)
POSTCONVICTION RELIEF - abuse of discretion alleged disparate sentence res judicata evidentiary hearing not required where evidence does not demonstrate substantive grounds for relief.
- 2018 Ohio 2678State v. Corpening (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - App.R. 5(A) delayed appeal motion fails to set forth reasons for delay.
- 2018 Ohio 2680Disciplinary Counsel v. Rutherford. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Multiple violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct, including neglecting client matters, failing to refund unearned legal fees, engaging in dishonest conduct, and failing to cooperate in disciplinary investigations—Permanent disbarment.
- 2018 Ohio 2681State ex rel. Hunter v. Binette (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Mandamus—Relator has misconstrued docket sheets—Judgment of dismissal affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2682State v. Gordon (2018)
Trial court correctly found defendant's driver's license was suspended at time she operated her car in Delaware County.
- 2018 Ohio 2684State v. Bolden (2018)
Court cannot re-sentence to correct post-release control because defendant completed sentence.
- 2018 Ohio 2685State v. Dawson (2018)
Motion to dismiss properly overruled. Probation officer authorized to notify court of probation violation.
- 2018 Ohio 2689First Merit Bank, N.A. v. Akron Gen. Med. Ctr. (2018)
Trusts - Cy Pres Doctrine
- 2018 Ohio 2690State v.Hoopingarner (2018)
Domestic violence, sufficientc/manifest weightineffective counsel
- 2018 Ohio 2691Homes v. Guess (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2692State ex rel. Neil v. French (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Procedendo—R.C. 2969.25—Failure to file a statement setting forth the balance in an inmate's account—R.C. 2969.25 does not allow for substantial compliance—Court of appeals' dismissal of complaint for a writ affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2693State ex rel. Russell v. Dept. of Rehab. & Corr. (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Mandamus—Relator cannot raise new issues on appeal—Court of Appeals' decision affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2694Thevenin v. White Castle Mgt. Co. (2018)
Trial court did not err in granting summary judgment in favor of employer on a former employee's claim that he was terminated, in violation of R.C. 4123.90, in retaliation for filing a workers' compensation claim and complaint where the former employee failed to prove the employer's articulated reasons for terminating him were a mere pretext for the adverse action. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 269517AP-767 (2018)
A decision of the State Board of Education is a "quasi-judicial" adjudication that is appealable to the Franklin County Court of Common Pleas under R.C. 119.12, based on interpretation of the word "final" in R.C. 3314.08(K)(2)(d). Judgment reversed and remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 2695Elec. Classroom Tomorrow v. Ohio State Bd. of Educ. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2696State ex rel. White v. Richard (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Habeas corpus—Appeal from court of appeals' dismissal of petition dismissed as untimely.
- 2018 Ohio 2698Conner v. Conner (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2699Dayton Bar Association v. Wilcoxson. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct—Conditionally stayed six-month suspension.
- 2018 Ohio 2701Nat'l Collegiate Student Loan Trust 2005-3 v. Dunlap (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2703State ex rel. Williams v. Croce (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Procedendo—Procedendo will not compel performance of a duty that has already been performed—Court of Appeals' dismissal affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2704State ex rel. Payne v. Reinbold (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Procedendo—Appellant had adequate remedy by way of direct appeal—Court of appeals' dismissal of complaint affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2705Disciplinary Counsel v. Benbow. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct—Two-year suspension, with second year stayed on conditions.
- 2018 Ohio 2706Columbus Bituminous Concrete Corp. v. Harrison Twp. Bd. of Zoning Appeals (In re Columbus Bituminous Concrete Corp.) (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2709Barberton v. Kay (2018)
left turn, failure to yield right-of-way, Barberton Code of Ordinances, §331.17, manifest weight, proceeding lawfully, rebuttable presumption
- 2018 Ohio 2711Disciplinary Counsel v. Leksan (2018)
On petition for reinstatement.
- 2018 Ohio 2714State v. Lillie (2018)
Assault - insufficient evidence
- 2018 Ohio 2721State v. Porter (2018)
App.R. 26(B) untimely good cause lack of transcript. The application to reopen an appeal filed beyond the 90-day time frame set forth in App.R. 26(B) was untimely and without good cause. Application denied.
- 2018 Ohio 2723State v. Dennis (2018)
App.R. 26(B) ineffective assistance of appellate counsel Sixth Amendment right to impartial jury biased juror sexual assault rape DNA evidence and plain error. Appellate counsel was not ineffective for failing to argue that jurors who had been sexually assaulted years ago could not be fair and impartial in a rape trial. Jurors affirmed that they could be fair and impartial. DNA evidence made it difficult to show plain error or prejudice.
- 2018 Ohio 2724State v. Perez (2018)
Rejection of a plea. The trial court abused its discretion in rejecting the plea set forth on the record without explaining its reasons for the rejection.
- 2018 Ohio 2725Brobst v. Lyndhurst (2018)
Summary judgment ordinance home occupation retail store sale of goods abuse of discretion statutory construction unambiguous, clear meaning expressio unius est exclusio alterius. The trial court erred by granting summary judgment in favor of the city. The trial court's finding is not supported by the broad definition of a "home occupation" set forth in L.C.O. 1150.09(c)(73). However, the trial court did not abuse its discretion by denying the city's motion to submit additional evidentiary materials in support of its motion for summary judgment. 105849 - Paul J. Brobst, Et al. v. Lyndhurst
- 2018 Ohio 2726Disciplinary Counsel v. Maney (2018)
On application for reinstatement.
- 2018 Ohio 2727AIDS Taskforce of Greater Cleveland v. Ohio Dept. of Health (2018)
Preliminary injunction final appealable order meaningful or effective remedy R.C. 2505.02(B)(4) substantial likelihood of success irreparable harm abuse of discretion. Because appellant would be deprived of a meaningful and effective remedy if it could not have appealed the trial court's denial of its motion for preliminary injunction before a final judgment, the trial court's order is a final, appealable order. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying appellant's motion for preliminary injunction where the injunction factors weighed in favor of denial.
- 2018 Ohio 27281229 Summit, L.L.C. v. Cater (2018)
106007 Because appellant would be deprived of a meaningful and effective remedy if it could not have appealed the trial court's denial of its motion for preliminary injunction before a final judgment, the trial court's order is a final, appealable order. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying appellant's motion for preliminary injunction where the injunction factors weighed in favor of denial. The trial court's judgment and opinion are supported by sufficient evidence. The trial court did not improperly deny the appellant's demand for judgment of ejectment because they are not the lawful owners of the property in question. The trial court did not improperly disregard the parties' liquidated damages agreement by issuing an order to the breached party to make them whole. The trial court's reconsidered opinion was issued pursuant to the appellate court directive.
- 2018 Ohio 2729State v. Green (2018)
R.C. 2929.14(C)(4), consecutive sentences, sentencing, nunc pro tunc. The trial court made the correct findings in accordance with R.C. 2929.14(C)(4). The trial court sentenced the appellant to nine years imprisonment, but stated at the sentencing hearing that he was sentenced to eight years. The journal entry reflected the mistake the trial court made by stating the appellant was sentenced to eight years, but the aggregate sentence was actually nine years. A nunc pro tunc order can only be used to correct what the trial court actually did.
- 2018 Ohio 2730State v. Turner (2018)
Revocation of community control, allied offenses, res judicata, sentencing anew. Appellant's allied offense challenge was barred on appeal from his community-control-revocation hearing by res judicata. The trial court erred by failing to sentence appellant anew following the revocation of his community control.
- 2018 Ohio 2731Lakewood v. Tate (2018)
municipal court jurisdiction, Ohio Uniform Traffic Ticket, driving under financial responsibility law suspension, limited driving privileges. The municipal court had jurisdiction over a uniform traffic ticket. The evidence did not support the driving under suspension conviction appellant had limited driving privileges and the record demonstrates that he was driving within the privileges.
- 2018 Ohio 2732Watts v. Fledderman (2018)
CONTRACTS – REAL PROPERTY/LANDLORD AND TENANT – CIV.R. 6(B) – PROCEDURE/RULES: The trial court did not abuse its discretion under Civ.R. 52 by asking the prevailing party to submit proposed findings of fact and conclusions of law and by then adopting the prevailing party's proposed findings of fact and conclusions of law when they accurately reflected the record and the law. In a declaratory-judgment action concerning the escrowed proceeds from the sale of real property, the trial court did not err in awarding the proceeds to the titled owner of the property and dismissing a counterclaim brought by the deceased tenant's sister contending that the deceased tenant was the equitable owner of the property pursuant to an oral land contract where the deceased tenant had entered into a commercial lease agreement with the owners the clear and unambiguous language of the lease gave the deceased tenant the right-of-first-refusal to purchase the property for $40,000 and the deceased tenant had not exercised the right of first refusal during his lifetime, but had acted consistently with his obligations as a commercial tenant of the property. The trial court properly dismissed with prejudice a counterclaim for a breach of a claimed residential lease agreement and for reimbursement of monies paid by the decedent during the tenancy in violation of Ohio's Landlord-Tenant Act where the clear and unambiguous language of the lease agreement showed that the agreement was a commercial lease, which was not subject to the provisions of the Landlord Tenant Act. The trial court did not abuse its discretion under Civ.R. 6(B) in denying a motion for a default judgment on counterclaims for a declaratory judgment and a breach of a claimed residential lease agreement, or in granting the titled property owner's motion for leave to file an answer out of time, where the counterclaims demanded the opposite declaratory relief that the titled property owner sought in her declaratory-judgment claim and where the titled property owner had not flagrantly disregarded the civil rules, but had moved to answer within nine days of being served with the motion for a default judgment.
- 2018 Ohio 2733Williams v. Sharon Woods Collision Center, Inc. (2018)
CONSUMER SALES PRACTICES ACT – DAMAGES – ATTORNEY FEES – PROCEDURE/RULES – NEW TRIAL : In a case brought by an automobile owner against an automobile repair shop for violations of the Consumer Sales Practices Act, the trial court did not err in allowing plaintiff to present evidence as to diminution in value of the automobile or in permitting the jury to consider that issue where plaintiff presented expert testimony showing the value of the car after an accident but before the alleged shoddy repairs by defendant repair shop, and testimony regarding the car's value after the shoddy repairs therefore, there was evidence showing the diminished value of the car after the repairs, and the evidence was legally sufficient to proceed to a jury. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in awarding plaintiff attorney fees where the court found that the claims in the case stemmed from a common core of facts and legal theories and could not be separated, the court conducted a thorough analysis of the reasonableness of the fees, and the amount of the fees was not so high or so low as to shock the conscience. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying defendant repair shop's motion for a new trial based on the misconduct of plaintiff automobile owner, because the record did not show that plaintiff had committed any misconduct by selling the car after the trial where defendant had had the opportunity to present evidence regarding the car's value after the repairs, and where the amount a third-party received for the car in a sale after-the-fact was irrelevant. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying defendant's motion for a new trial on the basis of newly discovered evidence, because matters occurring after trial cannot be newly discovered evidence that would justify the granting of a new trial. The trial court did not err in denying defendant's motion for a new trial on the basis of an error of law at trial, because no error of law occurred at trial, and events that occurred after trial did not change the fact that no error had occurred. The trial court did not err in failing to hold a hearing on defendant's motion for a new trial or in failing to refer it to the visiting judge who had presided over the trial, because Civ.R. 59 does not require a hearing except when the court grants a new trial of its own initiative, and nothing in the record indicated that the assigned trial judge did not give full and fair consideration to the issues raised in the motion.
- 2018 Ohio 2734R.T. v. Knobeloch (2018)
Defendant physician in a medical malpractice and lack of informed consent case requested this court to certify with a case from the Eighth and Fourth Districts Court of Appeals. In the first case there was no conflict with the Eighth Dist. regarding application of Evid.R. 601(D) because one expert met the requirements of the rule and the other expert's testimony was limited to nonstandard of care opinions. In the second case there was expert testimony to support lack of informed consent claim.
- 2018 Ohio 2735State ex rel. Bravo Brio v. Indus. Comm. (2018)
The Industrial Commission of Ohio acted within its discretion in determining that an intervening injury did not break the causal connection between claimant's work-related injury and the allowed condition. The Commission did not need to expliclity address relator's argument that nonallowed conditions caused the claimant's disability or explicitly find new and changed circumstances. The record contained sufficient evidence of a causal relationship between the allowed conditions and the proposed medical treatment, and that the allowed conditions were independently disabling.
- 2018 Ohio 2736Bay Emm Vay Store, Inc. v. BMW Fin. Servs. NA, L.L.C. (2018)
Judgment affirmed. The trial court's ruling denying appellant's petition under Civ.R. 34(D) was a final appealable order under R.C. 2505.02(B)(1). Because appellant knew the identities of the potential defendants of future litigation, the trial court properly the petition because appellant did not seek discovery to "ascertain the identity of a potential adverse party," as required by Civ.R. 34(D)(3)(1).
- 2018 Ohio 2739State v. Carty (2018)
OVI guilty plea, Crim.R. 11 ineffective assistance of counsel Veterans Treatment Court. Judgment affirmed. Defendant's pleas were knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily made. Defense counsel was not ineffective. The trial court did not abuse its discretion when it denied defendant's request for a transfer to Veterans Treatment Court when the defendant was subject to mandatory prison time and has a lengthy criminal record, including several OVIs.
- 2018 Ohio 2740Shingler v. Provider Services Holdings, L.L.C. (2018)
Dismissal of complaint motion for judgment on pleadings common-law tort for wrongful discharge in violation of public policy Greeley claim unlicensed practice of nursing R.C. 4723.03 reporting Ohio Board of Nursing retaliatory discharge R.C. 4723.341 R.C. 4113.52 jeopardy adequate statutory remedy. Trial court did not err in dismissing employee's complaint for failure to state a claim for wrongful discharge in violation of public policy where jeopardy element of claim was not satisfied. Adequate statutory remedy existed under R.C. 4723.33 and 4723.341 — incorporating the rights and duties granted "whistleblowing" employees under R.C. 4113.52 — that addresses society's interest in protecting employees who report violations of R.C. Chapter 4723. Employee's failure to comply with the requirements for statutory relief for wrongful discharge did not render statutory remedy inadequate.
- 2018 Ohio 2741Ceasor v. City of Cleveland (2018)
Summary judgment wrongful death R.C. 2744.02 R.C. 2744.03 immunity willful and wanton misconduct wanton or reckless manner final appealable order motion to strike. The trial court's denial of summary judgment for the city was appropriate because there were genuine issues of material fact as to whether the city was immune from liability for the decedent's death. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying the city's motion to strike.
- 2018 Ohio 2746Dayton v. International Assoc. of Firefighters, Local 136 (2018)
The litigants, a municipality and a union, are parties to a collective bargaining agreement (CBA) which, among other things, governs union members' overtime compensation. The parties, as required by the CBA, submitted an overtime dispute to binding arbitration with the arbitrator ruling in the union's favor. The trial court vacated the arbitration award finding that the arbitrator, by ignoring unambiguous contractual language, exceeded his authority. The arbitrator's decision is consistent with a reasonable, appropriate interpretation of the contested contractual language thus, the arbitrator did not exceed his authority. Judgment reversed and remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 2747State v. Clemmons (2018)
Defendant appeals from a judgment following resentencing for the sole purpose of properly imposing post-release control. Defendant's assignments of error, all of which relate to pretrial or trial matters, are barred by res judicata. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2748Harson Investments, Ltd. v. Troy (2018)
The trial court did not err in dismissing Appellants' petition for a writ of mandamus, as Appellants failed to exhaust administrative remedies following the denial of their application for a sign permit. In addition, the trial court did not err in granting a motion for judgment on the pleadings with respect to Appellants' request for a declaratory judgment. The ordinance outlining permissible limits for signage was not ambiguous and clearly limited the total square feet of signage to specific amounts listed in T.C.O. 749.11(o)(1), regardless of the number of tenants in a commercial building. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2749State v. Hayes (2018)
Defendant-appellant's counsel filed a brief under the authority of Anders v. California, 386 U.S. 738, 87 S.Ct. 1396, 18 L.Ed.2d 493 (1967). A thorough review of the record reveals no arguably meritorious appellate issues. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2750Holzapfel v. State (2018)
After two dogs were involved in an incident where a woman's legs were bitten, an animal control officer issued a "dangerous dog" notice to the dog's owner. At the hearing, the State did not prove by clear and convincing evidence which of the two dogs caused the injury. Judgment reversed. (Welbaum, P.J., dissenting.)
- 2018 Ohio 2751State v. Huber (2018)
The State concedes error in the trial court's award of 87 days of jail time credit, and since the award is not supported in the record, the judgment of the trial court is reversed, and the matter is remanded for a calculation of Huber's jail time credit.
- 2018 Ohio 2752State v. Kennard (2018)
Anders appeal. Claims related to the entering of defendant's guilty plea and the denial of his motion to withdraw his plea without a hearing lack arguable merit. No non-frivolous issues found. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2754Runions v. Burchett (2018)
Trial court did not err when it denied appellant's application for a concealed carry license (CCL) based upon three felony convictions for which he been pardoned by the governor of Ohio. Significantly, his pardon does not equate with a sealing or expungement of his convictions pursuant to sections 2151.355 to 2151.358, sections 2953.31 to 2953.36, or section 2953.37 of the Revised Code. Since appellant was not convicted of a felony "offense of violence" pursuant to R.C. 2923.13(A)(2), none of his felony convictions caused him to be placed under disability to carry or possess a firearm pursuant to R.C. 2923.13. Because appellant was not under disability, there is no disability to remove. Thus, the pardon did not relieve appellant "under operation of law or legal process from any disability imposed pursuant to section 2923.13 of the Revised Code." R.C. 2923.125(D)(4). Therefore, the sheriff was required to consider Runions's unsealed felony convictions in finding him not qualified for a CCL. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2757Estate of Mitchell v. Chessar (2018)
Toledo Municipal Court lacked subject-matter jurisdiction over a wage garnishment proceeding in which the parties were not residents of Toledo and the events that formed the basis of the matter took place outside of the territorial jurisdiction of the court.
- 2018 Ohio 2763Koch v. Ohio Acres4U LLC (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2764State v. Christian (2018)
App.R. 26 reconsideration R.C. 2903.11(B)(1).
- 2018 Ohio 2765State v. Tate (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2769Spires v. Oxford Mining Co. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2771KB Res., LLC v. Patriot Energy Partners, LLC (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2775State v. Mieczkowsk (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2776Richardson v. MYCAP (2018)
Employee handbook unjust enrichment payment of accrued, unused PTO summary judgment
- 2018 Ohio 2777State v. Harvey (2018)
R.C. 2945.71 extradition proceedings reasonable diligence.
- 2018 Ohio 2778State v. Redmond (2018)
Alford plea ineffective assistance of counsel
- 2018 Ohio 2781Nationwide Mut. Fire Ins. Co. v. Pusser (2018)
: summary judgment coverage existed for a vehicle-pedestrian fatality Allstate Ins. Co. v. Boggs, 27 Ohio St.2d 216, 271 N.E.2d 855 (1971) warranties vs. representations use of the words "may" and "could" did not clearly and unambiguously put the insured on notice that a misstatement would render a policy void ab initio
- 2018 Ohio 2782State v. Paige (2018)
Postrelease control parole classified felony State v. Fischer, 128 Ohio St.3d 92, 2010-Ohio-6238, 942 N.E.2d 332
- 2018 Ohio 2784Kraynak v. Whitacre (2018)
oil and gas lease paying quantities requests for admissions declaratory judgment.
- 2018 Ohio 2785State v. Kinney (2018)
Aggravated vehicular homicide R.C. 2903.06(A)(1)(a) OVI R.C. 4511.19(A)(1)(a) R.C. 4511.19(A)(1)(h) proportionality and consistency State v. Williams, 7th Dist. No. 11 MA 131, 2012-Ohio-6277 R.C. 2929.12.
- 2018 Ohio 2788State v. Houston (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2797State v. Young (2018)
petition for post-conviction relief – abuse of discretion – ineffective assistance of counsel – deficient performance – prejudice – Evid.R. 609 – Evid.R. 616 – DNA evidence – impeachment – expert
- 2018 Ohio 2798Wenning v. Advanced Spine Joint & Wellness Ctr., L.L.C. (2018)
malpractice, chiropractor, relation back, Civ.R. 15(C), statute of limitations
- 2018 Ohio 2799Mullins v. Grey Hawk Golf Club (2018)
summary judgment, open and obvious, duty, primary assumption of the risk, Civ.R. 56
- 2018 Ohio 2800State v. Moore (2018)
post-conviction relief, R.C. 2953.21, R.C. 2953.23, retroactive right, untimely petition
- 2018 Ohio 2802Hudson v. Lager & Vine Gastro Pub & Wine Bar (2018)
motion for summary judgment, magistrate's decision, Civ.R. 53, untimely objections, forfeit all but plain error
- 2018 Ohio 2803Clough v. Haines (2018)
summary judgment. Civ.R. 56, defamation, false light, truth, publicity
- 2018 Ohio 2804State v. Barga (2018)
Sufficient evidence has been presented for forgery in violation of R.C. 2913.31(A)(3) when the State introduces some evidence that suggests the defendant has (1) uttered or possessed with the intent to utter any writing that the person knows to have been forged (2) with the purpose to defraud.
- 2018 Ohio 2805State v. Wilson (2018)
A waiver of the right to counsel in a misdemeanor case must be made on the record in open court and must be voluntary, knowing, and intelligent.
- 2018 Ohio 2807State v. Cheek (2018)
The trial court did not err in sentencing the defendant-appellant to the maximum sentence. The judgment of the trial court is affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2808State v. Leugers (2018)
Trial court erred by failing to properly advise defendant of post-release control at the sentencing hearing and then improperly imposing it in the sentencing entry. Matter remanded to the trial court to determine if defendant had completed his prison term or if he could be subjected to a limited resentencing.
- 2018 Ohio 2809State v. Stuber (2018)
Defendant-appellant's driving-under-suspension conviction under R.C. 4510.111(A) is based on sufficient evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 2810Rucker v. Larose (2018)
Habeas corpus failure to file commitment papers failure to file affidavit of prior civil actions state court of appeals lacks jurisdiction over federal inmates dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 2811In re Sangster v. Larose (2018)
Habeas corpus failure to file commitment papers failure to file affidavit of prior civil actions state court of appeals lacks jurisdiction over federal inmates dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 2812State v. Panezich (2018)
Plea was entered into knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily plea was not product of coercion Appellant waived Kastigar hearing by withdrawing requesting and entering guilty plea.
- 2018 Ohio 2813Citizen's Bank v. Leek (2018)
trial court confirmed foreclosure sale to third-party purchaser after finding the bank had no right to redeem the property after the sale at the second auction R.C. 2329.311(A) allowed the bank, as judgment creditor and first lienholder, to redeem by paying the purchase price within 14 days after a sale "at an auction with the minimum bid pursuant to division (B) or section 2329.52" this language does not mean the right to redeem does not exist unless the sale had a minimum bid minimum bid is set in R.C. 2329.20, whereas R.C. 2329.52(B) deals solely with subsequent sales and provides the minimum bid requirements of R.C. 2329.20 are not applicable.
- 2018 Ohio 2814Hills & Hollers, LLC v. Ohio Gathering Co. (2018)
affirming summary judgment for grantee of pipeline right of way right of way agreement contained clause stating grantee "shall be responsible for all other taxes, charges, and market enhancements charged to the flow of gas or liquids from the [named] well pad" clause was not independent and collateral to the right of way agreement grantor could no longer enforce clause after conveyance to Gulfport reservation of mineral rights was not dispositive.
- 2018 Ohio 2818State v. Huston (2018)
The trial court made a clerical error in its judgment entries of plea and sentence by claiming appellant pled guilty rather than appellant's actual plea of no contest, thereby requiring the matter to be reversed and remanded to the trial court to issue the necessary nunc pro tunc judgment entries to correct the clerical errors in its applicable judgment entries. The trial court, however, did not err by finding appellant guilty upon appellant entering a no contest plea to burglary and attempted aggravated arson where the trial court went to great lengths to ensure appellant was entering his no contest plea knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily with a complete understanding of the nature of the charges against him and the maximum possible penalty that he faced.
- 2018 Ohio 2819State v. Nelson (2018)
Trial court did not err in finding that probable cause existed in support of issuing a search warrant for offender's hotel room, and in denying offender's motion to suppress drug trafficking evidence seized in offender's hotel room.
- 2018 Ohio 2820State v. Fehrenbach (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2821Duke Energy Ohio, Inc. v. City of Hamilton (2018)
The trial court did not err in granting a partial-dismissal of a public utility's complaint, as the utility's claim that it had exclusive right to provide natural gas and electric services to an area located in Fairfield Township was a service-based claim that requires the PUCO's administrative expertise to resolve. The public utility's claim is based on the Ohio Certified Territories Act and tariffs filed with PUCO, and both the tariffs and the Act fall within the exclusive purview of PUCO.
- 2018 Ohio 2823Bunta v. Superior Vacupress L.L.C. (2018)
Motion to compel arbitration
- 2018 Ohio 2824Citimortgage, Inc. v. Elrod (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - App.R. 4(A) thirty-day rule Civ.R. 58(B) untimely appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 2825State v. Pino (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - pursuant to R.C. 2929.15(B)(1)(c)(i), if a defendant who is under community control sanctions for committing a fifth degree felony commits a technical violation of his community control sanctions or a new crime which is not a felony, the trial court can only impose a sentence not exceeding 90 days a technical violation of community control sanctions is one which violates the terms of the sanctions, but which is not itself criminal.
- 2018 Ohio 2826State v. Snyder (2018)
CRIMINAL - consecutive sentences R.C. 2929.14(C)(4) findings contrary to law jury waiver no contest plea error in plea agreement Crim.R. 11 substantial compliance harmless error
- 2018 Ohio 2827State v. Weir (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - PLEAS - guilty plea Crim.R. 11(C)(2) waiver of constitutional rights strict compliance colloquy reasonably intelligible to the defendant defendant read plea agreement into the record knowingly and voluntarily stipulated sentence not reviewable on appeal R.C. 2953.08(D)(1) no duty to advise.
- 2018 Ohio 2828Pfalzgraf v. Miley (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2829Hinton v. Shoop (2018)
Trial court did not err in granting Warden's Civ.R.12(B)(6) motion for dismissal for failure to state a claim.
- 2018 Ohio 2830Fox v. Nationwide Mut. Ins. Co. (2018)
Trial court did not err in granting appellee's motion for summary judgment where the evidence in support of the motion established as a matter of law that appellant was an independent contractor of appellee, not an employee. Nor did the trial court err by granting summary judgment as to appellant's claim for breach of contract, breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing, and invasion of privacy where the evidence failed to create a genuine issue of fact as to the essential elements of those claims. Finally, the trial court did not err when it determined that the parties' fully integrated written agreement barred appellant's claim of unjust enrichment and that the release executed by appellant barred appellant's claims for fraud. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2831Moore v. Mount Carmel Health Sys. (2018)
Appellant's request for service of the complaint, by operation of law, was a dismissal and refiling of the complaint and was a failure otherwise than on the merits. The trial court, therefore, erred in failing to apply the savings statute. Based on this error, the trial court also erred in dismissing the vicarious liability claims against Appellees (a medical practice and hospital). In light of these errors, whether the trial court erred in its conclusion about a physician's status as an employee of the medical practice is moot. Reversed and remanded for further proceedings.
- 2018 Ohio 2832State v. Edmonds (2018)
Doyle Violation Mistrial
- 2018 Ohio 2837State v. Timmons (2018)
Drugs heroin Crim.R. 11 plea voluntary maximum consecutive sentence clear and convincing R.C. 2929.11 R.C. 2929.12 ineffective assistance. Appellant's convictions for drug-related offenses and the sentences imposed in three underlying cases were upheld. The record reflected that the trial court complied with Crim.R. 11 and that appellant's guilty pleas were knowing, intelligent, and voluntary. Trial court did not err in the imposition of maximum, consecutive sentences, and it could not be determined by clear and convincing evidence that the record did not support the trial court's findings or the sentence imposed. Appellant failed to demonstrate ineffective assistance of counsel.
- 2018 Ohio 2839UH Rainbow Babies & Children's Hospital v. Caresource (2018)
Arbitration, nonsignatory, compel, insurance coverage. Trial court did not abuse its discretion in finding that the nonsignatory to the contract containing a mandatory arbitration provision did not seek to benefit from the contract. The claim was an insurance coverage dispute that would be determined by relevant Ohio law and the insured's certificate of coverage, which does not contain an arbitration provision. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying the motion to stay the proceedings and compel arbitration.
- 2018 Ohio 2840State v. Beaver (2018)
Conceded error consecutive sentence harmless moot served sentence modified. Although the parties concede that the trial court did not make the requisite findings prior to imposing consecutive sentences, the error is harmless. The sentence that the trial court ordered the new sentence consecutive to was already served at the time of sentencing.
- 2018 Ohio 2841State v. Thomas (2018)
Assault R.C. 2903.13(A) felony caretaker developmentally disabled hearsay Evid.R. 801(C) Evid.R. 802 exceptions Evid.R. 804(B)(5) unavailable incompetent Evid.R. 803(3) state of mind Evid.R. 803(2) excited utterance Confrontation Clause harmless error reasonable probability conviction. Appellant's conviction for assault of a developmentally disabled person was affirmed. Trial court's allowance of hearsay testimony and alleged Confrontation Clause violation concerning statements made by nontestifying physically and mentally impaired victim was determined to be harmless because there was no reasonable possibility that the improperly admitted evidence contributed to the conviction. The jurors heard other evidence of the assault, including testimony from an eyewitness who described the assault in detail and testimony from another witness, whom the appellant called, who testified appellant admitted to the assault. Photographs of the victim depicted an injury to his inner lip that was consistent with being slapped across the face.
- 2018 Ohio 2842State v. Lugo (2018)
Sexual predator classification criminal history recidivism. As a result of the limited proceedings, the sexual predator classification is reversed and the matter remanded for the purpose of conducting a proper sexual offender classification hearing in accordance with State v. Eppinger and with full consideration of all factors enumerated in former R.C. 2950.09(B)(2).
- 2018 Ohio 2843State v. Fontanez (2018)
Proportionate sentence rape kidnapping recommended sentence R.C. 2929.11 R.C. 2953.08(D)(1). Defendant-appellant's nine-year sentence was within the range of his recommended sentence. Because the sentence was authorized by law, had been recommended jointly by the defendant and the prosecutor, and was imposed by a sentencing judge, it was not subject to appellate review.
- 2018 Ohio 2844Resco Holdings, L.C.C. v. AIU Insurance Co. (2018)
Equitable contribution pro rata time-on-risk "all sums" approach allocation insurance coverage fair share equity joint claims interest prejudgment interest postjudgment interest. Trial court properly applied all sums approach to determining an insurer's equitable share of insurance coverage liability. Two insurance plaintiffs may jointly prosecute equitable contribution claim against another insurer who has not paid its fair share of insurance coverage liability. Where judgment entry ordered interest but did not make any findings necessary for prejudgment interest, the judgment entry authorizes postjudgment, rather than prejudgment interest.
- 2018 Ohio 2845Rimmer v. Citifinancial, Inc. (2018)
Intervention as of right permissive intervention class action class notice discovery affidavit Civ.R. 24 explanation abuse of discretion untimely final judgment. Civ.R. 24 does not require trial courts to make findings of fact or conclusions of law. Appellants' motions to intervene were untimely. Consequently, the trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying appellants' separate motions to intervene.
- 2018 Ohio 2846Cleveland v. Oke (2018)
Double jeopardy drug court. The Cleveland Municipal Drug Court's imposition of two successive sentences violated the prohibition against double jeopardy.
- 2018 Ohio 2849H.P. Mfg. Co. v. Westfield Ins. Co. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2850State v. Harris (2018)
SENTENCING: The trial court's R.C. 2929.14(C)(4) findings that consecutive prison terms were necessary to protect the public from future crime by the defendant and were not disproportionate to the seriousness of the defendant's conduct were sufficiently supported by the record, which showed that the defendant was out on bond when he committed four robberies and a felonious assault, his conduct demonstrated an escalating path of violence, he had a long record of juvenile adjudications, and he had a plethora of infractions while housed in the justice center. Because the sentencing entries do not reflect the sentences the trial court actually imposed upon the defendant at the sentencing hearing, the causes are remanded for the trial court to correct the defect by nunc pro tunc entries.
- 2018 Ohio 2853Hobart v. Indus. Comm. (2018)
On the facts of this case, given the restrictions imposed on the right upper extremity by the physician upon whom the commission relied, the court adopts the magistrate's decision examining the specific restrictions imposed by the physician and determining the physician's opinion failed to meet the criteria for light-duty work. The court adopts the magistrate's decision and grants the requested writ of mandamus.
- 2018 Ohio 2854Deanru, L.L.C. v. Ohio Liquor Control Comm. (2018)
Common pleas court did not abuse its discretion by affirming order of Liquor Control Commission revoking liquor permits. Order was supported by reliable, probative, and substantial evidence because appellant stipulated to facts contained in investigative report setting out basis for revocation of permits. Because revocation of permits was an authorized penalty under the law, the common pleas court and the court of appeals lacked authority to modify that penalty.
- 2018 Ohio 2855Kingston of Miamisburg v. Maute (2018)
Trial court properly granted summary judgment to heir and his wife on facility's fraud, civil conspiracy, and estoppel claims. Facility did not, as a matter of law, reasonably rely on wife's statements regarding the opening of an estate or payment of the facility's bill when the facility failed to open an estate for decedent and procure the appointment of an executor or administrator so that it could timely present its claim heir did not receive assets of the estate by fraud or unjust enrichment. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2858State v. Taylor (2018)
The trial court erred in ordering defendant to pay a $130 court-appointed counsel fee. Defendant's trial counsel was not ineffective for failing to request a waiver of the supervision fee and court costs. Judgment reversed in part and affirmed in part, and the matter is remanded for the filing of an amended judgment entry that omits the imposition of court-appointed counsel fees. (Welbaum, J., dissenting.)
- 2018 Ohio 2859State v. Tucker (2018)
Appellant's convictions for felonious assault (deadly weapon), improperly discharging a firearm at or into a habitation, and discharge of a firearm on or near prohibited premises were not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2860State v. Turner (2018)
Trial court properly concluded that restitution could be awarded to a law enforcement agency where the agency's property, a cruiser, was damaged in the course of defendant's criminal activity. However, the trial court erred in awarding restitution in the amount of the replacement value of the vehicle, which was "at its end of life," because that amount exceeded the agency's economic loss. Judgment affirmed in part and reversed in part, and remanded for further proceedings on restitution.
- 2018 Ohio 2861Vectren Energy Deliver of Oh., Inc. v. Bansal Construction, Inc. (2018)
The affidavit on which plaintiff-utility company relied in support of its motion for summary judgment did not demonstrate the affiant's personal knowledge of the matters addressed, nor did it demonstrate that the attached documents were business records of which the affiant was the custodian. Moreover, the black-and-white photographic exhibits attached to the affidavit, which were the sole basis for plaintiff's assertion that defendant negligently excavated in the vicinity of a gas line, did not establish that there was no genuine issue of material fact as to negligence the yellow markings allegedly made by plaintiff to demonstrate the location of its utility lines prior to excavation were not clearly visible in the photographs and do not show markings prior to the damage to the gas line. Judgment reversed and remanded. (Hall, J., dissenting.) (Welbaum, P.J., concurring in judgment only.)
- 2018 Ohio 2862Weinberg v. Weinberg (2018)
The trial court correctly granted summary judgment in favor of the Appellee on Appellant's cause of action under R.C. 2111.04(D). The trial court, however, erred by granting summary judgment to the Appellant on Appellee's testamentary capacity cause of action because there is a genuine issue of material fact regarding the parties' father's testamentary capacity. Judgment affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded to the trial court.
- 2018 Ohio 2865Niedziewcki v. Swancreek Water Dist. (2018)
Requirement under R.C. 6119.011(G) that a resolution contains a finding that a project is consistent with EPA standards does not apply to resolutions declaring the necessity of a project. In an administrative appeal, the transcript provided under R.C. 2506.02 contains sufficient conclusions of fact where it can be determined from the resolution, meeting minutes, and other documents what the agency decided and why it made the decision.
- 2018 Ohio 2866State v. Page (2018)
Motion to suppress properly denied evidence of later bad acts improperly admitted under Evid.R. 404(B), but did not result in prejudice sufficient evidence to submit the case to the trier of fact tax map properly admitted into evidence to prove the 1,000-foot boundary to enhance a trafficking conviction.
- 2018 Ohio 2867Amalgamated Transit Union, AFL-CIO, Local 697 v. Toledo Area Regional Transit Auth. (2018)
Civ.R. 52 motion for findings of fact and conclusions of law following bench trial.
- 2018 Ohio 2868State v. Compton (2018)
Consecutive sentences
- 2018 Ohio 2869State v. Renz (2018)
Aiding & abetting aggravated murder, abuse of corpse
- 2018 Ohio 2871State v. Lindsay (2018)
due process, community control, written finding of violation, harmless error, Crim.R. 52(A), post-release control, R.C. 2967.28
- 2018 Ohio 2872Talarek v. Weaver (2018)
summary judgment – tax lien foreclosure – treasurer – land reutilization corporation – direct transfer of property – personal judgment – certify as a lien – demolition costs – R.C. 715.261 – forfeited – plain error
- 2018 Ohio 2873State v. Yost (2018)
The trial court did not err in overruling the appellant's motion to suppress.
- 2018 Ohio 2874Ditech Fin., L.L.C. v. Akers (2018)
If the moving party properly supports a motion for summary judgment, the nonmoving party must respond by establishing that a genuine issue of material fact exists for trial in order to defeat the motion for summary judgment. If the nonmoving party does not respond with evidentiary materials that satisfy the requirements of Civ.R. 56, then summary judgment is appropriate.
- 2018 Ohio 2875State v. Swoveland (2018)
Defendant-appellant's guilty pleas were not unknowing, unintelligent, or involuntary. The trial court did not abuse its discretion by failing to order a competency hearing. Defendant-appellant did not receive the ineffective assistance of trial counsel.
- 2018 Ohio 2876State v. Cumbow (2018)
Whether speedy trial rights violated due to continuance
- 2018 Ohio 2877State v. Moscoso (2018)
Motion to suppress/Appeal of sentence/Fine & costs/Sufficiency of the evidence
- 2018 Ohio 2879State v. Amison (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Court of appeals' judgment reversed on authority of State v. Paige.
- 2018 Ohio 2881Hamilton v. Purvis (2018)
Appellant's conviction for domestic violence was not against the manifest weight of the evidence where the state demonstrated appellant knowingly caused physical harm to his teenage daughter when he punched her in the face with a closed fist. Furthermore, the finder of fact was entitled to conclude that a closed fist punch to the face was not proper and reasonable parental discipline.
- 2018 Ohio 2882State v. Martino (2018)
The trial court did not err by finding appellant guilty of two counts of domestic violence where the victims, who were appellant's family or household members, testified appellant caused them physical harm.
- 2018 Ohio 2883Cincinnati Ins. Co. v. Kesner (2018)
Trial court did not abuse its discretion granting motorist's motion for relief from default judgment.
- 2018 Ohio 2884State v. Mock (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2885MTGLQ Investors L.P. v. Faulkner (2018)
The trial court did not err in granting summary judgment in favor of appellee where appellee demonstrated it is the holder of the note and mortgage, appellant had defaulted on his payment obligation, and the debt owed had been properly accelerated.
- 2018 Ohio 2886Eastbrook Farms, Inc. v. Warren Cty. Bd. of Revision (2018)
Landowner appeals the valuation of its property by the Ohio Board of Tax Appeals. Landowner claims the Board erroneously relied on an appraiser who valued the property based on a mistaken assumption that the property was zoned for retail development. The Board of Tax Appeals did not err in relying on the appraiser where there was no credible evidence that the appraiser's alleged misunderstanding affected the appraiser's valuation of the property.
- 2018 Ohio 2887LRC Realty, Inc. v. B.E.B. Properties (2018)
CIVIL - declaratory judgment breach of contract tortious interference indemnification summary judgment Civ.R. 56(C) real property easement lease agreement rental payments reformation of deed standing privity warranty deed right to receive rent property owner landlord encumbrance recording statutes reservation exception bona fide purchaser for value constructive notice chain of title deed construction intent of the parties assignment.
- 2018 Ohio 2888State ex rel. Ames v. Portage Cty. Bd. of Commrs. (2018)
CIVIL - Ohio's Open Meetings Act Sunshine Law commissioners convened meetings prearranged no minutes jail overcrowding opiate epidemic members of community Jail-Overcrowding Task Force Portage County Tea Party tax measure rescinded public body meeting and deliberations concerning public business mere information gathering investigation fact finding no decisions no deliberations no violations.
- 2018 Ohio 2889Germadnik v. Auld (2018)
CIVIL - landlord tenant rental payments late fees counterclaim unlawful eviction security deposit personal property compensatory damages demand for relief Civ.R. 54(C) Civ.R. 15(B) punitive damages small claims division limited subject matter jurisdiction R.C. 1925.02(A).
- 2018 Ohio 2890State ex rel. Davis v. Sloan (2018)
ORIGINAL ACTION - writ of habeas corpus Civ.R. 12(B)(6) failure to state a claim jurisdiction adequate remedy at law.
- 2018 Ohio 2891McGann v. Altiere (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - App.R. 4(A) thirty-day rule Civ.R. 58(B) untimely appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 2892Rock v. Bracy (2018)
ORIGINAL ACTION - writ of habeas corpus Civ.R. 12(B)(6) adequate remedy at law.
- 2018 Ohio 2893Lloyd v. Thornsbery (2018)
CIVIL - civil protection order R.C. 2903.214 trial court's discretion petitioner must establish a violation of R.C. 2903.11 by a preponderance of the evidence sufficiency of the evidence manifest weight of the evidence App.R. 12(A)(2) App.R. 16(A) pro se.
- 2018 Ohio 2895Lorain Cty. Bar Assn. v. Nelson (2018)
On application for reinstatement.
- 2018 Ohio 2896State v. Price (2018)
Criminal: trial court's disregard of statutory requirements when imposing a lump-sum community control term for separate offenses renders that part of sentence void R.C. 2929.11-2929.19.
- 2018 Ohio 2898State v. Nix (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW—SENTENCING—JURISDICTION—CONSTITUTIONAL LAW/CRIMINAL—CRIM.R. 36: The second appeal filed from the same common pleas court order was subject to dismissal as duplicative of the first appeal. The common pleas court properly declined, because it had no jurisdiction, to resentence defendant based on his claim in his postconviction motion that former R.C. 2929.14(D)(1)(b) precluded sentencing him for each firearm specification accompanying his two felonious-assault offenses. The constitutional protections against double jeopardy are not implicated by sentencing on multiple firearm specifications, because specifications are penalty enhancements, not offenses. The common pleas court erred in not correcting under Crim.R. 36 the clerical error contained in defendant's judgment of conviction with a nunc pro tunc entry indicating that he had been convicted following a jury trial, not, as the entry stated, upon guilty pleas.
- 2018 Ohio 2899In re A.T. (2018)
CONSTITUTIONAL LAW/CRIMINAL – FOURTH AMENDMENT – SEARCH AND SEIZURE: The trial court properly denied defendant's motion to suppress evidence obtained from searches of a vehicle and defendant's person where defendant was a passenger in a vehicle that was lawfully stopped for a traffic violation, the police officer smelled marijuana in the vehicle, and the driver of the vehicle admitted that there was marijuana in the vehicle, but did not admit that it was his. [But see DISSENT: The trial court erred in overruling defendant's motion to suppress where there was no evidence that defendant smelled of marijuana and no other evidence to support probable cause to believe that defendant had marijuana on his person.]
- 2018 Ohio 2901State v. Shuster (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2903State v. Brooks (2018)
Violation of Community Control - Manifest Weight - IAC
- 2018 Ohio 2904State v. Franklin (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2905Peterson v. Natl. Sec. Assoc., Inc. (2018)
Judgment reversed. The trial court erred in granting defendants' motions for summary judgment on the basis of primary assumption of risk, as the record presented an issue of fact regarding attendant circumstances which elevated the risks at issue beyond the ordinary risks of an explosive breaching training. Additionally, as the trial court failed to rule on certain issues presented in the summary judgment proceedings, this court would not rule on those issues for the first time.
- 2018 Ohio 2906Straight v. Levy (2018)
The trial court did not err when it denied appellant's motion to intervene.
- 2018 Ohio 2907State v. Hart (2018)
Hart's convictions are not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 2908State ex rel. Steele v. Frye (2018)
Action dismissed. It is well-established that procedendo does not lie to compel performance of a duty that has already been performed. In accordance with the magistrate's recommendation, we grant respondent's motion to dismiss, and dismiss relator's request for a writ of procedendo as moot.
- 2018 Ohio 2909Worthington City Schools Bd. of Edn. v. Franklin Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation—Real-property valuation—R.C. 5713.03—Real property must be valued based on "the true value of the fee simple estate, as if unencumbered"—Appraisal presented by property's owner complied with R.C. 5713.03—Decision of Board of Tax Appeals reversed.
- 2018 Ohio 2910Neff v. Knapp (2018)
Core Terms: public record court of claims R.C. 2743.75 R.C. 149.43 moot. Overview: Requester sought copies of an individual trustee's personal email or correspondence 1) of her records requests to the township, 2) with a firm auditing the township, and 3) regarding a legal question. The special master found that the fiscal officer responsible for official records kept by the township improperly forwarded these requests to the trustee for response. The special master recommended that the court find that production of the official copies kept by the township rendered the first request moot, that the official copies responsive to the second request were not excepted by R.C. 4701.19(B) and must be produced, and that the third request was properly denied as ambiguous and overly broad. Both parties filed objections. Outcome: Based on respondent's assertion that it had provided township records generally related to the first request, the court overruled requester's objection that she had not received responsive records. Because those records had been provided promptly, the court upheld respondent's objection to the finding that the township had caused delay in production of records by also forwarding the request to the individual trustee for response. The court adopted the report of the special master, as modified, and rendered judgment in favor of requester.
- 2018 Ohio 2911Darr v. Huber Heights (2018)
Core Terms: public record court of claims R.C. 2743.75 R.C. 149.43 email overly broad moot. Overview: Requester sought all email to and from each of twelve public employees for a fourteen-month period. Respondent denied the request, but also provided thousands of responsive emails to requester. The special master recommended that the court find that the request had been properly denied as overly broad, and had also been rendered moot.
- 2018 Ohio 2913Parrish v. Village of Glendale (2018)
Core Terms: public record court of claims R.C. 2743.75 R.C. 149.43(B)(1) moot promptly. Overview: On January 20, 2018, Requester sought 1) a 2015 file for village sewer and water issues, and 2) records of the village budget for 2015 as related to sewer, water, and other utilities. The special master found that respondent had provided records responsive to the first request in an earlier response and again on March 2, 2018, and provided the additional records identified in the second request on March 2, 2018. The special master recommended that the court find that both requests were moot, but the delay of six weeks in producing budget records in response to the second request violated respondent's duty to produce those records promptly. Respondent objected to the finding that it had failed to provide all records promptly, and to the recommendation that its motion to dismiss be denied and the case determined on the merits. Outcome: The court overruled the objection regarding denial of the motion to dismiss. The court found that under the facts and circumstances of the case the special master's conclusion that respondent failed to promptly prepare and make records available for inspection pursuant to R.C. 149.43(B)(1) should not be adopted. The court adopted the report of the special master, as modified, and rendered judgment in favor of respondent.
- 2018 Ohio 2914Reinel v. Butler Cty. Aud. (2018)
Core Terms: public record court of claims R.C. 2743.75 R.C. 149.43 request for information. Overview: Requester sought the method of calculation of property tax and for the public office to identify where he had made an alleged statement. The special master found that both requests were for information or answers to questions, rather than requests for specific existing records. The special master recommended that the court deny the claim for relief.
- 2018 Ohio 2916State v. Sims (2018)
speedy trial tolled murder manifest weight.
- 2018 Ohio 2917Penalosa v. Larose (2018)
Habeas corpus failure to file commitment papers failure to file affidavit of prior civil actions state court of appeals lacks jurisdiction over federal inmates dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 2918Anderson v. Larose (2018)
Habeas corpus failure to file commitment papers failure to file affidavit of prior civil actions state court of appeals lacks jurisdiction over federal inmates dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 2921State v. Taylor (2018)
Confrontation Clause – dying declaration – sufficiency of the evidence – manifest weight of the evidence – felony murder
- 2018 Ohio 2922State v. Tilley (2018)
Criminal: waiver of right to counsel Crim.R. 32.3(B) & (D) Crim.R. 44(C) court costs.
- 2018 Ohio 2923E. Mfg. Corp. v. Testa (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Use tax—Board of Tax Appeals correctly determined that manufacturer does not qualify for exemption from use tax under R.C. 5739.011(C)(5)'s exception for total environmental regulation of a "special and limited area" of the facility or for either R.C. 5739.011(B)(4)'s general exemption for items used in a manufacturing operation or R.C. 5739.011(B)(8)'s specific exemption for gas used in a manufacturing operation—Board of Tax Appeals' decision affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2927In re Resignation of Skelton (2018)
Attorneys at law—Resignation with disciplinary action pending—Gov.Bar R. VI(11)(C).
- 2018 Ohio 2929State v. Norman (2018)
R.C. 2929.11 R.C. 2929.12 felony sentencing purposes and principles Crim.R. 32.1 motion to withdraw guilty plea. The trial court's imposition of an 11-year prison sentence was within the permissible statutory range for first-degree felonies, and the trial court considered the purposes and principles of felony sentencing set forth in R.C. 2929.11 and the seriousness and recidivism factors in R.C. 2929.12. Thus, the sentence was not contrary to law. The trial court's denial of defendant's motion to withdraw his guilty plea was not error because the defendant failed to demonstrate that he was actually innocent and failed to demonstrate that he did not enter his guilty plea voluntarily, intelligently and knowingly.
- 2018 Ohio 2930State v. McGowan (2018)
Consecutive sentence R.C. 2929.14(C)(4) statutory findings R.C. 2953.08 recommended sentence. The trial court made the statutorily required findings necessary to impose consecutive sentences under R.C. 2929.14(C)(4), and the findings were clearly and convincingly supported by the record. The defendant had notice that the trial court could deviate from the agreed recommended sentence, therefore, he could not have had a reasonable expectation that the trial court could only impose the agreed recommended sentence.
- 2018 Ohio 2932State v. Nicholson (2018)
Motion to withdraw guilty plea res judicata retained counsel. Issues raised in postsentence motion to withdraw guilty plea were res judicata because they were raised and rejected in earlier petition to vacate conviction.
- 2018 Ohio 2933State v. Davenport (2018)
Ineffective assistance of counsel, not guilty by reason of insanity, R.C. 2901.04(A)(14).
- 2018 Ohio 2934State v. Robertson (2018)
Hearsay Evid.R. 801(C) Evid.R. 802 explanation of investigation harmless error manifest weight of the evidence. Although detective's testimony regarding what victim told him about his encounter with defendant likely went beyond what is permissible in describing the steps in an investigation, in light of other evidence presented, there was no reasonable possibility that the improper testimony contributed to defendant's convictions such that the admission of the testimony was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt. Defendant's convictions were not against the weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 2935Salvati v. Anthony-Lee Screen Printing, Inc. (2018)
Negligence independent contractor frequenter open and obvious. Owner of premises had no duty to warn independent contractor of dangers posed by unguarded fan because the evidence showed that the independent contractor was aware of the unguarded fan and nevertheless put his hand into the fan to check to see if the fan was operating.
- 2018 Ohio 2936State v. Freeman (2018)
Res judicata sentencing firearms specification. Court does not err by overruling a postconviction motion challenging a sentence as it relates to a firearms specification when the defendant could have asserted the challenge on direct appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 2937Cleveland v. Williams (2018)
R.C. 2945.67 Cleveland Codified Ordinances 605.11 fare evasion Fourth Amendment constitutional questions constitutional avoidance.
- 2018 Ohio 2938State v. Smith (2018)
Motion to correct void judgment aggravated murder kidnapping inconsistent verdicts res judicata consecutive sentences. Appellant's argument that a finding of not guilty of a felony murder specification resulted in an acquittal of aggravated murder is barred by res judicata. Appellant's argument that his sentences should be vacated because the trial court failed to impose mandatory consecutive sentences is meritless because the trial court imposed consecutive sentences.
- 2018 Ohio 2941Gutierrez-Gordillo v. Tomo Hibachi Rest. & Lounge, L.L.C. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 2954State ex rel. White v. Woods (2018)
The court overrules relator's objections and adopts the magistrate's decision recommending dismissal of relator's mandamus/procedendo action. Relator had a prior and adequate remedy at law which he exercised in a prior appeal to this court.
- 2018 Ohio 2956Vos v. Ohio Environmental Protection Agency (2018)
The Court of Claims did not err in dismissing appellants' complaint for failure to state a claim pursuant to Civ.R. 12(B)(6). There is no private cause of action for the alleged violations of agency regulations.
- 2018 Ohio 2957Tobin v. Steptoe & Johnson, P.L.L.C. (2018)
The trial court did not err in granting summary judgment in favor of appellee. Appellant's legal malpractice claim against the law firm necessarily fails because appellant did not sue any individual attorney and because the claim is barred by the applicable statute of limitations. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2958Yu v. Ohio State Univ. Med. Ctr. v. Pacific Interpreters, Inc. (2018)
Local rules of the Court of Claims of Ohio governed the timeliness of a notice of appeal filed in that court. Motion to dismiss granted due to notice of appeal being untimely filed.
- 2018 Ohio 2959State v. Littlepage (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW/JURISDICTION—POSTCONVICTION—GRAND JURY: The common pleas court properly declined, because it had no jurisdiction, to grant the relief sought in defendant's postconviction motions: the trial court's failure to make sentencing findings was neither reviewable under any postconviction proceeding provided by statute or rule, nor correctable under a court's jurisdiction to correct a void judgment and R.C. 2939.19 and Crim.R. 6(E) did not confer upon the common pleas court jurisdiction to order disclosure of grand-jury proceedings, when no proceeding within that court's jurisdiction was pending. The court of appeals dismissed for lack of jurisdiction the appeals from the common pleas court's judgments overruling defendant's postconviction motions challenging the trial court's failure to make sentencing findings and seeking disclosure of grand-jury proceedings, because those judgments were not reviewable under the jurisdiction conferred upon an intermediate appeals court by R.C. 2953.02 or 2953.08 to review a judgment of conviction entered in a criminal case, by R.C. 2953.23(B) to review an order denying postconviction relief, or by R.C. 2505.03(A) to review, affirm, modify, or reverse a "final order, judgment or decree."
- 2018 Ohio 2960State v. Thorton (2018)
OVI – PROBABLE CAUSE – SEARCH AND SEIZURE: The trial court erred by granting defendant's motion to suppress evidence where sufficient indicia of impairment existed to cause an objectively reasonable police officer to conclude that defendant was operating a motor vehicle while under the influence of alcohol, including defendant's (1) erratic driving (2) slow response, lethargy, confusion, and disorientation (3) odor of alcohol about him (4) slurred and slow speech (5) bloodshot and watery eyes (6) repeated attempts to open a locked glove compartment with the wrong key (7) admission to the consumption of alcohol and (8) demonstrating four out of six clues of impairment on the HGN test, two out of eight clues of impairment on the walk-and-turn test, and two out of four clues of impairment on the one-leg-stand test.
- 2018 Ohio 2961In Re: The S Children (2018)
CHILDREN – CUSTODY – APPELLATE REVIEW – JURISDICTION – EVIDENCE – PROCEDURE/RULES – JUV.R. 45(B) – CIV.R. 41(B)(2): The juvenile court's judgment dismissing the Hamilton County Department of Job and Family Services' complaint for permanent custody was made in a special proceeding and affected a substantial right of the children and the children's guardian ad litem under R.C. 2505.02(B)(2). Immediate review of the juvenile court's order is necessary to ensure that, if the trial court did err in returning the children to their parents, the children are protected from physical harm and abuse, because the infliction of harm on the children would obviously be irreparable. Although the children's siblings remain subjects of the state's complaint and there was no Civ.R. 54(B) certification, the appellate court has jurisdiction under App.R. 4(B)(5) to hear the appeal: App.R. 4(B)(5) specifically contemplates an immediate appeal where there has been an order that affects a substantial right made in a special proceeding, but there has been no Civ.R. 54(B) certification. The trial court properly converted the parents' summary-judgment motion to a motion to dismiss the custody complaint under Civ.R. 41(B)(2): the Ohio Rules of Juvenile Procedure do not provide for a motion for summary judgment, and Juv.R. 45(B) allowed the trial court the discretion to recast the motion. The trial court's judgment determining that the children were not neglected under R.C. 2151.03(A)(2) was not against the manifest weight of the evidence: the trial court did not err in affording little weight to the children's medical records without expert testimony explaining the significance of the records to the state's allegation that the children lacked adequate parental care. The trial court erroneously concluded that R.C. 2151.04(C) required evidence of direct harm, and that the mere presence of the children in a home where a sibling had been abused was insufficient as a matter of law to prove dependency under that section. Where there was sufficient evidence that, if believed by the trial court, would support a dependency adjudication under R.C. 2151.04(C), the trial court erred by failing to consider the facts of the case under that section.
- 2018 Ohio 2962State v. Hildebrand (2018)
SEX OFFENSES–REGISTRATION: Where the trial court did not include in the judgment of conviction defendant's tier sex-offender classification under Ohio's Adam Walsh Act, that sanction was never imposed, and there was no order in place requiring defendant to register as a sex offender therefore, defendant had no duty to register as a Tier I sex offender, and his conviction for failing to notify the sheriff of an address change must be reversed and the defendant must be discharged.
- 2018 Ohio 296327795 (2018)
The trial court did not err by adopting the magistrate's decision granting Appellee restitution of the apartment in which Appellant is living. Appellant failed to properly file objections to the magistrate's decision and fails to show plain error. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2965State v. Cooper (2018)
The trial court did not err by dismissing Appellant's claims against Appellee under Civ.R. 12(B)(6). The claims all concerned Appellant's prior criminal case, and they were all barred by res judicata. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2966State v. Milum (2018)
Defendant's conviction for unauthorized use of a vehicle (possession more than 48 hours) was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2967State v. Owensby (2018)
The trial court did not err in overruling Appellant's petition for post-conviction relief because the petition was untimely and the claims asserted therein either lacked merit or were not cognizable in post-conviction proceedings. In addition, Appellant's claim that the post-conviction process is unconstitutional because it does not grant a petitioner the right to conduct discovery also lacks merit, as it is well established that post-conviction review is not a constitutional right and that a non-capital petitioner is not entitled to discovery in post-conviction proceedings. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2968Perrucci v. Whittington (2018)
Appellant Perrucci is a supplier within the meaning of the Consumer Sales Practices Act. The trial court did not err in qualifying James Hellman as an expert in carpentry. Appellant breached his contract with Appellee and failed to complete repairs to Appellee's mobile home in a workmanlike manner following water damage to the home. The trial court correctly calculated Appellee's damages. The court did not err in sustaining Appellee's objection to the testimony of a lay witness regarding Hellman's conclusions that the repairs to the mobile home were not done in a workmanlike manner. The trial court did not err in awarding attorney's fees. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2969Shaw v. Access Ohio (2018)
Plaintiffs-appellants, who are mother and daughter, were employed by Defendant-appellee. Defendant-appellee terminated mother and daughter, resulting in the filing of a complaint alleging that their respective terminations were unlawful. The trial court did not err in granting summary judgment against the daughter because she did not establish, through either direct or circumstantial evidence, a prima facie case that the termination decision was based upon her race. Further, the trial court, turning to the mother's case, did not err in dismissing her cause of action under Civ.R. 12(B)(6), because a termination based upon a family relationship, the only termination reason set forth in the complaint, is not, under R.C. 4112.02 or otherwise, an unlawful employment decision. Finally, the trial court did not abuse its discretion by not allowing the mother to amend the complaint. Judgment affirmed. (Froelich, J., concurring.)
- 2018 Ohio 2970Silvers v. Clay Twp. Police Dept. (2018)
Upon remand from the federal district court, trial court did not err in granting summary judgment to defendants on plaintiff's claims of common law sexual harassment, intentional infliction of emotional distress, and negligent hiring and/or retention. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2971Upkins v. Brosh (2018)
The propriety of the dismissal of Appellant's complaint for malicious prosecution should have been raised on a direct appeal. The denial of his motion for Civ.R. 60(B) relief is affirmed. (Froelich, J., concurring.)
- 2018 Ohio 2972State v. Williams (2018)
Defendant's guilty plea precluded him from challenging the trial court's ruling on his pretrial motion to suppress. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2975State v. Macklin (2018)
Reasonable Suspicion to Conduct Field Sobriety Tests
- 2018 Ohio 2976Coykendall v. Lucas Cty. Dog Warden (2018)
Trial court properly rejected appellant's classification of appellee's dog as a dangerous dog where appellant failed to demonstrate that the dog acted without provocation under R.C. 9511(1)(a).
- 2018 Ohio 2977State v. Buford (2018)
Anders brief filed pre-Wenner. No merit to potential assignments of error counsel's request to withdraw granted.
- 2018 Ohio 2979State v. Dyer (2018)
Anders brief. Counsel failed to comply with the requirements of Anders and 6th Dist.Loc.App.R. 10(G).
- 2018 Ohio 2980Neuendorff v. Gibbons (2018)
The trial court properly dismissed appellant's action challenging Toledo City Council's grant of a special use permit to a non-residential drug and alcohol rehabilitation facility where appellant lacked standing.
- 2018 Ohio 2981Toledo v. Reese (2018)
The trial court properly denied appellant's motion to suppress because the trooper had probable cause to stop appellant for a traffic violation and reasonable suspicion to conduct field sobriety tests. The prosecutor's statements in closing argument did not rise to the level of plain error. The trial court failed to comply with Crim.R. 32(A)(1) by not addressing appellant at sentencing to ask if he wanted to make a statement on his behalf, but the error was harmless.
- 2018 Ohio 2982Schroeder v. Meyers (2018)
Trial court properly determined testamentary intent and identity of probate document. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 2983State v. Stanford (2018)
Appellant's aiding and abetting/trafficking convictions were supported by sufficient evidence and were not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Confidential informant credibility ineffective assistance of counsel hearsay.
- 2018 Ohio 2984State v. Davis (2018)
Anders brief filed pre-Wenner. No merit to potential assignments of error counsel's request to withdraw granted. PSI report. Aggravated Robbery. Alford plea. No merit to pro se assignments of error. Ineffective assistance of counsel.
- 2018 Ohio 2985State v. Pryor (2018)
JUVENILE – BINDOVER – PROCEDURE/RULES: In a discretionary-transfer proceeding, the juvenile court complied with R.C. 2152.12 and Juv.R. 30(G) where the juvenile court orally stated at the amenability hearing its specific reasons for transferring the juvenile's case to common pleas court.
- 2018 Ohio 2986Toledo v. Byrd (2018)
In a criminal damaging conviction, lack of documentary evidence to establish amount of damages for purposes of restitution is irrelevant to the question of guilt, which must be decided by the evidence produced at trial. Appellant's conviction is not against the manifest weight of the evidence where the homeowner and another person witnessed appellant banging and kicking at the glass screen door, causing it to break.
- 2018 Ohio 2988Disciplinary Counsel v. Engel. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct—Two-year license suspension with 18 months of the suspension stayed.
- 2018 Ohio 2990Disciplinary Counsel v. Skolnick. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct—One-year license suspension with six months of the suspension stayed on condition.
- 2018 Ohio 2991Bartchak v. Columbia Twp. (2018)
political subdivision immunity, R.C. 2744.02, obstruction, in repair, design, Civ.R. 56
- 2018 Ohio 2992State v. Hoffman (2018)
R.C. 4301.69(B) underage drinking misdemeanor sentencing R.C. 2929.22
- 2018 Ohio 2993In re D.T. (2018)
aggrieved party – relief requested
- 2018 Ohio 2994State v. Jaeger (2018)
speedy trial, R.C. 2945.71, R.C. 2923.32, sufficiency, manifest weight
- 2018 Ohio 2995State v. Lawless (2018)
petition for post-conviction relief, untimely, R.C. 2953.21, R.C. 2953.23
- 2018 Ohio 2996State v. May (2018)
Allied offenses of similar import, waived, forfeited, plain error
- 2018 Ohio 2997Thomas v. Lorain Metro Hous. Auth. (2018)
political subdivision – immunity – water meter crock – lid – proprietary function – governmental function – summary judgment – immunity appeal – R.C. 2744.02
- 2018 Ohio 2998State v. Weaver (2018)
R.C. 2945.38 – R.C. 2945.39 – commitment proceedings – intellectual disability – mental illness – substantial disorder – psychiatric diagnosis – subject to institutionalization – kidnapping – sexual motivation
- 2018 Ohio 3000State v. Grater (2018)
Defendants-appellants' convictions for violating a township's zoning resolution are not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Defendants-appellants waived arguments that a township's zoning resolution is void for vagueness and deprived them of equal protection. Defendants-appellants were not fined in excess of the maximum fine permitted under R.C. 519.99. By failing to raise the issue of selective prosecution in a pre-trial motion, defendants-appellants waived the defense of selective prosecution.
- 2018 Ohio 3001State v. Heimberger (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion by denying the defendant-appellant's witness to testify as an expert or lay witness. Further, the stop of the defendant-appellant was based upon a reasonable suspicion and her statements made to the arresting officer were not in violation of her constitutional rights. Lastly, the jury's verdict was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3002State v. Dukes (2018)
The trial court's comments made while admitting an exhibit into evidence did not prejudice the appellant. Further, the conviction of the appellant was not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 3004Bennett v. Scotts Miracle-Gro (2018)
Trial court's determination that claimant did not meet his burden to establish that he had asbestosis for workers' compensation claim affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3005State v. Bradley (2018)
The trial court did not err in denying appellant's post conviction motion for a new trial. The judgment of the trial court is affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3006State v. Shoe (2018)
Defendant-appellant's obstructing-official-business conviction is supported by sufficient evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 3007State v. Hunter (2018)
Trial court did not err in sentencing defendant to 15 years in prison for involuntary manslaughter with a discharging a firearm form a motor vehicle specification.
- 2018 Ohio 3008State v. Greer (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3009State v. Meyer (2018)
Trial court did not err by denying petitioner's motion for postconviction relief where his arguments could have been raised on direct appeal and are therefore barred by res judicata.
- 2018 Ohio 3011Russell v. Warden, Lebanon Corr. Inst. (2018)
Trial court did not err by dismissing an inmate's petition for declaratory judgment where the inmate's complaint failed to state a claim entitled to relief and his action is now moot, as he is located in a different corrections facility.
- 2018 Ohio 3012North Kingsville v. Beals (2018)
APPELLATE PROCEDURE - appellant's appellate brief does not comply with the Ohio Rules of Appellate Procedure her brief does not contain a table of cases, statutes, and other authorities cited, with references to the pages of the brief where cited a statement of facts supported by references to the record or a separate argument, with citations to legal authority in support of each assignment of error in violation of App.R. 12(A)(2), 16(A)(2), and (7) based on appellant's serious violations of the Ohio Rules of Appellate Procedure, this court is well within its authority to summarily affirm the trial court's judgment.
- 2018 Ohio 3013State v. Long (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - EVIDENCE - limitations on cross-examination Confrontation Clause guarantees only an opportunity for effective cross-examination trial courts may impose reasonable limits on cross-examination standard of review determined by the nature of the limitation Evid.R. 611 Evid.R. 616 proffer manifest weight. ALLIED OFFENSES - R.C. 2941.25 two counts of Aggravated Burglary R.C. 2911.11(A) is not meant to criminalize an offender's conduct toward the occupants of the structure separate victims single trespass trial court failed to merge.
- 2018 Ohio 3015State v. Goodman (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - court costs motion to waive or defer court costs R.C. 2947.23(C) gives trial courts jurisdiction to consider waiving court costs even after sentencing thus, regardless of when court costs were imposed, the defendant may ask trial court to waive costs since appellant could have asked trial court to waive court costs in his prior motion for payment plan, but failed to do so, his present motion to waive costs is barred by res judicata.
- 2018 Ohio 3016Unifund CCR Partners v. Piaser (2018)
CIV.R. 23 - class action defendant sought class certification for time bar class, alleging plaintiff-debt-collector filed action against her and class members that was time barred while trial court's finding that the account agreement was a written contract (thus making the plaintiff's claim timely-filed) seems definitive, the court's additional finding that a fact question exists as to whether the account agreement applies to defendant casts doubt on whether such is the case court's judgment is ambiguous and thus court must detemine on remand whether the account agreement is a written contract for purposes of statute of limitations.
- 2018 Ohio 3017Disciplinary Counsel v. Mancino. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—When a professional-conduct rule found by the Board of Professional Conduct to be violated requires that an attorney-client relationship exist and no such relationship existed, the finding of a violation cannot be accepted—When a panel of the Board of Professional Conduct unanimously dismisses a count of a disciplinary complaint for insufficient evidence under Gov.Bar R. V(12)(G), the dismissal is not reviewable by the board or by the Supreme Court of Ohio—Complaint dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 3018State ex rel. Evans v. McGrath (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Mandamus and prohibition—Court of Claims did not fail to comply with an appellate court's mandate—Court of Appeals' judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3020State v. Pandey (2018)
Personal liability for LLC
- 2018 Ohio 3021Moore v. Michalski (2018)
Attorney fees for legal malpractice case are not recoverable as damages
- 2018 Ohio 3024State v. Fryer (2018)
Post conviction relief/Subject matter jurisdiction
- 2018 Ohio 3027State v. Ross (2018)
The trial court's error in admitting evidence of Ross's prior conviction was harmless error, and the trial court did not abuse its discretion in allowing the rebuttal testimony, in admitting into evidence posts made on Facebook, or in instructing the jury.
