Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

29 F. Cas. 945

The Whitaker

Massachusetts District Court

Decided March 15, 1854

Massachusetts District Court · decided 1854-03-15

<p>Case No. 17,524.</p> <p>Salvage Contract — Lien—Laborers Employed by Contractor.</p> <p>1. A person who contracts with the owner. to supply or repair a foreign vessel, for a round sum, is not. merely by virtue of his contract, the agent of the owner.</p> <p>[Cited in The AVundrahm, 14 C. C. A. 414, 07 Beil. 301).]</p> <p>2. Laborers employed by such contractor have not a lien upon the vessel, for the price or value of their labor.</p> <p>[3. Cited in The Williams, Case No. 17,710, to the point that there is no lien for salvage services performed under a contract for a fixed sum. to be paid at all events, whether resull-ing successfully or not.]</p> <p>[NOTE. Subsequently another suit was brought against the same brig by the same libellants, only the seamen who served under Otis sued in their own names. See Case No. 17.525.]</p> <p>[The opinion of SPRAGUE. District Judge, as given in IS Law Itop. dilli, is as follows:</p> <p>[SPRAGUE. District Judge, dismissed the libel, with costs for the claimants, and in pronouncing the decree said, in substance, that it was apparent the libellants had rendered meritorious services in getting the vessel off: and if their claim had been made for a salvage compensation, he would intimate no opinion what the result would have been. The claim set up. however, was for labor and materials furnished for a foreign vessel. In such a case, there was no lien upon the vessel, unless the labor and materials were furnished at the request of the owners, or their agent, the master, or some other person having authority to act for the owners. That, as a general rule, no one could subject property to a lien but the owner or his agent. That Holbrook, in virtue of his contract merely, was not the agent of the owners of the Whitaker, for this purpose; and there was no evidence that he had any other authority, and it was therefore immaterial whether he had or had not told his employees that they were to look to the vessel. That Holbrook had a lien upon the vessel for the $900. for which he had contracted to get her off. and to allow the libellants to sustain their claim, would lie to subject the owners of the vessel to pay twice for. the same, service.]</p>

Decided 1854-03-15

SPRAGUE, District Judge.

¶1Holbrook had a lien, which he might enforce, either in a cause of contract or of salvage. But in the execution of his contract with the master, he had no authority to hire laborers, or procure materials, upon the credit either of the vessel or owners; and the men employed by him have no lien upon the vessel, which they can enforce in this libel. They knew that Holbrook was a contractor, and not an agent of the owners. The libellants did not bestow their labor and materials on the vessel, under a contract with the owners or master, or with any person who, by the acts or conduct of the owners, had apparent authority to bind the vessel by a lien.

¶2The aggregate amount of the claims of these libellants greatly exceeds the $900, for which Holbrook had contracted to get the vessel off; and if they have a lien therefor, it would subject the owners to the payment of a larger sum than that stipulated in the contract with Holbrook, under which alone these persons labored. This libel to enforce a lien, as material men, in which Holbrook has not joined, must be dismissed. Whether the libellants might join with Holbrook, in a libel for salvage, 1 have no occasion now to consider.

¶3Libel dismissed.

/29/fcas/945 · .json · Public domain