Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

28 Pa. 231

Rodgers v. Kichline

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania

Decided July 1, 1857

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · decided 1857-07-01

This was an action of assumpsit by Jacob Kichline against Amos Rodgers. On the 24th of March, 1851, Henry B. Duffin, being indebted to Jacob Kichline, gave his promissory note for $321, payable thirty days after date, and gave Amos Rodgers, the plaintiff in error, as his surety on the note. Kichline brought suit against Rodgers on the note, and obtained an award of arbitrators, but died before the cause came to trial in court, and his administrators were substituted.

Decided 1857-07-01

¶1The opinion of the court was delivered by

Knox, J.

¶2The note dated November 8th, 1850, was clearly inadmissible. It was given some months before the note in suit, and was neither evidence of payment, nor did it tend to show failure of consideration:. There was no plea of set-off, and consequently the offer to introduce' evidence of goods sold and delivered by the defendant to the plaintiff was properly rejected. An affidavit of defence setting forth particularly in what the defence consists, may obviate the necessity of giving notice of special matters: Insurance Company v. Hakes. But evidence which has been given before arbitrators may not be received on the trial in court, unless it is appropriate under the pleadings: 2 Wh. 97; 2 Barr 88.

¶3The order for twenty-five dollars, without date, specifying upon its face that it was to apply on old account, was no evidence that that amount had been paid on the note. So far the decision of *233the Common Pleas was right. But there was error in rejecting the receipts of May 10th, May 13th, and June 10th, 1851. These receipts all bore date after the note, and were evidence of money paid, whether applicable to the note or not, was a question for the jury to decide. Two of them, specify that the payment was on account, and the other is merely a receipt for fifty dollars, without anything further. The word account, without saying what account, whether book account or on account of some other claim, does not clearly designate the application of the money. These receipts should have been permitted to go to the jury subject to any explanations which either party could give to aid the jury in determining whether the money mentioned in the receipts had, or had not, been paid on the note in suit.

¶4Judgment reversed and venire de novo awarded.

/28/pa/231 · .json · Public domain