- 2018 Ohio 3028Am. Water Mgmt. Servs., LLC v. Div. of Oil & Gas Res. Mgmt. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3029Hoffman v. Hoffman (2018)
DEFAULT JUDGMENT – PROCEDURE/RULES – CIV.R. 5 – CIV.R. 55(A): The trial court erred in denying defendants' motions to vacate default judgments entered against them where defendants were not served with the motions for a default judgment or sent notices of the hearing on the motions despite having appeared in the action, in violation of Civ.R. 5 and Civ.R. 55(A).
- 2018 Ohio 3030Banker's Choice, L.L.C. v. Zoning Bd. of Appeals & Cincinnati (2018)
ADMINISTRATIVE MISCELLANEOUS – APPELLATE REVIEW/CIVIL – STANDARD OF REVIEW – ZONING: A court of appeals' review of an administrative appeal under R.C. 2506.04 is a limited one focused on the existence of legal error in the trial court the appeals court's authority is limited to reviewing the common pleas court's decision on questions of law only, does not encompass that court's power to weigh the evidence, and permits reversal only when the court of common pleas errs in its application or interpretation of the law or its decision is unsupported by a preponderance of the evidence as a matter of law. Pursuant to Civ.R. 53(D)(4)(d), when a trial court rules on objections to a magistrate's decision, the court must undertake an independent review as to the objected matters, thus when, in exercising its independent review, the trial court's judgment has modified the magistrate's decision and conflicts with it to such a degree by rejecting important factual findings that underpin the magistrate's decision, by employing its new factual findings in its analysis, and by choosing not to reach the magistrate's legal holding regarding constitutional issues, the magistrate's decision and the trial court's judgment cannot be read together as one judgment. [But see DISSENT: Where the trial court cited the proper factors to consider when reviewing the magistrate's decision and the proper standard of review to apply when considering the decision of the administrative agency and the decision of its magistrate, the trial court's decision, based in part on its own analysis and in part on its agreement with the substantial analysis already conducted by the magistrate, may be read together to render the trial court's judgment sufficiently complete to permit this court to affirm under the limited legal-error analysis provided by R.C. 2506.04.]
- 2018 Ohio 3031Evans v. Akron Gen. Med. Ctr. (2018)
Civ.R. 56, summary judgment, Civ.R. 15(D), statute of limitations, relation back, "unnamed defendants", waiver of affirmative defense, insufficiency of process, negligent hiring, supervision, and retention, direct liability, vicarious liability
- 2018 Ohio 3032State v. Greene (2018)
felonious assault – having a weapon under disability – police officer – lay testimony – expert testimony – harmless error – post-release control – void
- 2018 Ohio 3033State v. Mackim (2018)
OVI – motion to suppress – community caretaking function – reasonable suspicion to administer field sobriety tests – probable cause to arrest –– findings of fact – competent, credible evidence – incorrect facts – incomplete facts
- 2018 Ohio 3035Hale v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. (2018)
Summary judgment - ACD - proximate cause - negligence per se
- 2018 Ohio 3040State v. Reed (2018)
Crim.R. 11(C) guilty plea ineffective assistance of counsel. Defendant-appellant's convictions for attempted felonious assault, abduction, and domestic violence affirmed. Defendant's argument that his plea was not knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily made was unpersuasive. The trial court substantially complied with the requirement under Crim.R. 11(C)(2)(a) to determine that the defendant is voluntarily making his plea with understanding of the nature of the charges and of the maximum penalty involved. The trial court was not required under Crim.R. 11 to determine that the defendant understood the merger doctrine. Defendant's ineffective assistance claim was unpersuasive because defendant failed to establish that defense counsel's performance fell below an objective standard of reasonable representation that caused his guilty plea to be less than knowing, intelligent, and voluntary.
- 2018 Ohio 3041State v. Lester (2018)
Sufficiency of the evidence accomplice liability manifest weight of the evidence fruit of unconstitutional seizure confrontation clause ineffective assistance of counsel. Judgment affirmed. The state presented sufficient evidence to convict defendant on accomplice liability grounds even though codefendants were not convicted of same crimes because it is not required that the person with whom the accused was in complicity with has to be convicted as a principal offender. Defendant's convictions are not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Defense counsel was not ineffective for not moving to suppress the gun because defendant was not under arrest at the time the officer discovered the gun. Defendant was not denied his right to confrontation when defense counsel did not object to expert's testimony, which was based on test results performed by someone else. Out of court statements that are related by the expert solely for the purpose of explaining the assumptions on which that opinion rests are not offered for their truth and, thus, fall outside the scope of the Confrontation Clause.
- 2018 Ohio 3042Dean v. Liberty Mut. Ins. (2018)
Summary judgment race discrimination promissory estoppel overtime hours discovery motions. Trial court erred by granting summary judgment to defendant-employer regarding employee's race discrimination claim, because there are genuine issues of material fact. Summary judgment was properly granted to employer regarding employee's promissory estoppel and violation of Minimum Fair Wage Standards Act claims. Court did not abuse its discretion in denying plaintiff's motion to compel discovery.
- 2018 Ohio 3043State v. Houston (2018)
Murder, manifest weight, ineffective assistance of counsel, confrontation clause, mandatory consecutive sentence. Appellant's conviction for murder was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Alleged tactical errors by this trial counsel did not amount to ineffective assistance of counsel because he suffered no prejudice. The trial court erred at sentencing where the record reflected that the court was operating under in the incorrect belief that it was statutorily required to order appellant's conviction for attempted failure to comply to be served consecutively to his other sentences.
- 2018 Ohio 3045Sosnoswsky v. Koscianski (2018)
<p> ON RECONSIDERATION: </p>
- 2018 Ohio 3046In re: Grand Jury Subpoena of Byrd (2018)
Grand jury subpoena, exception to mootness doctrine, Crim.R. 17, R.C. 2939.12. Appellant's motion to quash a grand jury subpoena was properly declared to be moot because the subpoena had already been executed and the relief requested by appellant had been granted and implemented. Appellant could not meet both prongs of the test for an exception to the mootness doctrine.
- 2018 Ohio 3047State v. Young (2018)
Search and seizure, manifest weight of the evidence, inconsistent verdicts, disproportionate sentences, merger, firearm specification, weapon while under disability. The officers had probable cause to stop appellant's vehicle for committing a traffic offense and to search the vehicle after observing drugs and guns in plain view and the verdict was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. The exoneration of appellant's codefendant did not constitute an inconsistent verdict. Sentences between two codefendants are not disproportionate where one defendant is determined to be not guilty. A firearm specification and the charge of having a weapon while under disability are not allied offenses.
- 2018 Ohio 3048State v. Austin (2018)
Child endangering R.C. 2919.22(A) sufficiency of evidence manifest weight of evidence flight instruction consecutive sentences. Defendant's conviction for child endangering in violation of R.C. 2919.22(A) was supported by sufficient evidence and not against the manifest weight of the evidence where, even if the jury found that the defendant did not cause the child's life-threatening injuries, the jury could have reasonably found that the defendant failed to protect the child from such injuries sustained while in his care trial court's flight instruction, although improper, was not prejudicial error trial court erred in denying defendant's motion for a new trial because the trial court had no jurisdiction to rule on the motion while defendant's appeal was pending trial court made the necessary findings to impose consecutive sentences.
- 2018 Ohio 3049State v. Herrington (2018)
Preindictment delay, actual prejudice, speculation, manifest weight, DNA evidence, credibility, effective assistance of counsel, independent expert, consecutive sentences, moot. Defendant failed to demonstrate actual prejudice in his motion to dismiss for preindictment delay because he only presented speculative reasoning. Defendant's convictions were not against the manifest weight of the evidence because DNA evidence linked the defendant to the victim, and weighing the evidence and evaluating credibility rests with the trier of fact. Counsel was not ineffective for failing to consult with or obtain an independent expert to evaluate the DNA evidence. Counsel's decision to instead employ rigorous cross-examination of the state's expert may have been tactical. Defendant's consecutive sentence challenge is moot because the sentence was ordered consecutive to the life-without-parole sentence he was already serving.
- 2018 Ohio 3054State ex rel. Tri Eagle Fuels L.L.C. v. Dawson (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3061State v. Nelson (2018)
In a trial with both the judge and a jury as trier of fact on separate charges, the verdicts on the separate charges do not have to correspond.
- 2018 Ohio 3062U.S. Bank Trust, N.A. v. Kerwood (2018)
Appellants appeal the granting of summary judgment, arguing that the bank failed to show that it was the holder of the note and mortgage. The bank was able to present an affidavit of employee with sufficient personal knowledge of the transaction that summary judgment was properly granted. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3063State ex rel. Steele v. McIntosh (2018)
A writ of procedendo is not appropriate to compel a judge to do an act already performed.
- 2018 Ohio 3066State v. Black (2018)
The trial court did not err by overruling Appellant's motion to suppress the handgun found in his vehicle and his statements related to the presence of the handgun. A computer check revealed the appellant had an Ohio carrying concealed weapon permit, and he had an Oklahoma nationwide-radius felony arrest warrant. Once handcuffed and in custody, the police officer's questions to Appellant about whether Appellant had anything dangerous in the vehicle did not violate Miranda. Appellant was statutorily required to inform the officer he had a handgun in the vehicle. Also, under the public-safety exception to Miranda, in the circumstances of this case, the officer's questions were objectively reasonable and related to the immediate potential danger from a firearm. The officer was not required to give Appellant Miranda warnings before asking him about a dangerous item in the vehicle. Judgment affirmed. (Donovan, J., dissenting.)
- 2018 Ohio 3067State v. Brammer (2018)
The nine-year sentence imposed upon the appellant was within the permissible statutory range and therefore not contrary to law. The record establishes that the trial court properly considered and applied R.C. 2929.11, which governs the overriding purposes of felony sentencing, and R.C. 2929.12 which sets forth the seriousness and recidivism factors for the court to consider in imposing sentence. The trial court did not abuse its discretion when it ordered appellant to pay a mandatory fine of $20,000.00. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3068State v. Brown (2018)
Appellant's felonious assault conviction was supported by sufficient evidence and was not against the manifest weight of the evidence, as the evidence established that Appellant knowingly caused the victim to suffer serious physical harm. In addition, under the circumstances of this case, the trial court's failure to sua sponte instruct the jury on aggravated assault as an alternative to felonious assault does not amount to plain error since the record indicates that Appellant proceeded solely on the theory of self-defense at trial. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3069State v. Harris-Smith (2018)
Sufficient evidence supported Appellant's conviction for falsification. The evidence established that Appellant knowingly made a false statement with the purpose to mislead a public official in performing the public official's official function Appellant falsely certified that her two intact dogs were spayed and neutered to the deputy auditor in the course of obtaining dangerous dog certificates. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3072State v. Ramey (2018)
The trial court, following a jury trial, merged certain counts resulting in the Defendant-appellant being convicted and sentenced for murder (proximate cause of felonious assault) and aggravated burglary (physical harm). Since Defendant-appellant's commission of felonious assault – with the felonious assault being necessary to the murder conviction – is the aggravating element that made the burglary an aggravated, as opposed to simple, burglary, the offenses of murder (proximate cause of felonious assault) and aggravated burglary are allied offenses of similar import subject to merger. The trial court, accordingly, erred by not merging the two offenses. The record does not support a conclusion that during deliberations the jury had incorrect jury instructions. The trial court's decision to give a "castle doctrine" instruction that the victim did not have a duty to retreat from his home was an accurate statement of law, and, given the circumstances of the case, the instruction was not an abuse of discretion. Defendant-appellant, given the facts of the case, was not entitled to a voluntary manslaughter instruction. Defendant-appellant, therefore, was not prejudiced by any error regarding the trial court's voluntary manslaughter instruction. Finally, the jury's rejection of Defendant-appellant's self-defense claim was not against the manifest weight of the evidence, and the State produced sufficient evidence that Defendant-appellant trespassed into the victim's home. Judgment reversed in part, affirmed in part, and remanded for re-sentencing. (Hall, J., concurring in part and dissenting in part.)
- 2018 Ohio 3075Tax Ease Ohio, L.L.C. v. Lucas (2018)
Appellant's alleged inability to pay real estate taxes is not a defense to a forfeiture proceeding brought under R.C. 5721.40. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3076State v. White (2018)
Defendant's convictions for unlawful sexual conduct with a minor (10 or more years older than the victim), two counts of trafficking in persons, and two counts of compelling prostitution in furtherance of human trafficking were based on sufficient evidence and were not against the manifest weight of the evidence. The State concedes, and we agree, that defendant's conviction for pandering obscenity involving a minor was based on insufficient evidence because the photographs were not obscene. The trial court did not err in denying defendant's motion to suppress statements made at the police station following Miranda warnings. Defendant waived his Miranda rights, and his statements were made voluntarily. Defendant forfeited his void-for-vagueness constitutional challenge to R.C. 2905.32(A)(2)(a), the trafficking in persons statute. Even if we were to consider his argument regarding the "less than sixteen years of age" language, we would not find it to be vague. The record fails to demonstrate ineffective assistance of counsel or that the prosecutors engaged in misconduct by offering the testimony of defendant's co-defendant. Judgment reversed as to the charge of pandering obscenity involving a minor. In all other respects, judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3077State v. Wiles (2018)
The trial court did not err by imposing a six-month jail term as part of Appellant's community-control sentence. The trial court's questions about the facts underlying Appellant's past criminal cases, which were ultimately dismissed, and Appellant's denials did not demonstrate the trial court was improperly punishing her for those crimes. Judgment affirmed. (Donovan, J., concurring.)
- 2018 Ohio 3078Wilhelm v. Coverstone (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3079State v. Norris (2018)
Post conviction relief
- 2018 Ohio 3080State v. Straley (2018)
Criminal: post-sentence motion to withdraw guilty plea Crim.R. 32.1 res judicata void sentence manifest injustice.
- 2018 Ohio 3083State v. Bonner (2018)
Trial court erroneously allowed the state to treat its witness as a hostile witness in order to elicit identification evidence, but such error was harmless in light of the remaining identification evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 3084State v. Dornoff (2018)
Criminal. Rape. Felonious assault. Kidnapping. Sexual offender classification. Guilty Plea. Crim.R. 11. R.C. Chapter 2950.
- 2018 Ohio 3087Khaledi v. Nickris Properties, Inc. (2018)
In a dispute involving a home construction contract, the trial court did not abuse its discretion when it stayed the matter pending arbitration. R.C. Chapter 2711 waiver ambiguous unconscionable civil
- 2018 Ohio 3088State v. Kubat (2018)
Anders no-merit, sentencing, consecutive sentences
- 2018 Ohio 3089State v. Lamb (2018)
Criminal, manifest weight, sufficiency of the evidence, aggravated arson, credibility, circumstantial evidence, jury, cost of court-appointed counsel
- 2018 Ohio 3090State v. Valiente-Mendoza (2018)
Criminal. Trial court did not err in denying appellant's motion to suppress where encounter with law enforcement was consensual and later became supported by reasonable, articulable suspicion of criminal activity. Appellant, a native Spanish speaker, was properly provided with two Supreme Court certified interpreters.
- 2018 Ohio 3099McConnell v. Dudley (2018)
Motion to certify conflict McConnell v. Dudley, 7th Dist. No. 17 MA 0045, 2017-Ohio-5704, -- N.E.3d --, R.C. 2744.02(B)(1).
- 2018 Ohio 3100In re K.E. (2018)
delinquency case remanded for new dispositional hearing due to the juvenile court's expression of mistaken belief that DYS could reduce minimum sentence DYS cannot reduce minimum sentence imposed by juvenile court alternative contention on abuse of discretion in imposing maximum, consecutive sentences is not ripe.
- 2018 Ohio 3101Bank of America, N.A. v. Truax (2018)
Default judgment Rule 55 Rule 8(D) action on an account abuse of discretion.
- 2018 Ohio 3102State ex rel. Carlson v. State Bd. of Pharmacy (2018)
mandamus state board of pharmacy standing public rights exception R.C. 4729.25 pharmacy board's enforcement and investigation obligation R.C. 4729.26 Ohio Adm.Code 4729-5 rules for pharmacy board's enforcement and investigation obligation enforcement obligation
- 2018 Ohio 3105Wilson v. Larose (2018)
Habeas corpus failure to file commitment papers failure to file affidavit of prior civil actions state court of appeals lacks jurisdiction over federal inmates dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 3106Grand Valley Local School Dist. Bd. of Edn. v. Jack Gibson Constr. Co. (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - trial court judgment can only be reviewed on appeal if it constitutes a final order pursuant to R.C. 2505.02 and Civ.R. 54(B) multiple claims or parties remain pending interlocutory order no mandatory language that there is no just reason for delay lack of a final and appealable order.
- 2018 Ohio 3107Sankey v. Fasano (2018)
CIVIL - failure to prosecute abuse of discretion incarcerated party no constitutional right to be present at trial alternate means of appearance less drastic alternative dismissal without prejudice bias
- 2018 Ohio 3108State v. Weideman (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - jail-time credit R.C. 2967.191 res judicata R.C. 2929.19(B)(2)(g)(iii) continuing jurisdiction consecutive prison terms Ohio Adm. Code 5120-2-04(G).
- 2018 Ohio 3109State ex rel. DeWine v. Osborne Co., Ltd. (2018)
CIVIL - Ohio Environmental Protection Agency U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Water Pollution Control Act Clean Water Act 33 C.F.R. 328.3 Ohio Administrative Code Chapter 3745 Revised Code Chapter 6111 R.C. 6111.04(A) R.C. 6111.07(A) R.C. 6111.99(A) public nuisance pollution direct or indirect violation permits storm water runoff discharge dredged material notice of intent river waters of the state ordinary high water mark floodplain restoration remediation not alleged in the complaint personal liability pierce the corporate veil personal participation theory corporate officer personal benefit.
- 2018 Ohio 3110State v. Fowler (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - felony sentencing consecutive sentences R.C. 2953.08(G)(2) R.C. 2929.14(C)(4) trial court is not required to give reasons supporting its decision to impose consecutive sentences findings supported by the record.
- 2018 Ohio 3112State v. Lair (2018)
Good faith exception to the Fourth Amendment exclusionary rule applied to execution of search warrant.
- 2018 Ohio 3114State v. Bennett (2018)
Failure to confine dog
- 2018 Ohio 3115State v. Blackford (2018)
Motion to Vacate/Nunc Pro Tunc
- 2018 Ohio 3116Warren Cty. Bar Assn. v. Brenner (2018)
On certification of default.
- 2018 Ohio 3119State v. Griffin (2018)
Appellant's conviction was not against the manifest weight of the evidence where the trial court determined that appellant's testimony lacked credibility and where appellant committed his assault out of anger rather than a need to protect himself.
- 2018 Ohio 3120In re H.C. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3121Griffin Contracting & Restoration v. McIntyre (2018)
Trial court's decision finding HSSA inapplicable was not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 3123State v. Porter (2018)
Appellant was improperly given jail-time credit for the time he was on house arrest, overruling this court's previous decision in State v. Fillinger, 12th Dist. Madison No. CA2016-04-015, 2016-Ohio-8455. The trial court, however, properly calculated jail-time credit in regard to not giving appellant credit for the time he was subject to a curfew.
- 2018 Ohio 3124Reid v. Ohio Depart. of Rehab. & Corr. (2018)
Negligence- Another inmate assaulted plaintiff, an inmate in defendant's custody, with a glass shank fashioned from a broken window. After trial, the magistrate found that defendant lacked notice of an impending attack on plaintiff. Plaintiff also failed to establish any policy on defendant's part mandating the replacement of cell window glass and, therefore, plaintiff could not recover for the unreasonable and/or untimely implementation of such a policy, if any. The magistrate recommended judgment for defendant.
- 2018 Ohio 3125Vickers v. Ohio Dept. of Rehab. & Corr. (2018)
Negligence- Other inmates attacked plaintiff's decedent, an inmate in defendant's custody, with baseball bats resulting in his death. On summary judgment, the court found the discretionary immunity doctrine, under which defendant is generally immune from tort liability for policy and procedure decisions, applied to defendant's adoption of policies and procedures relative to the security and management of inmate recreation. The attacking inmates and decedent were properly classified at the same security level and defendant's employees acted in accordance with institutional policies and procedures. Defendant could not be liable for negligent hiring, training or supervision because its employees did not act tortuously. The court granted judgment to defendant.
- 2018 Ohio 3126Electronic Classroom of Tomorrow v. Ohio Dept. of Edn. (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Education—Community schools—Funding of internet- or computer-based community schools ("e-schools")— Ohio Department of Education has authority under R.C. 3314.08 to base funding of an e-school on the duration of student participation—E-schools may be required to provide data documenting the duration of a student's participation—Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3127State v. Lanter (2018)
BURGLARY – JURY INSTRUCTIONS – LESSER-INCLUDED OFFENSE: The trial court is only required to give a jury instruction on a lesser-included offense where: (1) one offense carries a greater penalty than the other, (2) some element of the greater offense is not required by statute to prove the lesser offense, and (3) the greater offense as defined by statute cannot be committed without the lesser offense being committed and the jury could reasonably convict defendant of the lesser-included offense. Receiving stolen property is not a lesser-included offense of burglary.
- 2018 Ohio 3128State ex rel. Keith v. Dept. of Rehab. & Corr. (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Mandamus—Inmate failed to show that his parole record contains false or misleading information that might have adversely affected parole board's consideration of his parole request—Court of appeals' denial of writ affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3129State v. Evans (2018)
JUVENILE – BINDOVER – SPEEDY TRIAL: Where the juvenile was bound over by the juvenile court to the court of common pleas, the speedy-trial time began to run on the day after the juvenile court relinquished jurisdiction. Even though a judgment entry stated that defendant was "[n]ot waiving time," where the continuance was granted at defendant's request the delay caused by the request was not chargeable to the state. Where defendant waived a substantial amount of time, and a substantial amount of time was tolled due to his actions, defendant was tried within the speedy-trial period. Though defendant was not tried for over a year after his arrest on felony charges, his constitutional right to a speedy trial was not violated because much of the delay was caused by his requests for continuances, he did not assert his speedy-trial right until late in the proceedings, and the pretrial incarceration was not oppressive because the length of the delay was attributable to defendant. The juvenile court did not abuse its discretion in transferring jurisdiction to the common pleas court where the juvenile court considered the statutory factors, and its decision was based on the circumstances of the offense, the harm to the victim, and that defendant was awaiting disposition on another felony charge at the time of the offense and was minimizing his role in the offense. Where the record showed that the juvenile court considered a psychological report stating that defendant was amenable to rehabilitation in the juvenile system the juvenile court did not abuse its discretion in transferring jurisdiction to the common pleas court, because the juvenile court was entitled to disagree with the opinion of a medical expert and take into account the severity of the offenses.
- 2018 Ohio 3130State v. Hill (2018)
BURGLARY – EVIDENCE – CONSTITUTIONAL LAW/CRIMINAL – MIRANDA – CUSTODIAL INTERROGATION – OTHER ACTS – COUNSEL – CUMULATIVE ERROR: In a prosecution for burglary in violation of R.C. 2911.12(A)(2), where the state presented evidence that a home was regularly inhabited, the residents were in and out of the home on the day of the burglary, and the residents were temporarily absent at the time of the offense, the state presented sufficient evidence to prove the likely-to-be-present element. A suspect who voluntarily gives information without being asked questions is not subject to custodial interrogation and is not entitled to Miranda warnings. Where defendant voluntarily submitted into evidence videos that contained other-acts evidence, he waived the right to appeal their admissibility. Defense counsel's failure to object to the other-acts evidence did not constitute deficient performance where the case was tried to the bench and defendant failed to establish that the court considered the evidence or that there is a reasonable probability that the result of the trial would have been different absent the evidence. The doctrine of cumulative error is inapplicable where there are not multiple instances of harmless error.
- 2018 Ohio 3133Felix v. Gerth Law Offices, L.L.C. (2018)
Trial court did not err in granting summary judgment in favor of appellees on appellants' claim for legal malpractice.
- 2018 Ohio 31341st Natl. Fin. Servs. v. Ashley (2018)
In a common law motion to vacate judgment on a cognovit note, the party seeking to vacate alleged facts that, if true, would have prevented the court from having subject-matter jurisdiction. Under these circumstances, the trial court improperly placed the burden of proof on the party seeking to vacate the judgment, rather than the party that was invoking the court's jurisdiction.
- 2018 Ohio 3135State v. Greene (2018)
A trial court plainly errs when it sentences a defendant to consecutive sentences for violations of community control without first orally making the findings necessary to dispel the presumption that sentences will be served concurrently, and this constitutes plain error such that it results in prejudice to the substantial rights of the defendant. R.C. 2929.41(A) Crim. R. 52(B).
- 2018 Ohio 3137State v. Arega (2018)
The trial court did not err in denying defendant's postconviction motion to vacate the judgment of conviction.
- 2018 Ohio 3138State v. Oteng (2018)
Where a defendant has been convicted of murder based on the testimony of a single eyewitness that is in conflict with physical and forensic evidence and the testimony of other witnesses, the trial court abused its discretion in denying the defendant leave to amend his postconviction petition with the affidavit of another direct eyewitness to the shooting who averred that the defendant was not the murderer. Arguments about ineffective assistance of counsel based on facts outside the original trial court record about counsel's simultaneous personal criminal proceedings prosecuted by the same party as the one prosecuting the defendant could not have been raised on direct appeal and were thus not foreclosed by res judicata in considering the defendant's postconviction petition.
- 2018 Ohio 3140Lane v. U.S. Bank, N.A. (2018)
Judgment affirmed. The trial court did not err when it applied principles of res judicata to deny the appellant's request for a default judgment or reconsider the dismissal of his action alleging breach of a mortgage loan modification agreement when the issue could have been litigated in a prior foreclosure action.
- 2018 Ohio 3143State v. Allison (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3145State v. Brown (2018)
Post Release Control Res Judicata
- 2018 Ohio 3146Spires v. Marquis (2018)
Writ of Habeas Corpus Denied
- 2018 Ohio 3152Ware v. Dept. of Rehab. & Corr. (2018)
Inmate negligence damages. The magistrate determined that plaintiff was struck in the left calf by a pepper ball and he suffered bruising, tenderness, swelling, and pain. Plaintiff's injuries were temporary in nature and resolved over the course of several weeks. Further, plaintiff failed to establish the proximate cause of any long-term injuries that he claimed to have experienced. The magistrate recommended plaintiff recover damages in the amount of $2,000, plus the $25 filing fee.
- 2018 Ohio 3154The STATE EX REL. O'MALLEY v. COLLIER-WILLIAMS, Judge. (2018)
Mandamus and prohibition—Judge lacked jurisdiction to invalidate a jury waiver and impanel a jury for sentencing only—Writ of prohibition granted.
- 2018 Ohio 3155State ex rel. Sponaugle v. Hein (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Procedendo—Prohibition—Court of appeals correctly dismissed procedendo claim because appellant sought to undo a court order, not to compel judge to issue a ruling—Appellant not entitled to writ of prohibition because he had an adequate remedy at law by way of appeal—Court of appeals' judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3156Boyd v. Kingdom Trust Co. (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Certified question of state law—R.C. 1707.43 does not impose joint and several liability on custodian of a self-directed individual retirement account ("IRA") that purchased illegal securities on behalf and at direction of IRA account holders.
- 2018 Ohio 3158State v. Alghamdi (2018)
unlawful restraint, R.C. 2905.03, sufficiency, manifest weight, Crim.R. 29
- 2018 Ohio 3160State v. Pyle (2018)
rape, gross sexual imposition, sufficiency of the evidence, manifest weight, child competency, Evid. R. 601(A), sexually violent predator specification, R.C. 2971.02(H)(2), ineffective assistance of counsel, cumulative error
- 2018 Ohio 3161State ex rel. Guest v. Husted (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Elections—Mandamus—Writ of mandamus sought to compel secretary of state and county board of elections to place candidate's name on general-election ballot as independent candidate for common-pleas-court judge—Secretary of state did not abuse his discretion in refusing to place candidate's name on the ballot—Writ denied.
- 2018 Ohio 3163Lloyd v. Roosevelt Properties, Ltd. (2018)
Breach of warranty of habitability constructive eviction breach of contract R.C. 5321.04 R.C. 5321.16 R.C. 5321.07 security deposit damages attorney fees manifest weight. The trial court's findings in favor of tenant for breach of the implied warranty of habitability, breach of contract, and constructive eviction were not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Landlord violated R.C. 5321.16(B) by withholding tenant's security deposit. Further, the trial court abused its discretion when it awarded excessive attorney fees pursuant to R.C. 5321.07 and in awarding compensatory damages to tenant.
- 2018 Ohio 3164Tiggs c/o Indian hills Healthcare Group, Inc. v. Ohio Dept. of Job & Family Servs. (2018)
R.C. 5101.35 R.C. 119.12 R.C. Chapter 5163 medicaid eligibility requirements administrative appeal 42 C.F.R. 435.923 Ohio Adm.Code 5160-1-33 authorized representative standing. The trial court did not err in its statutory interpretation when it found an authorized representative had standing to appeal the denial of an individual's medicaid eligibility to the trial court. The administrative agency lacked statutory authority pursuant to R.C. 119.12 to bring its appeal, and this court lacks jurisdiction to consider the agency's appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 3165UBS Fin. servs., Inc. v. Lacava (2018)
Summary judgment Civ.R. 56 charging order R.C. 1705.19 fraudulent transfer venue statute of limitations R.C. 1336.09 R.C. 1336.04 R.C. 1336.07 standing R.C. 1336.08 transferee operating agreement attorney fees R.C. 1705.18 R.C. 1705.081 Civ.R. 3 Civ.R. 12 waiver interested party due process. The trial court properly granted summary judgment in favor of appellee. The trial court did not err in ordering appellant to comply with the charging order. Appellant lacks standing to assert the rights of third parties or to challenge the trial court's judgment in order to protect their rights. Because appellant was not the prevailing party, the trial court did not err in determining that appellee was not required to pay appellant's attorney fees. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying appellant's motion to transfer venue because the record reflects that appellant waived the defense of improper venue. Appellant was an interested party in the trial court proceedings, and thus, the trial court did not err in denying appellant's motion to be removed as a defendant. The trial court's orders on summary judgment did not violate appellant's due process rights.
- 2018 Ohio 3166City of Parma v. Treanor (2018)
Aggravated menacing, domestic violence, threats, self-defense, Castle Doctrine. Trial court erred in refusing to give the jury an instruction on self-defense and the Castle Doctrine. Both defenses are affirmative defenses to offenses where the threat of harm is an element of the offense. The evidence was sufficient to warrant the instructions because the defendant, who was inside his own home, had a reasonable belief of great bodily harm, and that he used a reasonable threat of force to repel what he perceived to be an imminent threat.
- 2018 Ohio 3167State v. McCaughey (2018)
Indictment delay Crim.R. 5(B) motion to dismiss speedy trial R.C. 2945.71(C)(2). Trial court did not err by dismissing indictment on speedy trial grounds. The statutory time for defendant's subsequent felony indictment began to run on the date of defendant's arrest, and the subsequent indictment 13 months after the date of arrest, with no other additional facts, violated defendant's speedy trial rights.
- 2018 Ohio 3168State v. Henderson (2018)
Jail-time credit R.C. 2967.191 confinement community-based correctional facility consecutive sentences R.C. 2953.08 R.C. 2929.14(C)(4). The trial court erred by failing to award appellant jail-time credit for the time he spent in the community-based correctional facility. The trial court did not err in imposing consecutive sentences because the court complied with R.C. 2929.14(C)(4) and made the requisite consecutive sentence findings.
- 2018 Ohio 3169Cleveland MetroParks v. Sferra (2018)
R.C. 1547.41, operating a watercraft after sunset, R.C. 2921.29, failure to produce identification, Fifth Amendment right to travel, law enforcement jurisdiction on Lake Erie, R.C. 4705.01, R.C. 2301.33, judicial practice of law, code of judicial conduct, Crim.R. 11(A), R.C. 1901.20, municipal court jurisdiction, manifest weight and sufficiency of the evidence. Interstate travel is a fundamental right but the right to intrastate travel, whether by motor vehicle or watercraft, is a privilege. The CMRD Unit has authority to enforce the law on Lake Erie within Cuyahoga County extending to the international boundary line between the United States and Canada. Crim.R. 11(A) allows a trial court to enter a not guilty plea on behalf of a defendant that refuses to plead. Appellant's convictions are supported by the manifest weight of the evidence, subsuming the sufficiency challenge.
- 2018 Ohio 3171State v. McGee (2018)
Megan's Law Adam Walsh Act de novo resentencing limited classification sexual predator void plea stipulation automatic remedial jurisdiction. When a defendant stipulates as part of his plea bargain that he is to be classified as a sexual predator, such classification is automatic and there is no need for the trial court to conduct a hearing. The trial court had jurisdiction to automatically impose the civil and remedial classification based on the defendant's stipulation at the time of his plea.
- 2018 Ohio 3173Turoczy Bonding Co. v. Mitchell (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3174State v. Weber (2018)
Impostion of Community Based Correctional Facility Sentence Consecutive to a Prison Sentence
- 2018 Ohio 3175State v. Smith (2018)
Speedy Trial Right to Confrontation Ineffective Assistance of Counsel
- 2018 Ohio 3176State v. McCabe (2018)
Agg Murder Void Judgement
- 2018 Ohio 3177State v. Washington (2018)
Crim. R. 29 motion/Manifest weight/Hearsay exception-excited utterance
- 2018 Ohio 3178State ex rel. Bristow v. Frary & Sheldon (2018)
Public Officials Posting of Fee Tables
- 2018 Ohio 3179State v. inzy (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3181State v. Campbell (2018)
Trial court did not err when it denied appellant's motion to suppress evidence of cocaine and heroin found by police in a warrantless search of appellant's person because police had a reasonable suspicion, based on specific, articulable facts, that appellant was engaged in illegal narcotics activity and may be armed and because the subsequent search of appellant's person, including a pat-down of his groin and buttocks area did not exceed the permissible scope of Terry search for weapons. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3182State v. Oloye (2018)
Trial court acted properly in sustaining a motion to suppress as there was no probable cause to arrest the suspect.
- 2018 Ohio 3192State v. Bradley (2018)
The record does not clearly and convincingly fail to support the appellant's 30-month prison sentence for attempted felonious assault. The trial court erred, however, in imposing a separate concurrent sentence for the acknowledged allied offense of domestic violence. The trial court's judgment is modified by vacating the domestic violence sentence. The conviction and sentence for attempted felonious assault are unaffected. Judgment affirmed as modified. (Froelich, J., concurring.)
- 2018 Ohio 3193Cannabis for Cures, L.L.C. v. State of Ohio Bd. of Pharm. (2018)
Appellant, an Ohio limited liability company, lacks standing to appeal the dismissal of the complaint filed by the non-lawyer CEO of the company, who also filed the appeal for the LLC. Appeal dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 3194State v. Coyle (2018)
Defendant-appellant's conviction on one count of abduction was supported by sufficient evidence and was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3195Daniel v. Walder (2018)
Magistrate dismissed plaintiff's action, stating that the matter had already been addressed in a prior case. A week later, the trial court adopted the magistrate's decision and dismissed the action. Eight days later (15 days after the magistrate's decision was filed), both the magistrate's decision and the trial court's judgment were served on the parties. Plaintiff's subsequent objections to the magistrate's decision were untimely and were tantamount to a motion for reconsideration, which is a nullity. The trial court's judgment overruling those objections as untimely was also a nullity. Plaintiff's appeal from the trial court's second judgment overruling the untimely objections is dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 3197State v. Miller (2018)
The State has conceded error with regard to the trial court's failure to make findings for consecutive sentences at the sentencing hearing. In view of this concession, Appellant's other assignment of error is moot. Judgment reversed as to Appellant's sentence. Appellant's sentence is vacated, and this cause is remanded for a new sentencing hearing.
- 2018 Ohio 3198State v. Morgan (2018)
Appellant's ineffective-assistance claim lacks merit because Appellant failed to establish how his trial counsel's performance at the resentencing hearing prejudiced him. Appellant's claim that the trial court erred by imposing consecutive sentences for allied offenses during Appellant's resentencing hearing also fails because this court lacks jurisdiction to review the sentence at issue. Specifically, this court lacks jurisdiction to review Appellant's sentence under R.C. 2953.08(D)(1), as the sentence was agreed by the parties, authorized by law, and accepted by the trial court. This court also lacks jurisdiction to review Appellant's sentence because Appellant did not appeal from his sentence, but from the trial court's decision on several pro se motions that were filed by Appellant prior to his resentencing. Even if this court had jurisdiction to review Appellant's sentence, Appellant failed to raise his allied-offenses claim before the trial court and waived all but plain error for appeal. Upon review, we find no error, plain or otherwise, in the trial court's sentencing decision and further find that Appellant's allied-offenses claim is barred by res judicata. Lastly, Appellant's claim that he was denied due process during both his original sentencing and resentencing hearings fails because, again, this court does not have jurisdiction to review the sentence at issue and Appellant's arguments in support of his due process claim otherwise lack merit. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3199State v. Pendleton (2018)
Defendant-appellant's indictment for aggravated trafficking in a Schedule II drug as a second degree felony and aggravated possession of a Schedule II drug as a second degree felony, with neither indictment generating an objection before trial, validly charged Defendant-appellant with trafficking in a Schedule II controlled substance and possession of a Schedule II controlled substance based upon the fentanyl contained within the mixtures of controlled substances found at Defendant-appellant's home. The State presented sufficient evidence of the amount of fentanyl involved to support Defendant-appellant's convictions for aggravated trafficking in a Schedule II drug as a second degree felony and aggravated possession of a Schedule II drug as a second degree felony. The trial court correctly concluded that the heroin trafficking and the heroin possession counts and the aggravated trafficking (fentanyl) and the aggravated possession (fentanyl) counts did not merge into one offense as allied offenses of similar import. Defendant-appellant's convictions are not against the manifest weight of the evidence. The trial court's jury instructions did not include an instruction regarding excluded fingerprint evidence nor a formal bulk amount instruction. Neither omission generated an objection, and, on this record, we cannot conclude that the trial's outcome would have been different if the instructions had been given. Based upon the same reasoning, we cannot conclude that trial counsel provided ineffective assistance of counsel by not objecting to the omission of these instructions. Finally, the trial court, as to the offense of having a weapon under disability, erroneously concluded that the State had the burden to prove that the Defendant had not been relieved from disability. Relief from a weapon possession disability is an affirmative defense with the defendant having the burden of proof by a preponderance of the evidence however, double jeopardy prohibits a retrial of this offense. Judgment affirmed. (Froelich, J., concurring in part and dissenting in part.)
- 2018 Ohio 3200PNC Bank, N.A. v. Khalili (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in overruling the appellant's motion to intervene in this foreclosure action. The appellant, the purchaser of the subject property at a sheriff's sale, sought to intervene solely to argue that the property it had purchased lacked any means of ingress or egress and that the sale should be vacated. The trial court correctly found that the purchased property remained accessible by means of an existing easement over a driveway on an adjacent lot. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3201State v. Ruley (2018)
Appeal of defendant-appellant who had completed jail sentence for misdemeanor drug possession offense to which he entered a guilty plea was not moot where court costs remained unpaid. Trial court did not err by accepting appellant's uncounseled guilty plea and imposing maximum jail sentence where the record demonstrates that the trial court's inquiry sufficed to assure an effective waiver of right to counsel. Appellant's claim that he was convicted of an offense as to which he was immune under R.C. 2925.11(B)(2)(b) also lacked merit because appellant was not eligible for protection under that statute. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3208State v. Braswell (2018)
Where testimonial evidence established that defendant exited victim's home within minutes of burglary, door had been forced open, items were missing, and defendant subsequently confessed, his conviction was supported by legally sufficient evidence and was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Despite multiple claims of ineffective assistance of counsel, defendant could not demonstrate that any impacted the outcome of the trial.
- 2018 Ohio 3209In re Estate of Watson (2018)
Trial court abused its discretion when it denied appellants' Civ.R. 60(B)(1) motion for relief from judgment. Judgment reversed. Wrongful death, settlement, distribution, statutory wrongful death beneficiaries, next of kin, notice, reasonable diligence, relief from judgment, abuse of discretion, de novo review, civil
- 2018 Ohio 3211State v. Leavell (2018)
Motion to vacate conviction barred by the doctrine of res judicata and because it was untimely.
- 2018 Ohio 3212Tillimon v. Moore (2018)
Remand is necessary for court to calculate, ascertain, and grant appropriate monetary damages for months appellant owned rental property. Post-argument motion to supplement record is denied.
- 2018 Ohio 3215State v. Bryner (2018)
motion to suppress – dog sniff – probable cause – closed container – purse – motel parking lot – parked car – independent source
- 2018 Ohio 3216State v. Pitts (2018)
hearsay – statements to explain police conduct – harmless error – recorded recollection – presumption trial court disregarded improper evidence
- 2018 Ohio 3217State v. Tillison (2018)
R.C. 2505.02, final appealable order, allied offenses, nunc pro tunc, nullity
- 2018 Ohio 3218State v. Jacobs (2018)
The sentencing entry imposing postrelease control is not void because a reasonable person in defendant-appellant's position had sufficient notice that the trial court authorized postrelease control to be imposed following the expiration of his sentence despite the trial court's mistaken use of discretionary language in the sentencing entry. Because defendant-appellant's sentence is not void, any challenge to the propriety of the sentencing court's imposition of postrelease control in the sentencing entry could have been raised in a direct appeal. Because defendant-appellant failed to directly appeal his conviction and sentence, any challenge to the imposition of postrelease control is barred by the doctrine of res judicata.
- 2018 Ohio 3220Ohio Renal Assn. v. Kidney Dialysis Patient Protection Amendment Commt. (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Elections—Initiative-proposal petition—Challenge under Article II, Section 1g, Ohio Constitution—Petition-circulation managers were required to file disclosures under R.C. 3501.381(A)—It is a violation of R.C. 3501.381(A)(1) for a circulator to obtain signatures before that circulator's compensated manager has filed disclosures required by R.C. 3501.381(A) with secretary of state—Managers violated R.C. 3501.381(A)(1) by managing circulators who collected signatures before filing their R.C. 3501.381(A) disclosures—Challenge sustained.
- 2018 Ohio 3221HSBC Bank U.S.A v. Faulkner (2018)
The trial court did not err by granting appellee's motion for summary judgment where appellee satisfied its initial burden requiring it to provide evidence indicating it was entitled to judgment as a matter of law, to which appellants failed to file a timely response in opposition indicating there was any issue of material fact yet remaining for the trial court to resolve.
- 2018 Ohio 3222State v. Harris (2018)
Appellant's guilty plea was voluntary, knowing, and intelligent where the trial court delivered a valid colloquy according to Crim.R. 11, and where appellant reasoned that accepting the plea in order to avoid death penalty specifications was in his best interest.
- 2018 Ohio 3223State v. Hensley (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3224Aviation Publishing Corp. v. Morgan (2018)
Plaintiffs, an individual and corporation, appeal the court's decision denying their attempt to domesticate a California default judgment against the defendant, an Ohio resident. Plaintiffs failed to object to the magistrate's decision finding that the California court that entered the judgment lacked personal jurisdiction over the defendant. There was no plain error in the court's adoption of the magistrate's decision where there were no obvious errors of law in the magistrate's decision.
- 2018 Ohio 3226State v. Martin (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Juvenile procedure—R.C. 2152.021(F)(3)—R.C. 2152.021(F)(3) requires appointment of guardian ad litem when a juvenile is a human-trafficking victim and is charged with one or more offenses related to the victimization, which may include violent offenses—In absence of objection to a juvenile court's failure to consider applicability of R.C. 2152.021(F), criminal plain-error standard applies—Appellant failed to present evidence that her offenses were related to her victimization and therefore failed to show that juvenile court's failure to consider and apply R.C. 2152.021(F) was plain error—Court of appeals' affirmance of appellant's convictions and sentence affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3227State v. Lucas (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3228Downtown Ent. Co. v. Mullet (2018)
Quiet Title Adverse Possession Trespass
- 2018 Ohio 3230State v. Caplinger (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3232State v. King (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3233Smith v. Sheldon (2018)
Writ of Habeaus Corpus
- 2018 Ohio 3237State v. Moore (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Criminal law—Jail-time credit—R.C. 2967.191—Firearm specifications—R.C. 2929.14—Equal protection—Jail-time-credit provision in R.C. 2967.191 may not serve to reduce a prison term for a firearm specification—Because a rational basis exists for an inmate to serve the entirety of a mandatory sentence before becoming eligible for judicial release, requiring an inmate to serve the entire sentence for a firearm specification does not violate equal-protection guarantees.
- 2018 Ohio 3238Disciplinary Counsel v. Gold. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct, including misappropriating client funds, engaging in conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation, engaging in conduct that is prejudicial to the administration of justice, and engaging in conduct that adversely reflects on the lawyer's fitness to practice law—Two-year suspension, with second year stayed on conditions.
- 2018 Ohio 3239State v. Parker (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - Fourth Amendment search warrant emergency aid exception officer's subjective intent irrelevant constructive possession dominion or control over object sufficiency of jury instruction manifest weight of evidence defendant's residence R.C. 2929.14(C)(4) imposition of consecutive sentences consideration of unproven crime harmless error.
- 2018 Ohio 3240Stae v. Allen (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - PLEAS, MOTIONS & OTHER HEARINGS - motion to suppress the police may conduct a warrantless search if a defendant consents.
- 2018 Ohio 3241State v. Jackson (2018)
CRIMINAL - motion to sever joinder prejudice admissible simple and distinct Evid.R. 404(B) other acts sufficiency of the evidence manifest weight of the evidence Robbery Aggravated Robbery credibility of witnesses conflicting testimony circumstantial evidence
- 2018 Ohio 3244State v. Martin (2018)
CRIMINAL - ineffective assistance of counsel death penalty postconviction relief R.C. 2953.21 res judicata penalty phase mitigation evidence
- 2018 Ohio 3245State v. Cretella (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - successive motions for jail-time credit barred by res judicata.
- 2018 Ohio 3246Discover Bank v. Bennington (2018)
CIVIL - the trial court erred in denying appellant's motion to stay proceedings pending arbitration R.C. 2711.02(B) Cardmember Agreement.
- 2018 Ohio 3248State v. Krug (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - motion for leave to file delayed motion for new trial motion for disclosure of partial transcript of grand jury proceedings Crim.R. 6(E) no particularized need abuse of discretion standard Crim.R. 33 untimely evidence is not newly discovered.
- 2018 Ohio 3249State v. Lacy (2018)
CRIMINAL - trafficking motion for new trial conflict of interest Crim.R. 33 ineffective assistance of counsel credibility admission of evidence chain of custody Evid.R. 901
- 2018 Ohio 3250Am. Energy-Utica, L.L.C. v. Fuller (2018)
Oil and gas lease unitization
- 2018 Ohio 3253State v. Newman (2018)
Waiver of right to counsel
- 2018 Ohio 3254Columbus City Schools Bd. of Edn. v. Franklin Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation—Real-property valuation—Valuation of government-subsidized residential properties—Board of Tax Appeals' decision vacated, and cause remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 3255Licking Hts. Local Schools Bd. of Edn. v. Franklin Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation—Real-property valuation—Voluntary dismissal of complaint filed under R.C. 5715.19(A) did not retroactively invalidate complaint filed under R.C. 5715.19(B)—Although complaint filed under R.C. 5715.19(A) challenged value of land only, board of revision and Board of Tax Appeals had jurisdiction to consider claim, set forth in complaint filed under R.C. 5715.19(B), for increased value of both land and improvements.
- 2018 Ohio 3256State v. Carnes (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Criminal law—R.C. 2923.13—Juvenile adjudication of delinquency as an element of the offense of having a weapon under a disability—Due process—A prior juvenile adjudication may be an element of a weapons-under-disability offense without violating due process under the Ohio or United States Constitutions.
- 2018 Ohio 3261State v. Gibson (2018)
The trial court erred when it failed to merge the offenses of abduction and unlawful sexual conduct with a minor for purposes of sentencing.
- 2018 Ohio 3262State v. Ross (2018)
Appellate record does not support claim that appellant received additional prison time as a result of his conduct when he was still a juvenile.
- 2018 Ohio 3263Portee v. Cleveland Clinic Found. (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Statutes of limitations—R.C. 2305.19 (saving statute)—If an action is commenced in another state in either a state or federal court and fails otherwise than upon the merits and the statute of limitations for commencement of the action has expired, R.C. 2305.19, Ohio's saving statute, does not apply to permit recommencement of the action in Ohio within one year—Savings statute does not apply to action commenced in Ohio that was originally commenced in federal court in Indiana—Court of appeals' judgment reversed and trial court's judgment reinstated.
- 2018 Ohio 3264Jacboson v. MOM Corp. (2018)
open and obvious, water, slip and fall, negligence, duty, summary judgment
- 2018 Ohio 3265Najsztup v. Ford Motor Co. (2018)
lemon law, arbitration, summary judgment, Civ.R. 56, affirmative defenses, waiver
- 2018 Ohio 3266State v. Rouse (2018)
jointly-recommended sentence – agreed sentence – R.C. 2953.08(D)(1) – authorized by law – firearm specifications – consecutive sentence – allied offenses of similar import – forfeiture – plain error
- 2018 Ohio 3267Cleveland Metropolitan Bar Association v. Thomas. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct—Conditionally stayed one-year suspension.
- 2018 Ohio 3268Columbus Bar Assn. v. Magee (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Presumptive sanction for misappropriation of client funds is disbarment—Respondent disbarred.
- 2018 Ohio 3269In Re: Proposed Charter Petition (2018)
CIVIL - Because no final appealable order is before us we must dismiss this appeal for lack of jurisdiction.
- 2018 Ohio 3271State v. Curry (2018)
App.R. 26(B) ineffective assistance of appellate counsel motion to suppress DNA evidence credibility weight Evid.R. 901 authentication. The application to reopen an appeal based on failure of appellate counsel to raise issues of ineffective assistance of trial counsel for failure to file a motion to suppress DNA evidence is denied. The state established that the DNA records were what they purported to be, and the applicant offered no basis for their suppression.
- 2018 Ohio 3272State v. Hart (2018)
Preindictment delay due process faded memories deceased witnesses unavailable other acts evidence Evid.R. 404(B) unfair prejudice. Trial court properly denied defendant's motion dismiss for preindictment delay where defendant failed to establish actual prejudice caused by the delay. Trial court's decision to allow evidence of defendant's prior sex crime into evidence was an abuse of discretion that resulted in unfair prejudice in violation of Evid.R. 404(B).
- 2018 Ohio 3273State v. Barnes (2018)
R.C. 2505.02, final appealable order, R.C. 2505.02(B)(4), provisional remedy, motion to withdraw, office of the public defender, Prof.Cond.R. 1.7, conflict of interest, Prof.Cond.R. 1.9, duty of confidentiality. The motion to withdraw due to conflict of interest and duty of confidentiality is a final appealable order. The elements of a provisional remedy have been met. The office of the public defender is a firm pursuant to the Professional Rules of Conduct. Because the office of the public defender represented a former client who is the alleged victim in the instant case, issues of confidentiality and conflicts of interest arose, resulting in whether counsel would zealously represent the defendant. The defendant would not be afforded a meaningful and effective remedy after trial by way of appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 3274Heba El Attar v. Marine Towers E. Condominium owner's Assn. (2018)
Judgment on the pleadings condominium declaration and bylaws reserve fund. Trial court erred by granting judgment on the pleadings where the evidence showed condominium association failed to "build up and maintain a reasonable reserve" as required by its bylaws.
- 2018 Ohio 3275In re T.W. (2018)
Evid.R. 807 delinquency independent proof Evid.R. 702 bootstrapping rule R.C. 2905.01 R.C. 2907.05 R.C. 2907.02 sufficiency of the evidence force restraint implied force gross sexual imposition lesser included offense. The state failed to present independent proof of the sexual act under Evid.R. 807 for the purposes of admitting the incompetent victim's testimony at trial, and the state failed to present sufficient evidence of force or restraint for the purposes of the rape and kidnapping convictions. In this case, gross sexual imposition was improperly considered as the lesser included offense of the statutory rape count with which the juvenile was charged.
- 2018 Ohio 3276UBS Fin. Servs., Inc. v. Lacava (2018)
Fraudulent conveyance venue compensatory damages punitive damages attorney fees statutory exemptions summary judgment. The case was properly disposed of in the county where prior, related proceedings occurred. The record demonstrated that there was no genuine issue of material fact that defendant-appellant engaged in a fraudulent transfer summary judgment therefore was properly granted in favor of the plaintiff-appellee. The record supported the trial court's award of compensatory and punitive damages, and attorney fees. The statutory exemptions relative to damages were inapplicable.
- 2018 Ohio 3277State v. Martemus (2018)
Ineffective assistance of counsel manifest weight of the evidence in-court identification DNA evidence. Trial counsel is not ineffective for not moving to suppress an in-court identification. Cross-examination of a witness challenges such an identification. Convictions are not against the manifest weight of the evidence when the evidence supporting the conviction is not rebutted.
- 2018 Ohio 3279State v. Poe (2018)
SENTENCING – ALLOCUTION: The trial court's failure to ask defendant if she wished to exercise her right of allocution before sentencing her to more than a minimum sentence was not harmless error where nothing in the record demonstrates that defendant was ever adequately informed of or afforded her right to make a statement to the court with respect to the sentence imposed, even though the court had asked defendant about a part of one victim's testimony, and defendant had touched on the issue of guilt in response.
- 2018 Ohio 3281Brown v. Holiday Inn Express & Suites (2018)
The trial court did not err in dismissing plaintiff's claims for battery and intentional infliction of emotional distress because plaintiff did not file those claims within the one-year statute of limitations applicable to battery claims. However, the trial court erred in dismissing plaintiff's claims for negligence and negligent supervision on statute-of-limitations grounds.
- 2018 Ohio 3282State v. Schadhauser (2018)
The trial court did not err in granting ODRC's motion for summary judgment.
- 2018 Ohio 3283Filonenko v. Smock Constr., L.L.C. (2018)
The trial court erred in concluding that the resolution of the underlying case mooted motions for sanctions brought pursuant to R.C. 2323.51 and Civ.R. 11.
- 2018 Ohio 3284State v. Boyle (2018)
Defendant-appellant, after pleading guilty to a number of indictment counts (with the remaining counts being dismissed) and after his conviction and sentence were affirmed on appeal, filed a motion asserting that the indictment was defective and seeking its dismissal. The trial court properly overruled the motion because Defendant-appellant's guilty pleas acted as a waiver of any defects in the indictment. Further, even if any indictment defects had not been waived, consideration of the issue would be barred by the doctrine of res judicata. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3285State v. Caplette (2018)
Pursuant to Evid.R. 404(B), the trial court did not err in admitting evidence regarding the prior acts of the appellant, as the danger of unfair prejudice was minimal and the evidence was clearly probative of whether appellant had knowledge that his accomplice intended to burglarize the victims' residence when they arrived there. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3286Deutsche Bank Natl. Trust Co. v. Jones (2018)
Upon remand from the court of appeals, the trial court was vested with jurisdiction to consider and rule upon appellee's motion to vacate a Foreclosure Decree judgment pursuant to Civ.R. 60(B). The trial court did not abuse its discretion when it granted appellee's motion to vacate a Foreclosure Decree judgment pursuant to Civ.R. 60(B). Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3287State v. Diamond (2018)
Ineffective assistance of counsel is not demonstrated in Appellant's bench trial on four counts of animal cruelty. Overwhelming evidence was adduced by the State and no deficient performance was established. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3288State v. Grissom (2018)
An independent review of the record pursuant to Anders v. California, 386 U.S. 738, 87 S.Ct. 1396, 18 L.Ed.2d 493 (1967), reveals no issues with arguable merit to present on appeal. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3290State v. Kuck (2018)
Trial court did not err in concluding that petitioner failed to demonstrate operative facts supporting his post-conviction relief claim that trial counsel was ineffective. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3291State v. McCloud (2018)
Defendant-appellant's conviction, following a jury trial, for robbery in violation of R.C. 2911.02(A)(2) is supported by sufficient evidence and it is not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3292State v. Ragland (2018)
Under the provisions of R.C. 2929.19(B)(2)(g)(iii), the doctrine of res judicata does not bar appellate review of a jail time credit claim of a defendant who failed to raise such claim on direct appeal. However, where any jail time credit due was applied to the defendant's sentence for unrelated offenses in a different county, defendant was not entitled to have jail time credit also applied to the consecutive sentence imposed in the case on review. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3293State v. Ray (2018)
Pursuant to our responsibilities under Anders we have conducted an independent review of appellant's conviction and sentencing. We find no arguably meritorious issues for appeal. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3295State v. Schooler (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3296In re S.J. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3300State v. Anderson (2018)
Based on authority of Baker and Lester, trial court did not err in denying motion to release as sentencing entry complied with Crim.R. 32(C). criminal
- 2018 Ohio 3301Holloway v. Bucher (2018)
Oral agreement concerning a loan that required monthly payments is unenforceable under R.C. 1335.05 because the monthly payments would not pay the loan off within one year and the parties did not contemplate early payoff of the loan at the time the agreement was reached.
- 2018 Ohio 3303Pippo v. Fitzgerald (2018)
Trial court did not abuse its discretion for how it fashioned the jury instructions because they were correct, complete and factually warranted by the evidence in the case. Judgment affirmed. Negligence, proximate cause, expert opinion, probability, jury instructions, abuse of discretion, de novo review, civil
- 2018 Ohio 3304Quest Workforce Solutions, L.L.C. v. Job 1USA, Inc. (2018)
The trial court erred in awarding damages for a breach of contract because it excluded certain expenses that were proper under the parties' profit sharing agreement. The trial court also erred in awarding prejudgment interest because it failed to determine the appropriate interest rate and the date when prejudgment interest began to accrue. Civil
- 2018 Ohio 3305State v. Schuttera (2018)
Trial court failed to consider RC 2929.12 factors in assessing community control sanctions.
- 2018 Ohio 3306State v. McCall (2018)
Post conviction relief/Void sentence/Final appealable order
- 2018 Ohio 3307State v. Gibbons (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3309State v. Kind (2018)
Weapons while under disability manifest weight of the evidence sufficient evidence R.C. 2903.12. Weapons while under disability conviction was not against the manifest weight of the evidence even though jury acquitted appellant of all charges tried to the jury the trial court, as trier of fact on weapons while under disability charge, was free to assess the testimony of the witnesses and find that the eyewitness testimony proved the offense beyond a reasonable doubt.
- 2018 Ohio 3310State v. Greiner (2018)
Murder purpose ineffective assistance of counsel authentication weight of the evidence. Authentication of evidence has a low threshold that requires the proponent of the evidence to make a prima facie showing of genuineness and leaves it to the jury to decide the true authenticity and probative value of the evidence. The court did not abuse its discretion allowing into evidence an undated, unsigned letter found in the defendant's bedroom because the letter, professing defendant's love and desire to marry, was consistent with evidence showing the relationship between the defendant and the victim.
- 2018 Ohio 3317State v. Miles (2018)
The trial court did not err by denying defendant-appellant's motion to dismiss the indictment for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction. By pleading guilty, defendant-appellant waived his argument that the trial court erred by denying his motion to dismiss the indictment on the grounds that he was entrapped by law enforcement.
- 2018 Ohio 3318Holt v. Feron (2018)
The judgment of the trial court to grant the civil stalking protection order was supported by sufficient evidence and was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. The trial court did not err in questioning witnesses when no obection was raised, the questions did not indicate a bias, and the matter was a trial to the bench.
- 2018 Ohio 3319State v. Davenport (2018)
Defendant was not denied due process at community control revocation hearing and defendant did not demonstrate that his sentece was clearly and convincingly contrary to law.
- 2018 Ohio 3320State v. Hampton (2018)
The State's evidence was sufficient to support the jury's verdict finding the defendant-appellant guilty of Failure to Comply with Order or Signal of a Police Officer. Further, the verdict was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3321State v. Yoder (2018)
Sufficient evidence exists in the record to convict the Defendant-Appellant of gross sexual imposition. Further, the judgment of the trial court was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3322Enervest Operating, L.L.C v. JSMB0912, L.L.C. (2018)
REAL PROPERTY - quiet title indmnification delinquent taxes summary judgment intervention if the effect of a judgment entry is to render all other claims at issue moot, it need not contain Civ.R. 54(B) language to be a final appealable order.
- 2018 Ohio 3323Xtreme Elements, L.L.C. v. Foti Contracting, L.L.C. (2018)
CIVIL - contractor subcontractor Ohio Prompt Payment Act attorney's fees R.C. 4113.61(B) inequitable case-by-case basis abuse of discretion
- 2018 Ohio 3324State v. Motley (2018)
INEFFECTIVE ASSISTANCE OF COUNSEL - felonious assaultcounsel is not ineffective for failing to move to suppress a confession if the motion is not likely to be granted a trial court does not commit plain error by failing to dimiss an entire jury pool when one juror shows potntial bias manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 3325State v. Lorraine (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - motion for leave delayed "motion for new mitigation trial" death penalty Sixth Amendment jury trial Hurst v. Florida not appropriately raised in Crim.R. 33 motion unavoidably prevented timeliness harmless error R.C. 2953.21 postconviction relief violation of constitutional rights untimely R.C. 2953.23 retroactivity collateral review Ring v. Arizona unnecessary to reach constitutional issue State v. Mason.
- 2018 Ohio 3326State v. Gray (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - guilty plea merger R.C. 2941.25 allied offenses of similar import failed to seek merger in the trial court plain error appellant must demonstrate a reasonable probability that he has been convicted of allied offenses of similar import offenses committed separately offenses dissimilar in import or significance felony sentencing statutes require that the trial court impose either a prison term or community control sanctions for each felony offense.
- 2018 Ohio 3327State v. D.M. (2018)
Motion to waive court costs–trial court could not grant defendant's request to waive court costs when defendant convicted before effective date of statute that vested court with continuing jurisdiction to consider motion to waive court costs–Application to seal record of conviction–res judicata barred defendant's second application to seal record when defendant did not allege sufficient change in circumstances since he filed his first application
- 2018 Ohio 3329State v. Mason (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3334State v. Manning (2018)
The trial court did not err in imposing fines because appellant failed to file an affidavit of indigency before the trial court's judgment entry of sentence was filed. Appellant's counsel was not ineffective for failure to file an affidavit of indigency where there is no indication that the trial court would have granted the motion to waive the mandatory fees. The trial court did not err in imposing court costs in the judgment entry of sentence without first addressing the costs at the sentencing hearing because appellant can move for waiver of courts costs at any time per the recent amendment to R.C. 2947.23(C).
- 2018 Ohio 3335State v. Lynn (2018)
The trial court did not err by denying appellant's motion to suppress alleging law enforcement officer did not have probable cause to conduct a warrantless search of a vehicle's trunk where a warrantless search of the vehicle's passenger compartment led to the discovery of marijuana and ecstasy located in the vehicle's glove compartment.
- 2018 Ohio 3336State v. Troy (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3337State v. Holder (2018)
Trial court did not err by denying appellant's motion to terminate court costs, as the waiver of said costs are a matter of discretion with the trial court and appellant showed no change in financial circumstances from the time of his recent sentencing hearing.
- 2018 Ohio 3338State v. Brown (2018)
Trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying petition for postconviction relief where petitioner's claims were barred by the doctrine of res judicata.
- 2018 Ohio 3339State v. Kremer (2018)
This matter is remanded in part based on ineffective assistance of counsel on one count, and also for findings as to whether possession and trafficking charges constitute allied offenses of similar import.
- 2018 Ohio 3340State v. Flucas (2018)
Inmate appeals his conviction for harassment by bodily substance. Inmate spat upon a corrections officer. The inmate's multiple confessions to the offense were admissible and did not violate the corpus delicti rule. Inmate's conviction was supported by sufficient evidence and the greater weight of the evidence where the state presented overwhelming evidence of guilt.
- 2018 Ohio 3341In re D.E. (2018)
The juvenile court's decision granting permanent custody of a child to a children services agency, thereby denying appellants motions for legal custody of the child, was supported by sufficient evidence and otherwise not against the manifest weight of the evidence where the juvenile court's decision to grant permanent custody to the children services agency was in the child's best interest.
- 2018 Ohio 3342State ex rel. McCann v. Delaware Cty. Bd. of Elections (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Elections—Prohibition—Writ of prohibition sought to prevent board of elections from placing township zoning referendum on the ballot—R.C. 519.12(H)—R.C. 3501.38(E)(1)—Writ granted.
- 2018 Ohio 3344Fraternal Order of Police Ohio Labor Council, Inc. v. Uhrichsville (2018)
Collective Bargaining Agreement
- 2018 Ohio 3345Feister v. Felton (2018)
Civil Protection Order
- 2018 Ohio 3347State v. Shine-Johnson (2018)
Defendant's conviction for murder and tampering with evidence was not against the manifest weight of the evidence where defendant admitted to firing a shotgun at his father while defendant was standing in the yard of the home where both he and his father lived, and several witnesses contradicted defendant's testimony that he feared for his life and shot his father in self-defense. Defendant did not demonstrate that he was denied a right to a fair trial or suffered prejudice due to prosecutorial error, the trial court's refusal to provide certain curative instructions and jury instructions, ineffective assistance of counsel, or the cumulative effect of errors. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3348State v. Patterson (2018)
FELONIOUS ASSAULT – RECEIVING STOLEN PROPERTY – EVIDENCE – CONSTITUTIONAL LAW/CRIMINAL – ID/PHOTOS – EVIDENCE/WITNESS/TRIAL – SENTENCING – CONSECUTIVE SENTENCES: In a felonious-assault prosecution, the trial court did not abuse its discretion in admitting a Facebook photograph depicting defendant with a gun where a detective testified that he had used the photograph in the course of his investigation to confirm defendant's identity as the perpetrator, and the victim testified that the gun in the photograph was similar to the gun that the victim had seen defendant brandish. Where a police officer testified that in the aftermath of a shooting he had shown the victim several Facebook photographs of defendant's accomplice to confirm the accomplice's identity, the trial court did not err in overruling defendant's motion for a mistrial based upon the state's failure to preserve those photographs: defendant argued that the photographs may have contained defendant, so the photographs would have been at most potentially useful for defendant, and nothing suggested that the officer had acted in bad faith by failing to save the photographs. Defendant did not demonstrate ineffective assistance of counsel for counsel's failure to file a motion to suppress defendant's admission to a police officer that he had been at the scene of a shooting, but had not been the shooter, because the record does not demonstrate that defendant made the statement without having been advised of his rights under Miranda v. Arizona, 384 U.S. 436, 479, 86 S.Ct. 1602, 16 L.Ed.2d 694 (1966). Defendant's felonious-assault conviction was neither based on legally insufficient evidence nor contrary to the manifest weight of the evidence: the evidence adduced by the state at trial showed that defendant and an accomplice pointed guns at the victim, defendant threatened to shoot him, and the accomplice's gun discharged. Defendant's receiving-stolen-property conviction was neither based on legally insufficient evidence nor contrary to the manifest weight of the evidence: the evidence adduced by the state at trial showed that defendant had been driving a stolen vehicle the same day it had been reported stolen, and once a police officer initiated a stop of the vehicle, defendant crashed the vehicle into a post and fled on foot. The trial court did not err in imposing consecutive sentences: the trial court's judgment entry tracked the necessary statutory language for consecutive-sentencing findings, and although the trial court did not recite the statutory language at the sentencing hearing, the appellate court can discern from the trial court's comments that it engaged in the necessary analysis.
- 2018 Ohio 3349Schirmann v. Arena Mgt. Holdings, L.L.C., d.b.a. U.S. Bank Arena (2018)
NEGLIGENCE/SLIP/FALL – SNOW AND ICE: The trial court did not err by granting summary judgment to defendants in a slip-and-fall action, because the evidence showed only that plaintiff had fallen on a natural accumulation of snow and ice, and no material issues of fact existed that would result in liability based on the allegation that defendants owed plaintiff the duty of cared owed a business invitee.
- 2018 Ohio 3350In Re B.H. (2018)
JUVENILE – ADMISSION – SENTENCING – FIREARM SPECIFICATION – COUNSEL: Where the juvenile admitted to conduct that, if committed by an adult, would have constituted two firearm specifications of the type set forth in R.C. 2941.145, the juvenile court did not err by committing the juvenile to the Department of Youth Services for three years on each specification R.C. 2152.17(A)(2) required the court to commit the juvenile for each firearm specification for a definite period of at least one year and not more than three years. The juvenile's admission in a delinquency case constitutes an admission of the facts contained in the complaint and is a waiver of the juvenile's right to challenge those allegations thus, where the juvenile admitted that in committing offenses, he had displayed and brandished a firearm and that his conduct, if committed by an adult, would have constituted two firearm specifications of type set forth in R.C. 2941.145, the juvenile waived his right to challenge those allegations on appeal. The juvenile cannot complain on appeal that defense counsel was ineffective for failing to argue that he was merely an accomplice for purposes of sentencing on firearm specifications where the juvenile admitted to the complaints' allegations that he had displayed and brandished a firearm.
- 2018 Ohio 3351Lehmier v. W. Res. Chem. Corp. (2018)
summary judgment – gender discrimination – legitimate business reason – pretext – retaliation – judgment based on arguments not asserted
- 2018 Ohio 3352State v. Woods (2018)
suppression – traffic stop – findings of fact unsupported by evidence
- 2018 Ohio 3353State v. Alls (2018)
Fourth amendment/Search of vehicle
- 2018 Ohio 3354City of Dublin v. Beatley (2018)
Appropriation/Subject matter jurisdiction
- 2018 Ohio 3355State v. McClellan (2018)
Witness competency/Manifest weight/Sufficiency of evidence/Evid. R. 803(4)/Evid. R. 404(B)
- 2018 Ohio 3356Gatschet v. W. Manor Dev. Group, L.L.C. (2018)
Premises liability/Slip and fall/Open and obvious/Two inch rule
- 2018 Ohio 3357Bunting v. Watts (2018)
Declaratory judgment/12(b)(6) motion to dismiss
- 2018 Ohio 3361State ex rel. Leneghan v. Husted (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Elections—Mandamus—Writ of mandamus sought to compel secretary of state and county boards of elections to not count ballots from certain precincts cast in the May 2018 primary election and to certify new results that do not include those ballots—Allegation that improprieties occurred during recount of votes—Cause dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 3363State v. Sinclair (2018)
Aggravated murder, R.C. 2903.01, murder, R.C. 2903.02, aggravated robbery, R.C. 2911.01, felonious assault, R.C. 2903.11, kidnapping, R.C. 2905.01, Crim.R. 29, sufficiency of the evidence, manifest weight of the evidence, bifurcation of cases, lesser included offense instructions, consecutive sentencing, R.C. 2929.14, H.B. 86. The evidence is sufficient to support appellant's convictions and are sustained by the manifest weight of the evidence where appellant admitted to the armed robberies and shooting as confirmed by security camera videos and eyewitness testimony. The trial court did not err in failing to require separate trials for robberies at two establishments where the evidence was direct, uncomplicated, and could reasonably be separated as to each offense. Appellant was not entitled to lesser included offense instructions because the evidence did not support the instruction. The trial court correctly addressed each of the requisite elements of R.C. 2929.14 and accurately journalized the findings.
