[Cite as Smith v. Smith,
2018-Ohio-4176.]
IN THE COURT OF APPEALS
ELEVENTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
PORTAGE COUNTY, OHIO
IN THE MATTER OF THE : MEMORANDUM OPINION
DISSOLUTION OF THE MARRIAGE OF:
:
CASE NO. 2018-P-0065
NATHAN M. SMITH AND :
KELLY M. SMITH, n.k.a. KELLY M.
CHRISTEAN :
Civil Appeal from the Court of Common Pleas, Domestic Relations Division, Case No.
2008 DR 00274.
Judgment: Appeal dismissed.
Robert E. Rosenberg and Michael D. Dailey, Rosenberg & Associates, 533 East Main
Street, Ravenna, OH 44266 (For Appellee, Nathan M. Smith).
Mary E. Randazzo, 6555 Dean Memorial Parkway, Boston Heights, OH, 44236 (For
Appellant, Kelly M. Smith, n.k.a. Kelly M. Christean).
DIANE V. GRENDELL, J.
{¶1} Appellant, Kelly M. Smith, n.k.a. Kelly M. Christean, through counsel, filed
an appeal from an entry of the Portage County Court of Common Pleas, Domestic
Relations Division.
{¶2} On September 5, 2018, appellee filed a motion to dismiss the appeal as
untimely. Appellee explains that pursuant to Civ.R. 5(B), appellant’s attorney was
properly served with a copy of the entry by facsimile on July 30, 2018. On September
11, 2018, appellant filed a “Motion to Determine Appeal Timely Filed,” and appellee
opposed. Appellant alleges that “[s]ending notice of judgment by facsimile fails to
properly serve notice of judgment.” In his opposition, appellee argues that proof of
service was noted on the appearance docket pursuant to Civ.R. 58(B).
{¶3} Civ.R. 5(B)(2)(f) provides that a document is served by “sending it by
electronic means to a facsimile number or e-mail address provided … by the attorney
or party to be served, in which event service is complete upon transmission ….”
{¶4} App.R. 3(A) expressly states that the only jurisdictional requirement for
filing a valid appeal is to file it within the time allowed by App.R. 4. The Supreme Court
of Ohio has held that the failure to comply with the time requirements of App.R. 4(A) is a
jurisdictional defect, which is fatal to an appeal. In re H.F., 120 Ohio St.3d 499, 2008-
Ohio-6810, ¶ 17, citing State ex rel. Pendell v. Adams Cty. Bd. of Elections,
40 Ohio
St.3d 58, 60 (1988).
{¶5} “Subject to the provisions of App.R. 4(A)(3), a party who wishes to appeal
from an order that is final upon its entry shall file the notice of appeal required by App.R.
3 within 30 days of that entry.” See App.R. 4(A)(1). Civ.R. 58(B) directs the clerk of
courts to serve the parties with notice of the entry, in a manner prescribed by Civ.R.
5(B), within three days of entering the judgment upon the journal. If Civ.R. 58(B) service
does not occur within three days, the time to appeal does not begin to run until service
is made and noted in the appearance docket. Coles v. Lawyers Title Ins. Corp., 163
Ohio App.3d 659, 664,
2005-Ohio-5360.
{¶6} Here, the record shows that the trial court issued its entry on July 27,
2018. In that entry, the trial court directed the clerk to “serve upon all parties notice of
[the] Judgment Entry and its date of entry upon the journal in accordance with Civ.R.
5(B), in the manner provided in Civ.R. 58(B).” The clerk of courts noted on the
2
appearance docket on July 30, 2018 that “NOTICE UNDER RULE 58 ISSUED TO
ATTYS/PARTIES BY REGULAR MAIL OR FACSIMILE OR EMAIL.” The appearance
docket also shows on July 30, 2018, a “PROOF OF FAX FILED FOR ROBERT EVAN
ROSENBERG …” and a “PROOF OF FAX FILED FOR MARY E RANDAZZO ….”
{¶7} Since service was made on appellant within the three-day period required
in Civ.R. 58(B), the thirty-day period began to run on the date of entry of judgment, i.e.
July 27, 2018. The deadline for appellant to file her appeal was August 27, 2018, which
was not a holiday or a weekend. Thus, appellant’s August 29, 2018 notice of appeal
was untimely filed.
{¶8} This court is not empowered to extend the time deadline for filing an
appeal in civil cases. Pendell, supra, at 60; see also App.R. 14(B).
{¶9} Based upon the foregoing, appellee’s motion to dismiss is granted, and
this appeal is hereby dismissed pursuant to App.R. 4(A)(1).
TIMOTHY P. CANNON, J.,
COLLEEN MARY O’TOOLE, J.,
concur.
3