Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

261 Pa. 496

Commonwealth v. Dantine

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania

Decided June 3, 1918

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · decided 1918-06-03

<p>Appeal, No. 54, Oct. T., 1918, by defendant, from judgment of O. T. Westmoreland Co., Nov. T., 1917, No. 1, on verdict of guilty of murder of the first degree in case of Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. John Baptist Dantine.</p> <p>Indictment for murder. Before McConnell, J.</p> <p>From the record it appeared that on the night of February 17,1917, the dead body of Louise Delare, a woman sixty-five years of age, was found on the Hoor of an enclosed porch, just outside the kitchen door of her home at Jeannette, Pa.</p> <p>The deceased was badly beaten and had come to her death as the result of violence inflicted upon her body.</p> <p>At three o’clock on the afternoon of the same day the decedent’s son gave her $70, which she put in a bureau drawer in the bedroom. The son then went to Pittsburgh and did not return home until late that night when he found his mother dead, and the bedroom showing evidence of a violent struggle. The drawer in which the $70 had been put had been forced open and the money taken.</p> <p>The defendant was arrested later the same night. The condition of his raincoat and trousers then indicated that they had been recently washed. There was blood on his raincoat, spectacles, and on his underwear. There were scratches on defendant and finger marks on the back of his raincoat.</p> <p>There was evidence that on the evening of the murder defendant was in the washroom of a hotel in Jeannette washing his raincoat and trousers, that immediately thereafter he boarded a street car on which he several times displayed a roll of bills, stated that he had $50, and paid a stranger’s car fare.</p> <p>It appeared that the day of the commission of the crime was pay day at the plant at which defendant worked, and that he had received only $2.50, and on the pay day of the previous Aveek had been paid only $9.25. A short time before February 16, 1917, he borrowed money from a friend stating that he was out of funds. He had not paid his board bill for months.</p> <p>The defendant admitted that he had committed the crime to officers in the lockup after his arrest and later in jail to his brother in the presence of a friend.</p> <p>The jury found a verdict of guilty of murder of the first degree, upon which sentence of death was subsequently passed. Defendant appealed.</p> <p>Error assigned, among others, was the charge of the court.</p>

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Affirmed · Decided 1918-06-03

How this case has been cited

Cited by 17 later decisions — most recently March 2013

17 state decisions

3019181920193019401950196019701980199020002010decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Per Curiam,

¶1The contention of the Commonwealth on the trial of the prisoner was tha.t he killed the deceased in the perpetration of, or the attempt to perpetrate robbery, and that his offense was, therefore, murder of the first degree under the statute. The jury found him guilty of that crime, and, on this appeal from the judgment pronounced against him, his main complaint is that the learned trial judge erred in defining robbery to the jury. While it is the felonious and forcible taking from the person of another of goods or money to any value by violence or putting in fear, the. offense is complete if they are taken in the presence of the owner by violence or putting in fear. In other words, it is not necessary for the completion of the offense that they be taken from the person of the owner: 2 East P. C. C. 16, section 124; 2 Roscoe’s Criminal Evidence, 935; 2 Wharton’s Criminal Law, section 1081; Trickett’s Pennsylvania Criminal Law, 664; United States v. Jones, No. 15494 Federal *499Cases, 663. The first four assignments are dismissed. The ingredients necessary to constitute murder of the first degree having been proved to exist, the fifth assignment is overruled and the judgment is affirmed, with direction that the record be remitted for the purpose of execution.

/261/pa/496 · .json · Public domain