- 2018 Ohio 3364N. Chem. Blending Corp., Inc. v. Strib Industries, Inc., D.B.A. Prod. Chem. (2018)
App.R. 3(D) notice of appeal affidavit strike evidence summary judgment trade secret misappropriation breach of contract tortious interference business relationship improper invoice written admission counterclaim deposition testimony admissible untimely Civ.R. 56. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in striking the untimely affidavit attached to the appellants' brief in opposition to summary judgment. Nor did the court abuse its discretion in striking exhibits that were not incorporated in a properly framed affidavit. The trial court erred as a matter of law in granting summary judgment in favor of defendants. Defendants did not come forward with admissible evidence suggesting that there is a genuine issue for trial.
- 2018 Ohio 3365State v. Lenard (2018)
Other acts, Evid.R. 404(B), pretrial identification, Evid.R. 901, restitution, ability to pay, sufficiency and manifest weight of the evidence. Trial court did not abuse its discretion in allowing the state to use other acts evidence to refute the defendant's claim that he was an innocent party in real estate transactions that he initiated. A witness's in-court identification of the defendant is not necessary when the accused's identity can be established through direct or circumstantial evidence. The witness's pretrial identification through the use of a photo array was properly admitted. Defendant's convictions upheld where evidence showed that the defendant held himself out to be the seller of two properties when he was not the owner. The defendant used false and deceptive statements to induce the buyers into signing fictitious agreements to purchase real estate.
- 2018 Ohio 3366State v. Simmons (2018)
Aggravated murder aggravated robbery having a weapon while under disability material prejudice Crim.R. 52(A) harmless error plain error Evid.R. 901 Evid.R. 803(6) stipulation authentication business records Evid.R. 2945.29 discharge juror alternate juror discretion manifest weight of the evidence court costs cumulative error. Affirmed appellant's conviction and sentence for aggravated murder, aggravated robbery, and having a weapon while under disability. Much of the claimed error did not cause material prejudice, amounted to harmless error, or did not amount to plain error. Because defense counsel did not explicitly limit stipulation to the authenticity of cell phone records, no foundational requirement was required for the authenticity of business records under Evid.R. 803(6). Trial court did not abuse its discretion in discharging a juror who was reported to express concern in deciding the case because of defendant's gang affiliation. Appellant's conviction was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Remand was not required when appellant could seek waiver of court costs with the trial court. Appellant's claim of cumulative error was not substantiated.
- 2018 Ohio 3367Keybank Natl. Assn. v. Thalman (2018)
Trust declaratory judgment law of the case attorney fees. Law-of-the-case doctrine applied on remand from appellate court opinion that found that trustee had split a single trust into two trusts. The court erred by conducting trial on appellate court finding and reaching conclusion inconsistent with that reached by appellate court.
- 2018 Ohio 3368State v. Williams (2018)
Motion to dismiss/preindictment delay motion for mistrial motion to disqualify counsel/ineffective assistance of counsel sufficiency manifest weight prejudicial testimony/evidence allied offenses juvenile/bindover. The trial court did not err in denying appellant's motion to dismiss for preindictment delay. The state's charges of rape and kidnapping were within the statute of limitations. Nonetheless, appellant failed to address at the hearing the issue of witness unavailability and that the evidence was unavailable because the business is now closed. Those issues are waived and ultimately, appellant failed to show actual prejudice. Appellant's disruptive behavior during trial falls under the invited error doctrine evidence presented was not prejudicial and could be interpreted as appellant's consciousness of guilt and the photographs entered into evidence were used to impeach appellant's testimony. The trial court's denial of appellant's motion for mistrial was proper. Appellant failed to show that defense counsel's performance was deficient and fell below a reasonable standard of representation. Appellant's claim of ineffective assistance of counsel fails. Witness testimony of the presence of a firearm, identification and DNA results were issues for the trier of fact and the jury did not lose its way in determining the sufficiency of that evidence. Appellant's convictions were not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Each of appellant's acts were performed separately from each other and failed to meet the requirement for merger. Appellant was not apprehended until after he was 21 years old and the common pleas court had proper jurisdiction.
- 2018 Ohio 3369State v. Toby (2018)
Sufficiency of the evidence gross sexual imposition burglary attempted rape eyewitness testimony circumstantial evidence. The state presented sufficient evidence to support defendant's convictions for gross sexual imposition, burglary, and attempted rape where the victim testified that she knew the assailant, he forced his way into her apartment and assaulted her, his belongings were recovered from the apartment, a mixture of his and victim's DNA was recovered from his jacket, and video surveillance recorded him in the immediate area
- 2018 Ohio 3370State v. Caldwell (2018)
Notice of prior conviction R.C. 2941.11.
- 2018 Ohio 3371Clay v. Schriver Allison Courtley Co. (2018)
Intentional infliction of emotional distress breach of contract emotional damages motion to amend Civ.R. 15(B) Civ.R. 9(B).
- 2018 Ohio 3372Hernandez v. Larose (2018)
Habeas corpus failure to file commitment papers failure to file affidavit of prior civil actions state court of appeals lacks jurisdiction over federal inmates dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 3373Stevenson v. Larose (2018)
Habeas corpus failure to file commitment papers failure to file affidavit of prior civil actions state court of appeals lacks jurisdiction over federal inmates federal criminal complaint 18 U.S.C. 4 misprision of felony state court lack of jurisdiction over federal criminal statutes dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 3374Davis v. Larose (2018)
Habeas corpus failure to file commitment papers failure to file affidavit of prior civil actions state court of appeals lacks jurisdiction over federal inmates dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 3375Davis v. Larose (2018)
Habeas corpus failure to file commitment papers failure to file affidavit of prior civil actions state court of appeals lacks jurisdiction over federal inmates dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 3378Tarullo v. Thompson (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3379State v. Woods (2018)
Trial court granted motion to suppress
- 2018 Ohio 3383State v. McHenry (2018)
VEHICULAR MANSLAUGHTER – R.C. 2945.75(A)(2) – COUNSEL: Where defendant was charged with vehicular manslaughter, a misdemeanor of the second degree in violation of R.C. 2903.06(A)(4), and the complaint did not allege any element that would have elevated the degree of the offense, R.C. 2945.75(A)(2) was inapplicable. Where trial counsel's decision not to hire a crime scene reconstructionist and to instead cross-examine the state's witness was a matter of trial strategy, and where it cannot be demonstrated that the outcome of the proceedings would have been different but for counsel's failure to hire such an expert, counsel did not render ineffective assistance.
- 2018 Ohio 3386State ex rel. Navistar, Inc. v. Indus. Comm. & Bisdorf (2018)
The magistrate did not err in finding that the Industrial Commission's granting of claimant's request for permanent total disability compensation was not an abuse of discretion because some evidence supported that decision. Writ of mandamus denied.
- 2018 Ohio 3388State v. Mohamood (2018)
Appellant fails to demonstrate the trial court erred in denying his request for additional jail-time credit. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3389State ex rel. Davis v. Holbrook (2018)
Dismissal of inmate's mandamus action is required where the inmate fails to comply with R.C. 2969.25(C) by filing an affidavit containing a statement of the balance in his inmate account for each of the preceding six months as certified by the institutional casher. Failure to comply with the mandatory requirements of R.C. 2969.25(C) cannot be cured by subsequent amendment to the inmate's affidavit. Objections to magistrate's decision overruled action dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 3390Marshall v. Marshall (2018)
Assignment of error overruled and judgment affirmed. Because appellant never filed a motion to contest the child support agency's request under R.C. 3121.11 for a transmittal of a lump sum due to her, the record in the trial court does not contain the agency's investigation or the grounds supporting its conclusion that she was owed a lump sum. Without a reason or evidence before it to contest the agency's recommendation, the trial court did not err by adopting it as an order of the court.
- 2018 Ohio 3391State v. Underdown (2018)
The trial court did not err by overruling appellant's motion to vacate his criminal sentences. Construed as a motion for postconviction relief under R.C. 2953.21(A)(1), the motion was untimely, barred by principles of res judicata, and without merit. Because appellant received the maximum sentence for an offense, the trial court properly imposed a repeat violent offender specification under R.C. 2929.14(B)(2)(a)(iii). Assignments of error overruled and judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3392Cotten v. Dept. of Corr. & Rehab. (2018)
The trial court did not err in granting ODRC's motion to dismiss pursuant to Civ.R. 12(B)(1) and (6), and the trial court did not err in not conducting an immunity analysis for ODRC's employees.
- 2018 Ohio 3393State v. Allen (2018)
Defendant-appellant's convictions, occurring after a bench trial, for domestic violence and assault are not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Further, it cannot be concluded that the prosecutor's closing argument comments vouching for the victim's credibility, though improper, changed the trial's outcome. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3394State v. Arnold (2018)
Trial judge did not err in denying Appellant's Crim.R. 29 motion on charges of rape, unlawful sexual conduct with a minor, and gross sexual imposition where State presented sufficient evidence of both penetration and force or threat of force. Consideration of the same credible evidence demonstrates that verdicts finding Appellant guilty of those charges were not against manifest weight of the evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3395State v. Body (2018)
Appellant's conviction for obstructing official business was supported by sufficient evidence and was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. In addition, Appellant's claim that her First Amendment rights were violated when police officers prohibited her from filming and observing a traffic stop involving her brother lacks merit because there is no evidence in the record indicating that Appellant attempted to film the traffic stop and there is no First Amendment right to merely observe a traffic stop. Any right that Appellant had to observe police activity was forfeited by her conduct that obstructed the officers' lawful actions. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3396Bolin v. Allstate Property and Casualty Ins. Co. (2018)
The trial court, because the claims are barred by the one-year limitations period set forth in each insurance contract, properly sustained Appellees' motion for judgment on the pleadings regarding Appellants' causes of action for declaratory judgment and breach of contract. Further, the trial court appropriately dismissed the negligent fulfillment of contractual duties cause of action because it was not a cognizable tort claim. Appellants' assignment of error relating to the imposition of discovery sanctions and Appellees' cross-appeal are rendered moot by this decision. The trial court, however, erred by dismissing Appellees' bad faith cause of action, and the associated claim for punitive damages, because, under Bullet Trucking, Inc. v. Glen Falls Ins. Co., 84 Ohio App.3d 327, 616 N.E.2d 1123 (2d Dist. 1982), a contractual limitations period does not control the statute of limitations regarding the tort of bad faith. Judgment affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded for further proceedings consistent with this opinion. (Froelich, J., concurring.)
- 2018 Ohio 3397Clark v. Cherryhill Management, Inc. (2018)
The Ohio Unemployment Compensation Review Commission (Commission) decided that Plaintiff-appellant's employment termination was for just cause, and, accordingly, that she was ineligible to receive unemployment compensation benefits. The trial court affirmed the Commission's decision. The record is not sufficient to allow a determination of whether the Commission's just cause conclusion is unlawful, unreasonable, or against the manifest weight of the evidence. In particular, the record needs to be further developed to allow the Commission to determine whether Plaintiff-appellant's termination violated the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA). Trial court judgment and Commission determination are reversed matter is remanded to the Commission for further proceedings.
- 2018 Ohio 3398Garner v. Bureau of Workers' Comp. (2018)
The trial court did not err by entering summary judgment for Appellees on Appellant's claim for workers' compensation benefits for injuries sustained in an assault. Appellant did not receive his injuries "in the course of" his employment, and the injuries did not "arise out of" his employment. While the assault occurred in the employee parking lot, it occurred outside working hours, was committed by a non-employee, and was the result of an entirely personal dispute. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3399State v. Hayes (2018)
The appellant did not receive ineffective assistance when his trial counsel, at appellant's request, initiated a line of questioning during the cross-examination of the victim which ultimately permitted the State to elicit a positive identification of the appellant by the victim during her later testimony. Furthermore, even if we were to find that defense counsel was ineffective for questioning the victim regarding the identification of the suspect, the appellant cannot establish there was a reasonable probability that, but for his counsel's errors, the result of the trial would have been different. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3401In re M.B. (2018)
Appellant's counsel filed a brief under the authority of Anders v. California, 386 U.S. 738, 87 S.Ct. 1396, 18 L.Ed.2d 493 (1967). A thorough review of the record reveals no arguably meritorious appellate issues. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3402State v. Muse (2018)
The State has conceded error with regard to the trial court's failure to have a hearing to comply with R.C. 2953.52(B) before denying the appellant's application to seal his record. It is not apparent that the trial court weighed appellant's interest in sealing against any legitimate government need to maintain the record. Nor is there any indication that the trial court scheduled or held a hearing on the application before denying it. Judgment reversed and cause remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 3405State v. Mathew (2018)
Consecutive sentences
- 2018 Ohio 3406State v. Peck (2018)
Trial court did not err in appellant's mandatory felony drug trafficking sentence. Judgment affirmed. criminal
- 2018 Ohio 3408State v. Heiney (2018)
Gross sexual imposition convictions upheld where evidence supported findings that physician-defendant used force (by physically manipulating patients' clothing during medical examinations) to make sexual contact. Tampering with records conviction upheld
- 2018 Ohio 3410State v. Smith (2018)
Crim.R. 11(C) guilty plea having weapons while under disability participating in criminal gang.Defendant-appellant's convictions for participating in a criminal gang, having a weapon while under disability, and drug possession affirmed. The record demonstrates that the trial court fully complied with Crim.R. 11(C). The record is devoid of any confusion, hesitation, or protestations of innocence on defendant's part at the plea hearing. Defendant's argument that his plea was not knowingly, voluntarily, and intelligently made because the trial court did not advise him that having a weapon while under disability was a low-tier, third-degree felony was unpersuasive. The trial court advised defendant of the maximum penalties involved for his offenses as required under Crim.R. 11(C)(2)(a). Likewise, defendant's argument that the trial court should have concluded that he did not knowingly, voluntarily, or intelligently enter his guilty plea to participating in a criminal gang as a result of his post-plea statements at sentencing was unpersuasive.
- 2018 Ohio 3411State v. Noble (2018)
Aggravated vehicular homicide aggravated vehicular assault leaving the scene of an accident manifest weight of the evidence recklessness excessive speed failure to slow brakes headlights intoxication ineffective assistance of counsel opening statements motion in limine evidence of alcohol circumstantial evidence unfair prejudice. Defendant's convictions were not against the manifest weight of the evidence where evidence of excessive speed, failure to apply brakes, failure to illuminate headlights, and fleeing after the accident demonstrated that the defendant recklessly caused collision resulting in death and serious physical injuries to victims. Defense counsel was not ineffective even though he described the defendant as "freaking out" after the accident, failed to file a motion in limine or object to evidence of defendant's alcohol use, and decided not to seek funds to retain an accident reconstructionist where these decisions did not amount to deficient performance and the defendant could not demonstrate that counsel's actions prejudiced his defense.
- 2018 Ohio 3418State v. Lee (2018)
Plea colloquy, Crim.R. 11(C)(2)(a), nonconstitutional rights, substantial compliance, breach of plea agreement, parole recommendation, ineffective assistance of counsel
- 2018 Ohio 3419Miller v. Troyer (2018)
insurance policy, contract, horse-drawn buggy, motor vehicle, trailer, definitions, common meaning
- 2018 Ohio 3420State v. Zubaidah (2018)
municipal court, subject matter jurisdiction, R.C. 1901.20, R.C. 1901.02, insufficient praecipe, lack of transcript
- 2018 Ohio 3422State v. Fields (2018)
Appellant's conviction was supported by sufficient evidence where the state presented evidence that the shooting took place after the victim and appellant argued, appellant went into his house and armed himself, and then returned and shot the victim.
- 2018 Ohio 3424State v. Henderson (2018)
Application for reconsideration timely from second mailing date Extraordinary circumstances exist for delay in filing application Movant merely disagrees with logic and analysis of court Application denied.
- 2018 Ohio 3425Hills & Hollers v. Ohio Gatherings Co., L.L.C. (2018)
reconsideration denied issue was not specified in appellate brief no obvious legal error.
- 2018 Ohio 3427Citizens Bank, N.A. v. Leek (2018)
reconsideration denied bank's right to redeem residential property unsold at first auction by paying purchase price within 14 days of a subsequent auction R.C. 2329.311(A) minimum bid pursuant to R.C. 2329.52(B).
- 2018 Ohio 3428State v. Yarbrough (2018)
Appellate court and trial court do not have authority to alter or review the Ohio Supreme Court's decision that affirmed, reversed and vacated Appellant's convictions State v. Yarbrough, 104 Ohio St.3d 1, 2004-Ohio-6087 the matter was not remanded to the trial court.
- 2018 Ohio 3429State v. Panezich (2018)
Application for reconsideration untimely Movant merely disagrees with logic and analysis of court Application denied.
- 2018 Ohio 3430State v. Miller (2018)
defendant contends his constitutional rights were violated when he was convicted of multiple rape counts which were not differentiated in the indictment or bill of particulars and which he believes were not differentiated in his children's trial testimony no concerns as to whether the jury unanimously found him guilty of the same acts convictions affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3431State v. Baker (2018)
In examining whether a verdict is against the manifest weight of the evidnece, appellate courts are deferential to the jury, as finder of fact, in matters addressing the credibility of witnesses.
- 2018 Ohio 3432State v. Troiano (2018)
Appellant's sentence is not clearly and convincingly contrary to law because the prison term is within the statutory range and the record fully supports the trial court's sentencing decision to impose a four-year prison term.
- 2018 Ohio 3433State v. Miller (2018)
Miller's conviction for murder was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Miller unable to demonstrate prosecutorial misconduct or ineffective assistance of counsel.
- 2018 Ohio 3435State v. McRae (2018)
The trial court did not err in denying the motion to dismiss when although the lack of probable cause in the application for the warrant, the arresting officers had a good faith belief that the warrant was valid. Defendant was not denied the effective assistance of counsel. No instruction for voluntary manslaughter was required when the basic elements of the offense were not supported by the record. Defendant's speedy trial rights were not violated since his counsel had waived those rights due to the need for additional time to prepare the case for trial.
- 2018 Ohio 3436State v. Smith (2018)
Exigent circumstances/search
- 2018 Ohio 3437Lunsford v. Sterlite of Ohio, L.L.C. (2018)
Civ. R. 12(b)(6)/Invasion of privacy
- 2018 Ohio 3439Morford v. Morford (2018)
DOMESTIC RELATIONS - divorce motion to terminate spousal support cohabitation magistrate's decision inadmissible hearsay facts not in evidence reversible error substantial rights of the parties reversed burden of proof manifest weight of the evidence credibility day-to-day living expenses financial support significant visitation time actually residing together functional equivalent of a marriage.
- 2018 Ohio 3440State v. Barajas-Anguiano (2018)
CRIMINAL - felony sentencing consecutive sentences R.C. 2929.14(C)(4) plain error course of conduct harm caused by multiple offenses
- 2018 Ohio 3441Mentor v. Spehar (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - Mentor Codified Ordinance 505.13 App.R. 9(B) R.C. 715.23 R.C. 715.67 R.C. 3901.02(G)(2) R.C. 2901.03(A) R.C. 2904.04(A) Crim.R. 12(F) R.C. 1901.26(A)(1)(a) Crim.R. 1.
- 2018 Ohio 3443State v. Mahr (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - lack of a final appealable order Crim.R. 32(C) failure to state the fact of conviction failure to describe the crime or set forth Revised Code section number hanging charge time stamp jurisdiction
- 2018 Ohio 3444State v. Trimble (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - Crim.R. 33 motion for new trial evidentiary hearing newly discovered evidence reasonable diligence discovery due process.
- 2018 Ohio 3447In re Striff (2018)
On certified entry of felony conviction.
- 2018 Ohio 3451State v. Ervin (2018)
Manifest weight of the evidence Forgery Request for expert at state expense Opportunity to present complete defense Forfeiture of argument
- 2018 Ohio 3452State v. Miller (2018)
Trial court did not abuse discretion in denying motion to seal misdeameanor record.
- 2018 Ohio 3456State v. Walters (2018)
Disrupting public services domestic violence
- 2018 Ohio 3458State v. Williams (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3460State ex rel. Hutch v. Village of Bolivar (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3461State v. White (2018)
The trial court did not err in denying appellant's motion to set aside guilty plea and to dismiss. According to the Supreme Court of Ohio's recent decision in State v. Carnes, __ Ohio St.3d __, 2018-Ohio-3256, a juvenile adjudication may be used as a predicate offense to convict a person of having weapons while under disability without violating due process and State v. Hand, 149 Ohio St.3d 94, 2016-Ohio-5504.
- 2018 Ohio 346217AP-705 (2018)
Health and Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) does not create or constitute a private cause of action. Possible alternative state law claim is not available to pro se appellant who did not respond to appellee's request for admissions, thereby deemed admitted in support of summary judgement. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3463State v. Jones (2018)
The trial court did not err in denying defendant leave to file a delayed motion for a new trial.
- 2018 Ohio 3464State ex rel. v. McIntosh (2018)
Because Judge McIntosh had already ruled on the underlying motions, Monford's requested writ of procedendo will not issue to compel the performance of a duty that has already been performed.
- 2018 Ohio 3467H.S.B.C. Bank U.S.A. v. Brinson (2018)
summary judgment – foreclosure – personal judgment – standing – jurisdiction – raise any time – indorsements – assignments – note – mortgage
- 2018 Ohio 3468Georgia Banking Co. v. Summit Housing, L.L.C. (2018)
R.C. 2333.09, debtor's exam, alternative grounds for decision.
- 2018 Ohio 3469Scalise v. Johnston Invest., L.L.C. (2018)
tax foreclosure, in rem, personal jurisdiction
- 2018 Ohio 3471State v. Martucci (2018)
rape – gross sexual imposition – motion to suppress – factual findings – competent, credible evidence – sufficiency – burden of production – testimony of victim
- 2018 Ohio 3472Schutte v. Strittmatter (2018)
jury demand, magistrate's order, abuse of discretion, Civ.R. 38, Civ.R. 39(A), App.R. 12(A)(1)(c).
- 2018 Ohio 3473State v. Singh (2018)
Obstructing official business, risk of physical harm, illegal use or possession of drug paraphernalia, sufficiency of the evidence, Crim.R. 29, manifest weight of the evidence
- 2018 Ohio 3474State v. Tayse (2018)
motion for discharge – motion for appointed counsel – res judicata – R.C. 2971.03(A) –
- 2018 Ohio 3475Gupta v. Cleveland (2018)
Core Terms: public record court of claims R.C. 2743.75 R.C. 149.43(B) moot inspect promptly non-existent backup server email personal ambiguous overly broad. Overview: Requester sought to inspect city records relating to waste collection/disposal, and specific city employees. During litigation, the city produced over 24,000 pages of responsive records, denied most of the requests as overly broad, and stated there were no additional records responsive to the properly made requests. Requester asked the court to rule on several of the requests as modified in the course of mediation, rather than the original requests pled in her complaint. Requester claimed that the city had violated R.C. 149.43(B) by not searching its backup email server for responsive records, and by not requiring employees to search their personal email accounts, computers, cell phones, and other devices for responsive records. The special master found that under the facts and circumstances the city had no duty to search either its backup server or its employees' personal accounts and devices. The special master found that, other than as they had been rendered moot by the city's production of existing responsive records, requester's requests were ambiguous, overly broad, and therefore unenforceable.
- 2018 Ohio 3476DeCrane v. Cleveland (2018)
Core Terms: public record court of claims R.C. 2743.75 R.C. 149.43(B) moot ambiguous overly broad. Overview: Requester sought records of a division of fire employee, division drug-testing policy, and "all correspondence from the [division's] drug-testing contractor" for a two-month period. The City asserted that it had provided all records responsive to the first two requests, and that the third request was improperly ambiguous and overly broad. The Special Master recommended that the court find the first two requests were moot, and that the third claim was properly denied as both ambiguous and overly broad.
- 2018 Ohio 3477King v. Dept. of Job & Family Servs. (2018)
Core Terms: public record court of claims R.C. 2743.75 R.C. 149.43(B) email records ambiguous overly broad. Overview: Requester sought copies of all email between 24 pairs of correspondents for a nine-month period. Respondent denied the requests as overly broad, and further argued that a request for "emails" is not inherently a request that seeks "records." The special master found that the media category "emails" in an office includes both records and non-records, and non-records may be withheld from release. The special master found that these requests were properly denied as overly broad for demanding all email over a lengthy period not limited by message subject or topic. Requester filed objections stating that he had modified his requests during litigation so that they were not overly broad. Outcome: The court noted its previous rulings that revisions to requests during public records litigation do not relate back to the complaint. The court overruled the objection and adopted the special master's report and recommendation as its own.
- 2018 Ohio 3478King v. Dept. of Job & Family Servs. (2018)
Core Terms: public record court of claims R.C. 2743.75 R.C. 149.43(B) email records ambiguous overly broad. Overview: Requester sought copies of all email between 24 pairs of correspondents for a nine-month period. Respondent denied the requests as overly broad, and further argued that a request for "emails" is not inherently a request that seeks "records." The special master found that the media category "emails" in an office includes both records and non-records, and non-records may be withheld from release. The special master found that these requests were properly denied as overly broad for demanding all email over a lengthy period not limited by message subject or topic.
- 2018 Ohio 3479Ellis v. Cuyahoga Cty. Prosecutor's Office (2018)
Core Terms: public record court of claims R.C. 2743.75 R.C. 149.43(B)(8) inmate standing res judicata. Overview: Requester inmate and his designees sought records pertaining to his criminal case. The Prosecutor's Office argued that Ellis lacked standing to seek enforcement of requests filed by designees, that a previous determination rendered this case res judicata, and that Ellis had not complied with the procedure required by R.C. 149.43(B)(8) for inmates seeking law enforcement investigatory records. The Special Master recommended that the court find, 1) Ellis had standing to seek enforcement of requests filed by designees, 2) Ellis' previous action did not operate as res judicata, and 3) Ellis has not shown that he has complied with R.C. 149.43(B)(8), and thus is not entitled to production of records. Ellis objected that the special master erred in concluding that his designees were subject the same limitations in R.C. 149.43(B)(8) that applied to Ellis himself. Outcome: Based on Ellis' failure to affirmatively plead in his complaint that he met all of the requirements of R.C. 149.43(B)(8), the court modified the report and recommendation to find that the prosecutor's office's contention that Ellis had failed to state a claim upon which relief can be granted was not wholly without merit. The court overruled Ellis' objections, and adopted the special master's report and recommendation as modified.
- 2018 Ohio 3480Ellis v. Cuyahoga Cty. Prosecutor's Office (2018)
Core Terms: public record court of claims R.C. 2743.75 R.C. 149.43(B)(8) inmate standing res judicata. Overview: Requester inmate and his designees sought records pertaining to his criminal case. The Prosecutor's Office argued that Ellis lacked standing to seek enforcement of requests filed by his designees, that a previous determination involving a separate law enforcement agency rendered this case res judicata, and that Ellis had not complied with the procedure required in R.C. 149.43(B)(8) for inmates seeking law enforcement investigatory records. The Special Master recommended that the court find, 1) Ellis has standing to seek enforcement of requests filed by his designees, 2) Ellis' previous action did not operate as res judicata, and 3) Ellis has not shown that he has complied with R.C. 149.43(B)(8), and thus is not entitled to production of the requested records.
- 2018 Ohio 3481State v. Miller (2018)
Duplicity in indictment
- 2018 Ohio 3482State v.Norris (2018)
Motion for relief from dormant judgment - res judicata
- 2018 Ohio 3483Caldwell v. Marc's Deeper Discount Drug Stores, AKA Marc Glassman, Inc. (2018)
Open and Obvious Doctrine/Attendant Circumstances
- 2018 Ohio 3485State v. Lenzy (2018)
Suppression - reasonable suspicion - search incident to arrest
- 2018 Ohio 3486State v. Bell (2018)
Jury deliberations juror interview irregularities in proceedings
- 2018 Ohio 3487Village of Rayland v. Jenkins (2018)
Sovereign immunity retaliation constitutional claims termination of water services unified utility bill
- 2018 Ohio 3488State v. Hutter (2018)
Postrelease control completed original term of imprisonment improper notice of postrelease control
- 2018 Ohio 3489State ex rel. Citizens for Responsible Green Govt. v. Green (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Elections—Mandamus—Laches bars relief requested due to relator's failure to act with diligence in filing complaint 92 days before election—Cause dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 3490Farmer v. State (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3492State v. Jackson (2018)
Rape gross sexual imposition kidnapping hearsay next investigatory step confrontation clause harmless error manifest weight. Any error in admitting detective's testimony describing his interaction with victim when he arrived on scene was harmless. Defendant's convictions for rape, gross sexual imposition and kidnapping were not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 3494State v. Campbell (2018)
App.R. 26(B) application for reopening, untimely filed, failure to establish good cause for untimely filing. The applicant did not timely file an App.R. 26(B) application for reopening. The applicant has not established good cause for the untimely filing of the application for reopening as based upon the failure of a mail delivery system to timely deliver the application to the clerk of the appellate court. Notwithstanding the failure to establish good cause, a substantive review of the proposed assignments of error raised by the applicant fails to establish the claim of ineffective assistance of appellate counsel.
- 2018 Ohio 3495State v. Rogers (2018)
Admission of evidence authentication Evid.R. 901 chain of custody ineffective assistance of counsel felonious assault R.C. 2903.11 sufficiency serious physical harm R.C. 2901.01 manifest weight. The trial court did not err or abuse its discretion in permitting the introduction of the video evidence of the robbery. Appellant was not denied his constitutional right to the effective assistance of counsel. Because the record contains sufficient evidence of serious physical harm, appellant's felonious assault conviction was supported by sufficient evidence. Appellant's convictions are not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 3496State v. Stock (2018)
Motion to suppress, search warrant affidavit, probable cause, R.C. 2925.03, R.C. 2925.11, GPS warrant. The trial court did not err in denying appellant's motion to suppress based on the totality of the circumstances. Police corroborated information from the anonymous tipster, the information in the affidavit was not stale, and other indications of drug activities including high electricity consumption, foil-covered windows, and secure fencing established probable cause to issue a GPS warrant for appellant's vehicle.
- 2018 Ohio 3498State v. Richey (2018)
Appellant's convictions were supported by sufficient evidence and not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Trial court did not commit plain error by allowing the state to include references to appellant's untimely filing of his notice of alibi during closing arguments.
- 2018 Ohio 3499Hobnob, Inc. v. Ohio Liquor Control Comm. (2018)
The trial court erred in affirming the State Liquor Control Commission's order suspending appellant's liquor permit because the evidence before the commission was insufficient to support its finding that appellant furnished beer or intoxicating liquor to an intoxicated person in violation of R.C. 4301.22(B). Judgment reversed cause remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 3500Dailey v. Dept. of Rehab. & Corr. (2018)
Court of Claims did not err when it granted summary judgment to ODRC on appellant's false imprisonment claim because there was no factual dispute that appellant's sentence had not yet expired. Because the sentencing entries issued in 2000 and 20007 did not state the sentences imposed for the felony fleeing and eluding convictions were to be served concurrently to the sentences for which appellant had been paroled, ODRC had the authority to apply the mandatory consecutive sentencing provision of R.C. 2921.331(D) in calculating appellant's sentence expiration date. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3501State v. Cantrel (2018)
The trial court did not err in overruling Appellant's motion to suppress because the drug evidence at issue was discovered as the result of a lawful traffic stop, inventory search, and search incident to arrest. In addition, Appellant failed to establish that his trial counsel was ineffective in failing to make certain arguments regarding the validity of the inventory search. Trial counsel's decision not to pursue the arguments in question was a matter of trial strategy, and Appellant failed to demonstrate that the outcome of the proceedings would have been different had the arguments been made. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3504State v. Lucas (2018)
Anders appeal. The record reveals no non-frivolous issues for appellate review. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3505State v. Martin (2018)
Trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying defendant's petition for post-conviction relief without a hearing. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3506State v. Murphy (2018)
Defendant-appellant's convictions for sexual battery in violation of R.C. 2907.03(A)(7), for tampering with records in violation of R.C. 2913.42(A)(1), and for forgery in violation of R.C. 2913.31(A)(3) are supported by sufficient evidence and they are not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Further, R.C. 2907.03(A)(7) is not an unconstitutional statutory enactment. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3507State v. Silcott (2018)
Appellant's convictions for aggravated trafficking in drugs, aggravated possession of drugs, possessing criminal tools, and having weapons while under disability are supported by sufficient evidence and not against the manifest weight of the evidence. The trial court did not err, on the day of trial, in amending the indictment to reflect the correct amount of the drug involved in Count II, aggravated possession of drugs, since the indictment identified Count II as a felony of the second degree with mandatory time and correctly identified the offense as a violation of R.C. 2925.11(A),(C)(1)(c). Ineffective assistance of counsel is not demonstrated in defense counsel's failure to file a pre-trial motion to suppress and an affidavit of indigency at sentencing, since an audio-video recording of the controlled buy supports the confidential informant's version of events, and it is not established that an affidavit of indigency would have resulted in an absence of fines at sentencing. The trial court did not err in imposing mandatory sentences for aggravated trafficking in drugs and aggravated possession of drugs. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3508State v. Bigelow (2018)
Judicial sanction for violation of post-release control was properly imposed upon conviction for new offense in 2012. Appellant's 1997 sentencing entry complied with then-existing law concerning imposition of post-release control. Trial court did not have jurisdiction to resentence appellant in 2010, therefore, 1997 sentencing entry controlled. State v. Grimes, 151 Ohio St.3d 19, 2017-Ohio-2927, 85 N.E.3d 700, is not to be applied retroactively.
- 2018 Ohio 3509State v. Clinton (2018)
Trial court did not strictly comply with Crim.R. 11(C) because it completely failed to orally inform defendant of his constitutional right to require the state to prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt. The defendant's guilty plea was, therefore, invalid.
- 2018 Ohio 3510Gibsonburg Health, L.L.C. v. Miniet (2018)
An Ohio court lacks jurisdiction to enforce a subpoena issued by another state under the Uniform Depositions and Discovery Act. civil
- 2018 Ohio 3513State v. Jones (2018)
Appellant's felony sentence was not based upon findings not supported by the record or otherwise contrary to law. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3515Wray v. Sandusky 250-Perkins, L.L.C. (2018)
Trial court abuses its discretion where it states that based on its personal knowledge it finds that the witness is a "good witness."
- 2018 Ohio 3516State v. Salman (2018)
Trial court considered the mitigating and statutory factors in sentencing.
- 2018 Ohio 3517State v. Stewart (2018)
Burglary. Hearsay. Effective assistance of counsel. Motion for acquittal. Manifest weight of evidence. Criminal.
- 2018 Ohio 3519State v. Wise (2018)
Criminal: intimidation of a public servant R.C. 2921.03(A) sufficiency of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 3522J.Y. v. J.Y. (2018)
domestic violence civil protection order, objections, Civ.R. 65.1
- 2018 Ohio 3523State v. Palacios (2018)
motion to suppress, no contest plea, knowing voluntary intelligent plea
- 2018 Ohio 3524State v. Ross (2018)
retained counsel – counsel of choice – motion to disqualify – immediately appealable – conflict of interest – substantial risk – serious potential
- 2018 Ohio 3525State v. Dunlap (2018)
Disorderly conduct, sufficiency of the evidence, manifest weight of the evidence, Crim.R. 29, App.R. 16
- 2018 Ohio 3526Grubb & Assocs., LPA v. Brown (2018)
Civ.R. 12(B)(6), motion to dismiss, defamation, libel, tortious interference with a business relationship
- 2018 Ohio 3527BP Metals, L.L.C. v. Glass (2018)
The trial court erred by granting summary judgment in favor of defendant-appellee because there is a genuine issue of material fact whether plaintiff-appellant is a person entitled to enforce a negotiable instrument and, consequently, has standing to invoke the jurisdiction of the trial court. There is a genuine issue of material fact whether the parties intended to conduct the transaction by electronic means and create a binding contract within the meaning of R.C. Chapter 1306.
- 2018 Ohio 3528State v. Vanmeter (2018)
The trial court did not err by sentencing the defendant-appellant to 11 years in prison because the sentence is within the permissible statutory range, the trial court properly considered the criteria found in R.C. 2929.11 and 2929.12, and the record clearly and convincingly supports the trial court's findings under R.C. 2929.11 and 2929.12. The defendant-appellant waived his argument concerning the proportionality of his sentence because he failed to raise the issue before the trial court.
- 2018 Ohio 3529Link v. Wayne Ins. Group (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying Plaintiffs' motion to reconsider. Futher, the trial court did not err by its grant of summary judgment to the Defendant-Appellee. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3530State v. Denton (2018)
The trial court did not err in overruling the defendant-appellant's motion to suppress. The judgment of the trial court is affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3531State v. Alicea (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - Sentencing R.C. 2929.13(B)(1)(a) & (b) imposition of community control for fourth-degree felony exception factual finding as to application of exception R.C. 2953.08(G)(1) court's failure to state finding on record.
- 2018 Ohio 3532State v. Selvaggio (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - PLEAS, MOTIONS OTHER HEARINGS - aggravated disorderly conduct R.C. 2917.11(E)(3)(a) a defendant must show a manifest injustice to withdraw a plea pursuant to Crim.R. 32.1.
- 2018 Ohio 3533In re Guardianship of Rosenberger (2018)
PROBATE - guardianship R.C. 2111.50(A)(1) motion to intervene nomination of power of attorney R.C. 2111.121 interested party R.C. 2111.02(A) notice of hearing R.C. 2111.04(A)(2)
- 2018 Ohio 3534State v. Jones (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCING/FINES, RESTITUTION, EXPUNGEMENT - trial court did not err in denying appellant's motion for reconsideration to correct the sentencing entry to show he pled guilty to count 4 (attempted felony murder) rather than count 3 (attempted purposeful murder) because this was not a simple clerical error that could be corrected appellant's motion sought to change the name or identity of the offense to which he pled guilty, which is not the province of a motion to correct a sentencing entry.
- 2018 Ohio 3536State v. Green (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - guilty plea murder firearm specification full colloquy jointly-recommended sentence Anders brief request to withdraw ineffective assistance of trial counsel no errors wholly frivolous.
- 2018 Ohio 3537Ferrara v. Liberty Twp. Zoning Bd. of Appeals (2018)
ZONING - township board of zoning appeals administrative appeal zoning ordinance constitutional single family district conditional use private club pretextual commercial enterprise residential area guest lodging court of common pleas should not substitute its judgment for that of an administrative board.
- 2018 Ohio 3538Dahmen v. Black (2018)
CIVIL - prescriptive easement magistrate's decision objections Civ.R. 53(D) plain error adverse or hostile use claim of right permissive use
- 2018 Ohio 3539State v. Shrider (2018)
Vehicular Homocide Sentencing State's Breach of Plea Agreement
- 2018 Ohio 3540State v. Olagbemiro (2018)
AUTOMOBILES – CONSTITUTIONAL LAW/CRIMINAL – SEARCH AND SEIZURE: The trial court did not err by denying defendant's motion to suppress drugs, claimed to be the fruits of an illegal search of the passenger compartment of an automobile during a lawful traffic stop, because a limited protective search of the automobile was warranted for officer safety where the police possessed a reasonable belief, based on the totality of the circumstances, including the observance of furtive movements and some corroboration of a tip from a confidential informant, that defendant, who was the passenger, was trafficking in heroin, was dangerous, and may have gained immediate control of a weapon.
- 2018 Ohio 3541State v. Siemering (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW—SENTENCING—JURISDICTION—CONSTITUTIONAL LAW/CRIMINAL: The common pleas court had no jurisdiction to entertain defendant's postconviction motion seeking resentencing for his community-control violations, because the motion was not reviewable under any postconviction procedure provided by statute or rule, and his sentences were not void: the trial court had not demonstrably lacked the authority to impose a prison term, because in the absence of a transcript of the prior sentencing hearing, the record cannot be said to show the alleged deficiency in R.C. 2929.19(B)(4) notification and the trial court, in originally sentencing defendant, had had the discretion and statutory authority to order that his community-control sanctions be served consecutively to the prison term imposed for another offense.
- 2018 Ohio 3542State v. Walker (2018)
Judgment affirmed. Appellant's merger arguments do not rely on any evidence outside the record. Appellant had the opportunity to raise his merger arguments at sentencing or thereafter in a direct appeal. Appellant failed to do so and as a result his claims are barred by res judicata.
- 2018 Ohio 3547State v. Lazier (2018)
Appellant's sentence was not contrary to law where appellant was sentenced within the statutory range, was informed of postrelease control issues, and the trial court considered the requisite statutory factors for sentencing.
- 2018 Ohio 3550State v. Coteat (2018)
State v. Hand, prior juvenile adjudication, disability element, having weapons while under disability, R.C. 2923.13(A)(2), State v. Carnes
- 2018 Ohio 3552State v. Riggs (2018)
Denial of motion for relief from judgment seeking a resentencing
- 2018 Ohio 3554State v. Leach (2018)
GSI prosecutorial midconduct
- 2018 Ohio 3555State v. Roberts (2018)
Unauthorized Use of a Motor Vehiccle
- 2018 Ohio 3558State v. Butler (2018)
Petition for Post-Conviction Relief
- 2018 Ohio 3560State v. Chandler (2018)
Post Conviction Relief Alibi Witness
- 2018 Ohio 3561Sanctuary Condominium Assn., Inc. v. Castro (2018)
App.R. 4(A), untimely appeal, Civ.R. 60(B), motion to vacate judgment. This court's dismissal of appellant's previous untimely appeal pursuant to App.R. 4(A) divested the trial court of jurisdiction to take further actions on the merits of the case where the dismissal was not challenged by further appeal or a motion to vacate the prior judgment that remains in effect.
- 2018 Ohio 3562Daniels v. Northcoast Anesthesia Providers, Inc. (2018)
Cumulative error. The cumulative effect of multiple trial errors deprived the defendants of a fair trial. Cumulative error doctrine applies to civil cases.
- 2018 Ohio 3563State v. Ford (2018)
Rape kidnapping defense witness ineffective assistance of counsel mistrial prejudicial testimony Evid.R. 806 Evid.R. 609 Crawford violation Sixth Amendment Evid.R. 803(4) sufficiency of the evidence manifest weight of the evidence. Judgment affirmed. Defendant's rape and kidnapping convictions affirmed where the state presented sufficient evidence and the evidence is not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Defense counsel was not ineffective by calling Dr. Layton as a defense witness because the defendant was provided with the opportunity he requested — testimony that would assist with his defense. A reviewing court may not second guess decisions of counsel that can be considered matters of trial strategy. The trial court did not abuse its discretion when it denied defendant's motion for a mistrial because defendant essentially testified without taking the stand and could be impeached under Evid.R. 806 and 609. Victim's statements to medical professional that medical professional testified to at trial are admissible under Evid.R. 803(4) and do not violate the confrontation clause.
- 2018 Ohio 3566State v. Hundley (2018)
Prearrest silence, Fifth Amendment to United States Constitution, Article I, Section 10, Ohio Constitution, manifest weight of the evidence, Evid.R. 609, effective assistance of counsel. Appellant's constitutional right to remain silent was not infringed by the state's reference during trial to appellant's prearrest silence because appellant was not in custody at the time, appellant testified at trial that opened the door to impeachment evidence, the trial court is presumed to consider only relevant, material, and competent evidence during the bench trial, and the record does not demonstrate that the allegedly unlawful testimony contributed to the conviction. Appellant's conviction was not against the manifest weight of the evidence where eyewitnesses testified appellant removed the firearm from his waist band, pointed, and fired and appellant admitted ownership and possession of the gun. Counsel was not ineffective in failing to impeach a witness under Evid.R. 609 where counsel was able to elicit testimony regarding the witness' criminal history and appellant could not demonstrate that, but for the error, the outcome of the trial would have been different.
- 2018 Ohio 3568Scheel v. Rock Ohio Caesars Cleveland, L.L.C. (2018)
Summary judgment, negligence, duty, foreseeability, spoliation of evidence. The trial court properly awarded summary judgment on the appellant's negligence claim to the appellee-security company because it did not have a duty to ensure that the Casino's security plan was adequate, and the appellant's injury was not foreseeable to the security company. The trial court also properly awarded summary judgment on the appellant's spoliation of evidence claim to the security company because the appellant offered no evidence creating a genuine issue of material fact as to whether the security company had possession or control over the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 3569State v. Foster (2018)
Felonious assault sufficiency of the evidence manifest weight serious physical harm. Defendant-appellant's felonious conviction was supported by sufficient evidence where there was significant testimony and documentary evidence regarding the extent of the victim's injuries. The defendant-appellant's conviction was not against the manifest weight of the evidence because the totality of the evidence showed that the victim suffered serious physical harm.
- 2018 Ohio 3570Berry v. Progressive Direct Ins. Co. (2018)
Civ.R. 56/summary judgment Civ.R. 36/ requests for admissions. Appellant failed to apply the remedies available to her to obtain the documents she claimed she needed in order to answer appellee's requests for admissions. The disputed admissions were properly deemed admitted. The cooperation clause in an insurance policy is an enforceable contract provision. The trial court's grant of appellee's motion for summary judgment on appellee's denial of appellant's alleged theft claim was proper. Appellant failed to cooperate in appellee's investigation of appellant's alleged theft claim and also failed to respond to appellee's motion for summary judgment.
- 2018 Ohio 3571Cleveland v. Andujar (2018)
Conceded error explanation of circumstances. Reversible error occurs if a trial court enters a finding of guilt on a no contest plea where there was not an explanation of circumstances or an explicit waiver and such an error is akin to the failure to establish facts sufficient to support a conviction.
- 2018 Ohio 3576State v. Bell (2018)
Because the trial court correctly provided notice of postrelease control at the sentencing hearing but failed to properly incorporate notice in the sentencing entry, the judgment must be remanded for the trial court to issue a nunc pro tunc entry correcting the deficiencies.
- 2018 Ohio 3577State v. Oggs (2018)
The sufficiency of the evidence and the manifest weight of the evidence support Oggs' convictions for receiving stolen property and theft from a person in a protected class.
- 2018 Ohio 3578State ex rel. Dodson v. Brown (2018)
Action dismissed for failure to comply with R.C. 2969.25.
- 2018 Ohio 3586State v. Minarik (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3595Pfalzgraf v. Miley (2018)
reconsideration motion denied en banc consideration denied
- 2018 Ohio 3597Nationwide Mut. Fire Ins. Co. v. Pusser (2018)
summary judgment coverage existed for a vehicle-pedestrian fatality Allstate Ins. Co. v. Boggs, 27 Ohio St.2d 216, 271 N.E.2d 855 (1971) warranties vs. representations use of the words "may" and "could" did not clearly and unambiguously put the insured on notice that a misstatement would render a policy void ab initio
- 2018 Ohio 3598Booher v. Brace Quest Corp. (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion by finding the arbitration provision at issue to be enforceable. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3599State v. Evilsizor (2018)
While on post-release control, defendant committed two separate offenses on different dates and was charged in separate cases for the new offenses. At a joint plea hearing on the new offenses, the trial court erred in informing the defendant that it could terminate defendant's post-release control in both cases and order prison sentences for the violation in both cases to be served consecutively. However, we find no basis to conclude that defendant was prejudiced by the trial court's erroneous notification. After terminating defendant's post-release control, the trial court erred in imposing a sentence for violating post-release control based on the amount of time remaining on defendant's post-release control as of the time of the offense, rather than the amount of time he had remaining on post-release control at sentencing. Judgment affirmed as to the case where the court did not impose a prison sentence for the violation of post-release control. In the case where a prison sentence was imposed for the post-release control violation, the prison sentence for the violation of post-release control is reversed, and the matter is remanded for resentencing on that issue in all other respects, that judgment is affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3600In re K.B. (2018)
The record does not support Appellant's contention that the trial court was prejudiced or biased against him, and an appellate court cannot review whether the magistrate or trial judge should have been disqualified. The trial court erred by overruling Appellant's objections to the magistrate's decision prior to expiration of the time for filing a transcript under Juv.R. 40(D)(3)(b)(iii). Judgment reversed and case remanded for further proceedings.
- 2018 Ohio 3601State v. Laster (2018)
Any error in the certificate of assignment of a visiting judge was voidable, not void. Nonetheless, Appellant waived this procedural error and there is no reason to notice plain error. The trial court also did not err in overruling Appellant's motion to suppress evidence. When Appellant was detained and questioned, he was not in custody and the police were not required to administer Miranda warnings. Further, since Appellant's statements were not obtained during custodial interrogation, statements that he later made after being given Miranda warnings were admissible. Finally, Appellant waived any error with respect to the reliability of an anonymous tip, as he failed to raise the issue in the trial court, and there is no plain error concerning this point. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3602Smith v. Hess (2018)
Trial court did not err by granting partial summary judgment in favor of the defendant in a personal injury action where the undisputed evidence showed that plaintiff's injuries from a fall on a hillside adjacent to the scene of the automobile accident were not proximately caused by the defendant's negligence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3603Staub v. Miller (2018)
In this appeal, Appellant challenges the trial court's decision to grant Appellee's Civ.R. 60(B) motion for relief from judgment. The judgment that was vacated was a stalking protection order. However, the trial court subsequently dismissed Appellant's petition for the stalking protection order and Appellant failed to appeal from that judgment. As a result, there is no relief that can be afforded to Appellant, and the current appeal is moot. Even if the judgment setting aside the protection order could be considered, Appellee demonstrated excusable neglect. Appeal dismissed as moot.
- 2018 Ohio 3604Williams v. Dept. of Rehab. & Corr. (2018)
Negligence, Wrongful Death- An inmate, in defendant's custody who initiated a fight, died after being stabbed by the inmate with whom he fought. In overruling plaintiff's objections to the magistrate's decision, which recommended judgment in favor of defendant, the court found defendant lacked notice of threats or danger to the decedent. The court also found no error in the magistrate's determination that the decedent's contributory negligence in initiating the fight outweighed any potential negligence on the part of defendant. The court adopted the magistrate's decision and granted judgment to defendant.
- 2018 Ohio 3605Demetriades v. Ohio Lottery Comm. (2018)
Breach of Contract, Negligence- After purchasing a winning scratch-off lottery ticket and receiving $500, plaintiff claimed the ticket was actually a $500,000 winner. On summary judgment, defendant presented evidence which established that plaintiff's ticket was only a $500 winner and that the limited number of $500,000 winning tickets were all claimed. The court found defendant did not commit a breach of contract, that an independent bad faith claim could not be asserted, and that the economic loss rule barred any negligence claim. The court granted summary judgment to defendant.
- 2018 Ohio 3606Oakley v. Ohio State Univ. Wexner Med. Ctr. (2018)
FLSA, Class Certification- Plaintiffs sought conditional certification of an FLSA class pursuant to 29 USC 216(b) based on a clock-in and clock-out rounding policy. The magistrate found that potential plaintiffs were identified and submitted affidavits. However, the magistrate found evidence of a widespread discriminatory practice lacking because defendant did not uniformly enforce the clock-in and clock-out rounding policy and, therefore, that plaintiffs could not prove a violation as to all plaintiffs. Thus, the magistrate recommended denial of conditional class certification.
- 2018 Ohio 3608State v. Hayes (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3609State ex rel. Harris v. Rubino (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Mandamus—Writ of mandamus sought to compel city finance director or city council and county board of elections to place zoning ordinance proposed by initiative petition on the November 2018 ballot—City charter does not clearly and expressly conflict with the requirements of R.C. 731.28—City council did not have a clear legal duty to submit the proposal to the board of elections—City finance director ordered to certify the sufficiency and validity of the initiative petition for placement on the November 2018 ballot—Costs and attorney fees awarded—Writ granted in part and denied in part.
- 2018 Ohio 3611Talarek v. Colton (2018)
condemnation, demolition, procedural due process, 42 U.S.C. 1983, summary judgment, affidavit
- 2018 Ohio 3613State v. Fluttrow (2018)
Defendant-appellant's operating-a-vehicle-while-under-the-influence-of-alcohol-or-drugs conviction is not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Defendant-appellant's trial counsel was not ineffective.
- 2018 Ohio 3614State v. Rutschilling (2018)
The trial court did not err in imposing consecutive sentences when all required findings were made and the findings were supported by the record.
- 2018 Ohio 3615State v. Williams (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion by denying defendant-appellant's presentence motion to withdraw his guilty pleas.
- 2018 Ohio 3617State v. Schofield (2018)
Appellant's petition for postconviction relief was barred by res judicata. Appellant further failed to support his petition on substantive grounds to warrant a hearing on the petition. Appellant's petition did not comport with the statutory requirements to be a valid habeas corpus petition.
- 2018 Ohio 3618State v. McWay (2018)
Trial counsel does not have to pursue every line of inquiry when investigating mitigating factors for sentencing.
- 2018 Ohio 3619State v. Wieser (2018)
Appellant's convictions for OVI and failure to maintain reasonable control were supported by sufficient evidence and were not against the manifest weight of the evidence. The record does not support Appellant's claim that the trial court was bias.
- 2018 Ohio 3621State v. Johnson (2018)
Trial court erred by imposing two-year mandatory prison term for third-degree felony OVI offense.
- 2018 Ohio 3622Crane Serv. & Inspections, L.L.C. v. Cincinnati Specialty Underwriters Ins. Co. (2018)
Trial court abused its discretion in precluding an insured company from conducting and obtaining any discovery prior to granting summary judgment in favor of the insurance company.
- 2018 Ohio 3623State v. Bennett (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in permitting the state to cross-examine a defense witness about a prior specific instance of appellant's conduct where appellant opened the door to the character evidence by questioning the witness about appellant's character for appropriate behavior with women. Furthermore, appellant's conviction for sexual imposition was supported by sufficient evidence and was not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 3624Tyler v. W. Brown Local School (2018)
Appellants, a school district and its employee, appeal the court's decision denying the employee's motion for judgment on the pleadings in a personal injury action. The trial court properly denied the employee's motion where it could not be demonstrated, beyond doubt, that the plaintiff had no viable claim against the employee.
- 2018 Ohio 3625Disciplinary Counsel v. Baldwin (2018)
On certified order of the Supreme Court of Illinois.
- 2018 Ohio 3626Andolsek v. Polstein (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - Motion for reconsideration is a nullity does not extend the time to appeal a final judgment App.R. 4 Civ.R. 58(B), untimely appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 3627State v. Hubbard (2018)
CRIMINAL - Nonsupport of Dependents R.C. 2919.21(A)(2) and (B) State v. Pittman current obligation to pay support arrearage-only order emancipation
- 2018 Ohio 3628State v. Braun (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - domestic violence fair trial due process of law abuse of discretion standard Evid.R. 401, 402, 403(A), 404(B) R.C. 2903.211 manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 3629Kennedy v. Specht (2018)
CIVIL - conversion bailment failure to state a claim dismissal Civ.R. 12(B)(6) prosecutorial immunity R.C. 2744.03(A)(7) common law investigative/administrative functions
- 2018 Ohio 3631State ex rel. Bales v. Dept. of Agriculture (2018)
Destruction of Deer Taking of Property
- 2018 Ohio 3633Rink v. Dept. of Rehab. and Corr. (2018)
Because appellant's civil action against the state was determined administratively by the clerk of the Court of Claims, the judgment is not subject to further appeal. Appeal sua sponte dismissed for the lack of jurisdiction.
- 2018 Ohio 3634State v. Rexrode (2018)
Trial court's judgment finding proper service was not based upon insufficient evidence and was not against the manifest weigh of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 3635DeMatteo v. State Teachers Retirement Sys. (2018)
Writ of mandamus granted ordering respondent to accept relator's appeal and to provide her the opportunity to present additional medical evidence regarding whether she is entitled to disability benefits.
- 2018 Ohio 3636Gatling Ohio, L.L.C. v. Allegheny Energy Supply Co., L.L.C. (2018)
Judgment affirmed in part and reversed in part. Although the trial court applied an erroneous interpretation of what constituted "commercial and operational neutrality" under the parties' coal sales agreement, the manifest weight of the evidence supported its ultimate conclusion that the seller's substitute coal did not comply with the agreement's neutrality requirement. Because the trial court erred by applying the statutory rate of prejudgment interest to the damages award instead of the interest rate in the agreement, the cause is remanded for the sole purpose of the application of the appropriate rate. In all other respects, the judgment is affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3638Bank of Am., N.A. v. Smith (2018)
PROCEDURE/RULES — FORECLOSURE — DEFAULT JUDGMENT – CIV.R. 55: The trial court properly denied defendants-mortgagors' motion to dismiss the complaint in an in rem foreclosure action where plaintiff mortgagee had attached to its complaint a valid copy of the assignment of the mortgage and a note that referenced the mortgage and had alleged that it was seeking only to enforce its security interest against the property it was entitled to enforce the promissory note, which contained a blank indorsement in its name and it was the assignee of the mortgage at the time of the foreclosure action. The trial court erred under Civ.R. 55 by adopting the magistrate's decision and granting a default judgment in favor of plaintiff where defendants had appeared and "otherwise defended" against the allegations in plaintiff's complaint by filing a timely motion and an amended motion to dismiss the complaint and by removing the case to federal court the magistrate had failed to give defendants 14 days to file a responsive pleading after ruling on their motion to dismiss, in violation of Civ.R. 12(A)(2) and the magistrate had applied the Civ.R. 56 summary-judgment standard instead of the Civ.R. 55 default-judgment standard.
- 2018 Ohio 3639In re T.J. (2018)
CHILDREN—TEMPORARY CUSTODY: The juvenile court did not err in adjudicating the child abused and dependent and in determining that it was in the child's best interest to be placed in the temporary custody of a children's services agency where the record contained evidence that the child suffered from mental-health issues and had extensive behavioral problems at school, and mother refused to recognize the child's fault in these aggressive incidents and refused offered therapeutic services for the child mother had thrown a mirror at the child the child expressed that she did not want to return to mother's care mother and child had a volatile relationship and mother had refused to sign a release of information, a necessary prerequisite to participating in a diagnostic assessment. Where the magistrate and the child were able to effectively communicate in an in camera hearing held via a video teleconference, and the child was able to clearly articulate her feelings regarding placement despite being hospitalized, the juvenile court did not err in overruling mother's motion to set aside the magistrate's order reflecting that the in camera hearing had taken place and continuing the matter for disposition. Where a children's services agency was not required to obtain an agreement between the parties before filing a proposed change to a case plan, and where mother failed to file objections and request a hearing after receiving notice of the proposed change to the case plan, the juvenile court did not err by approving and incorporating the amended case plan.
- 2018 Ohio 3640State v. Pennington (2018)
COUNSEL – EVIDENCE/WITNESS/TRIAL – HOMICIDE – INVITED ERROR – EVID.R. 404(B) – EVID.R. 405 – EVID.R. 609: Trial counsel's decision not to call a forensic pathology expert and instead rely on cross-examination of the state's forensic pathology expert fell within the wide range of reasonable professional assistance and did not constitute ineffective assistance of counsel. Defendant failed to establish that prejudice resulted from trial counsel's decision not to call a forensic pathology expert where nothing in the record indicated that testimony from another forensic pathologist would have been favorable to defendant and would have altered the outcome of the trial. Defendant could not establish that trial counsel was ineffective for failing to discover that the model of handgun used in a murder offense was the subject of a class-action lawsuit that had alleged defects with the handgun's firing, because defendant's allegations of ineffectiveness were based on facts not appearing in the record. The appellate court will not second-guess trial counsel's decision not to call a witness, because that is a matter of trial strategy. In defendant's trial for murder and having weapons while under a disability, the trial court properly admitted into evidence a weapon and ammunition not used in the shooting of the victim where the evidence was relevant to the question of whether defendant knowingly possessed any firearm, for purposes of the weapons-under-disability charge, and the admission of the evidence did not contravene Evid.R. 404(B). Defendant cannot challenge testimony elicited during his cross-examination of a state's witness on hearsay and confrontation grounds, because any error in the admission of the testimony was invited or induced by the defendant. The appellate court engages in the presumption that, in a bench trial, even where defense counsel has failed to object to a prosecutor's question to a witness, the trial court is able to distinguish between what the prosecutor tries to get the witness to say and the witness's actual testimony. Where the defense elicited testimony about defendant's nonviolent character, the trial court did not err by allowing the prosecutor to rebut the character evidence by inquiring into a prior domestic-violence complaint against defendant, even though the complaint had not resulted in a conviction. The ten-year limitation in Evid.R. 609 for use of evidence of a prior conviction for impeachment purposes does not apply if it is being used as a prior specific instance of conduct pursuant to Evid.R. 405. Defendant's murder conviction under R.C. 2903.02(A) was based upon sufficient evidence, because a rational trier of fact could have concluded beyond a reasonable doubt that defendant had purposely killed the victim by shooting her in the face where a forensic pathologist opined that the manner of death was homicide and not suicide as claimed by defendant, and the state presented evidence that defendant was the only other person in the home at the time of the shooting, defendant had been so angry with the victim that the victim was scared that defendant would harm her, the murder weapon was clean and devoid of blood and other matter that, according to experienced investigators, would normally be present if the gunshot wound had been self-inflicted, and defendant lied about having the gun.
- 2018 Ohio 3643State v. Faggs (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3647Hinton v. Shoop (2018)
Trial court did not err in granting Warden's Civ.R.12(B)(6) motion for dismissal for failure to state a claim.
- 2018 Ohio 3648Haney v. Cleveland (2018)
Core Terms: public record court of claims R.C. 2743.75 R.C. 149.43 moot promptly ambiguous overly broad revise. Overview: Requester requested public records and filed this action having received no records after 30 days. Haney received the records responsive to six of the eight requests during mediation, and elected to voluntarily dismiss the other two. The special master recommended the court find that all Haney's requests had been rendered moot or voluntarily dismissed, but that the City had failed to promptly provide personnel records, and further failed to provide Haney the information and opportunity to revise requests pursuant to R.C. 149.43(B)(2). Neither party filed objections. Outcome: The court found no error of law or other defect on the face of the special master's decision and adopted the report and recommendation as its own.
- 2018 Ohio 3649Haney v. Cleveland (2018)
Core Terms: public record court of claims R.C. 2743.75 R.C. 149.43 moot promptly ambiguous overly broad revise. Overview: Requester requested various public records, including personnel files, and filed this action having received no records after 30 days. Haney received the records responsive to six of the eight requests during mediation, and elected to voluntarily dismiss the other two. The special master recommended the court find that all Haney's requests had been rendered moot or voluntarily dismissed, but that the City had failed to promptly provide personnel records, and further failed to provide Haney information and opportunity to revise requests pursuant to R.C. 149.43(B)(2).
- 2018 Ohio 3650DeCrane v. Cleveland (2018)
public record court of claims R.C. 2743.75 R.C. 149.43 R.C. 149.011(G) moot non-record non-existent personal. Overview: Requester sought all written correspondence between a government attorney and a union attorney, and work or personal itemized call logs, and work or personal voicemails. Respondent asserted that it had provided all written work correspondence and phone logs kept by the city, denied any duty to search the employee's personal devices or accounts, and stated that no responsive voicemails existed. The special master found that the claim was moot as to official records of the office. The special master found that requester provided no evidence that the official copy of any requested record had been kept on a city employee's personal device, and failed to show that the city's search and retrieval process violated R.C. 149.43(B). The special master found that requester provided no evidence that the city required, received, or kept employee personal telephone records to document the activities of the office, and thus failed to show that personal call detail documents were "records" of the office.
- 2018 Ohio 3651DeCrane v. Cleveland (2018)
public record court of claims R.C. 2743.75 R.C. 149.43 moot: ambiguous overly broad. Overview: Requester sought all records "generated while processing" a previous public records request. Respondent denied the request as ambiguous and overly broad. The special master found that the claim was moot as to the records provided to requester in the city's response to the previous request, and as to previous request correspondence already in requester's possession. The special master found that the request was ambiguous and overly broad, and that the city had properly offered the opportunity to discuss revision of the request.
- 2018 Ohio 3652Hinners v. Huron (2018)
public record court of claims R.C. 2743.75 R.C. 149.43 attorney-client non-responsive. Overview: Requester sought 21 e-mail chains. Respondent asserted that portions of the emails constituted attorney-client privileged material, and that some emails included within the chains were not responsive to the request for emails between two persons that "includes messages in which either of the above are copied to the correspondence." The special master found that emails attached through a forwarding or reply command were included by the sender as part of the email chain and, under the facts and circumstances of this case, were responsive to the terms of the request. The special master found that none of the emails contained language expressly requesting or delivering legal advice on an identified legal issue, and recommended the court grant requester's claim for production.
- 2018 Ohio 3653Anderson v. Greater Cleveland Regional Transit Auth. (2018)
public record court of claims R.C. 2743.75 R.C. 149.43 timeliness moot. Overview: Requester and his representatives made 94 public records requests, and claimed that respondent had failed to respond to fourteen of the requests within a reasonable period of time. Respondent presented evidence that it had provided the requested records within 23 business days after the request. The special master found that under the facts and circumstances of the case the records had been timely provided.
- 2018 Ohio 3654Dillingham v. Butler Cty. Prosecutor's Office (2018)
public record court of claims R.C. 2743.75 R.C. 149.43(B)(8) inmate delivery R.C. 2930. Overview: Requester inmate sought records pertaining to his criminal case, as well as to a criminal investigation he had initiated against an investigating officer. The Prosecutor's Office argued that Dillingham had not complied with the procedure required in R.C. 149.43(B)(8) for inmates seeking law enforcement investigatory records, and that it had never received Dillingham's public records request. The Special Master recommended that the court find, 1) the court had no authority over Dillingham's claim to enforce R.C. Chapter 2930, 2) Dillingham failed to show that he had actually delivered his request, and 3) Dillingham had not shown that he complied with R.C. 149.43(B)(8), and respondent thus had no duty to produce the requested records.
- 2018 Ohio 3658State v. Dunlap (2018)
motion to suppress, traffic stop, reasonable articulable suspicion, Miranda waiver, fruit of the poisonous tree
- 2018 Ohio 3660In re R.L.B. (2018)
certificate of qualification for employment – petition – R.C. 2953.25 – statutory factors – abuse of discretion
- 2018 Ohio 3661Absolute Resolutions X, L.L.C. v. Ratta (2018)
summary judgment, Civ.R. 56(E), assignee, real party in interest, chain of title
- 2018 Ohio 3663State v. Spaulding (2018)
aggravated murder, death penalty, petition for post-conviction relief, ineffective assistance of counsel, prosecutorial misconduct, cumulative error, res judicata, application for DNA testing
- 2018 Ohio 3666State v. Wilson (2018)
Crim.R. 14, joinder severance waiver effective assistance of counsel consecutive sentences nunc pro tunc. Defendant's guilty plea waived his right to challenge the denial of his Crim.R. 14 motion to sever, and he failed to demonstrate how the joinder of his cases affected his decision to enter into a guilty plea. Defendant failed to demonstrate how the trial court's decision denying his motion for removal of counsel affected the knowing and voluntary nature of his plea. He was not denied effective assistance of counsel when counsel agreed to a recommended sentence. The record demonstrated that the sentence was only a recommendation and not binding, and the defendant could have advocated for a lesser sentence. Consecutive sentence findings were properly made and supported by the record the issuance of a nunc pro tunc is the proper remedy when the trial court fails to incorporate those findings in the sentencing journal entry.
- 2018 Ohio 3667State v. Oliver (2018)
Right to confrontation Skype motion to suppress hotel guest search. Trial court did not err in allowing a witness who was unavailable to testify at trial via Skype. Trial court committed harmless error in allowing another witness who was merely inconvenienced to testify at trial via Skype. Appellant's burden of proving on appeal whether a motion to suppress would have been granted is difficult based on the trial transcript record. But even looking at the record as presented, there was not a reasonable probability that a motion to suppress would have been granted.
- 2018 Ohio 3668State v. Buehner (2018)
Motion for leave to file motion for new trial Crim.R. 33 motion for new trial Brady material unavoidably prevented newly discovered evidence exculpatory evidence reasonable probability postconviction relief ineffective assistance of counsel. Denial of motion for leave to file a motion for new trial without a hearing was an abuse of discretion where the state failed to disclose exculpatory evidence in pretrial. However, because it was unclear whether the exculpatory evidence would have changed the outcome of the trial, the case was remanded for a hearing on the motion for new trial.
- 2018 Ohio 3669State v. Walker (2018)
Preindictment delay due process actual prejudice burden of proof unavailability. Trial court erred in finding actual prejudice caused by preindictment delay where defendant failed to establish that two of the three "missing" witnesses were truly unavailable and failed to show actual prejudice as a result of the actual availability of the third witness.
- 2018 Ohio 3670State v. Johnson (2018)
Attempted felony murder R.C. 2923.02 and 2903.02(B) cognizable claim void vacate merged resentence aggravated arson R.C. 2909.02(A)(1) R.C. 2909.02(A)(2) knowingly R.C. 2901.22(B) substantial risk R.C. 2901.01(A)(8) serious physical harm to persons R.C. 2901.01(A)(5) expert Evid.R. 702 abuse of discretion qualified reliable Crim.R. 52(B) plain error consecutive sentences R.C. 2929.14(C)(4) restitution R.C. 2929.18(A)(1) reasonable degree of certainty competent, credible evidence evidentiary hearing remand. Vacated appellant's conviction and sentence for felony attempted murder under R.C. 2923.02 and 2903.02(B) because it is not a cognizable claim and is void. Appellant's convictions for aggravated arson were not against the manifest weight of the evidence, and the challenged convictions were based upon sufficient evidence. The trial court did not abuse its discretion by permitting expert to testify as to the cause and origin of the fire, and no plain error occurred. Trial court's imposition of consecutive sentences was upheld. The amount of restitution ordered was arbitrary because the state did not present sufficient competent, credible evidence from which the trial court could discern the appropriate amount of restitution to a reasonable degree of certainty. Case was remanded to the trial court for resentencing on Count 2 only, which had been merged with the vacated count, and for an evidentiary hearing to determine the appropriate amount of restitution.
