Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

274 F. 494

In re Jupp

Washington Western District Court

Decided January 25, 1921.)

Washington Western District Court · decided 1921-01-25

<p>Aliens <@=>62 — Naturalization; seaman on cable supply ship not one on “merchant vessel.”</p> <p>Within the meaning of Naturalization Act June 29,1906, § 4, subd. 7, as amended by Act May 9, 1918 (Comp. St. 1918, Comp. St. Ann. Supp. 1919, § 4352, subd. 7), authorising naturalization without previous five years’ residence of any alien “who has served * * * for three years on board oí merchant or Ashing vessels of the United States,” etc., a “merchant vessel” is a ship that is engaged in the carrying trade in connection with trade and commerce,, and does not include a vessel owned by a cable company and used as a supply ship in connection with repair work on its cable lines.</p>

Cited by 3 later decisions (1 by the Supreme Court) — most recently November 1981

2 federal appellate ·

1 counsel of record

Relies on Rosenbaum v. . New Bern · Torrey v. Shawano County · White v. Commonwealth

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Application denied · Decided 1921-01-25

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1Aliens <@=>62 — Naturalization; seaman on cable supply ship not one on “merchant vessel.”

¶2Within the meaning of Naturalization Act June 29,1906, § 4, subd. 7, as amended by Act May 9, 1918 (Comp. St. 1918, Comp. St. Ann. Supp. 1919, § 4352, subd. 7), authorising naturalization without previous five years’ residence of any alien “who has served for three years on *495board oí merchant or Ashing vessels of the United States,” etc., a “merchant vessel” is a ship that is engaged in the carrying trade in connection with trade and commerce,, and does not include a vessel owned by a cable company and used as a supply ship in connection with repair work on its cable lines.

¶3Naturalization Petition. In the matter of the application .{or citizenship of .Francis M'cEean Jupp.

¶4Application denied.

¶5John Speed Smith, of Seattle, Wash., Chief Naturalization .Examiner.

¶6NETERER, District Judge.

¶7Applicant applies for citizenship under seventh subdivision of Act of Ma.y 9, 1918, amending section 4, Act oi June 29, 1906 (Comp. St. 1918, Comp. St. Ann. Supp. 1919, § 4352, subd. 7):

“Any alien of the age of twenty one years and upward, who has served for three years on hoard of merchant or fishing vessels of the United States of more than twenty tons burden, and while still in the service or within six months after an honorable discharge or separation therefrom, may, on presentation of the required declaration of intention petition for naturalization without proof of the required five years’ residence within the United States.

¶8The applicant has been in the service of the cable ship Restorer, of more than 20 tons burden, owned by the MacKay-Bennett Company, since May 30, 1916. The ship is used as a supply ship for the cable lines belonging to the owners of the ship. The vessel has been stationed in this jurisdiction and has American register since 1914. The captain, chief engineer, and second mate are aliens. The applicant contends that the vessel is a merchant vessel of American register, and that he is entitled to the benefit of this statutory provision. This ship clearly is not engaged in the business of transporting commodities for trade or commerce, or for use in the general trade. Its business is purely for cable repair work for the MacKay-Bennett Company. “Merchant” is defined by Webster:

“One who carries on trade, or traffic; who buys goods to sell again; any one who is engaged in the purchase and sale of goods; a trafficker; a trader.” Hein v. O’Connor (Tex. App.) 15 S. W. 414; Torrey v. Shawano Co., 79 Wis. 152, 48 N. W. 240.
“A merchant is a dealer in goods, wares, and merchandise, who has the same on hand for sale and present delivery.” White v. Commonwealth, 78 Va. 484.

¶9The term “merchant” embraces all who buy and sell any species of movable goods for gain or profit. Rosenbaum v. City of Newbern, 118 N. C. 83, 24 S. E. 1, 32 L. R. A. 123.

¶10A merchant ship must be a ship that is engaged in a carrying trade in connection with trade and commerce, and not merely engaged in the transportation of such goods as may be necessary for repairs of cable lines of a privately owned concern, and which goods are not designed for the general trade.

¶11The applicant is not within the provisions of the statute.

/274/f1d/494 · .json · Public domain