Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

3 Me. 92

Haskell v. Becket

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine

Decided May 15, 1824

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine · decided 1824-05-15

<p>The Court,in the exercise of its dieretion, will not grant a review on petition, where the object is merely to discredict a witness who testified at the trial; — nor because one of the jury was not impartial, or was hostile in his feelings to the petitioner, if this fact was known to the petitioner before the trial; — nor because a juror had expressed a general opinion of the cause before the trial, if it appear that he had formed no judgment of the merits, and stood indifferent between the parties.</p> <p>On such an application the juror ought to be called, to explain his own feelings and declarations, and he may be examined generally in support of the verdict.</p>

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently December 1882

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1824-05-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Per Curiauí.

¶1The legislature has repealed the law granting reviews of right, because of the temptation it afforded to the crime of perjury; but for the advancement of justice it has referred the same subject to the general discretion of this Court. In the exercise of this discretion the Court will endeavor on the one hand to prevent the mischiefs which existed under the old law, and on the other to preserve in all its purity the trial by jury.

¶2It is alleged by the petitioner that the trial of his cause was not a fair one, because one of the jurors entertained feelings of hostility against him, resulting from supposed injuries which the petitioner had oifered him. How far this fact, if unexplained, might go, it is not necessary now to determine; yet of itself it might probably induce the Court to send the cause to another jury. But it seems to have been as well known to the petitioner before the trial, as now; and if he would object to the juror for this cause, the objection should have been taken at the trial. Not being taken then, it is waived.

¶3It is also stated by the petitioner, that the juror had formed and expressed an opinion unfavorable to his cause. But this is explained in a satisfactory manner by the juror himself, who is very properly called for this purpose. Indeed whenever the verdict is impeached for any cause of this sort, the jurors implicated ought to he permitted to explain. Here the juror had heard much conversation respecting the cause, and upon the state*94ments made by the different parties, if they should prove to be true, he anticipated a certain result. But of the truth of these statements he does not seem to have entertained any distinct opinion, much less to have formed any judgment of the merits of the cause, or to have attempted to weigh them. It does not appear therefore that he stood any otherwise than indifferent between the parties.

¶4As to the other ground stated in the petition, it cannot be sustained. It is not the practice of this Court to grant a review on petition, where the object is merely to impeach the credibility of a witness who testified at the trial.

¶5Petition dismissed, without costs»

/3/me/92 · .json · Public domain