- 2018 Ohio 3671State v. Carter (2018)
Dying declaration excited utterance other acts evidence motive limiting instruction felony murder independent-felony/merger doctrine jury instructions lesser included and inferior offenses provocation manifest weight of the evidence. Defendant's conviction for murder and felonious assault affirmed where (1) the victim's statement to his cousin made immediately after the shooting that the defendant had shot him, although not a dying declaration, was properly admitted as an excited utterance (2) the trial court did not abuse its discretion in admitting other acts evidence of an incident between the defendant and the victim that created a motive for defendant to shoot the victim (3) the trial court did not err in not giving a limiting instruction regarding the other acts evidence because there was no evidence the jury used the other acts evidence to convict the defendant because he was a bad person (4) the defendant's conviction for felony murder was not unconstitutional because this court does not recognize the independent-felony/merger doctrine (5) there was no plain error in the trial court's failure to instruct on involuntary manslaughter and aggravated assault because there was no evidence the defendant had been provoked to shoot the victim and (6) the defendant's convictions were not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 3672State v. Hernandez (2018)
Allied Offenses, consecutive sentences, potential deportation. Trial court erred in failing to merge allied offenses at sentencing after the parties had previously stipulated to merger. Trial court did not err in imposing consecutive sentences. The potential deportation of the defendant following the conclusion of his prison terms was not a valid reason to preclude the imposition of consecutive sentences.
- 2018 Ohio 3674State v. Brown (2018)
Self-representation Sixth Amendment repeat violent offender collateral attack sufficiency of the evidence R.C. 2903.11 inference stacking R.C. 2953.08(G)(2). The defendant's right to self-representation was not violated because he abandoned his request for self-representation after a second attorney was appointed and the defendant accepted the representation the finding of guilt on the repeat violent offender specification is not contrary to law because a defendant cannot collaterally attack the entry of conviction underlying the specification there is sufficient evidence in support of the conviction for felonious assault under R.C. 2903.11(A)(2) and the trial court did not err in sentencing.
- 2018 Ohio 3675State v. Samuels (2018)
Allied offenses sentence void res judicata findings. Where the trial court made no findings that the offenses were allied prior to imposing separate sentences for each offense, the sentence was not void and the defendant should have raised any issue regarding allied offenses in his direct appeal. Because he did not do so, his postconviction motion to correct his sentence was barred by res judicata, and the trial court therefore properly denied the motion.
- 2018 Ohio 3680In re T.S. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3681State v. Lewis (2018)
Motion to suppress granted - affirmed
- 2018 Ohio 3682State v. Williams (2018)
Judgment affirmed and motion overruled. The trial court did not err in overruling appellant's motion for jail-time credit under R.C. 2929.19(B)(2)(g)(iii) where, at the time of filing the motion, there was no transcript in the record of the sentencing hearing to demonstrate an error that would give the trial court jurisdiction to consider appellant's claim. Appellant's motion to move to judgment is overruled as moot.
- 2018 Ohio 3683State v. Balderson (2018)
Judgment affirmed. The trial court made all of the necessary findings at the sentencing hearing to impose consecutive sentences.
- 2018 Ohio 3684Franklin Cnty. Sheriff v. Teamsters Local No. 413 (2018)
Appeal from decision confirming an arbitrator's award and denying a motion to vacate the award. Trial court did not err in finding the grievance was arbitrable and upholding arbitrator's decision to reduce discipline and reinstate the grievants.
- 2018 Ohio 3685State ex rel. Thomas v. Ohio Adult Parole Auth. (2018)
Appellant failed to provide clear and convincing evidence that he was denied parole based on impermissible discrimination.
- 2018 Ohio 3686State ex rel. Hillman v. Blunt (2018)
No party filed objections to the magistrate's decision recommending the dismissal of relator's complaint for writ of procedendo as moot, as the trial court has ruled on the motion that prompted relator to file the complaint. Finding no error of law or defect in the magistrate's decision, it is adopted in in its entirely. Respondent's motion to dismiss and motion for leave to file a motion to dismiss instanter are sustained and relator's complaint for writ of procedendo is dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 3691Watkins v. Columbus City Schools Bd. of Edn. (2018)
The common pleas court did not abuse its discretion on R.C. 3319.16 appellate review when it affirmed the board of education's order terminating teacher's employment. Judgment of the common pleas court affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3692State v. Howard (2018)
VIOLATING A CIVIL PROTECTION ORDER – EVIDENCE – AUTHENTICATION – SUFFICIENCY: Testimony that a Facebook messenger screenshot fairly and accurately depicts the messages received is sufficient evidence to support the document's authenticity, and the burden shifts to the opponent to present evidence to rebut the testimony. Defendant's conviction for violating a civil protection order was supported by sufficient evidence where the state presented unrefuted evidence that defendant attempted to contact the victim through Facebook messenger.
- 2018 Ohio 3693Johnson v. Hisle (2018)
CIV.R. 3(A) – PROCEDURE/RULES – JURISDICTION: The trial court erred in continuing to exercise jurisdiction over the case where plaintiff instructed the clerk of court to attempt service of the complaint outside the one-year period in Civ.R. 3(A), because the instruction for service functioned as a notice of dismissal of plaintiff's claims.
- 2018 Ohio 3695State v. Erby (2018)
Appellant's conviction after a bench trial of reckless homicide with a firearm specification was supported by sufficient evidence and was not against the manifest weight of the evidence, where undisputed evidence showed that Appellant unintentionally shot and killed his girlfriend while excitedly "waving" loaded handgun in her vicinity with his finger on the trigger. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3696State v. Gary (2018)
The trial court did not erroneously apply the plain view doctrine when overruling Appellant's motion to suppress. The detective who discovered Appellant's drugs in plain view was lawfully located in an area from which he could observe the drugs because he had a legitimate purpose for entering the area in question and the area in question was substantially open to public view and part of a premises that had a reduced expectation of privacy. Judgment affirmed. (Froelich, J., concurring.)
- 2018 Ohio 3697State v. Jenkins (2018)
Defendant-appellant, following a jury trial, was convicted of domestic violence. Evidence of Defendant-appellant's pre-arrest silence admitted during the State's case-in-chief violated his Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination, but this error, based upon the overwhelming evidence of guilt, was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt. Further, Defendant-appellant's conviction was supported by sufficient evidence, and it was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3698State v. Webster (2018)
The appellant's first-degree misdemeanor conviction for gross neglect of a patient in violation of R.C. 2903.34(A)(2) is based on legally insufficient evidence. Although Appellant's gross neglect is supported by the evidence because he did not periodically check on the patient as required, the State did not present evidence to establish the causation element of the definition of "gross neglect," R.C. 2903.33(C)(1), which required proof that the appellant not only knowingly failed to provide treatment, care, goods or service to a "care facility" patient but also that the failure "resulted in" physical harm. Although the evidence demonstrates appellant failed to provide treatment or care, the record contains no evidence that this failure itself resulted in the physical harm at issue. Judgment reversed.
- 2018 Ohio 3699State v. Pierce (2018)
The record establishes that appellant's no contest plea to one count of violating a protection order was made in a knowing, voluntary, and intelligent fashion. Further, the court did not err by overruling appellant's motion to withdraw his no contest plea. Appellant's change of heart with respect to his plea was not a sufficient basis to permit withdrawal. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3700Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. v. Herman (2018)
In mortgage foreclosure action, trial court did not err by granting default judgment against homeowner who was served by publication in accordance with R.C. 2703.141. Appellant waived constitutional challenge to R.C. 2703.141 by failing to raise that argument in a Civ.R. 60(B) motion for relief from the trial court's judgment, and her constitutional claim lacks substantive merit. In addition, any defect in the proceedings leading to entry of default judgment against Appellant's heirs was harmless as those parties had no protectable legal interest. Finally, HUD Secretary's approval to accelerate loan was not required where HUD expressly disclaimed any interest in the subject property. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3702State v. Smith (2018)
Consecutive sentences cruel and unusual punishment
- 2018 Ohio 3703Sims v. Coley (2018)
Horse running at large
- 2018 Ohio 3706Jackson v. Am. Bulk Commodities, Inc. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3708State ex rel. Bolzenius v. Preisse (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Elections—Mandamus—Writ of mandamus sought to compel board of elections to place proposed city ordinance on the ballot—Proposed ordinance attempts to enact provisions that are beyond the scope of municipality's legislative power—Writ denied.
- 2018 Ohio 3710State v. Lodwick (2018)
CRIMINAL - Appellant's conviction for burglary was supported by sufficient evidence and trial court's determination of a repeat violent offender is affirmed. However, the 10-year maximum prison term ordered to be served consecutively to the prison term imposed on burglary is contrary to law as no evidence exists in record to show Appellant threatened or attempted to cause serious physical harm during the burglary.
- 2018 Ohio 3714Bollinger v. Ohio Dept. of Edn. (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in affirming the administrative agency's decision to permanently revoke Appellant's teaching license for engaging in conduct unbecoming to the profession.
- 2018 Ohio 3715State v. Lee (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion by denying defendant-appellant's petition for post-conviction relief.
- 2018 Ohio 3717Homan v. Franklin Twp. Bd. of Zoning Appeals (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion by determining that a township board of zoning appeal's decision denying plaintiff-appellant's application for a conditional use permit was supported by a preponderance of reliable, probative, and substantial evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 3718State v. Ackles (2018)
In order to impose consecutive sentences, the trial court must make several statutorily required findings at sentencing.
- 2018 Ohio 3719Mahoning County Bar Association v. McNally. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Misdemeanor convictions involving dishonesty—One- year license suspension conditionally and partially stayed.
- 2018 Ohio 3720State v. Johnson (2018)
Trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying Johnson's motion for a mistrial and Johnson's conviction was not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 3721State ex rel. Cincinnati Enquirer v. Pike Cty. Gen. Health Dist. (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Mandamus—Coroner's records-statute, R.C. 313.10—The coroner shall grant a journalist's proper request to review preliminary autopsy and investigative notes made by the coroner—Writ granted.
- 2018 Ohio 3723State v. Clark (2018)
driving under suspension failure to control misdemeanor sentencing right of allocution R.C. 2929.21 Crim.R. 32(A)(1)
- 2018 Ohio 3724State v. Putnam (2018)
failure to comply with the order of a police officer guilty plea trial court failed to strictly comply with Crim.R. 11(C)(2)(c) in advising appellant of the constitutional rights he waived by pleading guilty plea not entered knowingly, voluntarily, and intelligently
- 2018 Ohio 3726State v. Fletcher (2018)
motion to withdraw plea sentence post-release control consecutive sentences.
- 2018 Ohio 3727State v. Austin (2018)
untimely postconviction petition R.C. 2953.21(A)(2) murder felony murder
- 2018 Ohio 3728Bank of NY Mellon v. Kohn (2018)
summary judgment on foreclosure action motion to strike affidavit of loan servicer business records exception to hearsay rule
- 2018 Ohio 3730McCloud v. Duffy (2018)
Workers' Compensation R.C. 4123.512(A) fraud right to participate
- 2018 Ohio 3733Jefferis Real Estate Oil & Gas Holdings, LLC v. Schaffner Law Offices, L.P. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3735Kirk Excavating & Constr., Inc. v. RKJ Enters., LLC (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3736Neth. Ins. Co. v. BSHM Architects, Inc. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3738State v. Braunskill (2018)
The trial court properly treated appellant's motion for resentencing as a petition for postconviction relief, which was untimely filed, and the arguments therein were barred by res judicata because they could have been argued on direct appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 3739Johnson v. Miller (2018)
Defendant defaulted on a promissory note and appeals the trial court's decision granting judgment on the note and ordering foreclosure of defendant's properties. Competent, credible evidence established that the terms of the promissory note and mortgages were mutually agreed upon by the parties and the agreements were supported by sufficient consideration.
- 2018 Ohio 3740State v. Payne (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - felony sentencing consecutive sentences 27 months imprisonment statutory factors proper findings supported by the record.
- 2018 Ohio 3741State v. McKee (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - aggravated murder aggravated robbery grand theft of a motor vehicle aggravated arson firearm specifications phone records search warrant lawful seizure manifest weight of the evidence sufficient, credible evidence to support convictions.
- 2018 Ohio 3743Kent v. CDC-Kent, L.L.C. (2018)
CIVIL - planning commission codified ordinances zoning amendment constitutionality void ab initio R.C. 713.121 statute of limitations procedural error preliminary injunction permanent injunction declaratory judgment counterclaim motion to vacate void judgment jurisdiction Civ.R. 60(B) voidable judgment any other reason justifying relief from judgment court errors and omissions beyond control of the movant due process notice opportunity to be heard no notice that counterclaim was subject to dismissal movant's burden is to allege a meritorious claim not to prevail on the merits injustice. OTHER CIVIL RULES - Civ.R. 53 judgment interim order magistrate's decision magistrate's order Civ.R. 41(A) notice of voluntary dismissal self-executing without order of court Civ.R. 56 summary judgment Civ.R. 54(B) no just reason for delay final appealable order.
- 2018 Ohio 3744McCormack v. Jefferson Area Local School Dist. (2018)
CIVIL - PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT - PROVISION OF DEFENSE AT PUBLIC EXPENSE - R.C. 2744.07(A)(1) following amendment to this statute, in order for a political subdivision to be required to provide a defense for its employee, the trial court must determine that the employee's act occurred while he was acting both in good faith and not manifestly outside the scope of his employment the pleadings themselves no longer provide an alternative basis on which to require a subdivision to provide its employee with a defense appellate court held the trial court's finding that the girls basketball coach's sexual activity with two of his students could not reasonably be considered to be in the scope of his employment was supported by competent, credible evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 3745State v. Lao (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - plea of guilty preliminary hearing hearing on motion to suppress no transcripts of proceedings unreviewable no ineffective assistance of counsel.
- 2018 Ohio 3746Browne v. Artex Oil Co. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3749State ex rel. Beavercreek Twp. Fiscal Officer v. Graff (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Mandamus—R.C. 507.021(A) unambiguously requires township fiscal officer to obtain board of township trustees' approval for salary offered to assistants hired under R.C. 507.021(A)—Fiscal officer failed to show board abused its discretion in rejecting her salary proposals—Board exceeded its authority under R.C. 507.021(A) in setting the assistants' salaries—Writ granted in part and denied in part.
- 2018 Ohio 3750In Re L.G. (2018)
Appeal dismissed as having been improvidently accepted.
- 2018 Ohio 3751Ford v. Smith (2018)
Dismissal For Failure To Prosecute
- 2018 Ohio 3752State v. Smith (2018)
Challenge to fines/Restitution/Court costs
- 2018 Ohio 3753Smith-Kadey, L.L.C. v. Companions of Ashland, L.L.C. (2018)
Frivolous Conduct - Attorney Fees - RC 2323.51
- 2018 Ohio 3754State v. Hendrix (2018)
POSTCONVICTION—APPELLATE REVIEW/CRIMINAL: Petitioner's postconviction ineffective-counsel claim was not barred under the doctrine of res judicata, because it depended for its resolution upon evidence outside the trial record. The court of appeals must presume the regularity of, and thus affirm, the common pleas court's judgment dismissing petitioner's postconviction petition without a hearing, when in the absence of the defense exhibits, the record on appeal did not include a complete transcript of the proceedings necessary to the resolution of the challenge advanced on appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 3755Barger v. Elite Mgmt. Servs., Inc. (2018)
CIV.R. 12(B)(6) – CONTRACTS – OHIO PLANNED COMMUNITY LAW – OHIO CONSUMER SALES PRACTICES ACT – UNJUST ENRICHMENT: The trial court properly dismissed plaintiff homeowner's breach-of-contract claim under Civ.R. 12(B)6) where plaintiff's complaint did not set forth facts demonstrating that she was a party to the contract between the homeowners' association and defendant management company, or an intended beneficiary of it and even if plaintiff was an intended beneficiary, the contract did not require that a certification letter be provided to plaintiff at a reasonable cost. The trial court properly dismissed plaintiff's claim under the Ohio Planned Community Law, because that law applies only to homeowner associations and those with an ownership or possessory interest in a planned community, and defendant management company was neither. The trial court properly dismissed plaintiff's claim under the Ohio Consumer Sales Practices Act, because that act does not apply to collateral services that are solely associated with the sale of real estate. The trial court erred in dismissing plaintiff's claim for unjust enrichment where plaintiff pled sufficient facts to support it. [But see DISSENT: Plaintiff's complaint did not allege facts sufficient to support a claim for unjust enrichment.]
- 2018 Ohio 3756State v. Bryant (2018)
AUTOS/CRIMINAL – R.C. 4549.02: Defendant's conviction under R.C. 4549.02 for failure to stop after an accident was supported by sufficient evidence and was not against the manifest weight of the evidence where defendant left the scene of a motor vehicle accident before giving his name and address to the police officer who responded to the scene of the accident. [But see DISSENT: Where defendant gave his name and address to the operator of the other vehicle, and that operator did not call the police until after defendant had left the scene of the collision an hour later, there was no officer at the scene and defendant did not violate R.C. 4549.02 by not providing him with the information.]
- 2018 Ohio 3757State v. Schwegmann (2018)
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE – EVIDENCE/WITNESS/TRIAL – EVID.R. 608(B) – COHABITATION : An alleged prior threat by the victim to make a false accusation of domestic violence was not clearly probative of truthfulness or untruthfulness where the alleged threat was not made to defendant, and the victim testified that she had never made a false accusation of domestic violence against anyone therefore, the trial court did not abuse its discretion in preventing defense counsel from cross-examining the victim about the alleged threat. [But see CONCURRENCE: The trial court erred in not allowing defense counsel to cross-examine the victim as to whether she had threatened to falsely accuse anyone of domestic violence, because a threat to make a false accusation of domestic violence is probative to truthfulness or untruthfulness in a domestic-violence case but the error was harmless in light of the overwhelming evidence against defendant.] Defendant's conviction for domestic violence was supported by sufficient evidence and was not against the manifest weight of the evidence where the state established cohabitation through the victim's testimony that she had been dating the defendant for six months and had been living with him for a month when the altercation occurred.
- 2018 Ohio 3758Smith v. Nationwide Mut. Ins. Co. (2018)
Judgment affirmed. The trial court did not abuse its discretion when it granted appellee's motion to stay pending arbitration and referred appellant's claims to arbitration. The arbitration clause in the parties' contract is not unconscionable and appellant's claims of fraud and material breach of the agreement do not defeat appellee's right to have the arbitration clause enforced.
- 2018 Ohio 3759State v. Dixon (2018)
Judgment affirmed. The trial court made all of the necessary findings at the sentencing hearing to impose consecutive sentences and consecutive sentences were not clearly and convincingly unsupported by the record. The defendant also failed to show that he was prejudiced and denied a fair and just hearing after the trial court ordered his removal from the sentencing hearing for being an obstreperous defendant.
- 2018 Ohio 3760State ex rel. Evans v. Mohr (2018)
The relator's action in mandamus and/or prohibition is dismissed because a declaratory judgment action provides an adequate remedy at law to correct prison records.
- 2018 Ohio 3761State ex rel. Swanson v. Dept. of Rehab. & Corr. (2018)
Writ of mandamus dismissed because relator did not list all civil actions he had filed in the past five years in the affidavit filed pursuant to R.C. 2969.25(A).
- 2018 Ohio 3762State v. Hillman (2018)
The trial court did not err in denying defendant's motion that the court make a determination that defendant was wrongfully arrested and incarcerated.
- 2018 Ohio 3763State v. Goff (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Criminal law—Aggravated murder—Death sentence imposed after resentencing hearing affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3765Lucas v. Ford Motor Co. (2018)
Ohio Lemon Law, arbitration, Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act, Maitland v. Ford Motor Co., new vehicle warranty
- 2018 Ohio 3769State v. Kitzmiller (2018)
Speedy trial triple count provision refusal to sign own recognizance bond warrant and detainer.
- 2018 Ohio 3770U.S. Bank, N.A. v. Smith (2018)
App.R. 26(B) reconsideration arguments raised for the first time on appeal Moore v. Ogden, 35 Ohio St. 430.
- 2018 Ohio 3771Disciplinary Counsel v. Simmonds (2018)
On certification of default.
- 2018 Ohio 3772In re Resignation of Chuparkoff (2018)
Attorneys at law—Resignation with disciplinary action pending—Gov.Bar R. VI(11)(C).
- 2018 Ohio 3773In re Resignation of Scudder (2018)
Attorneys at law—Resignation with disciplinary action pending—Gov.Bar R. VI(11)(C).
- 2018 Ohio 3774In re Resignation of Verkhlin (2018)
Attorneys at law—Resignation with disciplinary action pending—Gov.Bar R. VI(11)(C).
- 2018 Ohio 3775In re Resignation of Thomas (2018)
Attorneys at law—Resignation with disciplinary action pending—Gov.Bar R. VI(11)(C).
- 2018 Ohio 3776Disciplinary Counsel v. Tinch (2018)
On certification of default.
- 2018 Ohio 3779Taylor v. Mizer (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3781Bragg v. GFS Marketplace, L.L.C. (2018)
Slip and Fall Civ. R. 56(F) Motion to Conduct Discovery
- 2018 Ohio 3783Freeport Lodge Free & Accepted Masons Ohio v. MC Mineral Co. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3785Fries v. Greg G. Wright & Sons, L.L.C. (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW/CIVIL – ARBITRATION – CONTRACTS – JURISDICTION – PROCEDURE/RULES: The denial of a motion for a more definite statement is not a final, appealable order. The appellate court's standard for reviewing the trial court's determination of whether a party has waived a contractual right to arbitrate a dispute is an abuse of discretion. Defendants-appellants did not waive their right to arbitrate when they filed a motion to stay the proceedings pending arbitration within 93 days of the commencement of the litigation and, in the time prior to filing the motion, had filed only a few pleadings and conducted only one deposition. The appellate court's standard of review for determining whether a claim falls within the subject matter of a contractual arbitration provision is de novo. When determining whether a claim falls within the subject matter of a contractual arbitration provision, the trial court must consider the allegations made within each cause of action and determine whether the claim could be maintained without reference to the contract or relationship at issue. Plaintiff's claims for breach of fiduciary duty, unjust enrichment and conversion arose from his status as a member of defendant company, his claimed ownership interest in the company and the rights resulting from his membership therefore, those claims were subject to the arbitration clause in the company's operating agreement. Plaintiff's claims for unjust enrichment, fraudulent concealment and civil conspiracy did not arise from defendant company's operating agreement or from plaintiff's status as a member of the company, and could be maintained without reference to the operating agreement or plaintiff's status as a member of the company therefore, those claims were not subject to arbitration. An entry by the trial court compelling a party to produce discovery is not a final, appealable order.
- 2018 Ohio 3786State v. Gordon (2018)
CRIMINAL DAMAGING – RESTITUTION – R.C. 2929.28(A)(1): In ordering restitution under R.C. 2929.28(A)(1) for criminal damaging, the trial court did not abuse its discretion in finding that the economic loss to the victim was the cost of repairing her vehicle where the victim produced repair estimates from three qualified collision repair companies and defendant produced evidence only of the car model's trade-in value, but not its retail value.
- 2018 Ohio 3787Mezher v. Schrand (2018)
CONTRACTS – REAL PROPERTY: In an action for specific performance of a real-estate agreement allegedly formed by the parties through an email exchange, the trial court erred in granting summary judgment to the defendants-sellers on statute-of-frauds grounds, because the email exchange contained the essential terms of the sale, and because a genuine issue of material fact existed as to whether the parties had a present intention to be bound at the time they exchanged emails, or whether the parties did not intend to be bound until the anticipated execution of a formal document.
- 2018 Ohio 3789State v. Gilbert (2018)
Motion for a new trial, Crim.R. 33, Crim.R. 43, right to counsel, witness recantation. The trial court did not violate the defendant's Sixth Amendment and due process rights when it removed him from the courtroom during the hearing on his motion for a new trial. The trial court did not err when it denied the defendant's motion for a new trial.
- 2018 Ohio 3791State v. Scott (2018)
Sufficiency firearm manifest weight serious physical harm attempt knowingly allied offenses merger having weapons while under disability discharge of a firearm on or near a prohibited premises felonious assault improperly discharging a firearm into a habitation. Defendant's felonious assault conviction is supported by sufficient evidence and is not against the manifest weight of the evidence. The trial court did not error by failing to merge appellant's convictions for the purposes of sentencing.
- 2018 Ohio 3792State v. Williams (2018)
Hearsay testimony Crim.R. 29 sufficiency manifest weight. The trial court issued a curative instruction to the jury pertaining to the detective's hearsay testimony and appellant failed to show that his substantial rights were affected. The trial court did not err by denying appellant's request for a mistrial. The video evidence presented was sufficient to sustain the element of prior calculation and design appellant's conviction was not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 3793State v. Crosby (2018)
Aggravated murder R.C. 2903.01(B) complicity sufficiency of the evidence jury instruction flight jurisdiction to review sentences. Sufficient evidence supported the conviction for complicity to commit aggravated murder under R.C. 2903.01(B), and therefore, the jury instruction on complicity was warranted and there is no appellate jurisdiction to review the sentences imposed under R.C. 2953.08(D)(4). In addition, the trial court did not err in instructing the jury on flight in light of the facts and the form of the instruction.
- 2018 Ohio 3795Skiver v. Wilson (2018)
Default judgment Civ.R. 54(C) Civ.R. 55(A) hearing on damages. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in holding a hearing on damages on a default judgment where there was no written agreement reflecting the duration of the agreement, payment terms, or the extent of the services provided, nor was there an itemization of hours worked. The trial court's award of damages was not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 3797State v. Henderson (2018)
R.C. 2903.11(A)(2), felonious assault, criminal damaging or endangering, R.C. 2909.06(A)(1), domestic violence, R.C. 2929.25(A), manifest weight of the evidence, right to confrontation and cross examination, ineffective assistance of counsel. The trial court did not violate the defendant's right to confrontation and cross examination because it permitted defense counsel to question the victim extensively about her relationship with her girlfriend and her license to carry and conceal a weapon. The defendant's convictions were not against the manifest weight of the evidence because the evidence established that the defendant fired a gun at least six times in the direction of the victim. The defendant did not establish that his counsel's performance was deficient for failing to call other witnesses and for failing to argue that the victim may have committed the crimes instead of him.
- 2018 Ohio 3798City of S. Euclid v. Turner (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3803State v. Wade (2018)
Trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying appellant's motion to withdraw his guilty plea.
- 2018 Ohio 3804State v. Upchurch (2018)
Where the evidence showed that a gun sold by the defendant was operable when seized over one and one-half years after it was sold and that no efforts were made to repair or service it, the finder of fact was permitted to infer that it was operable at the time of sale to support a finding that a defendant possessed a firearm while under a disability from a prior criminal conviction for domestic violence.
- 2018 Ohio 3805In re M.L.H (2018)
Trial court judge acted within his discretion to refuse an additional continuance of proceedings in a PCC case. Mother whose whereabouts had been unknown was taken into custody after she fled her half-way house.
- 2018 Ohio 3806State v. Blair (2018)
Consecutive sentences were appropriate for multiple armed robberies. One of which involved a pistol whipping which caused serious physical harm.
- 2018 Ohio 3808State ex rel. Franks v. Ohio Adult Parole Auth. (2018)
Inmate was not entitled to a writ of mandamus to change his parole eligibility date. Inmate also failed to provide the proper filing fee.
- 2018 Ohio 3809State v. Gibson (2018)
Appellant's conviction for felonious assault was not against the manifest weight of the evidence, as the jury did not lose its way in finding the greater weight of the evidence did not establish that Appellant acted in self-defense. In addition, the trial court's response to a question posed by the jury during deliberations did not amount to plain error. Finally, the trial court did not abuse its discretion in overruling Appellant's Crim.R. 33 motion for new trial as the motion was based on unsubstantiated juror statements and was therefore barred by the aliunde rule and Evid.R. 606(B). Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3810King v. Miami Cnty. Ohio Bd. of Cnty. Commissioners (In Re Children's Home County Ditch) (2018)
The judgment of the trial court upholding the decision of the Miami County Board of Commissioners and dismissing the Appellants' petition for the improvement or replacement of the Children's Home drainage tile, pursuant to R.C. 6131.04, was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Appellants failed to establish by a preponderance of the evidence at trial de novo that the benefits to be derived from the proposed improvements would exceed the cost. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3811State v. Lewis (2018)
Officers approached Lewis on RTA property when they observed him smoking in an area designated as non-smoking. The trial court did not err in overruling Lewis's motion to suppress, since the officers' encounter with him was consensual and not a seizure. Lewis then pled no contest to one count of possession of heroin. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3812State v. Ojezua (2018)
Pursuant to Anders v. California, 386 U.S. 738, 87 S.Ct. 1396, 18 L.Ed.2d 493 (1967), there is no arguable merit to the potential assigned errors, and an independent review reveals no issues with arguable merit for Appellant to assert on appeal. Judgment affirmed. (Froelich, J., dissenting.)
- 2018 Ohio 3813State v. Pendergrass (2018)
Defendant-appellee was indicted for two counts of unlawful sexual conduct with a minor, violations of R.C. 2907.04(A), as second, as opposed to fourth, degree felonies based upon his previous conviction for unlawful sexual conduct with a minor. The previous conviction was for conduct which occurred after the conduct alleged in the current indictment. The trial court dismissed the indictment concluding that for Defendant-appellee to have been indicted for a second degree felony upon the basis of a previous conviction, the previous conviction must have already been a matter of record at the time he committed the acts alleged in the indictment. R.C. 2907.04(B) allows an offense degree elevation "if the offender previously has been convicted of or pleaded guilty to a violation of [R.C.] 2907.04." This language unambiguously allows a violation of R.C. 2907.04 to be elevated to a second degree felony if the defendant, at the time of the indictment, had already been convicted of a violation of R.C. 2907.04. The trial court, since this conclusion applies to Defendant-appellee's situation, erred by dismissing the indictment. Judgment reversed and remanded. (Froelich, J., concurring.) (Donovan, J., dissenting.)
- 2018 Ohio 3814State v. Portman (2018)
Appellant was convicted following a guilty plea to one count of possession of cocaine, a felony of the fifth degree, in exchange for the dismissal of one count of aggravated possession of drugs. He was not eligible for mandatory community control sanctions, and he was sentenced to 12 months in prison. Appellate counsel asserts an absence of meritorious issues for review, pursuant to Anders v. California, 386 U.S. 738, 87 S.Ct. 1396, 18 L.Ed.2d 493 (1967). A thorough and independent review of the record reveals no arguably meritorious appellate issues. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3815State v. Ropp (2018)
The trial court's imposition of some maximum and some consecutive sentences was not clearly and convincingly unsupported by the record. Judgment affirmed. (Froelich, J., concurring.)
- 2018 Ohio 3816State v. Shaw (2018)
Defendant's plea, which included agreements that he pay a specific amount of restitution in two cases, was made knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily. The trial court did not err in ordering the amounts of restitution as agreed by the parties. Although the trial court's order of restitution did not specifically identify to whom the restitution was to be paid, the record clearly identifies the victims to whom restitution was owed. The trial court erred in its award of jail time credit in two cases when it imposed concurrent sentences. One judgment affirmed. Two judgments reversed as to the amount of jail time credit, and those matters are remanded for amended judgment entries of conviction reflecting the correct amount of jail time credit and for the trial court to notify the appropriate prison officials of the amended judgment entries. (Welbaum, P.J., concurring in part and dissenting in part.)
- 2018 Ohio 3817In re M.H. (2018)
Mother lacked standing to file motion to vacate judgment where motion was filed more than 13 months after judgment terminating her parental rights and awarding permanent custody to children's services agency, and judgment had already been affirmed on appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 3819In re J.J. (2018)
Mother failed to rectify the conditions which caused the children to be removed from the home. On-going relationship and contact with father with domestic violence history towards mother. Anger issues. Safety issues. Cognitive limitations.
- 2018 Ohio 3820Wilson v. Wilson (2018)
Appellant failed to timely object to magistrate's decision regarding separation agreement and did not argue plain error on appeal, so he waived all issues relating to separation agreement. Regardless, trial court did not commit plain error by adopting magistrate's decision because statute of frauds does not apply to in-court settlements. Trial court did not err by holding final hearing when appellant participated "under protest." Trial court's final judgment properly adopted valid separation agreement.
- 2018 Ohio 3821Toledo v. Cox (2018)
Record does not reflect trial court breach of due process rights. Judgment affirmed. Criminal
- 2018 Ohio 3822State v. Allen (2018)
Plea was entered knowingly, voluntarily, and intelligently, and the imposed sentence was not contrary to law.
- 2018 Ohio 3824State v. Faulkner (2018)
Trial court properly imposed additional prison sentence for appellant's violation of the terms of his postrelease control, where the sentencing court provided appellant with the appropriate notification of postrelease control under the law that existed at the time of sentencing. Criminal
- 2018 Ohio 3825State v. Threats (2018)
Postconviction petition evidentiary hearing motion to withdraw plea Crim.R. 32.1 Defendant's statements at plea hearing
- 2018 Ohio 3826Dundics v. Eric Petroleum Corp. (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Occupations and professions—An oil-and-gas lease falls within definition of "real estate" in R.C. 4735.01(B)—Negotiation of oil-and-gas leases requires real-estate-broker's license pursuant to R.C. 4735.01(A) and 4735.02(A)—Because oil-and-gas land professionals seek compensation for conducting an activity described in R.C. 4735.01(A) without real-estate-broker's license, R.C. 4735.21 precludes their cause of action—Court of appeals' affirmance of trial court's dismissal of complaint affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3828Cincinnati Bar Association v. Fernandez. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Multiple violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct—Respondent's law license indefinitely suspended.
- 2018 Ohio 3829State ex rel. Twitchell v. Saferin (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Mandamus—Writ of mandamus sought to compel board of elections to place a proposed charter amendment on the ballot for the November 2018 ballot—Relators failed to show that the board of elections abused its discretion in keeping the proposed amendment off the ballot--Writ denied.
- 2018 Ohio 3830State ex rel. Perry Twp. Bd. of Trustees v. Husted (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Elections—Mandamus—Township board of trustees failed to establish that it has clear legal right or that county board of elections has clear legal duty to certify proposed levy for placement on ballot—Writ denied.
- 2018 Ohio 3833State v. Kubisen (2018)
intervention in lieu of conviction – Revised Code 2951.041(A)(1) – mandatory assessment – eligibility assessment – presume regularity
- 2018 Ohio 3834State v. Soucek (2018)
felonious assault – sufficiency of the evidence – knowingly – recklessly
- 2018 Ohio 3835Strickler v. First Ohio Banc & Lending, Inc. (2018)
class action, certification, final appealable order, affirmed, law of the case, intervening decision, R.C. 1322.11, R.C. 1322.062, safe harbor
- 2018 Ohio 3836State v. Harrigan (2018)
robbery four counts of kidnapping and eight repeat-violent offender specifications R.C. 2929.14(B)(2) appellant's maximum consecutive sentences not contrary to law
- 2018 Ohio 3837In re C.W. (2018)
Trial court's decision to terminate parental rights was not against the manifest weight of the evidence when father had failed to visit or contact the child for more than 90 days, so abandoned the child. Trial court did not err in allowing the admission of screen shots of father's Facebook pages.
- 2018 Ohio 3839State v. Mathews (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3840State v. McClurg (2018)
Failure to Inform Defendant of Possible Sentence upon Probation Violation
- 2018 Ohio 3841State v. Brownlee (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - felony sentencing plea of guilty two counts of aggravated robbery two firearm specifications no provocation no duress findings supported by record.
- 2018 Ohio 3842Burnett Rd. Assocs., L.L.C. v. Franklin Twp. (2018)
CIVIL - rezoning standing owner of parcel township zoning resolution denial of zoning commission's recommendation unanimous vote R.C. 519.12(H) requires only majority vote local ordinance must be within the boundaries of the enabling statute unconstitutional as applied regulation is the focus of analysis, not proposed use.
- 2018 Ohio 3843State ex rel. Aguirre v. Doherty (2018)
ORIGINAL ACTION - writ of procedendo motion to dismiss judicial officer completed the act relator sought to compel moot.
- 2018 Ohio 3844State v. Lawrence (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - suppression not required protective sweep exigent-circumstance exception reasonable merger required under R.C. 2941.25 and State v. Ruff, 143 Ohio St.3d 114, because the same amount of the drug was used to support both the possession and cultivation offenses.
- 2018 Ohio 3845State v. McDonald (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - misdemeanor aggravated menacing criminal trespass purposes and principles of misdemeanor sentencing R.C. 2929.21 sentencing factors R.C. 2929.22 silent record raises the presumption the trial court considered the factors sufficiency manifest weight victim's subjective belief that the defendant will cause serious physical harm.
- 2018 Ohio 3846Cragon v. Shinkle (2018)
REAL PROPERTY - Foreclosure action delinquent property taxes no bids on property at sheriff's sale forfeiture of land R.C. 5723.01 due process violation insufficient time to respond to forfeiture motion.
- 2018 Ohio 3848State v. Mize (2018)
Appellant's sentence is not blended because the trial court sentenced appellant to two separate sentences, one including prison time and one including community control, for appellant's two separate offenses.
- 2018 Ohio 3849State v. Lynch (2018)
The trial court did not err by sentencing appellant to serve nine consecutive 12-month prison terms as a result of his guilty plea to nine counts of burglary, all third-degree felonies, where the trial court properly considered the necessary sentencing statutes prior to issuing its sentencing decision.
- 2018 Ohio 3850State v. Sigman (2018)
Appellant's conviction for child endangering was supported by sufficient evidence and was not against the manifest weight of the evidence because appellant allowed a child that was in his control to ride on a zero-turn lawnmower. The child was thrown off of the lawnmower and had his hand cut off when the child's arm was caught under the lawnmower's deck.
- 2018 Ohio 3852State v. Porter (2018)
A sentencing court may not award jail time credit for time spent on house arrest, confirming this court's decision in State v. Porter, 12th Dist. Warren Nos. CA2017-07-101 and CA2017-07-103, 2018-Ohio-3123 and overruling our prior decision in State v. Fillinger, 12th Dist. CA2015-04-015, 2016-Ohio-8455.
- 2018 Ohio 3855Westerville City School Dist. Bd. of Edn. v. Franklin Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Real-property valuation—R.C. 5713.03—Recent arm's-length-sale price of real property is the best evidence of value, but taxing authorities must also consider any other evidence presented by the parties that is relevant to the value of the property—Board of Tax Appeals' decision vacated and cause remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 3856GC Net Lease @ (3) (Westerville) Investors, L.L.C. v. Franklin Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Real-property valuation—R.C. 5713.03—Board of Tax Appeals' decision vacated and cause remanded based on reasoning in Westerville City Schools Bd. of Edn. v. Franklin Cty. Bd. of Revision.
- 2018 Ohio 3857Columbus Bar Association v. Okuley. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Multiple violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct—One-year law-license suspension partially stayed on conditions.
- 2018 Ohio 3858Wynn v. Waynesburg Rd., L.L.C. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3859Notice Violation v. LMD Integrated Logistic Servs., Inc. (In Re LMD Integrated Logistic Servs., Inc.) (2018)
Public utilities—Motor carrier's appeal from civil-forfeiture order of Public Utilities Commission—Denial of commission's motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction affirmed even though motor carrier did not file notice of appeal with commission but, rather, filed notice of appeal in Tenth District Court of Appeals and served commissioner.
- 2018 Ohio 3860Columbus Bar Association v. Rieser. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct—Two-year suspension, with second year stayed on conditions.
- 2018 Ohio 3861Cleveland Metropolitan Bar Association v. Rosett. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct, including failing to act with reasonable diligence in representing clients, failing to perform and retain a monthly reconciliation of the funds held in a client trust account, and failing to properly safeguard client funds—Public reprimand.
- 2018 Ohio 3862Akron Bar Association v. Glitzenstein. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct, including client-trust-account mismanagement—Conditionally stayed 18-month suspension.
- 2018 Ohio 3863Jacobs v. Shearer's Foods, L.L.C. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3865State v. Luce (2018)
Involuntary manslaughter
- 2018 Ohio 3866State v. Osborn (2018)
CRIMINAL - Because Appellant's motion to correct sentence constituted an untimely petition for post-conviction relief it was untimely and trial court lacked jurisdiction and other claims are barred by res judicata and dismissed herein.
- 2018 Ohio 3869Turner v. CertainTeed Corp. (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Asbestos claims—Court of appeals' judgment affirming trial court's denial of manufacturer's motion for administrative dismissal reversed and cause remanded for trial court to determine whether manufacturer put application of R.C. 2307.92(C)(1) at issue by submitting "written report of a competent medical authority" specifying that plaintiff had "smoked the equivalent of one-pack year during the last fifteen years" under R.C. 2307.91(DD).
- 2018 Ohio 3870Skorvanek v. Dept. of Rehab & Corr. (2018)
Judgment affirmed. ODRC did not have notice, either actual or constructive, that a fellow inmate would attack appellant. The attacking inmate's mental health records were privileged from discovery under the physician-patient privilege, and appellant's counsel did not have a right to inspect the mental health records. A witness did not answer a question of the law. The evidence demonstrated that the attacking inmate had medical authorization for his cane, and that ODRC medical and security staff were present on the floor and swiftly ended the attack. Appellant's contentions regarding the placement and duties of correction officers were barred by the doctrine of discretionary immunity. The manifest weight of the evidence supported the lower court's decision.
- 2018 Ohio 3871State v. Jennings (2018)
Judgment affirmed. Appellant's sentence is not void, partially or otherwise, and his 16-years-to-life sentence is proper. In addition, appellant's arguments regarding jury instructions and ineffective assistance of counsel are barred by res judicata.
- 2018 Ohio 3872State v. Harris (2018)
Appellant's convictions of tampering with evidence and medicaid fraud were supported by sufficient evidence and not against the manifest weight of the evidence. A determination of the weight and credibility afforded the testimony of co-conspirators who have taken plea deals in return for their testimony was a matter for the jury, and the record does not support appellant's contention that the jury lost its way and created a manifest injustice by considering the testimony of these witnesses in reaching its verdict. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3873Intralot, Inc. v. Blair (2018)
In a case involving a vendor challenge to the Request for Proposal evaluation process for a state lottery services contract, the trial court did not err in concluding the sole basis for the preliminary injunction ordered by the magistrate is now moot and, as a result, rejecting the magistrate's decision to grant a preliminary injunction in favor of appellant. The trial court did err in dismissing appellant's complaint in its entirety. Judgment affirmed in part, reversed in part cause remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 3874State ex rel. McCollum v. Ohio Police & Fire Pension Fund Bd. of Trustees (2018)
Consistent with State ex rel. Marmaduke v. Ohio Police & Fire Pension Fund, 147 Ohio St.3d 390, 2016-Ohio-5550, the decision of the board of trustees of the Ohio Police & Fire pension fund to deny relator's R.C. 742.38 application for disability benefits was supported by some evidence in the record. Writ of mandamus denied.
- 2018 Ohio 3875State v. Smith (2018)
The trial court erred in certifying the incorrect number of days of jail-time credit and in imposing an aggregate prison sentence in its judgment entry that varied from that announced at the sentencing hearing. However, the trial court did not err in convicting appellant of having a weapon while under disability based on his prior juvenile adjudication of delinquency for his commission of a robbery. Judgment affirmed in part and reversed in part cause remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 3876State v. Pattin (2018)
The trial court did not err in denying appellant's motion to suppress because the police officers could search the house without a warrant pursuant to the community-caretaking/emergency aid exception to the Fourth Amendment warrant requirement under these circumstances.
- 2018 Ohio 3877Dublin Express Transport Solutions, Ltd. v. Ohio Dept. of Job & Family Servs. (2018)
Common pleas court did not abuse its discretion by affirming Unemployment Review Commission determination on the facts of this case, that medical transportation company's drivers were employees rather than independent contractors. The common pleas court examined the twenty factors set forth by rule and was not clearly wrong in its analysis of those factors. The common pleas court also did not abuse its discretion by refusing to admit findings from the Bureau of Workers Compensation as newly-discovered evidence because those findings were issued before the administrative hearing occurred and could have been introduced at the administrative level.
- 2018 Ohio 3878State v. Partee (2018)
The trial court did not deny Partee the ability to cross-examine the witnesses, the trial court did not err in its evidentiary rulings, the trial court had subject-matter jurisdiction to hear the case, Partee did not receive the ineffective assistance of counsel, and sufficient evidence supports Partee's conviction for obstructing official business.
- 2018 Ohio 3879Ohio Veterans Home v. Taylor (2018)
Because R.C. 119.12(N) expressly limits an agency's right to appeal an adverse ruling of the common pleas court to questions of law relating to the constitutionality, construction, or interpretation of statutes and rules of the agency, the court of appeals did not have jurisdiction of an appeal by Ohio Veterans Home from a decision of the common pleas court affirming SPBR's determination that appellee's position with OVH placed him in the classified civil service. The question presented to the common pleas court was the correctness of the judgment in light of the facts and not a question of law relating to the constitutionality, construction, or interpretation of statutes and rules of the agency. Appeal dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 3881Wolfe v. J.C. Penney Corp. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3887State v. Hogue (2018)
CRIMINAL - Trial court did not err as Appellant's drug related convictions are supported by competent, credible evidence and are not against the manifest weight of the evidence. And, no plain error occurred below as to admission of evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 3890State ex rel. Klein v. Precision Excavating & Grading Co. (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Workers' compensation—When a claimant voluntarily removes himself from his former position of employment for reasons unrelated to a workplace injury, the claimant is no longer eligible for temporary-total-disability compensation, even if the claimant remains disabled at the time of his separation from employment—State ex rel. Reitter Stucco, Inc. v. Indus. Comm. and State ex rel. OmniSource Corp. v. Indus. Comm. overruled.
- 2018 Ohio 3891Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. v. Burd (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Appeal dismissed as having been improvidently accepted.
- 2018 Ohio 3892State ex rel. Jackson Tube Serv., Inc. v. Indus. Comm. (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Workers' compensation—To establish impossibility as an affirmative defense to an application for an additional award for a violation of a specific safety requirement, an employer must show (1) that it would have been impossible to comply with the specific safety requirement or that compliance would have precluded performance of the work and (2) that no alternative means of employee protection existed or were available.
- 2018 Ohio 3893State v. Peterson (2018)
Crim.R. 8(A) joinder of offenses, Evid.R. 601 competency, child
- 2018 Ohio 3894State v. Barnes (2018)
RESISTING ARREST – EVIDENCE – HEARSAY: False statements made by a perpetrator to police that defendant had kidnapped him at gunpoint and forced him to pass a bad check were admissible to establish the police officers' probable cause for arresting defendant. Defendant's convictions for resisting arrest were supported by sufficient evidence and were not against the manifest weight of the evidence where the state presented evidence that defendant interfered with his arrest by struggling with police on two separate occasions while being transported to jail and where defendant did not prove that he was defending himself against excessive force by the arresting officers.
- 2018 Ohio 3895State v. Shelton (2018)
PROCEDURE/RULES – CONTINUANCE — EVID.R. 404(B) — IDENTIFICATION — ALLIED OFFENSES: The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying a continuance requested by defense counsel after the jury had been empaneled in order to subpoena materials and a witness that the state had just disclosed: defendant suffered no prejudice from the denial of the continuance where counsel was able to timely obtain the materials and present testimony from the witness that he sought to subpoena, as well as use the information in cross-examination. Because photographs depicting ammunition not used in the offenses were admitted to establish defendant's identity as the perpetrator, they were not admitted in violation of Evid.R. 404(B). No plain error resulted from the victim's in-court identification of the defendant as the perpetrator of the offenses. Where the force used during the commission of the felonious-assault offense was much more than was necessary to effectuate the aggravated-robbery offense, and demonstrated a specific intent to harm the victim separate from any animus to rob him, the two offenses were committed with a separate animus and were not allied offenses of similar import. Where the offenses of aggravated robbery and theft from an elderly person were committed as part of the same course of conduct with a single state of mind, and where the harm caused by the offenses was not separate and distinct, the two offenses were allied offenses of similar import, and the trial court erred by imposing a separate sentence for each offense.
- 2018 Ohio 3896Patterson v. Adleta, Inc. (2018)
NEGLIGENCE – LANDOWNER – PREMISES LIABILITY: The trial court did not err in entering summary judgment in favor of defendant landowner on plaintiff's negligence claims where plaintiff, a business invitee, was injured after falling off of a ladder supplied by defendant while delivering fuel to an above ground fuel tank on defendant's property: defendant landowner did not owe a duty of care to the plaintiff where (1) climbing and descending a ladder is inherently dangerous (2) there were no latent or hidden defects in the ladder plaintiff used and (3) defendant did not actively participate in plaintiff's work.
- 2018 Ohio 3897In re J.W. (2018)
permanent custody – reasonable efforts determination – continuance – abuse of discretion
- 2018 Ohio 3898State v. Turner (2018)
motion to suppress, identification, photo array, eyewitness identification, unnecessarily suggestive, unreliable, sufficient evidence, manifest weight of the evidence
- 2018 Ohio 3899Disciplinary Counsel v. Harter. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct, including misappropriating client funds, knowingly making false statements of material fact in connection with a disciplinary matter, and engaging in conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation—Permanent disbarment.
- 2018 Ohio 3900Warren County Bar Association v. Ernst. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct, including failing to act with reasonable diligence in representing a client—Public reprimand.
- 2018 Ohio 3901State v. Hill (2018)
Appeal of sentence for firearms specifications/Appeal of jury instruction on flight
- 2018 Ohio 3905State v. Smith (2018)
Interstate Agreement and Detainers Act R.C. 2963.30 App.R. 4 R.C. 2505.02 provisional remedy
- 2018 Ohio 3906In Re Application of Wammes. (2018)
Attorneys—Character and Fitness—Application to register as a candidate for admission to the practice of law—Delinquent-child adjudication—Pending application to take the bar exam approved—Applicant may apply to take the February 2019 bar exam.
- 2018 Ohio 3907Toledo Bar Association v. Rehkopf. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct, including continuing to represent a client when a conflict of interest may be created, even with client consent, if the representation would involve the assertion of a claim by one client against another client represented by the lawyer in the same proceeding and communicating about the subject of the representation with a person the lawyer knows to be represented by another lawyer—Public reprimand.
- 2018 Ohio 3908Columbus Bar Association v. Midian. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Violations of the Rules of Professional conduct, including charging excessive fee—Public reprimand.
- 2018 Ohio 3909Disciplinary Counsel v. Clutts (2018)
On certified order of the Supreme Court of Illinois.
- 2018 Ohio 3914State v. Hammock (2018)
Consequences of Violating PRC at Sentencing Hearing not Given
- 2018 Ohio 3915In re J.J. (2018)
Appellant's motion for reconsideration is granted as appellant has called attention to an issue not considered. {¶ 5} Mother failed to rectify the condition which caused the children to be removed from the home. On-going relationship and contact with father with domestic violence history towards mother. Anger issues. Safety issues. Cognitive limitations.
- 2018 Ohio 3916State v. Lowe (2018)
RESISTING ARREST – EVIDENCE – CONTEMPT: Under R.C. 2921.33(A), no person, either recklessly or by force, is permitted to resist or interfere with his own lawful arrest. For purposes of a resisting-arrest offense, an arrest occurs when the following four requisite elements are present: (1) an intent to arrest, (2) under a real or pretended authority, (3) accompanied by an actual or constructive seizure or detention of the person, (4) which is so understood by the person arrested. Where the evidence showed that defendant had been informed less than four minutes before that the police were looking specifically for him to execute warrants for his arrest, and that his flight amounted to an obvious interference with his apprehension, the record contains substantial, credible evidence from which the trial court could have reasonably concluded that each element of resisting arrest had been proved beyond a reasonable doubt, including that the police intended to arrest defendant and that defendant knew of that intention. To find that a contemnor has committed direct, criminal contempt a court need only determine, beyond a reasonable doubt, that the contemnor's misbehavior, conducted in the presence of the trial court acting in its judicial function, obstructed the administration of justice.
- 2018 Ohio 3917State v. Morrissette (2018)
MURDER – EVIDENCE – COUNSEL – PROSECUTOR – JURY INSTRUCTIONS – FLIGHT: Defendant's conviction for murder was not against the manifest weight of the evidence where the evidence of his guilt, including credible eyewitness testimony that he was the shooter, and an abundance of circumstantial evidence, such as surveillance video footage, that supported the inference that he was the shooter, was overwhelming. Any misconduct by the prosecutor, including, at trial, referring to defendant by his nickname "Psycho" when not necessary for identification or clarity but without purpose to impugn defendant's character, and during closing argument, fleetingly referring to a matter outside the evidence, making an argument not supported by the evidence, and touching on the issue of punishment in the context of explaining a consciousness of guilt argument, did not result in reversible error, because the impact of such misconduct, even if combined, did not deny defendant a fair trial nor was it outcome determinative, when weighed against the strength of the state's case. The trial court did not abuse its discretion by instructing the jury on flight because evidence that defendant had suddenly left town after the murder, had hid in a tree when fleeing from the police, and had rubbed "hair grease," "seasoning" and "cologne" on his body to avoid detection by K-9 police dogs supported the instruction. Defense counsels' failure to object to the prosecutor's unnecessary use of defendant's nickname "Psycho," and their own allegedly unnecessary use of that name, was not outcome determinative in light of the state's overwhelming evidence of guilt. The cumulative errors at trial did not affect the fairness of defendant's trial.
- 2018 Ohio 3918State v. Walker (2018)
CONSTITUTIONAL LAW/CRIMINAL – CONFRONTATION CLAUSE – EVID.R. 804 – WITNESS UNAVAILABILITY – COUNSEL – SENTENCING: The trial court did not err in determining that a witness was unavailable despite reasonable, good-faith efforts on the part of the state to secure the witness's presence and in allowing the state, pursuant to Evid.R. 804, to introduce the witness's testimony from a prior trial where the state had issued a subpoena to the witness approximately six weeks prior to trial the appearance docket indicated that the subpoena had been "returned and endorsed," despite the record containing a return on the subpoena indicating a failure of service on the witness a victim's advocate had contacted the witness a few days before the trial and the state attempted to personally serve the witness with another subpoena the day that the witness failed to appear for trial: the introduction of the witness's testimony from the prior trial, which had ended in a mistrial, did not violate the Confrontation Clause, because the witness was unavailable despite the state's reasonable, good-faith efforts to secure his presence, and defendant had the opportunity to cross-examine the witness during the prior trial. [But see DISSENT: The state did not make a good-faith effort to secure the witness's presence for trial, and the trial court erred in relying on the appearance docket as evidence of the state's good-faith efforts where the state presented no testimony at the unavailability hearing regarding the subpoena that had been issued and returned or the clerk's notation regarding the subpoena, and the state's multiple efforts to contact the witness after the subpoena was returned unserved began two days before the scheduled trial date therefore, the trial court erred in permitting the state to introduce the witness's testimony from the prior trial.] Where defendant failed to establish resulting prejudice from counsel's failure to present a mitigation argument at sentencing, counsel's performance will not be considered ineffective. The trial court did not err in the imposition of sentence where defendant failed to demonstrate that the trial court's comments at sentencing were the product of actual vindictiveness.
- 2018 Ohio 3920State v. Shoecraft (2018)
The record establishes that appellant waived his right to a jury trial in a knowing, intelligent, and voluntary fashion. The trial court did not err when it rejected appellant's affirmative defenses of self defense and defense of another. The trial court did not err when it failed to find appellant guilty of voluntary manslaughter, an inferior degree of the charged offense of murder. Appellant's convictions for murder, felonious assault, carrying a concealed weapon, discharge of firearm on or near prohibited premises, having a weapon while under disability, and trafficking in drugs were not allied offenses subject to merger. Appellant's conviction for felonious assault was supported by sufficient evidence and not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3923State v. Cable (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion by declining to appoint a DNA expert for Appellant at state expense. Appellant failed to show a particularized need for the expert. The trial court did not err by declining to merge the offenses of aggravated burglary and aggravated robbery. Each offense involved separate conduct that caused separate, identifiable harm. The convictions were supported by sufficient evidence and were not against the manifest weight of the evidence. DNA evidence found at the scene linked Appellant to the crimes. Judgment affirmed. (Donovan, J., concurring in judgment only.)
- 2018 Ohio 3924John A. Becker Co. v. Jedson Eng'g, Inc. (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion by overruling Appellant's motion for a stay pending arbitration. The court reasonably found that Appellant waived its right to arbitration by participating in litigation for nine months before raising the right to arbitrate. Appellee, in its cross-appeal, does not seek to change the trial court's decision, but only the reason on which the decision was based. The issues raised in the cross-appeal are related to the contents of the parties' contract. These issues are interlocutory at this stage in the case and not properly decided in this appeal. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3925State v. Baker (2018)
The record reflects that the appellant understood the nature of a kidnapping charge against him when he entered his guilty plea. Based on the appellant's statements at a plea hearing, the indicted offenses, and information provided by a bill of particulars, the record reflects that appellant adequately understood the charge. The appellant's indictment was not fatally defective for failing to specify the predicate felony underlying the kidnapping charge. Defense counsel did not provide ineffective assistance by failing to seek dismissal of the kidnapping charge. The trial court did not impermissibly involve itself in plea negotiations when it initially assented to a plea agreement containing an agreed three-year sentence and later allowed the appellant to waive the agreed sentence aspect of the plea deal so appellant could argue that he should receive community control instead. The appellant's five-year prison sentence is not contrary to law. Judgment affirmed. (Donovan, J., dissenting.)
- 2018 Ohio 3926State v. Trivett (2018)
custodial interrogation—Miranda—sufficient evidence—manifest weight—endangering children
- 2018 Ohio 3927State v. Protsman (2018)
traffic stop – field sobriety tests – substantial compliance – totality of the circumstances – motion to suppress – operating a vehicle with a prohibited blood alcohol concentration –
- 2018 Ohio 3928Martin v. Steiner (2018)
power of attorney, fiduciary, undue influence
- 2018 Ohio 3931State v. DeRemer (2018)
sufficiency of the evidence, manifest weight of the evidence, business records, Evid.R. 803(6), abuse of discretion, Evid.R. 1002, Evid.R. 1003, Crim.R. 25(B), advisory opinion, cumulative error
- 2018 Ohio 3932State v. Clark (2018)
waiver of counsel, Crim.R. 44, knowing, intelligent, voluntary
- 2018 Ohio 3933Vill. of Grafton v. Leonard A. Bescan Family Trust (2018)
deed restrictions, merger by deed, declaratory judgment, plain and ordinary meaning of deed language
- 2018 Ohio 3934State v. Bennett (2018)
restitution, R.C. 2953.08, R.C. 2929.18, economic loss, R.C. 2929.01, clear and convincing evidence
- 2018 Ohio 3935State v. Bennett (2018)
R.C. 2929.14(C)(4), consecutive sentences, presentence investigation report, presume regularity
- 2018 Ohio 3937Wolford v. Willis (2018)
Modify prior decree allocating parental rights–trial court did not abuse its discretion by declining to follow guardian ad litem's recommendation when appellant failed to establish threshold requirement of change in circumstances any error trial court may have committed by discounting counselors' testimony constituted harmless error trial court did not abuse its discretion by determining change in circumstances had not occurred when appellant attempted to re-litigate same facts and issues parties presented during earlier proceeding involving appellee's motion to modify and when any difficulties were pre-existing and of appellant's own making.
- 2018 Ohio 3938In re J.R.P. (2018)
Adjudication of abused, dependent and neglected R.C. 2151.42 R.C. 3109.04 nonparent change of circumstances best interest Sup.R. 48 R.C. 2151.353(A)(3) plain error manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 3940State v. Perry (2018)
Speedy trial triple count provision a delay in resetting a trial date after a continuance tolls speedy trial time until the rescheduled trial date so long as the continuance was reasonable ineffective assistance of counsel prior bad acts R.C. 2929.14(C) factors must be made at the sentencing hearing and incorporated into the sentencing entry.
- 2018 Ohio 3941Gasper v. Adkins (2018)
Probate court did not err in overruling appellant's objections to magistrate's decision and in ordering sale of ward's property.
- 2018 Ohio 3942State v. Kurtz (2018)
Appellant's convictions of aggravated murder, murder, robbery, and kidnapping were not against the manifest weight of the evidence where the jury heard conflicting testimony whether appellant was at fault for causing the affray and whether appellant reasonably believed he was in imminent danger of death or serious bodily harm. Jury did not lose its way and create a manifest miscarriage of justice when it rejected appellant's claim of self-defense. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3943State v. Small (2018)
Trial court erred in granting motion to suppress on basis that officers impermissibly engaged in conversation with passenger of vehicle case remanded for trial court to consider remaining issues raised by motion to suppress.
- 2018 Ohio 3944State v. Powell (2018)
Appellant's convictions for murder, aggravated robbery, aggravated burglary, and kidnapping were supported by legally sufficient evidence in the form of eyewitness testimony and were not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 3947State v. Pattin (2018)
Because a guilty plea is a complete admission of guilt and therefore also satisfies the question of whether there is probable cause to believe the defendant committed the offense, the trial court did not commit an error in permitting the defendant to plead guilty to an unindicted offense as part of a plea bargain. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 3948Cotten v. Court of Common Pleas (2018)
Court of Claims did not abuse its discretion by dismissing complaint for failure to comply with order directing appellant to name a proper defendant within the jurisdiction of the court. The court also did not abuse its discretion by failing to sua sponte amend the complaint to name a state entity as a defendant. Appellant failed to name a state entity as a defendant and did not assert any claims that could be construed as claims against a state entity.
- 2018 Ohio 3949State v. Davenport (2018)
The trial court did not err in denying Davenport's untimely petition for postconviction relief.
- 2018 Ohio 3950State v. Steele (2018)
Where a defendant's two aggravated robbery charges with firearm specifications concerned separate victims, R.C. 2929.14(B)(1)(g) required consecutive imposition of the two firearm specifications.
- 2018 Ohio 3951State v. Linder (2018)
Ineffective assistance of counsel motion to suppress Crim.R. 29/motion for acquittal sufficiency manifest weight allied offenses speedy trial. Although appellant's testimony opened the door to raise questions about his criminal past, appellant otherwise failed to show that the outcome of the trial would have been different the detective's testimony was proper where he did not testify to the credibility of any of the witnesses, and his rebuttal testimony was solely for the purpose of refuting evidence presented by the defense appellant presented nothing definitive as to what a witness would have testified to had she been subpoenaed. Appellant has failed to show that his trial counsel was ineffective. Suppression testimony and review of the police interrogation tape supported the trial court's denial of appellant's motion to suppress. Evidence that a violent and prolonged confrontation occurred and the medical condition of the victim was sufficient to sustain appellant's attempted murder and felonious assault convictions, and those convictions were not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Where the physical assault of the victim ended and the kidnapping of the victim began, two separate offenses occurred and for merger purposes were not allied offenses. Appellant failed to show that his statutory of constitutional speedy trial rights were violated. The trial court did not err in denying appellant's motion to dismiss.
- 2018 Ohio 3952Lansky v. Brownlee (2018)
R.C. 2323.51, Civ.R. 11, frivolous conduct, sanctions, attorney fees. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in awarding fees and sanctions under R.C. 2323.51 and Civ.R. 11, an objective and subjective inquiry respectively, in light of the individual's experience with the legal standards involved in the case and history of filing similar law suits. A trial court has broad discretion to award sanctions and fees under R.C. 2323.51 and Civ.R. 11 and, in its considerable discretion, may reduce or deny attorney fees even where frivolous conduct exists.
- 2018 Ohio 3954Disciplinary Counsel v. Hull (2018)
On order to show cause.
- 2018 Ohio 3958Hassey v. City of Columbus (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3959Housden v. Wilke Global, Inc. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3962State ex rel. Swift v. Geauga Cty. Court of Common Pleas (2018)
EXTRAORDINARY WRITS - mandamus procedendo Crim.R. 32(C) one document rule.
- 2018 Ohio 3963State v. Gibson (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - motion to suppress evidence custodial interrogation voluntarily agreed to interview reasonable person feels at liberty to terminate formal arrest or restraint on freedom of movement equal to arrest casual atmosphere non-threatening not in custody Mirandized no question-first strategy waiver volungtary admonished to tell truth admission voluntary.
- 2018 Ohio 3964State v. Walker (2018)
CRIMINAL - sentencing postrelease control void voidable mandatory optional Parole Board R.C. 2967.28 res judicata withdraw plea
- 2018 Ohio 3965State v. Solomon (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - App.R. 5(A) delayed appeal reason for delay does not justify delay of three and one-half years.
- 2018 Ohio 3966State v. Schillinger (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - plea of guilty felonious assault failure to comply Crim.R. 11(C) understood consequences of entering plea post-release control notification R.C. 2929.11(A)(1) and (2) notification not required R.C. 2929.19(B)(2)(f) notification not required assessment and recoupment fees no error.
- 2018 Ohio 3968State v. Johnson (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCING/FINES, RESTITUTION, EXPUNGEMENT - trial court satisfies its obligation to consider the sentencing criteria in R.C. 2929.11 and R.C. 2929.12 by stating it considered them trial court is merely required to consider the purposes and principles of felony sentencing in R.C. 2929.11 it is not required to impose a less burdensome sentencing option R.C. 2929.14(C)(4) does not require that the trial court make the consecutive sentence findings in any particular order. INEFFECTIVE ASSISTANCE OF COUNSEL - counsel's failure to request discovery does not place his performance outside wide range of reasonable professional assistance appellant must establish prejudice resulting from counsel's failure to request discovery.
- 2018 Ohio 3969Williams v. Brockway (2018)
CIVIL - motion for summary judgment executor sale of real property three-bedroom house current agricultural use valuation grow grasses for biofuels parties represented by realtors in dual agency capacity did not represent land was farmable as-is waived right to inspect no reliance on representations unsuitable for farming no duty to disclose latent defect no fraudulent misrepresentation or concealment.
- 2018 Ohio 3970Schaefer v. Lake Hosp. Sys., Inc. (2018)
WORKERS' COMPENSATION - summary judgment additional allowances proximate causation preexisting condition substantial aggravation R.C. 4123.01(C) objective evidence pre-injury reference point cross-examination deposition testimony.
- 2018 Ohio 3973Disciplinary Counsel v. Bennett. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct, including failing to provide competent representation to a client, failing to keep a client reasonably informed about the status of a matter, and engaging in conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation—One-year suspension.
- 2018 Ohio 3976City of Youngstown v. Edmonds (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3977Carapellotti v. Breisch & Crowley (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3978State v. Bartulica (2018)
Manifest weight, sufficiency of the evidence, assault, felonious assault, tampering with evidence, knife, closing argument, jury instructions, criminal
- 2018 Ohio 3979Brake v. Keegan (2018)
In a multi-party, multi-claim case, where the judgment entry confirming the sale of the foreclosed property omits the necessary Civ.R. 54(B) certification, the court lacks jurisdiction, and the appeal must be dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 3980State v. Flores (2018)
Trial court does not abuse its discretion by denying appellant's postconviction petition, where appellant failed to establish a denial or infringement of constitutional rights.
- 2018 Ohio 3982In re L.N. (2018)
Where the juvenile court conducted a juvenile offender registration hearing after the delinquent child's release from the secure facility and after the court had terminated its order of probation, the court exceeded its statutory authority under R.C. 2152.83(B)(1) and had no jurisdiction over the child to enter a classification order.
- 2018 Ohio 3983State v. Smith (2018)
Convictions not against manifest weight of evidence despite key witness's consumption of drugs when offenses committed. Aggravated robbery and burglary convictions were supported by sufficient evidence. Trial counsel not ineffective for failing to make opening statement, investigate phone records, and renew Crim.R. 29 motion. Court properly imposed two consecutive prison terms for firearm specifications where one of appellant's two felony convictions was for offense enumerated in R.C. 2929.14(B)(1)(g).
- 2018 Ohio 3984Spitulski v. Bd. of Educ. of the Toledo City Sch. Dist. (2018)
Court lacked subject-matter jurisdiction of age discrimination claim against school board where employee elected to file OCRC charge tortious violation of rights not recognized claim under Ohio law employee failed to submit proper evidence to support disability discrimination claim employee failed to make prima facie case of retaliation conduct supporting IIED claim not sufficiently extreme and outrageous no abuse of discretion in affirming termination under R.C. 3319.16.
- 2018 Ohio 3986State ex rel. Livingston v. Bates (2018)
A trial judge does not violate the public's right to attend criminal proceedings by placing limitations on spectators' ingress and egress to the courtroom to prevent distractions during jury instructions, closing arguments, and witness testimony. The public's right to attend criminal proceedings is also not violated when the trial judge restricts access to the courtroom when court is not in session.
- 2018 Ohio 3987State v. Lawrence (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 3988Ohio Bar Liab. Ins. Co. v. CCF Dev., L.L.C. (2018)
Trial court did not err by finding that parties had released mortgage encumbering real property even though there were irregularities in the description of the property, as all necessary information was provided and correctly referenced the recording records.
- 2018 Ohio 3989State v. Williams (2018)
Appellant's assignment of error challenging the trial court's calculation of jail-time credit was dismissed where appellant had already completed his prison sentence, thereby rendering his arguments moot. Further, the trial court did not err in imposing court costs in the judgment entry of sentence without first addressing the costs at the sentencing hearing because appellant can move for waiver of court costs at any time per the recent amendment to R.C. 2947.23(C).
- 2018 Ohio 3990State v. Williams (2018)
Trial court failed to properly impose postrelease control in the sentencing entry and failed to fulfill its obligations under R.C. 2950.09 regarding the defendant's status as a sexual predator and habitual sex offender.
