Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

22 P.R. 595

People v. Bird

Supreme Court of Puerto Rico

Decided June 28, 1915

Supreme Court of Puerto Rico · decided 1915-06-28

<p>Aggravated Assault and Battery — Contradictory Evidence. — The evidence in this case being contradictory and there being absolutely nothing in the record to show passion, prejudice, or partiality, abuse oí discretion or manifest error on the part of the trial judge in weighing the evidence, the judgment appealed from should be affirmed.</p>

Decided 1915-06-28

Mr. Justice Hutchison

¶1delivered the opinion of tbe court.

¶2Defendant, appellant, was found guilty by tbe G-uayama District Court of aggravated assault and battery. Witnesses for tbe prosecution testified that tbe offense was committed within tbe bouse of a private family and witnesses for tbe defense insisted that when the blow was struck tbe parties were standing facing each other, defendant upon tbe sidewalk and tbe person assaulted in the doorway of his residence.

¶3It is not claimed that tbe penalty imposed is excessive viewed as a punishment for aggravated assault but it is urged that tbe court erred in finding tbe facts as related by witnesses for tbe prosecution. Tbe judgment shows that tbe court did act upon tbe testimony of these witnesses, there being no evidence of any aggravating circumstance other than tbe alleged invasion of tbe dwelling-house; but there is absolutely nothing in tbe record suggestive of partiality, passion or prejudice.

¶4In addition to tbe contradiction of tbe witnesses for tbe prosecution by other eye-witnesses for tbe defense, there is some further conflict as to certain minor details in the testimony accepted as true by tbe court below, but tbe record offers no ground upon which we could possibly justify tbe adoption of appellant’s theory as to abuse of discretion or manifest error upon tbe part of tbe trial judge .in weighing tbe evidence pro and con.

¶5Tbe judgment must be

¶6Affirmed.

Chief Justice Hernández and Justices Wolf, del Toro and Aldrey concurred.
/22/pr/595 · .json · Public domain