Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

2018 Ohio 5187

State v. Yenyo

Ohio Court of Appeals

Decided December 21, 2018

Ohio Court of Appeals · decided 2018-12-21

CRIMINAL LAW - Signature on sentencing entry status of judicial officer magistrate or acting judge nothing in record verifying status appellate burden to establish error presumption of regularity vacation of entry by elected judge.

Decided 2018-12-21

[Cite as State v. Yenyo, 
2018-Ohio-5187
.]


                                     IN THE COURT OF APPEALS

                                 ELEVENTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

                                     ASHTABULA COUNTY, OHIO


 STATE OF OHIO,                                    :         OPINION

                   Plaintiff-Appellee,             :
                                                             CASE NO. 2018-A-0017
         - vs -                                    :

 JEFFERY M. YENYO,                                 :

                   Defendant-Appellant.            :


 Criminal Appeal from the Ashtabula Municipal Court, Case No. 18 TRC 00003.

 Judgment: Appeal dismissed.


 Lori B. Lamer, Assistant Ashtabula City Solicitor, Ashtabula Municipal Court, 110 West
 44th Street, Ashtabula, OH 44004 (For Plaintiff-Appellee).

 Malcolm Stewart Douglas, 113 North Chestnut Street, Jefferson, OH                 44047 (For
 Defendant-Appellant).



THOMAS R. WRIGHT, P.J.

        {¶1}      Appellant, Jeffery M. Yenyo, appeals the trial court’s decision purporting to

both vacate and overrule a magistrate’s decision sentencing him for driving under the

influence and reckless operation. The appealed decision is signed by Judge Laura

DiGiacomo and designates David C. Sheldon as a magistrate. At issue is whether

Sheldon was serving in his capacity as a magistrate or acting judge.
       {¶2}   Appellant was cited for driving while intoxicated and reckless operation. He

appeared before Sheldon, entered pleas to both charges, was found guilty, and

sentenced.

       {¶3}   On the same day Sheldon signed the form sentencing entry as “JUDGE,”

Judge DiGiacomo, in a separate judgment on the bottom margin of the form, both vacated

and overruled the sentence. In so doing, Judge DiGiacomo deemed Sheldon’s decision

as a “Magistrate’s Decision,” crossed out the word “JUDGE” and wrote “Mag” next to

Sheldon’s signature. One day later, Judge DiGiacomo granted the state’s motion to

dismiss the entire case without prejudice.

       {¶4}   In appealing Judge DiGiacomo’s order vacating and overruling, appellant

assigns the following as error:

       {¶5}   “The Trial Court committed reversible error by ‘overruling’ a Judgment Entry

of plea/sentence and conviction which was not otherwise defective on its face, and

vacating Defendant-Appellant’s Judgment of pleas and sentence.”

       {¶6}   Disposition depends upon whether Sheldon was serving as a court

magistrate or acting judge when he rendered decision. If serving as a magistrate, his

decision had no effect until rejected or approved by Judge DiGiacomo. A magistrate can

accept pleas, make findings of guilt or innocence, and recommend a penalty in a

misdemeanor case. Crim.R. 19(C)(1)(c)(ii).       See also Traf.R. 14(A).     However, a

“magistrate’s decision is not effective unless adopted by the court.” Crim.R. 19(D)(4)(a).

       {¶7}   In her judgment vacating and overruling, Judge DiGiacomo deems

Sheldon’s entry to be a magistrate’s decision. Of record, there is no judgment entry

appointing Sheldon as the acting judge.




                                             2
      {¶8}   On appeal, the appellant has the burden of establishing the alleged error by

reference to matters in the record. State v. Palo, 11th Dist. Ashtabula No. 2015-A-0001,

2015-Ohio-5212, ¶5
. Here, appellant cannot sustain this burden as to Sheldon’s status.

Accordingly, we presume the regularity of proceedings. See State v. Belknap, 11th Dist.

Portage No. 2002-P-0021, 
2004-Ohio-5636, ¶18
.

      {¶9}   In light of this presumption, Sheldon’s entry was not a final sentencing

judgment, but rather an unadopted magistrate’s decision. Because Sheldon’s decision

was not a final order, Atlas America, Inc. v. Fano, 11th Dist. Portage No. 2008-P-0093,

2008-Ohio-6561, ¶4
, quoting Ingledue v. Premier Siding & Roofing, Inc., 5th Dist. No.

2005CAE120088, 
2006-Ohio-2698, ¶11-12
, Judge DiGiacomo’s judgment vacating and

overruling is interlocutory, not final and appealable. Fleenor v. Caudill, 4th Dist. Scioto

No. 03CA2886, 
2003-Ohio-6513, ¶13
.

      {¶10} Given the lack of a final appealable order, this court lacks jurisdiction to

address appellant’s arguments.

      {¶11} Appeal dismissed.



TIMOTHY P. CANNON, J.,

COLLEEN MARY O’TOOLE, J.,

concur.




                                            3

/2018/ohio/5187 · .json · Public domain