- 2018 Ohio 3991State v. Green (2018)
Jury did not lose its way and create a manifest miscarriage of justice by rejecting defendant's claim of self-defense and finding him guilty of murder. Trial counsel's failure to call a crime scene reconstruction expert did not constitute ineffective assistance of counsel.
- 2018 Ohio 3993State v. Cummings (2018)
Motion for a new trial Crim.R. 33 motion for mistrial materially affect substantial right untimely affidavit motion in limine abuse of discretion prejudice. Judgment affirmed. Trial court did not abuse its discretion when it denied defendant's motion for a mistrial when the alleged misconduct by the prosecutor did not materially affect defendant's substantial rights. Additionally, the trial court did not abuse its discretion when it denied defendant's motion for mistrial when the defendant was not prejudiced by the testimony in question.
- 2018 Ohio 3994State v. Cummings (2018)
Crim.R. 11(C), voluntary, prejudice. The defendant's guilty plea was voluntary because the trial court engaged in a lengthy colloquy with the defendant and ensured that the defendant understood the charges against him and the constitutional rights that he was waiving by entering into a plea agreement, and the defendant did not show how he was prejudiced.
- 2018 Ohio 3995State v. Easton (2018)
Motion to suppress traffic stop fourth amendment The trial court did not err in granting a motion to suppress evidence obtained during a traffic stop. In evaluating whether reasonable suspicion of criminal activity existed to support the stop, the trial court heard testimony from the officer who initiated the stop. The trial court found that the officer's account of the circumstances of the stop lacked credibility and, therefore, the motion to suppress was properly granted.
- 2018 Ohio 3996State v. McQueen (2018)
Motion to suppress, reasonable suspicion, exclusionary rule. The trial court did not err in granting the appellee's motion to suppress because the officers did not have reasonable suspicion to search and seize the appellee. Any evidence obtained from the unlawful search and seizure of the appellee is subject to the exclusionary rule because it was a result of the unlawful arrest of the appellee.
- 2018 Ohio 3997State v. Teaque (2018)
Allied offenses R.C. 2941.25 plain error receiving stolen property simultaneous possession. The trial court erred in not merging appellant's four convictions for receiving stolen property where the record demonstrates appellant simultaneously possessed the four firearms belonging to the same victim at the same time and location and there was no separate, identifiable harm.
- 2018 Ohio 3998State v. Taylor (2018)
Juvenile court mandatory bindover prejudice. Juvenile court did not err by failing to conduct amenability hearing and ordering mandatory bindover because the decision that found mandatory bindover of juveniles unconstitutional had been stayed. With the Ohio Supreme Court overruling its prior decision on reconsideration and upholding the constitutionality of mandatory bindover, defendant could show no prejudice from the court refusing to enforce a legal holding that the Supreme Court later overruled.
- 2018 Ohio 3999State v. Johnson (2018)
R.C. 2941.25(A)/allied offenses R.C. 3939.11(A)/maximum sentence. Attempted rape and aggravated burglary are not allied offenses under the facts of this case. The harm of the assault appellant committed was separate and identifiable from the harm of the aggravated burglary offense. Testimony and evidence in the record supported the trial court's imposition of a maximum sentence for attempted rape and the eight-year sentence was within the statutory range. The trial court did not err where it imposed a maximum sentence against appellant.
- 2018 Ohio 4000Thomas v. PNC Bank, N.A. (2018)
Disability discrimination perceived prima facie transitory and minor. A plaintiff claiming disability discrimination cannot make out a prima facie case of being perceived as disabled if the plaintiff's injuries are transitory and minor — defined under federal law as an impairment with an actual or expected duration of six months or less. Although plaintiff-employee had been placed on disability leave after breaking bones in both hands, her injuries healed and she returned to work in six weeks. The court did not err by directing a verdict in favor the defendant-employer because the plaintiff's injuries were thus transitory and minor, excluding her from a "perceived as" disabled discrimination claim.
- 2018 Ohio 4002State v. Vega (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Criminal law—Fourth Amendment—Police officer had probable cause to search car from which strong odor of marijuana emanated—After finding marijuana and other drug paraphernalia in car, police officer had probable cause to open sealed envelopes found in the car, based on his reasonable belief that they could contain marijuana.
- 2018 Ohio 4004State v. Mastrodonato (2018)
Appellant's appeal is dismissed as moot because he is challenging the length of his sentence, not his conviction, and he has already served his sentence so that there is no controversy before this court for determination.
- 2018 Ohio 4005State v. Roth (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4006State v. Foster (2018)
GUILTY PLEA – CRIM.R. 11(C) – APPELLATE REVIEW/CRIMINAL: Defendant failed to demonstrate that his guilty plea was not knowingly, voluntarily, and intelligently entered on the ground that the trial court had failed to inform him that he was subject to a mandatory prison term where the plea form failed to inform defendant about the mandatory nature of the prison term, and the trial court advised defendant that he was eligible for community control, but it then expressly told defendant multiple times during the plea colloquy that community control was not a sentencing option and that it was planning to impose a prison term upon him. [But see DISSENT: Where the trial court failed to inform defendant that his prison sentence for rape was mandatory time the court wholly failed to comply with Crim.R. 11(C)(2)(a), and defendant's guilty plea must be vacated.] Crim.R. 11(C) does not require the trial court to inform a defendant during the plea colloquy about his eligibility for judicial release or earned days of credit unless it is incorporated into a plea bargain or the trial court made some misstatement or misrepresentation about judicial release or earned days of credit that induced defendant to enter his plea. Defendant could not demonstrate that his guilty plea to rape was not knowingly, voluntarily, and intelligently entered where the trial court's misstatement of law regarding judicial release did not induce the defendant to enter his guilty plea to rape, and the trial court did not relay inaccurate information during the plea colloquy regarding earned days of credit. Defendant's claim that the Ohio Department of Rehabilitation and Correction violated the separation-of-powers doctrine by administratively adding the designation "mandatory" to his records without any judicial order requiring the designation was not demonstrated in the record where the defendant had appended a printout from the Department of Rehabilitation and Correction to his brief, but the printout had not been made a part of the record in the trial court, and thus, was not part of the record on appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 4007Ford v. Chamberlin (2018)
declaratory judgment removal of trustee final appealable order special proceedings affect substantial right R.C. 5808.15 R.C. 2505.02(A)(1) R.C. 2505.02(B)(1) R.C. 2505.02(B)(2)
- 2018 Ohio 4008Albrecht v. Franklin Cty. Court of Appeals (2018)
Where a petition for a writ of habeas corpus fails to allege an unlawful restraint of liberty, it fails to state a claim for which relief may be granted. Also, a court of appeals has original jurisdiction to hear only those types of cases enumerated in Article IV, Section 3 of the Ohio Constitution, and an action filed in the court of appeals that includes other types of claims must be dismissed on subject-matter jurisdiction grounds.
- 2018 Ohio 4009In re Application of Dayton Power & Light Co. (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Public utilities—Public Utilities Commission's approval of new electric-security plan that replaces the electric-security plan at issue in this appeal renders the appeal moot—Appeal dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 4011State ex rel. Steele v. McClelland (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Mandamus and prohibition—Petition to compel trial court to vacate journal entry dismissing first indictment—Existence of second indictment constituted "good cause" for purpose of R.C. 2941.33 requirement—Adequate remedy existed at law—Court of appeals' dismissal affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4013State v. Gibson (2018)
Crim.R. 11(B), and (C) - T/C failed to properly advise def.
- 2018 Ohio 4015Wildcat Drilling, L.L.C. v. Discovery Oil & Gas, L.L.C. (2018)
summary judgment prejudgment interest breach of contract indemnification oil and gas brine ODNR.
- 2018 Ohio 4016State v. Reber (2018)
Motion to continue abuse of discretion voluntary intelligent knowing coerce: plea
- 2018 Ohio 4017Ohio Tpk. & Infrastructure Comm'n v. Vlasach (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4021State v. Walton (2018)
App.R. 26(B) ineffective assistance of appellate counsel res judicata motion to suppress test results R.C. 4511.19 weight of the evidence. The applicant failed to set forth a colorable claim of ineffective assistance of appellate counsel where counsel did not raise an assignment of error regarding the trial court's decision denying a motion to suppress. The arguments addressed at the suppression hearing went to the credibility or weight of this evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 4022State v. Cunningham (2018)
Promoting prostitution corrupting another with drugs sufficiency of the evidence manifest weight ineffective assistance of counsel Evid.R. 404(B) unfair prejudice. There was sufficient evidence to support promoting prostitution conviction where witness testified that appellant was directing her prostitution. There was sufficient evidence to support corrupting another with drugs conviction in violation of R.C. 2925.02(A)(2) where the appellant provided the victim with a deadly drug. We decline to address the manifest weight challenge where appellant fails to set forth an independent argument in support of this assignment of error. Counsel was not ineffective for failing to request a mistrial. The trial court did not err in overruling an objection to alleged "other acts" testimony where a curative instruction was issued.
- 2018 Ohio 4023State v. Johnson (2018)
Aggravated murder complicity aiding and abetting R.C. 2923.03(A)(2) conspiracy R.C. 2923.03(A)(3) R.C. 2923.01 manifest weight admission of evidence discretion materially prejudiced plain error Crim.R. 52(B) coconspirator statements Evid.R. 801(D)(2)(e). The state's complicity case against appellant and her conviction for aggravated murder were supported by sufficient evidence, which established that appellant aided and abetted or conspired with another in the commission of the offense with the same culpability required for the principal offense. Appellant's conviction was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Trial court's admission of evidence and testimony concerning a codefendant's gang affiliation did not materially prejudice appellant, and plain error did not occur. Coconspirator statements were properly admitted pursuant to Evid.R. 801(D)(2)(e).
- 2018 Ohio 4024Glemaud v. MetroHealth Sys. (2018)
Race discrimination summary judgment R.C. 4112.02(A) Civ.R. 56(C) Ohio Civil Rights Act discriminatory animus direct evidence indirect evidence prima facie case. The trial court did not err when it granted the defendant's summary judgment motion on the plaintiff's race discrimination claim because the plaintiff failed to meet his burden in establishing a prima facie case of race discrimination through direct or indirect evidence. Accordingly, no genuine issues of material fact remained, and the defendant was entitled to judgment as a matter of law.
- 2018 Ohio 4025Calanni v. Stowers (2018)
Magistrate's decision objections independent review Civ.R. 53(D) credibility landlord tenant damages ordinary wear and tear cleaning painting abuse of discretion. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in adopting the magistrate's award of damages to the landlord where the court conducted an independent review, deferred to the trier of fact's credibility assessment of the witnesses, and found the record supported the magistrate's findings of fact and conclusions of law. The record demonstrated a lack of credibility, evidence lacking sufficient detail to support that the work was actually performed on the premises, and the landlord failed to show that the bulk of the repairs were made for damage beyond ordinary wear and tear.
- 2018 Ohio 4027State v. Baker (2018)
Consecutive sentences nunc pro tunc remand restitution. Consecutive sentences for violations of community control sanctions affirmed as they were within the statutory range, not contrary to law, and the court made the statutory findings at the sentencing hearing. Case remanded for nunc pro tunc entry incorporating statutory findings. Restitution proper as reflected in the journal entries.
- 2018 Ohio 4028State v. Buehler (2018)
Mandamus records jury forms impossibility R.C. 2969.25(C) poverty affidavit R.C. 2731.04 State ex rel. caption and motion for mandamus. Mandamus to compel production of jury verdict forms was denied because the respondent established that it did not possess the forms. There is no duty to furnish records not in possession. Relator did not comply with R.C. 2969.25(C) he did not furnish a cashier's certificate. Relator improperly captioned the case, and mandamus is not started by a motion.
- 2018 Ohio 4029State ex rel. Daffner v. Indus. Comm. (2018)
Where the evidence relied on by the commission to deny TTD benefits does not contain a finding that relator's allowed condition of "failed back syndrome, lumbar" has reached maximum medical improvement and where the evidence submitted by relator supports a finding that "failed back syndrome" is independently causing TTD, the commission abuses its discretion in denying TTD benefits. Limited writ issued requiring commission to vacate its order denying TTD benefits and to issue a new order consistent with the court's analysis. Objection overruled writ granted.
- 2018 Ohio 4030Nunn v. Ohio Dept. of Ins. (2018)
Grant of motion to dismiss affirmed because appellant's claims time-barred by R.C. 2743.16(A) Civ.R. 5(B)(2)(f) authorizes a defendant to serve a motion to dismiss by email when plaintiff includes an email address on the complaint. No abuse of discretion denying oral argument when no memorandum in opposition to motion filed. Arguments not waived below waived on appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 4033Disciplinary Counsel v. Camino (2018)
On certification of default.
- 2018 Ohio 4034State v. Pyles (2018)
Criminal: venue motion for jury view ineffective assistance unadmitted exhibit prosecutorial misconduct unauthenticated exhibit insufficient evidence manifest weight
- 2018 Ohio 4035State ex rel. Maxcy v. Saferin (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Mandamus—Writ of mandamus sought to compel board of elections to place a proposed charter amendment on the ballot for the November 2018 ballot—Article XVIII, Sections 8 and 9 of the Ohio Constitution require a municipal legislative authority to submit a proposed charter amendment to the electors by ordinance—Because city council did not enact an ordinance submitting the proposed amendment to the board of elections, relators did not have a clear legal right to have the board of elections place the proposed amendment on the ballot—Writ denied.
- 2018 Ohio 4038Dayton Bar Assn. v. Williams (2018)
On certification of default.
- 2018 Ohio 4039Disciplinary Counsel v. Thomas (2018)
On certification of default.
- 2018 Ohio 4041State v. Blair (2018)
The trial court did not err by rejecting Appellant's postconviction application for DNA testing. Appellant did not show that a new test could produce an exclusion result or would be outcome-determinative. Consequently the trial court did not err in rejecting the application. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4042State v. Clark (2018)
Pursuant to a plea agreement, the State agreed to dismiss six counts of rape (child under 13) and to amend five additional counts of rape to sexual battery (stepchild under 13), and Appellant entered an Alford plea. After the trial court dismissed Appellant's "motion for a new trial," this Court, on appeal, remanded the matter to the trial court to consider the "motion for a new trial" as a petition for post-conviction relief. The trial court did not err in overruling Appellant's petition for post-conviction relief, since the supporting affidavit provided by the victim's mother alleging the victim's recantation did not contain new evidence, and res judicata barred Appellant's argument. Appellant's argument that defense counsel was ineffective for failing to investigate the alleged recantation also lacks merit, since Appellant acknowledged that he made admissions to law enforcement regarding the victim's allegations of rape, and pursuant to the Alford plea, Appellant avoided the potential of life in prison. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4043State v. Coleman (2018)
The trial court correctly concluded that Defendant-appellant unambiguously asserted his right to silence and that the interrogating officer did not honor the invocation. Further, Coleman's comment that could be construed as a willingness to continue the discussion was not, based upon the failure to honor the invocation of the right to counsel, relevant to the suppression analysis. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4044State v. Dowell (2018)
Defendant-appellant, following a bench trial, was convicted of two counts of sexual battery. The convictions were supported by sufficient evidence and they were not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Further, even assuming trial counsel was ineffective by failing to object to the introduction of a note relating to the victim's allegations, the note's introduction was not prejudicial. The convictions, additionally, were not violative of Defendant-appellant's fundamental liberty interest to parent his child. Finally, the consecutive sentence was not contrary to law because the record supports the conclusion that the trial court engaged in the appropriate consecutive service analysis. Judgment affirmed. (Donovan, J., concurring in part and dissenting in part.)
- 2018 Ohio 4045State v. Hagen (2018)
Trial court did not err in denying Defendant's demand for immunity regarding drug possession offenses. Defendant did not qualify for immunity under R.C. 2925.11(B)(2)(b) where evidence supporting drug possession charges was not obtained as a result of Defendant's "experiencing an overdose and needing medical assistance." Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4046LexisNexis v. Hudia (2018)
Even if the trial court should not have taken judicial notice of the filing date of documents on the Secretary of State's website, the appellant was not prejudiced because the record before the trial court contained the file-stamped documents. The trial court correctly entered summary judgment against the appellant for money due under a subscription agreement where the evidence established that the appellant was personally liable. The trial court did not err in failing to rule that the appellant acted as a "pre-incorporation promoter." The appellant never raised that argument below in summary judgment proceedings. The trial court did not err in failing to sustain the appellant's competing summary judgment motion. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4047State v. Reed (2018)
Appellant's convictions for felonious assault, improper handling of a firearm in a motor vehicle, discharge of a firearm on or near a prohibited premises, and having a weapon under disability were not against the manifest weight of the evidence, as the weight of the evidence established that Appellant was the individual who fired gunshots at the police cruiser in question. In addition, pursuant to our prior decision in State v. McComb, 2017-Ohio-4010, 91 N.E.3d 255 (2d Dist.), and the Supreme Court of Ohio's recent decision in State v. Carnes, 2018-Ohio-3256, ___ N.E.3d ___, the use of a juvenile adjudication to support a charge of having a weapon under disability does not violate a defendant's constitutional right to due process. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4048State v. Taylor (2018)
Defendant-appellant, following a bench trial, was convicted of assault but she was found not guilty of endangering a child. The assault conviction was supported by sufficient evidence, and it was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. However, the trial court, as conceded by the State of Ohio, lacked subject-matter jurisdiction over the charge of child endangering. Judgment affirmed with respect to the assault charge and vacated with respect to the child endangering charge.
- 2018 Ohio 4049State v. Jones (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4050State v. Stuckman (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in joining indictments for trial under Crim.R. 13 and 8(A). Attempted aggravated murder, aggravated robbery, and felonious assault convictions were supported by sufficient evidence. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in granting the state's pretrial motion to amend the indictment to include the defendant's true name. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4052Fowler v. Menards, Inc. (2018)
Trial court committed no reversible error when confirming and entering judgment in conformity with the $0 arbitration award.
- 2018 Ohio 4053Halliday v. Mental Health & Recovery Bd. of Erie & Ottawa Ctys. (2018)
Appellant was terminated for cause in compliance with R.C. 340.04. Appellant was afforded due process where he was given an opportunity to be heard and present defenses at an administrative hearing in compliance with R.C. 340.04.
- 2018 Ohio 4054Ottney v. Al Sobb's Auto & Truck Frame Serv., Inc. (2018)
Judgment was contrary to the manifest weight of the evidence regarding a violation of the Consumer Sales Practices Act, R.C. Chapter 1345.
- 2018 Ohio 4055State v. Warford (2018)
Trial court complied with sentencing criteria under R.C. 2929.11 and 2929.12. Anders. No error brief. Counsel's request to withdraw granted.
- 2018 Ohio 4057Ohio N. Univ. v. Charles Constr. Servs., Inc. (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Insurance claims—"Occurrence"—Subcontractor faulty workmanship—Insurer is not required to defend a commercial-general-liability policyholder against suit by property owner, because subcontractor faulty workmanship is not fortuitous—Custom Agri, applied.
- 2018 Ohio 4058Rogers v. Eppinger (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Habeas Corpus—R.C. 2969.25(C)—Failure to document balance of inmate account for six months preceding filing of petition—Court of appeals' dismissal of petition affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4060Eichenlaub v. Eichenlaub (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4061Lopez v. Warden (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Habeas Corpus—Successive habeas petition arguing issue already litigated barred by res judicata—Court of appeals' dismissal of petition affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4065State v. Kuhn (2018)
The trial court did not err by revoking appellant's intervention in lieu of conviction after she was found guilty violating the terms and conditions of her intervention in lieu of conviction treatment plan by failing to report to her probation officer as instructed where the then applicable intervention in lieu of conviction statute, R.C. 2951.041, required the trial court revoke appellant's intervention in lieu of conviction upon finding appellant violated the terms of her intervention in lieu of conviction treatment plan.
- 2018 Ohio 4066State ex rel. Swain v. Harris (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Habeas Corpus—Erie County ceded to Ohio in the Treaty of Fort Industry—Court of appeals' dismissal of petition affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4068The STATE EX REL. SIMPSON v. COOPER, Judge. (2018)
Mandamus—Challenge to credibility of the evidence—Res judicata—Court of appeals' dismissal of petition affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4069State v. Bonnell (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Criminal law—Postconviction DNA testing—Appellant failed to demonstrate that results of testing of any evidence he sought to have tested could be outcome determinative—This court lacks jurisdiction to consider matters relating to adequacy of prosecution's search for biological material that could be tested—Trial court's denial of application for testing affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4070Molly Co. Ltd. v. Cuyaohga Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Real-property valuation—R.C. 5715.19(D) does not authorize dismissal of a continuing complaint for lack of timeliness—Board of Tax Appeals' decision reversed, and cause remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 4071Cleveland Metropolitan Bar Association v. Moody. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Failure to act with reasonable diligence—Knowingly making false statements to a tribunal or third person—Intentionally failing to comply with proper discovery requests—Counseling a witness to testify falsely—Engaging in conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation—Engaging in conduct that is prejudicial to the administration of justice—Indefinite suspension.
- 2018 Ohio 4072Rivenbark v. Discount Drug Mart (2018)
discrimination, disability, employment, admission of evidence, manifest weight, failure to object, plain error, jury instructions
- 2018 Ohio 4073Thompson v. Donnelly (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Procedendo—Mandamus—Court of appeals correctly denied complaint because procedendo will not compel performance of a duty that has already been performed—Appellant not entitled to extraordinary relief in mandamus because he had an adequate remedy by way of appeal—Court of Appeals' judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4074Trumbull County Bar Association v. Large. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Multiple violations of the professional-conduct rules—Several aggravating factors including prior disciplinary offenses—Permanent disbarment.
- 2018 Ohio 4075Riehm v. Green Springs Rural Volunteer Fire Dept. (2018)
Trial court erred by finding that an issue of fact existed as to whether volunteer firefighter's action was willful, wanton, or reckless.
- 2018 Ohio 4077In Re Application of Baldwin. (2018)
Attorneys—Character and fitness—Lack of candor during admissions process—Pending application to take bar exam disapproved—Reapplication permitted, for February 2021 or later bar exam.
- 2018 Ohio 4078McAdams v. Mercedes-Benz United States, LLC (2018)
Formalistic compliance with an opt-out notice is not required to validly opt-out of a class action. A vehicle owner, who, by admission, knows little about cars and has never done any service on any cars, nor personally observed the condition, is not qualified to offer an opinion, either as an expert or lay witness, to overcome summary judgment on whether a transmission conductor plate was faulty four or more years before it was found to be faulty and replaced.
- 2018 Ohio 4080Kelley v. Gerth (2018)
Appeal is sua sponte dismissed for failure to file a brief in compliance with rules.
- 2018 Ohio 4082U.S. Bank Natl. Assn. v. Bartlett (2018)
CIVIL - foreclosure default judgment Civ.R. 60(B) res judicata failure to file direct appeal timely appeal failure to provide ground for relief
- 2018 Ohio 4083Mischa Hill Assocs., L.L.C.. v. Parker Jax Legacy, L.L.P. (2018)
VEXATIOUS LITIGATOR - dismissal required when appellant deemed vexatious litigator during pending appeal and did not secure leave to continue the proceedings R.C. 2323.52 State ex rel. Sapp v. Franklin Cty. Court of Appeals, 118 Ohio St.3d 368.
- 2018 Ohio 4084State v. Drawl (2018)
CIVIL - removal of a public official of a public office R.C. 117.40 knowingly refuse to keep the accounts of his or her office proceedings to remove a public officer are quasi-penal in nature clear and convincing evidence records contained significant deficiencies township was unable to operate properly unwillingness to comply.
- 2018 Ohio 4086In re R.B. (2018)
Abused Child Perpatraton Unknown
- 2018 Ohio 4087In re B.B. (2018)
Dependent ChildUnharmed Sibling
- 2018 Ohio 4088G.S. v. M.L. (2018)
Reallocation of parental rights
- 2018 Ohio 4089State v. Jones (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4090State v. Mathis (2018)
Trial Counsel's Failure to File Motion to Waive Costs
- 2018 Ohio 4093Wyatt v. Roses Run Country Club (2018)
summary judgment—open and obvious—premises liability
- 2018 Ohio 4095State v. Davis (2018)
State Does Not Have Right to Appeal Sentence Modification on a 3 or 5 Degree Felony
- 2018 Ohio 4096Quinlan v. Highfield (2018)
New Trial - Manifest Weight - Inadequate Damages - Civ. R. 59(A)(4),(6)
- 2018 Ohio 4098State ex rel. Feagin v. Robinson (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4099Neuhart v. Transatlantic Energy Corp. (2018)
Pugh clause when an amendment letter provided that any undrilled acreage would be released if three wells were not drilled by the end of the primary term the landowner need not act within a statute of limitations because the undrilled acreage automatically reverted to them by operation of law at the end of the primary term paying quantities temporary cessation of production capital expenses not included in a paying quantities analysis expenses unrelated to the production of oil and gas not included in paying quantities analysis.
- 2018 Ohio 4100Disciplinary Counsel v. Stovell (2018)
On certified order of District of Columbia Court of Appeals, No. 18-BG-115.
- 2018 Ohio 4106State v. Thomas (2018)
Guilty plea Crim.R. 11 R.C. 2151.23(I), 2152.03 and 2152.12(J) statute of limitations rape. Trial court had subject matter jurisdiction where defendant was indicted for rape after attaining adulthood after the court learned that defendant had been detained as a juvenile for offense, it properly transferred matter to juvenile court and defendant was in turn bound over to general division trial counsel was not ineffective for failing to file a motion to dismiss under statute of limitations trial court complied with Crim.R. 11 in accepting guilty plea and in properly advising defendant of constitutional and nonconstitutional rights matter would be remanded for defendant to receive jail-time credit for juvenile detention.
- 2018 Ohio 4107State v. Keller (2018)
Rape, substantially impaired, knowledge, voluntary intoxication, sleep, Evid.R. 403(A), flight. Defendant's rape conviction is upheld where sufficient evidence was presented that the defendant knew or had reasonable cause to believe that the victim was substantially impaired. The evidence showed that the defendant was with the victim while she consumed alcohol and smoked marijuana. The victim was also asleep when the rape occurred. The trial court allowed irrelevant testimony to be presented, but the error was harmless because both the victim and the defendant testified, allowing the jury to assess their credibility without relying on irrelevant testimony. The jury instruction on flight was harmless error because the defendant testified about his motives for leaving the scene.
- 2018 Ohio 4108State v. Jordan (2018)
Rape aggravated burglary kidnapping sufficiency of the evidence manifest weight of the evidence ineffective assistance of counsel prosecutorial misconduct cumulative error.
- 2018 Ohio 4109City of Cleveland v. Grunt (2018)
Community control sanctions interior inspection of property housing code violation misdemeanor sentencing constitutionality of inspection privacy expectations. Court's imposition of interior property inspection as a condition of community control sanctions imposed for exterior housing code violations is constitutional.
- 2018 Ohio 4110Podor v. Harlow (2018)
Prof.Cond.R. 1.2, 1.7, 1.10, 1.13, 3.4, and 3.7 disqualification of opposing counsel conflict of interest loyalty to organization counsel as witness. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in granting appellee's motion to disqualify opposing counsel from representing affiliated business organizations and their trustees, employees, directors, and officers. A substantial risk of a conflict of interest exists where counsel is a named party to the proceedings served as business counsel for the codefendant businesses represented codefendant officers, directors, trustees, and employees against appellee in a prior litigation as well as the current action may testify as witnesses or who will be unable to properly defend their clients due to adverse interests.
- 2018 Ohio 4111State v. Swanson (2018)
Petition for postconviction relief, R.C. 2953.23(A)(1), res judicata. The trial court lacked jurisdiction over the defendant's petition for postconviction relief because the defendant did not claim that he was unavoidably prevented from discovering facts upon which he relied in his petition or that the United States Supreme Court has recognized a new federal or state right that applies retroactively to him.
- 2018 Ohio 4112Rockside-77 Properties, L.L.C. v. Partners Fin. Group, L.L.C. (2018)
Lease landlord lessor lessee rent contract personal guaranty contract interpretation matter of law de novo damages reasonable certainty. Judgment is affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded for the trial court to enter judgment that the personal guaranty is capped at $6,000. The trial court erred, as a matter of law, in interpreting the guaranty to find that lessee made only 11 qualifying "rent" payments and that defendant's personal obligation under the guaranty was reduced only to $49,000. With regard to the damages award, the defendants did not offer any evidence demonstrating that lessor's calculations are incorrect. The defendants did not dispute the amount owed rather, they assert that lessor's damages must be incorrect because it offered different accountings at different times. Accordingly, there is sufficient, credible evidence in the record that supports lessor's assessment of damages, including late fees and interest, with reasonable certainty.
- 2018 Ohio 4113State v. Bridges (2018)
Postconviction petition new evidence errors in sentencing res judicata. Appellant's petition for postconviction relief is untimely where his petition was filed more than three years after the trial transcript in his direct appeal was filed and he presents no new evidence in support of his claims. His claims alleging sentencing errors are also barred by res judicata because they could have been raised in his direct appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 4114State v. Patterson (2018)
Involuntary manslaughter firearm specification attempted murder tampering with evidence carrying a concealed weapon negotiated plea agreement jointly recommended sentence consecutive sentence R.C. 2929.14 R.C. 2953.08(D)(1) authorized by law. Because Patterson's 25-year sentence was within the range jointly recommended by Patterson and the state and authorized by law, it is not subject to appellate review, despite the absence of an explicit agreement as to consecutive sentences.
- 2018 Ohio 4115State v. Carter (2018)
Postconviction relief R.C. 2953.21 interlocutory order final, appealable order R.C. 2505.02 substantial right. The trial court's denial of appellant's motion to amend his petition for postconviction relief is an interlocutory order and does not affect a substantial right that appellant would not be able to protect without immediate review where his original petition remains pending.
- 2018 Ohio 4124Columbus v. Kuhel (2018)
Application to seal records in dismissed cases was properly denied.
- 2018 Ohio 4125McDonald v. Abdella (2018)
Owner of a motor vehicle, as opposed to the driver, was sued for a motor vehicle collision. This resulted in the statute of limitations lapsing as to the driver.
- 2018 Ohio 4126State v. Jones (2018)
The trial court did not err in denying defendant leave to file a delayed motion for a new trial.
- 2018 Ohio 4127State ex rel. Robinson v. Mohr (2018)
Inmate not entitled to a writ of mandamus to compel the Oho Adult Parole Authority to remove a prior conviction from consideration when deciding if he should be granted parole.
- 2018 Ohio 4128Alten v. Scott (2018)
Because the appellant did not file a transcript, we presume the validity of the proceedings and affirm.
- 2018 Ohio 4129State ex rel. T.P. v. Franklin Cty. Children Servs. (2018)
Person not entitled to a jury trial and other related relief in his juvenile court proceedings.
- 2018 Ohio 4131State v. Johnson (2018)
MURDER – WEAPONS UNDER DISABILITY – EVIDENCE – OTHER ACTS – JURY INSTRUCTIONS – HARMLESS ERROR – PLAIN ERROR: The trial court did not err in admitting other-acts evidence relating to defendant's and his codefendant's drug activity where the evidence was "inextricably interwoven" with the charged crimes, was necessary to give a complete picture of what had occurred, and was necessary to show the relationship between defendant, his codefendant and the victim. The admission of testimony about items pulled from the codefendant's trash, which included ammunition not related to the shooting and two digital drug scales, was not plain error given the other admissible evidence showing that defendant and his codefendant were involved in drug activity, and the otherwise overwhelming evidence against defendant. The admission into evidence of defendant's statement to the police that he had spent time in jail was harmless error given the evidence about his drug activity and the otherwise overwhelming evidence against him. The trial court did not err in admitting other-acts evidence under Evid.R. 403(A) where the evidence was not presented for the sole purpose of appealing to the jurors' emotions, sympathies or biases, but instead provided the setting of the case. The trial court did not commit plain error in failing to give limiting instructions after the testimony of every witness about other acts where defendant failed to request limiting instructions and where nothing in the record suggested that the jury had used improper other-acts evidence to convict defendant. The evidence was sufficient to support defendant's conviction for having weapons under a disability where it showed that defendant had constructively possessed a gun through his codefendant, and where defendant had a prior conviction for trafficking in marijuana, which precluded him from having a weapon. The evidence was sufficient to support defendant's conviction for felony murder under R.C. 2903.02 where it showed that defendant assaulted the victim, and aided and abetted his codefendant in shooting the victim, and the state did not rely on inference stacking to prove aiding and abetting.
- 2018 Ohio 4133State v. Barnett (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in permitting testimony at trial concerning Appellant's prior violent behavior when the challenged testimony was not offered to prove that Appellant had bad character or that he acted in conformity with that bad character, but rather to assist in explaining why the victim delayed disclosing her abuse. The trial court also did not abuse its discretion in excluding the contents of the victim's sexually explicit text messages at trial when the actual content of the text messages was of no consequence to Appellant's defense and would have served no purpose other than to portray the victim in a negative light. The fact that the DNA and seminal fluid tests were performed by forensic scientists other than the scientist who analyzed the test results and testified at trial did not violate the Confrontation Clause because the results of the tests performed by the other scientists were not offered for their truth, but used to help the testifying expert explain his own scientific conclusions, all of which were subject to cross-examination. Based on the evidence submitted at trial, there was sufficient evidence to support Appellant's conviction for two counts of sexual battery and said conviction was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Lastly, Appellant's sentence was not contrary to law and we find no clear and convincing evidence indicating that the record does not support Appellant's sentence. Judgment affirmed. (Froelich, J., dissenting.)
- 2018 Ohio 4134Becker v. Direct Energy, LP (2018)
Alleged error in denial of Appellant's motion for summary judgment is moot or harmless, due to the judgment in Appellee's favor, and the fact that the issues involved were not pure questions of law. Further, the trial court did not err in denying Appellant's motion for a directed verdict, as substantial competent evidence existed to support Appellee's claims, upon which evidence reasonable minds might reach different conclusions. The trial court also did not err in instructing the jury on Appellee's claim for breach of contract. Appellant waived most alleged errors by failing to object, and there was no error, let alone plain error, in the instructions that were given. Finally, the trial court did not abuse its discretion by awarding attorney fees to Appellee, given the jury's finding that Appellant acted in bad faith. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4135State v. Bevers (2018)
Defendant-appellant asserts that his guilty plea to the illegal manufacture of methamphetamine in violation of R.C. 2925.04(A) was not entered into in a knowing, voluntary, and intelligent fashion because the trial court, during the plea colloquy, incorrectly informed him that the mandatory minimum prison term was five years. This court, however, can take judicial notice of Defendant-appellant's previous conviction to a violation of R.C. 2925.041(A). Thus, the trial court accurately informed Defendant-appellant of the mandatory minimum prison term. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4136State v. Brittain (2018)
The trial court did not err in overruling the appellant's motion to suppress. Police entered the appellant's house with voluntary consent that was not the product of unlawful deception. An affidavit for a subsequently-obtained search warrant did not contain any material misrepresentations in violation of Franks v. Delaware, 438 U.S. 154, 98 S.Ct. 2674, 57 L.Ed.2d 667 (1978). Judgment affirmed. (Donovan, J., concurring.)
- 2018 Ohio 4137State v. Davis (2018)
The trial court erred in awarding Appellant 102 days of jail-time credit. Appellant should have been awarded 109 days of jail-time credit since he was placed in custody on November 1, 2016, and sentenced to prison 109 days later on February 17, 2017. The judgment of the trial court is reversed only as to the jail-time credit calculation, and the matter is remanded for the sole purpose of issuing a corrected sentencing entry that credits Appellant with 109 days of jail time served.
- 2018 Ohio 4138State v. Dixon (2018)
Trial court did not err when it denied appellant's fourth petition for post-conviction relief, because all of his arguments were barred by res judicata. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4139State v. Fader (2018)
Appellant's conviction for obstructing official business was supported by sufficient evidence. The State presented sufficient evidence on each element to sustain the verdict as a matter of law, namely that appellant, without privilege, and with purpose to prevent, obstruct, or delay the investigation, impeded the police officer's performance of his duties by providing a false identity in an effort to avoid being arrested on an outstanding warrant. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4140State v. Housley (2018)
The trial court did not err in finding the appellant's motion for return of property to be moot insofar as the motion sought property that previously had been ordered forfeited and destroyed. The trial court erred, however, in finding that it lacked authority to order the City of Troy to return a safe that allegedly belonged to the appellant and that was not addressed in the prior forfeiture order. Judgment affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 4142State v. Johnson (2018)
The trial court did not err in concluding that it could not award jail-time credit for days that Appellant spent on electronic home detention as a condition of bail. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4147Current v. Dept. of Rehab. & Corr. (2018)
Negligence- Plaintiff, an inmate in defendant's custody, brought claims against defendant after being attacked by another inmate or inmate(s) in defendant's custody. On plaintiff's objections to a magistrate's decision that recommended judgment in defendant's favor, the court agreed with the magistrate's determination that defendant lacked actual or constructive notice of any danger to plaintiff and found insufficient evidence demonstrating other inmates knew plaintiff acted as an informant. The court agreed with the magistrate's rulings on certain testimony and exhibits. The court overruled plaintiff's objections, adopted the magistrate's decision, and granted judgment in defendant's favor.
- 2018 Ohio 4148Geter v. Dept. of Rehab. & Corr. (2018)
FMLA Disability Discrimination, 4112.02- Plaintiff, a former corrections officer for defendant, brought claims after defendant terminated him for performance and attendance issues. The court found defendant established legitimate, nondiscriminatory reasons for plaintiff's termination and that defendant's reasons for plaintiff's termination were not pretextual. The court further found that defendant did not deny or interfere with plaintiff's FMLA benefits and that plaintiff could not establish a causal connection between the exercise of his FMLA rights and his termination. The court granted defendant summary judgment on all of plaintiff's claims.
- 2018 Ohio 4149Tokes v. Dept. of Rehab. & Corr. (2018)
Wrongful Death Negligence 12(B)(6) Public Duty Doctrine- The decedent's estate brought claims against defendant after the decedent's murder, alleging defendant acted negligently in its supervision and monitoring of decedent's murderer who was on post release control at the time of decedent's murder. Applying R.C. 2743.02(A)(3), the court found defendant, in supervising and monitoring the decedent's murderer, was engaged in the performance of a public duty and further found the estate failed to plead sufficient facts to establish a special relationship. The court, therefore, found defendant was entitled to immunity and granted defendant's motion to dismiss.
- 2018 Ohio 4150State v. Buxton (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4152State v. Gurley (2018)
Manifest weight & sufficiency/Assault and disorderly conduct/Right to allocution
- 2018 Ohio 4153Frazeysburg v. Stokes (2018)
Administrative appeal re: chickens, res judicata does not apply
- 2018 Ohio 4154Mackay v. Thomas (2018)
Intentioal interference with expectancy of inheritance
- 2018 Ohio 4155State v. Daboni (2018)
CRIMINAL - Appellant's drug-related convictions are affirmed however, we reverse his sentence on sole count of possession of heroin and reduce sentence from 32 years to 24 years.
- 2018 Ohio 4156Ohio Edison Co. v. Houser (2018)
Trial court improperly awarded damages to utility in negligence action for the recovery of costs to replace a utility pole, where the court failed to account for accrued depreciation of the pole and the facilities attached thereto, and erroneously awarded indirect costs that were not proven to a reasonable certainty.
- 2018 Ohio 4157Dicarlo v. Mohr (2018)
Writ of prohibition. Exercise of judicial or quasi-judicial power. Sua sponte dismissal.
- 2018 Ohio 4158Weber v. GEICO Cas. Co. (2018)
Whether or not a coverage increase in appellant's Ohio automobile policy was triggered to include the statutory minimum Michigan coverage of the subject Michigan accident remains a material fact in dispute. As such, the summary judgment ruling in favor of appellee was not proper. Judgment reversed.
- 2018 Ohio 4160State v. Brown (2018)
Crim.R. 11 – plea colloquy – constitutional rights –
- 2018 Ohio 4161State v. Bryant (2018)
post-release control, R.C. 2929.19, mootness, App.R. 12
- 2018 Ohio 4162D.M. v. D.B. (2018)
civil protection order, evidentiary standard, preponderance of the evidence
- 2018 Ohio 4163L.B. v. D.B. (2018)
civil protection order, evidentiary standard, preponderance of the evidence
- 2018 Ohio 4167State v. Kegley (2018)
The trial court did not err by recasting defendant-appellant's motion to vacate as a petition for postconviction relief or by subsequently denying the petition because a trial court's failure to order and consider a presentence investigation as it is required to do under R.C. 2951.03(A) and Crim.R. 32.2 when imposing community control for a felony offense renders a sentence voidable, not void.
- 2018 Ohio 4168State v. Clark (2018)
The trial court's ruling on a motion to reconsider a final judgment entry imposing a sentence was not a final, appealable order. Appeal dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 4169Nelsons v. Ohio High School Athletic Assn. (2018)
The trial court erred in granting Appellees' complaint seeking to enjoin the OHSAA's enforcement of its determination of ineligibility to participate in interscholastic athletics.
- 2018 Ohio 4170State v. Gamache (2018)
A mere reference to unadjudicated offenses is not sufficient to warrant the reversal of a sentence. Appellate courts will not reverse a sentence unless the sentence is contrary to law or unsupported by the record.
- 2018 Ohio 4171Allstate Ins. Co. v. Bowman (2018)
The trial court did not err in granting the insurance company's motion for summary judgment finding that it had no duty to defend or indemnify its insured against the Appellants' claims.
- 2018 Ohio 4172State v. Kennedy (2018)
Conviction for murder supported by sufficient evidence and not against the weight of the evidence. Trial counsel was not ineffective, plain error was not committed by the trial court, and the trial court did not err in declining to include a jury instruction on negligent homicide.
- 2018 Ohio 4174Disciplinary Counsel v. Marshall. (2018)
Conspiracy to commit wire fraudindefinite suspensionno credit for time served
- 2018 Ohio 4175State v. Rock (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - Crim.R. 32.1 motion to withdraw a plea of guilty or no contest after the imposition of sentence Crim.R. 32.1 motions are subject to the doctrine of res judicata de novo ineffective assistance withholding exculpatory evidence arguments could have been raised in direct appeal issues barred by res judicata trial court not required to hold an evidentiary hearing.
- 2018 Ohio 4176Smith v. Smith (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - App.R. 4(A) thirty-day rule Civ.R. 58(B) Civ.R. 5(B) untimely appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 4177State v. Thompson (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - no final order premature appeal appellant not sentenced.
- 2018 Ohio 4182In RE Application of JONES. (2018)
Attorneys—Character and fitness—Prof.Cond.R. 5.5—A lawyer admitted to practice law in another jurisdiction who provides legal services exclusively in that jurisdiction from Ohio pending resolution of an application for admission to Ohio bar without examination and who otherwise complies with Prof.Cond.R. 5.5(c) is providing legal services on temporary basis and therefore has not engaged in unauthorized practice of law—Application for admission without examination approved.
- 2018 Ohio 4183State v. Hunt (2018)
Criminal: sufficiency of the evidence manifest weight of the evidence accomplice testimony jury instruction scope of cross-examination ineffective assistance of counsel excited utterance.
- 2018 Ohio 4184State ex rel. Cannon v. Mohr (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Habeas corpus—Petition failed to comply with R.C. 2725.04(D)—Petitioner is not entitled to immediate release—Court of appeals' dismissal of petition for writ affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4186State v. Sow (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion when it denied the defendant's presentence motion to withdraw his guilty plea. The trial court substantially complied with R.C. 2943.031 as it informed the defendant of the immigration consequences of his guilty plea.
- 2018 Ohio 4187Suon v. Mong (2018)
Judgment affirmed. This court lacked jurisdiction to address appellant's assignment of error regarding summary judgment. Trial court did not err in denying appellant's motion for Civ.R. 60(B) relief without a hearing.
- 2018 Ohio 4188State v. Smith (2018)
Trial court lost jurisdiction to impose sanction for community coontrol violation because defendant completed sentence on underlying offense.
- 2018 Ohio 4189State v. Devore (2018)
Manifest weight/Abduction/Sufficiency of the evidence/Domestic violence/Appeal of reopening of case/Appeal of sentence
- 2018 Ohio 4190State v. Dunkle (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4191State v. Zinn (2018)
Plea Motion to Continue Trial Properly Overloaded
- 2018 Ohio 4193Staffrey v. D'Apolito (2018)
Procedendo rape R.C. 2907.02(A)(2) attempted aggravated murder R.C. 2923.02(A) R.C. 2903.01(A) kidnapping R.C. 2905.01(A)(4) aggravated burglary R.C. 2911.11(A)(3) petition for postconviction relief R.C. 2953.21 moot duty already performed.
- 2018 Ohio 4194State v. Long (2018)
PUBLIC RECORDS – APPELLATE REVIEW/CRIMINAL – POSTCONVICTION: The common pleas court erred in denying postconviction petitioner's request for, because petitioner had established an entitlement to, a finding for purposes of the Public Records Act that "the information sought in the public record is necessary to support what appears to be a justiciable claim," when the request was made in connection with, and sought information material to, pending postconviction prosecutorial-misconduct and ineffective-counsel claims that were cognizable in a late postconviction petition. See R.C. 149.43(B)(8). The common pleas court's entry denying the request of a postconviction petitioner for a finding for purposes of the Public Records Act that "the information sought in the public record is necessary to support what appears to be a justiciable claim" constituted a final appealable order, because the entry was made in a special proceeding and affected a substantial right. See R.C. 149.43(B)(8), 2505.03(A) and 2505.02(B)(2).
- 2018 Ohio 4196State v. Gordon (2018)
felony sentence – contrary to law – presumption of prison – R.C. 2929.13(D) – mandatory findings – demean the seriousness of the offense
- 2018 Ohio 4199State v. Webb (2018)
insufficient evidence – R.C. 2925.11 – knowingly possess – circumstantial evidence – methamphetamine – controlled delivery
- 2018 Ohio 4200The State Ex Rel. McDougald v. Greene. (2018)
Mandamus—R.C. 2969.25—Inapplicable to original actions filed in Supreme Court—Motion to dismiss denied—Alternative writ granted.
- 2018 Ohio 4201The State Ex Rel. Martin v. Greene. (2018)
Mandamus—R.C. 2969.25—Inapplicable to original actions filed in Supreme Court—Motion to dismiss denied—Alternative writ granted.
- 2018 Ohio 4202Disciplinary Counsel v. Turner. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct, including improper use of client trust account, engaging in sexual activity with a client, and engaging in conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation—Prior discipline—Two-year suspension with six months stayed on condition that respondent commit no further misconduct—Multiple conditions for reinstatement—Two years of monitored probation upon reinstatement.
- 2018 Ohio 4203State v. Horsley (2018)
final appealable order R.C. 2505.02(B)(2) summary application collection actions affects a substantial right
- 2018 Ohio 4204In re Estate of Weaver (2018)
final appealable order R.C. 2505.02(B)(2) special proceeding estate administration motion for reconsideration affect substantial right
- 2018 Ohio 4206In re A.B. (2018)
Denial of nonparent's motion for legal custody of neglected and dependent children was supported by a preponderance of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 4207State v. Amey (2018)
Sufficiency manifest weight voluntary manslaughter mitigating circumstances burden of proof inconsistent verdicts. The conviction on the involuntary manslaughter count is affirmed because the defendant solely challenges the evidence pertaining to the mitigating circumstances that are not an element the state must prove and any inconsistency in the verdicts is not grounds for a new trial.
- 2018 Ohio 4208Kaferle, Exr. v. MKT Holdings, L.L.C. (2018)
Default judgment Civ.R. 55(A) appearance hearing individual unauthorized practice of law presume regularity liquidated damages unliquidated damages negligence. Trial court abused its discretion in granting default judgment without a hearing where defendant demonstrated intention and purpose to defend lawsuit and damages awarded were not supported by sufficient evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 4209State v. A.M. (2018)
Rape, gross sexual imposition, kidnapping, motion for mistrial, motion to sever charges. Trial court did not err in denying appellant's motion for mistrial where a witness made an isolated reference to hearsay indicating that the appellant may have previously been in prison. Trial court did not err by failing to sever sexual assault charges involving three separate victims as the evidence at trial was simple and direct. Appellant's counsel provided ineffective assistance of counsel by failing to move for merger of various rape and kidnapping counts that constituted allied offenses of similar import.
- 2018 Ohio 4210State v. Coleman (2018)
Ineffective assistance of counsel extortion intimidation retaliation using sham process attempted aggravated theft tampering with records. Defendant was not denied effective assistance of trial counsel where counsel failed to object to evidence pertaining to related civil proceedings in which defendant used sham legal process in an attempt to extort money from defendants, intimidate them, and commit a theft offense, as some of the challenged evidence pertained directly to the sham proceedings, and remainder of evidence was relevant to defense trial strategy of attempting to demonstrate that defendant lacked criminal intent and used the process to assert a breach of contract claim.
- 2018 Ohio 4211State v. Bogan (2018)
Mistrial manifest necessity juror bias misconduct jury deliberations discharge objection verdict form consent implied consent totality of circumstances dismiss abuse of discretion double jeopardy. Because the trial court's declaration of a mistrial was made with defendant's implicit consent, this is not the rare or exceptional case where the protections of the Double Jeopardy Clause require the dismissal of his indictment with prejudice. The trial court did not err in denying defendant's motion to dismiss on double jeopardy grounds.
- 2018 Ohio 4212Warren v. Ohio (2018)
Mandamus, pending motion, defective caption – R.C. 2731.04, failure to include addresses of all parties in caption – Civ.R. 10(A), R.C. 2969.25(A), R.C. 2969.25(C), moot. The relator seeks a writ of mandamus in order to compel the trial court to issue a ruling with regard to a pending motion. The complaint for a writ of mandamus is defective because it is improperly captioned. Pursuant to R.C. 2731.04, a complaint for a writ of mandamus must be brought in the name of the state on relation of the person applying and cannot be captioned as a motion. The relator has also failed to comply with Civ.R. 10(A), which requires that the complaint must include the addresses of all parties. In addition, the relator has failed to comply with R.C. 2969.25(A) and 2969.25(C). Pursuant to R.C.2969.25, an inmate that commences a civil action against a government entity or employee must file a sworn affidavit that contains a description of each civil action or appeal of a civil action filed in the previous five years in any state or federal court. R.C. 2969.25(C)(1) requires that Warren file a statement setting forth his inmate account balance for each of the preceding six months as certified by the institutional cashier. Finally, attached to the respondent's motion for summary judgment are copies of judgment entries that demonstrate the relator's motion has been denied. Thus, the relator's request for a writ of mandamus is moot.
- 2018 Ohio 4213State v. Bush (2018)
Involuntary plea trial court participation in plea bargain attorney-client relationship ineffective assistance of counsel consecutive sentences. Guilty plea is not involuntary where the trial court makes reasonable inquiry into defendant's claimed dissatisfaction with representation, and where the court makes fleeting statement that it considers the offered plea to be "a good deal." Neither counsel's advisement that the defendant plead guilty, nor defendant's assertion that counsel was verbally abusive during a private conversation constitute ineffective assistance of counsel. Consecutive sentences are appropriate where the court makes required findings that are supported by the record.
- 2018 Ohio 4214State v. Cummings (2018)
Photo array, sufficient evidence, manifest weight of the evidence. The trial court did not err when it failed to suppress a photo array because it was not unduly prejudicial. The state presented sufficient evidence to convict the appellant of aggravated robbery with firearm specifications, and the conviction was not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 4215Blisswood Village Home Owners Assn. v. Genesis Real Estate Holdings Group, L.L.C. (2018)
Foreclosure lien assessment common expenses subject matter jurisdiction administrative R.C. 5311.18 R.C. 5311.081 void App.R. 12(A)(1)(b) regularity transcript App.R. 9(B) App.R. 12 App.R. 16. Foreclosure actions are within the subject matter jurisdiction of a court of common pleas. The trial court had jurisdiction to decide the foreclosure action on its merits. This court need not address the merits of the underlying foreclosure judgment because such an argument is not set forth as an assignment of error in conformity with App.R. 12(A) and 16(A). Appellant failed to comply with the requirements of App.R. 9(B)(5). Without a complete transcript of the trial proceedings, we must presume regularity below.
- 2018 Ohio 4217State v. Vicario (2018)
Manifest weight of the evidence, motion for mistrial, prosecutorial misconduct, ineffective assistance of counsel. The convictions of the appellant were not against the manifest weight of the evidence because we are required to give due deference to the factfinder's conclusions because the demeanor of witnesses, the manner of their responses, and many other factors observable by the factfinder simply are not available to an appellate court on review. The trial court did not abuse its discretion when it denied the appellant's motion for a mistrial because the appellant has not demonstrated how the testimony of the witness was prejudicial or improper. The state is not guilty of prosecutorial misconduct because the appellant has not demonstrated that he was deprived of a fair trial because of the state's statements. Trial counsel was not ineffective because the appellant did not demonstrate why trial counsel should have requested a continuance to locate a missing witness that was not a witness for the appellant.
- 2018 Ohio 4218M.D. v. M.D. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4219State v. Mannah (2018)
Sentencing - Revocation of Community Control R.C. 2929.15(B)(1)(c)(i)
- 2018 Ohio 4220State v. Bowen (2018)
Vehicle Search Drug Trafficking and Drug Possession Allied Offenses
- 2018 Ohio 4221State v. Feagin (2018)
Denial of PCR- untimely, successive petitions, res judicata
- 2018 Ohio 4226State v. Hinshaw (2018)
State's appeal. The trial court erred in concluding that police officer did not lawfully enter the defendant's residence, based on a misdemeanor arrest warrant, after observing the defendant in the residence. Judgment reversed and case remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 4227State v. Arnett (2018)
Appellant fails to show that trial counsel rendered ineffective assistance by not filing a motion to compel, motion to suppress, or motion to dismiss based on unpreserved video evidence. Appellant has not shown that the potential video evidence was materially exculpatory or that it was destroyed in bad faith. Based on the record, it cannot be said that counsel acted unreasonably or that Appellant was prejudiced by counsel's failure to file the motions. Judgment affirmed. (Donovan, J., concurring in judgment only).
- 2018 Ohio 4228State v. Bittles (2018)
Defendant-appellant pleaded guilty to speeding in violation of R.C. 4511.21(D)(4). The trial court, in addition to the imposition of a fine and court costs, suspended Defendant-appellant's driver's license for 30 days. Defendant-appellant appealed the license suspension but did not seek a stay of the license suspension. The suspension has been served, and the record does not suggest that Defendant-appellant will suffer any collateral legal disability as a result of the license suspension. This appeal, as a result, is moot, requiring dismissal of the appeal. Appeal dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 4229CitiMortgage, Inc. v. Stanley (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion by overruling Appellants' Civ.R. 60(B) motion for relief from a foreclosure judgment. Appellants did not demonstrate that they failed to answer or otherwise respond to Appellee's complaint as a result of excusable neglect, nor did they allege operative facts warranting a hearing on the motion. Judgment affirmed. (Froelich, J., concurring.)
- 2018 Ohio 4231Thomas v. Dayton Pub. Schools Bd. of Edn. (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in overruling Appellant's motion to amend her complaint, to include facts regarding her PTSD diagnosis and claims of racial and disability discrimination, eight months after she filed her administrative appeal from the termination of her teaching contract. The trial court did not consider Appellant's prior discipline at another school when determining that she was subject to termination, and Appellant was not denied due process. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in finding that Appellant's failure to enter third quarter final grades was good and just cause for termination. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4232State v. Johnson (2018)
The trial court correctly sentenced Johnson to consecutive sentences pursuant to R.C. 2921.331(D), which requires that, if an offender is sentenced to a prison term for failure to comply with an order or signal of a police officer, the offender shall serve the prison term consecutively to any other prison term imposed upon the offender. The imposition of maximum sentences for failure to comply with an order or signal of a police officer and possession was neither contrary to law nor clearly and convincingly unsupported by the record. Judgment affirmed. (Hall, J., concurs.)
- 2018 Ohio 4233Rauch v. Jefferson Twp. Bd. of Zoning Appeals (2018)
This case concerns the requested operation of a commercial compost facility, with such operation being a permitted, but conditional, use. The township, through the board of zoning appeals, approved the facility but imposed certain conditions upon its operation. The common pleas court, in a R.C. 2506.01 appeal, concluded that several of the imposed conditions were not supported by the record but that other conditions were so supported. Both parties appealed. The trial court, regarding the rejected conditions, did not abuse its discretion when determining that the conditions were not supported by the record. Further, the record did not support the contention that the trial court ignored or improperly discounted any witness's testimony. Upon remand from the common pleas court ordering the BZA to issue a conditional use permit allowing the operation of the compost facility, the BZA had the authority to impose conditions upon the facility's use following a hearing. Further, the conditions imposed were not barred by res judicata. Finally, the conditions relating to the BZA's ability to review the facility's operation were authorized by the township's zoning code. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4234Sullivan v. Willhoite (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying Appellant's petition for a civil stalking protection order. Review of Appellant's arguments is limited because Appellant failed to file a transcript of the full civil protection order hearing. As a result, the regularity of the proceedings below is presumed, and the limited record for review does not affirmatively demonstrate error. The trial court also did not use an incorrect burden of proof in deciding the case. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4235State v. Hart (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4236Disciplinary Counsel v. Speights (2018)
On certified order of District of Columbia Court of Appeals, No. 17-BG-1091.
- 2018 Ohio 4238Smetzer v. Catawba Island Twp. Bd. of Zoning Appeals (2018)
Zoning appeal dismissed as moot where appellant failed to obtain a stay of execution and construction of a retail store has commenced.
- 2018 Ohio 4239Northwest Ohio Properties, Ltd. v. Lucas Cty. (2018)
Specific performance. Easement by estoppel. Trespass. Ejectment.
- 2018 Ohio 4242State v. Megarry (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4243State ex rel. Wegman v. Ohio Police & Fire Pension Fund (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Disability benefits—Mandamus—Ohio Police & Fire Pension Fund board did not abuse its discretion in denying certain benefits—Court of Appeals' judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4244Greenway Ohio, Inc. v. Cuyahoga Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Real-property tax—Property managers are not among the nonlawyers who are authorized under R.C. 5715.19(A) to file valuation complaints on behalf of property owners—Board of Tax Appeals' decision remanding to board of revision for dismissal of valuation complaint affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4245State ex rel. Sands v. Court of Common Pleas (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Mandamus—Appellant not entitled to extraordinary relief in mandamus because he failed to identify the alleged duty he sought to enforece and he had an adequate remedy by way of appeal—Court of appeals' dismissal affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4246State ex rel. Keith v. Dept. of Rehab. & Corr. (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Criminal law—Inmate failed to show that substantively inaccurate information remains in his parole record, prejudicing his parole applications—Court of appeals' judgment denying motions for show-cause and contempt orders affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4247Ohio State Bar Association v. Ross. (2018)
Unauthorized practice of law—Drafting, signing, and litigating civil actions for eviction and related claims—Consent decree approved—Civil penalty imposed.
- 2018 Ohio 4248State v. Tyburski (2018)
petition for post-conviction relief – guilty plea – ineffective assistance of counsel – knowing, intelligent, and voluntary – waiver – murder
- 2018 Ohio 4249State v. Hunter (2018)
Complicity, Firearm Specification, Sufficiency of the Evidence, R.C. 2941.141(A), Operability, Weight of the Evidence, Plain Error, Ineffective Assistance of Counsel, Accomplice Testimony
- 2018 Ohio 4250State v. Heater (2018)
manifest weight – speeding – sudden emergency doctrine – affirmative defense – tailgating – reckless operation – license suspension
- 2018 Ohio 4252State v. Todd (2018)
Defendant-appellant's absence from a portion of voir dire conducted in camera is not plain error. The trial court did not abuse its discretion by denying defendant-appellant's motion for a new trial.
- 2018 Ohio 4253State v. Godley (2018)
The record does not demonstrate that defendant-appellant was mentally incompetent to undertake self-representation. Defendant-appellant clearly and unequivocally invoked his right to self-representation. Defendant-appellant knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily waived his right to counsel.
- 2018 Ohio 4256State v. Ritchie (2018)
Appellant's convictions were supported by sufficient evidence and were not against the manifest weight of the evidence because appellant failed to fulfill the duty he owed his child to provide medical attention after the appellant's wife burned the child as punishment and because not providing the medical attention caused the child's death.
- 2018 Ohio 4257State v. Sizemore (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4258State v. Miller (2018)
The trial court did not err by denying appellant's motions requesting it to dismiss his conviction and mandatory seven-year prison sentence for want of subject matter and personal jurisdiction upon finding appellant's "sovereign citizen" arguments lacked merit in that appellant's arguments had no basis in law or fact.
- 2018 Ohio 4259State v. Prues (2018)
Appellant was charged with petty offenses and therefore was required to file a written request for a jury trial if she did not want her case tried to the bench.
- 2018 Ohio 4260State v. Snyder (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4261State v. Williams (2018)
The trial court did not err by finding aggravated burglary and kidnapping were not allied offenses of similar import subject to merge for purposes of sentencing where the offenses were committed separately with separate and identifiable harm to the two victims.
- 2018 Ohio 4262State v. Anderson (2018)
Appellant's conviction was not against the manifest weight of the evidence where the trial court determined appellant's testimony lacked credibility and where appellant failed to demonstrate he had an honest belief that he was in danger before lifting the victim off the ground and choking him.
- 2018 Ohio 4263State v. Henderson (2018)
Possession of a Deadly Weapon While Under Detention Weight of the Evidence as to Deadly Nature
- 2018 Ohio 4264Alt v. Bauer (2018)
Appeal of summary judgment order on nuisance/Trespass claims/Whether final appealable order
- 2018 Ohio 4265Strohminger v. B&W Cartage Co., Inc. (2018)
No Final Order Civ. R. 54(B)
- 2018 Ohio 4266State v. Strohl (2018)
Failure to Appear Tolling of Probation Periiod
- 2018 Ohio 4269State v. Nixon (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - App.R. 5(A) delayed appeal reason fails to explain delay notice of appeal over nine months late.
- 2018 Ohio 4270Trickett v. Masi (2018)
CIVIL - receiver appellant's claims for legal malpractice, breach of fiduciary duty, and conversion against court-appointed receiver arising from receiver's performance of duties ordered by the court were barred due to lack of standing and res judicata.
- 2018 Ohio 4271In re Estate of Copeland (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - App.R. 16(A) Local Rule 16(C) & (E) failure to include assignments of error or statement of issue presented for review no decipherable argument on appeal appeal dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 4272State ex rel. Sands v. Culotta (2018)
EXTRAORDINARY WRITS - mandamus summary judgment res judicata.
- 2018 Ohio 4273State ex rel. Dewine v. Church of Troy (2018)
CIV.R. 54 - no final appealable order not all point resolved appeal dismissed no appellate jurisdiction
- 2018 Ohio 4274Fid. Natl. Title Co. v. Carlson (2018)
CIVIL - foreclosure confirmation of sale notice of sale R.C. 2329.26(A)(1)(a)(i)
- 2018 Ohio 4275State v. Magri (2018)
CRIMINAL - Theft Receiving Stolen Property hearsay business records exception to hearsay Evid.R. 803(6) qualified witness familiarity with record keeping manifest weight of the evidence sufficiency of the evidence circumstantial evidence permissible inference
- 2018 Ohio 4276State v. Spencer (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - Anders v. California wholly frivolous ineffective assistance of counsel no constitutional right to choice of counsel or to determine trial tactics competence to stand trial R.C. 2945.37(G) criminal defendants are presumed competent willingness to assist attorney is not the test for competency maximum prison term R.C. 2929.11 R.C. 2929.12.
- 2018 Ohio 4277Spencer v. Spencer (2018)
CIV.R. 53 - Appellant-trustee's argument that trial court erred in awarding appellee-beneficiary exclusive possession of certain property jointly owned by them without compensating appellant for his interest was waived because appellant failed to raise this issue as an objection to the magistrate's decision appellant's argument that damages awarded by court were against manifest weight of evidence lacked merit as he failed to raise this issue in his objections to magistrate's decision. TRUST - trustee was personally liable in conversion since he converted property to his own use appellant-trustee was liable to appellee-beneficiary of the trust whose rights were violated through trustee's misfeasance.
- 2018 Ohio 4281State ex rel. Grant v. Collins (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Prohibition—Megan's Law provisions remain in effect for those who committed their offenses before enactment of the Adam Walsh Act—Judgment dismissing writ action affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4282Hilliard City Schools Bd. of Edn. v. Franklin Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Real-property valuation—Special-purpose doctrine—BTA has great discretion in evaluating conflicting appraisals and appraiser credibility—Decision affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4283Disciplinary Counsel v. Dunn. (2018)
Judge misconduct—Violations of the Code of Judicial Conduct and the Rules of Professional Conduct—Six-month stayed suspension.
- 2018 Ohio 4284Huber Hts. City Schools Bd. of Edn. v. Montgomery Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Real-property valuation—Appraisal-review evidence—Appellant has burden to prove new value before the BTA—Decision affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4286Groveport Madison Local Schools Bd. of Edn. v. Franklin Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Real-property valuation—BTA's independent valuation of property using evidence in the record—Regularity presumed in official actions—Decision affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4287In Re Application of Jones. (2018)
Attorneys—Character and fitness—Law school honor-code violation and lack of candor during bar-admissions process—Pending applications to take bar exam disapproved—Reapplication permitted for February 2021 or later bar exam.
- 2018 Ohio 4289State v. Jackson (2018)
Criminal: sufficiency of the evidence plain error lesser-included offense jury instruction.
- 2018 Ohio 4290State v. Atkinson (2018)
Sentence not contrary to law and record supports trial court's maximum sentence.
- 2018 Ohio 4291State v. Frazier (2018)
Suppression - Plain View Doctrine
- 2018 Ohio 4292State v. Stepherson (2018)
Matter sua sponte dismissed for late filed appeal when no leave for delayed appeal filed, due to lack of jurisdiction to hear appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 4293Wallace v. OhioHealth Corp. (2018)
Failure to provide an affidavit of merit in a medical claim was not required when common knowledge was sufficient to state a claim for liability.
- 2018 Ohio 4294Avalon Resort & Spa, L.L.C. v. Unemp. Comp. Rev. Comm. (2018)
In appeal from a decision finding employer liable for contributions under Ohio unemployment compensation law, court of common pleas did not apply incorrect standard of review or abuse its discretion in finding that the decision of the commission was supported by reliable, probative, and substantial evidence and was in accordance with law.
- 2018 Ohio 4295State v. Morris (2018)
Convctions for weapon under disability upheld pursuant to State v. Carnes, 2018-Ohio-3256. No error in denying motion to suppress or motion to withdraw guilty plea.
- 2018 Ohio 4296Parker v. Mausser (2018)
Appellant failed to state a claim for relief in his action for declaratory judgment. The nunc pro tunc entries at issue did not dismiss appellant's conviction for aggravated murder. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4297State v. Smith (2018)
Where a defendant kept a loaded pistol near at hand without a concealed carry permit while driving a truck, he violated R.C. 2923.16(B). Because there are numerous ways he could have protected his truck with a firearm (including a handgun) without violating the law, and because a truck (even though the defendant sometimes slept in the truck) is not a home within the meaning of District of Columbia v. Heller, 554 U.S. 570 (2008), the statute the defendant violated was not unconstitutional either facially or as applied.
- 2018 Ohio 4298Thompson v. Lester (2018)
Trial court erred by granting motion for relief from judgment and subsequent motion for restitution when appellees voluntarily paid the amount due on a default judgment and did not seek a stay of execution of the default judgment order. Although appellees asserted they paid the judgment to avoid further collection efforts, this did not render their payment involuntary.
- 2018 Ohio 4299State v. Armengau (2018)
Because the trial court lost jurisdiction to alter or amend the judgment of conviction and sentence after the judgment was affirmed on appeal, the trial court did not err when it denied appellant's combined motion for reconsideration of his first motion for leave to file a motion for new trial and, in the alternative, second motion for leave to file a delayed motion for new trial. The law of the case doctrine also presented a bar to the trial court's consideration of appellant's motion because the court of appeals had affirmed the denial of appellant's first motion for leave to file a motion for new trial on timeliness grounds. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4300Beavercreek Towne Station, L.L.C. v. Greene Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Real-property valuation—Standing—Property owner may authorize tenant to pursue tax appeal on property owner's behalf—Decision vacated and cause remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 4301Store Master Funding VI, L.L.C. v. Franklin Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation—Real-property valuation—Board of Tax Appeals failed to consider property owner's appraisal evidence—Decision of Board of Tax Appeals vacated and cause remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 4302Spirit Master Funding IX, L.L.C. v. Cuyahoga Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation—Real-property valuation—Board of Tax Appeals failed to consider property owner's appraisal evidence—Decision of Board of Tax Appeals vacated and cause remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 4303Northland-4, L.L.C. v. Franklin Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation—Real-property valuation—Board of Tax Appeals failed to consider property owner's appraisal evidence—Decision of Board of Tax Appeals vacated and cause remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 4304MK Menlo Property Owner, L.L.C. v. Summit Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation—Real-property valuation—Board of Tax Appeals failed to consider property owner's appraisal evidence—Decision of Board of Tax Appeals vacated and cause remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 4305Menlo Realty Income Properties 28, L.L.C. v. Franklin Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation—Real-property valuation—Board of Tax Appeals failed to consider property owner's appraisal evidence—Decision of Board of Tax Appeals vacated and cause remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 4306Icon Owner Pool 3 Midwest/Southeast, L.L.C. v. Franklin Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation—Real-property valuation—Board of Tax Appeals failed to consider property owner's appraisal evidence—Decision of Board of Tax Appeals vacated and cause remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 4307Icon Owner Pool 3 Midwest/Southeast, L.L.C. v. Franklin Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation—Real-property valuation—Board of Tax Appeals failed to consider property owner's appraisal evidence—Decision of Board of Tax Appeals vacated and cause remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 4308DISCIPLINARY COUNSEL v. HOLMES and Kerr. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct, including revealing information relating to the representation of a client—Six-month stayed suspension.
