Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

22 Minn. 559

Hostetter v. Alexander

Supreme Court of Minnesota

Decided April 28, 1876

Supreme Court of Minnesota · decided 1876-04-28

Action to reform and foreclose a mortgage on real estate, made by defendant to one Irish, to secure the purchase money upon a sale and conveyance of the same real estate by Irish to him, and by Irish assigned, together with the mortgage notes, (which were payable to bearer,) to the plaintiff. Defence, want of title in Irish to the premises conveyed, and consequent failure of the consideration of the notes and mortgage, and a partial payment before the assignment to plaintiff.

Relies on Carpenter v. Longan · Johnson v. Carpenter · Humphrey v. Havens

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1876-04-28

How this case has been cited

Cited by 13 later decisions — most recently January 1929

12 state decisions

50187618801890190019101920decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Berry, J.

¶1This appeal was taken within six months “ after the entry ” of the judgment appealed from. It was, therefore, in time. Laws 1869, ch. 70s; Humphrey v. Havens, 9 Minn. 318.

¶2The principal question presented by this case was examined and considered in Johnson v. Carpenter, 7 Minn. 176. It was there determined that “ where a debt is secured by a *561mortgage, and also by a negotiable promissory note, tbe mortgage is a chose in action as between tbe mortgagor and any subsequent assignee, and is taken subject to tbe state of accounts between tbe mortgagor and mortgagee at tbe time of tbe assignment; ” and, in effect, that tbe privileged character of tbe note as negotiable paper does not extend to tbe mortgage by which it is secured, but that tbe mortgage is exposed to tbe same defences in tbe hands of an . assignee as in tbe bands of tbe mortgagee. If this was not tbe only ground upon which tbe decision in Johnson v. Carpenterwas based, it is evident that it was tbe ground which received most consideration in that case from tbe court and counsel, and upon which tbe court mainly relied. Notwithstanding tbe doubt which may be thrown around tbe original soundness of Johnson v. Carpenterby tbe comparatively recent case of Carpenter v. Longan, 16 Wall. 271, and tbe considerations there suggested, we are not disposed to disregard or overrale a decision of our own court so distinctly made. It follows that, in our opinion, tbe court below erred in declining to pass upon tbe issue as to tbe want or failure of tbe consideration of tbe notes and mortgage involved in tbe action.

¶3Judgment reversed.

/22/minn/559 · .json · Public domain