- 2018 Ohio 4309White v. Quest Diagnostics, Inc. (2018)
workers' compensation, R.C. 4123.01(C), coming-and-going rule, arising out of, in the course of, zone of employment, control, Civ.R. 56
- 2018 Ohio 4310State ex rel. Maher v. Akron (2018)
judgment on the pleadings – inverse condemnation – regulatory taking – breach of contract – breach of implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing
- 2018 Ohio 4311State v. Gordon (2018)
postconviction relief—successive petition
- 2018 Ohio 4312In Re K.T.1 (2018)
CHILDREN – CUSTODY – EVIDENCE: The juvenile court complied with the appellate court's mandate on remand to consider all the statutory best-interest factors when making a permanent custody best-interest determination, where the court specified in its judgment after remand that it had considered all the statutory factors, and it was not required to discuss each factor. The juvenile court's R.C. 2151.353(A)(4), R.C. 2151.414(E), and R.C. 2151.414(D)(1) determinations in support of an award of permanent custody to the Hamilton County Department of Job and Family Services as the initial disposition of K.T.3 were supported by clear and convincing evidence and were not against the manifest weight of the evidence where the child was adjudicated dependent due in part to Mother's chronic mental illness, identified as paranoid-type schizophrenia, which had led to K.T.3's removal at birth and had prevented Mother's reunification with her older children, K.T.1, A.T. and K.T.2., and where the record reflects that K.T.3 could not be placed with either parent within a reasonable time and should not be placed with either parent, and that it was in K.T.'s best interest, after more than three years of temporary custody, to be placed in the permanent custody of the agency, so that he may be adopted. The juvenile court erred as a matter of law by failing to award permanent custody of K.T.1, A.T. and K.T.2 to the agency based on the mandatory provisions of R.C. 2151.414(D)(2) where the children, who had been in the agency's temporary custody for over two years, no longer qualified for temporary custody, were not old enough to qualify for a planned permanent living arrangement, and were not the subject of a request for legal custody filed by a relative or interested party, could not be returned to either parent within a reasonable time or should not be returned to either parent: Father had abandoned the children, and evidence of Mother's instability caused by her chronic mental illness, which had led to the court's determination that K.T.3 could not be placed with Mother within a reasonable time and should not be placed with Mother, also prevented the other children's placement with Mother.
- 2018 Ohio 4316State v. Harris (2018)
Obstructing official business–no contest plea–explanation of circumstances sufficiently showed that defendant obstructed official business when defendant handed open container to adult son, instructed daughter (who also possessed open container) to leave the scene, instructed son to intervene in arrest, and became combative during arrest.
- 2018 Ohio 4317State v. Contini (2018)
Dismissal Without Prejudice Speeedy Trial
- 2018 Ohio 4318State v. Kress (2018)
Manifest weight of the evidence/Sufficiency of the evidence
- 2018 Ohio 4320State v. Loyd (2018)
Manifest Weight - Promptness - Void for Vagueness
- 2018 Ohio 4321State v. McKenzie (2018)
OVI - Stop - Suppression
- 2018 Ohio 4322Marshman v. State (2018)
Habeas corpus, R.C. 2725.04(D), R.C. 2969.25(A), R.C. 2969.25(V), Civ.R. 10(A), adequate remedy at law. The petitioner's request for a writ of habeas corpus is denied because of the following procedural errors. First, the petitioner failed to comply with R.C. 2725.04(D), which requires the attachment of commitment papers to the petition. Second, the petitioner failed to comply with R.C. 2969.25(A), which requires that an inmate who commences an action against a government entity to file with this court an affidavit that contains a description of each civil action or appeal of a civil action that the inmate has filed in the previous five years in any state or federal court. Third, the petitioner failed to comply with R.C. 2969.25(C), which requires that any inmate filing a civil action against a government entity or employee in forma pauperis submit with their complaint an affidavit of indigency and a statement that sets forth the balance in the inmate account of the inmate for each of the preceding six months, as certified by the institutional cashier. Fourth, the petitioner failed to comply with Civ.R. 10(A), which requires the petitioner to list the proper parties and their addresses in the case caption. Finally, the petitioner possesses an adequate remedy at law through a direct appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 4323Cleveland v. Shevchenko (2018)
Parking violation vacant lot expired registration failure to transfer minor misdemeanor Traf.R. 3 Crim.R. 4 Crim.R. 7. The criminal action for violations of parking restrictions and other nonmoving violations was properly initiated through the use of a uniform traffic ticket, and the trial court did not err in amending the citation for the purposes of trial because the amendment did not constitute a material variance of the allegations.
- 2018 Ohio 4324Woods v. Marcano (2018)
Forcible entry and detainer action dismissal fictitious name R.C. 1329.01(A)(2), (D) R.C. 1329.10(B) title to real property. Where subject properties were titled in a fictitious name plaintiff had reported the use of to the Ohio Secretary of State before taking title to the properties and before filing eviction actions, the trial court erred in dismissing his claims for damages on the ground that he was not the owner of the properties and the properties were titled in a fictitious name.
- 2018 Ohio 4325State v. Bridges (2018)
Crim.R. 32.1 undue delay. Defendant's five-year delay from the final sentencing in filing a Crim.R. 32.1 postconviction motion to withdraw his plea militated against defendant's credibility especially in consideration of the fact that defendant's community control sanctions were revoked approximately a year after the final conviction.
- 2018 Ohio 4326State v. Sharpley (2018)
Guilty plea Crim.R. 11 sentencing. Trial court complied with Crim.R. 11 and properly determined that no promises had been made to defendant before accepting guilty plea sentence was not unlawful.
- 2018 Ohio 4327State v. Hill (2018)
Plea, strict compliance, constitutional rights, allied offenses. Trial court strictly complied with Civ.R. 11(C)(2) when advising appellant of his constitutional and nonconstitutional rights. Isolated comments and irrelevant questions did not create an inference that appellant did not appreciate the effect of his plea or the rights he was waiving. Offenses that occur on different days do not merge because they are committed separately. Domestic violence and burglary did not merge because the offenses were committed separately and with a separate animus.
- 2018 Ohio 4328State v. Heaggans (2018)
Burglary photo array unduly suggestive R.C. 2933.83 ineffective assistance of counsel hearsay manifest weight sufficiency of the evidence. Heaggans did not receive ineffective assistance of counsel where counsel did not file a motion to suppress a photo identification and did not object to alleged hearsay testimony because he was not prejudiced by either alleged failure. His convictions were supported by sufficient evidence and was not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 4330Cleveland v. McCall (2018)
Double jeopardy effect of a no contest plea due process explanation of circumstances.
- 2018 Ohio 4335Cleveland v. Embassy Realty Invests., Inc. (2018)
Demolition costs collection piercing-the-corporate-veil theory satisfaction of judgment moot. Appeal dismissed as moot. Defendant-appellant failed to obtain a stay of execution of the judgment. Plaintiff-appellee obtained judgment against defendant-appellant under a piercing-the-corporate-veil theory of liability for demolition costs of a building on property owned by a corporate entity of which defendant-appellant was the sole officer and shareholder. During the pendency of the appeal, the plaintiff-appellee city obtained satisfaction of the judgment through garnishment of defendant-appellant's wages and personal earnings. Defendant-appellant did not seek to stay execution of the judgment, and the judgment was voluntarily satisfied, rendering moot the appeal from the judgment.
- 2018 Ohio 4336In re Atway (2018)
On certified entry of felony conviction.
- 2018 Ohio 4337In re Resignation of Beckley (2018)
Attorneys at law—Resignation with disciplinary action pending—Gov.Bar R. VI(11)(C).
- 2018 Ohio 4338State ex rel. Johnson v. Bur. of Sentence Computation (2018)
A petition for a writ of habeas corpus must be filed in a court in the county where the inmate is incarcerated. A writ of mandamus will not be issued that disregards binding caselaw from the Supreme Court of Ohio.
- 2018 Ohio 4339State v. Vogel (2018)
Practicing attorney could be found guilty of contempt where the evidence indicated that he lied to the court about the existence of a plea offer.
- 2018 Ohio 4340Gallick v. Benton (2018)
Trial court did not abuse its discretion in adopting the magistrate's findings of fact and conclusions of law and entering judgment for appellee on appellant's negligence claim. The weight of the evidence supported the trial court's determination that appellee was confronted with a sudden emergency when his vehicle was struck by a van whose driver had failed to yield at a stop sign and pushed off the roadway into appellant's building causing property damage. Appellee did not waive the defense of sudden emergency, pursuant to Civ.R. 8(C), by failing to specifically plead the defense in his answer because the Ohio Civil Rules do not apply to small claims matters under Chapter 1925 of the Ohio Revised Code, and because appellant had notice appellee intended to assert the defense at trial and an adequate opportunity to present arguments and evidence in opposition to the defense. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4341Chris Haus Auto Sales L.L.C. v. Dept. of Job & Family Servs. (2018)
Common pleas court erred by affirming Unemployment Compensation Review Commission decision that applied the wrong statutory standard in determining whether one employer was the successor in interest to another employer. The Commission determined the acquiring employer acquired substantially all of the business of the transferring employer however, because there was no application for voluntary successorship the appropriate statutory standard was whether the acquiring employer acquired all of the trade or business of the transferring employer. Therefore, the Commission's decision was not in accordance with law.
- 2018 Ohio 4342State v. Sipple (2018)
Trial court did not err by denying appellant's motion to suppress statements made to a police officer during a subsequent interaction with police because the statements were relevant to the charges against appellant and the probative value of the statements was not substantially outweighed by the risk of undue prejudice. Trial court did not err by denying appellant's motion for mistrial because, under the circumstances of the case, the prosecutor's brief comment about appellant's record did not prejudicially affect appellant's substantial rights.
- 2018 Ohio 4344State v. Williams (2018)
Defendant-appellant, following a bench trial, was found guilty of disorderly conduct, resisting arrest, and obstructing official business. The trial court's verdicts were supported by sufficient evidence and they were not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4345State v. Thomas (2018)
Appellant's conviction for two counts of rape of a person under the age of 13 and four counts of gross sexual imposition of a person under that age of 13 was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. In addition, the trial court did not abuse its discretion in permitting the victim to testify regarding other wrongful acts of the Appellant, including: (1) the Appellant showing the victim material on his computer that a reasonable juror could infer was child pornography and (2) three incidents of sexual abuse that were not alleged in the indictment. Finally, this court finds no plain error with regard to the prosecutor classifying the material on Appellant's computer as child pornography during its closing argument, as such an inference was reasonable and it did not affect the outcome of Appellant's trial. Judgment affirmed. (Donovan, J., concurring.)
- 2018 Ohio 4346Tax Ease Ohio, L.L.C. v. Wells (2018)
Trial court's judgment entry in a tax certificate foreclosure case was not a final appealable order. Appeal dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 4347State v. Johnson (2018)
The trial court did not prevent the appellant from subpoenaing any witnesses. Therefore, it did not deprive him of his Sixth Amendment right to compulsory process. The appellant's no-contest plea waived his ability on appeal to challenge the trial court's ruling on a motion in limine. Although the appellant entered his no-contest plea under the mistaken belief that it preserved his ability to challenge the ruling on the motion in limine, we are unable to exercise our discretion to notice plain error because the trial court's ruling undoubtedly was correct, the result would be the same if an appeal of the liminal ruling itself had proceeded, and therefore there is no plain error to notice. Judgment affirmed. (Donovan, J., dissenting.)
- 2018 Ohio 4349State v. Fickert (2018)
The trial court erred in granting Appellant's motion to suppress evidence obtained during a traffic stop. Specifically, the trial court incorrectly concluded that the traffic stop was unlawful where the court did not discredit the investigating officer's testimony and the officer's testimony was sufficient to establish a reasonable, articulable suspicion that Appellant committed a traffic violation. Judgment reversed and remanded for further proceedings. (Froelich, J., dissenting.)
- 2018 Ohio 4350Dayton City School Dist. Bd. of Edn. v. Dayton Edn. Assn. (2018)
The trial court did not err in concluding that an arbitration award had a rational connection to the parties' collective bargaining agreement and was not arbitrary, capricious, or unlawful. Judgment affirmed. (Tucker, J., concurring.) (Hall, J., dissenting.)
- 2018 Ohio 4351State v. Chavez (2018)
The trial court did not err in overruling Appellant's motion to suppress the drug evidence discovered in his motel room. The entry and search of the motel room by law enforcement officers was lawful given that the officers had an arrest warrant and a reasonable belief that the subject of the arrest warrant was a registered tenant present inside the motel room. Judgment affirmed. (Donovan, J., dissenting.)
- 2018 Ohio 4354Toledo v. Williams (2018)
Where the state only presented evidence of the street address where the vehicle was found, insufficient evidence of venue required the reversal of appellant's conviction for unauthorized use of a motor vehicle. R.C. 2901.12(A). Crim.R. 29 plain error.
- 2018 Ohio 4355Blackstone v. DeSmith (2018)
The trial court did not err by granting summary judgment where the double-dismissal rule under Civ.R. 41(A)(1)(a) acted to bar the action under the doctrine res judicata. Concurrent unauthorized two dismissal.
- 2018 Ohio 4356State v. Norales-Martinez (2018)
Trial counsel not ineffective for (1) failing to file motion to suppress statements, (2) failing to object to multiple instances of prosecutorial misconduct, admission of hearsay statements, admission of irrelevant, "highly prejudicial" evidence, or jury instructions or (3) failing to appreciate that mandatory eight-year prison term was at stake. While assistant prosecutor asked several improper questions and made improper comments during closing, conduct was not sufficiently pervasive or prejudicial.
- 2018 Ohio 4357Perrysburg v. Kelley (2018)
Appellant's probation violation conviction for breaching a cpo was supported by the weight of the evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4358Ferguson v. ProMedica Cent. Physicians, L.L.C. (2018)
Summary judgment in favor of appellees on appellant's claim for retaliatory discharge is warranted where appellant has not demonstrated a genuine issue of material fact regarding whether appellees' proffered legitimate reason for the adverse employment action is mere pretext.
- 2018 Ohio 4359State v. Davis (2018)
Appellant's sentence was not void where postrelease control was properly imposed. R.C. 2967.28 multiple concurrent.
- 2018 Ohio 4364State v. Reffitt (2018)
Trial court should advise defendant pleading to felony committed while on PRC that PRC violation must be impposed consecutively pba vacated
- 2018 Ohio 4365People's Bank, N.A. v. Garcia (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4367State v. Rader (2018)
If a defendant commits a felony while he or she is on post-release control, R.C. 2929.141(A) governs and gives the sentencing court the authority to terminate post-release control and impose a sentence for the post-release control violation.
- 2018 Ohio 4368State v. Davis (2018)
Appellant's convictions were supported by competent and credible evidence to sustain the jury's verdict of guilt. Further, Appellant's convictions were not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Additionally, Appellant was not denied effective assistance of counsel. Lastly, the trial court did not err in its various pre-trial rulings and did not err in permitting an expert to testify who had not prepared and provided a report. Judgments affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4369In re T.C. (2018)
adjudication – abused – neglected – dependent – clear and convincing evidence – manifest weight of the evidence – findings of fact and conclusions of law – R.C. 2151.28(L)
- 2018 Ohio 4370Harrah's Ohio Acquisition Co., L.L.C. v. Cuyahoga Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation—Real-property valuation—Board of Tax Appeals ("BTA") did not commit legal error in assessing property owner's appraisal or in denying school board's motion for judicial notice but did commit legal error in refusing to consider school board's appraisal—BTA's decision vacated and cause remanded for BTA to fully consider and address evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 4371In re Prisley (2018)
On certified entry of felony conviction.
- 2018 Ohio 4374State ex rel. Davis v. Sloan (2018)
ORIGINAL ACTION - writ of habeas corpus Civ.R. 12(B)(6) failure to state a claim jurisdiction adequate remedy at law res judicata.
- 2018 Ohio 4375State v. Casper (2018)
CRIMINAL - motion to withdraw plea plea agreement terms of agreement full and fair consideration contract right to enforcement of obligations breach of plea agreement
- 2018 Ohio 4376State v. Lee (2018)
DRUG OFFENSES - possession of heroin aggravated possession of fentanyl since powdery-solid material in appellant's possession weighed .566 gram and the indictment alleged the amount of each drug was .566 gram, the two offenses should have merged for purposes of sentencing because the two charges amounted to one criminal act.
- 2018 Ohio 4377State v. Goodwin (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - pre-sentence motion to withdraw guilty plea oral motion and arguments at sentencing Peterseim factors complete and impartial hearing full and fair consideration Crim.R. 44(A) right to counsel motion is not "pro se" when represented by counsel.
- 2018 Ohio 4378Estie Invest. Co. v. Braff (2018)
LANDLORD/TENANT - Action to recover damages to leasehold evidence necessary to link damages to tenant prior condition of leasehold insufficient evidence describing specific damage to separate items in leasehold failure to present itemized estimate of cost to repair each individual item testimony regarding ordinary wear and tear reasonable evidence of recoverable damages estimate of repair cost prepared by different person inadmissible hearsay.
- 2018 Ohio 4379State v. Miller (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - Crim.R. 32.1 post-sentence motion to withdraw guilty plea manifest injustice standard ineffective assistance of counsel knowing and voluntary nature of guilty plea arguments that rely on information de hors the record cannot be addressed on direct appeal duty to notify defendant of longest term of postrelease control in multiple offense cases.
- 2018 Ohio 4380Block v. Battaglia (2018)
CIV.R. 60 - a motion for relief from judgment pursuant to Civ.R. 60(B)(2) is no substitute for appeal res judicata.
- 2018 Ohio 4382State v. Blevings (2018)
The trial court's sentencing decision and restitution order was not contrary to law.
- 2018 Ohio 4384Eckert v. Warren Cty. Rural Bd. of Zoning Appeals (2018)
Trial court did not err in affirming county zoning board's approval of a conditional-use permit and site plan to operate a Class 2 home-occupation business.
- 2018 Ohio 4385In re B.S. (2018)
Juvenile court did not err by granting permanent custody in favor of the children services agency where the child had been in the temporary custody of the agency for more than the statutory 12-month period and permanent custody was in the child's best interest.
- 2018 Ohio 4386Tankersley v. Ohio Fair Plan Underwriting Assn. (2018)
The trial court properly granted insurance company's Civ.R. 12(B)(6) motion to dismiss where the property owners failed to exhaust all available administrative remedies prior to filing their complaint against the insurance company and where their participation in the administrative appeal process would not have been a vain act. The trial court properly granted summary judgment in favor of insurance agent regarding property owners' common law fraud and deceit claim.
- 2018 Ohio 4387State v. Bowling (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4390Johnson v. Clark Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation—Real-property valuation—Current-agricultural-use valuation—Board of Tax Appeals did not misapply burden of proof, improperly apply presumption of validity to county board of revision's decision, fail to properly consider property owner's evidence under owner-opinion rule, err in finding that county auditor complied with his duty to determine property's 2013 value, or err in finding that property owner failed to establish boundaries of portions of property for which he sought reduced valuation—Board of Tax Appeals' decision affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4391Schmitz v. Natl. Collegiate Athletic Assn. (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Statutes of limitations—Discovery rule—Discovery rule applies to plaintiffs-appellees' negligence, fraudulent-concealment, and constructive-fraud claims—Civ.R. 12(B)(6) does not warrant dismissal of appellees' claims because amended complaint does not conclusively show that they are time-barred—Appellees' fraudulent-concealment and constructive-fraud claims are subject to R.C. 2305.10(A)'s two-year statute of limitations—Court of appeals' judgment reversing dismissal of appellees' claims affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4392Pfalzgraf v. Miley (2018)
motion to certify untimely
- 2018 Ohio 4393State v. Pullin (2018)
New Trial - Newly Discovered Evidence - Crim.R. 33(A)(6)
- 2018 Ohio 4395State v. Perry (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4398State v. Vogel (2018)
Practicing attorney could be found guilty of contempt where the evidence indicated that he lied to the court about the existence of a plea offer.
- 2018 Ohio 4399City v. Jolly (2018)
By participating in initiating and negotiating a sexual encounter in exchange for $10, the defendant committed the offense of soliciting in violation of Columbus City Code 2307.24(A).
- 2018 Ohio 4400Duell v. City of Cincinnati (2018)
NEGLIGENCE—SLIP AND FALL: A lease between business owners, which contractually allocates maintenance responsibilities for the business premises and requires general compliance with municipal ordinances, such as those pertaining to the removal of snow and ice, did not create a duty to plaintiff business invitee greater than that established under the common law for actionable negligence due to the natural accumulation of snow and ice.
- 2018 Ohio 4404State v. Miku (2018)
Post-conviction relief
- 2018 Ohio 4407Bayes v. Jago (2018)
Civil Stalking Protection Order - No Aod Denying Motion to Continue Hearing
- 2018 Ohio 4408Burchard v. Ashland Cnty. Bd. of Developmental Disabilities (2018)
R.C.2744 Immunity Negligent Hiring: Supervision and Retention of Employees
- 2018 Ohio 4409State v. Luce (2018)
Ineffective Assistance/Pred. Felony Invol. Manslaughter - Bruton Rule - Co-Def. Testimony
- 2018 Ohio 4414State v. Abernathy (2018)
Crim.R. 11, mandatory consecutive sentences, conceded error. State concedes that the trial court failed to substantially comply with Crim.R. 11 when it did not advise the defendant that any prison sentence imposed on failure to comply must be served consecutively to any other prison term.
- 2018 Ohio 4415State v. Walter (2018)
Crim.R. 33(B) motion for leave motion for new trial untimely unavoidable delay clear and convincing proof evidentiary hearing. The trial court did not abuse its discretion when it denied defendant's motion for leave to file a motion for new trial without an evidentiary hearing. The trial court could determine from the face of defendant's motion that the defendant obtained the evidence on which he based his motion for new trial over four years prior to filing his motion for leave. Therefore, the defendant did not clearly and convincingly prove that he was unavoidably prevented from filing his motion timely.
- 2018 Ohio 4416C.S. v. J.M. (2018)
Civil stalking protection order menacing by stalking R.C. 2903.211 R.C. 2903.214 motion to modify abuse of discretion voluntary dismissal App.R. 28 res judicata. Appellant's challenge to the trial court's granting of a protection order is barred by res judicata where the appellant voluntarily dismissed an earlier appeal of the order. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying a motion to modify a protection order where it was not shown that a change in circumstances rendered the order inequitable.
- 2018 Ohio 4417State v. Gray (2018)
Murder, aiding and abetting jury instruction, consecutive sentences. The State presented sufficient evidence to support appellant's convictions stemming from his active participation in a drive-by shooting. His convictions were not against the manifest weight of the evidence. The trial court's jury instruction on aiding and abetting was appropriate as appellant's convictions were based on complicity. The record supported the trial court's findings in favor of consecutive sentences as the shooting resulted in the death of two people.
- 2018 Ohio 4418Cleveland v. Caraballo (2018)
Sufficiency fare-evasion. Sufficient evidence was not provided at trial that appellant evaded paying the required transit fare. The trial court's judgment of guilty was not proper.
- 2018 Ohio 4420City of Cleveland v. Jones (2018)
plea no contest factual basis explanation of circumstances R.C. 2937.07. The explanation of circumstances requirement in a no contest plea occurs at the time of the plea and prior to the trial court's determination of guilt. A previously held suppression hearing or an explanation at a subsequent sentencing hearing does not satisfy the factual basis requirement under R.C. 2937.07.
- 2018 Ohio 4421State v. Smith (2018)
Abuse of discretion, indigent, mandatory fine, R.C. 2925.03(D)(1). The trial court did not abuse its discretion when it determined that the appellant was not indigent. The trial court considered the appellant's present ability to pay the mandatory fine, in accordance with R.C. 2925.03(D)(1), and assessed that the appellant was in good financial standing.
- 2018 Ohio 4422Ditech Fin., L.L.C. v. Kudroff (2018)
Motion for sanctions hearing R.C. 2323.51 frivolous conduct abuse of discretion. Judgment reversed and remanded. The trial court abused its discretion by denying defendants' motion for sanctions without a hearing when the record evidences frivolous conduct and an arguable basis exists for an award of sanctions.
- 2018 Ohio 4423Moran v. Lewis (2018)
GPS invasion of privacy Civ.R. 12(C) judgment on the pleadings. The trial court did not err in granting judgment in favor of the defendant because in order to properly plead an invasion of privacy claim premised on the invasion into another's seclusion, at a minimum, there must be allegations demonstrating an intrusion, physical or otherwise, into another's solitude or private affairs.
- 2018 Ohio 4425Paulozzi v. Parkview Custom Homes, L. L.C. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4431State v. Asadi-Ousley (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4433State v. Robinson (2018)
VENUE: Where the state failed to establish venue, defendant's conviction for criminal damaging was based on insufficient evidence and must be reversed.
- 2018 Ohio 4434State v. Bolware (2018)
PROSECUTOR – SENTENCING – CONSECUTIVE SENTENCES: Even if the prosecutor's statements could have been interpreted as referring to defendant's criminal history or as denigrating defense counsel, the comments were isolated, and the evidence against defendant was so overwhelming that he was not prejudiced. Where the trial court failed to make the statutorily-mandated findings before imposing consecutive sentences, the consecutive nature of the sentences must be vacated, and the cause must be remanded for the trial court to make the appropriate findings on the record and record those findings in the sentencing entry.
- 2018 Ohio 4435State v. Stuckey (2018)
ALLIED OFFENSES – R.C. 2941.25 – DRUGS – SENTENCING: Defendant's convictions for trafficking in cocaine and possession of fentanyl were not allied offenses of similar import, even though defendant possessed both drugs at the same time. Where the trial court expressly stated that it had considered the appropriate sentencing factors, and defendant has not affirmatively shown that the court did not, the trial court did not err in imposing defendant's sentences.
- 2018 Ohio 4436State v. Ball (2018)
Death of appellant. Appeal dismissed as moot.
- 2018 Ohio 4438State v. Huckleby (2018)
Plain error existed when the trial court's jury instructions for failure to appear and vandalism were improper and the outcome clearly would have been different but for the erroneous instructions.
- 2018 Ohio 4439State v. Stevens (2018)
The trial court did not err in overruling Appellant's motion for resentencing. Appellant's claim that his life sentence for aggravated murder was void because the trial court failed to specify that he would be eligible for parole after 20 years was barred by res judicata and otherwise lacked merit in that the law presumes Appellant will be eligible for parole after 20 years. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4440State v. Potter (2018)
Counsel for Appellant filed an Anders brief on his client's behalf. The potential assignment of error raised by counsel addressed to the validity of Appellant's plea is wholly without merit. The trial court complied with Crim.R. 11. Having conducted a thorough review of the record, we find no arguably meritorious issues. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4442Natl. Collegiate Student Loan Trust 2007-2 v. Tigner (2018)
Trial court did not err when it overruled appellant's Civ.R. 60(B) motion for relief from judgment. The 14-day time period set forth in Montgomery County Court of Common Pleas Loc.R. 2.05(B)(2)(b) is inapplicable to the instant case and did not act to bar the trial court from granting default judgment in favor of appellee. Civ.R. 55(A) governs default judgments and because appellant failed to answer or otherwise appear prior to the filing of the appellee's motion for default judgment, appellant effectively admitted the allegations in the initial complaint. As a result, appellant was not entitled to the notice required by Civ.R. 55(A), and the trial court properly entered default judgment against her without notice. Appellant's failure to file an answer or make an appearance in the action because of her alleged inexperience with the legal system did not constitute excusable neglect entitling her to relief from the trial court's grant of default judgment to appellee. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4443State v. Muwwakkil (2018)
Appellant's appeal is moot because he did not request a stay and the contested period of local incarceration has been served. Appeal dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 4445State v. Gitzinger (2018)
The record establishes Appellant knowingly, voluntarily and intelligently waived his Miranda rights. Furthermore, the video recording of his confession did not illustrate any coercion or promises that overcame his will. Appellant's counsel did not render ineffective assistance by failing to call police department employees to explain a video malfunction during part of Appellant's police interview. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4448State v. Brown (2018)
The trial court did not err in denying defendant's motion to suppress the statements he made to the police defendant waived his Miranda rights, and the trial court reasonably concluded that defendant's statements were made voluntarily. Defendant's convictions for murder, aggravated robbery, having weapons while under disability, and improper handling of a firearm in a motor vehicle were not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4449Ajibola v. Ohio Med. Career College, Ltd. (2018)
Former nursing students appeal from the trial court's dismissal of their claims for breach of contract, negligence, fraud, and violations of the Ohio Consumer Sales Practices Act, brought against a private nursing school. Allegations of plaintiffs' amended complaint are sufficient to withstand Civ.R. 12(B)(6) motion to dismiss. Judgment reversed and matter remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 4450State v. Tristan (2018)
Appellant cannot prevail on claim for ineffective assistance of counsel based on counsel's failure to present evidence at hearing on motion to withdraw guilty plea because there are no facts in record from which it can be concluded that there was reasonable probability of different outcome. Postconviction relief procedures would need to be employed to add such facts to the record.
- 2018 Ohio 4451State v. Reed (2018)
The jury's verdict convicting appellant of aggravated possession of drugs and preparation of oxycodone for sale was not against manifest weight of evidence. Constructive possession of drugs was established by evidence that appellant was driver of vehicle, he quickly opened then closed center console in which drugs were found, and his tone and demeanor changed from politeness and cooperation to agitation and anxiousness upon learning that vehicle was going to be searched.
- 2018 Ohio 4452State v. Hartman (2018)
Trial court's failure to allow defendant to withdraw his guilty plea was unreasonable where defendant maintained his innocence during the plea hearing and the state would have suffered no prejudice if the plea was vacated.
- 2018 Ohio 4454State v. Gibson (2018)
Appellant's aggravated robbery conviction was not against the manifest weight where the state utilized fingerprint evidence and video surveillance to establish that appellant was the perpetrator of the robbery.
- 2018 Ohio 4455State v. Douglas (2018)
Appellant's conviction for felonious assault was supported by sufficient evidence, and was not against the manifest weight of the evidence, where the state introduced identification testimony, supported by surveillance video and photographs, to establish that appellant was the individual who committed the assault.
- 2018 Ohio 4456State v. Chevalier (2018)
Trial court failed to make all findings required by R.C. 2929.14(C)(4), and failed to incorporate any findings into sentencing entry. Judgment reversed and case remanded for resentencing.
- 2018 Ohio 4458State v. Pierce (2018)
CRIMINAL - Trial court's imposition of consecutive sentences of Appellant for nonsupport of dependents is supported by the record and not contrary to law.
- 2018 Ohio 4459State v. O'Cull (2018)
CRIMINAL - Appellant's 8-year sentence for her conviction of corrupting another with drugs (fentanyl) in connection with the death of another is supported by the record.
- 2018 Ohio 4461Kohl's Illinois, Inc. v. Marion Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation—Real-property valuation—Collateral estoppel—Law of the case—BTA properly applied collateral estoppel—Decision affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4462Daher v. Cuyahoga Community College Dist. (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Discovery—Final, appealable order—Trial court's in camera inspection order does not determine the action with respect to a provisional remedy under R.C. 2505.02—Court of Appeals' judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4463State v. Wasil (2018)
inconsistent verdicts—manifest weight—presentence investigation—maximum sentence
- 2018 Ohio 4464State v. Rudai (2018)
Public trial jury trial strict compliance
- 2018 Ohio 4465State v. Gheen (2018)
guilty plea to one count of burglary strict compliance with Crim.R. 11(C)(2) required advisement of "speedy and public" trial is not advisement of "jury" trial trial court did not coerce appellant into confessing to another crime
- 2018 Ohio 4466State v. Dotson (2018)
application to reopen
- 2018 Ohio 4467State v. Norville (2018)
The decision to object at trial is a tactical decision. To establish a case for felonious assault, the State must prove that the defendant knowlingly caused serious physical harm to another.
- 2018 Ohio 4468State v. Carter (2018)
State presented sufficient evidence to support conviction for Felonious Assault. Convictions for Felonious Assault and Aggravated Burglary were not against the weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 4469State v. Rose (2018)
When imposing consecutive sentences, the trial court must make the required findings and, in so doing, give notice to the offender.
- 2018 Ohio 4470State v. Guzman (2018)
The trial court erred in issuing a nunc pro tunc order that added a new party to the trial court's prior order. Judgment reversed and cause remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 4472Courtney v. Dept. of Job & Family Servs. (2018)
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - administrative appeal pursuant to R.C. 5103.0326(B) a person's certification as a foster parent may be revoked if that person has not had any foster children during the preceding 12 months.
- 2018 Ohio 4473Brownfield Restoration Group, L.L.C. v. Trickett (2018)
CIVIL - breach of contract ambiguous language intent of parties extrinsic evidence fraudulent inducement witness credibility "cleanup" "remediation" R.C. 122.65 failure to perform impossibility hearsay waiver reasonable time to perform reasonable value
- 2018 Ohio 4474In re Estate of Brunger (2018)
PROBATE - administration of estate motion for extraordinary attorney fees fee guidelines necessary and reasonable extraordinary services consent of beneficiaries summary denial hearing.
- 2018 Ohio 4475In re G.B.M. (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - delinquency proceeding App.R. 4(A) thirty-day rule App.R. 5(A).
- 2018 Ohio 4476Thompson v. Custer (2018)
CIVIL - oil and gas lease surface estate mineral interest signing bonus amended complaint Civ.R. 15(A) undue delay, undue prejudice, bad faith summary judgment conversion right to lease right to receive bonus payments contracting parties unjust enrichment benefit conferred by plaintiff upon defendant quiet title property interest procedural due process constitutional Dormant Mineral Act 1989 version of R.C. 5301.56 was not self-executing 2006 version of R.C. 5301.56 applies to all claims asserted after June 30, 2006 advance notice to mineral rights holder "deemed abandoned" vested in surface holder affidavit of abandonment notice of claim to preserve.
- 2018 Ohio 4478State v. Bentley (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - Crim.R. 33(A) motion for new trial newly discovered evidence recanting witness materially affected outcome of trial credibility discretion of the trial court.
- 2018 Ohio 4479State v. Vance (2018)
Trial court did not abuse its discretion when it denied appellant's postconviction relief petition.
- 2018 Ohio 4481State v. Warnock (2018)
The trial court erred by granting appellee's motion to suppress where officers observed in plain view a firearm located under a vehicle's driver's side seat, thereby establishing reasonable suspicion that criminal activity was afoot permitting further investigation regarding the firearm in question.
- 2018 Ohio 4482State v. Gibson (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4484Anglin v. Donohoo (2018)
The appellate court did not have jurisdiction to rule on the trial court's decision denying appellant's motion to dismiss under Civ.R. 12(B)(6) as an order denying a motion to dismiss is not a final appealable order. Furthermore, as appellants did not file a motion to stay proceedings pending arbitration as contemplated by R.C. 2711.02(B) but, rather, filed a motion to dismiss the complaint due to an arbitration provision, the trial court's determination that appellants waived their right to arbitration was not a final appealable order.
- 2018 Ohio 4485State v. Walsson (2018)
Trial court did not err in finding R.C. 2929.15(B)(1)(c)(i) inapplicable to the defendant.
- 2018 Ohio 4487State v. Rarden (2018)
Appellant's sentence was not void or contrary to law and appellant has previously challenged his sentence on numerous prior occasions. As a result, his arguments are barred by res judicata.
- 2018 Ohio 4488Willoughby Hills Dev. & Distrib., Inc. v. Testa (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Commercial-activity tax—Gross receipts—Gasoline distributor not eligible for gross-receipts exclusion from commercial-activity tax under R.C. 5751.01(F)(2)(l) because it was not acting as agent of manufacturer/supplier when selling gasoline to retailers—Board of Tax Appeals' decision affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4489State ex rel. White v. Nusbaum (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Mandamus and prohibition—Appellant not entitled to extraordinary relief in mandamus or prohibition to correct or vacate dismissal of an earlier petition for habeas corpus because common pleas judge properly dismissed that earlier petition on grounds of res judicata—Court of appeals' dismissal affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4491Disciplinary Counsel v. Clark. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct and former Code of Professional Responsibility for engaging in conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation and engaging in conduct prejudicial to the administration of justice—Conditionally stayed six-month suspension.
- 2018 Ohio 4492Disciplinary Counsel v. Wochna. (2018)
Judge—Misconduct—Violations of the Code of Judicial Conduct and the Rules of Professional Conduct for conduct that erodes public confidence in the judiciary and that creates the appearance of judicial impropriety and for engaging in conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation—Conditionally stayed six-month suspension.
- 2018 Ohio 4493State v. Jones (2018)
Motion to suppress/Error in factual findings
- 2018 Ohio 4494State v. Ireland (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Criminal law—Affirmative defenses—Trial court did not create unconstitutional shift of state's burden to prove all elements of offense beyond reasonable doubt when court required defendant-appellee to prove his blackout defense by a preponderance of evidence—Court of appeals' reversal of appellee's conviction reversed and cause remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 4498City of Cincinnati v. State (2018)
MOOTNESS DOCTRINE – JUSTICIABLITY: Where the legislation challenged under the "single-subject" rule had been repealed or replaced after the lawsuit was filed, the issue is moot and will not be addressed on appeal. The trial court exceeded its authority when it struck as unconstitutional provisions of a bill that plaintiff had not challenged, because there was no justiciable controversy before the court concerning those provisions.
- 2018 Ohio 4499State v. McCullough (2018)
motion to dismiss, Crim. R. 12(C), repeal, amend, S.B. 331, H.B. 60, R.C. 1.52, reconcile changes to statute
- 2018 Ohio 4500City of Akron v. Brown (2018)
R.C. 2925.11, minor drug possession, immunity, possession of drug abuse tools, drug paraphernalia, motion to dismiss, statutory interpretation, unambiguous statute, allied offenses of similar import
- 2018 Ohio 4502State v. Dennison (2018)
Trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying Appellant's postconviction relief petition.
- 2018 Ohio 4504State v. Weist (2018)
Guilty Pleas - Knowingly, Voluntarily & Intelligently Made - T/C did not err in accepting Plea
- 2018 Ohio 4505State v. Sweet (2018)
effective assistance of counsel evidence outside the record knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily enter a guilty plea jointly recommended sentence authorized by law R.C. 2953.08(D)(1)
- 2018 Ohio 4506State v. Abner (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4506State v. Abnet (2018)
Felony sentencing Community control revocation Technical violation of community control
- 2018 Ohio 4508Dolder v. Auto Boutique Collision, Ltd. (2018)
The trial court did not err in granting summary judgment in favor of appellees as to appellant's breach of contract claim. Judgment affirmed
- 2018 Ohio 4511Brown v. State Hwy. Patrol (2018)
Assault Use of Force- The court granted summary judgment to defendant. Plaintiff had a history of fleeing, had consumed alcohol and therefore constituted a danger to himself and others, and fled from the officer during the traffic stop. Therefore, the court found the officer's use of a taser, after which plaintiff received medical attention, to be both reasonable and necessary under the circumstances.
- 2018 Ohio 4512Ware v. Dept. of Rehab. & Corr. (2018)
Negligence- The court overruled plaintiff's objections to a magistrate's decision on damages recommending judgment in plaintiff's favor and adopted the magistrate's decision. Plaintiff failed to file a transcript, requiring the court to accept the magistrate's factual findings relative to damages. The court further found the magistrate correctly determined the plaintiff suffered a temporary, minor soft-tissue injury and that plaintiff failed to present expert testimony establishing a chronic or long-term injury.
- 2018 Ohio 4513Mid Am. Constr., L.L.C. v. Univ. of Akron (2018)
Breach of contract- Defendant terminated the contractor without pay during a public construction project after the project experienced significant delay. After a bench trial on the parties' breach of contract claims, the court granted judgment to plaintiffs. The court found the contractor did not fail to prosecute its work and found the project's delay could not be attributable solely to the contractor. The court determined that defendant breached its contract with the contractor when it terminated plaintiff without pay and breached its contract with the surety when it refused to pay contract funds to the surety after the surety took over the project. Defendant's claims failed because defendant failed to perform its contractual obligations and because the evidence did not demonstrate the contractor failed to perform its work in a good and workmanlike manner.
- 2018 Ohio 4515State v. Maxson (2018)
Criminal: criminal damaging R.C. 2909.06 sufficiency of the evidence knowingly R.C. 2901.22(B) manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 4517In re R.G. (2018)
Serious Youthful Offender ("SYO") R.C. 2152.13 indictment speedy trial. The juvenile court did not err in dismissing a SYO indictment where the State failed to comply with the notice requirements set forth in 2152.13(A)(4). The State's proposed interpretation would have allowed it to evade the requirements and the juvenile's speedy trial rights set forth therein.
- 2018 Ohio 4518State v. Reed (2018)
Motion to correct a void sentence petition for postconviction relief res judicata direct appeal review in the first instance. Judgment affirmed. The trial court properly denied defendant's motion when the defendant framed his argument as a challenge to a void sentence, but actually challenged the jury's guilty findings on his aggravated murder convictions in light of the jury's not guilty findings on the accompanying felony murder specifications. Defendant's motion to correct a void sentence is a petition for postconviction relief, which was untimely filed and barred by res judicata. Furthermore, this court cannot render a decision on defendant's sentencing issues because they were not raised in the motion he appealed from. Generally, we are not a court of first instance.
- 2018 Ohio 4519State v. Haynesworth (2018)
Crim.R. 11 ( C)/guilty plea effective assistance of counsel. The trial court conducted an extensive colloquy with appellant regarding his mental state, prescribed medications and understanding of the proceedings. Appellant failed to show that his mental condition or his lack of taking all of his medications affected his judgment or ability to understand the proceedings. There was no error by the trial court in accepting appellant's guilty plea. There was no indication that appellant was not competent accordingly, appellant's counsel's failure to request a competency evaluation prior to appellant's plea did not prejudice appellant.
- 2018 Ohio 4520State v. Hopper (2018)
Impeachment with a prior conviction, invited error, felonious assault. Trial court did not err in questioning court's witness regarding a prior conviction for forgery where appellant conceded at trial that the questioning was appropriate.
- 2018 Ohio 4521State v. Congress (2018)
App.R. 26(B) application for reopening, untimely filed, failure to establish good cause for untimely filing, reliance upon counsel, ignorance of the law. The applicant has filed an untimely App.R. 26(B) application for reopening. The applicant has failed to establish "good cause" for the untimely filing of the application for reopening by arguing that: 1) he did not timely receive notice from appellate counsel with regard to the ability to file an App.R. 26(B) application for reopening 2) detrimental reliance upon the legal advice provided by appellate counsel and 3) ignorance of the law. The application for reopening is denied.
- 2018 Ohio 4523State v. Simmons (2018)
The trial court did not err in accepting Appellant's plea or in sentencing Appellant to a ten-month prison term. After conducting an independent review of the record pursuant to Anders, we agree with Simmons's appellate counsel that, based on the facts and relevant law, there are no issues with arguable merit to present on appeal. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4524State v. Russell (2018)
The trial court's instruction on the R.C. 2911.11(A)(2) aggravated burglary count did not accurately track the statutory language. Defendant-appellant did not object to the instruction, and, based upon the submitted evidence, the instruction did not affect the trial's outcome. We further find that the trial court did not abuse its discretion when it overruled Defendant-appellant's motion for a mistrial. We conclude that the trial court's failure to explicitly inform the jury of its rulings on objections also did not affect the trial's outcome. Finally, the jury's guilty verdict on the aggravated burglary count was supported by sufficient evidence, and the aggravated burglary and having weapons under disability verdicts were not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Judgment affirmed. (Hall, J., concurring.) (Donovan, J., concurring in part and dissenting in part.)
- 2018 Ohio 4525State v. Rollins (2018)
The trial court did not err when it overruled appellant's motion to vacate a void sentence because it was untimely filed and barred by res judicata. Furthermore, the record establishes that, even though the indictment stated an inapplicable specification pursuant to R.C. 2971.03(A)(4) with respect to Counts IV, V, and VII, the trial court, prior to sentencing and through an agreement of the parties, sentenced appellant under the applicable section, R.C. 2971.03(A)(3)(d)(ii). Thus, any error in the indictment was harmless. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4526Le v. Pham (2018)
Appellee was entitled to summary judgment on Appellant's complaint to obtain title to a vehicle Appellant admitted that he agreed to transfer title of a Toyota Sienna van, which remained in Appellee's possession, after Appellee paid the loan in full, and he admitted that he refused to do so after Appellee paid off the loan. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4527State v. Morris (2018)
The trial court lacked jurisdiction to consider Appellant's successive petition for post-conviction relief because Appellant failed to meet the threshold requirements to excuse his untimely petition under R.C. 2953.23(A)(1). Judgment affirmed. (Hall, J., concurring.)
- 2018 Ohio 4528State v. Moore (2018)
Appellant pled guilty to one count of aggravated possession of drugs, a felony of the fifth degree. His sentence to five years of community control, including a community-residential sanction at the MonDay Program (a community based correctional facility), was authorized by R.C. 2929.16. Appellant's assertion that he may have been acquitted if he had proceeded to trial is speculative, and ineffective assistance of trial counsel is not demonstrated. Due to a bond violation, it was within the court's discretion to impose a prison term at sentencing. However, Appellant indicated a willingness to participate in the community-residential sanction in lieu of prison. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4529State v. Hoskins (2018)
The juvenile court did not abuse its discretion by ordering the transfer of Defendant-appellant's cases involving two counts of aggravated robbery to the common pleas court's general division. Further, Defendant-appellant's counsel did not provide ineffective assistance of counsel. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4530State v. Garrett (2018)
The trial court did not err in overruling Appellant's motion to suppress drug evidence that officers lawfully observed in plain view. The trial court also did not err in failing to suppress drug evidence found during multiple pat-down searches of Appellant's person, as the pat-down searches were either justified for purposes of officer safety or as a search incident to arrest. The trial court did, however, err in failing to suppress drug evidence that was discovered underneath some junk mail, as that evidence was not in plain view. Judgment affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded for further proceedings.
- 2018 Ohio 4532U.S. Bank v. Hill (2018)
Trial court properly granted summary judgment to appellee because there were no genuine issues of material fact and appellee was entitled to judgment as a matter of law. Judgment affirmed. Summary judgment, de novo review, promissory note, mortgage, foreclosure, breach of contract, fraudulent inducement
- 2018 Ohio 4533State v. Tucker (2018)
Petition for postconviction relief properly denied where appellant's assertion that state failed to disclose exhibits was belied by trial record showing that appellant made deliberate decision not to request discovery to avoid tolling speedy-trial time. Additionally, the issue was barred by res judicata because it could have been raised on direct appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 4534City of Toledo v. State (2018)
Beyond a reasonable doubt, blatant disunity exists in the subject-matter of S.B. 331, and the bill, therefore, violates the one-subject rule of Article II, Section 15(D) of the Ohio Constitution. And because the bill lacks a discernible primary subject, the severance doctrine cannot operate to save any portion of it.
- 2018 Ohio 4535State v. Startzman (2018)
Appellant's conviction was supported by sufficient evidence and not against the manifest weight of evidence. Crim.R. 29 motion for acquittal was properly denied. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4536State v. Quinn (2018)
Application for DNA testing properly denied on res judicata grounds where previous application, requesting the same testing, was denied. Also, because the identity of the perpetrator was not at issue, defendant could not show that he would have otherwise been entitled to DNA testing under R.C. 2953.74(C)(3).
- 2018 Ohio 4537State v. Poulin (2018)
Trial court properly imposes mandatory fine under R.C. 2929.18(B)(1) where the record reveals that appellant will be able to obtain gainful employment upon his release from prison and therefore possesses the future ability to pay the fine.
- 2018 Ohio 4538Pollard v. Elber (2018)
The trial court erred by granting summary judgment because it relied on improper evidence. Appellee's evidence was not of the types permitted by Civ.R. 56(C) and the trial court could not take judicial notice of proceedings in a separate case. The trial court did not abuse its discretion by denying prejudgment interest because appellant did not show that she was entitled to prejudgment interest under the common law.
- 2018 Ohio 4539Ogdahl v. Baumgartner (2018)
Trial court's judgment adopting a magistrate's decision is not a final appealable order where the trial court has not yet ruled on appellants' objections to the magistrate's decision.
- 2018 Ohio 4540State v. Nettles (2018)
Appellant waived his right to challenge the trial court's denial of his motion to suppress when he entered a guilty plea. The trial court erroneously ordered appellant to pay the costs of confinement and appointed counsel, where the record contains no evidence of appellant's present or future ability to pay such costs, and appellant was sentenced to 18 years to life in prison.
- 2018 Ohio 4541State v. Mathis (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion when it denied appellant's presentence motion to withdraw his Alford plea. Further, the imposition of the costs of prosecution, confinement, and counsel was not contrary to law. Change of heart Crim.R. 11 Crim.R. 32.1 ability to pay.
- 2018 Ohio 4542Al-Fayez v. Baycliffs Homeowners Ass'n, Inc. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4546State v. Hassenruck (2018)
Megan's Law – Sexual Classification Hearing – due process
- 2018 Ohio 4547State v. Washington (2018)
Appellant's claim that the original sentence was erroneously imposed was barred by the doctrine of res judicata when they were raised for the first time on appeal after the sentence was reimposed for a violation of judicial release terms.
- 2018 Ohio 4549State v. Powell (2018)
The trial court did not err in imposing consecutive sentences in separate criminal cases. Judgments affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4550State v. Henderson (2018)
Defendant-appellant's assault conviction is not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 4551State v. Dye (2018)
Forfeiture of bond without hearing
- 2018 Ohio 4552State v. Hopson (2018)
RVO Specification Defendant Properly Sentenced
- 2018 Ohio 4555State v. Phillips (2018)
The trial court properly considered the required analysis before ordering appellant's consecutive sentence, and also made the requisite findings at the time of sentencing and within the sentencing entry.
- 2018 Ohio 4557State v. Gross (2018)
There was sufficient evidence of penetration to support offender's rape conviction. Offender's rape conviction was not against the manifest weight of the evidence notwithstanding trial testimony that the victim was very intoxicated when she arrived at his home.
- 2018 Ohio 4558Estate of Welch v. Taylor (2018)
The probate court did not rule on a proper motion where the motion was previously filed and ruled upon in a different court. On remand, the probate court will rule on the pending motions independent of motions and complaints filed in other courts.
- 2018 Ohio 4559In re N.W. (2018)
A mother, father, and their two biological children appeal the juvenile court's decision granting permanent custody of the children to a children's services agency. Sufficient credible evidence existed to support the juvenile court's decision the agency's permanent custody motion where the mother had serious mental health issues, the father had substance abuse issues, and neither parent substantially remedied the issues that led to the children's removal.
- 2018 Ohio 4560State v. Chapman (2018)
Appellant's felonious assault conviction was supported by sufficient evidence and otherwise not against the manifest weight of the evidence where the evidence, if believed, established appellant as the perpetrator who caused the victim to suffer serious physical harm by inflicting several blows to the victim's head with a firearm appellant used as a "bludgeon." The state, however, did not provide sufficient evidence to support appellant's conviction for a three-year firearm specification where the evidence presented at trial did not indicate the firearm appellant used to beat the victim over the head was operable, or capable of being readily rendered operable, in that appellant neither explicitly nor implicitly threatened to shoot the victim at the time the offense occurred.
- 2018 Ohio 4561State v. Foster (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4562State v. Smith (2018)
Postrelease control the trial court's use of the words "up to" did not render the defendant's postrelease control term advisement insufficient.
- 2018 Ohio 4563State v. Lucicosky (2018)
R.C. 2929.14(C)(4) consecutive sentences no facts within the record to support trial court's finding of a criminal history or that defendant was on bond while act committed.
- 2018 Ohio 4565State v. Watters (2018)
The trial court erred in imposing a prison sentence on the firearm specification accompanying Watters' conviction of improperly handling a firearm in a motor vehicle.
- 2018 Ohio 4566State v. Wallington (2018)
Evidence supported the jury verdicts of guilty of murder and aggravated robbery. Given the links between two murder situations, joining the two for trial was not reversible error.
- 2018 Ohio 4567Bennett v. State Police (2018)
MANDAMUS - R.C. 2731.04 caption sufficient grounds for dismissal no proof of entitlement to relief.
- 2018 Ohio 4568State v. Luther (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - CONSTITUTIONAL - motion to suppress Fourth Amendment Ohio Constitution unreasonable search and seizure warrantless Terry stop protective search pat-down reasonable suspicion specific and articulable facts concealed weapons safety of officer and public not a pretext to search for contraband removal of object from pocket opened metal case retrieved from pocket exceeded the scope of Terry razor blade small firearm.
- 2018 Ohio 4569Crawford v. Kirtland Local School Dist. Bd. of Edn. (2018)
CIVIL - gender discrimination motion for summary judgment Civ.R. 12(B)(1) lack of subject-matter jurisdiction collective bargaining agreement grievance procedure requires final, binding arbitration R.C. 4117.10(A) abuse of discretion failure to consider evidence beyond court's jurisdiction prima facie case failure to establish replacement by male or that a similarly situated male with same deficiencies was treated more favorable failure to compel no transcript of conference.
- 2018 Ohio 4570State v. Eyajan (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW-CRIMINAL - denial of jury trial is not final appealable order when case has not been concluded final order in criminal case is conviction and sentence premature.
- 2018 Ohio 4571May-Dillard v. State (2018)
HABEAS CORPUS - R.C. 2725.04(D) copy of commitment papers none attached successive petition res judicata.
- 2018 Ohio 4572L.T. Harnett Trucking, Inc. v. Res. Environmental Servs., Inc. (2018)
CIVIL - appointment of receiver R.C. 2735.01 irreparable harm weight of the evidence adoption of magistrate's decision no objection any error harmless.
- 2018 Ohio 4573Harris v. Rossi (2018)
CIVIL - legal malpractice - duty to check the docket no evidence as to success on underlying appeal summary judgment warranted R.C. 2323.51 frivolous conduct improper venue affirmative defense Civ.R. 3(C)(2) permits costs from either transferee or transferor court.
- 2018 Ohio 4575State v. Gaston (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - aggravated murder aggravated burglary firearm specification motion to suppress evidence Tennessee officers voluntarily accompanied officers to police department Ohio officers wished to interview defendant no initial arrest Miranda no tainted statements speedy trial written waiver no violation.
- 2018 Ohio 4576State v. Kiger (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - Insufficient evidence aiding and abetting escape R.C. 2921.34(A) purposely requires the person's specific intent to cause a certain result absent evidence that defendant knew substance of conditions governing her husband's work release, state unable to prove she acted with specific intent to assist a violation conviction vacated.
- 2018 Ohio 4578State ex rel. DeWine v. Buckeye Impact Group, L.L.C. (2018)
The right against self-incrimination must be asserted properly and timely. A blanket assertion will generally be insufficient to invoke this right.
- 2018 Ohio 4579In re D.M. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4580State v. Williams (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4581State v. Alexander (2018)
suppress—minor traffic violation—credibility
- 2018 Ohio 4582State v. Landrum (2018)
SEARCH AND SEIZURE – COMMON AUTHORITY – APPARENT AUTHORITY : The trial court erred in overruling defendant's motion to suppress evidence obtained during a warrantless search of his bedroom after probation officers entered the home he shared with a probationer, searched his bedroom, and found cocaine, where the state failed to prove that the probationer had joint access or control over the bedroom, such that the probationer had common authority or apparent authority over the bedroom to consent to the search.
- 2018 Ohio 4583Altman v. Parker (2018)
DEFAULT JUDGMENT – VOID – LACHES: The trial court erred by overruling defendant's motion to set aside an allegedly void default judgment, because laches did not bar defendant from seeking relief from a void judgment, and the court was prohibited from making a credibility determination without first holding an evidentiary hearing to assess the credibility of defendant's unrebutted assertion that he had not received service of the complaint.
- 2018 Ohio 4588State v. Woods (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4589State v. Mitchem (2018)
Guilty Plea: Validity Guilty Plea: No Duty to Notify about Right to Appeal Ineffective Assistance of Counsel: Self-Serving Affidavit
- 2018 Ohio 4590Narciso v. Powell Police Dept. (2018)
Core Terms: public record court of claims R.C. 2743.75 R.C. 149.43 incident report investigatory work product uncharged suspect incorporated safety privacy non-record burden of proof inextricably intertwined. Overview: Requester sought police investigative file. Police department provided a partial incident report and conceded the investigation had concluded, but asserted that all remaining records were "inextricably intertwined" with the identity of an uncharged suspect, and that some of the records would endanger the physical safety of crime victims or witnesses, or violate a constitutional right of privacy, or were non-records. The special master found that the department must release additional parts of the initial incident reports, including documents incorporated by reference. The special master found that the investigatory file contained specific items of information that if released would have a high probability of disclosing the identity of an uncharged suspect. The special master further found that Powell PD provided no evidence that disclosure of any record would endanger the life or physical safety of a crime victim or witness. The special master further found that social security numbers and images of genitals, breasts and underwear were subject to a Fourteenth Amendment right to privacy and may be redacted from the records. The special master further found that to the extent the contents of storage devices obtained in the investigation were not actually used to document the investigation, they were not "records" of the department and thus not subject to the Public Records Act. The special master further found that the department could redact information excepted by R.C. 149.43(A)(1)(dd) and R.C. 1306.23. Other than two particular records, the special master found that none of the excepted information was "inextricably intertwined" with the records in which they were contained. The special master found that the department had improperly sought to transfer its duty to redact only exempt information from its records onto the court. The special master recommended the court grant requester's claim for production of records, subject to the specific redactions approved in the report.
- 2018 Ohio 4591Slattery v. Cleveland (2018)
Core Terms: public record court of claims R.C. 2743.75 R.C. 149.43 reasonable period of time. Overview: Requester sought and received records from respondent, but argued that the 277-day delay between the request and the response was untimely. The special master found that respondent had failed to provide the records within a reasonable period of time. The special master recommended that the court deny requester's prayer "to correct this issue going forward" for lack of injunctive authority under R.C. 2743.75.
- 2018 Ohio 4592Kanter v. Cleveland Hts. (2018)
Core Terms: public record court of claims R.C. 2743.75 R.C. 149.43 ambiguous overly broad embedded moot. Overview: Requester sought all communications, schedules, logs and other documents shared between respondent City and a media organization regarding the requester over a period of five weeks. The City objected to the request as ambiguous and overly broad, but provided some information and invited revision. The special master found that the City provided responsive records to a specific request embedded within the request, and that the remainder of the request was properly denied as ambiguous and overly broad.
- 2018 Ohio 4594Colahan v. Worthington Police Dept. (2018)
Requester sued respondent, alleging a denial of access to public records. A special master issued a report and recommendation, finding, among other things, that the requester had established by clear and convincing evidence that respondent violated R.C. 149.43(B) by withholding certain records in an investigatory file. Respondent objected to the report and recommendation, contending that the special master recommended the disclosure of evidence of an alleged crime. The court sustained two of respondent's objections. The court adopted in part, rejected in part, and modified in part the special master's report and recommendation the court also adopted, as modified, the special master's report and recommendation.
- 2018 Ohio 4595Parks v. Colburn (2018)
Requester sued respondent, alleging a denial of access to public records. A special master issued a report and recommendation, advising the court to grant requester's claim for partial production of certain records withheld by respondent. Requester and respondent objected to the special master's report and recommendation. The court overruled requester's objections and sustained respondent's objections. The court did not adopt the special master's recommendation for partial production of withheld documents, determining that withheld documents were protected by attorney-client privilege or the work-product doctrine.
- 2018 Ohio 4596Anderson v. Greater Cleveland Regional Transit Auth. (2018)
Core Terms: public record court of claims R.C. 2743.75 R.C. 149.43 reasonable period of time. Overview: Requester sought and received records from respondent, but argued that 23 business days between the request and full response was untimely. The special master found that under the facts and circumstances of the case, respondent had provided the records within a reasonable period of time. Neither party filed objections. Outcome: The court found no error of law or other defect on the face of the special master's decision and adopted the report and recommendation as its own.
- 2018 Ohio 4599In re K.A. (2018)
Serious youthful offender R.C. 2152.13 indictment. The juvenile court did not err in dismissing a serious youthful offender indictment where the state failed to comply with the notice requirements set forth in R.C. 2152.13(A).
- 2018 Ohio 4602Cleveland Ass'n of Rescue Employees/Ila Local 1975, Relator v. City of Cleveland (2018)
Writ of mandamus R.C. 149.43 mootness attorney fees failure to respond reasonable time costs. Relator was entitled to attorney fees incurred in the bringing of a mandamus action to require respondent city to produce public records, where the records were released after the filing of the mandamus action but prior to its conclusion, rendering that portion of the action moot.
- 2018 Ohio 4603State v. Sanders (2018)
Witness intimidation R.C. 2921.04(B)(2) criminal act prosecutorial misconduct. State did not have to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that a person had been murdered in order for the death to be considered a criminal act for purposes of witness intimidation. The state need only prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant believed that a criminal act occurred and attempted to intimidate a witness to that criminal act. Statement that defendant's attempt to intimidate the witnesses did not stop those witnesses from coming to court and "telling you the truth" was not a statement vouching for the credibility of the witnesses.
- 2018 Ohio 4604Cleveland v. Ruiz (2018)
Sufficient evidence aggravated menacing subjective fear serious physical harm court costs. A conviction for aggravated menacing is not supported by sufficient evidence where there is no proof that the victim had subjective fear of serious physical harm. It is harmless error where trial court imposes court costs outside of sentencing because the court retains jurisdiction over the issue of waiving the payment of court costs at any time.
- 2018 Ohio 4605Henderson v. Speedway, L.L.C. (2018)
Motion to compel discovery Civ.R. 56/summary judgment objections to magistrate's decision. Appellant's motion to compel failed to designate which of appellee's responses were deficient. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying appellant's motion to compel. There also was no error by the trial court where it did not compel depositions of additional witnesses where appellant agreed to limit his depositions to key witnesses only. Appellant failed to preserve the gasoline he is claiming to have damaged his vehicle and therefore cannot show that the gasoline was contaminated, and without evidence that the gasoline was contaminated appellant cannot show that the gasoline was the cause of the damage to his vehicle. The trial court's grant of summary judgment was proper. Because appellant failed to file a transcript or affidavit of the evidence for the trial court record with his objections, this court under a plain-error review find no error in the trial court's overruling appellant's objections to the magistrate's decision.
- 2018 Ohio 4606State v. Cross (2018)
R.C. 2929.14(C)(4)/consecutive sentences. Evidence in the record supported the trial court's finding that consecutive sentences were required and that consecutive sentences were not disproportionate to the seriousness of appellant's conduct or the danger appellant poses to the public.
- 2018 Ohio 4607Cantlin v. Smythe Cramer Co. (2018)
Class certification rigorous analysis fraud unjust enrichment unearned real estate transaction fees identifiability typicality predominance. New class definition after remand satisfies the Civ.R.23(B) class certification requirements. At issue is a $225 real estate transaction fee that plaintiffs (certain home buyers and sellers) allege is unearned by defendant (real estate brokers and agents). Class certification is favored when plaintiffs allege fraud concerning the defendant's form contracts. The class is identifiable, and the definition is unambiguous. The claims of the named-plaintiffs are typical of the claims of the entire class, and common questions of law or fact predominate over individual issues.
- 2018 Ohio 4608Johnson v. New Direction IRA F.B.O. (2018)
Express easement modification of easement termination of easement statute of frauds R.C. 1335.04 R.C. 1335.05 recording of instruments constructive notice R.C. 5301.01 bona fide purchaser for value R.C. 5301.25 forfeiture deed R.C. 5723.12 Civ.R. 54(D) fees and costs compensatory damages for trespass. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in finding the existence of an express easement appurtenant in favor of appellee. Appellee, owner of the dominant estate, sued appellant, owner of the servient estate, for constructing a fence across the shared driveway that provided the sole source of ingress and egress to appellee's landlocked property. Appellee is a bona fide purchaser for value under R.C. 5301.25 who purchased the property without knowledge of an unrecorded notice of termination of the easement that stemmed from an invalid agreement attempting to modify the easement to provide a termination right. Prior transfer of the parcel by forfeiture deed did not terminate the easement pursuant to R.C. 5723.12. A presumption in favor of costs exists under Civ.R. 54(D) and the award of costs is within the sound discretion of the trial court. The owner of a dominant estate is entitled to compensatory damages from the owner of the servient estate for easement interference.
- 2018 Ohio 4609Burnell v. Cleveland Mun. Sch. Dist. Bd. of Educ. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4611Case v. Clark Indus. Insulation (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4618State v. Anderson (2018)
The trial court's order of restitution in a felony case was not clearly and convincingly contrary to law where record evidence demonstrated the trial court considered appellant's present and future ability to pay restitution under R.C. 2929.19(B)(5) and 2929.18(A)(1). Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4619Grove City v. Sample (2018)
The record failed to support appellant's claim that his guilty plea to a misdemeanor assault charge was not knowingly and voluntarily made due to his alleged understanding restitution would not be imposed. However, the trial court committed plain error by ordering restitution when the record did not contain competent, credible evidence establishing the amount of loss sustained by the victim pursuant to R.C. 2929.28. Judgment affirmed in part, reversed in part cause remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 4620Groveport Madison Local Schools Bd. of Edn. v. Franklin Cty. Bd. of Revision (2018)
In a tax appeal case involving two competing appraisals that differed on issues surrounding present use, highest and best use, choice of comparable properties, and capitalization rates, the decision of the Board of Tax Appeals was reasonable and lawful under R.C. 5717.04 in determining the Board of Education presented the most credible, competent, and probative indication of the subject property's value. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4621Dublin City Schools Bd. of Edn. v. Franklin Cty. Bd. of Revision (2018)
In a tax appeal case involving two competing appraisals that differed on issues surrounding present use, highest and best use, choice of comparable properties, and capitalization rates, the decision of the Board of Tax Appeals was reasonable and lawful under R.C. 5717.04 in determining the Board of Education presented the most credible, competent, and probative indication of the subject property's value. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4622South-Western City Schools Bd. of Edn. v. Franklin Cty. Bd. of Revision (2018)
In a tax appeal case involving two competing appraisals that differed on issues surrounding present use, highest and best use, choice of comparable properties, and capitalization rates, the decision of the Board of Tax Appeals was reasonable and lawful under R.C. 5717.04 in determining the Board of Education presented the most credible, competent, and probative indication of the subject property's value. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4623Vallejo v. Haynes (2018)
Judgment affirmed. Our de novo review shows that the trial court was correct in granting summary judgment because appellants introduced no relevant evidence to show that the trial court erred in finding that appellee was a landlord, and not the owner, keeper, or harborer of the dog, nor was she negligent. Appellants failed to set forth speci?c facts, by affidavit or by other appropriate evidence, showing that there is a genuine issue for trial.
- 2018 Ohio 4624Ohio Edison Co. v. Soule (2018)
Trial court order granting summary judgment for appellee is affirmed, in part, and reversed, in part. Negligence, damages, utility pole, depreciation, direct and indirect costs, reasonable costs of restoration, summary judgment, genuine issues, material facts, questions of law, de novo review.
- 2018 Ohio 4625State v. Somers (2018)
Consecutive sentences
- 2018 Ohio 4626State v. Mayfield (2018)
Trial court strictly complied with its obligations under Crim.R. 11(C)(2)(c) by informing appellant of his constitutional rights, including his right not to be compelled to testify against himself at trial. The trial court's lack of subject-matter jurisdiction over one of the charges that was dismissed under the plea agreement does not render the plea involuntary, nor does it render defense counsel's assistance ineffective.
- 2018 Ohio 4628State v. Taylor (2018)
The trial court did not err in overruling Appellant's pro se "Motion to Vacate Unlawful Sentence." The trial court correctly concluded that the holding in Miller v. Alabama, 567 U.S. 460, 132 S.Ct. 2455, 183 L.Ed.2d 407 (2012) did not apply to Appellant's case and that Appellant was not denied equal protection of the law. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4629State v. Smedley (2018)
The trial court did not err by overruling Appellant's motion to suppress. The affidavit supporting the search warrant provided a substantial basis for the issuing judge's conclusion that contraband would likely be found in Appellant's residence. The descriptions of three controlled buys were sufficient by themselves to issue a search warrant. Appellant fails to establish that trial counsel was ineffective for not challenging the search warrant under Franks v. Delaware, 438 U.S. 154, 98 S.Ct. 2674, 57 L.Ed.2d 667 (1978). The record reveals no basis for a Franks challenge. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4630State v. Poling (2018)
The trial court, following Defendant-appellant's guilty plea to unlawful sexual conduct with a minor in violation of R.C. 2907.04(A), sentenced Defendant-appellant to a five-year term of imprisonment, the maximum sentence the trial court could impose. It cannot be concluded by clear and convincing evidence that the record does not support the trial court's sentence, and the sentence is not otherwise contrary to law. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4632State v. Pack (2018)
The trial court did not err in sentencing Appellant to a 30-month prison term for one count of third-degree-felony aggravated trafficking in drugs, because the sentence was not clearly and convincingly contrary to law and we do not find by clear and convincing evidence that the record failed to support the sentence. Judgment affirmed. (Froelich, J., concurring in judgment only.)
- 2018 Ohio 4633State v. Monahan (2018)
Trial counsel did not render ineffective assistance by failing to qualify a proper expert for an impossibility defense or by failing to argue self-defense. The trial court allowed the defense expert to testify about re-enactment and experimentation that the expert conducted, and the elements of self-defense were not met. The court's judgment, after a bench trial, that Appellant was guilty of aggravated assault was also not against the manifest weight of the evidence, Finally, the trial court did not abuse its discretion by denying the motion of Appellant's appointed counsel to withdraw. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4635Kuntz 2016, L.L.C. v. Montgomery Cty. Auditor (2018)
Since the subject property was included on the tax-exempt list in 2016, and therefore not on the tax list and/or duplicate for that year, the trial court did not err when it found that the board of revision did not have jurisdiction to hear appellant's complaint regarding the valuation of the subject property for 2016. Additionally, the trial court did not affirm any valuation determination the board of revision did not make a valuation determination pursuant to appellant's complaint, since it did not have jurisdiction to do so. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4636State v. Holloway (2018)
The trial court did not err in denying Appellant's motion to dismiss on speedy trial grounds, as Appellant was timely brought to trial. The court also did not err in denying Appellant's motion to suppress evidence, because the police received consent from an occupant to search the area in which Appellant had been seen with suspected drugs. In addition, Appellant's conviction for several trafficking and drug possession offenses was supported by sufficient evidence and was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Furthermore, trial counsel did not render ineffective assistance by failing to call a witness for the suppression hearing. Finally, the trial court made all requisite statutory findings to support consecutive sentences we also cannot clearly and convincingly find that the record does not support the trial court's findings or that the sentence was contrary to law. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4638State v. DeMoss (2018)
The rape indictment against Defendant-appellant, contrary to his contention on appeal, includes a sexually violent predator specification. As such, Defendant-appellant, consistent with due process requirements, was given fair notice of the specification. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4646State v. Cole (2018)
Defendant-appellant's consecutive sentences are not contrary to law because the trial court made the appropriate R.C. 2929.14(C)(4) findings at the sentencing hearing. Although the trial court failed to properly incorporate all of its consecutive sentencing findings into its judgment entry of sentence, the trial court may correct this error via a nunc pro tunc order.
- 2018 Ohio 4647State v. Hill (2018)
The defendant-appellant's rights under R.C. 2929.19 and Crim.R. 32 were not violated. Further, the trial court did not abuse its discretion in revoking the defendant-appellant's community-control sanctions. Lastly, the defendant-appellant's trial counsel was not ineffective. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4648State v. Miller (2018)
By pleading no contest, defendant-appellant waived his right to appeal the trial court's ruling granting the State's motion in limine. Defendant-appellant did not receive ineffective assistance of counsel.
- 2018 Ohio 4649State v. Hawkins (2018)
The trial court did not clearly err by overruling defendant-appellant's Batson objection. Defendant-appellant properly raised only one Batson objection and thus the trial court did not err by not requiring the State to provide race-neutral reasons for exercising a second peremptory challenge against another black potential juror. The record does not contain evidence demonstrating that defendant-appellant's trial counsel's failure to properly raise a second Batson objection constitutes ineffective assistance of counsel.
- 2018 Ohio 4651State v. Randolph (2018)
Community control violations
- 2018 Ohio 4652State v. Randolph (2018)
Community control violations
- 2018 Ohio 4653Alford v. Arbors at Gallipolis (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4655Jones v. Gori (2018)
Appellee's motion to dismiss appeal for lack of a final appealable order granted and decision in Huegemann v. VanBakel, 12th Dist. Fayette No. CA2013-08-022, is overruled. The denial of a motion to dismiss based on lack of personal jurisdiction does not satisfy the requirements for a provisional remedy necessary to constitute a final appealable order because it was directed toward resolution of the main action itself and does not involve a proceeding ancillary to the main action as required by R.C. 2505.02(A)(3).
- 2018 Ohio 4656Langendorfer v. Gastrich (2018)
Plaintiff-appellant was not entitled to a directed verdict with regard to her medical expenses where her expert witness was cross-examined and the amount of damages proximately caused by the automobile accident was a matter properly before the jury.
- 2018 Ohio 4657State v. Burns (2018)
Appellant's assignment of error challenging the trial court's calculation of jail-time credit was dismissed where appellant had already completed his prison sentence, thereby rendering his arguments moot. Further, the trial court did not err by not making the consecutive sentencing findings set forth in R.C. 2929.14(C)(4) at sentencing as the findings were not required since appellant had already completed and been discharged from a prior prison sentence before the court imposed the nine-month prison sentence for violation of a protection order.
- 2018 Ohio 4658Turner v. Tri-County Baptist Church of Cincinnati (2018)
Trial court did not err in dismissing complaint for lack of subject matter jurisdiction pursuant to the ecclesiastical abstention doctrine.
- 2018 Ohio 4659State v. McClafferty (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - Fourth Amendment scope of search under valid warrant any place where sought item could be plain-view exception incriminating character immediately apparent probable cause to believe item is contraband officer's specialized knowledge.
- 2018 Ohio 4660State v. Ober (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - post-sentence motion to withdraw guilty plea without hearing community control sanctions violations claimed coercion separate case plea entered knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily.
- 2018 Ohio 4661State v. Garner (2018)
CIVIL - postconviction petition motion to nullify sentencing entry timeliness R.C. 2953.21(A)(1) successive petition res judicata
- 2018 Ohio 4662Phillips v. Director, Dept. of Job & Family Servs. (2018)
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEAL - unemployment compensation appeal to court of common pleas dismissed failure to prosecute without prejudice no assignments of error no argument to evaluate App.R. 16(A) nothing to review.
- 2018 Ohio 4663Spurrier v. Lake Cty. Dog Warden (2018)
CIVIL - dog warden dangerous dog without provocation killed another dog manifest weight of the evidence clear and convincing witness credibility burden of proof essential element harmless error.
- 2018 Ohio 4665Salinda Invest. Group v. Lake Cty. Util. Dept. (2018)
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEAL - R.C. 2506.04 standard of review question of law de novo board of utilities appeal imposition of additional tap-in/capacity fee for drinking water and sewage expansion of restaurant change of use interpretation of water department regulations.
- 2018 Ohio 4666Victor v. Big Sky Energy, Inc. (2018)
CIVIL - Trespass Conversion oil and gas wells motion in limine expert report expert testimony Ashtabula County Court of Common Pleas Local Rule 6(F)(2) relevant evidence Evid.R.803(8) hearsay duty to report well operators lack of production manifest weight of the evidence equitable estoppel royalty payments Trespass ambiguous contract damages remediation attorney's fees in Trespass action compensatory damages punitive damages bad faith expert witness fees not taxable as costs litigation expenses
- 2018 Ohio 4667State ex rel. Ali v. Sloan (2018)
HABEAS CORPUS - petitioner burden to prove release warranted Civ.R. 12(B)(6) jury trial waiver trial court's failure to comply with R.C. 2945.05 is an issue that can be raised on direct appeal issue precluded via habeas corpus.
- 2018 Ohio 4668State ex rel. Mars Urban Solutions, L.L.C. v. Cuyahoga Cty. Fiscal Officer (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Mandamus—Writ of mandamus sought to compel county fiscal officer and board of revision to comply with BTA judgment—County offices complied with decision for the applicable years—Writ denied.
- 2018 Ohio 4669Cincinnati Reds, L.L.C. v. Testa (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation—Use tax—Sale-for-resale exemption, R.C. 5739.01(E)—Promotional items distributed at professional baseball games were transferred with the purpose to "resell" them for consideration and therefore qualified for tax exemption—Decision of Board of Tax Appeals reversed and cause remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 4671In re Resignation of Lynch (2018)
Attorneys at law—Resignation with disciplinary action pending—Gov.Bar R. VI(11)(C).
- 2018 Ohio 4672State v. Patterson (2018)
Trial counsel was not so ineffective as to deprive appellant of meaningful representation because no error in the record resulted in prejudice or precluded appellant from entering a knowing, voluntary plea. R.C. 2941.401 time limits were not violated.
- 2018 Ohio 4674In re M.F. (2018)
Father had ongoing drug issues and sporadic visitation with the children. Children services agency with temporary custody of the children have the right to move at any time for a final dispositional order pursuant to R.C. 2151.353(F)(2). No extension of the case required because father did not demonstrate significant progress on the case plan.
- 2018 Ohio 4676State v. McGuire (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4677Delaware v. Boggs (2018)
Tellecomunications Harassment Faebook Messaging R.C 2917 21(A)(5)
- 2018 Ohio 4678State v. Mobley (2018)
Where officers observed what objectively resembled a hand-to-hand drug transaction, detected the smell of marijuana coming from the vehicle and saw marijuana grinders in plain-view inside the car, probable cause existed to search the car and containers within it that logically could have contained marijuana. The officers were not required to accept the defendant's assurance the marijuana they found on his person was the only marijuana in the car and they were justified in continuing their search, including searching containers in the vehicle such as the defendant's backpack, in which they found the gun for which he was charged with carrying a concealed weapon. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4679Veterans & Fraternal Charitable Coalition v. DeWine (2018)
The trial court did not err in its interpretation of R.C. 2915.01(CC).
- 2018 Ohio 4680Clark v. State Teachers Retirement Sys. (2018)
STRS exceeded its statutory authority under R.C. 3305.061 when it increased the mitigating rate for participants in alternative retirement plans.
- 2018 Ohio 4681State v. Staten (2018)
Appellant's burglary and theft convictions were supported by sufficient evidence and were not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4682de Bourbon v. State Med. Bd. (2018)
Trial court did not err when it affirmed the decision of the state medical board.
- 2018 Ohio 4683State v. McVay (2018)
Trial court did not err when it found the defendant was incompetent to stand trial and not restorable to competency.
- 2018 Ohio 4685State v. McCarley (2018)
aggravated murder – identity – circumstantial evidence – motion to suppress – law of the case – appellate review – R.C. 2953.08(D)(3)
- 2018 Ohio 4686Huber v. Inpatient Med. Servs., Inc. (2018)
forum selection—voluntary dismissal—Civ.R. 41(A)(1)—res judicata—Civ.R. 3(E)
- 2018 Ohio 4687State v. Franklin (2018)
manifest weight—credibility—excited utterance
- 2018 Ohio 4688State v. Conte (2018)
Restitution, failure to pay, willfully, community control violation, prison, Bearden v. Georgia
- 2018 Ohio 4689State v. Thompson (2018)
This action involves Appellant's petition for postconviction relief. The trial court granted summary judgment in favor of the State of Ohio. The trial court, upon this record, abused its discretion by granting judgment to the State of Ohio without conducting an evidentiary hearing. Judgment reversed and remanded. (Hall, J., concurs.)
- 2018 Ohio 4690State v. Thompson (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in overruling Appellant's motion to release seized property that was used as evidence during Appellant's trial. Pursuant to R.C. 2981.11(A)(1), the trial court may permit the State to retain seized property if the property is needed as evidence. Because there was an appeal pending on the denial of Appellant's petition for post-conviction relief, the trial court reasonably determined that there was a possibility that Appellant's conviction would be vacated and that the matter would be remanded for a new trial, during which the State may again need to submit the property in question as evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4691State v. Smith (2018)
The trial court did not err in overruling Appellant's motions for a new trial. Contrary to Appellant's claim otherwise, the State's failure to disclose an audio-recorded conversation between the victim and the investigating detective did not violate the rule announced in Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83, 83 S.Ct. 1194, 10 L.Ed.2d 215 (1963), because the information on the undisclosed audio recording was cumulative to information already known by the defense prior to trial and/or did not constitute favorable and material evidence that would have affected the outcome of trial. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4696State ex rel. Evans v. Scioto Cty. Common Pleas Court (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Mandamus—Adequate remedy in the ordinary course of the law precludes issuance of a writ of mandamus—Prohibition—Court of common pleas did not patently and unambiguously lack jurisdiction to act in divorce and probate matters—Dismissal of complaint for writs affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4697In re Application of Ohio Power Co. (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Public utilities—Electric-security plan—Party seeking reversal of an order of the commission must show that it has been or will be harmed by the order—No harm or prejudice to ratepayers was caused by Public Utilities Commission's approval of a zero-rate power-purchase rider—Appeal dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 4698In Re Application Seeking Approval of Ohio Power Company's Proposal to Enter Into an Affiliate Power Purchase Agreement for Inclusion in the Power Purchase Agreement Rider (2018)
Public utilities—Electric-security plan—Application to recover costs under a power-purchase-agreement rider—Under R.C. 4928.143, utility may include charges in electric-security plan that are otherwise prohibited by R.C. Title 49—R.C. 4928.143(B)(2)(d) allows financial limitations on customer shopping for retail electric-generation service—Public Utilities Commission properly conduct test under R.C. 4928.143(C)(1) for approving an electric-security plan—Commission's order affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4699State v. Melton (2018)
Former R.C. 2929.03(C)(2) life imprisonment parole eligibility indefinite sentence. The defendant's sentence under former R.C. 2929.03(C)(2) of "20 full years to life in prison" was affirmed. Although the trial court did not follow the exact wording of former R.C. 2929.03(C)(2) ("life imprisonment with parole eligibility after serving [20] full years of imprisonment"), the trial court did not convert a "defacto definite sentence" into an indefinite one because the defendant's sentence was already an indefinite sentence.
- 2018 Ohio 4701Huntington Natl. Bank v. Cade (2018)
Sheriff's sale foreclosure confirmation of decree final order assignment of bidder R.C. 2329.30 contempt. Judgment affirmed. Trial court's judgments denying defendant's motion to assign bidder and finding defendant in contempt was proper. This court has previously found that an assignment is not proper postconfirmation of the sale because the confirmation of the sheriff's sale is a special proceeding and is a final appealable order under R.C. 2505.02(B)(2). Once the trial court confirms the sale, the order of confirmation becomes dispositive as to the propriety of the sale and the sale confirmation procedures unless the trial court properly vacates the confirmation pursuant to Civ.R. 60(B). Here, the defendant's motion to assign or substitute a new bidder was filed two months after the trial court had already issued the decree of confirmation of the sale. This decree was a final order, and the bid had been accepted, closed, and confirmed. Because the bidding process was closed and the bid was confirmed, the bid could no longer be assigned. In addition, a review of the record reveals that defendant did not move to vacate the confirmation under Civ.R. 60(B). Therefore, defendant could not assign the bidder postconfirmation of the sale. Moreover, under R.C. 2329.30, the trial court may issue a contempt order if the purchaser fails to timely pay the remainder of the balance after the sheriff's sale. Here, the defendant had not paid the remainder of the balance more than four months after the sheriff's sale.
- 2018 Ohio 4702State v. Nix (2018)
Crim.R. 32(B) advisement of appellate rights harmless error. Trial court's failure to advise defendant of appellate rights was harmless error. Because defendant's pro se motion to file a delayed appeal was granted and counsel was appointed to represent defendant in his appeal, defendant was not prejudiced by the trial court's failure to advise him of his appellate rights.
- 2018 Ohio 4703State v. Carey (2018)
Crim.R. 11(C)(2)(a) postrelease control. The appellant has not demonstrated that the trial court erred when it accepted his guilty plea. The trial court's use of "will" versus "mandatory" is sufficient to convey that the appellant would be placed on mandatory postrelease control.
- 2018 Ohio 4704Jones v. Univ. Hosps. of Cleveland (2018)
Summary judgment manually filed complaint statute of limitations tolling agreement addresses caption of complaint clerk of courts authority. Trial court did not err in granting summary judgment to certain defendants where tolling agreements did not apply to those defendants clerk of courts had no authority by statute or court rule to reject manually filed complaint that did not contain the addresses of the parties in the caption complaint was therefore timely commenced and trial court erred in granting summary judgment in favor of defendant.
- 2018 Ohio 4705N. Coast Commercial Roofing Sys. v. MGM, Inc. (2018)
Request for admissions Civ.R. 36 discretion summary judgment Civ.R. 56. Trial court had discretion to deny appellant's motion to vacate deemed admissions where appellant submitted responses to the discovery request nearly five months late, the court found appellant had disregard for the court's deadlines and schedule, and appellee would be prejudiced by permitting withdrawal. Where each of the purported genuine issues of material fact proffered by appellant had been conclusively resolved in favor of appellee by the admissions that had not been withdrawn or amended, summary judgment was proper.
- 2018 Ohio 4706Cleveland v. Davis (2018)
Competent witness Evid.R. 601(C) R.C. 4549.13 R.C. 4549.14 sufficiency of the evidence illegal right turn on red. Police officer was not required to be in a marked car or his uniform when he stopped defendant for a traffic stop, and was competent to testify at trial regarding the traffic stop, because the officer's main purpose for his period of duty was to patrol for drug activity, not enforce traffic laws defendant's conviction for illegal right turn on red was supported by sufficient evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 4707State v. Brown (2018)
Consecutive sentences, imposition of costs, indigent, remanded for resentencing. Trial court erred by failing to make the necessary findings for the imposition of consecutive sentences. Because the court failed to make the necessary findings, case is remanded for the limited purpose of determining whether consecutive sentences should be imposed and, if so, making the required findings. It is within the trial court's discretion to waive costs for an indigent defendant the discretion also includes the discretion not to waive them. A finding of indigence for purposes of appointment of counsel is insufficient to warrant a waiver of costs and fines at sentencing.
- 2018 Ohio 4708State v. Luton (2018)
Misuse of credit cards R.C. 2913.21 grand theft R.C. 2913.02 venue sufficiency manifest weight R.C. 2901.12 plain error Crim.R. 52(B) course of criminal conduct invited error stipulation R.C. 2913.61. As the state concedes, the evidence in the record does not support a conviction for fourth-degree felony misuse of credit cards. Accordingly, appellant's conviction is modified to a first-degree misdemeanor misuse of credit cards. The trial court's sentence on the fourth-degree felony conviction is vacated and the matter is remanded for resentencing on this count only. Appellant's convictions for grand theft and first-degree misuse of credit cards are supported by sufficient evidence and are not against the manifest weight of the evidence. The record contains sufficient evidence establishing that venue in Cuyahoga County was proper.
- 2018 Ohio 4717Disciplinary Counsel v. Sarver. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct, including soliciting or engaging in sexual activity with a client, committing an illegal act that adversely reflects on the lawyer's honesty or trustworthiness, and engaging in conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation—Two-year license suspension, with 18 months stayed on conditions.
- 2018 Ohio 4718State ex rel. Harris v. Pureval (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Mandamus—Writ sought to compel county clerk of courts to produce certain public records—Court of appeals' judgment denying writ affirmed in part and reversed in part, and limited writ of mandamus granted.
- 2018 Ohio 4720State v. Thoma (2018)
Trial court did not err in imposing consecutive prison terms for an aggregate 28-year prison sentence following defendant's conviction for sexual battery. Appellant failed to establish that his sentence was inconsistent with sentences imposed for sexual battery convictions in other cases.
- 2018 Ohio 4721Havens v. Havens (2018)
Appellant failed to file necessary transcript of proceedings and, as a result, this court must presume the regularity of the proceedings and affirm the decision of the trial court.
- 2018 Ohio 4722State v. Watkins (2018)
Trial counsel's performance at trial does not meet the criteria set forth in State v. Cronic. Further, Appellant was not denied the effective assistance of counsel. Lastly, the State presented sufficient evidence to convict Appellant and the jury verdict was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4723Snyder v. Affordable Constr. Co (2018)
The trial court did not err in denying Appellant's request for a continuance. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4724NBRT Properties, Inc. v. ATFH Real Property, L.L.C. (2018)
Frivolous conduct R.C. 2323.51 quiet title documents attached to the complaint
- 2018 Ohio 4728Rockaway Park Holdings Corp. v. Davey Kent, Inc. (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - Lack of final appealable order denial of motion to dismiss is not a final appealable order pursuant to R.C. 2505.02.
- 2018 Ohio 4729State v. Taylor (2018)
CRIMINAL - Cruelty to Companion Animals allied offenses merger plain error former R.C. 959.131(C)(2) and (3) separate, identifiable harms dissimilar import modification of sentence
- 2018 Ohio 4730Columbus Bar Association v. Keating. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct—Conditionally stayed six-month suspension.
- 2018 Ohio 4731Cleveland Metropolitan Bar Association v. Wintner. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct—Conditionally stayed one-year suspension.
- 2018 Ohio 4736State v. Hoover (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4738State v. Phelps (2018)
Failure to appear - sufficiency/manifest weight, ineffective counsel
- 2018 Ohio 4740Sharp v. Miller (2018)
2006 Dormant Mineral Act R.C. 5310.56(H) reasonable due diligence R.C. 5301.56(E) untimely claim of preservation an oil and gas lease is not a savings event when the lessor did not own the mineral interests involved in the lease.
- 2018 Ohio 4742State v. Brown (2018)
Judgment affirmed. Appellant's motion to withdraw his guilty pleas to possession of cocaine was properly denied by the trial court. There is no basis for the assertion that the pleas should be set aside to avoid a manifest injustice, nor was he prejudiced by ineffective assistance of counsel.
- 2018 Ohio 4743Glover v. Columbus (2018)
Judgment reversed. Since the city was involved in the construction or reconstruction of the water supply system, it was engaged in a governmental function and is immune from liability pursuant to R.C. 2744.02(A)(1). Repasky v. Gross, 10th Dist. No. 12AP-752, 2013-Ohio-2516.
- 2018 Ohio 4744State v. Apanovitch (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Criminal Law—Postconviction DNA testing—R.C. 2953.21 and 2953.23(A)—Trial court lacked subject-matter jurisdiction to entertain untimely and successive petition for postconviction relief when requirements of R.C. 2953.23(A) were not satisfied—Judgment vacated and cause remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 4745State ex rel. Cobb v. Adult Parole Auth. (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Mandamus—Parole—Inmate failed to meet his burden to present credible allegation of substantive inaccuracy in information contained in his parole-board file—Court of appeals' denial of writ affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4746Ross v. Cuyahoga Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation—R.C. 5717.01 requirement to timely file notice of appeal—Board of Tax Appeals' decision affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4747State v. Moss (2018)
Obstructing official business, purpose, Crim.R. 29, sufficiency, multiple affirmative acts
- 2018 Ohio 4748Waverly City School Dist. Bd. of Edn. v. Triad AR, Inc. (2018)
Civil: breach of contract summary judgment Civ.R. 56 damages.
- 2018 Ohio 4750HCP EMOH, L.L.C. v. Washington Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation—Real-property valuation—An appraiser is permitted but not required to rely on apartment comparables when valuing an assisted-living facility—Board of Tax Appeals ("BTA") did not abuse its discretion in rejecting property owner's appraisal but did err in adopting county's appraisal, which was based on unreliable data that led appraiser to value the business rather than the realty—BTA's decision vacated and cause remanded to BTA.
- 2018 Ohio 4751Chagrin Realty, Inc. v. Testa (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation—Charitable-use real-property exemption—Property owner does not use property "exclusively for charitable purposes" under R.C. 5709.12(B) and does not qualify as a charitable institution under R.C. 5709.121 based on its own activities and sole use of property, which is to lease it—Board of Tax Appeals' decision affirming tax commissioner's denial of exemption affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4753State v. Hall (2018)
Judgment affirmed. Appellant's convictions for murder and related offenses were supported by sufficient evidence and in accord with the manifest weight of the evidence. In addition, the trial court did not err in ruling on issues concerning the identification of appellant, a photo lineup, jury instructions, the weapon under disability statute, and the exclusion of a potential witness.
- 2018 Ohio 4754State v. Jones (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW/CRIMINAL – JURIES – PEREMPTORY CHALLENGE – CRIM.R. 24: In a criminal proceeding, the use of peremptory challenges allows both the prosecution and the defense to secure a more fair and impartial jury by enabling them to remove jurors whom they perceive as biased, even if the jurors are not subject to a challenge for cause peremptory challenges provide both the defendant and the state an opportunity to dismiss potential jurors for any reason, except an impermissible reason such as race or gender, without inquiry and without the trial court's approval. The number of peremptory challenges available to each party is controlled by Crim.R. 24(D) and (G), and the order in which they may be used is controlled by Crim.R. 24(E): under Crim.R. 24(E), the state begins the peremptory-challenge process, and then the parties alternate exercising their remaining challenges a party's failure to exercise a challenge in turn waives that party's right to that challenge, in effect forcing a party to exercise each challenge in turn or lose it. Crim.R. 52(A) generally governs the criminal appeal of a nonforfeited error, and provides that any error which does not affect substantial rights shall be disregarded but there is a very limited class of errors, now described as "structural errors," which are not reviewable for harmless error under Crim.R. 52(A) and mandate a finding of per se prejudice, and automatic reversal. A structural error is a constitutional defect that affects the framework within which the trial proceeds, rather than simply being an error in the trial process itself an error is designated as "structural" not because of the difficulty in demonstrating prejudice, but rather when the error permeates a trial and necessarily renders the trial fundamentally unfair or an unreliable vehicle for determining guilt or innocence. In determining whether an alleged error is structural, the threshold inquiry is whether the error involves the deprivation of a constitutional right. There is no federal or state constitutional requirement that peremptory challenges be provided within a trial in noncapital criminal cases, the right to peremptory challenges exists by virtue of Crim.R. 24, not by virtue of the federal or Ohio constitution. Given that a trial court's error in controlling the use of peremptory challenges available to a party is not a constitutional error, it cannot be structural error thus a defendant challenging the trial court's error in permitting the state to exercise its final peremptory challenge after the state had waived that challenge, after the selection of the alternate jurors was already under way, and after the court had expressly asked the parties if they were satisfied with the jury, can prevail only if that error was prejudicial and affected the outcome of the trial court proceedings: where the defendant had ample opportunity to examine the prospective juror on voir dire, found no showing of any bias or lack of impartiality on his part challengeable for cause, and elected not to use his peremptory challenge to remove the prospective juror, he has not demonstrated prejudice flowing from the trial court's error.
- 2018 Ohio 4755Jester Ex Rel. Estate of Jester v. Utilimap Corp. (2018)
NEGLIGENCE – NEW TRIAL – R.C. 2307.23 – EMPTY-CHAIR DEFENSE: In a wrongful-death action brought by the surviving spouse of a utility worker who died when a rotted utility pole collapsed on him, the trial court did not err in denying the pole inspection company's motion for judgment as a matter of law based upon assumption of the risk: The inspection company cannot invoke the inherently-dangerous-activity exception under Eicher v. U.S. Steel Corp., 32 Ohio St.3d 248, 512 N.E.2d 1165 (1987), because the company did not own or control the premises where the utility worker was injured, the utility worker was not an independent contractor, and the underground rot on a utility pole is not the kind of danger inherent in utility work, such that it cannot be eliminated. The trial court erred in prohibiting defendant pole inspection company from arguing the empty-chair defense with respect to the deceased's employer, and the trial court erred in denying the company's requests to include the employer on the jury interrogatories and verdict form: The plain language of R.C. 2307.23 allows a jury to apportion fault to an employer, even if that employer is immune from suit under the workers' compensation statutes, and the trial court's error is not harmless where reasonable minds could differ as to whether the deceased employer's actions proximately caused the employee's death.
- 2018 Ohio 4756Mauntel v. Norwood (2018)
IMMUNITY – POLITICAL SUBDIVISIO: The trial court erred in denying defendant city's motion for summary judgment on the basis of Ohio's Political Subdivision Tort Liability Act in a lawsuit brought by a woman who fell on a curb, because the curb is not a part of the "public roads" for purposes of the exception to immunity in R.C. 2744.02(B)(3).
- 2018 Ohio 4757State v. Warren (2018)
SENTENCING – CONSECUTIVE SENTENCES: The trial court erred in ordering defendant's prison term for failing to comply with an order or signal of a police officer, a third-degree felony, to be served consecutively to a prison term previously imposed by a Kentucky court for another felony offense where the record shows that the court imposed the consecutive term under the erroneous understanding that a consecutive sentence was required under R.C. 2929.14(C): the relevant sentencing statutes, when read together, unambiguously permitted the trial court to order a consecutive sentence, but did not require that result.
- 2018 Ohio 4758In re L.S. (2018)
R.C. 2907.02(A)(1)(c) is not unconstitutionally vague as applied. State presented sufficient evidence that juvenile knew or should have known that victim's ability to resist or consent to sexual conduct was substantially impaired by voluntary intoxication. Counsel was not ineffective for stipulating to the admission of BCI reports and failing to object to purported hearsay statements. Juvenile court was required to comply with Juv.R. 29 and 35(B) when it imposed suspended DYS commitment.
- 2018 Ohio 4759State v. Clark (2018)
Failure to preserve video depicting time when appellant allegedly made retaliatory threats does not violate due process where the video was not materially exculpatory because it did not contain audio and the state's failure to preserve was the result of negligence, not bad faith.
- 2018 Ohio 4760State v. Collins (2018)
Anders appeal. Defendant appealed from the trial court's judgment following resentencing on post-release control only. Defendant has no arguably meritorious claim that the trial court erred in denying him a hearing on his sex offender classification. Any claim that the trial court lacked jurisdiction to impose post-release control for both rape and endangering children would be frivolous, as defendant was still serving his sentences on both offenses. Given that defendant would be serving five years of post-release control on the rape and the three-year post-release control obligation would be served concurrently, no arguably meritorious claim exists that the trial court erred in imposing a mandatory, rather than discretionary, period of post-release control for endangering children. Judgment affirmed, but case remanded for the limited purpose of a nunc pro tunc entry to reflect that the endangering children sentence is to be served consecutively to the rape sentence, consistent with the original 2007 judgment entry.
- 2018 Ohio 4761State v. Damiano (2018)
Appellant's counsel filed a brief under the authority of Anders v. California, 386 U.S. 738, 87 S.Ct. 1396, 18 L.Ed.2d 493 (1967). A thorough review of the record reveals no arguably meritorious appellate issues. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4763State v. Nelson (2018)
Appellant was specifically ordered by his probation officer to avoid contact with a particular person as a community control sanction. The court's judgment entry of conviction required Appellant to "follow all orders given to me by my supervising officer or other authorized representatives of the Court or the Department of Rehabilitation and Correction." Appellant's violation of the sanction prohibiting contact with the particular person was non-technical in nature such that R.C. 2929.15(B)(1)(c)(ii) did not apply to limit his sentence. Appellant's sentence is not contrary to law, and the judgment of the trial court is affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4764State v. Strawsburg (2018)
Anders appeal. No non-frivolous issues exist for review. The trial court adequately complied with Crim.R. 11 during the appellant's plea hearing. On a silent record, it is presumed that the trial court considered R.C. 2929.11 and R.C. 2929.12 at sentencing. The record supports the appellant's ten-month prison sentence, and the trial court was not obligated to follow the State's recommendation of community control. In addition, Appellant has completed his sentence, rendering moot issues regarding sentencing. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4765State v. Tillman (2018)
Appellant's vehicle was stopped so that the involved officer could investigate observed traffic and equipment violations. The officer, following his initial investigation, summoned a K-9 unit to perform a free air sniff, with the free air sniff ultimately resulting in the discovery of contraband. The trial court overruled Appellant's motion seeking suppression of the contraband. The stop had not been impermissibly prolonged when the K-9 unit was summoned, and, further, at this point, the officer, based upon his observations and investigation, possessed a reasonable suspicion that Appellant was engaged in non-traffic related criminal activity. Thus, it was permissible to prolong the stop to allow the free air sniff. However, assuming the circumstances did not support a reasonable suspicion conclusion, the officer did not unreasonably prolong the stop to allow the K-9 unit to arrive. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4766State v. Verdell (2018)
The trial court did not err in overruling Appellant's motion to suppress incriminating statements that Appellant made to law enforcement. The incriminating statements that were not preceded by Miranda warnings were not suppressible because they were not made during a custodial interrogation. The other incriminating statements in question were not suppressible because they were made following a knowing, intelligent, and voluntary waiver of Appellant's Miranda rights. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4767State v. Wiley (2018)
The trial court's imposition of consecutive sentences was not clearly and convincingly unsupported by the record. Judgment affirmed. (Hall, J., concurring.)
- 2018 Ohio 4769Cleveland Metro. Bar Assn. v. Mariotti (2018)
On certification of default.
- 2018 Ohio 4772State v. Glaze (2018)
App.R. 26(B) untimely good cause motion for extension of time. An application for reopening was denied where it was untimely filed without a showing of good cause. A motion for extension of time attempting to set forth good cause does not comply with App.R. 26(B) and is not proper under this rule.
- 2018 Ohio 4773Cleveland v. Daniels (2018)
Failure to comply notice of violation Cleveland Codified Ordinance Section 3103.25(e) waiver of counsel Crim.R. 44 no contest plea waiver of right to counsel maximum penalties R.C. 2929.24(A)(1) complaint Crim.R. 8(A) Crim.R. 12(C)(2) failure to raise objection. Appellant expressly tendered a plea of no contest however, he did not knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily waive his right to counsel. Thus, the portion of appellant's sentence imposing jail time is vacated. There was a factual basis to support the conviction for the failure to comply offense, and the trial court properly informed appellant of the maximum penalties associated with the 42-count complaint. Appellant waived the right to argue any defect in the complaint because he failed to raise any objection in the trial court.
- 2018 Ohio 4774State v. Sykes (2018)
Judicial release eligible offender mandatory contract plea agreement agreed upon sentence sentencing negotiated modification contrary to law. Where the mandatory nature of the agreed-upon sentence is an express condition of the plea agreement, it becomes a binding contractual term that renders the offender ineligible for judicial release under R.C. 2929.20(A). The trial court erred by granting judicial release to an ineligible offender.
- 2018 Ohio 4775J.S. v. D.L. (2018)
Domestic violence civil protection order, R.C. 3113.31, Civ.R. 65.1. Appellant, who was incarcerated at the time the full hearing on a domestic violence civil protection order against him was conducted, did not have a constitutional right to be present for the hearing. Appellant had adequate time to seek a continuance of the hearing or retain counsel. Appellant was prohibited from challenging factual findings made by the magistrate below because he failed to provide the domestic relations court with a transcript of the proceedings to support his objections.
- 2018 Ohio 4776Deutsche Bank Natl. Trust Co. v. Lovette (2018)
R.C. 1923.01 jurisdiction of forcible entry and detainer action R.C. 1923.02 color of title R.C. 1923.04 three-day notice to leave premises R.C. 5321.01(A) definition of tenant R.C. 5321.03(A)(4) eviction of holdover tenant R.C. 5321.17(B) 30-day notice to terminate periodic tenancy expiration of lease. The trial court did not err in granting a writ of restitution where appellant lacked color of title or other valid possessory interest the appellee bank held title to the property the underlying lease between appellant and the prior owner expired and no evidence existed of a periodic tenancy. A notice to leave premises that contained the requisite R.C. 1923.04(A) statutory language and was served by appellee bank 30 days prior to filing the forcible entry and detainer action was sufficient to invoke the trial court's jurisdiction where no written lease or periodic tenancy existed between the parties.
- 2018 Ohio 4778State v. Moore (2018)
Crim.R. 29/Sufficiency prosecutorial misconduct. Appellant removed the victim's money from her wallet without her permission and returned it only after the victim fought with appellant. Sufficient evidence was submitted that appellant's actions constituted theft. Appellant failed to show that but for the prosecutor's statements made during closing argument the outcome of the trial would have been different. Appeal as to maximum sentence is moot because appellant is only challenging length of his sentence and he has completed his sentence.
- 2018 Ohio 4779Cleveland v. State (2018)
R.C. 2505.02/final appealable order motion to intervene App.R. 4/timely notice of appeal. The trial court's denial of intervenor-appellant's motion to intervene was a final, appealable order and intervenor-appellant failed to file its notice of appeal in the 30-day required time period.
- 2018 Ohio 4780State v. King (2018)
Guilty plea trial court presentence motion to withdraw plea agreement competent counsel medication knowing voluntary intelligent hearing full and fair consideration impartial. Defendant was represented by highly competent counsel at the time of the plea, was given a full Crim.R. 11 hearing before entering his pleas, was afforded a complete and impartial hearing on his motion to withdraw, and the trial court gave full and fair consideration to the plea withdrawal request. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying defendant's motion to withdraw his guilty plea.
- 2018 Ohio 4782Rayco Mfg., Inc. v. Murphy, Rogers, Sloss & Gambel (2018)
Motion to enforce settlement agreement advisory jury Civ.R. 39(C)(1) standard of proof presumption of regularity witness-advocate rule Ohio Prof. Cond. R. 3.7(a) motion for attorney fees incurred to enforce settlement agreement. Regardless of whether a preponderance of the evidence or a clear and convincing evidence standard applied, trial court's finding that parties entered into an enforceable settlement agreement that resolved client's legal malpractice claim against attorneys was supported by sufficient competent, credible evidence. Trial court did not err in allowing appellees' counsel to serve as both witnesses and advocates at the hearing on motion to enforce settlement agreement where jury had only an advisory role, matters as to which counsel testified were not in dispute and trial court was well aware of the different roles assumed by appellees' counsel at the hearing and was not likely to be confused or misled by the lawyers' dual capacities. Trial court erred in denying appellees' motion to recover attorney fees incurred to enforce settlement agreement.
- 2018 Ohio 4783State v. Combs (2018)
Drug trafficking sentence concurrent fourth- and fifth-degree felonies R.C. 2929.11, 2929.12, and 2953.08 clear and convincing evidence merger allied offenses R.C. 2941.25. Judgment affirmed. Trial court's concurrent sentence of 18 months in prison for fourth- and fifth-degree felony convictions was proper. The trial court properly considered both R.C. 2929.11 and 2929.12 when sentencing the defendant. In doing so, the trial court expressly considered the defendant's PSI, the nature of the offenses involved, his criminal history, and what the defendant stated at the sentencing hearing. Under these circumstances, the defendant has not shown by "clear and convincing evidence that the record does not support the sentence." The defendant pled to three counts of drug trafficking with each count listing a different type of drug. Because these offenses are not similar in import or significance, the trial court properly found that these offenses do not merge for purposes of sentencing.
- 2018 Ohio 4784Lake Milton Estate Property Owner Assn., Inc. v. Hufford (2018)
Summary judgment Civ.R. 56(C) homeowners association planned community R.C. 5312.01 R.C. 5312.15 R.C. 5312.02(D)(1) R.C. 5312.02(D)(2) constructive notice.
- 2018 Ohio 4785In re Q.R. (2018)
The juvenile court's decision allocating the parties' parental rights and responsibilities regarding the upbringing of their daughter must be reversed and remanded for further proceedings where the juvenile court's decision was devoid of any reasoning and analysis demonstrating why rejecting the parties' stipulation regarding appellee's parenting time and the allocation of the dependency tax exemption was in the child's best interest.
- 2018 Ohio 4786In re C.S. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4789State v. Clark (2018)
Right to Self Representation Deadly Weapon
- 2018 Ohio 4790State v. Boyd (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4791State v. Berry (2018)
Consensual Encounter Suspected Drug Use
- 2018 Ohio 4799State v. Smith (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - identification procedure impermissibly suggestive and unnecessary Neil v. Biggers, 409 U.S. 188, factors to assess whether identification was reliable under the totality of the circumstances suppression not required attempted murder, aggravated robbery, aggravated burglary convictions supported by sufficient evidence and weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 4800State v. Hill (2018)
CRIMINAL - motion for new trial newly discovered evidence Crim.R. 33 motion to strike leave to file for new trial motion to strike Crim.R. 57(B) Civ.R. 12(F) unavoidable delay res judicata law of the case circumstantial evidence other acts evidence Evid.R. 404(B) evidentiary hearing disqualification of prosecutor's office presumption of prejudice breach of confidence
- 2018 Ohio 4801State v. Michalos (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - aggravated disorderly conduct Crim.R. 29(A) motion sufficiency manifest weight city council meeting recklessly offensively course utterance, gesture, or display inconvenience, annoyance, or alarm reasonable warning or request to desist.
- 2018 Ohio 4802State v. Lafferty (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCING - R.C. 2953.08(G)(2) sentence in the prescribed range Eighth Amendment challenge claiming sentencing judge has too much discretion must be raised to trial court or the issue is waived.
- 2018 Ohio 4803In re F.D. Johnson Co. (2018)
DISCOVERY - Separate action for discovery Civ.R. 34(D) identification of potential party through production of documents use of civil rule improper when identity already known R.C. 2317.48 discovery of facts as basis for potential claim mootness continuing enforceability of judgment.
- 2018 Ohio 4807State v. Eutsey (2018)
Evid. R. 804(B)(6) - Ineffective Assistance
- 2018 Ohio 4808State v. Stockbridge (2018)
Permit required for collection of petition signatures
- 2018 Ohio 4809State v. Stockbridge (2018)
Permit required for collection of petition signatures
- 2018 Ohio 4810In re K.B. (2018)
SEX OFFENSES – JUVENILE – CLASSIFICATION: The juvenile court's decision to continue the juvenile's classification as a Tier I sex offender under Ohio's version of the federal Adam Walsh Act was not an abuse of discretion where the record shows that the magistrate and the juvenile court carefully considered the statutory factors and the evidence supported the decision.
- 2018 Ohio 4811State v. Battin (2018)
Motion to reopen denied.
- 2018 Ohio 4814State v. Jenkins (2018)
sufficiency, manifest weight, R.C. 2925.03, R.C. 2925.11, motion to suppress, major drug offender, harmless error, hearsay, prosecutorial misconduct, cumulative error
- 2018 Ohio 4815State v. Najmuddeen Salaam (2018)
Denial of motion to remit bond
- 2018 Ohio 4819State v. Donohue (2018)
Appellant's conviction for complicity to illegal manufacture of methamphetamine is not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 4821Schuetzman v. Dept. of Rehab. & Corr. (2018)
Negligence contributory negligence inmate magistrate Civ.R. 53 objections. Plaintiff inmate was injured after falling from a step ladder while working as part of a construction crew. Defendant objected to a decision of the magistrate recommending judgment for Plaintiff with a 40 percent reduction in damages for contributory negligence. Defendant objected: (1) the magistrate erred in concluding that Defendant breached a duty of reasonable care to Plaintiff (2) the magistrate erred by not concluding that Plaintiff's actions were the sole proximate cause of Plaintiff's injuries (3) the magistrate erred by not concluding that Plaintiff's negligence exceeded any negligence by Defendant and (4) the magistrate erred by ignoring evidence that Plaintiff commented that the accident was "nobody's fault." The court overruled Defendant's first and second objections because Defendant knowingly allowed Plaintiff to use a step ladder while removing a wall vent of unknown weight. In doing so, Defendant allowed Plaintiff to perform work in a dangerous manner that foreseeably resulted in the Plaintiff's injuries. The court overruled Defendant's third objection because the Defendant, as Plaintiff's supervisor, was in a superior position to prevent Plaintiff from performing work in a risky manner. The court overruled Defendant's fourth objection because the facts established Defendant's negligence, regardless of Plaintiff's opinion. The court adopted the magistrate's decision and recommendation.
- 2018 Ohio 4822Wayt v. DHSC, L.L.C. (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Torts—Damages—R.C. 2315.18—Defamation—Cap on noneconomic compensatory damages— R.C. 2315.18(B)(2) caps noneconomic damages that can be recovered as a result of defamation.
- 2018 Ohio 4823State v. St. Jules (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Court of appeals' judgment affirmed on authority of State v. Carnes.
- 2018 Ohio 4824State v. Barfield (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Court of appeals' judgment affirmed on authority of State v. Carnes.
- 2018 Ohio 4825State v. McCray (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Court of appeals' judgment affirmed on authority of State v. Carnes.
- 2018 Ohio 4826State v. Sally (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Court of appeals' judgment affirmed on authority of State v. Carnes.
- 2018 Ohio 4827State v. Young (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Court of appeals' judgment affirmed on authority of State v. Carnes.
- 2018 Ohio 4828State v. Jackson (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Court of appeals' judgment affirmed on authority of State v. Carnes.
- 2018 Ohio 4829State v. Ortiz (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Court of appeals' judgment affirmed on authority of State v. Carnes.
- 2018 Ohio 4830State v. Herron (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Court of appeals' judgment affirmed on authority of State v. Carnes.
- 2018 Ohio 4831State v. Jones (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Court of appeals' judgment affirmed on authority of State v. Carnes.
- 2018 Ohio 4835State v. Guy (2018)
Convictions for heroin trafficking, heroin possession, and kidnapping were supported by sufficient evidence and were not against the manifest weight of the evidence where detective's eyewitness testimony plus other evidence established appellant was the individual who committed the offenses. Although appellant's alibi witnesses provided contrary testimony regarding appellant's whereabouts at the time of some of the offenses, the jury did not clearly lose its way in finding appellant guilty.
- 2018 Ohio 4836State v. Guy (2018)
Convictions for heroin trafficking, heroin possession, and kidnapping were supported by sufficient evidence and were not against the manifest weight of the evidence where detective's eyewitness testimony plus other evidence established appellant was the individual who committed the offenses. Although appellant's alibi witnesses provided contrary testimony regarding appellant's whereabouts at the time of some of the offenses, the jury did not clearly lose its way in finding appellant guilty.
- 2018 Ohio 4837Huntington Natl. Bank v. Haehn (2018)
The trial court did not err in vacating an interlocutory order, extending a deadline for the submittal of a proposed judgment entry, or granting the lender judgment in its foreclosure action.
- 2018 Ohio 4838You v. Northeast Ohio Med. Univ. (2018)
Trial court did not err in granting summary judgment on appellant's breach of contract claim as related to the termination of her administrative positions. However, trial court erred in granting summary judgment on appellant's breach of contract claim related to the cancellation of appellant's endowed professorship where appellee failed to demonstrate the absence of a genuine issue of material fact. Trial court did not err in determining that it lacked jurisdiction over constitutional due process claim. Trial court did not err in granting summary judgment on discrimination claim because appellant failed to meet her burden of demonstrating prima facie case and pretext. Trial court did not err in granting summary judgment on retaliation claim because appellant failed to demonstrate prima facie case.
- 2018 Ohio 4839Settle-Muter Elec. Ltd. v. Intertech Sec., LLC (2018)
The trial court did not err in refusing to stay the litigation of certain claims pending arbitration where (1) those claims that were not part of the action that included the arbitrable claims and (2) the parties to the claims at issue had not executed an arbitration agreement.
- 2018 Ohio 4840State v. Le Blanc (2018)
Former girlfriend no longer had a priviledge to enter former boyfriend's residence.
- 2018 Ohio 4841State v. Dixon (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying appellant's motion for a new trial. The recantation by one of the witnesses who identified appellant as the shooter was not sufficient to establish a strong probability that a different verdict would result when considering the other evidence presented at trial.
- 2018 Ohio 4842State v. Dillard (2018)
The state charged appellant with committing the offenses of menacing by stalking "on or about" April 24, 2016 and was provided or permitted to inspect requested discovery which included police reports and recordings of 911 call and police interviews. Therefore, the trial court did not err in considering evidence of appellant's actions on April 25, 2016 to establish a "pattern of conduct." The state charged appellant with attempted burglary and therefore was not required to prove appellant entered the home, rather, was only required to prove appellant knowingly engaged in conduct that, if successful, would have constituted entering the victim's home. Accordingly, the judgments were supported by sufficient evidence and were not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Judgments affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4843OMG MSTR LSCO, L.L.C. v. Dept. of Medicaid (2018)
Trial court did not abuse its discretion when it dismissed plaintiffs-appellants' declaratory judgment action. On its face, the complaint did not establish that pursuit of administrative proceedings would be so burdensome as to meet the exceptions to the affirmative defense of failure to exhaust administrative remedies
- 2018 Ohio 4844State v. Bridges (2018)
The trial court did not err in denying appellant's motion to vacate void sentence. The trial court in imposing the repeat violent offender specifically applied R.C. 2929.14(B)(2)(a) rather than R.C. 2929.14(B)(2)(b). Therefore, the two prior voncition the court considered were not required to have been committed within 20 years. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4845Rawlings v. Springwood Apartments of Columbus, Ltd. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4849State v. Hunt (2018)
Statement of record App.R. 9(C) presume regularity R.C. 2945.06 Crim.R. 11. The appellant has not demonstrated through his App.R. 9(C) statement of record that the trial court or panel erred in any way. Where there is no transcript of the lower court's proceedings, we presume regularity. The trial court complied with R.C. 2945.06 and Crim.R. 11(C)(3), which requires a panel of three judges to accept a plea of guilty to a charge of aggravated murder with specifications.
- 2018 Ohio 4851SMS Fin. XXVI, L.L.C. v. Waxman Chabad Ctr. (2018)
Res judicata, claim preclusion, final appealable order. The trial court erred in finding that res judicata applied to a 2016 commercial foreclosure action. In 2014, the trial court granted summary judgment in favor of appellees in a commercial foreclosure action finding that the underlying promissory note was not properly endorsed. This court dismissed the appeal of that judgment and remanded the case to the trial court due to the lack of a final appealable order as the result of an outstanding fraud count. On remand, the 2014 case was consolidated with a newly filed 2016 case between the same parties involving an endorsed version of the promissory note. In a single entry, the trial court again granted summary judgment in the 2014 case and determined that the 2016 filing was barred by the doctrine of res judicata, a finding that conflicted with the trial court's concurrent scheduling of a pretrial on the remaining fraud count in the 2014 case, indicating the matter was not, in fact, final.
- 2018 Ohio 4852State v. Anglero (2018)
Res judicata motion to withdraw guilty plea imposition of postrelease control. Defendant's challenge to the imposition of a fine as part of his felony sentence is barred by res judicata, because he did not raise the issue in a direct appeal. The court properly notified defendant about postrelease control therefore, the court did nor err when it denied his motion to withdraw guilty plea.
- 2018 Ohio 4853State v. Everette (2018)
Guilty plea trial court's involvement in the plea bargaining process Crim.R. 11(C) maximum penalty. The trial court's statements outlining the maximum potential prison sentence defendant would be facing if he were found guilty after a trial, do not amount to involvement in the plea bargaining process. To the contrary, the trial court was merely advising the defendant of the maximum penalty he could receive if he went to trial and was found guilty of all the counts alleged against him in the indictment. Under Crim.R. 11(C)(2)(a), the trial court must be sure that before a defendant pleads guilty to a felony, he knows the maximum penalty. Therefore, by explaining the maximum sentence defendant could receive, the trial court was complying with the requirements of Crim.R. 11(C)(2)(a).
- 2018 Ohio 4854State v. Burkes (2018)
Aggravated murder R.C. 2903.01(A) prior calculation and design provocation cooling off jury instruction voluntary manslaughter sudden R.C. 2903.03(A) sufficiency of the evidence manifest weight murder R.C. 2903.02(B) felonious assault R.C. 2903.11(A) knowingly Batson challenge race neutral reasons sentence R.C. 2953.08(D)(3). Burkes failed to show serious provocation sufficient to warrant jury instructions on voluntary manslaughter where the evidence demonstrated a cooling off period between the alleged provocation and the commission of the crime that rendered the "sudden" element of voluntary manslaughter insufficient as a matter of law. The state presented sufficient evidence of prior calculation and design to support Burkes's conviction for aggravated murder where Burkes expressed revenge for a prior incident with a man he knew, acquired a gun, obtained a ride to the home where he knew the victim to be staying, charged upstairs threatening the victim, called him outside, and shot and killed him. The state also presented sufficient evidence to support the knowing element of Burkes's convictions for murder and felonious assault. Burkes's convictions were not against the manifest weight of the evidence. The trial court did not err in denying Burkes's Batson challenge where the court engaged in the proper analysis and the state provided sufficient race neutral reasons for utilizing its peremptory challenge. Burkes's sentence for aggravated murder is not reviewable pursuant to R.C. 2953.08(D)(3).
- 2018 Ohio 4855State v. Berry (2018)
Statute of limitations preindictment delay rape 20-year statute of limitations ineffective assistance of counsel prejudice R.C. 2901.13 reasonable diligence. Judgment is vacated, and the matter is remanded so counsel can file a motion to dismiss the indictment. The state's attempts to locate defendant lacked the requisite "reasonable diligence" to commence the prosecution within the 20 year limitations period when the defendant was first arrested in 1995 for the offense, but the victim chose not to pursue the case and then the defendant was indicted one week prior to the 20 years after the investigator reopened the case based on a CODIS hit (on another male) from the victim's rape kit. The summons was returned via FedEx for a "bad address" and the case was stagnant for nearly two years until the defendant was arrested. Consequently, nearly 22 years passed since the incident in January 1995. During the state's investigation in 2014, the investigator was aware that the defendant was making child support payments, but he did not seek out defendant's contact information through the county agency.
- 2018 Ohio 4856State v. Woods (2018)
Finding of guilt in open court court speaks through its journal entry firearm specification having weapons while under disability consecutive sentences. Court's consecutive sentence for firearm specification, having weapons while under disability, community control sanctions, and violations were supported by evidence in the record and not contrary to law.
- 2018 Ohio 4857State v. Collins (2018)
R.C. 2152.12(B) Juv.R. 30 amenability discretionary bindover. The juvenile court did not abuse its discretion in determining that defendant-appellant was not amenable to rehabilitation in the juvenile system and discretionarily binding the matter over to the general division of the common pleas court for prosecution of defendant-appellant as an adult. Defendant-appellant does not dispute the juvenile court's finding of four of the nine factors in favor of transfer under R.C. 2152.12(D) and two of the eight factors against transfer under R.C. 2152.12(E). Defendant-appellant does argue, however, that the record supports the application of three additional factors against transfer. The record supports the juvenile court's resolution of the statutory factors and, therefore, does not demonstrate an abuse of the juvenile court's discretion.
- 2018 Ohio 4859State v. McCluskey (2018)
CRIMINAL - Trial court did not err in admitting statements made to medical professionals by child as Appellant failed to preserve issue for appeal and no plain error occurred.
- 2018 Ohio 4860MorEquity, Inc. v. Gombita (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4861State v. Taylor (2018)
R.C. 2967.28/postrelease control. Appellant was guilty of an unclassified felony and was therefore entitled to be informed of postrelease control at his sentencing hearing.
- 2018 Ohio 4864OHIO STATE BAR ASSOCIATION v. KLOSK Et Al. (2018)
Unauthorized practice of law—Lawyer not licensed in Ohio held self and firm out as representing Ohio debtor in correspondence with Ohio counsel for creditor—Injunction issued and civil penalty imposed.
- 2018 Ohio 4866Pivonka v. Sears (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 48706610 Cummings Court, L. L.C. v. Scott (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4873Cleveland Cent. Catholic High Sch. v. Mills (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4877State v. Adams (2018)
Appellant completed his 90-day prison sentence without any of the jail-time credit to which the trial court found he was entitled having been deducted. Because he has served his sentence and been released, this issue is moot. The court costs and restitution that he was originally ordered to pay cannot be forgiven as restitution for the extra time Appellant spent in prison. Appeal dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 4879State v. Eleyet (2018)
The appellant's challenge to his jail-time credit is moot where he admittedly has completed his sentence and has been released from confinement. The "interest of justice" does not favor appellate review of a moot issue. Appeal dismissed as moot.
- 2018 Ohio 4880State v. Hudson (2018)
In the absence of a transcript of the plea hearing, we presume regularity regarding the trial court's compliance with Crim.R. 11(E), namely that the court advised appellant of the effect of his no contest plea on one count of failure to stop after an accident, a misdemeanor of the first degree. Regarding appellant's conviction for failure to comply with an order or signal of a police officer, the initial complaint charged the offense as a felony of the third degree, and the court accepted appellant's no contest plea to the offense as a misdemeanor of the first degree, without causing a complaint charging the misdemeanor offense to be filed, as required by Crim.R. 5(B)(6). In the absence of an amended complaint, the trial court acted without authority in convicting appellant of felony failure to comply, and analysis of whether the trial court complied with Crim.R. 11(F) by failing to recite the negotiated plea agreement for that offense on the record is not required. Having found that the trial court lacked authority to convict appellant of felony failure to comply, we need not consider the alleged ineffective assistance of defense counsel regarding the absence of a new complaint pursuant to Crim.R. 5(B)(6). Appellant's conviction for failure to stop is affirmed. Appellant's conviction for failure to comply is vacated, and the matter is remanded for proceedings consistent with this opinion. (Hall, J., concurring.) (Welbaum, P.J., dissenting.)
- 2018 Ohio 4882State v. Kerr (2018)
Anders appeal. No non-frivolous issues for appellate review. The record reflects that the appellant entered a valid guilty plea pursuant to a favorable plea deal. The trial court lawfully imposed community control sanctions, which included placement in a residential treatment facility. The record does not portray any ineffective assistance of counsel in connection with the proceedings below. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4883State v. Muldrew (2018)
The trial court did not err by not merging Appellant's convictions. Also, it cannot be concluded that the trial court's consecutive sentence findings are clearly and convincingly not supported by the record, and, further, there is no basis upon which to conclude that the trial court at sentencing did not appropriately consider Appellant's mental health. Finally, Appellant, by pleading guilty, waived any error regarding the trial court's determination that he was competent to stand trial, but, even if this were not so, the record reveals no error relating to this issue. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4884State v. Owens (2018)
The trial court erred when it prohibited defense counsel from introducing evidence of appellant's additional tattoos, as they were directly relevant as to his identification as the man who committed the instant offenses. Because appellant's tattoos were akin to other identifying features such as height, weight, eye color, hair color, and skin color, they were not subject to discovery under Crim.R. 16. However, in light of the other substantial evidence of appellant's guilt, we find that the trial court's decision to prohibit defense counsel from introducing evidence of appellant's additional tattoos was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt. Because we find that exclusion of tattoo evidence was harmless, appellant's trial counsel was not ineffective for failing to provide the State with reciprocal discovery, including evidence of all of appellant's tattoos. Defense counsel also did not render ineffective assistance by failing to suggest a less severe discovery sanction the record establishes that she suggested to the trial court the alternative of introducing photographs of the tattoos in lieu of the shirt removal, which the trial court likewise rejected erroneously as a discovery violation. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4885State v. Roberts (2018)
The trial court did not err in imposing maximum sentences for Appellant's convictions of improperly discharging a firearm at or into a habitation and having weapons under disability. The record indicates that the trial court properly considered relevant factors under R.C. 2929.11 and R.C. 2929.12. Furthermore, the record does not clearly and convincingly fail to support the court's decision to impose maximum sentences. The trial court also did not err in imposing the sentences in this case consecutive to Appellant's sentence for a prior conviction of having weapons under disability. The court made the proper findings for imposing consecutive sentences under R.C. 2929.14(C)(4). Judgment affirmed. (Froelich, J., concurring.)
- 2018 Ohio 4886State v. Southern (2018)
Defendant appealed conviction of four counts of knowingly committing an act of cruelty against a companion animal. Trial counsel was not ineffective for failing to pursue defense based on statute's non-application to hunting dogs where testimony elicited during trial negated that defense. In addition, evidence presented was sufficient to support guilty verdicts, and those verdicts were not against manifest weight of the evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4888State v. Rose (2018)
Record supports maximum and consecutive sentences
- 2018 Ohio 4889State v. Pine (2018)
Consecutive Sentences
- 2018 Ohio 4904State v. Braddy (2018)
Motion for new trial. Credibility. Strong probability does not exist that new evidence will change result if new trial is granted.
- 2018 Ohio 4905State v. Williamson (2018)
Trial court does not abuse its discretion in imposing maximum six-month jail sentence on appellant for stealing a $6 sponge where appellant's criminal history supports the conclusion that the longest jail term was necessary to deter her from committing future crimes.
- 2018 Ohio 4906State v. George (2018)
sufficiency of the evidence manifest weight denial of motion for acquittal
- 2018 Ohio 4907In re N.F. (2018)
Appellant's arguments concerning the trial court's journalization of certain case plan requirements in conjunction with its determination of dependency and award of temporary custody are not subject to appellate review prior to a final judgment, as the case plan may be modified at any time pursuant to R.C. 2151.412(F)(2)(a).
- 2018 Ohio 4908State v. Nettles (2018)
In a drug-trafficking case, the judge who issued the interception warrant in the county where the cell phone was located had jurisdiction, the application for the interception warrant complied with R.C. 2933.53, and the warrant was supported by sufficient probable cause of criminal activity. Motion to suppress evidentiary hearing consecutive sentences maximum sentence judicial fact-finding.
- 2018 Ohio 4909State v. Nicholson (2018)
Appellant's conviction was supported by sufficient evidence and was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4910State v. Bryant (2018)
Statements by prosecutor at sentencing that multiple officers raided the house and were yelling at the time that appellant fired several shots in their direction were sufficient to support the trial court's conclusion that there were multiple victims of appellant's act of felonious assault, and thus the two counts should not merge.
- 2018 Ohio 4911Seaton Corp. v. Testa (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation—R.C. 5739.01(B)(3)(k)—Sales tax imposed on transactions by which "employment service" is provided—R.C. 5739.01(JJ)—Definition of "employment service"—Providing personnel to perform work or labor "under the supervision or control of another"—Employment-service inquiry under R.C. 5739.01(JJ) focuses on who controlled workers' schedules and workplace assignments based on the evidence presented, with the "supervision or control" exercised involving the specific work performed by the provided personnel.
- 2018 Ohio 4912Embassy Healthcare v. Bell (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Creditor must present claim for unpaid necessaries to decedent's estate under R.C. 2117.06 before it can pursue claim individually against surviving spouse under R.C. 3103.03.
- 2018 Ohio 4913State v. Bauman (2018)
felonious assault failure to remain at the scene of an accident evidence was sufficient to uphold appellant's convictions convictions not against manifest weight of the evidence trial court did not abuse discretion in limiting scope of cross-examination new trial not warranted trial counsel not ineffective no cumulative error sentence not contrary to law
- 2018 Ohio 4914Thomason v. AT&T (2018)
Abuse of process probable cause ulterior motive ulterior purpose
- 2018 Ohio 4915Metro. Life Ins. Co. v. Lee (2018)
summary judgment on foreclosure action genuine issue of material fact as to whether plaintiff compiled with terms of note and mortgage certified mail first class mail
- 2018 Ohio 4916State v. Staffrey (2018)
untimely postconviction petition trial court lacked jurisdiction to entertain petition or hold a hearing
- 2018 Ohio 4917Besancon v. Cedar Lane Farms (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4918State v. Mukha (2018)
R.C. 4511.202, failure to control, sufficiency of the evidence, manifest weight of the evidence
- 2018 Ohio 4921State v. Watkins (2018)
Trial court's sentence was supported by the record.
- 2018 Ohio 4922State v. Lawson (2018)
Plea vacated where pressure placed on defendant to proceed in the absence of a sufficient waiver of counsel.
- 2018 Ohio 4923State v. Buckner (2018)
This court's review of defendant-appellant's sentence is barred under R.C. 2953.08(D)(1). Appeal dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 4926State v. Slack (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4928Hoover Kacyon, LLC v. Martell (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 4929State v. King (2018)
Criminal: probable cause to arrest for marijuana impaired OVI motion to suppress R.C. 4511.19.
- 2018 Ohio 4930Disciplinary Counsel v. Leneghan (2018)
On peitition for reinstatement.
- 2018 Ohio 4931Disciplinary Counsel v. Potts (2018)
On certification of default.
- 2018 Ohio 4936State v. Gray (2018)
The trial court did not err in sentencing appellant to eight years in prison where the sentence was not contrary to law and was fully supported by the record.
- 2018 Ohio 4937In re Guardianship of Chieu (2018)
The probate court held proper jurisdiction, both subject matter and personal, where appellant established a legal settlement in Butler County and the probate court has exclusive subject matter jurisdiction to appoint guardians per R.C. 2101.24(A)(e).
- 2018 Ohio 4942State v. Reynolds (2018)
Appellant's guilty plea was entered knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily where record reveals that the trial court strictly complied with Crim.R. 11(C)(2)(c) and substantially complied with the nonconstitutional notifications required by Crim.R. 11(C)(2)(a) and (b).
- 2018 Ohio 4943State v. Butcher (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - Pretrial identification photo array facial tatoo not unduly suggestive Crim.R. 12(F) no statement of factual findings on suppression motion sufficient basis to uphold decision manifest weight of the evidence corrupting another with drugs aggravating drug trafficking failure to appear for trial no-contact order invalid when defendant sentenced to prison R.C. 2925.02(C)(1)(a) mandatory prison term jury finding that schedule I drug, fentanyl, was involved jury instruction only referred to fentanyl imposition of fine ability to pay evidence in record showing that trial court considered issue.
- 2018 Ohio 4944State v. Mahvi (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - Illegal use of food stamps R.C. 2913.46(B) failure to disclose all assets in applying for benefits bank accounts real property manifest weight witness credibility forensic accounting degree unnecessary medicaid eligibility fraud R.C. 2913.401(B) false statements as to amount of income from businesses defendant's testimony as to source of income unbelievable.
- 2018 Ohio 4945State v. Bozek (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - sentencing greater sentenc no evidence of vindictiveness merger offenses R.C. 2941.25 Ruff firearm specifications no error previously rejected argument law of the case.
- 2018 Ohio 4946State v. Ralston (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - plea of guilty Crim.R. 11 Boykin Veney strictly comply no reference to a right to jury trial cannot rely exclusively upon outside sources advise in a manner reasonably intelligible failure to comply plea invalid.
- 2018 Ohio 4947State v. Brown (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - resentence consecutive sentences R.C. 2929.14(C)(4) findings criminal history no single prison term adequately reflects the seriousness of the offender's conduct.
- 2018 Ohio 4949Fatica Renovations, L.L.C. v. Bridge (2018)
CONSTITUTIONAL LAW - Injunction barring former property owner from making public statements about present ownership commercial speech not protected if statement is false prior determination by federal district court that former owner has no present interest in property res judicata for purposes of state action for injunctive relief privity to party in prior foreclosure case issue pertaining to subject matter jurisdiction res judicata still apply if issue fully litigated merits of preliminary injunction moot once permanent injunction granted no duty to grant injunctive relief when it was not requested party not entitled to jury trial when summary judgment warranted.
- 2018 Ohio 4950State v. Donoho (2018)
PROBATION - motion to modify conditions of community control change of circumstances Ohio Revised Code Chapter 3796 controlled substances marijuana THC Marinol dronabinol medical marijuana not yet cultivated, processed, or dispensed by licensed facilities in Ohio no reciprocity with other states probation violation affirmative defense.
- 2018 Ohio 4952Nieto v. Marcellino (2018)
CIVIL - magistrate's decision Civ.R. 53 failure to file a transcript of the magistrate's hearing appellate review confined to whether the conclusions of law are supported by the factual findings R.C. 5321.16(B) & (C) double damages as to amount wrongfully withheld magistrate failed to make findings regarding whether any deductions were proper.
- 2018 Ohio 4953Gorslene v. Dept. of Transp. (2018)
Negligence contributory negligence bifurcated liability. Plaintiff brought this negligence action after suffering injuries in an incident involving a state-owned vehicle operated by Defendant's employee. Plaintiff's wife also brought a loss of consortium claim. The issues of liability and damages were bifurcated. Defendant owned a vehicle parked on a road construction site where Plaintiff was working. Defendant's employee tried to move the vehicle to another location near the site, and accidentally backed over Plaintiff, who was kneeling behind the vehicle refilling a box of chalk. The magistrate found that Defendant's employee failed to exercise proper care under the circumstances. The magistrate concluded that, in a busy, fast-paced work environment, Defendant's employee had a duty to ensure that nobody was behind the vehicle before backing out. Plaintiff's behavior did not constitute contributory negligence, as Plaintiff was wearing safety gear, engaged in a normal work duty, and was working in plain sight several feet away from Defendant's vehicle. The magistrate found Defendant liable for Plaintiff's injuries.
- 2018 Ohio 4954Acts 17:28 Ministries, Inc. v. Dept. of Rehab. & Corr. (2018)
Civil procedure magistrate objections Civ.R. 53 transcript. Plaintiffs brought this action for breach of contract after Defendant terminated a service contract. Following a bench trial, the magistrate found in favor of Defendant. Plaintiffs filed objections to the magistrate's decision, pursuant to Civ.R. 53(D)(3)(b)(i). Plaintiffs' objections challenged a factual finding by the magistrate. Civ.R. 53(D)(b)(iii) requires objections to a factual finding to be supported by a transcript or affidavit of evidence. The party filing objections must file the transcript or affidavit within 30 days of filing the objections, unless the court extends time in writing or there is other good cause. In this case, the court did not grant an extension of time to file a transcript or affidavit. Plaintiffs failed to file a transcript or affidavit within 30 days. Because Plaintiffs' objections concerned factual findings by the magistrate and Plaintiffs did not file a transcript or affidavit, the court overruled the objections. Finding no error in the magistrate's legal conclusions, the court adopted the magistrate's decision.
- 2018 Ohio 4955Ventresco v. Ohio State Univ. Wexner Med. Ctr. (2018)
Negligence liability duty open and obvious causation comparative negligence damages parental consortium magistrate. Plaintiff brought this negligence action after suffering injuries on Defendant's premises. Plaintiff's son also asserted a claim for the loss of parental consortium. Plaintiff suffered a puncture injury to her leg after tripping on a curb and landing on a metal bolt protruding from a mulched area in Defendant's parking lot. The magistrate found that Defendant owed a duty of care to Plaintiff as an invitee. Plaintiff did not exceed the scope of her invitation by walking through a mulched area of the parking lot, because the area was obviously worn down by pedestrian use and Defendant's employees walked through the mulched area. Defendant did not breach a duty of care to Plaintiff with respect to the curb, because the danger of the curb should have been open and obvious to the Plaintiff. However, Defendant did breach a duty of care with respect to the protruding bolt, because Defendant knew or should have known it presented a danger. Defendant's breach of care was a proximate cause of Plaintiff's injury. However, Plaintiff's comparative negligence warranted a 50 percent reduction of any award for damages. The magistrate determined that Plaintiff was entitled to damages for medical expenses, lost wages, and pain and suffering. The magistrate also determined Plaintiff's son was entitled to damages for the loss of parental consortium.
- 2018 Ohio 4956State v. Hedges (2018)
Crim.R. 33(A)(6)–trial court did not abuse its discretion by overruling new trial motion on basis of newly discovered evidence when new evidence served only to impeach or contradict testimony and did not disclose a strong probability that it would change the result if a new trial were granted.
- 2018 Ohio 4957State v. Johnson (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Court of appeals' judgment reversed and trial court's judgment denying motion to vacate judicial sanction reinstated based on State v. Gordon and State v. Grimes.
- 2018 Ohio 4958State v. Murray (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Court of appeals' judgment affirmed on authority of State v. Johnson.
- 2018 Ohio 4959Blackstone v. Moore (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Marketable Title Act—R.C. 5301.47 et seq.—A reference in a deed to an oil-and-gas royalty that includes the type of interest created and to whom the interest was granted is sufficiently specific to preserve the interest in the record title.
- 2018 Ohio 4960State v. Walker (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Appeal dismissed as having been improvidently accepted.
- 2018 Ohio 4961Mahoning County Bar Association v. Sciortino. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Felony convictions involving dishonesty—Indefinite license suspension.
- 2018 Ohio 4963State v. Kuhel (2018)
No expungement of criminal charges dismissed in municipal court and not bound over but later subject to direct indictment.
- 2018 Ohio 4964State v. Watson (2018)
Appellant's felonious assault conviction was supported by sufficient evidence. Viewed in a light most favorable to the state, the evidence demonstrated beyond a reasonable doubt that appellant knowingly caused serious physical harm to the victim when, without any provocation or warning to the victim, he struck the victim with a strong closed fist punch to the side of the victim's head. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4965Zarbana Indus., Inc. v. Hayes (2018)
Appellant failed to demonstrate the court of common pleas erred in finding it lacked jurisdiction to address appellant's declaratory judgment action contending the Industrial Commission lacked authority to reject its VSSR settlement agreement under R.C. Chapter 4121 and Ohio Admin.Code 4121-3-20(F). Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4966State v. Wright (2018)
Judgment affirmed. Appellant is not subject to post-release control in Franklin County. As such, his assignments of error are overruled.
- 2018 Ohio 4967State v. Jennings (2018)
The trial court did not err in denying Jennings' motion to terminate commitment.
- 2018 Ohio 4968Wood v. Div. of Oil & Gas Resources Mgt. (2018)
Court of Claims lacked subject matter jurisdiction over oil and gas well operator's claim for declaratory judgment.
- 2018 Ohio 4969Kanu v. Univ. of Cincinnati (2018)
The trial court did not err in granting appellee's motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim pursuant to Civ.R. 12(B)(6). Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4971State v. Watson (2018)
CONSTITUTIONAL LAW/CRIMINAL – SPEEDY TRIAL – GUILTY PLEA – WAIVER: Defendant waived his constitutional and statutory speedy-trial rights where his guilty plea was made knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily.
- 2018 Ohio 4972In re K.P. (2018)
AGGRAVATED ROBBERY – FELONIOUS ASSAULT – ALLIED OFFENSES – R.C. 2941.25 – SENTENCING: Where in committing felonious assault defendant used force greater than was necessary to effectuate an aggravated robbery, defendant acted with a specific intent to harm, separate from any animus to rob the victim, and the offenses were separately punishable under R.C. 2941.25. Defendant committed felonious assault with an animus separate from that of aggravated robbery where defendant beat the victim into unconsciousness, continued to beat the victim after he had lost consciousness, and then stole property from the victim therefore, the juvenile court did not err under R.C. 2941.25 in imposing separate punishments for the offenses.
- 2018 Ohio 4973State v. Freeman (2018)
SENTENCING – MANDATORY FINE – INDIGENCY – R.C. 2929.19: The trial court did not err in imposing a mandatory fine where defendant filed an affidavit of indigency that established he was currently unable to pay the fine, the record supported a finding that defendant would have the future ability to pay the fine, and the trial court considered defendant's present and future ability to pay the fine as required by R.C. 2929.19(B)(5).
- 2018 Ohio 4975State v. Holland (2018)
CRIMINAL - The imposition of a mandatory fine by the trial court for Appellant's conviction for trafficking in cocaine and heroin was not in error.
- 2018 Ohio 4976State v. Shaffer (2018)
CRIMINAL - Trial court did not err in convicting Appellant of one count of unlawful sexual conduct with a minor as no error occurred as to jury verdicts and record supports the same.
- 2018 Ohio 4979Francis v. Akron Metro. Hous. Auth. (2018)
App.R. 4(B)(2)(c) – final, appealable order – motion to reconsider
- 2018 Ohio 4980In re Estate of Hamad (2018)
estate removal of executor R.C. 2113.18(A)(1) final, appealable order abuse of discretion.
- 2018 Ohio 4984State v. Brown (2018)
Trial court did not abuse its discretion by denying motion to withdraw guilty plea because appellant failed to establish manifest injustice through facts in the record demonstrating that his mental health issues or medication status at the time of the plea hearing prevented him from making a knowing, voluntary, and intelligent plea. Appellant also failed to show facts that would overcome the presumption of competency such that his counsel rendered ineffective assistance by failing to request a competency hearing.
- 2018 Ohio 4985Hayton v. Reliable Staffing Resources (2018)
Trial court erred in granting summary judgment based on doctrine of res judicata.
- 2018 Ohio 4986State v. Farley (2018)
Judgment affirmed. The trial court properly denied appellant's petition for post-conviction relief because the trial court's judgment was not void nor dormant. In addition, appellant's petition was untimely and he had the opportunity to appeal the final sentencing entry but failed to do so.
- 2018 Ohio 4988State v. Jenkins (2018)
Appellant's challenge to the victim's credibility failed to support reversal of his conviction of felonious assault on manifest weight or sufficiency of the evidence grounds. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4990State v. Young (2018)
Trial court did not plainly err by accepting appellant's guilty plea to failure-to-notify under R.C. 2950.05(F)(1) using prior juvenile adjudication as basis for duty to notify did not obviously violate due process.
- 2018 Ohio 4993State v. Burk (2018)
Appellant's conviction for Overtaking and Passing on the Right was based on sufficient evidence and was not against the weight of the evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4995State v. Merritt (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW/CRIMINAL – SEX OFFENSES – PLEAS : Defendant's sole assignment of error, which alleges that his guilty pleas were not knowing, intelligent, and voluntary because the trial court did not inform him prior to accepting his pleas that as a Tier III sex offender he would be subject to community notification and residency restrictions, must be overruled where defendant's Tier III classification was not included in the judgment of conviction and sentence: where defendant's Tier III classification was not included in the judgment of conviction and sentence, he is not subject to community notification and residency restrictions, because those sanctions were never imposed therefore, the appellate court cannot decide and defendant cannot show that his guilty pleas were not knowing, intelligent, and voluntary on the basis that he was not informed about community notification and residency restrictions. [But see DISSENT: Defendant's appeal must be dismissed, because no actual controversy exists: because defendant's Tier III sex-offender classification was not included in the judgment of conviction and sentence, there is no order in place requiring him to register as a sex offender, and the community-notification provisions and the residency restrictions have not attached therefore, the sanctions of which defendant claims he was not properly informed have not been imposed, and the appellate court cannot grant relief based on unimposed sanctions.]
- 2018 Ohio 4996State v. Crim (2018)
The trial court's imposition of consecutive service – in particular, the proportionality finding – was not clearly and convincingly not supported by the record. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4997State v. Kennedy (2018)
Appellant's conviction for one count of improperly handling a firearm in a motor vehicle and two counts of improperly discharging a firearm at or into a habitation, with two firearm specifications, was supported by sufficient evidence and was not against the manifest weight of the evidence. The aforementioned offenses and firearm specifications were not subject to merger at sentencing, and the trial court's imposition of consecutive, non-minimum sentences was proper. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4998State v. Luster (2018)
Trial counsel did not render ineffective assistance of counsel by failing to file either a motion to exclude evidence pertaining to a firearm specification or a motion to dismiss the firearm specification. Appellant pled guilty, and in such situations, the right to claim ineffective assistance of counsel is waived, other than defects that caused the plea to be less than knowing and voluntary. There is no evidence in the record which demonstrates that Appellant's guilty plea was not knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily made. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 4999State v. Milton (2018)
On appeal, following her no-contest plea to tampering with records (kept by governmental entity), defendant challenges the trial court's denial of her motion to dismiss the indictment on statute of limitations grounds. The stipulated facts presented at the hearing on the motion established that the offense occurred in 2008, the corpus delicti was discovered by defendant's probation officer in 2009, and defendant was indicted in 2016, beyond the six-year statute of limitations for the offense. The trial court's finding that the BMV learned about the fraudulent driver's license on September 15, 2015 was not supported by the record that fact, although agreed upon by the parties on appeal, cannot be considered when reviewing the trial court's decision. The one-year extension provided by R.C. 2901.13(B)(1) was not applicable. Judgment reversed and defendant's conviction vacated.
- 2018 Ohio 5000State v. Shern (2018)
The trial court did not err in failing suppress evidence that was obtained during Appellant's encounter with police. Appellant was not unlawfully detained during the encounter and was subject to a lawful pat-down search that was based on a reasonable, articulable belief that Appellant was armed and dangerous. The subsequent search of Appellant's vehicle was also lawful because the investigating officers had probable cause to believe the vehicle contained contraband. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 5001State v. Weirauch (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying the appellant's application to seal his criminal record pursuant to R.C. 2953.32. The trial court engaged in a sound reasoning process when it determined that the appellant's interests in having his record sealed were outweighed by a legitimate governmental need to maintain the record. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 5002State v. Hertel (2018)
Denial of motion for writ of habeas corpus
- 2018 Ohio 5003State v. Graham (2018)
Trial court lacked subject-matter jurisdiction to conduct a bench trial from which appellant was convicted of burglary. Judgment reversed. Burglary, serious offense, jury trial, effective waiver, knowingly, intelligently, voluntarily, in writing, signed by the defendant, filed, made part of the record, made in open court, consent, de novo, plain error
- 2018 Ohio 5004State v. Hill (2018)
Appellant's claims that could have been raised on direct appeal and that have been previously raised and rejected by this court are barred by res judicata and are without merit. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 5005In re L.S. (2018)
R.C. 2152.83(A)(1) does not require a juvenile court to hold a juvenile sex offender classification hearing upon the court's termination of the juvenile's commitment to JRCNO and imposition of the suspended commitment to DYS because the juvenile was not "released" from custody.
- 2018 Ohio 5006In re R.N. (2018)
Where the state put forth credible evidence to support every element of attempted murder and aggravated robbery charges, the juvenile court's probable cause finding and mandatory transfer of case to the general division for criminal prosecution was proper. Victim's testimony, that juvenile shot him five times and demanded his belongings, established more than a mere suspicion of guilt.
- 2018 Ohio 5008Ozdemir v. Boldt (2018)
R.C. 5321.17(B) R.C. 5321.06 liquidated damages must have some relation to actual damages unlawful penalty lease.
- 2018 Ohio 5009State v. Lu (2018)
Trial court did not err in relying on video evidence to grant appellee's motion to suppress based on an unconstitutional traffic stop where the video showed that, rather than driving too slowly in the center lane, appellee was travelling at the prevailing rate of speed and was passing vehicles in the right lane.
- 2018 Ohio 5010In re S Children (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 5013Krouse v. Ohio State Univ. (2018)
Core Terms: Core Terms: public record court of claims R.C. 2743.75 R.C. 149.43 grand jury Crim.R. 6(E) FERPA, 34 CFR 99.3. Overview: Requester sought a grand jury subpoena, and documents submitted in response, from respondent university. Respondent claimed the records were excepted in their entirety by Crim.R. 6(E) and the Family Education Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA). The special master found that the terms of Crim.R. 6(E) do not bar witnesses from disclosing subpoenas they receive or documents filed in response. The special master further found that because the request was made by a person who knew the identity of the student to whom the records related, disclosure of the withheld education records was excepted by 34 CFR 99.3 Personally Identifiable Information, subsection (g). Neither party filed objections. Outcome: The court found no error of law or other defect on the face of the special master's decision and adopted the report and recommendation as its own.
- 2018 Ohio 5016Kanter v. Cleveland Hts. (2018)
Core Terms: public record court of claims R.C. 2743.75 R.C. 149.43 ambiguous overly broad embedded moot. Overview: Requester sought all communications, schedules, logs and other documents shared between respondent City and a media organization regarding the requester over a period of five weeks. The City objected to the request as ambiguous and overly broad, but provided some information and invited revision. The special master found that the City provided responsive records to a specific request embedded within the request, and that the remainder of the request was properly denied as ambiguous and overly broad. Neither party filed objections. Outcome: The court found no error of law or other defect on the face of the special master's decision and adopted the report and recommendation as its own.
- 2018 Ohio 5018State v. Fisher (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 5020State v. Smith (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 5021State v. Mack (2018)
manifest weight of the evidence merger allied offenses of similar import ineffective assistance of counsel waiver of court costs R.C. 2947.23(C)
- 2018 Ohio 5023Satterfield v. Ameritech Mobile Communications, Inc. (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Damages—Class actions—Attempted recovery under R.C. 4905.61 of treble damages from public utility based on prior order of the Public Utilities Commission—R.C. 4905.61 limits recovery of treble damages to the "person, firm, or corporation" directly injured as a result of the "violation, failure, or omission" found by the Public Utilities Commission.
- 2018 Ohio 5024Girard v. Giordano (Slip Opinion) (2018)
R.C. 2937.07—Double-jeopardy principles not violated by a second attempt at conviction following a reversal of a conviction for a court's failure to comply with R.C. 2937.07's explanation-of-circumstances requirement.
- 2018 Ohio 5025Disciplinary Counsel v. Deters. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Multiple violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct—Respondent's law license indefinitely suspended.
- 2018 Ohio 5026State v. George (2018)
App.R. 26(B) application to reopen, ineffective assistance of appellate counsel, timeliness, and transcript. Pursuant to App.R. 26(B), this court denied the application to reopen as untimely. Lack of transcript and ineffective assistance of appellate counsel do not state good cause for filing late.
- 2018 Ohio 5027State Ex Rel. Essi v. City of Lakewood, Ohio (2018)
R.C. 149.43 public records mandamus in camera inspection client-counsel privilege work-product privilege private matters massive, broad public records request municipal hospital sale and disclosure of over 27,000 pages of records. In response to a massive, broad public records request concerning the sale of a municipal hospital, the municipality released over 27,000 pages of records and submitted some of those for in camera inspection. After reviewing all the materials, the court concluded that the municipality had fulfilled its duties under R.C. 149.43. The court conducted the in camera inspection and generally upheld the redactions under the client-counsel and work-product privileges and the private matters/unrelated to governmental functions exemption.
- 2018 Ohio 5028City of Brookpark v. Rodojev (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 5029State v. Johnson (2018)
Crim.R. 11 guilty plea R.C. 2950.11 sex offender classification sex offender registration duties. The trial court substantially complied with Crim.R. 11 because it sufficiently articulated to appellant his duties as a Tier III sex offender and, therefore, his plea of guilty was knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily made.
- 2018 Ohio 5031State v. Hernandez (2018)
Forfeiture of error failure to object ineffective assistance of counsel bolstering gross sexual imposition.
- 2018 Ohio 5032ALSOL, Inc. v. Barbolovici (2018)
Civ.R. 11 R.C. 2323.51 sanctions. Party's attempt to void a sheriff's sale and enforce the terms of a lease with prior owner of property was not so frivolous that the court abused its discretion by refusing to award sanctions.
- 2018 Ohio 5033State v. James (2018)
Motion to suppress Terry stop reasonable suspicion. The trial court did not err in granting a motion to suppress evidence obtained during an investigatory stop of a legally parked vehicle. In evaluating whether reasonable suspicion of criminal activity existed to support the stop, the trial court heard testimony from the officer, who initiated the stop. The trial court found that a single overdose at a house down the street did not support the officer's testimony that the car was parked in a known drug area.
- 2018 Ohio 5034State v. Gibson (2018)
R.C. 2929.13 R.C. 2953.08 not subject to appellate review mandatory community control firearm. Because the trial court found that the appellant's offense was committed with a firearm on or about his person or under his control, pursuant to R.C. 2929.13(B)(1)(b)(i), appellant's sentence is not subject to appellate review.
- 2018 Ohio 5035In re M.P. (2018)
Serious youthful offender (SYO), R.C. 2152.14(E), consecutive sentences, ineffective assistance of counsel. Trial court erred in finding that Appellant was serving "the juvenile portion of a serious youthful offender dispositional sentence" at the time the state filed its motion to impose the adult portion of his SYO sentence. Appellant had been sentenced in two separate juvenile cases and the trial court ordered the two resulting sentences to be served consecutively. One of the cases had an SYO sentence and the other did not. At the time the state sought to impose appellant's adult sentence, he was serving the non-SYO juvenile sentence and, therefore, did not qualify for imposition of his adult term under R.C. 2152.14(E). Appellant's counsel provided ineffective assistance by offering a stipulation under R.C. 2152.14(E) to appellant's prejudice.
- 2018 Ohio 5036State v. Robinson (2018)
Waiver of counsel knowingly, voluntarily, intelligently sufficient inquiry nature of the charges defenses and mitigating circumstances standby counsel. Trial court did not make sufficient inquiry to determine if the defendant understood and knowingly waived his right to counsel where the court did not adequately explain the nature of the charges to the defendant, and did not discuss with him any possible defenses and mitigating circumstances. The trial court also erroneously advised the defendant that he could not ask questions of appointed standby counsel. Thus, the defendant's waiver of counsel was not knowingly, voluntarily, and intelligently made.
- 2018 Ohio 5038State v. Middleton (2018)
Jail-time credit R.C. 2929.19(B)(2)(f)(I) domestic violence R.C. 2919.25(A) manifest weight credibility. Appellant was not sentenced to a prison term and he did not file a motion for calculation of jail-time credit in the trial court. Therefore, appellant was not entitled to a calculation of jail-time credit. Appellant's conviction for domestic violence was not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 5046State v. Lytle (2018)
Appellant's conviction for aggravated menacing was supported by sufficient evidence and was not against the manifest weight of the evidence where the victim testified that appellant threatened him by placing an aluminum baseball bat and demanding that he leave the scene.
- 2018 Ohio 5047In re M.R. (2018)
Juvenile court did not err in granting permanent custody where its best interest findings were supported by clear and convincing evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 5048In re L.H. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 5049In re J.B. (2018)
The juvenile court did not err by granting permanent custody of two of appellant's children to a children's services agency where the children had been in the temporary custody of the agency for 12 months of a consecutive 22-month period and where the children's best interest were served by granting permanent custody to the children services agency due to the uncertainty surrounding appellant's income, housing, and mental health issues.
- 2018 Ohio 5050State v. Chambers (2018)
Right to compulsory process, Evid.R. 901(A), foundation, abuse of discretion, motion for continuance, scope of cross-examination
- 2018 Ohio 5051State v. Harding (2018)
Appeal of the denial of a postconviction relief petition without a hearing dismissed for lack of a final appealable order.
- 2018 Ohio 5052McConnell v. Jordan (2018)
summary judgment, de novo review, breach of contract
- 2018 Ohio 5053State v. Narayan (2018)
Appellant's conviction was supported by sufficient evidence where the trooper who ticketed appellant testified at trial that appellant was driving over the legal speed limit.
- 2018 Ohio 5055State v. Watkins (2018)
Defendant-appellant's claim of ineffective assistance of counsel is without merit. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 5056Bates Recycling, Inc. v. Conaway (2018)
The doctrine of lis pendens applies to property that is the subject of a pending action. Lis pendens is not applicable when the suit is for money damages and the disputed property is merely a source of funds to satisfy a judgment for damages.
- 2018 Ohio 5057State v. Finfrock (2018)
Trial court did not err by failing to sua sponte order a competency evaluation. Appellant did not establish ineffective assistance of counsel. Sufficient evidence presented to support conviction for theft, and theft convictions supported by the weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 5061State v. Marr (2018)
Trial court's determination that defendant's letter substantially complied with R.C. 2963.30 is affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 5062State v. Keller (2018)
Defendant-Appellant's trial counsel was not ineffective by failing to request a pre-sentence investigation. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 5063In re Adoption of B.G.F. (2018)
The trial court did not err in finding that natural father's consent to step-father's adoption petition was not required under R.C. 3107.07(A).
- 2018 Ohio 5064State v. Wolford-Lee (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - cruelty against companion animals failure to preserve potentially useful information bad faith showing required motion in limine proffer or evidence required in context of trial to demonstrate prejudice no plain error no abuse of discretion in failing to allow cat videos that were not identified in advance of trial consistent with court's scheduling order.
- 2018 Ohio 5065State v. Talley (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - robbery pleas of guilty ineffective assistance of counsel unsupported allegations deadly weapon plea knowing, voluntary, intelligent felony sentence consecutive findings supported by the record.
- 2018 Ohio 5066State v. Rowe (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - rape and gross sexual imposition offenses supported by sufficient evidence and not against the manifest weight.
- 2018 Ohio 5067State v. Anderson (2018)
CRIMINAL - felony sentencing R.C. 2953.08(G) jail time credit R.C. 2929.19(B)(2)(f)(i)
- 2018 Ohio 5068State v. Velazquez (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - endangering children three-month old traumatic brain injury toddler fell recklessly duty of care while caregiver supported by the weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 5069State v. Hughes (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - search and seizure search of motel room based on arrest warrant but no search warrant Miranda rights mistaken identity consent to search drug paraphernalia in plain view acquiescence to show of authority.
- 2018 Ohio 5071Jones v. Natural Essentials, Inc. (2018)
CIVIL - sanctions Civ.R. 37(D) failure to appear at depositions notice of videotaped depositions discovery sanctions invoice authentication affidavit frivolous conduct R.C. 2323.51 Civ.R. 11 bad faith abuse of discretion attorney's fees hearing itemized notion of billing competent, credible evidence
- 2018 Ohio 5072In re N.M.P. (2018)
JUVENILE - termination of parental rights permanent custody best interest of the child clear and convincing evidence R.C. 2151.414(D) the wishes of the child guardian ad litem is authorized to give testimony regarding the child's wishes R.C. 2151.414(B)(1)(d) 12 in 22 months judicial notice submission of evidence due process.
- 2018 Ohio 5073State v. Hardy (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - App.R. 4(A) thirty-day rule untimely appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 5076Accettola v. Big Sky Energy (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 5079State v. Braden (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Criminal law—Sentencing—R.C. 2947.23—R.C. 2947.23(C) does not authorize a trial court to waive, modify, or suspend payment of court costs imposed prior to March 22, 2013, the effective date of R.C. 2947.23(C)—For sentences entered prior to March 22, 2013, an offender may seek waiver of costs only at sentencing, trial court lacks jurisdiction to reconsider its own final order, and res judicata bars any subsequent collateral attack on that order in either trial or appellate court—Court of appeals' judgment affirming trial court's denial of motion for waiver of costs affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 5080Disciplinary Counsel v. Owens. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct, including engaging in conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation and engaging in conduct prejudicial to the administration of justice—Conditionally stayed one-year suspension.
- 2018 Ohio 5082State ex rel. Technical Constr. Specialties, Inc. v. DeWeese (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Mandamus—Prohibition—Writs denied—Trial court judge authorized in exercise of jurisdiction—No final, appealable order and no clear legal right to relief—Court of appeals' judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 5083Disciplinary Counsel v. Ward. (2018)
Unauthorized practice of law—Preparing and filing legal pleadings in two court proceedings—Injunction issued and civil penalty imposed.
- 2018 Ohio 5084Ohio State Bar Association v. Cohen. (2018)
Unauthorized practice of law—Drafting, signing, and litigating civil actions for eviction and related claims—Consent decree approved—No civil penalty imposed.
- 2018 Ohio 5086State ex rel. Byington Builders, Ltd. v. Indus. Comm. (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Workers' compensation—Violation of specific safety requirement—Industrial Commission did not abuse its discretion in granting additional award—Record contained evidence supporting commission's finding that specific safety requirement applied, that employer violated it, and that violation was proximate cause of injury—Court of appeals' judgment denying of writ of mandamus affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 5087BANK OF NEW YORK MELLON v. RHIEL, Trustee. (2018)
Certified questions of state law—The failure to identify a signatory by name in the body of a mortgage agreement does not render the agreement unenforceable again that signatory—A person who is not identified in the body of a mortgage but who signed and initialed the mortgage mortgages his interest in the property when the mortgage as a whole evinces an intent to be bound by the signature.
- 2018 Ohio 5088STOLZ v. J & B STEEL ERECTORS, INC., Et Al. (2018)
Workers' compensation—Immunity from tort claims—Self-insured construction projects—R.C. 4123.35(O)—R.C. 4123.35(O)'s grant of immunity to subcontractors enrolled in a contractor's self-insurance plan from claims by employees of another enrolled subcontractor does not violate right-to-remedy, right-to-jury, or equal-protection provisions of Ohio Constitution.
- 2018 Ohio 5089State ex rel. Evans v. Mohr (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Mandamus—Writ will not issue to compel act already performed—Court of appeals' dismissal of complaint affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 5090Disciplinary Counsel v. Leon. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Violations of professional-conduct rules, including failing to perform contracted legal work and engaging in a sexual relationship with a client–One-year suspension, with 6 months stayed on conditions.
- 2018 Ohio 5091Disciplinary Counsel v. Oviatt. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct and the Rules for the Government of the Bar—Conditionally stayed six-month suspension.
- 2018 Ohio 5093Akron Bar Association v. Parkin. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct, including failing to inform clients the lawyer does not maintain professional-liability insurance, failing to act with reasonable diligence in representing clients, and engaging in conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation—Two-year suspension.
- 2018 Ohio 5094Wood County Bar Association v. Driftmyer. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct, including failing to act with reasonable diligence in representing a client, failing to inform a client that the lawyer does not maintain professional-liability insurance, and failing to respond to a demand for information from a disciplinary authority—Six-month suspension stayed on conditions.
- 2018 Ohio 5095Erie-Huron County Bar Association v. Zelvy. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct—Conditionally stayed six-month suspension.
- 2018 Ohio 5096Disciplinary Counsel v. Pigott. (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct, including failing to obtain clients' written consent to contingent-fee agreements, failing to promptly deliver funds to clients, and engaging in conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation—Six-month suspension.
- 2018 Ohio 5099Rubino Constr., Inc. v. Dept. of Job & Family Servs. (2018)
The common pleas court did not abuse its discretion when it found the decision of UCRC was supported by reliable, probative, and substantial evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 5101Bur. of Motor Vehicle Repair v. Griffin (2018)
Trial court did not err when it granted summary judgment.
- 2018 Ohio 5102Gallick v. Franklin Cty. Bd of Revision (2018)
BTA did not err in affirming BOR's dismissal of appellant's complaints, on jurisdictional grounds, challenging the valuation for two parcels of real estate.
- 2018 Ohio 5103State v. Sieng (2018)
Trial court did not err in denying appellant's motion to suppress the cocaine and firearm uncovered in the warrantless search of his home because appellant told police he had a firearm at his home and voluntarily consented to a search of his home in the course of a lawful traffic stop. Miranda warnings were not required because appellant's admissions regarding the firearm were not the result of a custodial interrogation. Appellant's convictions for possession of cocaine with a firearm specification and having a weapon while on disability were supported by sufficient evidence and not against the manifest weight of the evidence where appellant admitted ownership of the firearm and cocaine found in the search of his home. The jury was not required to believe appellant's testimony that the cocaine and firearm were planted by another individual. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 5104Sudberry v. Dept. of Rehab. & Corr. (2018)
Grant of motion to dismiss affirmed appellant's complaint fails to state a claim or raises claims over which the Court of Claims lacks jurisdiction.
- 2018 Ohio 5105Columbus v. Kotevski (2018)
Trial court did not err in rejecting appellant's constitutional challenge to C.C.C. 2131.12.
- 2018 Ohio 5107State v. Floyd (2018)
EXPUNGEMENT: Where defendant was on community control for a separate misdemeanor conviction, she was not subject to pending criminal proceedings and therefore, the trial court erred in overruling her R.C. 2953.52 motion to seal the records in three other criminal cases in which the complaints against her had been dismissed. State v. Blair, 2016-Ohio-5714, 62 N.E.3d 201 (1st Dist.), overruled. [But see DISSENT: Blair was not clearly wrongly decided, and therefore, it should not be overruled. Where the court in the separate misdemeanor case retains jurisdiction over defendant for the duration of her community-control sanction, pursuant to R.C. 2929.25(C), and over the suspended jail term on the separate conviction, pursuant to R.C. 2929.24(H), the misdemeanor case is a pending criminal proceeding.]
- 2018 Ohio 5113B.T. Environmental Solutions, L.L.C. v. B.T. Energy Group, Inc. (2018)
Shareholders' derivative action standing R.C. 1705.01(G) R.C. 1705.14(B) promissory estoppel.
- 2018 Ohio 5114State v. Grove (2018)
guilty plea to OVI trial court failed to properly advise appellant of the effect of his plea Traf.R. 10
- 2018 Ohio 5115Neuhart v. Transatlantic Energy Corp. (2018)
App.R. 26 application for partial reconsideration application for reconsideration.
- 2018 Ohio 5117State v. Messer (2018)
Theft, Crim.R. 29, sufficiency of the evidence, manifest weight of the evidence
- 2018 Ohio 5118Schutte v. DiCello (2018)
legal malpractice, statute of limitations, termination date, cognizable event, fraud, separate claims
- 2018 Ohio 5120State v. Sparks (2018)
petition for postconviction relief, successive petitions, R.C. 2953.23(A)(1)
- 2018 Ohio 5121State v. Smith (2018)
Manifest weight sufficiency
- 2018 Ohio 5124State v. Henderson (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 5125State v. Savage (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 5126State v. Dennison (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 5129State v. Sykes (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 5131State ex rel. Murray v. State Emp. Relations Bd. (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Mandamus—Public employees—State Employment Relations Board did not abuse its discretion when it dismissed appellant's unfair-labor-practice charges as untimely—Court of appeals' denial of writ affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 5132State v. Bishop (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Criminal law—Plea hearings—Crim.R. 11(C)(2)(A)—A trial court must advise a criminal defendant on postrelease control for a prior felony, during plea hearing in a new felony case, of trial court's authority under R.C. 2929.141 to terminate defendant's existing postrelease control and to impose a consecutive prison sentence for postrelease-control violation—Defendant-appellee need not show prejudice because trial court completely failed to inform him that he could receive a consecutive prison sentence under R.C. 2929.141(A)—Court of appeals' judgment vacating guilty plea and remanding cause affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 5133State Ex Rel. Hogan Lovells U.S., L.L.P. v. Department of Rehabilitation and Correction (2018)
Mandamus—Public-records law—Confidentiality of records that identify or could reasonably lead to the identification of any person participating in any of several activities related to drugs for lethal injections under R.C. 2949.221—Writ granted in part and denied in part—Attorney fees and court costs awarded.
- 2018 Ohio 5135State ex rel. Washington v. D'Apolito (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Mandamus—Standards for granting motion to dismiss under Civ.R. 12(B)(6)—Dismissal of mandamus complaint is warranted only when the relator can prove no set of facts entitling him or her to relief—Court of appeals' dismissal of petition reversed and cause remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 5136Barclay Petroleum, Inc. v. Bailey (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Appeal dismissed as having been improvidently accepted.
- 2018 Ohio 5138Bresler v. Rock (2018)
Trial court did not err in providing jury instruction requested by appellees, nor did court err in ruling on appellant's request to pursue a claim for retaliation in age discrimination action.
- 2018 Ohio 5140State v. Stevenson (2018)
The trial court did not commit plain error in its instruction to the jury. The evidence did not support an instruction for voluntary manslaughter. The self-defense instruction accurately reflected Ohio law. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 5143State v. Tatom (2018)
Trial court did not commit plain error by applying current sentencing law instead of the law in effect at the time the offense occurred. Application of amended statute to appellant was not an ex post facto violation trial court did not err by retaining jurisdiction. Appellant failed to demonstrate he received ineffective assistance of counsel because there was not a reasonable probability the result of the trial would have been different but for counsel's failure to raise the issues.
- 2018 Ohio 5144Dublin v. Willms (2018)
Appellant's appeal of the trial court's entry ordering work-release as a condition of probation is moot.
- 2018 Ohio 5145State v. Quintero (2018)
The trial court did not err when it denied appellant's motion to suppress. The trial court's findings of fact regarding the credibility of the officers and the trash pulls were supported by the evidence. The evidence presented at the suppression hearing also supported the trial court's findings that appellant was advised of his Miranda rights and that he voluntarily provided a statement. Appellant failed to establish that defense counsel provided ineffective assistance of counsel at sentencing. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 5146State v. Abdullahi (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in its evidentiary rulings, the sufficiency and manifest weight of the evidence supports Abdullahi's convictions, the trial court did not err in failing to merge his convictions for rape and kidnapping, and Abdullahi did not receive the ineffective assistance of counsel.
- 2018 Ohio 5148State v. Frank (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 5150State v. Gordon (2018)
App.R. 26(B) application to reopen Murnahan ineffective assistance of appellate counsel R.C. 2929.14(B)(1)(b) and (B)(1)(g) consecutive sentences for firearm specifications jail-time credit R.C. 2929.19(B)(2)(f) continuing jurisdiction to correct jail-time credit errors prejudice to appellant and disqualification of retained counsel. The court denied the applicant's App.R. 26(B) application to reopen. Applicant relied on a former and superseded provision of the Revised Code that prohibited consecutive sentences for firearm specifications. The trial court properly imposed sentence pursuant to R.C. 2929.14(B)(1)(g). Applicant suffered no prejudice in trial court's failure to award jail-time credit, because R.C. 2929.19(B)(2)(f) grants the court continuing jurisdiction to correct such errors. The Supreme Court of Ohio determined that the trial court had properly disqualified retained counsel.
- 2018 Ohio 5151State v. Johnson (2018)
Ineffective assistance of counsel App.R. 26(B) application to reopen good cause and timeliness. The court denied the App.R. 26(B) application to reopen as untimely miscalculation of the time needed for mailing is not good cause.
- 2018 Ohio 5152State v. Hardman (2018)
App.R. 26(B) application for reopening, timely filed application, ineffective assistance of counsel, failure of state to provide discovery, failure of state to authenticate records, judicial bias during trial. The applicant's App.R. 26(B) application for reopening is denied. The applicant has raised three proposed assignments of error in support of his application for reopening. Our review of the applicant's proposed assignments of error fails to disclose the existence of any ineffective assistance of appellate counsel and the applicant has also failed to establish how he was prejudiced by the failure of appellate of appellate counsel to raise any of the three proposed assignments or error on appeal. Appellate counsel is not required to argue on appeal assignments of error that are meritless.
- 2018 Ohio 5153State v. Jenkins (2018)
App.R. 26(B) application for reopening, timely filed, ineffective assistance of appellate counsel, prosecutorial misconduct during closing arguments, defective arrest warrant, defective indictment, facts not appearing in the trial court record cannot support application for reopening, in-court identification, res judicata. The applicant's App.R. 26(B) application for reopening is denied. The applicant has raised four proposed assignments of error in support of his application for reopening. Our review of the applicant's proposed assignments of error fails to disclose the existence of any ineffective assistance of appellate counsel and the applicant has also failed to establish how he was prejudiced by the failure of appellate counsel to raise any of the three proposed assignments or error on appeal. Appellate counsel is not required to argue on appeal assignments of error that are meritless.
- 2018 Ohio 5154State v. Lester (2018)
App.R. 26(B) application for reopening, timely filed, ineffective assistance of appellate counsel, App.R. 26(B)(2)(d) sworn statement, Civ.R. 11 signature requirement, application for reopening is a civil, postconviction proceeding, res judicata. The appellant's App.R. 26(B) application for reopening is procedurally defective. The application fails to comply with App.R. 26(B)(2)(d), which requires a sworn statement of the basis of the claim that appellate counsel's representation was deficient with respect to the proposed assignments of error raised pursuant to App.R. 26(B)(2)(c) and the manner in which the claimed deficiency prejudicially affected the outcome of the appeal. In addition, because an application for reopening is a civil, postconviction proceeding, the appellant was required to sign the application per Civ.R. 11. Finally, all issues raised by the appellant in his application for reopening were previously raised and addressed on appeal and found to be without merit. The doctrine of res judicata prevents relitigation of the issues presented in the application for reopening.
- 2018 Ohio 5155State v. Henderson (2018)
Jail-time credit R.C. 5145.01 R.C. 2967.191. The trial court incorrectly calculated the defendant's jail-time credit. The judgment is reversed for the trial court to issue a new judgment reflecting the proper amount of jail-time credit. The trial court had jurisdiction, however, to resentence the defendant to impose the proper sentence for murder because the original sentence was contrary to law. Further, the trial court could correct defendant's improper sentence because it was not void under R.C. 5145.01.
- 2018 Ohio 5157State v. Alvarado (2018)
Appellant, who was convicted of OVI, had prior OVI convictions, and for purposes of avoiding a penalty enhancement, she failed to make a prima facie showing that a previous OVI conviction in the municipal court was uncounseled. In the underlying municipal court case, Appellant initially received diversion, and in her conditional plea form she certified with her initials the accuracy of a statement indicating that she was represented by counsel and satisfied with counsel's representation. The municipal court's "Docket/Journal Entry" further identifies counsel for Appellant. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 5158Greater Dayton Regional Transit Auth. v. Amalgamated Transit Union AFL CIO Local 1385 (2018)
The trial court did not err by denying appellant's motion to vacate an arbitration award or by granting appellee's application to confirm the award. The arbitrator's interpretation of procedural rules, interpretation of the parties' collective bargaining agreement, and interpretation of Ohio law were all within the scope of his powers. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 5160State v. Howard (2018)
Defendant pled guilty in municipal court to violating a protection order, a first-degree misdemeanor. Trial court did not err in failing to schedule a jury trial defendant waived this claim by pleading guilty and by failing to timely request a jury trial pursuant to Crim.R. 23. Defendant's plea was made knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily. No ineffective assistance of counsel demonstrated. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 5161State v. Hurt (2018)
Based on this court's prior decision in State v. Hurt, 2d Dist. Miami No. 16-CA-11, 2017-Ohio-5495, concerning appellant's 2016 plea-withdrawal motion, the trial court correctly determined that the appellant's second plea-withdrawal motion in 2018 was barred by res judicata. The court also did not err in finding, as we also affirmed in a prior appeal, that a declaratory judgment action, rather than a plea withdrawal motion, is the proper vehicle for the appellant to seek relief regarding the constitutionality of application of new or different parole procedures to his sentence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 5162Montgomery Cty. Treasurer v. Islamic Ctr. of Peace (2018)
The trial court did not enter a final and appealable judgment of foreclosure. The court failed to determine the priority of the liens on the property and the amount of one of the liens. Appeal dismissed.
- 2018 Ohio 5163State v. Long (2018)
After his convictions were reversed on direct appeal and his case remanded for further proceedings, the defendant pleaded no contest to two, third-degree felony charges. Following remand, the subsequent delay of 11 months between the trial court's ruling on the defendant's first motion to dismiss, and the entry of the defendant's pleas, did not violate the defendant's constitutional right to a speedy trial. Therefore, the trial court did not abuse its discretion by refusing to dismiss the indictment against the defendant. Judgment affirmed. (Froelich, J., dissenting.)
- 2018 Ohio 5164State v. Shorter (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in overruling Appellant's post-sentence motion to withdraw his guilty plea where Appellant failed to demonstrate that a manifest injustice warranted the withdrawal of his guilty plea and provided no legitimate explanation for the nine-year delay in filing his motion. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 5166State v. Wilson (2018)
Appellant did not satisfy the requirements for post-conviction DNA testing
- 2018 Ohio 5167State v. Wilson (2018)
Trial court did not abuse discretion by denying PCR petition without a hearing.
- 2018 Ohio 5168State v. Snyder (2018)
Denial of motion to withdraw plea
- 2018 Ohio 5169State v. Ford (2018)
Rape kidnapping gross sexual imposition sexually violent predator aggravated robbery aggravated burglary robbery ineffective assistance of counsel motion to suppress joinder severance photo identification Evid.R. 404(B) other acts mistrial. Trial counsel's failure to file a motion to suppress and failure to request separate trials did not amount to ineffective assistance of counsel. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in admitting 404(B) evidence. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in failing to declare a mistrial as a result of several comments made by 404(B) witnesses.
- 2018 Ohio 5171Edvon v. Morales (2018)
Civ.R. 56 police officers immunity malicious prosecution probable cause aggravated menacing child endangering. Plaintiff's claim for malicious prosecution failed as a matter of law because probable cause existed to arrest and charge the plaintiff with aggravated menacing and child endangering. Accordingly, the police officer defendants were entitled to summary judgment on their individual immunity claims thus the trial court erred in denying the officers' motion for summary judgment in its entirety.
- 2018 Ohio 5172State v. Walker (2018)
Right to confrontation hearsay exception Evid.R. 803(2)/excited utterance R.C. 2923.03/complicity aiding and abetting instruction ineffective assistance of counsel sufficiency motion for acquittal manifest weight R.C. 2929.14(C)(4)/consecutive sentences. The witness's statements were determined to be nontestimonial and excited utterances and fell under the hearsay exception. Security videos and appellant's behavior before and after the crime established appellant's complicity to commit the crime. The trial court's aiding and abetting instruction to the jury was proper. Appellant failed to show that other evidence existed outside of what was presented at trial appellant's counsel zealously represented appellant both pretrial and during trial. Appellant's counsel's performance did not fall below an objective standard of reasonable representation. Appellant was shown to be an aider and abbetor and was complicit in the crime. The state provided sufficient evidence that appellant acted in concert with the shooters. Additionally, appellant failed to comply with the requirements for maintaining his CCW license. Sufficient evidence supported appellant's carrying a concealed weapon conviction. The jury, as trier of fact, was aware of the witness's criminal records, however, the jury found their testimony credible. Appellant's convictions were not against the manifest weight of the evidence. The trial court made the necessary sentencing findings for consecutive sentences and also corrected on the record its misstatement of the total number of years appellant must serve. Appellant's consecutive sentences are not contrary to law.
- 2018 Ohio 5174State v. Shivers (2018)
Rape R.C. 2907.02(A)(1)(c) substantial impairment knows or has reasonable cause to believe sufficiency voluntary intoxication prosecutorial misconduct closing argument gesture right to silence mistrial discovery violation sanction joinder simple and direct jury polling R.C. 2945.77 Crim.R. 31(D) abuse of discretion assent to the verdict pressure prior testimony entire transcript cross-examination. The state presented sufficient evidence that the victim was substantially impaired and the appellant knew or had reasonable cause to believe she was impaired. The evidence demonstrated the victim was extremely intoxicated and her intoxication was readily observed by all who encountered the victim on the night in question, including the appellant. The prosecutor's comment during closing argument when the appellant shook his head to indicate "no," under the circumstances, was not manifestly intended or was of such character that the jury would naturally and necessarily take it to be a comment on the appellant's failure to testify. Even if improper, the error was harmless in light of the overwhelming evidence of the appellant's guilt. The prosecutor's comment did not permeate the atmosphere of the entire trial such that it deprived the appellant of a fair trial. The trial court did not err in denying the appellant's motion for mistrial when it discovered that the victim made a prior statement and that statement was not disclosed by the state. The court engaged in a thorough inquiry into the circumstances, the appellant conceded the failure to disclose was not willful, the appellant conceded he had an opportunity to cross-examine the victim on the statement while she was still on the stand, and the trial court offered a less severe sanction of calling the victim back to the stand for recross-examination, and the trial court determined that the victim's statement contained no material inconsistencies. The trial court did not err when it denied the appellant's motion to sever. The evidence of each crime was simple and direct, the appellant presented no evidence of jury confusion, and the jury demonstrated that it considered each offense separately in finding the appellant guilty of substantial impairment rape of one victim and not guilty of gross sexual imposition by force or threat of force of another victim. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in not sending the jury back for further deliberations where the record demonstrated during jury polling that the juror followed the law in finding the appellant "guilty" and she assented to the verdict. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in allowing the state to submit the entire transcript of the victim's prior statement. We affirm the convictions.
- 2018 Ohio 5175State v. Krause (2018)
Jail-time credit, moot. An appeal of a jail time credit denial is moot where the defendant appellant has completed his prison sentence. The issue of jail time credit is moot once the sentence has been served because this issue relates only to the length of the sentence and not the underlying conviction.
- 2018 Ohio 5176In re B.H. (2018)
Juvenile court planned permanent living arrangement R.C. 2151.011 R.C. 2151.353 best interest of the child clear and convincing evidence. The juvenile court's granting of the agency's motion for a planned permanent living arrangement was supported by clear and convincing evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 5177In re Estate of Demsey (2018)
Civ.R. 41(B)(3) res judicata dismissal with prejudice adjudication on the merits. Prior involuntary dismissal with prejudice operated as an adjudication on the merits and was thus final, meaning that a party's attempt to make the same claim in a different proceeding is res judicata.
- 2018 Ohio 5178Morton v. Murray (2018)
Unjust enrichment R.C. 5715.22 overpayment of taxes directed verdict opening statement. Attorney could not seek reimbursement of unpaid legal fee against a client's overpayment of property taxes on a theory of unjust enrichment because R.C. 5715.22 provides that only the person who made the overpayment is entitled to the refund. Attorney had no claim of unjust enrichment against the purchaser of a tax lien because no taxes had been paid for the tax year in question that generated an overpayment and because the attorney failed to show that he and the persons who allegedly made the tax overpayment had an attorney-client relationship.
- 2018 Ohio 5179State v. Johnson (2018)
Sentence authorize by law consecutive sentences. Appellant's sentence is not contrary to law because the record does support the imposition of maximum and consecutive sentences. The trial court made the statutory findings required for consecutive sentences at the sentencing hearing and incorporated those findings into its sentencing journal entry.
- 2018 Ohio 5181State v. Hansard (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - aggravated robbery with a firearm specification telecommunications fraud bench trial Crim.R. 29(A) motion for acquittal sufficiency of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 5182Copeland v. Hiram Twp. (2018)
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEAL - nonconforming use R.C. 519.19 R.C. 2506.04 efforts to eradicate nonconforming uses limited to expansion and substantial alteration of existing uses.
- 2018 Ohio 5183State v. Smith (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - R.C. 2941.25 merger multiple felonious assault counts dissimilar import separate, identifiable harm for each count failure to notify defendant of post-release control at sentencing hearing notification of random drug testing not mandatory R.C. 2929.19(B)(2)(f).
- 2018 Ohio 5184Walters v. Goddard (2018)
CIVIL - BREACH OF CONTRACT - de novo review question of law plain language of the agreement read in its entirety buyers' failure to proffer signed amendment was breach precluding application of the null and void provision and resulting in ultimate failure of the agreement.
- 2018 Ohio 5185State v. Craciun (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - statutory immunity R.C. 2925.11(B)(2) qualified individual minor drug possession offense seek or obtain medical assistance overdose motion to dismiss no evidentiary hearing county court felony case Crim.R. 5 probable cause discharge bindover lack of jurisdiction to grant motion to dismiss.
- 2018 Ohio 5187State v. Yenyo (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - Signature on sentencing entry status of judicial officer magistrate or acting judge nothing in record verifying status appellate burden to establish error presumption of regularity vacation of entry by elected judge.
- 2018 Ohio 5188State v. Mullen (2018)
CRIMINAL - motion to suppress consensual encounter investigatory stop reasonable suspicion totality of the circumstances unlawful detention.
- 2018 Ohio 5194State ex rel. Daniels v. Russo (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Mandamus and procedendo—Trial court's entry denying appellant's motion for new sentencing entry was appealable under R.C. 2505.02(B)(1)—Appellant had adequate remedy in ordinary course of law in form of direct appeal from the entry—Court of appeals' judgment denying petition affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 5195In re Ang.O. (2018)
The trial court did not err in awarding permanent custody of appellant-father's child to the children services agency where father failed to have any contact with or support the child. Continuance incarcerated abandoned.
- 2018 Ohio 5196Wasserman, Bryan, Landry & Honold, L.L.P. v. Ergur (2018)
Motion to strike. Action for attorney fees. Counterclaims. Motion to continue trial date.
- 2018 Ohio 5197State v. Hicks (2018)
In appeal under Anders, sentence for burglary and felonious assault not contrary to law under R.C. 2953.08(G)(2)(b) where trial court imposed sentence within statutorily-permissible range, properly imposed post-release control, and considered R.C. 2929.11 and 2929.12. Review of record reveals no other issue of arguable merit.
- 2018 Ohio 5198Toledo v. McDuffey (2018)
The trial court abused its discretion by excluding appellant's witnesses, disclosed on the day of trial, without conducting an inquiry into the reason for the delay or considering less severe sanctions.
- 2018 Ohio 5199State v. Mincer (2018)
Guilty plea made knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily sentencing order complied with the law and sentencing findings are supported by the record no evidence in the record to support a claim of ineffective assistance of trial counsel.
- 2018 Ohio 5200State v. Triplett (2018)
Aggravated burglary, rape, merger, R.C. 2941.25, rape victim not only individual at risk, boyfriend, plain error, security guard
- 2018 Ohio 5201State v. Akers (2018)
Murder conviction is not against the manifest weight of the evidence where the state presented corroborating DNA evidence and testimony from defendant's fellow inmate to whom defendant confessed. Also, prosecutor's improper reference to a NGRI defense, that was not at issue in the case, was not prejudicial in light of overwhelming evidence of his guilt.
- 2018 Ohio 5202State v. Williams (2018)
Motion to suppress evidence should have been granted. Reasonable, articulable suspicion of criminal activity necessary to initiate investigative stop not shown where 9-1-1 caller reported merely that appellant was sitting in running car in gas station parking lot for over an hour.
- 2018 Ohio 5203Wood Cty. Health Dist. v. Bauer (2018)
Contempt proper without affording purchaser who fails to pay at hearing because R.C. 2329.30 does not mandate one be held. No standing or authority to challenge due process violations for other potentially interested parties.
- 2018 Ohio 5204State ex rel. Henley v. Langer (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Mandamus—Trial court's denial of appellant's motion for revised sentencing entry was appealable under R.C. 2505.02(B)(1)—Appellant had adequate remedy in ordinary course of law in form of direct appeal from denial of motion—Court of appeals' judgment denying complaint affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 5205State v. Tench (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Criminal law—Aggravated murder—Death sentence affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 5206In re Application of Black Fork Wind Energy, L.L.C. (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Power Siting Board—Motion to extend duration of siting certificate for wind-powered electric generating facility—Power Siting Board's extension of certificate constituted an "amendment" under R.C. 4906.06(E) and 4906.07(B)—Power Siting Board acted unlawfully in extending certificate by granting motion rather than following statutory procedures for amending a certificate—Orders reversed and cause remanded.
- 2018 Ohio 5207Great Lakes Bar Control, Inc. v. Testa (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation—Sales tax on "building maintenance and janitorial services" under R.C. 5739.01(B)(3)(j)—Appellee's beer-line service is not a "building maintenance and janitorial service" within meaning of R.C. 5739.01(II)—Board of Tax Appeals' decision reversing tax commissioner's assessment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 5208Yanega v. Cuyahoga Cty. Bd. of Revision (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Taxation—Jurisdiction to review a decision of the Board of Tax Appeals is dependent on the notice of appeal that is filed—Court lacks jurisdiction to consider errors not assigned in the notice of appeal—Board of Tax Appeals erred in reducing value on ground that it was applying a countywide blanket reduction—No evidence was presented showing that reduction was applied countywide.
- 2018 Ohio 5211State v. Cupp (Slip Opinion) (2018)
R.C. 2967.191—A defendant is not entitled to jail-time credit while held on bond if at the same time the defendant is serving a sentence on an unrelated case.
- 2018 Ohio 5212Disciplinary Counsel v. Karp (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Attorneys—Misconduct—Violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct—Two-year suspension, with 18 months stayed on conditions.
- 2018 Ohio 5213State v. Dunson (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Court of appeals' judgment reversed on authority of State v. Braden.
- 2018 Ohio 5214State v. Johnson (Slip Opinion) (2018)
Appeal dismissed as having been improvidently accepted.
- 2018 Ohio 5216State v. Riddle (2018)
Jury instruction regarding detention facility was not improper and trial court did not abuse its discretion permitting testimony regarding an arrest warrant being issued for defendant.
- 2018 Ohio 5218State v. Smale (2018)
The defendant-appellant's convictions are not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Further, the trial court did not abuse its discretion by admitting untimely provided discovery inot evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 5219State v. Leugers (2018)
Convictions for Rape of 10-year-old were not against the weight of the evidence where victim testified and there was some corroborating medical evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 5220State v. Norville (2018)
To be valid, a guilty plea must be knowingly, voluntarily, and intelligently entered. To ensure this, Crim.R. 11(C)(2) requires that trial courts notify defendants of various constitutional and nonconstitutional rights.
- 2018 Ohio 5223State v. Moore (2018)
motion to suppress – random license plate check – reasonable suspicion – reasonable expectation of privacy
- 2018 Ohio 5224State v. Robinson-Bey (2018)
RVO – weapon under disability – criminal record – harmless beyond a reasonable doubt – overwhelming evidence – sufficiency – juror unanimity – alternative means – lesser-included offense – negligent assault – unlawful restraint
- 2018 Ohio 5225State v. Singleton (2018)
sufficiency—robbery—force
- 2018 Ohio 5226State v. Crowell (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 5228State v. Anderson (2018)
Lesser included offense
- 2018 Ohio 5231Pincus v. Pincus (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 5234U.S. Bank Nat'l Ass'n v. Columbia Park E. MHP, L.L.C. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 5236Fireman's Fund Ins. Co. v. Hyster-Yale Grp., Inc. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 5240Sheil v. Horton (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 5242State v. Fannon (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 5242State v. Fannon (2018)
endangering children permitting child abuse R.C. 2903.15 R.C. 2919.22 joinder severance Crim.R. 14 failure to appear prosecutorial misconduct plain error Crim.R. 52(B) Bruton Rule confrontation clause testimonial statement guilty slide visual aids opening statement Evid.R. 404(B) other acts evidence Evid.R. 401 relevant evidence Evid.R. 403(A) Evid.R. 602 sufficiency of the evidence ineffective assistance of counsel merger allied offenses of similar import cumulative error doctrine jury instructions reasonable doubt
- 2018 Ohio 5243First State Bank v. K&B Indus. Supply, Inc. (2018)
motion for reconsideration. lien priorities, foreclosure action, interlocutory order, R.C. 2505.02(B)(1), final appealable order
- 2018 Ohio 5244State v. Kitchen (2018)
Final appealable order-denial of double-jeopardy motion to dismiss Final appealable order-denial of speedy-trial motion to dismiss Double Jeopardy-retrial following mistrial based on prosecutorial misconduct
- 2018 Ohio 5245State v. Lindsay (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 5246Banks v. Bur. of Workers' Comp. (2018)
The Court of Claims did not err in its determination that BWC was immune from liability under public duty doctrine and that no special relationship existed between BWC and appellant.
- 2018 Ohio 5248Champion Chrysler v. Dimension Serv. Corp. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 5248Parker v. Dimension Serv. Corp. (2018)
The trial court granted appellees' motion to confirm a final arbitration award and overruled appellant's motion to vacate the final arbitration award. We affirmed finding that appellant did not demonstrate evident partiality and the arbitration panel did not exceed its authority.
- 2018 Ohio 5249Thompson v. Winn (2018)
The trial court improperly granted appellees' motion for summary judgment because appellants demonstrated a genuine issue of material fact regarding whether a Lee's employee knowingly served alcohol to a noticeably intoxicated person.
- 2018 Ohio 5250State v. Lane (2018)
The trial court did not coerce appellant to withdraw his motion to withdraw by informing him that the maximum prison term he could face, 185 years, pursuant to jury trial and a finding of guilty was "substantially greater" than the maximum prison term he could face, 95 years, pursuant to the plea offer. The court was clear in stating the maximum prison terms pursuant to both alternatives and in informing Lane which potential prison terms were mandatory and in explaining that mandatory means that Lane would have to serve that prison term and there is no possibility that time would be reduced. The trial court's comparison and characterization of the difference between the sentences pursuant to both alternatives did not render appellant's pleas not knowing, intelligent and voluntary. Counsel did not perform deficiently and therefore was not ineffective. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 5251State v. Hawkins (2018)
The trial court did not err in not notifying appellant of post release control at sentencing because the offense date was prior to the enactment of postrelease control in Am.Sub.S.B. No. 2. Judgment denying appellant's motion to resentence is affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 5253State ex rel. McKibben v. Christensen Christensen Donchatz Kettlewell & Owen, L.L.P. (2018)
Relator's complaint seeking a writ of mandamus was dismissed sua sponte because it was duplicative of a pending appeal and named a private party as respondent.
- 2018 Ohio 5262State v. Delong (2018)
R.C. 4511.19(A)(1)(a), OVI, probable cause, reasonable suspicion, community caretaking function, Fourth Amendment, investigatory stop
- 2018 Ohio 5263State v. Diestler (2018)
aggravated murder – murder – felonious assault – conflict of interest – actual conflict – alternative defense theory – ineffective assistance of counsel – allocution
- 2018 Ohio 5264Estate of Henderson v. Henderson (2018)
summary judgment – reciprocal burden – self-serving affidavit
- 2018 Ohio 5266Cadle v. Kehl (2018)
new roof – fraudulent misrepresentation – manifest weight – small claims – residential property disclosure form
- 2018 Ohio 5267State v. Little (2018)
motion for new trial – newly discovered evidence – trial outcome – res judicata
- 2018 Ohio 5268Microdynamics Group, Inc. v. Equity Trust Co. (2018)
summary judgment—credibility—competing inferences—weighing evidence
- 2018 Ohio 5270Norman v. Tri-Arch, Inc. (2018)
summary judgment, negligence, slip and fall, open and obvious, Civ.R. 56
- 2018 Ohio 5272State v. Bush (2018)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion by overruling Appellant's motion, filed under Crim.R. 32.1, to withdraw his guilty pleas. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 5273State v. Gullatte (2018)
Defendant pled guilty to failure to comply with an order or signal of a police officer, and he received a 36-month prison sentence. Because defendant has challenged only the length of his prison sentence and that sentence has been completely served, there is no relief that we can provide him. Appeal dismissed as moot.
- 2018 Ohio 5274State v. Hazel (2018)
Appellant appeals from the trial court's denial of his demand to compel discovery. Whether the demand is considered as a petition seeking postconviction relief or simply as a motion to compel discovery, the trial court did not abuse its discretion by overruling the demand. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 5277In re T.D.H. (2018)
Juvenile's adjudications of delinquency based on rape and gross sexual imposition were not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 5278State v. Montgomery (2018)
The trial court, at appellant's sentencing hearing, did not mention post-release control, and the sentencing entry does not accurately state the duration of the mandatory post-release control. Therefore, this portion of Appellant's sentence was not properly imposed and is void. Since Appellant has completed his prison term, he cannot be resentenced. The trial court, accordingly, erred by overruling Appellant's motion to vacate post-release control. Judgment reversed, post-release control portion of Appellant's sentence vacated, and remanded for the trial court to notify the parole authority of the vacation of post-release control.
- 2018 Ohio 5279State v. Quinn (2018)
Defendant appeals from the trial court's denial, without a hearing, of his second motion for a new trial pursuant to Crim.R. 33(A)(6). All assignments of error related to Defendant's purported lack of access to exculpatory evidence are barred by res judicata, lack cognizable evidentiary support, and/or relate to evidence that is not new, that Defendant was not unavoidably prevented from discovering, and/or that is not material to his defense. Defendant's claim of ineffective assistance of counsel likewise lacks cognizable evidentiary support, and he also has failed to demonstrate that a different outcome would have been reasonably probable in the absence of his trial attorney's alleged omissions. Judgment affirmed.
- 2018 Ohio 5282Glesser v. Professional Transp., Inc. (2018)
Trial court properly granted summary judgment to appellee where appellant's claims were barred by the doctrine of res judicata, having been previously dismissed in an action brought against appellee's employee.
- 2018 Ohio 5283State v. Kraus (2018)
The trial court lacked jurisdiction to consider appellant's untimely petition for post-conviction relief. Appellant did not file his petition until after the applicable 365-day period of R.C. 2953.21(A)(2), and appellant did not attempt to demonstrate that R.C. 2953.23(A) was applicable. Trial court was not required to issue findings of fact and conclusions of law before dismissing the untimely petition.
- 2018 Ohio 5284Vermilion v. Lane (2018)
Appellant's motion to suppress evidence derived from a traffic stop should have been granted where the officer did not have a reasonable belief that she committed a traffic violation. R.C. 4511.33 marked lanes Heien v. North Carolina.
- 2018 Ohio 5286Toledo v. Myers (2018)
Appellant was deprived of his right to jury trial where (1) dialogue with court reflected that new date for jury trial would be scheduled if plea agreement was not reached by date of previously-scheduled trial and (2) written jury demand, purportedly withdrawn by defense counsel, was not properly withdrawn under R.C. 2945.05. Reversal and remand required.
- 2018 Ohio 5287State v. Reid (2018)
Defendant's 17 month prison sentence for domestic violence is not clearly and convincingly contrary to law under R.C. 2953.08(G)(2), where the trial court considered the principles and purposes of sentencing under R.C. 2929.11 and the seriousness and recidivism factors under R.C. 2929.12 and where it properly applied post-release control and sentenced him within the statutorily permissible range.
- 2018 Ohio 5288State v. Southam (2018)
Trial court properly convicted and sentenced appellant for breaking and entering and failure to comply with order or signal of a police officer. Judgment affirmed. Sufficiency of evidence, Crim.R. 29, manifest weight of evidence, allocution, ineffective assistance of counsel
- 2018 Ohio 5289State v. Strong (2018)
Appellant's convictions will not be disturbed when appellant pled guilty, and no reversible error due to the state's alleged failure to read facts into the record existed.
- 2018 Ohio 5292State v. Harris (2018)
The trial court erred by finding that disorderly conduct was a lesser included offense of felonious assault based on application of the Blockburger test.
- 2018 Ohio 5293State v. Ellis (2018)
Trial court did not abuse its discretion by proceeding with the final sentencing hearing, nor did it err by sentencing appellant to the maximum term of incarceration where the record reveals that appellant's sentence was within the permissible sentencing range and was fully supported by the law.
- 2018 Ohio 5294State v. Smith (2018)
The trial court did not err by sentencing appellant to an 18-month prison sentence after he pled guilty to one third-degree felony count of violating a protection order where the sentence imposed by the trial court was neither clearly and convincingly contrary to law nor unsupported by the record.
- 2018 Ohio 5296Kahle v. Graham (2018)
The juvenile court did not err in not ordering appellee to avoid nudity in front of the child where appellant never litigated the issue in front of the magistrate and no evidence was offered regarding the nudity issue. The juvenile court did not err by disregarding parties' suggestion of a four-week rotation schedule for visitation where a two-week rotation was in the child's best interest. The juvenile court did not provide any reasoning for terminating appellee's child support order. On remand, the court must offer its reasoning so that this court can perform a meaningful review of the issue.
- 2018 Ohio 5297State v. Shaffer (2018)
The trial court did not err in finding that the 90-day exception in R.C. 2929.15(B)(1)(c)(i) did not apply where the defendant's violations of his community control sanction consisted of new felony criminal offenses.
- 2018 Ohio 5298Hicks v. State (2018)
An individual, who filed a private citizen affidavit alleging that the county auditor had committed several crimes, appeals the dismissal of the affidavit. The matter was remanded to the trial court to follow one of the statutory options in disposing of the affidavit, i.e., to refer the matter to the prosecuting attorney for further investigation.
- 2018 Ohio 5299State v. Showalter (2018)
Appellant was not entitled to the sentencing limitation permitted by R.C. 2929.15(B)(1)(c)(i) because he continued to use cocaine, which constituted a new felony, leading to the revocation of his community control.
- 2018 Ohio 5300State v. Hall (2018)
Appellant's conviction was against the manifest weight of the evidence where the trooper who performed a traffic stop of appellant testified that he never saw the gun in appellant's vehicle so that the state failed to prove the necessary elements of a loaded gun carried in a vehicle in an inappropriate manner.
- 2018 Ohio 5301State v. Olmstead (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 5302State v. Cheatham (2018)
Theft Spousal Privilege
- 2018 Ohio 5304State v. Maurent (2018)
Evidence not newly discovered motion for leave to file a motion for new trial properly overruled.
- 2018 Ohio 5306State v. Bazler (2018)
Aggravated Trafficking - Sufficiency/Manifest Weight - Consecutive Sentences
- 2018 Ohio 5307United Elec. Radio & Mach. Workers of Am. v. Highland Local Sch. Dist. Bd. of Educ. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 5308State v. Thompson (2018)
Vehicle Assault OVI Implied Consent
- 2018 Ohio 5312Daso v. Creston Ins. Ctr., LLC (2018)
negligence per se—harm—summary judgment
- 2018 Ohio 5314Hall v. Crystal Clinic, Inc. (2018)
service of process – commercial carrier service – Civ.R. 4.1 – Civ.R. 3(A) – R.C. 2305.19(A)
- 2018 Ohio 5315State v. Hitsman (2018)
suppress—frisk—indictment—R.C. 1.51
- 2018 Ohio 5316R.S. v. J.W. (2018)
domestic violence civil protection order – full hearing – magistrate's decision – objections – family or household member – menacing –
- 2018 Ohio 5318Kuczirka v. Ellis (2018)
medical malpractice – wrongful death – statute of limitations – savings statute – refiled case – commence – Civ.R. 3(A) – pending – Civ.R. 4.1 – retroactive – attempt to commence
- 2018 Ohio 5319Fed. Natl. Mtge. Assn. v. McFerren (2018)
Foreclosure – summary judgment – standing – assignments – chain of mergers – note – holder – possession – affidavit – personal knowledge – law of the case
- 2018 Ohio 5320Niederst v. Niederst (2018)
settlement agreement, breach, compensatory damages, attorney fees, motion to enforce, objection to magistrate's decision, failure to object, forfeit, Civ.R. 53(D)(3)(b), Civ.R. 53(D)(3)(b)(iv)
- 2018 Ohio 5325State v. Hunter (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - aggravated robbery firearm specification sufficiency of the evidence manifest weight of the evidence.
- 2018 Ohio 5326Metal Seal Precision, Ltd. v. Good Time Outdoors, Inc. (2018)
CIVIL - contract for the sale of goods Ohio's Uniform Commercial Code breach of contract extrinsic evidence explain or supplement a writing consistent additional terms promissory estoppel action on account defective parts damages failure to mitigate damages.
- 2018 Ohio 5327State v. Chesnic (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - motion to suppress properly denied mixed standard of review purse on shoulder and under control at time of arrest State v. Banks-Harvey, 152 Ohio St.3d 368.
- 2018 Ohio 5328State ex rel. Davis v. Sloan (2018)
EXTRAORDINARY WRITS - petition for writ of habeas corpus doctrine of res judicata failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted sua sponte dismissal.
- 2018 Ohio 5329State v. Elliott (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - App.R. 4(A) thirty-day rule untimely appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 5330State v. Banks (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - PLEAS, MOTIONS &OTHER HEARINGS - aggravated murder post conviction relief res judicata.
- 2018 Ohio 5331State v. McCruter (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - domestic violence aggravated menacing a finding that a verdict is not against the manifest weight of the evidence means it is based on sufficient evidence
- 2018 Ohio 5332Kumar v. USA Insulation (2018)
CONTRACTS - small claims breach of service contract incomplete performance substantial performance damages general verdict Civ.R. 52 no request for findings of fact and conclusions of law presumption that all proper rules of law were applied.
- 2018 Ohio 5333Eyajan v. Nesco Resources (2018)
APPELLATE REVIEW - App.R. 4(A) thirty-day rule Civ.R. 58(B) untimely appeal.
- 2018 Ohio 5335State v. Perkins (2018)
CRIMINAL LAW - plea of guilty advisement of constitutional rights strict compliance right to a trial by jury reference to jury sufficient plea not invalid advise defendant of right to assistance of counsel on appeal not required no prejudice.
- 2018 Ohio 5336Reamensnyder v. Marino (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 5344State v. Vance (2018)
Appeal from resentencing failed to raise meritorious issues.
- 2018 Ohio 5345Torres v. Concrete Designs Inc. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 5366Ohio Office of Collective Bargaining v. Ohio Civil Serv. Emps. Ass'n (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 5383P.K. v. J.V. (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 5399Hise v. Laiviera (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 5402Doe v. Skaggs (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 5410Cliffs & Creeks, L.L.C. v. Swallie (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 5433State v. Isaac (2018)
- 2018 Ohio 5444Dissell v. Cleveland (2018)
Core Terms: public record court of claims R.C. 2743.75 R.C. 149.43 database ambiguous overly broad HIPAA protective order opioid dispatch EMS fire police. Overview: Requester sought records documenting EMS, fire, or police units called to respond to opioid related overdose calls. The city dispatch software could not separate opioid calls at the time the request was made, but the city voluntarily provided police dispatch event summaries for all overdose-related calls. The city argued that the entire request could be denied as improperly requiring it to create new records, that the street addresses in EMS and fire dispatch records were exempted by the federal Health Information Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA), and that a court protective order entered eleven months after the request was made prevented it from releasing any overdose records. The special master found that the request was sufficiently specific to require a response containing all overdose dispatch calls. The special master further found that HIPAA did not apply to otherwise non-exempt records. The special master further found that the terms of the protective order did not encompass disclosure pursuant to public records requests, that the city could not rely on any exception not in effect at the time of the request, and that the city did not establish that a protective order could serve as a valid exception to the Public Records Act. The special master recommended that the court order respondent to disclose responsive EMS/Fire CAD event summaries without redaction.
- 2018 Ohio 5445Chillicothe Gazette v. Chillicothe City Schools (2018)
Core Terms: public record court of claims R.C. 2743.75 R.C. 149.43 ambiguous overly broad Title IX FERPA R.C. 3319.321 personally identifiable information attorney-client privilege non-record quasi-agency non-existent moot. Overview: Requester sought a Title IX investigation report and other records related to a former employee of respondent city schools. Respondent denied some of the requests as ambiguous or overly broad, and asserted that some requested documents were not records of the city schools or did not exist. Respondent asserted that some records were exempted from the Public Records Act by common-law attorney-client privilege, the Family Education Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA), and R.C. 3319.321. The special master found that the requests were moot to the extent that records had been provided, and that certain requests were ambiguous or overly broad except to the extent that they contained a sufficiently specific embedded request. The special master further found that FERPA and R.C. 3319.321 had been overapplied in redacting the Title IX investigation report, and that material not falling squarely within the term "personally identifiable information" must be disclosed. The special master further found that the city schools' insurer was not a person responsible for public records, under the theory of quasi-agency, for an insurer-appointed defense counsel's engagement and payment records. The special master found that respondent had no duty to provide non-existent records, or records that did not fall under the terms of any request.
- 2018 Ohio 5446Ware v. Mansfield Corr. Inst. (2018)
Core Terms: public record court of claims R.C. 2743.75 R.C. 149.43 R.C. 149.43(E)(1) proof moot reasonable period of time. Overview: Requester sought various institution schedules and reports, and received no response from the institution. Requester made a new request in the complaint for certification of the institution's compliance public records training pursuant to R.C. 149.43(E)(1). Respondent disclosed all requested records during litigation, and alleged that requester had not shown that he actually mailed the request to the institution. The special master found that the request for training certification was unenforceable because it was not made prior to filing the complaint. The special master further found that the claim for production had been rendered moot by full disclosure, but that the response had not been made within a reasonable period of time.